The amount of mental sufferings these trainees endure in this show and they didn't even last long. Still glad other members debuted in permanent groups though. Wishing them the best.
Maybe because some X1 fans forget who the biggest victim is and said they don't care about manipulation votes bcs all they want X1 continue stay despite all of this mess (just like some of the comments here)
@@malakghalb8280 produce changed the final lineup, trainees that were supposed to debut didnt get to debut. i think there was 1 trainee or 2 of them who were supposed to be in the final lineup, min kyu and someone else. before the evaluations/eliminations, trainees knew if they were going to stay or leave they were already informed i think. though they knew nothing about who would get into the group/the final. x1 disbanded since the company figured that the boys didnt sign their 5 year contract and just decided to disband them after the news of the rigged lineup if im not wrong
I will never forgive mnet for taking away from the guys the only thing they earned with their own hard work during Produce x 101,they only released one album, they didn't last more than 6 months, it's frustrating to see how all of their effort faded,but remember to support to the guys in their respective new groups or solo, it's the only way to make up for all the hard work mnet took from them
Imagine your dream getting destroyed after all your hardwork and labelled as a r1gged group, meanwhile the so called v1ctim still thriving the flower path when my boys getting nothing and disbanded 😔
Three years passed, i still keep coming back to them, my X1. Their sudden disbandment was my first heart break in kpop and til now, it still hurts. I can't even listen to their songs without tearing up, which once gave me joy listening to.
lmao how is that dramatic...being picked for a produce series group is huge. You instantly know you're going to be big famous in Korea if you debut under the produce series.
I’m so happy for hangyul. On the unit he was one of the four people that had the chance to debut, but he wasn’t chosen. Now on produce x 101 he was 7th place and his facial expression says it all. You can tell he thought he was going to get rejected but then he didn’t, which made him surprised. Although I am saddened by the news of x1 I know I can support my two favs, hangyul and dohyun. Please support their new group as well!!
Since everyone says why they come back here, imma do the same as well. So, i came here after watching Tony from youth with you. He's also in produce x 101! I can see he improve so much!
Lee dongwook:- DSP media Son Dong Pyo Dong Pyo:- crying a little LDW:- Plan A Han Seungwoo Seungwoo:- happy for his debute Dong Pyo:- Crying more for him Seungyoun:- (holding dongpyo) It's okay baby.... Your dad will be here in a few seconds They are so cute😘😘
My heart still aches like ACHES everytime I watch this 😭 We were robbed of the BEST LINEUP to ever come out of this show, not one person from this ranking lacked in ANY way.. I know in the other produce groups there was always at least 1 member lacking but X1 was top tier and I will never get over it 😭
Looking back, I really feel like Kim Mingyu has been very very mature and composed in dealing with all the ups and downs during this season. Would love to see him be one of the biggest names in Korea, even not as an idol.
i miss them so much, i don’t care if the show was rigged this line up was just so powerful and perfect those mf who made x1 disband can die, and the fact that izone will probably extend the contract is so unfair.
X1 wouldn't have disbanded if the lineup wasn't rigged though. It's mnet's fault for manipulating the votes. I think it was better that they disbanded X1 because it wouldn't be fair to Jungmo, Jinhyuk and Keum. They were the people who were SUPPOSED to be in X1.
@@johnmarlo3002 And Jungmo... It was revealed that Jungmo was 6th. Jinhyuk was 7th. And Keum was 8th. 3 people were rigged out, not 2... you can even check for yourself
@@suniel4610 And what about the 8 other members who were supposed to debut and debuted isn't unfair for them too. Iz*one was also rigged but they got to stay but not X1 isn't it unfair for X1, Gaeul and Chowon too
so, this is place for Keum Dong Hyun number 8, number 7 Lee Jin Hyuk and number 6. Koo Jung Mo , the contestant were eliminated as a result of manipulation (Soompi News)
@@duingwing i think so, they are so easly manipulated vote didnt watch how all of the contestan working so hard for the final debut rank.feel so bad for all of the contestant.
I remember that time before Leedongwook called out Seungwoo name he looked up to dongpyo bcuz t He knew the dad&son😭😭 btw I miss the boys together our best rookie and best Leedongwook
I miss them so much, it's really hurt me when they disbanded, and after that i can't watch any survival program again, i doesn't want to be hurt again, i still being so mad and sad everytime i remember this
nooooo, the good old days, missing them since they disband. The issue were not really a big deal for me, i just wanna enjoy their performance ok, so sad..
@@melanielbateg2080 Dongpyo wasn't 6th place though. He was either supposed to be in the group but with a different ranking or he wasn't meant to be in the group at all.
Before the vote rigging, and assuming the other positions are accurate, the line up would have probably been: 1. Kim Yohan 2. Kim Wooseok 3. Han Seungwoo 4. Song Hyeongjun 5. Cho Seungyoun 6. Koo Jungmo 7. Lee Jinhyuk 8. Keum Donghyun 9. Son Dongpyo 10. Lee Hangyul 11. Lee Eunsang It's a shame because X1's lineup was so strong, but MNET's corruption had to ruin the dreams of the X1 members and Jungmo, Jinhyuk, and Donghyun who were rigged out. This list of course does not also consider the trainees who were unfairly eliminated during previous rounds.
For me I'd say the one's most likely added in by the PD are Dongpyo, Minhee, Chacha and Hangyul. Dohyon was always up there the whole season. Hangyul had never been close to debut position and Dongpyo's trajectory throughout the season was just going down in ranks. Jungmo was probably switched for Minhee. Starsh** was already planning Cravity and it would make sense to keep the really popular one to draw people to Cravity while milking the X1 money from overworking Minhee. When 2.5 years is up and exclusivity ends, Cravity would have already established themselves. A lot of companies didn't want to send their trainees because of the unfair distribution of profit. They work the boys like crazy but get so little back. I would not be surprised if Starsh** decided to keep the bigger moneymaker for themselves. The same reason for Minhee I would give to Chacha. Starshi** and Woollim were some of the agencies named that paid for escort services for the PD. Plus the fact Yunseong was told he wasn't debuting tells me that Woollim had an agreement in place. When the contract exclusivity ends, Chacha would join back with Drippin that would have been led by Yunseong at that point. Also Chacha's popularity was mostly early PDX. His popularity was kind of losing steam in the end. For Hangyul, he was not really in the top ranks throughout the show so it would be hard to be included in the debuting team. All the rest were really popular. Also MBK were called for questioning about their involvement in the bribery in PD48. They got away then so who is to say they won't try again? MSnake might have also seen how popular he was with internationals so they put him in. I'd like to think he was legit though. Hangyul had a lot of noona fans and those fans had money to vote unlike the canteen fans. Dohyon was always in debut ranks plus he had a lot of loaded noona fans so he was sure to debut imo. As for Dongpyo, he was an MNET pick. If you followed PD Note, the trainees initially voted for the center (my gut tells me it was Sihoon) but PD Ahn changed it all of a sudden because they wanted a different center to represent the show. Then we now had Dongpyo as center. Dongpyo's popularity was going down through the season so he might have been out of debut line. But since PD Ahn already rigged him before, why not again? They can also continue that the-pick-me-center-always-debuts scenario. And my hottest take. I would.not be surprised if Wooseok actually won as center. Yohan was MNET's center pick from the start and they did every single good edit for him. No one else would have been center imo. This was obvious by episode 2. For Wooseok, they did all these nasty edits hoping for his popularity to drop. Unlike Daniel vs Jihoon where the difference in popularity could be spotted, Yohan and Wooseok were neck and neck. We'll never know who really won though. The whole fiasco was awful for everyone. The ones who were rigged out lost a life-changing opportunity. The ones rigged in had to suffer the mental torture of wondering if they really made it. The ones who legitimately won lost a life-changing opportunity and also had to go through mental torture. MSnake, Starsh**, Woollim and all the other companies who toyed with these young boys are garbage.
@@cheshirecat5155 I actually think Hangyul is actually likely to have made it in naturally - he had a late surge, and before the rigging really probably have been the last trainee in besides the 11th. Dohyun’s position is a bit more precarious - he may have been up in the rankings but his position was a lot like Minkyu for me; good, but when it comes to final voting I wouldn’t really be surprised if he got passed up at the bell. I’d argue too that Dongpyo also made it but be low; he was on the line but likely. Minhee is unfortunately pretty obvious in place of Jungmo, and Junho was of about equal popularity as the rest of the trainees ranked 12-20. Jinhyuk being removed was obviously the red flag that something was up lmao. Either way, well really never know given that they’re only releasing the names of the trainees who were rigged out. For all of them it was such a shame, and MNET really needed to deal with more ramifications, as well as the companies who worked to rig in their trainees.
@@cheshirecat5155 I also think that Minkyu would've probably be the X and Eunsang is somewhere between 9-10th place because Minkyu's ranking was very similar to Kaeun's (PD48) his rankings were 1/3/2/2/3 and his lowest dip was 10th place and came up 5th place in the 11th episode which is also similar to Kaeun whose lowest dip was in 8th place and later rose back to 5th place.
@@yazbr8863 lmao why are you so pressed ?? All of this is just conjecture based on the only info that we have, which is the names and places of those who were rigged out, which, logically, would imply that those who are currently in their places were moved up in the ranking. Putting those who were rigged out back in and bumping people down is the only possible logical order based on what we know. Popularity is not a question lmao, especially since you can't argue that any members of X1 are actually that popular right now in the industry with their current groups. There's always a black sheep in these shows anyway; by your logic, based on 'popularity', Minkyu should've been in X1 as well! However, we now know that he wasn't rigged out of the lineup, he just didn't have the votes in the end to make the pre-rigged lineup either. There's a perfectly good and logical chance that Hangyul made X1 through his own merit - we will just literally never know who was actually rigged in since that information will never be released. Try thinking sometime, it's pretty fun! And exactly, it's 2021. Stop giving such a shit about Hangyul or other fans who have different opinions than you, lmao. X1 disbanded, none of this actually matters anymore. Move on.
@@cheshirecat5155 I just knew about X1 recently and I can’t see why people bring Dongpyo name when it comes to rigged votes. Not knowing a thing about them in advance I thought he was just the perfect for the center. I know how dirty the work was done to exclude some members but his videos was the most liked by the audience so in a sense he deserved it.
I wasn’t even a fan at the time-but they were so amazing-THIS IS SO CUTE😭~but now I stan all of them in their current careers- but them as a whole was a big loss😫🥲
When they called hangyul name i was really shocked and so freaking happy at the same time🥺😭 i always thought he really deserve to be in the final 11 but im scared cuz his previous ranks were not as good as other trainees😭
No hate but Jungmo can be a better vocal than Minhee, I think starship paid MNet to switch Jungmo with Minhee. Minkyu and Jinhyuk should've debuted too.
@HMH422 "besides this all others Produce groups (IOI, IZ*ONE and X1) had a fair and correct final lineup according to their popularity, but their scores and votes were messed up by Mnet" Read the news and the articles correctly, it was completely manipulated. Izone; Kaeun was very popular and had all of the Pledis stan support in Korea, she was constantly in top 12 and never faltered, not even once. To say that the lineup was "correct" then how come she suddenly dropped in finals? She had similar patterns with Minkyu who also got placed 5th place in 11th episode then fell from the debut line in the finals, if it was popularity then Minkyu should've gotten in along with Jungmo and Jinhyuk? Going back to PD48, if it was about popularity then Miu and Miho should've gotten in as well? They had a large Korean fanbase. Please stop spreading false information, the truth is already out there and it's completely manipulated. About IOI; global audiences were allowed to vote so Mnet couldn't mess up with that.
Please stop it already. Minhee and Jungmo are now in the same group,it is indeed sad that the votes are rigged,but those moments had passed already. The other contestants have their own career now. They lost at first,but still...they manage to achieve their dreams despite of what happened. Focus on the present,spread positive vibes only✨
![|Produce X 101| Dream For You [꿈을 꾼다] // Line Distribution](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MkAVBDmD6Pw/mqdefault.jpg)
![My Favoitre Produce 101 Season 2 moments [ep 0-11]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-NdZxeUEDiw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[BOYS PLANET/12회] 모두가 꿈꾸는 자리, 데뷔는 단 아홉 명! 눈물과 웃음이 함께하는 'TOP9 발표식'ㅣ#보이즈플래닛](/img/n.gif)
I CAME BACK HERE AND ENDED UP CRYING, I MISS MY BOYS SO MUCH
Same, but at least almost all of them are now in other groups and we can see them
ME TOO 😭😭😭
Sameeee
I know right😭😭
Me too
TWO YEARS SINCE THIS, and... I'm here still crying
me too 😭😭
3 YEARS SINCE AND I’M STILL HERE CRYING
4 years 😭
The amount of mental sufferings these trainees endure in this show and they didn't even last long. Still glad other members debuted in permanent groups though. Wishing them the best.
Right like barely even 5 months 😭
they were the victims but why did they received so much hate :'(
Maybe because some X1 fans forget who the biggest victim is and said they don't care about manipulation votes bcs all they want X1 continue stay despite all of this mess (just like some of the comments here)
@@dogstarrules7433 wait can u tell me what happened?
@@dogstarrules7433 Well, they didn’t really benefit from it, did they? And some of them didn’t even know they were rigged in…they’re victims too
@@tsuki4261 they did cuz they got the exposure
@@GoldsmithJohn they wouldn’t be flopping if they did get the exposure they would get in X1, all they got was negative attention.
Jinhyuk cried so hard when wooseok debut
Aaah my heart hurts 😭💔
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
The fact that the first words out of Kim Yohan’s mouth when he was first place was “Mom, please don’t cry.” 😭
oh, they are his dad & mom?
@@Nadivazzahr yes!
It's sad that they need to disband because of the manipulation of the votes😭 I MISSSSS X1 SO MUCH
How MAnupilaton the votes?
@@kim087 the votes were manipulated as in rigged :/
@@acesneo wait how ???
@@malakghalb8280 produce changed the final lineup, trainees that were supposed to debut didnt get to debut. i think there was 1 trainee or 2 of them who were supposed to be in the final lineup, min kyu and someone else. before the evaluations/eliminations, trainees knew if they were going to stay or leave they were already informed i think. though they knew nothing about who would get into the group/the final. x1 disbanded since the company figured that the boys didnt sign their 5 year contract and just decided to disband them after the news of the rigged lineup if im not wrong
@@acesneo mingyu, jeongmo and jinhyuk
아이들 꿈 가지고 뭐하는거지...
이렇게 간절하게 기도하고 우는 아이들한테 너무하다
I will never forgive mnet for taking away from the guys the only thing they earned with their own hard work during Produce x 101,they only released one album, they didn't last more than 6 months, it's frustrating to see how all of their effort faded,but remember to support to the guys in their respective new groups or solo, it's the only way to make up for all the hard work mnet took from them
fr i’m still so upset about it
when i first started to look into their new groups i was so shocked when i found out that some members were in groups such as cix, cravity and victon
what the hell?! such a short time 🤧
Actually im a nee fan of them i already watch all of the episode of produce 101 then fall inlove with them but! Shocks! What happen?
JUSTICE FOR ALL THE TRAINEES AND MEMBERS WHO DEBUTED! THEY DESERVE BETTER
Imagine your dream getting destroyed after all your hardwork and labelled as a r1gged group, meanwhile the so called v1ctim still thriving the flower path when my boys getting nothing and disbanded 😔
@@justawanderer4127 don't say that. the 'victims' deserved all right to be upset since they did work hard too for nothing.
Three years passed, i still keep coming back to them, my X1. Their sudden disbandment was my first heart break in kpop and til now, it still hurts. I can't even listen to their songs without tearing up, which once gave me joy listening to.
Cada que escucho "i'm here for you" no puedo evitar llorar😔 ya casi 4 años
These boys had dreams 😭😭😭
The way dongpyo collapsed when his name was said .
He’s so dramatic ,I miss X1
lmao how is that dramatic...being picked for a produce series group is huge. You instantly know you're going to be big famous in Korea if you debut under the produce series.
@@syoongkook It was dramatic because everybody knows that hes dramatic. Doesn't matter what, it was dramatic
@@syoongkook it wasnt meant to be offensive lol calm down
I'm not interested in manipulating votes, they 11 were perfect for that position.
I’m so happy for hangyul. On the unit he was one of the four people that had the chance to debut, but he wasn’t chosen. Now on produce x 101 he was 7th place and his facial expression says it all. You can tell he thought he was going to get rejected but then he didn’t, which made him surprised. Although I am saddened by the news of x1 I know I can support my two favs, hangyul and dohyun. Please support their new group as well!!
Since everyone says why they come back here, imma do the same as well. So, i came here after watching Tony from youth with you. He's also in produce x 101! I can see he improve so much!
What if X1 never disbanded, I need to know what that timeline is like 😭
Lee dongwook:- DSP media Son Dong Pyo
Dong Pyo:- crying a little
LDW:- Plan A Han Seungwoo
Seungwoo:- happy for his debute
Dong Pyo:- Crying more for him
Seungyoun:- (holding dongpyo) It's okay baby.... Your dad will be here in a few seconds
They are so cute😘😘
This lineup was PERFECT!
nah it doesn't
Not, there are more worthy
it was rigged that is why lol
i can’t believe jungmo could’ve been in final line up i was crying ugly asl when i heard he didn’t make it 😭 STUPID MANIPULATION VOTESS DJSNSJSSNBS
Yes jungmo ranked 6th place
PLS 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 but im happy for him and the other starship boys they got to debut in cravity
@@globalshooky8155 yes actually jungmo x1 lineup debut
@@cendekiazahra8777 where can i see the real lineup?
@@puteridelia2035 we don’t know the real lineup but they released the member who supposed to be in x1 . it’s jungmo (6th) keum donghyun (7th)
biggest lost in kpop industry 😭💔 I miss my boys so much 😭😭😭😭😭😭💔
My heart still aches like ACHES everytime I watch this 😭 We were robbed of the BEST LINEUP to ever come out of this show, not one person from this ranking lacked in ANY way.. I know in the other produce groups there was always at least 1 member lacking but X1 was top tier and I will never get over it 😭
It's been years but I'm still waiting and hoping to hear them say "Fly High X1" once again
제발 엑스원 부활해라......... 나 프엑만 제정신으로 못돌려본다고..... 내 아픈손가락......
i miss x1 so much
It was a historical night. Best lineup ever, EVER
Yes....🥲
EVER 😭💗
i remember waking up at 6 AM just to watch this LIVE, those were the days 😔
they could have become the best of their generation
앨범 아직 까지 가지고 있고 노래 듣고 있음..그립다..엑스원😭❤️
꿈만 같았던 순간들이 영원히 행복만 할 것 같았는데 왜 이렇게 된 지 모르겠다... 프로듀스를 통해 너희를 알고 프로듀스로 너희의 모습을 가장 많이 봤는데 너무 슬프고 다시 돌아와줬으면 좋겠는 마음 뿐이야 너무 슬퍼 눈물밖에 안 나와... 너무 수고했어
Looking back, I really feel like Kim Mingyu has been very very mature and composed in dealing with all the ups and downs during this season. Would love to see him be one of the biggest names in Korea, even not as an idol.
4 years ago
i miss them so much, i don’t care if the show was rigged this line up was just so powerful and perfect
those mf who made x1 disband can die, and the fact that izone will probably extend the contract is so unfair.
Iz*one will be disbanding this april, are u happy abt it? Stupid
X1 wouldn't have disbanded if the lineup wasn't rigged though. It's mnet's fault for manipulating the votes. I think it was better that they disbanded X1 because it wouldn't be fair to Jungmo, Jinhyuk and Keum. They were the people who were SUPPOSED to be in X1.
@@suniel4610 only jinhyuk and Keum is the real member revealed by court.
@@johnmarlo3002
And Jungmo...
It was revealed that Jungmo was 6th. Jinhyuk was 7th. And Keum was 8th. 3 people were rigged out, not 2... you can even check for yourself
@@suniel4610 And what about the 8 other members who were supposed to debut and debuted isn't unfair for them too. Iz*one was also rigged but they got to stay but not X1 isn't it unfair for X1, Gaeul and Chowon too
im sure its not only me, keep rewatching these compilations while missing our boys, and cry after :'(
아무리 생각해도 활동 그만 두겠다는 소속사들이 이해가 안감 분명 해체 안할 기회를 줬는데 그걸 발로 차버림..그렇다고 특출나게 잘된애가 있는것도 아니고 다들 소속사에서 방치중이면서 왜 그랬는지 모르겠네…멍청해서 말이 안나온다
so, this is place for Keum Dong Hyun number 8, number 7 Lee Jin Hyuk and number 6. Koo Jung Mo , the contestant were eliminated as a result of manipulation (Soompi News)
u r fast
they didnt given the grafik chart lmao looks like they didint prepare that before
@@duingwing just in time i am open soompi..hehehe
@@duingwing i think so, they are so easly manipulated vote didnt watch how all of the contestan working so hard for the final debut rank.feel so bad for all of the contestant.
@@savetea1252 feel bad for everyone..
The innocent eliminated trainees and the innocent X1 members.
They dint know it would only last 5 mths
Poor keumdong, leejinhyuk, and goo jungmo
Whatever with that sh*t vote,but i love these guys
Dohyon looks delighted to hear Hangyul is released! The same company ... I love this moment so much!
the way daehwi was so excited for hyeongjun:(
Their reactions are so pure .... I will never forgive what this mnet did or whoever is in charge of this survival show ... I miss them really bad
They never got the love that they deserved! Makes me so mad.
3 yrs... I'm crying so badly I miss them😭
X1 is the best line up ever.
i miss them so much idc if the line up was rigged i just love them
I remember that time before Leedongwook called out Seungwoo name he looked up to dongpyo bcuz t
He knew the dad&son😭😭 btw I miss the boys together our best rookie and best Leedongwook
Here again, but I'm so happy, Dongpyo will debut ╥﹏╥
i miss them so much. how can i bring them come back?
I miss them so much, it's really hurt me when they disbanded, and after that i can't watch any survival program again, i doesn't want to be hurt again, i still being so mad and sad everytime i remember this
nooooo, the good old days, missing them since they disband. The issue were not really a big deal for me, i just wanna enjoy their performance ok, so sad..
the real lineup was literally perfect it’s just that mnet hates certain companies that some contestants are in
They deserved SO MUCH MORE
Where can i wach there speechs? Lol tysm for this
Its been 2 freaking years and Im still cryin' my ass here 😭
ya mingyu not debut im so sad now
Me too :(
i miss them as x1 so bad
IT'S BEEN 2 YEARS AND I'M STILL CRYING. THIS IS SO SAD.
#6 KOO JUNGMO
#7 LEE JINHYUK
#8 KEUN DONGHYUN
IMAGINE IF THE REAL 6, 7 and 8 WERE IN THE LINE UP. MNET FCKIN SNAKE.
Dongpyo is #6
@@melanielbateg2080 it was rigged tho
@@melanielbateg2080
Dongpyo wasn't 6th place though. He was either supposed to be in the group but with a different ranking or he wasn't meant to be in the group at all.
After seunghwan disbanded hes now in boysplanet. Hope he gets to debut
이때 진짜 짜릿했는데... 이때로 돌아가서 빌고 싶다 주직하지 말아달라고,, 주작을 안하면 지금 저 멤버가 아닐 수도 있겠지만 애들 행복을 위해서라면 진심으로 빌고 싶음...
this line up was perfect 😭
It's not
3 years later you hated MNET again for not treating everyone who won right.
nam dohyon - keum donghyun
lee hangyul - lee jinhyuk
son dongpyo - koo jungmo
why am I still here crying while watching this...
2024 anyone?? i rlly miss them :::(
Before the vote rigging, and assuming the other positions are accurate, the line up would have probably been:
1. Kim Yohan
2. Kim Wooseok
3. Han Seungwoo
4. Song Hyeongjun
5. Cho Seungyoun
6. Koo Jungmo
7. Lee Jinhyuk
8. Keum Donghyun
9. Son Dongpyo
10. Lee Hangyul
11. Lee Eunsang
It's a shame because X1's lineup was so strong, but MNET's corruption had to ruin the dreams of the X1 members and Jungmo, Jinhyuk, and Donghyun who were rigged out. This list of course does not also consider the trainees who were unfairly eliminated during previous rounds.
For me I'd say the one's most likely added in by the PD are Dongpyo, Minhee, Chacha and Hangyul. Dohyon was always up there the whole season. Hangyul had never been close to debut position and Dongpyo's trajectory throughout the season was just going down in ranks.
Jungmo was probably switched for Minhee. Starsh** was already planning Cravity and it would make sense to keep the really popular one to draw people to Cravity while milking the X1 money from overworking Minhee. When 2.5 years is up and exclusivity ends, Cravity would have already established themselves. A lot of companies didn't want to send their trainees because of the unfair distribution of profit. They work the boys like crazy but get so little back. I would not be surprised if Starsh** decided to keep the bigger moneymaker for themselves.
The same reason for Minhee I would give to Chacha. Starshi** and Woollim were some of the agencies named that paid for escort services for the PD. Plus the fact Yunseong was told he wasn't debuting tells me that Woollim had an agreement in place. When the contract exclusivity ends, Chacha would join back with Drippin that would have been led by Yunseong at that point. Also Chacha's popularity was mostly early PDX. His popularity was kind of losing steam in the end.
For Hangyul, he was not really in the top ranks throughout the show so it would be hard to be included in the debuting team. All the rest were really popular. Also MBK were called for questioning about their involvement in the bribery in PD48. They got away then so who is to say they won't try again? MSnake might have also seen how popular he was with internationals so they put him in. I'd like to think he was legit though. Hangyul had a lot of noona fans and those fans had money to vote unlike the canteen fans. Dohyon was always in debut ranks plus he had a lot of loaded noona fans so he was sure to debut imo.
As for Dongpyo, he was an MNET pick. If you followed PD Note, the trainees initially voted for the center (my gut tells me it was Sihoon) but PD Ahn changed it all of a sudden because they wanted a different center to represent the show. Then we now had Dongpyo as center. Dongpyo's popularity was going down through the season so he might have been out of debut line. But since PD Ahn already rigged him before, why not again? They can also continue that the-pick-me-center-always-debuts scenario.
And my hottest take. I would.not be surprised if Wooseok actually won as center. Yohan was MNET's center pick from the start and they did every single good edit for him. No one else would have been center imo. This was obvious by episode 2. For Wooseok, they did all these nasty edits hoping for his popularity to drop. Unlike Daniel vs Jihoon where the difference in popularity could be spotted, Yohan and Wooseok were neck and neck. We'll never know who really won though.
The whole fiasco was awful for everyone. The ones who were rigged out lost a life-changing opportunity. The ones rigged in had to suffer the mental torture of wondering if they really made it. The ones who legitimately won lost a life-changing opportunity and also had to go through mental torture. MSnake, Starsh**, Woollim and all the other companies who toyed with these young boys are garbage.
@@cheshirecat5155 I actually think Hangyul is actually likely to have made it in naturally - he had a late surge, and before the rigging really probably have been the last trainee in besides the 11th. Dohyun’s position is a bit more precarious - he may have been up in the rankings but his position was a lot like Minkyu for me; good, but when it comes to final voting I wouldn’t really be surprised if he got passed up at the bell. I’d argue too that Dongpyo also made it but be low; he was on the line but likely. Minhee is unfortunately pretty obvious in place of Jungmo, and Junho was of about equal popularity as the rest of the trainees ranked 12-20. Jinhyuk being removed was obviously the red flag that something was up lmao. Either way, well really never know given that they’re only releasing the names of the trainees who were rigged out. For all of them it was such a shame, and MNET really needed to deal with more ramifications, as well as the companies who worked to rig in their trainees.
@@cheshirecat5155 I also think that Minkyu would've probably be the X and Eunsang is somewhere between 9-10th place because Minkyu's ranking was very similar to Kaeun's (PD48) his rankings were 1/3/2/2/3 and his lowest dip was 10th place and came up 5th place in the 11th episode which is also similar to Kaeun whose lowest dip was in 8th place and later rose back to 5th place.
@@yazbr8863 lmao why are you so pressed ?? All of this is just conjecture based on the only info that we have, which is the names and places of those who were rigged out, which, logically, would imply that those who are currently in their places were moved up in the ranking. Putting those who were rigged out back in and bumping people down is the only possible logical order based on what we know.
Popularity is not a question lmao, especially since you can't argue that any members of X1 are actually that popular right now in the industry with their current groups. There's always a black sheep in these shows anyway; by your logic, based on 'popularity', Minkyu should've been in X1 as well! However, we now know that he wasn't rigged out of the lineup, he just didn't have the votes in the end to make the pre-rigged lineup either. There's a perfectly good and logical chance that Hangyul made X1 through his own merit - we will just literally never know who was actually rigged in since that information will never be released. Try thinking sometime, it's pretty fun!
And exactly, it's 2021. Stop giving such a shit about Hangyul or other fans who have different opinions than you, lmao. X1 disbanded, none of this actually matters anymore. Move on.
@@cheshirecat5155 I just knew about X1 recently and I can’t see why people bring Dongpyo name when it comes to rigged votes. Not knowing a thing about them in advance I thought he was just the perfect for the center. I know how dirty the work was done to exclude some members but his videos was the most liked by the audience so in a sense he deserved it.
wooseok: debuting
wei/jinhyuk: *crying his ass out*
I came back here and ended up crying, I miss the boys so much🥺 (2)
ㅅㅂ 지금 봐도 구정모 김민규가 데뷔못한게 말이되냐 싶네
Cuz minkyu can't dance
김민규는 찐탈락
김민규 탈락은 조작 아님
kim min kyu unplaced but thriving in dramas.. where are the winners now🤔
watching boys planet but im still not over them :(
Is it bad that I only know some and Daniel as the enter but I’ve watch produce like 5 time and like all the seasons
it still hurts even in 2023
hablame d superar veo este video todos los años jajant
요한아..!! X1과 위아이의 팬으로써 응원하고 있을께!!
Lastima que todo el programa haya sido manipulado
This season really special for me 😍😭
Keumdong was so happy that Seungyeon passed, he should have passed too, it's all voice manipulation. Keumdong is the best!!!
I wasn’t even a fan at the time-but they were so amazing-THIS IS SO CUTE😭~but now I stan all of them in their current careers- but them as a whole was a big loss😫🥲
It's been over 4 years and still miss my X1 and PD X era
I can't let my One it' fan girl life.·´¯`(>▂
3 years since this and 2 days to go to boys planet finale
I cry when dongpyo cry
I really really miss them so much
I come back here and I miss them so much
When they called hangyul name i was really shocked and so freaking happy at the same time🥺😭 i always thought he really deserve to be in the final 11 but im scared cuz his previous ranks were not as good as other trainees😭
I can't get over the fact that they disbanded. These guys worked so hard just to fulfill their dreams 😭I pray for their happiness 💟💖
Isn't this 3:37 that one guy from dear.m??
No hate but Jungmo can be a better vocal than Minhee, I think starship paid MNet to switch Jungmo with Minhee. Minkyu and Jinhyuk should've debuted too.
@HMH422 "besides this all others Produce groups (IOI, IZ*ONE and X1) had a fair and correct final lineup according to their popularity, but their scores and votes were messed up by Mnet"
Read the news and the articles correctly, it was completely manipulated.
Izone; Kaeun was very popular and had all of the Pledis stan support in Korea, she was constantly in top 12 and never faltered, not even once. To say that the lineup was "correct" then how come she suddenly dropped in finals? She had similar patterns with Minkyu who also got placed 5th place in 11th episode then fell from the debut line in the finals, if it was popularity then Minkyu should've gotten in along with Jungmo and Jinhyuk? Going back to PD48, if it was about popularity then Miu and Miho should've gotten in as well? They had a large Korean fanbase. Please stop spreading false information, the truth is already out there and it's completely manipulated. About IOI; global audiences were allowed to vote so Mnet couldn't mess up with that.
Please stop it already. Minhee and Jungmo are now in the same group,it is indeed sad that the votes are rigged,but those moments had passed already. The other contestants have their own career now. They lost at first,but still...they manage to achieve their dreams despite of what happened. Focus on the present,spread positive vibes only✨
I MISS THEM SO MUCH! I'M CRYING
it's been 2 years and i missed them so much
2. Kim Wooseok, 1. Kim Yohan I love you boys ❤❤❤❤❤
Got to rank one and I'm crying, I'm still so upset for them
Lee dongwook:- YEEHUA Cho Seungyoun
Seungyoun:- smiling
Also Seungyoun:- I knew this would happen
😎😎
will came back if MNET making Boys Planet 999 next year.
These boys deserve a relaunch not under CJ ENM but another company should adopt them,someone who can protect them and love them
missing x1 so muuuuch
12:25 a.m., I'm watching this again, criying, and missing them so much
kim yohan's late responding...
THIS BRINGS SO MUCH FEELS WATCHING IT AGAIN HUHUHUHU BRING BACK X1!!!!!
Miss x1