She sings wrong notes on "sterben" in bar 21-22 of the first song (a flat - g instead of a - a flat). How awful that sounds!!! 😣 And then she makes no crescendo! (Just kidding... it doesn't make any difference.)
@@victorsaldiviacardoch8797 just graduated from college with music being my major focus and my lord , learning this atonal stuff was just - ugh. But surprisingly - I received an A on my final composition. I did a 12 tone row and really played around with diminished intervals.
@@litledevel15 Atonal music is amazing! I don't even study music and I find it great. It's an acquired taste though and it takes some time before you can understand it. Maybe don't start with Schoenberg - for example Feldman's Palais de Mari is a beautiful example of atonal music. I can totally understand that being forced to learn it can take the fun out of it - I had the same experience with Shakespeare in English classes.
@@victorsaldiviacardoch8797 Fair do's. I really dislike the music of the 2nd Viennese School and that of their disciples. It hasn't moved me or even impressed me, but when a person says they like it, all of my negativity towards it - when all is said and done - doesn't matter, fundamentally, more or less than anyone else's response. If you like it, you like it. Who am I to impose 'the right aesthetics' upon anyone? If I truly thought like that, then Scriabin, whose music I adore, would be as invalid as Schoenberg, for there are those who think his music is awful too. Yet, like OP, I cannot stifle my desire to express how much I dislike the sound of this music. It makes me sad - and not in a pleasing way. In a way that evokes a lack of humanity, of soul, of sensitivity, of love, of care, of heart, of desire, of searching, of beauty. In short, to me it is the music of the death of the soul and the fetishisation of the intellect. But to others it may be the most beautiful thing imaginable, and if it is, I respect that and encourage them to enjoy it, regardless of what I and others think. At the very least, I feel joy that someone can listen to this and feel the same emotions as I do when listening to music I love.
the last song is one of the most beautiful things I have ever heard. By that time you get used to the atonality and understand it perfectly.
Fantastic singer. I find this a little inaccessible, but its actually hauntingly beautiful.
Some people cant understand why this should be beautiful. I cant understand how one cannot think this is beautiful.
I wish I can play piano and sing this Song Its just amazing in the ears😊
Yummy E9 sound on 2nd beat of 6th measure
0:05 I
2:21 II
4:05 III
so good...
I watched it on 2x speed by accident. It makes even less sense on normal speed.
Água coca latão p Gringa e mais caroooo
hahahahaa Negão da BL o grande mestre.
My wife and I sound like this but not on purpose
Much better than sounding like “Screaming Jay Hawkins and Yoko Ono: The Duets”
She sings wrong notes on "sterben" in bar 21-22 of the first song (a flat - g instead of a - a flat). How awful that sounds!!! 😣 And then she makes no crescendo!
(Just kidding... it doesn't make any difference.)
How can people like atonal, it’s so horrible and I had to write a composition for this shit.
idk man, I just like it, I enjoy it a lot.
@@victorsaldiviacardoch8797 just graduated from college with music being my major focus and my lord , learning this atonal stuff was just - ugh. But surprisingly - I received an A on my final composition. I did a 12 tone row and really played around with diminished intervals.
@@litledevel15 Atonal music is amazing! I don't even study music and I find it great. It's an acquired taste though and it takes some time before you can understand it. Maybe don't start with Schoenberg - for example Feldman's Palais de Mari is a beautiful example of atonal music. I can totally understand that being forced to learn it can take the fun out of it - I had the same experience with Shakespeare in English classes.
I like good, well written atonal music.
@@victorsaldiviacardoch8797 Fair do's. I really dislike the music of the 2nd Viennese School and that of their disciples. It hasn't moved me or even impressed me, but when a person says they like it, all of my negativity towards it - when all is said and done - doesn't matter, fundamentally, more or less than anyone else's response. If you like it, you like it. Who am I to impose 'the right aesthetics' upon anyone? If I truly thought like that, then Scriabin, whose music I adore, would be as invalid as Schoenberg, for there are those who think his music is awful too.
Yet, like OP, I cannot stifle my desire to express how much I dislike the sound of this music. It makes me sad - and not in a pleasing way. In a way that evokes a lack of humanity, of soul, of sensitivity, of love, of care, of heart, of desire, of searching, of beauty. In short, to me it is the music of the death of the soul and the fetishisation of the intellect. But to others it may be the most beautiful thing imaginable, and if it is, I respect that and encourage them to enjoy it, regardless of what I and others think. At the very least, I feel joy that someone can listen to this and feel the same emotions as I do when listening to music I love.