QUICK SIDE NOTE : If they ultra creamy side looks brighter, its because the shade is a little brighter but I promise the original has a little bit more coverage :) ALSO they both have 35 shades on the Tarte Cosmetics website :)
Oh okay yeah the creamy side looks brighter.... but when u go back and watch it Vianney do u notice that the original seemed to almost make your dark under eye become DARKER????
I personally thought the Ultra Creamy side looked better , maybe bc I liked the shade Medium in Ultra Creamy on you better, the OG looked a tad dark. I’m 41 yrs old so I’m all about the Creamy hydrating concealers, that’s why I’ve never tried Shape Tape bc everyone says its so drying. I do love the elf hydrating concealer and it did look really similar so thanks for saving me some money. 🙌🏼💕
I think your right eye looked better! At the beginning of the video I liked that side better w/o knowing it was the new Shape Tape. Pretty look as usual.
As someone with super dry undereyes, when I set a hydrating concealer I have to let it sit for a min and dry down a little before I set it to keep it from looking weird with powder. I cant use the original shape tape its too dry. My go to full coverage concealer is the it cosmetics bye bye undereye and If I set that right away it looks weird and kinda curdled. But if I put it on, and do lashes or something else and then set its perfect. So try that next time!
The new one looks better on you, it looks brighter, smoother & also it looks like your underbags look less noticeable. Im shook that you said that you prefer the original, the camera its not accurate at all then🤣
The creamy side is DEFINITELY lighter and brighter than the original, at least from what I can see from this video. So crazy, didn't even know there was a new shapetape lol *LOVE YOUUUUU! I messaged you on IG my testimonial for Sephora Squad on your behalf!*
I have prominent wrinkle/folds under my eyes and I find it tricky bc I need some powder, but I also have mature skin. So I am forever chasing the happy medium. I may give this one a try with the Ulta sale and see if I like it.
I picked up 2 of the travel sizes in 35n & 38n bc I wanted 1 that is my skin tone for natural days & 1 that is a little brighter! I enjoy reg shape tape but I usually need to mix it with a more hydrating concealer so I'm excited to try this! I do like the hydrating elf camo as well! Thanks for reviewing these side by side!
Right away I could tell which side you used the newest one ! It made your under eye look more hydrated. Wow I need to get this! I have used Maybelline fitme for soo long. Ready for change 😉
Tbh I have 5-6 other good concealers 3 tarte and one too faced born this way, 1 estee lauder and another lancome and guess what I always reach for fit me. Idk why and what's going on but fit me is great!
Thank you for the comparison! I haven’t seen too many people talking about tarte’s new concealer so I’m glad you did a video over it 😁 I don’t think I’ll be picking up this one, I have a lot of concealers at the moment, lol! But for anyone who’s interested ULTA’s going to have this concealer as part of their 21 day sale for diamond and platinum members if I’m not mistaken.
The new one makes your skin look very airbrushed and smooth. Lol This might be a bad idea, but I think that I would have to mix the creamy one with the shape tape for my blemishes though.
I think the creamy looks better, a tad brighter & more luminous. The eye with original looks slightly darker, particularly when you look down. However, you are seeing it way more up close & personal than we can possibly see on camera.
I use so much eye cream for my under eyes that I would be good using the regular Tarte shape tape. Thinking of picking it back up during the sale tomorrow 🤔
Have you ever thought of blending the two concealers by tarte? I wonder if it mixes well to creat a more satin finish... I recently bought the creamy one to test out. The only thing is I hope it’s better then the elf one...the elf one tends to crumble when I use my fingers to apply and I personally don’t think it is that hydrating
Which concealer do you recommend for oily skin & texture? I prefer concealers that are not hydrating. I currently use the too faced multi-sculpt concealer and it emphasizes my texture
@@yazminnyoung2948 I prefer matte products also so I can control where I want my highlight. I would say use the regular tarte shape tape, but I have also come around to the elf one of you want a cheaper option. Also the makeup forever HD concealer is really amazing as well! I have been using the elf one (with the white cap) a bit more. Especially for just my everyday over spf. On its own it actually is quite good and reminds me more the regular tarte shape tape. I also recommend you having two different colors of concealers. One to brighten if you are using it under your eyes, and another to spot conceal. You want the one you are putting on your face to be the same color as your skin.
I’ve been waiting for this video!! Can’t wait to give this one a try, I plan on trying the Hydrating Elf concealer first tho because the Tarte is kinda pricey for me right now. The original Elf & Tarte concealers are drying on me and creases sooooo badly 😫
Same here, so I got the hydrating version of the ELF camO concealer and OMG!!! It’s the best!!! It still creases because I have creases under my eyes but it’s definitely a lot less noticeable! With the OG I looked way older due to how noticeable my creases were.
I can buy like 4 of my hydrating elf 16 hr camo concealer for the price of one shape tape .... but can’t deny the legend that is shape tape.... I’ve def bought my share, but might just stick with elf cause it’s been working for me !❤️❤️❤️
I ordered the new shape tape today 🙌 I can't wait to try it!! This is the second revision I've seen. I love the original shape tape so I hope I love the creamy one like the original! Thank you for posting this Vianney!! Hope to see another video soon!! 😍🥰😘🖤
Thank you for showing a comparison with the elf hydrating concealer! Their lightest warm said ‘fair warm’ is basically orange on me so I’ve bought the tarte ultra creamy one instead x
Saved me money, so thanks! I have like 3 Shape Tape backups right now (agree, it’s a holy grail product) and was considering buying the Ultra Creamy today for Ultas sale but the coverage is extremely important to me so if that suffered even a little bit, it isn’t worth it to me. Thanks again!
Hey girl I really love this video I'm struggling with dry skin and and needed to know about this concealer. But really on the side note what is your lip combo I really love the color ❤️❤️
It looks very dewy but agree so does the elf hydrating Concealer.i have tried the regular one and like it but the price is too high for me. I also did a review for you earlier this week.
Fantastic review! I am in my 40s and do love shape tape. It can sometimes look a little dry under my eyes if I’m super tired or haven’t been looking after my skin properly but it’s definitely a go to for me. I also like using it to help just tidy my skin when I don’t want to wear makeup but need my skin to be a bit better looking. Blended out all over where needed is something it works well at. I was considering this but I don’t like setting my under eyes because it just makes me look 20 years older! So I don’t think I’ll like it to be honest, as it’s definitely going to need setting by the looks of it. Thanks for helping me decide! For now I’ll pass! I’ll probably still get it eventually but I’ll wait a while I think. 😊
I am a die hard shape tape fan, only concealer to cover my dark circles. I was excited about the new one and immediately bought it. For me, it's more sheer than the og, meaning I need more product which means it creases a lot. I was disappointed 🙁 and will be returning it for the original
Me after watching your video: 🤦😒... I'd already ordered the new creamy concealer (it hasn't arrived yet), since I never liked the original cuz it was too drying for me, I was sooo excited when they came out with the ultra creamy, but when you said the e.l.f hydrating camo concealer is very similar to the Tarte one 😳 I was so bummed! I didn't like the e.l.f concealer!!! 😭 and then to make matters worse, I didn't know the Tarte one was going to be on sale during Ulta's 21 days of beauty 😣 at least I could've saved some $$ 🤦(sigh)... anyways, thnx for the review... hugzzz ❤️
$27! Sorry I don’t care how good it is, I’m not spending that much on a concealer that I’ll be using pretty much every day and will have to replace often. Hard pass I’ll stick to the elf one
I do not normally leave comments- but I submitted a testimonial to sephora squad! I think that you would be a great fit for it, and I personally love your videos! Can't wait to see what happens next for you!
I was a little irritated that you find the original Shape Tape side better, in my opinion the Ultra Creamy side looks much better and seems to provide more coverage
I can tell you first hand the elf hydrating camo concealer is NOT waterproof! So if you’re a crier, watery eyes, etc, the elf is not going to hold up. Do I still love it, yes. But warning
QUICK SIDE NOTE : If they ultra creamy side looks brighter, its because the shade is a little brighter but I promise the original has a little bit more coverage :) ALSO they both have 35 shades on the Tarte Cosmetics website :)
Awesome! Thank you babe ! 😉❤️💎
Oh okay yeah the creamy side looks brighter.... but when u go back and watch it Vianney do u notice that the original seemed to almost make your dark under eye become DARKER????
i think the ultra creamy one covered slightly more
@Desmond Bronson says
Which concealer for dry skin
I think the creamy undereye looks more luminous.
And it gives MORE coverage too.... The reg 1 still shows her eyebags peekin thru....
I personally thought the Ultra Creamy side looked better , maybe bc I liked the shade Medium in Ultra Creamy on you better, the OG looked a tad dark. I’m 41 yrs old so I’m all about the Creamy hydrating concealers, that’s why I’ve never tried Shape Tape bc everyone says its so drying. I do love the elf hydrating concealer and it did look really similar so thanks for saving me some money. 🙌🏼💕
Yes same! ✅
She had a lighter shade in the new formula that’s why it looks brighter 🧡
@@loren9597 pretty sure she used Medium in both but the Ultra Creamy Medium shade is a bit lighter than the OG, which I think looks a bit better. :)
@@makeurownsammich2597 yes the new formula is supposed to be brighter. That’s why it’s lighter
@@loren9597 I like it, it looks really nice.
I think your right eye looked better! At the beginning of the video I liked that side better w/o knowing it was the new Shape Tape. Pretty look as usual.
I was going to comment this exactly!! I totally agree.
Agreed. BTW both versions on sale one day only at ULTA this Saturday, their 21 days of beauty promo That usually happens twice a year as usual.
I really appreciate this review because I’ve been considering the creamy one. I thought the regular shape tape was too dry for me
same!! never liked it on my dry skin
literally just bought it feels really hydrated letting it sit in my under eyes for 2 minutes honestly better then the regular shape tape
As someone with super dry undereyes, when I set a hydrating concealer I have to let it sit for a min and dry down a little before I set it to keep it from looking weird with powder. I cant use the original shape tape its too dry. My go to full coverage concealer is the it cosmetics bye bye undereye and If I set that right away it looks weird and kinda curdled. But if I put it on, and do lashes or something else and then set its perfect. So try that next time!
Thats my go to girl!!
The new one looks better on you, it looks brighter, smoother & also it looks like your underbags look less noticeable. Im shook that you said that you prefer the original, the camera its not accurate at all then🤣
Es verdad, se mira mejor con el creamy, se nota menos su ojera
The creamy side is DEFINITELY lighter and brighter than the original, at least from what I can see from this video. So crazy, didn't even know there was a new shapetape lol
*LOVE YOUUUUU! I messaged you on IG my testimonial for Sephora Squad on your behalf!*
The creamy one after it was set with powder was so blurring and flawless wow
I have prominent wrinkle/folds under my eyes and I find it tricky bc I need some powder, but I also have mature skin. So I am forever chasing the happy medium. I may give this one a try with the Ulta sale and see if I like it.
Same girl ! 😉
I picked up 2 of the travel sizes in 35n & 38n bc I wanted 1 that is my skin tone for natural days & 1 that is a little brighter! I enjoy reg shape tape but I usually need to mix it with a more hydrating concealer so I'm excited to try this! I do like the hydrating elf camo as well! Thanks for reviewing these side by side!
Right away I could tell which side you used the newest one ! It made your under eye look more hydrated. Wow I need to get this! I have used Maybelline fitme for soo long. Ready for change 😉
Wait for the ulta sale!! They’re having 21 days of beauty rn
@@JS-cu2cu thank you so much!! ✅✅
@@JS-cu2cu when will it be on sale at ulta?
Tbh I have 5-6 other good concealers 3 tarte and one too faced born this way, 1 estee lauder and another lancome and guess what I always reach for fit me. Idk why and what's going on but fit me is great!
@@wheathusk2499 absolutely! Drugstore concealer = holy grail! ❤️
Thank you for the comparison! I haven’t seen too many people talking about tarte’s new concealer so I’m glad you did a video over it 😁
I don’t think I’ll be picking up this one, I have a lot of concealers at the moment, lol! But for anyone who’s interested ULTA’s going to have this concealer as part of their 21 day sale for diamond and platinum members if I’m not mistaken.
The new one looks better on you in my opinion. Nice video!
The new one makes your skin look very airbrushed and smooth. Lol This might be a bad idea, but I think that I would have to mix the creamy one with the shape tape for my blemishes though.
I think the new concealer looks smoother
Agreed, I think that her under eye bags are less noticeable on the creamy side
Yes 👍
I think the creamy looks better, a tad brighter & more luminous. The eye with original looks slightly darker, particularly when you look down. However, you are seeing it way more up close & personal than we can possibly see on camera.
Love this review. Learned my lesson to c reviews before buying new products I haven't used before
You’ve been reviewing all things I’ve been interested in!! Thank u Vianney 💜
I love your eyeshadow...where Can I find the colore,please???🙏
I'm excited to try to the ultra creamy! The elf concealers broke me out terribly 😳
I never tried the OG shape tape because I'm pretty dry.
I thought it was just me not cleaning my face right till I found out the elf was making me breakout 😭
Ulta is having their 21 days of beauty and this concealer will be on sale so I can try lol
That’s what I just looked at sale yes please I’ll take one
Only for diamond and platinum though
have you tried mixing the 2?
I use so much eye cream for my under eyes that I would be good using the regular Tarte shape tape. Thinking of picking it back up during the sale tomorrow 🤔
I am glad I watched your video. I am thinking to try it, ulta is gonna have it for their 21 days of beauty. May be for that price it’s worth trying
My goodness !! Ypur eyelashes are so beautiful!!
Vianney, doing reviews I care about..so great!💛
Do you think the original elf camo concealer is a dupe for tarte shape tape? 😊I kinda thought they were!
It is good cause the new one does not crease and us older people we can have good coverage on our dry under eyes
I love that gloss! What brand is it?
What mascara are you wearing? Lashes look amazing!
Have you ever thought of blending the two concealers by tarte? I wonder if it mixes well to creat a more satin finish...
I recently bought the creamy one to test out. The only thing is I hope it’s better then the elf one...the elf one tends to crumble when I use my fingers to apply and I personally don’t think it is that hydrating
Which concealer do you recommend for oily skin & texture? I prefer concealers that are not hydrating. I currently use the too faced multi-sculpt concealer and it emphasizes my texture
@@yazminnyoung2948 I prefer matte products also so I can control where I want my highlight. I would say use the regular tarte shape tape, but I have also come around to the elf one of you want a cheaper option.
Also the makeup forever HD concealer is really amazing as well!
I have been using the elf one (with the white cap) a bit more. Especially for just my everyday over spf. On its own it actually is quite good and reminds me more the regular tarte shape tape.
I also recommend you having two different colors of concealers. One to brighten if you are using it under your eyes, and another to spot conceal. You want the one you are putting on your face to be the same color as your skin.
I might try it..Only because I have very dry skin and can't poweder..Thanks for the review..💝🌼
what is your lip combo?? very flattering and pretty!
You look absolutely stunning in this video 😍 I'd kill to know what blush it is!
I’ve been waiting for this video!! Can’t wait to give this one a try, I plan on trying the Hydrating Elf concealer first tho because the Tarte is kinda pricey for me right now. The original Elf & Tarte concealers are drying on me and creases sooooo badly 😫
Same here, so I got the hydrating version of the ELF camO concealer and OMG!!! It’s the best!!! It still creases because I have creases under my eyes but it’s definitely a lot less noticeable! With the OG I looked way older due to how noticeable my creases were.
@@KarlaIleana I just ordered that one too as I thought the same ..
What is the lip combo you are wearing? It looks beautiful!
What’s the powder ???? What’s it for and what’s it called
I can buy like 4 of my hydrating elf 16 hr camo concealer for the price of one shape tape .... but can’t deny the legend that is shape tape.... I’ve def bought my share, but might just stick with elf cause it’s been working for me !❤️❤️❤️
Shape tape is way too drying for me so I’m really excited for this launch
I just tried the creamy one and have really dry skin. So far, still seems dry for me but I will give it a chance because only tried it on my chin.
@@anh7807 sometimes I add a drop of The Ordinary hyaluronic acid serum to the bottle to make it less drying
I kinda like the right eye and right side of the face all in all. But you look pretty always...💜
What medium did you use exactly they have 2 medium s
Nars creamy concealer or tarte ultra creamy concealer?
I ordered the new shape tape today 🙌 I can't wait to try it!! This is the second revision I've seen. I love the original shape tape so I hope I love the creamy one like the original! Thank you for posting this Vianney!! Hope to see another video soon!! 😍🥰😘🖤
What no. of shade is the creamy one?
Thank you for showing a comparison with the elf hydrating concealer! Their lightest warm said ‘fair warm’ is basically orange on me so I’ve bought the tarte ultra creamy one instead x
Hi, what is your mascara here? xx
What shade of concealer do you use and powder do you use?
Love this 💕 Are you going to review the new KVD Good Apple Foundation Balm? I'm thinking about buying it but not sure yet!
Saved me money, so thanks! I have like 3 Shape Tape backups right now (agree, it’s a holy grail product) and was considering buying the Ultra Creamy today for Ultas sale but the coverage is extremely important to me so if that suffered even a little bit, it isn’t worth it to me. Thanks again!
This was super helpful-thanks! Since I’m 49 I’m still tempted to try the new creamy Shape Tape😊
Thank you so much for your thoughts on this concealer! I appreciate it!
Oh my gosh. I love watching you!!!
Does it oxidize?
Love this review! Love you! Love elf! Hahah
Just submitted the testimonial. Good luck girly!! Xo
Can’t wait to buy it!! I still use the original 🥰
I also do the same ST concealer and powder foundation.
Hey girl I really love this video I'm struggling with dry skin and and needed to know about this concealer. But really on the side note what is your lip combo I really love the color ❤️❤️
I really loved the creamy shape tape on you!
What mAscara do u have also what lip product
It looks very dewy but agree so does the elf hydrating Concealer.i have tried the regular one and like it but the price is too high for me. I also did a review for you earlier this week.
what is your mascara please ?
Fantastic review! I am in my 40s and do love shape tape. It can sometimes look a little dry under my eyes if I’m super tired or haven’t been looking after my skin properly but it’s definitely a go to for me. I also like using it to help just tidy my skin when I don’t want to wear makeup but need my skin to be a bit better looking. Blended out all over where needed is something it works well at. I was considering this but I don’t like setting my under eyes because it just makes me look 20 years older! So I don’t think I’ll like it to be honest, as it’s definitely going to need setting by the looks of it. Thanks for helping me decide! For now I’ll pass! I’ll probably still get it eventually but I’ll wait a while I think. 😊
What powder did you use to set it?
This was so helpful! Also, what is on your lips?! 😍 they look amazing!!!
I got the creamy one and I like it the original was just way to drying for me
On Saturday at Ulta with their 21 days of beauty the tarte shape tape OG and the ultra creamy will be 1/2 off!!
I submitted a testimonial to Sephora! I hope you get it!!
OMG the ELF looks exactly the same. There is no way someone will know the difference unless I write a tattoo under my eyes 🤣
Which one?
watching this two years later, and the price now being $31. that's insane.
Super helpful review, thank you!! xxx
Are those your natural eyelashes ?😍
I am a die hard shape tape fan, only concealer to cover my dark circles. I was excited about the new one and immediately bought it. For me, it's more sheer than the og, meaning I need more product which means it creases a lot. I was disappointed 🙁 and will be returning it for the original
What tone is the tarte concealer?
Me after watching your video: 🤦😒... I'd already ordered the new creamy concealer (it hasn't arrived yet), since I never liked the original cuz it was too drying for me, I was sooo excited when they came out with the ultra creamy, but when you said the e.l.f hydrating camo concealer is very similar to the Tarte one 😳 I was so bummed! I didn't like the e.l.f concealer!!! 😭 and then to make matters worse, I didn't know the Tarte one was going to be on sale during Ulta's 21 days of beauty 😣 at least I could've saved some $$ 🤦(sigh)... anyways, thnx for the review... hugzzz ❤️
Can you do a review on Frankie Rose?
I also thought that your right eye looked better! There was definitely a difference
I’ve never tried it but maybe soon
The creamy one would be what I need
I haven't ever tried tarte shape tape!
Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
The creamy side looks better on you!
$27! Sorry I don’t care how good it is, I’m not spending that much on a concealer that I’ll be using pretty much every day and will have to replace often. Hard pass I’ll stick to the elf one
Girl I agree with u..I'll stick to an affordable one
Ulta has 21 days of beauty is gonna be on sale is normally when I get them
@@jessicagraterol8330 I think the sale for this item is limited to diamond and platinum members 🙁
@@RaeLyndsay I think it’s available for everyone I’m pretty sureee
I’ve used drugstore too bc I love it .. the only way I’ll buy a more expensive product is if the first 5 ingredients are good for my skin...
She is amazing!
thank you!! :)
Yay! Thank you!
I do not normally leave comments- but I submitted a testimonial to sephora squad! I think that you would be a great fit for it, and I personally love your videos! Can't wait to see what happens next for you!
Present!🙋♀️😃❣
From the viewer standpoint the creamy side looked so dewy not matte ... ahh need it
I think the side of your face with the new one had more coverage than the OG one.
I think the creamy one looks better on you personally
Thanks for both comparisons they will both be on sale soon I have not tried tarte shape tape concealer at all I think I want to pick this up
What blush are u wearing? Love it 😍
I was a little irritated that you find the original Shape Tape side better, in my opinion the Ultra Creamy side looks much better and seems to provide more coverage
I can tell you first hand the elf hydrating camo concealer is NOT waterproof! So if you’re a crier, watery eyes, etc, the elf is not going to hold up. Do I still love it, yes. But warning
I'll stick to my ELF 😊
I picked it up today for 15 dollas 😏
I think the ULTA Creamy side looked better! Jmho....
Squad 😘
I saw another review and the person also preferred the original shape tape, she said it had better coverage. I think I'll stick w the original!
Cute
So I clicked faster than...... Well what's fast? Lightning?