The responses to the SNP MPs every week is so abhorrent. Support them or not but they are raising the right issues for all people affected, and those people deserve a respectful response.
Starmer’s response to Dave Doogan was disgusting. The SNP lost most of their seats to his party, which a great many voters voted for tactically to remove the Tories. They didn’t vote for him with enthusiasm as even more people did for Tony Blair in 1997. What happened in July is irrelevant at this point, when so many people from all walks of life feel betrayed. He is just sticking his fingers in his ears and going la la la rather than attempting to address validly held concerns.
I’m sorry but this is ridiculous. I voted for the Labour party in the election but i’m so disappointed in his complete refusal to answer. The first SNP question was really really important and he made a really good point and Starmer completely brushes it off and has a laugh at the people’s expense. It’s absolutely disgraceful
Unfortunately every question is a gotcha question and cannot be answered by the pm. It would be nice for other mps to ask questions that would actually benefit people.
@@lynnwrigley4244 in a lot of constituencies it was either Labour, Tories or super Tories. I'm definitely not ashamed to have voted Labour. In my constituency the super Tories won and if anything that's more shameful to me even though I didn't help them I can't actually believe the amount of people who wanted 5 more years of Rishi
Free uni/college education, baby box, Scottish child payment, free prescriptions, free bus travel for two different age groups, free school lunches, recently there was the free dental for under 26, free sanitary products for women, and fracking ban to name a few off the top of my head. Criticise SNP all you want, i along with the rest of their voter base are pissed at them for not doing enough with education and local councils are useless, but don’t pretend SNP only hammer on about independence. Their governance is full of errors and they still outperform any British government we have had in that time
Do not forget how the Liberal party promised to abolish university fees, and joined with the Tories to deliver devastating austerity and exhorbitant university charges, along with unbelievable innequality, poor wages, high rents and bills, a diminished NHS, and increased child poverty,
Always the case with smaller parties in a coalition. They sell their souls to get into power, help enact horrible policies and then take all the blame. I see it in my own country every single government
People didn't forget and creepy bar steward Clegg and his cronies were almost completely rejected for years. They only increased their number of MPs because of a lack of trust in the Red and Blue Tories. Labour will suffer in a similar if not worse manner.
Winter fuel payments have gone up. Turns out they tend to do that when they lead mostly in winter. Those saying the SNP leader asked a question that the SNP asked, it was not a real questions, what answer did he expect?
I really wish Ed Davey was leader of the opposition. An actual voice to hold Labour accountable with well thought out points, rather than attempted election point scoring
Would not matter who was leader of the opposition starmer and co do not answer a question unless they want to try to fleece the public over what they are doing.
@@Loz-oh3uswithout an improvement in people's material conditions, people will look to more extreme alternatives. Many people think - mistakenly, in my opinion - the Labour Party are hardcore socialists and any failure on their part is going to lure people to the right instead of the left because they think the left as a whole has failed them.
@@chindit6784The point is that just about everyone on Starmer's corrupt front bench gave the impression that they would support the WASPI women, but when it came to the crunch Labour are like "we got your vote, now run along quietly" It's despicable behaviour and the flailing leader of the Labour party in Scotland has distanced himself from this policy. Newsflash for Anas: You're fooked!
Starmer needs new script writers. He just recycles old material, even when irrelevant, which it usually is. He's not only hopeless, but an embarrassment.
@@cbussey4676 The wheels of power move slowly. How long do you think change should take? Six months? Don't be absurd. We the people of this nation live on 24 hour news cycles but expect and demand change within weeks. Our democracy is doomed because the vast majority of those who vote have absolutely no idea how anything works. Which is why they are easily fooled by demagogues.
I don’t why these and the UK previous Government don’t invest in job creation and opportunities for all, specially to young people with families who are struggling to survive in these economic recession around the world? Always is the same putting taxes up and the high cost of living expenses, goods and services also are expensive with the same income for families and retired people and nothing change are the same problems as always. It's no secret that employment is a key component of economic growth. When people have jobs, they have money to spend on goods, house, services etc which helps businesses grow and create more jobs.
I absolutely cannot wait for this man to be unemployed. If we can make a complete mockery of Labour at the next local election and leave them with a seat deficit so severe that they can’t pass any laws for the rest of their tenure, I’ll be a happy man.
We have a Labour majority. But not a Labour government. Glad many Labour MPs still have their morals! Same as when Blair was in power with backbenchers like Benn and Corbyn.
Starmer should have been an airline pilot He spends more time Flying than being in this country He has had 37 flights Since he has taken government. Yet he complains about climate change😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I’m sorry but this has been several times now where Starmer has responded to SNP questions by just l hand waving and pointing out their loss of seats/distance from him. This is entirely unacceptable and a technique that you’d believe the tories have come up with. Why is no one talking about this? Is this not spitting in the face of democracy?
What exactly do you want him to say to a question which is basically "why are you shit?"? Sometimes the quality of answer is limited by the quality of the question
@@benashley2955Anything approaching a serious attempt to answer a question rather than just poking fun. He should know how FPTP works, that the Lib Dems do well when Labour does and the SNP when the Tories do. I get that they sometimes go for a funny answer, but that’s just wrong when you know it’s quite possible that you wouldn’t be where you are had restrict WFP to those on Pension Credit, give away territory, halving the employer’s NI threshold (which is far more damaging than the rise of a few percent) and no WASPI compensation been in the manifesto. He could recognise it’s painful right now and suggest that people judge them in 2029, commit to reviewing the system by which the WFP is means tested - the Pension Credit cliff edge is wrong.
Why doesn’t any MP in the commons bring up the billions of pounds that’s sent abroad in aid that also burdens the taxpayers..charity should start at home..
Labour can't afford to pay the Waspi women (my mum infact!)... Yet you can pay all the Unions, Nurses, Doctors, etc... Always with Labour they sort the arseholes of this country, rather than doing the right thing!!!!
There are no best bits.. The millionaires and billionaires are leaving London, not because of NI rises, but because the UK and its economy are in serious trouble, with no Government in decades fixing the known problems, many of which have made the UK 20% less productive then other countries. Continued austerity allows more freebies and tax breaks for the upper class, but they are not wealth creators, just takers. Even UK companies are leaving the FTSE and heading for Wall street. Labour are a joke, or worse and in cahoots with the establishment to usher in Farage. The dark forces are at work..
It’ll be happy for that lot Dan got worry about going cold over winter all sitting at home in the nice warm houses and the migrants. Happy Christmas you’re joking.
According to the PM, the taxpayer cannot afford the compensation for the WASPI women, but we can afford to continue to pay for endless boatloads of illegal migrants because he is failing to smash the gangs.
Did we shell out billions of ££ ? What have we seen from it ? ZERO . ALL WE DID WAS FUND THE BIGGEST SCAM ARTISTS UKRAINE AND FILL THEIR POCKETS @@PorthLlwyd
After the impact of the previous Tory prime ministers over 14 years, destroying the economy breaking their own laws, spending money the country doesn't have, and handing off deals to their mates, I don't see how anyone could say this with a straight face, no matter how much you dislike him
Yes, MPs prepare for PMQs. You aren't special for figuring that out. Why do you make the same comment on every PMQs video? Surely you can offer some of your original thoughts?
@GarfieldtheDestroyer It's satire because any criticism or opposition to Israel's actions over the last year have been thrown away as anti-Semitic by Starmer and his shadow cabinet and now cabinet in the UK media. The went as far to call Jewish people in opposition to Israel's actions in Gaza "un-Jewish" which is in itself actually anti-Semitic as is purposefully conflating a religion to the actions of Israel to shut down criticism. All of this, purely because of the strategic importance of having an ally in the middle east. Essentially hushing up a genocide for "military reasons". It turns my stomach. Britain seems to have forgotten The Empire collapsed, if we didn't have any right to meddle before, we certainly don't now.
There is only one response I can give to Sir Granny "I love freebies" Freezer's antics in the House of Commons today. ua-cam.com/video/mQrvmY5s2mo/v-deo.html
Anyone seriously thinking about voting for Reform should wait a few years to see the dystopian sh!thole that Trump creates, because that's what a Reform government would achieve here.
The responses to the SNP MPs every week is so abhorrent. Support them or not but they are raising the right issues for all people affected, and those people deserve a respectful response.
Starmer’s response to Dave Doogan was disgusting. The SNP lost most of their seats to his party, which a great many voters voted for tactically to remove the Tories. They didn’t vote for him with enthusiasm as even more people did for Tony Blair in 1997. What happened in July is irrelevant at this point, when so many people from all walks of life feel betrayed. He is just sticking his fingers in his ears and going la la la rather than attempting to address validly held concerns.
Good
So, just being A normal, usually bought off, owned and corrupt politician then ?
Starmer needs to step down. He is so dishonourable.
No wonder the front bench looks miserable and rejected.Thats what happens when you sell your integrity for status and reward.Shame on them all !
I’m sorry but this is ridiculous. I voted for the Labour party in the election but i’m so disappointed in his complete refusal to answer. The first SNP question was really really important and he made a really good point and Starmer completely brushes it off and has a laugh at the people’s expense. It’s absolutely disgraceful
I’m sorry, deeply sorry that voters did not see this coming when everyone else saw it coming
Unfortunately every question is a gotcha question and cannot be answered by the pm. It would be nice for other mps to ask questions that would actually benefit people.
L I think you should be ashamed of yourself voting labour not disappointed I certainly wouldn"t admit to voting labour
@@lynnwrigley4244 in a lot of constituencies it was either Labour, Tories or super Tories. I'm definitely not ashamed to have voted Labour. In my constituency the super Tories won and if anything that's more shameful to me even though I didn't help them
I can't actually believe the amount of people who wanted 5 more years of Rishi
I would never vote for those A Holes labour
It’s quite poetic when the SNP guy was talking about one trick pony’s and the reform party are sat right behind him 😭😭😭
he said one trick phoney.
But he was totally correct
@ never said he wasn’t?
The snp talking about one trick ponies 😂
Apart from calling from independence and stealing tax payers money what did they do for Scotland?
Free uni/college education, baby box, Scottish child payment, free prescriptions, free bus travel for two different age groups, free school lunches, recently there was the free dental for under 26, free sanitary products for women, and fracking ban to name a few off the top of my head.
Criticise SNP all you want, i along with the rest of their voter base are pissed at them for not doing enough with education and local councils are useless, but don’t pretend SNP only hammer on about independence. Their governance is full of errors and they still outperform any British government we have had in that time
Hardly laying into him is it.
Nice heather!
Do not forget how the Liberal party promised to abolish university fees, and joined with the Tories to deliver devastating austerity and exhorbitant university charges, along with unbelievable innequality, poor wages, high rents and bills, a diminished NHS, and increased child poverty,
Always the case with smaller parties in a coalition. They sell their souls to get into power, help enact horrible policies and then take all the blame. I see it in my own country every single government
People didn't forget and creepy bar steward Clegg and his cronies were almost completely rejected for years. They only increased their number of MPs because of a lack of trust in the Red and Blue Tories. Labour will suffer in a similar if not worse manner.
What an absolute circus this is its just a game for these people at the tax payers expence....sickening
Starmer’s “changed” party is a disgrace.
No it isnt
Think starmers mission was to destroy the Labour Party.
Winter fuel payments have gone up. Turns out they tend to do that when they lead mostly in winter. Those saying the SNP leader asked a question that the SNP asked, it was not a real questions, what answer did he expect?
A silly question from a silly party
Flynn used to get his own video... poor Davey getting lumped in with "MPs"
Yeah because SNP had more MPs so could ask more questions
@@kityhawk2000 Lib Dems quite literally have more MPs than the SNP had in the last parliament
Strict rules about anti-social behaviour? Where exactly. Two tier Kier needs a reality check for the public of this country.
I love how starmer has his two wing men beside him with their pretend serious faces
Two horse faces,
I really wish Ed Davey was leader of the opposition. An actual voice to hold Labour accountable with well thought out points, rather than attempted election point scoring
Never trust a LIb Dem.
They'll jump back into the bed with the Tories at the first opportunity.
Would not matter who was leader of the opposition starmer and co do not answer a question unless they want to try to fleece the public over what they are doing.
Starmer is pathetic. Lied to get in and has been found out
What did he lie about?
Shame to see most of his critique coming from behind him... Where is the opposition?
Please take the great out of Great Britain for the next 5 years, this is not a great country with these clowns in charge
Wonderful and glorious colonial days died a long long time ago .....😅😅
I wish labour would do better. They failure is ushering in the age of reform , I.e facism
Why do you believe that?
@@Loz-oh3usbecause Deform and there supporters are racist
Reform is the party of the elderly. Give them 5 years and a decent chunk of their support will no longer be with us
I would say the fascists are in power now ,
@@Loz-oh3uswithout an improvement in people's material conditions, people will look to more extreme alternatives. Many people think - mistakenly, in my opinion - the Labour Party are hardcore socialists and any failure on their part is going to lure people to the right instead of the left because they think the left as a whole has failed them.
Labour will need to jettison Starmer if they are to survive
Hahaha yeah because Kemi Badenoch is really good isnt she? 😂😂 Look forward to a decade of Starmer.🤫🤫🤫
@chrisbrookes7422 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I am sure that the taxpayers prefer to pay for WASPS women, than for foreign aid and immigration...
Pay 58 billion to boomers for the pension age being made equal when most tax payers prob wont even be able to retire? Your having a laugh
@@chindit6784The point is that just about everyone on Starmer's corrupt front bench gave the impression that they would support the WASPI women, but when it came to the crunch Labour are like "we got your vote, now run along quietly" It's despicable behaviour and the flailing leader of the Labour party in Scotland has distanced himself from this policy. Newsflash for Anas: You're fooked!
Starmer needs new script writers. He just recycles old material, even when irrelevant, which it usually is. He's not only hopeless, but an embarrassment.
"We inherited 14 years of Tory government!" ad infinitum
22 million black hole😂😂😂😂
@@cbussey4676 The wheels of power move slowly. How long do you think change should take? Six months? Don't be absurd. We the people of this nation live on 24 hour news cycles but expect and demand change within weeks. Our democracy is doomed because the vast majority of those who vote have absolutely no idea how anything works. Which is why they are easily fooled by demagogues.
I never heard any of these MPs objecting to the rise in the pension age to 67 when they should have been.
These MPs are complete hypocrites.
Keir Starmer try to answer an SNP MP's question (impossible challenge)
why would he theyre irrelevent
@@XeNeXX and you wonder why we want to leave the UK
He's taken a leaf out of the Tory handbook 😂
@@XeNeXXbecause they’re elected by the constituents you shill
Or any MP's question
A sad and pathetic excuse of a Prime Minister! Get gone!
I don’t why these and the UK previous Government don’t invest in job creation and opportunities for all, specially to young people with families who are struggling to survive in these economic recession around the world? Always is the same putting taxes up and the high cost of living expenses, goods and services also are expensive with the same income for families and retired people and nothing change are the same problems as always. It's no secret that employment is a key component of economic growth. When people have jobs, they have money to spend on goods, house, services etc which helps businesses grow and create more jobs.
I’m still waiting for they lay in.
I like Ed davey idc what anyone says, the mood has changed in the commons, the vultures are circling around starmer
Nah the vultures arent circling
@@gothicgolem2947 what I mean is his days are numbered even if it doesn't seem like it now
@@jamesmulrooney3309 i dont think so tbh. He will be here for four or five year
@ years
@@gothicgolem2947 I suppose you are right, atleast the mps are openly saying they don't like him anyway, small gains
love the scots chap
I absolutely cannot wait for this man to be unemployed. If we can make a complete mockery of Labour at the next local election and leave them with a seat deficit so severe that they can’t pass any laws for the rest of their tenure, I’ll be a happy man.
When even Joe is struggling with whether to support The Labour Party or not, you know Labour have turned Tory 😂
Stop the votes , but not he boats Starmer
Come on Labour MPs let's have a vote of no confidence, I'll bet the won't
Hes lost all their votes
Cant we have a no confidence vote
I will fight Queer Starmer at the O2 stadium. If I win, he quits , if he wins (which he won’t) taxes will go up to 55% and we will all live in 1984.
We have a Labour majority. But not a Labour government. Glad many Labour MPs still have their morals! Same as when Blair was in power with backbenchers like Benn and Corbyn.
Easy to moan when your not the one making decisions
These kids run our Country 🥃🏴
The circus is in town
I got nothing but contempt for him and his pathetic government got them out
4:00 what a childish response to his question this prime minister is an absolute joke
Starmer should have been an airline pilot He spends more time Flying than being in this country He has had 37 flights Since he has taken government. Yet he complains about climate change😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Or a builder as he keeps worrying about building the foundation 😂
They are all a joke really
They are not socialists
Like deployed 👍
You should have sang it will be freezing this Christmas that's at number 1 in the download chart's and see what his reaction was.
And we pay money to people abroad and migrants what a joke
Migrants get very little, stop buying into the hatred
500million going to farmers abroad while we try and raise that from our farmers by taxing them more 🤦♀️
@@conkers126tories gave 700 million away to rwanda 😂😂😂
All labour M Ps should vote him out
Shame on anybody voted liebour
Imagine being the most hated man in a country 😂
It wont bother Starmer as thats the sort of power he likes
What a pathetic PM 😡
I’m sorry but this has been several times now where Starmer has responded to SNP questions by just l hand waving and pointing out their loss of seats/distance from him.
This is entirely unacceptable and a technique that you’d believe the tories have come up with. Why is no one talking about this? Is this not spitting in the face of democracy?
What exactly do you want him to say to a question which is basically "why are you shit?"? Sometimes the quality of answer is limited by the quality of the question
@@benashley2955 exactly
@@benashley2955Anything approaching a serious attempt to answer a question rather than just poking fun. He should know how FPTP works, that the Lib Dems do well when Labour does and the SNP when the Tories do. I get that they sometimes go for a funny answer, but that’s just wrong when you know it’s quite possible that you wouldn’t be where you are had restrict WFP to those on Pension Credit, give away territory, halving the employer’s NI threshold (which is far more damaging than the rise of a few percent) and no WASPI compensation been in the manifesto. He could recognise it’s painful right now and suggest that people judge them in 2029, commit to reviewing the system by which the WFP is means tested - the Pension Credit cliff edge is wrong.
The gov can finance anything it wants to. The lie that tax payers fund everything is getting tired Starmer...
Where do you think most of their money comes from?
Where do you even start with a comment like this?
50m to syria,30m ongoing to ukraine,Britain first.
Wonder how many billions is going to Pakistan 😅😅
Keeps saying "taxpayers can't afford it" but he sending tens of millions to Syria & Ukraine & co
Ed Davey seems nice enough, but he would be a useless MP..
starmer aint gonna last a full term
I can’t even see Labour having second term with how they’re carrying on. Think they’ll be 1term government.
Strict rules on antisocial behaviour for only one Set of people, I've witnessed it. Call me a lier.
Who's that behind Ed Davey? She's fit for an MP
Michael Gove
the front bench all have a dead look on their face
Starmer doesn't mind burdening the tax payers when giving our money to Ukraine and Syria.
Syria???
Oh you’re a Russian bot
You do realize if you stop giving money to Ukraine now, you'll be paying for it 10x more later?
Fucking love that Scottish man attacking speech starmer was shitting himself 😂😂
Hardly 😂😂😂
I am pretty shocked and let down by what Labour have been doing to the pensioners.
The labour front bench look ten years older. That’s the price of lies
I was thinking the same..with no added smiles..l wonder why..oh yeah the clown in the middle not making them laugh...😮
Was Starmer laughing with the lib dem about the comment about the songs?
The frontbench looks miserable, they know Labour is done.
Cannot keep a promise.
Not sure if this muppet will last the duration what do you think?
Why doesn’t any MP in the commons bring up the billions of pounds that’s sent abroad in aid that also burdens the taxpayers..charity should start at home..
And that aid is in place to reduce burden of immigration, its cheaper than dealing with it here
Btw...all mps have to request a question...
Lol one failed SNP MP lol....
I think you will see because of him SNP will be back in power after this parliament.
@robertmiller4343 well in Scotland anyways not down here
2 tier and co are totally out of their depth
Scotland was so impressed with the SNP that they sacked most of the SNP MPs.
I still voted them because the alternative is a complete joke.
Hopefully nigel farage gets stuck in to stalin
Default Starmer ! Ffs
Labour can't afford to pay the Waspi women (my mum infact!)... Yet you can pay all the Unions, Nurses, Doctors, etc... Always with Labour they sort the arseholes of this country, rather than doing the right thing!!!!
Paying unions? 😂 You mean workers. Union members are WORKERS, not arseholes.
@@bluebob81 I'm sorry did you just say Union workers, work!? 🤣🤣 I needed a laugh today!
Take away the millions going on your immigrants
Divide and conquer still working a treat for the British Establishment, I see... 😬
You’re saying the NHS are arseholes?
Pantomime season 🤡
There are no best bits..
The millionaires and billionaires are leaving London, not because of NI rises, but because the UK and its economy are in serious trouble, with no Government in decades fixing the known problems, many of which have made the UK 20% less productive then other countries.
Continued austerity allows more freebies and tax breaks for the upper class, but they are not wealth creators, just takers.
Even UK companies are leaving the FTSE and heading for Wall street.
Labour are a joke, or worse and in cahoots with the establishment to usher in Farage.
The dark forces are at work..
90% DID NOT FUCKING KNOW
It was actually 91%
Why is Dawn Butler allowed to use the racist trope of WASP in the house? She is out of line.
Utterly shameless prime minister. Is he actually going to do something to make anything better or do anything he said he would?
He's been there for 5 months
No he isn't, he lied to get into power
It’ll be happy for that lot Dan got worry about going cold over winter all sitting at home in the nice warm houses and the migrants. Happy Christmas you’re joking.
What?
According to the PM, the taxpayer cannot afford the compensation for the WASPI women, but we can afford to continue to pay for endless boatloads of illegal migrants because he is failing to smash the gangs.
Starmer is a fake.
Jog on kier
Nothing for waspi women but reparations for windrush ok 💩
BARNEY BARNEY BARNEY
THERE IS SOMTHING SLIMY ABOUT THE LID LEADER
you mean because hes a good caring person?
LibDems simp for Labour in my opinion though their stance on PR voting is one I agree with.
Is dianne abbot ok lol
She’s a little wacky
@thepepper191 she might not look her age but she's certainly starting to sound 71 years old lol
But we can afford 10s of billions to pole the russian bear with
You don't understand how modern day economies work
Did we shell out billions of ££ ? What have we seen from it ? ZERO . ALL WE DID WAS FUND THE BIGGEST SCAM ARTISTS UKRAINE AND FILL THEIR POCKETS @@PorthLlwyd
Another nail in the coffin. Britain will never forget.
One trick phoney😂
He’s the worst PM ever
After the impact of the previous Tory prime ministers over 14 years, destroying the economy breaking their own laws, spending money the country doesn't have, and handing off deals to their mates, I don't see how anyone could say this with a straight face, no matter how much you dislike him
Worse than Liz Truss?
🇬🇧🔚🏴💪
All scripted months in advance for the deluded public
Yes, MPs prepare for PMQs. You aren't special for figuring that out.
Why do you make the same comment on every PMQs video? Surely you can offer some of your original thoughts?
@hayleyxyz yes, you are right thankyou
3:21 "waspy women".
Good grief. The language of political is going down the drain.
that's what they named themselves during their campaign
@@OxidusMagicus-c9vI have always heard WASPI women referred to this way.
Why are they not thanking feminists for they now have pension equity with men.
This constant criticism of Sir Kier Starmer is deeply antisemitic
1. Keir
2. He is atheist
3. What?
@GarfieldtheDestroyer Not when it comes to zionism.
hahahahahahaha
@GarfieldtheDestroyer It's satire because any criticism or opposition to Israel's actions over the last year have been thrown away as anti-Semitic by Starmer and his shadow cabinet and now cabinet in the UK media. The went as far to call Jewish people in opposition to Israel's actions in Gaza "un-Jewish" which is in itself actually anti-Semitic as is purposefully conflating a religion to the actions of Israel to shut down criticism. All of this, purely because of the strategic importance of having an ally in the middle east. Essentially hushing up a genocide for "military reasons". It turns my stomach. Britain seems to have forgotten The Empire collapsed, if we didn't have any right to meddle before, we certainly don't now.
@gabrielcoventry4586 that is a deeply antisemitic comment 😡
There is only one response I can give to Sir Granny "I love freebies" Freezer's antics in the House of Commons today.
ua-cam.com/video/mQrvmY5s2mo/v-deo.html
Vote reform
Farage is more in Florida than he in Claiton!🤥
Why would anyone want to vote for them?
Thatcher on steroids no thanks
A spoiled ballot is way more valuable than a vote to reform.
Anyone seriously thinking about voting for Reform should wait a few years to see the dystopian sh!thole that Trump creates, because that's what a Reform government would achieve here.
you all must pay out or your wage not from tax pay