Q & A session with Shaykh Uthman & Shaykh Karim AbuZaid

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @JB-1234
    @JB-1234 2 роки тому +18

    TIMESTAMPS
    [03:45] The meaning of upholding kinship ties
    [07:00] Ruling on combining fard prayers out of necessity
    [12:55] Ruling on whether to remake salah if prayed before it's time unintentionally
    [13:35] Example of two companions rich in both deen and dunya
    [15:42] Best way to accomplish homeschooling (worldly knowledge) with religious knowledge
    [19:44] Will all of the believers be able to see the face of Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَى?
    [22:14] Will all of the Prophets have their ummah with them on the day of Judgement?
    [24:31] Encouraging someone when they're doing good and giving naseeha when doing bad
    [29:50] Beautification for men and women: rings, swords, beards etc
    [36:52] Which is better: Living in a Muslim country vs non-Muslim country
    [39:12] How to repay a debt owed to someone you can't find anymore
    [40:15] Ruling on prayer beads
    [43:32] Advice on not exposing your sins
    [47:40] Ruling on stealing money
    [48:44] How to advise brothers on poor hygiene?
    [51:04] How to balance going to college and being a student of knowledge (in religion)
    [53:19] How to deal with LGBTQ in public places?
    [55:35] Ruling on making up for prior missed salah on purpose
    [57:07] Marriage advise (a brother seeking someone who doesn’t listen to music)
    [1:01:17] Who is the Angel of Death?
    [1:02:50] Is growing a beard obligatory (wajib) in Islam?
    [1:08:19] Permissibility of braided hair in Islam?
    [1:10:04] Length of hair allowed for men (up to shoulder length is permissible)
    [1:10:34] What entails tashbih of kuffar
    [1:16:35] What can you do to regain a parent's love and please them?
    [1:24:00] The habit of hoarding
    [1:25:49] What can a mother do to rebuild a relationship with her child?
    [1:28:06] Responsibility of ahkam for a person with dementia accepting Islam
    Please make dua for the Shaykh, his team and myself جَزَاكَ ٱللَّٰهُ خَيْرًا

  • @believer0001
    @believer0001 2 роки тому +41

    May Allah bless the Shayks who preach Islam as it's preserved.

    • @fidelcatsro6948
      @fidelcatsro6948 2 роки тому +4

      ameen

    • @thetruthwithproof8802
      @thetruthwithproof8802 2 роки тому +2

      The Order of the complete & perfect islam is 👉🏻 whatever the Prophet gives you take it & whatever he forbids you, leave it ( Quran 59:7 )
      The complete & perfect islam did not instruct us to follow any imam
      None of the 4 great imams told the people to follow them
      It's SH0CKING how the followers of imams have decided all the four imams are correct yet we must ONLY follow ONE
      Why do the followers of imams REJECT 3 of the four Great Imams ❓
      A Question for the followers of imams 👉🏻 who told you following 0NE imam is correct ❓
      Please explain why REJECTING 3 imams is correct ❓
      Why do the muslims not agree with what all the four imams said ❓ 👉🏻 All 4 Great imams told the muslims to REJECT what they have taught us if it contradicts the Hadith ( Why do the Muslims IGNORE this ❓)

    • @thetruthwithproof8802
      @thetruthwithproof8802 2 роки тому +2

      @@fidelcatsro6948 Brother how are you ?

    • @believer0001
      @believer0001 2 роки тому

      @Ram Eri
      With a open heart listen to this and stop spreading lies and propaganda against the last prophet mohammed Rasoolullah sallalahu alaihi wa Salam.
      Ayesha r.a was already had got engaged but thta engagement was broken in order to Marry her to Mohammed sallalahu alaihi wa Salam ❤.
      Arabs dint had a calendar so the correct age was not documented as it dint matter to them. As she was already engaged to someone else it's clearly shows that she was an adult and was about to get married.
      And wallahi no pagan of makkah ever taunted Mohammad sallalahu alaihi wa Salam for marrying Ayesha r.a , they tried to taunt in every matter but never taunted against his marriage why ? It was a normal she was a adult r.a
      NOW AFTER 1400 YEARS NOW THR "PAGANS" LIK YOU ONLY MOCK WITHOUT 0 KNOWLEDGE ON THIS MATTER.
      ua-cam.com/video/03b97GUacpM/v-deo.html
      WATCH THIS ITS BEEN CLEARLY EXPLAINED THAT AYESHA R.A WAS SOME WHERE BETWEEN 16-19 YRS OLD AT THE TIME MARRIAGE.

    • @believer0001
      @believer0001 2 роки тому

      @Ram Eri why Jesus has to die of our sins ? Does God requires a blood sacrifice of his innocent son to forgive ppl ? What type of God u belive ??? This is all Paul wrote it after many years later like soe 300 yrs later..
      Will u die for some one else sins? Is this justice??? NOOOO
      ALLAH is Al- wadood the all loving , caring and Ar Rahim the mossttt merciful..he doesn't need to sacrifice a innocent person to forgive...u just need to ask for forgiveness to the Almighty creator sustainer for forgiveness before u die and Insha'Allah the Almighty the all powerful the all merciful will forgive you because Allah likes to forgive.

  • @A.--.
    @A.--. 2 роки тому +22

    Jazakallah Khair. Two great sources of knowledge among us in these days of Ignorance. May Allah bless you both Sheiks.

    • @A.--.
      @A.--. 2 роки тому +1

      @Ram Eri the Bible is not a reliable source for facts. Please see Bart Ehrman and MythVision Podcast for details. All assumptions made on the basis of an unauthentic unpreserved book could lead to error. Jesus lived for 33yrs in his Meccan phase. Jesus has a 2nd coming (his Medinah phase) and just see what he does with his enemies and enemies of God, the righteous and pious humans. He gave you a hint in Mathew 10:34-37 and Luke 19:26-28 and Revelations.
      Brother Jesus did not die for anyone. There is no kingdom for those without belief in 1 true God (without relations, limitations, partners etc) and who's righteous does not surpass the righteous of Pharasies.
      Regarding your misconceptions about Prophet Muhammad and Islam I refer you to One Message Foundation and Musjid Ribat UA-cam channels.
      Muhammad was mentioned by NAME in Solomon 5::16 (read/listen to it in Hebrew) and in Isaiah.

  • @umibrahimibrahim4966
    @umibrahimibrahim4966 2 роки тому

    الحمد لله

  • @azizaahmad9249
    @azizaahmad9249 2 роки тому +1

    الحمد لله حاضر وجزاكم الله خيرا

  • @sa3edjunady425
    @sa3edjunady425 2 роки тому +2

    صلوا على النبي محمد صلى الله عليه وسلم

  • @youtrip1037
    @youtrip1037 2 роки тому +7

    May Allah love you sheikh

  • @skasifweb
    @skasifweb 2 роки тому +5

    Keep up the good work 👍🏻
    From kolkata India 🇮🇳

  • @houdarahma2as597
    @houdarahma2as597 2 роки тому +1

    اللهم لا اله الا انت سبحانك انت ربي خلقتني وانا عبدك وانا على وعدك وعهدك ما استطعت اعوذ بك من شر ما صنعت ابوء لك بنعمتك علي يا رب وابوء بذنبي فاغفرلي فانه لا يغفر الذنوب الا انت ولوالدي وللمؤمنين جميعا يا رب

  • @irfanahmed6411
    @irfanahmed6411 2 роки тому

    Dear brothers Allah bless you you are doing great work on this planet and we love you so

  • @wandaasgarali1737
    @wandaasgarali1737 2 роки тому +3

    Ya Allah grant us and our families Jannah Firdous Ameen Ameen.

  • @peopledontthink1503
    @peopledontthink1503 2 роки тому +8

    There are like 3 min missing from the video in the beginning when sheikh Karim abu Zaid starts with the comparison of alcohol and interest. Those were golden 3 minutes

    • @rayyan8952
      @rayyan8952 2 роки тому +1

      Salam, do you remember roughly what was said?

    • @anasibndawood6696
      @anasibndawood6696 2 роки тому

      Everyone buys homes in the west. All the Muslims . No way around interest in ANY transaction these days

    • @peopledontthink1503
      @peopledontthink1503 2 роки тому

      @@rayyan8952 watch this m.ua-cam.com/video/qYlbCZwDDWM/v-deo.html
      This is part 1. The At minute 39 sheikh Karim abu Zaid was asked about kingship but he changes the answer back to RIBA/interest and becomes very emotional. The video ends and somehow they lost the recording for that part.
      The man from Medina goes to imam Malik and tells him how he swore by Allah that if there is any sin worst than intoxication he would divorce his wife. Imam Malik asks for some time to do research. The second night the man goes again and imam Malik says that he isn’t done researching yet, third night the same. After couple nights the man goes back to imam Malik and Imam Malik replies how he has searched the book of Allah and all the books of Hadith and every other writings but he couldn’t find any sin worst that Riba. The sheikh become very emotional and kept repeating it. I don’t know the exact words he used in Arabic but it was powerful.

  • @sa3edjunady425
    @sa3edjunady425 2 роки тому +2

    سبحان الله
    الحمد لله
    لااله الا الله
    الله اكبر
    لاحول ولا قوة الا بالله العلي العظيم

  • @MuhammadWaqas-wy4hy
    @MuhammadWaqas-wy4hy 2 роки тому +1

    JazakAllah khair ❤️

  • @zahidmuslim4110
    @zahidmuslim4110 2 роки тому +1

    Love both of the shaikh for the sake of ALLAH....

  • @iimiboy
    @iimiboy 2 роки тому +4

    Jazakallah khair sheikh Karim and uthman and all those involved

  • @imranriaz1621
    @imranriaz1621 2 роки тому +7

    Aslamwalikum sheikh please make more lectures. I’m learning so much from you. I’m hooked not dawah video’s but lectures. Jazakallahkhayren

  • @zahidmuslim4110
    @zahidmuslim4110 2 роки тому +1

    Alhamdulillah...

  • @catcotton2022
    @catcotton2022 2 роки тому +1

    mashallah...jazakallah...

  • @nzweuwaheed
    @nzweuwaheed 2 роки тому +1

    Amazing

  • @sa3edjunady425
    @sa3edjunady425 2 роки тому +1

    سبحان الله وبحمده
    سبحان الله العظيم

  • @Zeen-Alabden
    @Zeen-Alabden 2 роки тому

    جزاكم الله خيرا

  • @sa3edjunady425
    @sa3edjunady425 2 роки тому +3

    سبحان الله
    عدد خلقه
    ورضانفسه
    وزنه عرشه
    ومداد كلماته

  • @sagormazumder5339
    @sagormazumder5339 2 роки тому +6

    السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ
    May Allah subhanawatala preserve both of our Shyek.love you both for the sake of Allah.Allahamdulillah Shyek we start DAWHA in town , city of Leicster in UK.May Allah subhanawatala give both of you Azar as Both of you my inspiration by the will of Allah.Make dua for us Shyek

  • @nawazishkhan2080
    @nawazishkhan2080 2 роки тому +2

    MASHALLAH JAZAKALLAH KHAIR,best combination of sheikhs

  • @jundullah4991
    @jundullah4991 2 роки тому +4

    Shykh uthman.... inshallah..i will come from india to meet u and to study....its my dream to study from u... inshallah..

    • @rafayshakeel4812
      @rafayshakeel4812 2 роки тому +4

      May Allah (SWT) help you in achieving your goals, Br!

  • @Taj_Mahal23
    @Taj_Mahal23 2 роки тому +2

    جزاكم الله خيرا و بارك فيكم جميعا 🌿

  • @Sallysmith123
    @Sallysmith123 2 роки тому

    JazakAllah Khair. Great help for new Muslims. May Allah give you all ajar those spreading the truth.

  • @mohammedsaleh5970
    @mohammedsaleh5970 2 роки тому +1

    ty

  • @user-qs1qm5xi7r
    @user-qs1qm5xi7r 2 роки тому +2

    قال الإمام ابنُ القَيِّمُ رحمه الله :
    *واعلَم أن َّ الناس َ إذا أُعجِبوا بِكَ فَإنَّمَا أُعجِبوا بِجَميلِ سَترِ اللهِ عَلَيك.*
    ( مدَارِجُ السَالكِين 2 / 293 .)
    قال الإمام ابـن الـجـوزي رحمه الله: *طوبى لعبد إذا احسن إليه الله حمد وشكر وإذا أساء إلى نفسه تاب واستغفر "* [التذكرة ٣١ ]
    قال الإمام الشاطبي رحمه الله:
    *من علامات السعادة على العبدِّ :*
    *❶ - تيسيرُ الطاعة عليه. ❷ -* *وموافقة السُنة في أفعاله .*
    ❸ - *وصُحبَتُه لأهلِ الصلاح. ❹ - وحُسن أخلاقهِ مع إخوانه* .
    ❺ - *وبَذلُ معروفهِ للخلق . ➏ - واهتِمَامهُ للمسلمين .*
    ➐ - *ومُراعاتِه لأوقاته*.
    [ الإعتصام || ٢ / ١٥٢ ]

  • @AMJdance
    @AMJdance 2 роки тому +1

    لماذا لا يوجد ترجمه ؟
    Please translation?

  • @MrCasco0o
    @MrCasco0o 2 роки тому +1

    What was the question asked before the video started? I didn't understand what Sheikh Karim was talking about it!

  • @abdulkhafidsulaymaan
    @abdulkhafidsulaymaan 2 роки тому

    the way the shaykh says "wasted" is hilarious.. 🤣😱😂

  • @lostandguided5533
    @lostandguided5533 2 роки тому +6

    Brother i am sick i am 25 years old but i have 5 broken discs and severe permanent injuries i can barely walk i find it hard to sit when i do salat can i lay down but i feel bad about it but i find it takes away from my khushu when im in pain?

    • @fidelcatsro6948
      @fidelcatsro6948 2 роки тому +3

      May Allah cure your ailments and make it 1000times easier!
      Duaa for pain relief
      Bismillah 3 x
      Audubillahi Wakudratihi Min shari Ma Ajidu Wa Uhadiru

    • @Emsyaz
      @Emsyaz 2 роки тому +2

      What happened?
      Is it due to lifting weights in the gym?

    • @khatibjuma1702
      @khatibjuma1702 2 роки тому +1

      May Allah grant you ease brother

    • @lostandguided5533
      @lostandguided5533 2 роки тому +1

      BarakAllah feekom

    • @lostandguided5533
      @lostandguided5533 2 роки тому

      @@Emsyaz Yes partly.

  • @mulapienjani237
    @mulapienjani237 2 роки тому +3

    🤲🤲🤲

    • @busufyan
      @busufyan 2 роки тому

      Where you been akhi?

    • @mulapienjani237
      @mulapienjani237 2 роки тому

      In Vegas getting ready for the next one April 22 in New Mexico

    • @mulapienjani237
      @mulapienjani237 2 роки тому

      Is everything OK with you

  • @asedalkrar7773
    @asedalkrar7773 2 роки тому

    😍

  • @bilalraza429
    @bilalraza429 2 роки тому

    You made a video in the past on beards and in there you told that we can trim the سبال can you give a proper hadeeth reference as it was not clearly given in the video, i searched for the hadeeth but could not find it

  • @protopwildrift2260
    @protopwildrift2260 2 роки тому +2

    26:17 Is silver haram for men? Didnt rasool Allah wear a silver ring?

  • @marykary8656
    @marykary8656 2 роки тому

    All praises to Allah if someone concerning a personal matter are there by a scholar or a person from the mosque or even from the otherwise be thankful there to inform you entice you and others the correct way better they tell you secretly I'm not in front of a lot of people for you and for the others remind thank the Lord Almighty I don't take it to heart forgive and forget boys try to make yourself a do not have arrogance ever just one person's opinion ascribe that to should everyone or the religion Islam look at yourself before you look at others Rush Hour his mercy upon us kindergarten 2 all

  • @nzweuwaheed
    @nzweuwaheed 2 роки тому

    Audio quality is very poor

  • @falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543
    @falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 2 роки тому

    After salat we say Allahuma Antas Salam...
    The Abu Hanifah followers were strong on zabiha (likely due to hindu neighbors hence not having a choice).
    Hadith womb held to throne off Allah (rahm). Allah says whoever upholds kinship I will uphold... whoever cuts ties of womb I will cut ties of womb.
    - Bukhari 5988, Book of Adab.
    (Allah 's Apostle said, "Whoever loves that he be granted more wealth and that his lease of life be prolonged then he should keep good relations with his Kith and kin."
    - Bukhari 5986, Book of Adab
    7 :20 - can one combine prayers due to medical surgery being a long time, is there a limit?
    Uthman says traveling and rain and harship allows combining prayers.
    at times you can combine due to hardship as Prophet peace and blessings eb upon him also combined prayer w/o this. Hanabilah spoke of this like cooking for rizq etc.
    Says make niyyat out of neccesity and don't abuse it.
    You can't combine Jumma and asr.
    Salat has to be prayed on time.
    13 :00 - if you unintentionally pray a prayer before its time... do you repray it?
    yes.
    13 :30 - which companions were rich in din and dinya?
    Many, Abdur Rahman Awf and Uthman ibn Affan.
    Thy gave away wealth, like Abdur Rahman Awf, when he went to Medina he didn't want other's wealth he went to market and became wealthy again.
    Uthman spent his wealth and became wealthy again.
    15 :30 - how to do home schooling with secular and Islamic
    Masjid ribat has a list essential books...
    Says he homeschools kids as well and involves them in darus in Masjid!
    Afsar Mufasirat by bilbani
    mukhals faqih by Sh. Fawzan.
    kitab Tawhid, Sirah..., ibn Qayyim fro tazkiya, Tafsir Saadi.
    19 :50 - Do all believers see face of Allah on qiyamat?
    hadith in bhukari, narrator Saeed Khudri? companions asked will we see Allah on qiyamat? Prophet peace and blessings be upon him said do you have problem seeing sun or moon when there are no clouds up?
    You will see Allah exactly like that.
    22 :20 - Do all Anbiya have ummat.
    Answer is in Surah Isra , the day we will call every person behind their imam!
    Hadith Anas Malik Tirmidhi, Prophet peace and blessings be upon him saw nations going into jannah following their prophets, I saw a prophet with 9 ppl and another with 2 followers and I saw a prophet with 0 followers...
    24 :30 - why do we correct each other but not encourage each other...
    we can always encourage good and mention like in hadith of the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him mentioning virtues of sahaba...
    dont take a correction as a criticism , as its helping go to jannah!
    if you do good and no one appreciates it, so what, if youa re doing it for Allah , it shouldn't matter.
    hadith there were ppl using pebbles to count thikr, Abu Musa went to Ibn Masud, I saw a thing in masjid and I wanted to ask you about it, ibn MAsud says even the bowls didn't break and either you are better then sahaba or doing bida, don't count your good deeds, Allah won't waste them, be aware of your sin!
    Do good with iklas, and don't reject a criticsm thats harsh, maybe you can correct them on harshness but accept the truth.
    30 00 - Book of znah and sunnah
    Aisha Radiyallahu anha said beauty of Man is in beard, only the ring as a stamp was worn by the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him!
    jewelry isn't from manhood, but nisahood!
    in essence, chains and bracelets are for nisa...
    salaf's precedent over culture... masculinity and feminity changes in other cultures due to it lacking guidance!
    34 :45 - sh. Karim when grls grow up they worry about dressing... says men distinguish yourself! there is no confusion like in west.
    37 :00 - question about working in a Muslim country, and hadith disowning Muslims in non Muslim countries.
    Sh. Karim says can you practice Islam and those you are in charage of or give dawa where ever you are? if yes you can stay, if not , leave!
    39 :15 - if you owe a debt or wronged and want to rectify but cant find them?
    Look for them or if they passed, look for their relatives, then give sadaqa with niyat for them to accept it!
    40 :30 - thikr beads aren't in sunnah, there will be light for those using fingers... (hadith?)
    Sh. Uthaymin says if you use it to keep count ok....
    but some ppl don't do thikr without it... and if you are making jewelry out of then this isn't done by sunnah.
    43 :30 - I did so many sins and think i should marry a sister who is similar and not a good one.
    Sh. Karim said good you didn't mention who you are, conceal what Allah conceals of sins, Quran 39 :52 - don't despair of Allah's mercy...
    Hadith if you sin a world's worth, Allah will forgive you if you don't do shirk!
    some ppl are addicted to sin, if so disclose so the sister can help or it can affect.
    47 :30 - if you steal from bank what happens?
    you can't stteal, if no need or mental issue you can lose an arm.
    48 :40 - how to advice on hygeine?
    advice and don't backbite.
    ibn Rajab has book on nasiha vs. criticism...
    maybe do it on side.
    51 :00 - how balance secular and din studies?
    seek means
    53 :30 - how deal with Qom Loot?
    deal with them like other sinners nicely but don't compromise on your din.
    55 :35 - what if you didn't pray for months?
    Karim says if you didn't pray bfore w/o valid excuse you can't make it up. Make tawba, sign its accepted is that you keep praying.
    57 :00 - brother says he wants a sister who doesn't listen to music & movies.
    Umar used to patrol, he heard a mom tell daughter to dilute milk, girl said Umar forbade this, her mom said he's not here, and she replied but His Lord sees us.
    So Umar told his son to propose to her the next day.
    ask on ruling of music.
    1 :01 :00 - Malik mawt obeys Allah is taking souls but he has angels with him like in hadith man died on the way.
    1 :03 :00 - beard is fard sunna, its an order as well as trmming mustache, all 4 mathhabs say its fard.
    hadith ppl of majewsis shaved beard and had tick mustache and he asked what have you done, my Lord ordered me to grow the beard and trim mustache.
    Sk says in Jannah no beards.
    1 :08 :30 - q on braids for men.
    Utman Faruq said sunna had braied their hair in 4 locks during travel.
    Prophet peace and blessings be upon him grew his hair up to his shoulders.
    hadith Abu Dawud whoever imitates a ppl is from them, you will be raised with who you love.
    clothing made by a non Muslim isn't haram by it.
    Muslims when they practice right ppl follow them...
    In philadelphia he saw a guy with kufi, jeans cut, thobe, beards give him directions to masjids but he said I am not a Muslim though.
    imitate good ppl not sinners.
    1 :16 :40 - how to attain parents love
    hadith of 3 amins. Anel Jibril said May Allah not have MErcy on one who finds his parent's in old age and doesn't find his way to heaven.
    there are 3 pairs in Quran to ibn Abbas.
    salat, zakat
    obey Allah and HIs Messenger
    Be grateful to Allah and then to parents! even if parents are bad.
    mothers and fathers day is bida.
    in hadith there are 2 eids.

    • @abdulkhafidsulaymaan
      @abdulkhafidsulaymaan 2 роки тому

      no. its because they understand that eating doubtful or clearly forbidden meat rinders your du'a unacceptable by Allah.
      haram is haram, that is clear so they know to repent for sins but actions that rinders your supplications unacceptable- that is simply a NO NO. Hanafs believe eating haram meat makes your du'a unacceptable.

  • @mtrabr6820
    @mtrabr6820 2 роки тому +1

    What was he refering to in the beginning???

    • @AbuJamilah
      @AbuJamilah 2 роки тому +1

      Buying homes on Riba

    • @mtrabr6820
      @mtrabr6820 2 роки тому +1

      @@AbuJamilah baraka Allahu fik

  • @logiic8835
    @logiic8835 2 роки тому +1

    Uthman ibn Farooq is not a master in fiqh right? Please correct me If I’m mistaken thanks.

    • @smr_0172
      @smr_0172 2 роки тому +1

      no one has mastered 'ilm.

    • @coha348
      @coha348 2 роки тому

      Im pretty sure his main is the study of ahadith. But I maybe wrong.

    • @logiic8835
      @logiic8835 2 роки тому

      @@coha348 yeah that’s what I thought too

    • @logiic8835
      @logiic8835 2 роки тому

      @@smr_0172 I was wondering if he had any accreditation in fiqh.

    • @smr_0172
      @smr_0172 2 роки тому +5

      @@logiic8835 i dont know. but i mean to say that NO ONE has mastered knowledge of Islam. not even the greatest scholars made this claim.

  • @Islamis4all
    @Islamis4all 2 роки тому

    The official position of great scholars such as Al-Khirqi, Ibn Al-Jawzi, Ibn Qudamah, `Ali Al-Mardawi, Al-Hijjawi, Al-Buhuti, Mar`i bin Yusuf, Al-Ba`li, and others (Allah have mercy upon them all) is that missed prayers must be made up, and that they must be made up in order unless it has been forgotten or the present prayer’s time becomes constricted.
    Ibn Taymiyyah and a few early scholars (Allah have mercy upon them all) were of the opinion that missed prayers do not need to be made up, since the person has become an apostate by intentionally missing the prayer and just as a kafir is not required to make up prayers when he enters Islam, neither is an apostate. I have yet to see something convincing that shows that this was ever used as the official position in the madhhab at any time, rather it seems to be a personal opinion that some scholars held.
    We can see that the vast majority of Hanbali scholars, both pre-Ibn Taymiyyah and post-Ibn Taymiyyah, rejected this position. How, then, can someone follow it and claim to be following the Hanbali madhhab? The people after Ibn Taymiyyah who rejected it (Allah have mercy upon him and them) were not against Ibn Taymiyyah, rather they had a great deal of respect for him. But they were first and foremost Hanbalis, and so when they weighed his opinion against the principles of the school they rejected it.
    In sha Allah I will look into this issue in depth.
    And Allah knows best.
    The Hanbalis in the next few generations after Ibn Taymiyyah and Ibn Qayyim Al-Jarwizzah (Allah have mercy upon them all) took the opinions of these two scholars and they reconciled them (for want of a better term) with the madhhab, weighing which opinion was strongest with respect to the foundations and principles of the school. Sometimes the position they took was taken, and sometimes it was not. Ibn Qayyim (Allah have mercy upon him) is just as controversial as his teacher, if not more so since he was the one who recorded and systematized Ibn Taymiyyah’s ideas. And whether or not people want to admit it, these two controversial figures did have an influence on Islam that will always be with us; some of the influences were good, and some of them bad.
    And Allah knows best.

  • @anasibndawood6696
    @anasibndawood6696 2 роки тому

    Unfortunately interest is everywhere and in every transaction these days. No way around it

  • @candeladellavita
    @candeladellavita 2 роки тому +1

    Godless homes are not usually great

  • @naveen-kumar
    @naveen-kumar Рік тому

    www.youtube.com/@AdamSeeker massallah