Conflating Secularism and Capitalism

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 31 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 99

  • @mohammadshahbaz4134
    @mohammadshahbaz4134 12 днів тому +12

    السلام علیکم سر آپ سے آج ٹھوکر نیاز بیگ میں ملاقات ہوئی اور آپ کو لائیو سنا اللہ تعالٰی آپ کو صحت والی لمبی عمر عطا کرے اور آپ اسی طرح ملک و قوم کے مسائل اور انکے حل کے لئے کو ششیں جاری رکھیں اور اللہ تعالٰی آپ کی ان کاوشوں کو قبول فرمائے آمین آپ کے لئے دعا گو

    • @Taimur_Laal
      @Taimur_Laal  12 днів тому +4

      @@mohammadshahbaz4134 thank you.

    • @user-vj1bl3se6t
      @user-vj1bl3se6t 12 днів тому +1

      ❤❤❤ﷲ پاک محمدﷺ❤❤❤

    • @ServantCalligraphy
      @ServantCalligraphy 11 днів тому

      انکے ساتھ ساتھ علماء سے بھی روابط رکھیں سمجھنے کی کوشش کریں ، مفتی یاسر ندیم الواجدی ، بسالت آدم وغیرہ وہ آپکو وہ بھی دکھوئی گے جو یہ چھپاتے ہیں

    • @user789as
      @user789as 5 днів тому

      ❤❤❤ﷲ پاک محمدﷺ❤❤❤

  • @kaveetamortee4512
    @kaveetamortee4512 12 днів тому

    The way you've made a serious issue so interesting is amazing.

  • @baljindersingh-cn5bs
    @baljindersingh-cn5bs 12 днів тому

    Spot on, Dr Saab digging the roots now👍

  • @Bethak_E_Sukhn
    @Bethak_E_Sukhn 13 днів тому +6

    Sir es Friday political theory wali series Ki vedio upload Nahi hui

    • @Taimur_Laal
      @Taimur_Laal  13 днів тому +7

      @@Bethak_E_Sukhn yes it is released. Just check my channel. Another one will be released tomorrow. Now I have scheduled them for a release every two days.

  • @aaaq1122
    @aaaq1122 12 днів тому

    I really idealize you as a teacher Sir Taimoor. My respect and lots of love. ❤

  • @Nuaman-v5m
    @Nuaman-v5m 12 днів тому

    Sir Red 😊 Thank you very much for explaining sec and cap.

  • @zaheerhassan1574
    @zaheerhassan1574 12 днів тому +1

    Not all religious preacher support landlords. Allama Pervaiz interpretation is entirely different. Molana Bahashani is another example

  • @abcdefg98138
    @abcdefg98138 12 днів тому

    Great video
    Great teacher ❤
    Great learning

  • @AkibHussain-qy5ou
    @AkibHussain-qy5ou 12 днів тому

    Beautiful explanations, I love your channel.

  • @sheikhhashimi5082
    @sheikhhashimi5082 12 днів тому +2

    آپ کے تجزیہ سے صد فیصد درست

  • @harrishameed3687
    @harrishameed3687 5 днів тому

    Very insightful ❤

  • @abC-x4p7p
    @abC-x4p7p 12 днів тому

    Your thoughts on Anarchists like mikhail bakunin and peter kropotkin. Please make a video

  • @akbar-nr4kc
    @akbar-nr4kc 12 днів тому

    sir which one is more difficult than other in lacan ecrites and heideggar ''being and time''?

  • @waqarahmed2694
    @waqarahmed2694 12 днів тому +1

    Nice knowledge sir

  • @A.SMotivation-ii1wk
    @A.SMotivation-ii1wk 12 днів тому +1

    ❤ love 💕 sir thank you for great work ❤

  • @rehan7098
    @rehan7098 12 днів тому

    Sir, Your lecture on Political theory which was due to be realised on Friday is not there in the channel.
    Or atleast it is not Public Yet.
    I have read your comment that you have uploaded the lecture but it is still missing.
    Kindly fix it at earliest.
    Thanks.

  • @Dr.VimleshTripathiInitiatives
    @Dr.VimleshTripathiInitiatives 11 днів тому +1

    🧡🧡🧡

  • @AhmadSaleem-k1q
    @AhmadSaleem-k1q 12 днів тому +1

    Sir g pleae make a video on nationalism in the view of islam and secularism in the view of islam ❤

    • @Taimur_Laal
      @Taimur_Laal  11 днів тому

      I've made so many. Just have a look on my channel. I have done hundreds of videos on these types of subjects.

    • @ServantCalligraphy
      @ServantCalligraphy 11 днів тому

      Ahmad Bhai Insa Seekh k Mufti Yasir Nadeem Al Wajidi sa debate kijiye ya Eman Union Team sa apka teacher to krty nai hayn

  • @knowledgekey4298
    @knowledgekey4298 12 днів тому +1

    Very knowledgeable video love from Bihar India

  • @Philosopher-ey6qg
    @Philosopher-ey6qg 12 днів тому +5

    Sir aap Mao, Stalin aur Lenin ko kaise dekhte hain. What about millions killed by communists Regimes

    • @ServantCalligraphy
      @ServantCalligraphy 11 днів тому

      Wo nai Btayn Ga Yah , Apni Patloon thori nah Utaarni hay
      Oska Liya Mufti Yasir Nadeem , Basalat Adam , Habib Nadwi , Tawhid Intruth In logon sa pochiye

    • @Philosopher-ey6qg
      @Philosopher-ey6qg 11 днів тому

      @ServantCalligraphy bete tameez se baat karie. Mai prof sahab ki bahut respect karta hun. Jin sahiban ka aapne naam lia hai, saare mulla munafiqeen hain. West ko gaali dete hain aur rehte bhi jaake wahin hain. Mufti wajidi Afghanistan kab shift ho raha hai

    • @Philosopher-ey6qg
      @Philosopher-ey6qg 10 днів тому

      @ServantCalligraphy bhai mufti sahab afghanistan kab shift ho rahe hain😄?
      Kyun khud wo ek evl secular democracy me rehte hain??

    • @ServantCalligraphy
      @ServantCalligraphy 10 днів тому

      @@Philosopher-ey6qg Bhai join ho k poch lo , aj raat Tawhid in Truth ki stream hy ajao ma baat krlunga apsa , ma b whi h hnga

    • @ServantCalligraphy
      @ServantCalligraphy 10 днів тому

      @@Philosopher-ey6qg aj raat chakar lgao Tawhid intruth ya Mufti Abdullah minhaj dono ki stream hy 9:00 k bd

  • @TalhaM-j3y
    @TalhaM-j3y 12 днів тому

    Apke pechle video k comment mein main ne kuch sawal kiye the jike reply mein aap ne kaha tha "Excellent questions" to Sir poochna ye tha un excellent questions k jawab ka wait karu ya bhool jaun?

    • @Taimur_Laal
      @Taimur_Laal  12 днів тому +1

      Bhool jain tu behtar hai 😂

  • @SajjadAli-ek8yy
    @SajjadAli-ek8yy 13 днів тому

    Thanks sir for your intellectual analysis❤

    • @Taimur_Laal
      @Taimur_Laal  12 днів тому +1

      Always welcome

    • @SajjadAli-ek8yy
      @SajjadAli-ek8yy 12 днів тому

      @Taimur_Laal I love the way you share ideas and interpret critically

  • @malik_e
    @malik_e 13 днів тому +2

    To date, that sahib has not renounced his own sworn allegiance to a totally secular and liberal constitution. There is not one conflation, there is hyper-inflation in the conflation of ideas and concepts he dabbles in as, in his own muslim humility, 'a renowned expert' and 'a school of knowledge in himself'. Can you beat that! The bottom line is the otherwise much maligned profit motive since the UK business of 'life coaching' is worth a staggering 588 Pounds Sterling. And in the intellectually infantile environment he has planted himself, it seems to be working.

  • @Javednawaz-nf8dn
    @Javednawaz-nf8dn 12 днів тому

    Very nice information

  • @Albayyinah4571
    @Albayyinah4571 12 днів тому +1

    These banks take away light of virtue from the heart of human. Until and unless this system is not destroyed, the talk about wisdom, civilization and religion are meaning less.
    Allama iqbal

  • @abdullahjan1930
    @abdullahjan1930 13 днів тому +1

    Sir Ap jb bol rhy Hain tu nechy Sanskrit lekhi arhi hai
    Ya Urdu a ay ya English a ay

  • @dharmeshparikh7837
    @dharmeshparikh7837 13 днів тому +2

    Interesting discussion, Mr. Taimur. I agree that secularism has nothing to do with wars, etc. But I don't agree with your second point. Both communist & and capitalism regimes can be brutal in violence. We have examples from the past. So don't say only Capatalism is the reason.
    I have one question.
    If you believe Capatalism is bad and communist governments are good compared to them, then why so many millions of people died in great leap Forward in China during the 1960s? Now, please don't say the Chinese regime during the 1950s was not communist as per your definition.

    • @Taimur_Laal
      @Taimur_Laal  13 днів тому +2

      @@dharmeshparikh7837 don’t call for capitalist propaganda. They are experts in deception.

    • @dharmeshparikh7837
      @dharmeshparikh7837 12 днів тому

      @@Taimur_Laal I think you haven't read my question. If communist governments are so good, then how great leap Forward resulted in the casualties of millions of innocent lives in China.

    • @moonfour4
      @moonfour4 12 днів тому +1

      ​@Taimur_Laal or or it just might be just you know the slightest of a chance (sarcasm ) you have fallen into the propaganda or very extreme one sided look on events by socialist or communist propaganda . Regulated Capitalism isn't perfect very bad actually in my opinion due to the flaws of mankind but socialism is the answer to everything is just to one sided or in a negative conanation stupid respectfully sir

    • @Taimur_Laal
      @Taimur_Laal  12 днів тому +1

      Please read.
      mronline.org/2011/06/26/revisiting-alleged-30-million-famine-deaths-during-chinas-great-leap/

    • @19665061
      @19665061 12 днів тому +1

      Who were "innocent lives"? Their class structure? ​@@dharmeshparikh7837

  • @WaliUllah0300
    @WaliUllah0300 12 днів тому

    Assalamu alikom professor I'm waiting for your lecture "Political Science".

  • @19665061
    @19665061 12 днів тому +1

    Taimur's facebook was once hacked. My select comments on Taimur's videos are removed! Who could be behind all this? In India, Taimur's father Saif is attacked! 🥴🥺

  • @kidzuna-p4j
    @kidzuna-p4j 12 днів тому

    But Sir, in secular county, if you liberal secular person. Than you are 1st class citizen. Even look at universities in Pakistan. If you are fundamentalists. You are on equal footings with the other person. I know it is not written in the constitution but it is...

    • @Taimur_Laal
      @Taimur_Laal  12 днів тому +1

      No. It’s the other way around. Elite has become secular. Just because you are secular doesn’t mean you will become part of the elite.

    • @kidzuna-p4j
      @kidzuna-p4j 12 днів тому

      @Taimur_Laal So, that means secularism is unable to teach them all the animals are equal. Then what's the use of secularism. I need equality in practice if it exists. Or needs to get money by hook or by crook ( Alas I don't have any of the means). In socialism once again islamists will be 2nd class citizens. Even if you are "mazdoor" you need to be socialist secular like wise you need to be Muslim in Pakistan.

  • @Kafir-e-Muqaddas
    @Kafir-e-Muqaddas 13 днів тому +2

    Sir ji, does Islam accept scientific thought process based on debate, discussion, questioning, logic, critical analysis, critical thinking, cross checking of evidence, proof & witness? Or is it just believing cooked-up stories, cock-&-bull stories, self proclamations and practising blind beliefs & blind faiths ....?

    • @Taimur_Laal
      @Taimur_Laal  13 днів тому +3

      @@Kafir-e-Muqaddas Islam is not a person. It can undertake no acts. The question is whether Muslims can do it.

    • @MuhammadBinAbbas-k7y
      @MuhammadBinAbbas-k7y 12 днів тому

      مسلمانوں کی حاکمیت اور اسلامی اقدار کا مطلب دین اسلام کی بنیادی تعلیم سے آراستہ لوگ رہبر ہوں گے ناکہ مدارس کے اساتذہ......

    • @whydontyoustfu
      @whydontyoustfu 12 днів тому

      ​@@Taimur_Laal cope out answer

    • @Kafir-e-Muqaddas
      @Kafir-e-Muqaddas 12 днів тому

      @@MuhammadBinAbbas-k7y Please translate to English.

    • @Human-xz2gr
      @Human-xz2gr 12 днів тому

      Islam is the biggest fraud in the name of “religion” it’s a fascist dogmatic ideology to promote Arab-Islamic imperialism.

  • @muhammadnadeem3467
    @muhammadnadeem3467 13 днів тому +2

    سر اپ کے کام اور شخصیت پہ ایک شعر۔۔میں 6 سال سے آپ کو سن رہا ہوں اور آپ کی سوچ کا خاموش مبلغ ہوں ۔زندہ دانشوروں میں صرف آپ سے ملنے کا اشتیاق ہے
    انہی کی شہہ سے انہیں مات کرتا رہتا ہوں
    ستم گروں کی مدارات کرتا رہتا ہوں
    یہاں پہ کوئی نہیں سنتا حدیث دل زدگاں
    مگر میں اور طرح بات کرتا رہتا ہوں
    بھلا یہ عمر کوئی کاروبار شوق کی ہے ؟
    مگر اک تلافئ ما فات کرتا رہتا ہوں

  • @knowledgekey4298
    @knowledgekey4298 12 днів тому

    Population per ek video please

  • @alvesimam6618
    @alvesimam6618 12 днів тому

    I think a bigger picture of political oppression is always ignored when US invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq is discused.
    Both PDPA of Afghanistan and Baathist Iraq were indeed secular, but they cracked down opposition, political activism and freedom of speech. At least there is space in Western world.
    Marxist people should understand to just have a one party rule you engage with a lot of oppression that they don't even desire.
    Within weeks the Khalqist Afghans amassed imprisonment and killed thousands in Herat. Saddam killed thousands of Shiites whom I am also a witness before them Communist Abul Qasim used to oppress Baathism.

    • @braveheart8318
      @braveheart8318 12 днів тому

      Of course he's going to ignore those examples because they're not fitting in his communist narrative.

  • @Mooneypilot101
    @Mooneypilot101 12 днів тому

    Islam, like all religions is a divider rather than a uniter. Secular countries are stronger and more prosperous.

    • @braveheart8318
      @braveheart8318 12 днів тому

      Eastern Europe is secular but far from prosperous.

    • @Mooneypilot101
      @Mooneypilot101 11 днів тому

      @@braveheart8318 They are far more prosperous than most Islamic countries or countries like Haiti which is devoutly Catholic. Secular societies allow different religious and non religious groups to come together for a common cause.....ECONOMICS. Read up on Denmark, Sweden and Norway. These were once very violent societies. They became secular and peaceful once they walked away from Christianity.

  • @ServantCalligraphy
    @ServantCalligraphy 11 днів тому

    Sir ap b Kuch Marxist k Zalum k khilaaf bolyn ga ya hm Mufti Yasir Nadeem ya Eman Union Team Sa h sunayn ga , Ap kyon inpa nai bolty?

  • @dainali1318
    @dainali1318 9 днів тому

    Agreed

  • @abdullahjan1930
    @abdullahjan1930 13 днів тому +2

    Hummmm❤

  • @nowie4007
    @nowie4007 13 днів тому +1

    ❤❤

  • @19665061
    @19665061 12 днів тому +1

    👌

  • @afkaar117
    @afkaar117 12 днів тому

  • @muhammadnadeem3467
    @muhammadnadeem3467 13 днів тому +2

    اور سر بنو قریظہ میں ایک اور بات بھی ایڈ کرلیں کہ فتح مکہ کے موقع پر جب حضرت سعد نے تیزی دکھائی اور تند و تیز کا نعرہ لگایا تو پیغمبر اسلام نے ان سے پرچم لے لیا تھا

  • @muhammadshahbaz2937
    @muhammadshahbaz2937 12 днів тому

    😍

  • @waqarahmed2694
    @waqarahmed2694 12 днів тому

    apki vidos si hum buht zyada wisdom mli hi

  • @irfanshafique5474
    @irfanshafique5474 12 днів тому +1

    تیمور بھائی آپ کے مطابق آقا علیہ السلام سرمایہ داری نظام کو سپورٹ کرنے نہیں تھے۔ یہ ہم مان لیتے ہیں۔ تو پھر آپ اب بتائیں کیا وہ سیکولرازم کو قائم کرنے آئے تھے؟ ۔ اس بات کی تھوڑی وضاحت کر دیں۔

    • @Taimur_Laal
      @Taimur_Laal  11 днів тому

      Systems keep changing with time. Secularism is a new social contract that is important for our times to solve the problems of minority majority and also sectarian issues.

  • @mohammadadil3833
    @mohammadadil3833 12 днів тому

    السلام علیکم، تیمور صاحب، کبھی فاطمی حکومت، ابو طاہر کرامتی اور حجر اسود کی چوری کے واقعہ کو تفصیل سے بتائیے

  • @tariqmehmood622
    @tariqmehmood622 12 днів тому

    ڈاکٹر صاحب ۔۔۔ماشاالللہ اپ پولٹیکل سائینس کے پروفیسر ہے اور اپ کا مطالعہ ںھی بہت وسیع ہے۔
    ایک V log ریاست مدنیہ کے خدوخال پر کرے کہ وہ ریاست کیسی تھی اور اس کے اصول سیاست و حکومت کیا تھے۔
    کیا یہی مذہب اسلام جو اج ہمیں بتایا جاتا ہے ، وہ اسی طرح کا اسلام تھا یا کوئی دین تھا۔ دین کا مطلب تو گورنمنٹ ہوتا ہے۔ کیا وہ ریاست ایک مذہبی ریاست یا ایک سیکولر ، سوشلسٹ، فلاحی ریاست تھی۔
    کیا وہ ریاست سکون سے عبادات کرنے کے لیے بنائی گئی تھی یا اس ریاست نے مذہبی ، استحصلی طبقوں سے جنگ کی تھی ؟
    امید ہے کہ اپ ان سوالوں پر ایک V log ضرور بنائے گے اور مذہبی لوگوں کی تنقید سے نہیں گھبرائے گے۔
    شکریہ

  • @elonayyub943
    @elonayyub943 12 днів тому +1