Rookie mistake. In AE, you have to separate the arm from the main body to make it more natural. Sure, the old school way is more natural and has character. But you could also do the same with AE if you learn it
The second one is not exactly the best example of what that type of animation can be. I believe Bluey is, at least in part, animated using either the same technology or at least similar to the second example. That show look incredible. The animation is genuinely very expressive, in the sense that the faces are full of personality and the movements are full of weight. Some of the falls Bandit takes almost make me feel pain.
@@justjulia1720 yes I believe it’s actually said to be puppet animation style specially where each piece is separated and moved so it’s like moving action figures around instead of frame by frame
as a hand-drawn animator I still don't understand and can't make tween animations huhuhuu 🥲😔. In my opinion, both are equally good, hand-draw animation looks more natural and cool,but tween animation is smoother and easier(according to others). Well.. although hand-drawn animator are rare now, but ya'll can't hate tween animator, at least we can appreciate them who want to animate the easy way. I mean it's not that bad, because hand-drawn animation will always be special ✨
As a tweening animator, it's really not easier than hand drawn if you do it properly. My animation software crashed twice while tweening one video and it took me hours (for a like 20 second vid) People like this water it down to "yeah just click and it does it for you:3"
As a fully hand drawn animator I would like to confirm that hand drawn is a very lengthy process that (I think) is probably less technical. I don't have the right apps, though, so don't take this too seriously!
Honestly shaming people for tweening is stupid. It can be well done and honestly it’s just working smarter not harder. Plus it’s not like you’re not doing ANY of the work. If you want to make a full animated project you still have to draw the different poses needed and maybe some in between frames but tweening can help the process by saving time
Frr, I know how to tween and fps animate and theyre still both difficult to do and require equal effort. But one benefit is everything is precoloured; I never colour my fps animations 😭🙏
As much as I prefer hand drawn/frame by frame animationg, tweening is just as good. I'm no pro, but this short is not a great example to show how good motion animation is. You usually have the art on separate layers for specific things being animated
Yeah, I use both. I started out on fps but bc of adhd I can't ever finish them. When I do tweening, it is just as difficult but "easier" in a sense that I can complete all the separate drawings and the rest I can edit together. The editing does take a lot of effort, but I'd rather do that over drawing so many frames lol
tweening can be done correctly and look nice and smooth with graphs! this is kinda a bad example, you can make tweening look REALLY smooth and not choppy, you just have to practice. the same goes with hand drawn animation, it can be choppy, but learning how to master movements and smoothness makes it better! both are great, and adding them both together is always really cool!
THIS!!!! I do tweening and it's extremely hard (I use capcut so that might be the issue) but it always ends up looking a lot nicer than this (if anyone wants to see what I mean I upload my tweens btw)
@@Ra1ndr0pomfg I saw a few and your tweenings amazing! I lowk still am an idiot and I don't know how to distort overlays/stretch them in perspective in capcut 😭😭 idrk how to explain it properly
Let’s be fair here, this is kind of a bad example of tweening. Tweening is an awesome art form! Very useful in many animations no matter what! This one only looks slightly off because the body and arm are one piece, if the arm was seperate, and moving without the body it would look quite nice! But it is all up to preference! I myself prefer the hand drawn, but as someone who animates, hand drawn animation takes a lot of time and is difficult. If you like the tweeted one more, that’s awesome! I’m so glad you appreciate the under appreciated art form that is tweening! I’ve used it in my animations many times along side my hand drawn work and it is such a time saver!
chat this is not how tweening suppose to work, theyre both really great methods and are both HELLA DIFFICULT!!!! to make look good. to be good at something you gotta put in the effort alright alright
First: sorta beginner, as there;s no ease in Second: That is the wrong way to character rig, as the rest of the body is distorting also Edit: also there is nothing wrong with tweening, as I always combine tweening with hand animation
Most of the people I meet that tween usually think they are better than me, personally I just animate, I don’t like how it looks when tweening, but that’s your opinion
Some forms of tweening are manual. Like you don't just do a rig then click, that's an extremely unrealistic depiction. I hate when people are showing how tweening works and they just water it down to a few clicks when it's anything but a few clicks😭😭
Fr, this isn't fair, I'd rather see a time-lapse of the same thing being animated in both fps and tweening (I'd volunteer if not for my low motivation)
As a tweener, this isn't really a good example of how to do it. First of all, you have to separate the body parts into segments so there's no distortion of the rest of the body seen in the video. Secondly Adobe isn't the best program to use and is not the program most tweeners use; personally I use alight motion bc it's easy to learn and mostly free but there's a lot more programs if u wanna try tweening look into it there's better ones that are cheaper and easier to use
I use capcut to tween and it makes me so mad when people water down tweening to "click to rig and then it does it for you" like no, you need keyframes, graphs, layers, overlays, etc
Oo motion? I use capcut but it's obviously not meant to be a tweening app and I wanna try to see the difference between it and apps catered towards art
It’s because the animator did it incorrectly, and also watered it down. You don’t just click and have it done for you, that’d be as bad as AI generated animation.
as a both frame by frame and tweening animator, that is definitely not how tweening works, youll have to seperate the body parts youre going to tween so that the specific part you want to move only moves there is no problem using tweening or frame by frame, as long as you know how to use them, itll come out great. also, both animation techniques take time to learn
Tweening is pretty difficult if you know what you are doing, i usually have to separate each part of the drawing and. For example:the head, hair, eyes, torso, and arms are separated and put back together when animating in a program. Tweening is kinda like making a marionette with all moveable joints but made digitally. Did you know that vtubers models use tweening?
The second one was way less detailed than the first. Some people can make really good animations with the one picture. This was not the best example. 😅
my only question is why are you using Adobe After Effects for 2D animation? you're better off using Flash or Animate (if you _have to_ use Adobe) or maybe use Maya or Toon Boom.. After Effects is more useful for things like Michael Bay-like movies
As a former GachaTuber and now someone who animates for fun Jesus Christ people underestimates the skill for tweening. If it’s me I’d say that I’d rather animate by hand than to tween something
Round 3: Alight motion Looking: the best 😘 Animation: like the lake under the willow flows gently and smoothly 😌 How many ppl use: LOTTTTSSS OFFF (I respect ppl who use ae and by hand, but alight m is more easy to me)
The issues with arm separation and lack of nuanced motion aside, if you transform raster graphics like this, it's inevitably going to have artifacts from stretching.
SEcond wasn't good because it also affects the head and the bottom torso, so the limbs must be seperated to make it better, second is good, but bad, First is mid, but kinda good, The second maybe smooth, but it's bad due to it affecting the head and the bottom torso
Realmente depende, tú eres mejor que una IA para escribir una novela porque puedes recordar todo lo que ha pasado. La IA tiene un límite de memoria a partir del cual empezará a contradecirse en la misma obra y siempre hace las cosas muy apresuradas, no pone desarrollo, va a la acción directa
Second one could have been done better, but in the end, both methods have their ups and downs and unique uses. I'd say artists today generally would wanna do a mix of both
Both of these work for different things. Tweening is nice for a more comedic or cutesy style of animating, as well as if you want to give a more alien/scary effect on things, whereas normal animating for everything else
I honestly think in Adobe Animate the way you use bones to animate characters is kind of like a puppet, but without the strings! It’s much easier than making thousands and thousands of drawings!
I used to hate tweening but then I had to work in AE in the college and damn it is the best program for that kind of stuff. I was working on a project as a practice and we had to make kids drawings move. I remember there was a goat mother from some fairytale and I had to move her arm. It was the most satisfying shit I've ever done. The hardest part was to separate layers since it's scanned kid's drawing but the animation was easy af Now I think using different types of animation for one project is good
If you know what you're doing you can make very convincing and well animated rigged animation. Frame by frame is a-lot harder and more time consuming. I'd suggest any new animators to choose Frame by frame first though.
Frame by frame takes a ton of time and work, but don't require too specific skills, tweening requires too many specific skills, but much less time than frame, but both combined become much more than on their own
Real, but tbf for frame by frame you need skills like perspective and being able to shift it, including background perspectives. Though I do agree that both require equal effort
У каждой анимации есть плюсы и минусы, в покадровой - плавность движений и детализация. Через векторы - простота использовании и скорость. Вообще можно попробовать их совмещать, в умелых руках работа будет выглядеть хорошо. Поэтому не понимаю почему в видео критикуется покадровая, почти всё мультфильмы/аниме сделаны с помощью покадровой, и совмещены с 3Д или векторной анимацией, либо для экономии бюджета либо для упрощения.
![Nuts [YTP] | A Moana parody](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MnIRAGodAXA/mqdefault.jpg)
As someone who does a mixture of tweening and frame by frame, both arts need their own respect
@@Aladite i feel like some animators would use both to get various effects
What do you feel about bone-based animation
tbh just thought he was gonna pick up the picture and violently shake it lmao.
same
@@Aladite não tem entender
Rookie mistake. In AE, you have to separate the arm from the main body to make it more natural.
Sure, the old school way is more natural and has character. But you could also do the same with AE if you learn it
thanks for the tip
This ^^^
Frfr
@@kaktusgoreng so what's AE is it after effects?
Yeah, I was thinking that was probably the issue
First: Very excellent.
Second: Easy, but bad.
Fr
God splicing would save this mans
Its not easy or ugly if you actually do it right.
@@Zulu_ah but this isn't actually done right. Every part is together. Of the arm and body were separayed it would've looked precious
@@ДмитрийНедеров-в9д true
Ae는 약간 괜찮아 괜찮아~ 하는 느낌이고
그림은 부드러운 인사 (좋아요 1000개 감사합니다)
ae
ae
ae
리깅한건가?
Aeㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 애프터이펙트
The second one is not exactly the best example of what that type of animation can be. I believe Bluey is, at least in part, animated using either the same technology or at least similar to the second example. That show look incredible. The animation is genuinely very expressive, in the sense that the faces are full of personality and the movements are full of weight. Some of the falls Bandit takes almost make me feel pain.
@@justjulia1720 yes I believe it’s actually said to be puppet animation style specially where each piece is separated and moved so it’s like moving action figures around instead of frame by frame
@@peachr384 also known as tweening.
@@ThatOne_Drag0n-X3 what they said isn't tweening. tweening is when the computer fills in frames between two keyframes
どちらかがより優れているとかは無く、場合によって使い分けるべき技術だと感じてる。
:thumbsup:
@@orxenborexstudios42 this isn't discord
@@File.Namee2:thumbsup:
근데 난 개인적으로 Ae애니메이션 보단 여러장 그린 애니메이션이 나음
Of course
What though
Si ami igual la de æ se siente más fea
대신 힘이 엄청나게 쓰이는 방면 ai는 힘이 안들어요
me too
as a hand-drawn animator I still don't understand and can't make tween animations huhuhuu 🥲😔.
In my opinion, both are equally good, hand-draw animation looks more natural and cool,but tween animation is smoother and easier(according to others).
Well.. although hand-drawn animator are rare now, but ya'll can't hate tween animator, at least we can appreciate them who want to animate the easy way. I mean it's not that bad, because hand-drawn animation will always be special ✨
As a tweening animator, it's really not easier than hand drawn if you do it properly. My animation software crashed twice while tweening one video and it took me hours (for a like 20 second vid)
People like this water it down to "yeah just click and it does it for you:3"
As both a handdrawn and tweening animator, both are equally hard and require the same amount of effort
@@Ra1ndr0p i respect you, Moreover, one of the reasons why I can't do tween animation is because... device issue 🤧:')🥀
@@averageSkykid For real💥
Both also have cool results!!
As a fully hand drawn animator I would like to confirm that hand drawn is a very lengthy process that (I think) is probably less technical. I don't have the right apps, though, so don't take this too seriously!
개인생각
Ae는 약간 자연스럽지가 않아
그치만 그림은 아주 자연스럽지
결론:주인장이 개 힘들다
ㅇㅈ
ㅇㅈ
근데 ae 본명이뭐임
ㅇㅈ뀨
Both are good in their own aspects. But a combo of both usually get you the best results.
But still it’s cannot beat the beauty of hand drawn animation 🫡
true
THAT WAS WHAT I WAS THINKING
Yes! You see the computer made one is getting stretched and squashed when it isn't supposed to
How bout smth like stick node?
That’s because they’re doing rigging really badly
에펙도 핀많이 찍고 팔 레이어 따로 적용하명 자연스러울듯
Honestly shaming people for tweening is stupid. It can be well done and honestly it’s just working smarter not harder. Plus it’s not like you’re not doing ANY of the work. If you want to make a full animated project you still have to draw the different poses needed and maybe some in between frames but tweening can help the process by saving time
Frr, I know how to tween and fps animate and theyre still both difficult to do and require equal effort. But one benefit is everything is precoloured; I never colour my fps animations 😭🙏
As much as I prefer hand drawn/frame by frame animationg, tweening is just as good. I'm no pro, but this short is not a great example to show how good motion animation is. You usually have the art on separate layers for specific things being animated
Yeah, I use both. I started out on fps but bc of adhd I can't ever finish them. When I do tweening, it is just as difficult but "easier" in a sense that I can complete all the separate drawings and the rest I can edit together. The editing does take a lot of effort, but I'd rather do that over drawing so many frames lol
tweening can be done correctly and look nice and smooth with graphs! this is kinda a bad example, you can make tweening look REALLY smooth and not choppy, you just have to practice. the same goes with hand drawn animation, it can be choppy, but learning how to master movements and smoothness makes it better! both are great, and adding them both together is always really cool!
THIS!!!! I do tweening and it's extremely hard (I use capcut so that might be the issue) but it always ends up looking a lot nicer than this (if anyone wants to see what I mean I upload my tweens btw)
@@Ra1ndr0pomfg I saw a few and your tweenings amazing! I lowk still am an idiot and I don't know how to distort overlays/stretch them in perspective in capcut 😭😭 idrk how to explain it properly
excellentの効果音懐かしすぎて泣きそう(´；ω；`)
マリルイ懐かしスンギ…。(ペパマリMIX
그림 스타일마다 다르죠 둘다 개성있고 좋습니다 분위기에 따라 다르게 하는 것도 있고요 둘다 배워도 좋습니다
Let’s be fair here, this is kind of a bad example of tweening. Tweening is an awesome art form! Very useful in many animations no matter what! This one only looks slightly off because the body and arm are one piece, if the arm was seperate, and moving without the body it would look quite nice! But it is all up to preference! I myself prefer the hand drawn, but as someone who animates, hand drawn animation takes a lot of time and is difficult. If you like the tweeted one more, that’s awesome! I’m so glad you appreciate the under appreciated art form that is tweening! I’ve used it in my animations many times along side my hand drawn work and it is such a time saver!
chat this is not how tweening suppose to work, theyre both really great methods and are both HELLA DIFFICULT!!!! to make look good. to be good at something you gotta put in the effort alright alright
Real🗣‼️
No
The tweening looks like it's from someone who just knew what tweening means. The arm isn't even separated from the body
First: sorta beginner, as there;s no ease in
Second: That is the wrong way to character rig, as the rest of the body is distorting also
Edit: also there is nothing wrong with tweening, as I always combine tweening with hand animation
Most of the people I meet that tween usually think they are better than me, personally I just animate, I don’t like how it looks when tweening, but that’s your opinion
I like hand draw always, but the second animation had no work in it, not a fair comparison
Some forms of tweening are manual. Like you don't just do a rig then click, that's an extremely unrealistic depiction. I hate when people are showing how tweening works and they just water it down to a few clicks when it's anything but a few clicks😭😭
Fr, this isn't fair, I'd rather see a time-lapse of the same thing being animated in both fps and tweening (I'd volunteer if not for my low motivation)
1: Hard, but looks realistic.
2: Easy, but looks a bit bad
TRANSLATION FOR KOREAN VIEWERS:
한국어 시청자를 위한 번역:
1: 어렵지만 현실적으로 보인다.
2: 쉽지만 좀 안 좋아 보인다
Bro flipped him off💀💀
Even a anime voice said F*CK YOU💀💀💀
Yes
wdym Yes💀
he use kizuna ai 's *hua kiu*
i like ai-chan lol
You got the same letter as me!
took me too long to find this comment
As a tweener, this isn't really a good example of how to do it. First of all, you have to separate the body parts into segments so there's no distortion of the rest of the body seen in the video. Secondly Adobe isn't the best program to use and is not the program most tweeners use; personally I use alight motion bc it's easy to learn and mostly free but there's a lot more programs if u wanna try tweening look into it there's better ones that are cheaper and easier to use
I use capcut to tween and it makes me so mad when people water down tweening to "click to rig and then it does it for you" like no, you need keyframes, graphs, layers, overlays, etc
Oo motion? I use capcut but it's obviously not meant to be a tweening app and I wanna try to see the difference between it and apps catered towards art
I like the Hand drawing animation more than the AE animation.❤️
It’s because the animator did it incorrectly, and also watered it down. You don’t just click and have it done for you, that’d be as bad as AI generated animation.
펜으로 팔흔드는거 자세히 보면 겨드랑이에 점 절묘하게 찍혀서 겨털 같음ㅋㅋ😂😂😂 근데 확실히 펜으로 하는게 힘들것 같긴하지만 더 자연스러움
as a both frame by frame and tweening animator, that is definitely not how tweening works, youll have to seperate the body parts youre going to tween so that the specific part you want to move only moves
there is no problem using tweening or frame by frame, as long as you know how to use them, itll come out great. also, both animation techniques take time to learn
Tweening is pretty difficult if you know what you are doing, i usually have to separate each part of the drawing and. For example:the head, hair, eyes, torso, and arms are separated and put back together when animating in a program. Tweening is kinda like making a marionette with all moveable joints but made digitally.
Did you know that vtubers models use tweening?
ふぁっきゅ！の言い方可愛い
Drawing it is better ngl❤
Those who criticize the second method haven't seen the average jshk edit
they have not seen the good part of tweening, i've seen object shows that prefer tween animation than hand-drawn and they are pretty good
@@anomalousanimatesOBJECT SHOWS MENTIONED!!! and yeah object shows with tweening look very good (and it's easier to release episodes)
The second one was way less detailed than the first. Some people can make really good animations with the one picture. This was not the best example. 😅
my only question is why are you using Adobe After Effects for 2D animation? you're better off using Flash or Animate (if you _have to_ use Adobe) or maybe use Maya or Toon Boom..
After Effects is more useful for things like Michael Bay-like movies
Me who uses capcut for tweening 😭 but yeah I wanna try buy some good software, what's some good ones for fps ans ones for tweening?
0:24 I can't get over the "[ __ ] you"
The hand drawn animation looks way more natural than the robotic website the blue guy used
It's a software blud☠️
Call After Effect
It's an adobe app, not a website...
@@Notdukc ik I use it for editing
bro said website…..
1 : existing but good
2: bad but easy
I personally like to use a mix of both
As a former GachaTuber and now someone who animates for fun
Jesus Christ people underestimates the skill for tweening. If it’s me I’d say that I’d rather animate by hand than to tween something
Just using 5 frames you can make good animation using easing in and out
Love your tutorial btw
Round 3: Alight motion
Looking: the best 😘
Animation: like the lake under the willow flows gently and smoothly 😌
How many ppl use: LOTTTTSSS OFFF
(I respect ppl who use ae and by hand, but alight m is more easy to me)
La primera animacion se ve mas pulida, fluida y natural
El otro parece que te saluda una hoja de papel que se mueve 😂
1: hard to do but looks better
2: is easy to do but doesnt look that well
This hurts as a game designer there exists a way to do this with splicing that actually works
手書きのアニメーションにしか出せない良さがあります
The issues with arm separation and lack of nuanced motion aside, if you transform raster graphics like this, it's inevitably going to have artifacts from stretching.
1번이 매우 자연스럽고 대단하십니다 고 행님!!!
Second really said "f*** you!" Instead of "bad" 💀💀💀
ラウンド2の効果音があまりにも懐かしすぎる！！！
Que dificil es hace las animaciones, una por una 😔 (por dibujo)
Por fin un comentario en español 👏
Todos creyendo q habla japones,coreano o ingles: :3
El mano hablando español :hola puñetas >:)
이정도면 ae 광고 아니냐고오...
The first round was the best 😅❤🎉
고누리님...콜라특 만들어주세요 콜라 많이따랐는데...거품 없으면 없어지는거요
"Harder time of dedication gives you the best results"
-wise boy
Ae 저거 잘 하면 그림보다 자연 스러움
SEcond wasn't good because it also affects the head and the bottom torso, so the limbs must be seperated to make it better, second is good, but bad, First is mid, but kinda good, The second maybe smooth, but it's bad due to it affecting the head and the bottom torso
인간은 ai를 이기지 못한다
Ai is made by humans
@@Fghga123 하지만 AI는 인간을 뛰어넘을거다(미래형)
@@Fghga123But Human can't defeat AI
Realmente depende, tú eres mejor que una IA para escribir una novela porque puedes recordar todo lo que ha pasado. La IA tiene un límite de memoria a partir del cual empezará a contradecirse en la misma obra y siempre hace las cosas muy apresuradas, no pone desarrollo, va a la acción directa
デジタルで作られるアニメーションも好きだが、手間暇かけて作られるアニメーションも大好きだぜ
私はアニメーションとあなたのビデオが好きです:3
maybe try putting the arm on another layer so it doesnt distort the rest of the drawing?
The Virgin Adobe Animate VS The Chad Hand-Drawn Animation
That was the cutiest cuss word ive ever heard
I dont know whybut i needed that and now i can live the rest of the day in peace
개인생각이긴한데 Ae자연스럽ㅈ가 않음(근데 그림은 아주 자연스러움) 손수그림 되게 자연스러움 모든것이 짱 ㅋ
직점 그려봐도 그생각이 유지될까요
I find tweening so complicated so i stick to drawing each individual frame instead
Escolha o número 1 que o número 2 é trapaça isso então eu coiso número 1 que é muito desenhista mesmo é legal 1😊
Drawing cartoons 2: take a bone, click on the create frame button and move it as you want. This is called the Madness Combat style
I used to animate now I tween more often but both are great :D
separate the arm from the body so it doesn't bend with the arm
First: wow 9/10 bro
Second: is joke no?
Me personally, i prefer Alight Motion.
When he drew the animation, I liked the animation more than technology did😁
Second one could have been done better, but in the end, both methods have their ups and downs and unique uses. I'd say artists today generally would wanna do a mix of both
하지만 애니메이션이 더 좋은(?) 역시 손맛이지(?) 애니메이션이 더 부드럽고 자연스러운😮😮
It didn't give the same result that was intended. Meaning it did fail this time
First one is much better cause it won’t cause problems to the whole art itself
"He called me POOP, so i found his IP Address."
I prefer to do it by hand, rather than having someone else do things like the one at the end
Both of these work for different things. Tweening is nice for a more comedic or cutesy style of animating, as well as if you want to give a more alien/scary effect on things, whereas normal animating for everything else
The 2 is not saying "hi" its saying "nah" and 1 is... CORRECLTY(I) 🤩🤩🤩🤩
Bro is so good at animating he can animate an animation in an animation💀
Tweening, great when done right.. But sometimes... You remember all the.. Interesting art made with it...
i LOVE TWEENING ‼️‼️‼️
i love it when I'm tweening and i click 7 times and I'm done 🙃
where are the finger animators? 😯
I honestly think in Adobe Animate the way you use bones to animate characters is kind of like a puppet, but without the strings! It’s much easier than making thousands and thousands of drawings!
진짜 나만 뻡규 소리나올때 뿜었냨ㅋㄱ
Wow i love this app “ after effects “
I use alight motion, It’s very easy and smooth, but layers, OHHH BOY THE MANY MANY MANY LAYERS
IKR YOU NEED SM LAYERS TO ANIMATE EVERY PART OF THA BODY OF YOUR CHARACTER
BROO WHY IS THE “PHOK YU” so adorable 😭😭
I used to hate tweening but then I had to work in AE in the college and damn it is the best program for that kind of stuff. I was working on a project as a practice and we had to make kids drawings move. I remember there was a goat mother from some fairytale and I had to move her arm. It was the most satisfying shit I've ever done. The hardest part was to separate layers since it's scanned kid's drawing but the animation was easy af
Now I think using different types of animation for one project is good
“Fu kio😊” so funny I’m dying 💀
If you know what you're doing you can make very convincing and well animated rigged animation. Frame by frame is a-lot harder and more time consuming. I'd suggest any new animators to choose Frame by frame first though.
我認為，兩種都有好處，電繪動畫的好處就是看起來流暢，且多變，但AE也是可以做到，現在很多的2DLive，也都可以非常精緻又生動，所以我覺得工具只適用於熟練的使用者。
Frame by frame takes a ton of time and work, but don't require too specific skills, tweening requires too many specific skills, but much less time than frame, but both combined become much more than on their own
Real, but tbf for frame by frame you need skills like perspective and being able to shift it, including background perspectives. Though I do agree that both require equal effort
I love every version 2D animation❤
У каждой анимации есть плюсы и минусы, в покадровой - плавность движений и детализация. Через векторы - простота использовании и скорость. Вообще можно попробовать их совмещать, в умелых руках работа будет выглядеть хорошо. Поэтому не понимаю почему в видео критикуется покадровая, почти всё мультфильмы/аниме сделаны с помощью покадровой, и совмещены с 3Д или векторной анимацией, либо для экономии бюджета либо для упрощения.
1st way of antmating is nice and smooth, like an animation, but the 2nd way of animating just gives off that tweened goofy vibe
Hand-drawn looks better for me