10 Times I Changed My Opinion On Albums

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 чер 2024
  • Opinions change! Get used to it! Here's me talking about 10 albums that my perception has altered on to some degree. Love ya!
    ===================================
    Subscribe: bit.ly/1pBqGCN
    Official site: theneedledrop.com
    TND Twitter: / theneedledrop
    TND Facebook: / theneedledrop
    Support TND: theneedledrop.com/support
    ===================================
    Y'all know this is just my opinion, right?

КОМЕНТАРІ • 3 тис.

  • @PatrickHogan
    @PatrickHogan 7 років тому +6409

    "To Pimp a Butterfly is actually a piece of shit." Whoa.

    • @borg3698
      @borg3698 7 років тому +35

      Patrick Hogan it was the album is fucking horrible

    • @T4xEvader
      @T4xEvader 7 років тому +218

      if you're below 15 years i old i understand, yes the music is shit, relisten to it when you're 18. If you're 15 or older and you said that that means you don't know how to appreciate rap, jazz, and hiphop. Get education on that shiz son

    • @borg3698
      @borg3698 7 років тому +42

      Brian B I'm 17 and I appreciate all genres of muisic and I personally love jazz I also love old school rap as much as I love new school but tpab was absolutely terrible

    • @soulboyinc
      @soulboyinc 7 років тому +259

      borg your fucking crazy

    • @medievaldad9537
      @medievaldad9537 7 років тому +24

      Honestly it's not a very memorable album

  • @Numorks_
    @Numorks_ 7 років тому +9300

    Anthony has so many opinions he has opinions on his opinions.

  • @b0nehead576
    @b0nehead576 7 років тому +9020

    Who was around for when Anthony used to do some weird walk and yell the title of the album from his yard as an intro

    • @danofnostand3977
      @danofnostand3977 7 років тому +844

      There were less memes infesting his comments section back then. I miss it. Plus there was more Cal back then.

    • @shaunm2644
      @shaunm2644 6 років тому +518

      who was around when anthony used to include sound clips in his reviews? that shit got yanked from youtube ages ago

    • @ablaise82
      @ablaise82 6 років тому +26

      those days

    • @takejaylor3528
      @takejaylor3528 6 років тому +15

      bonehead4348 good times

    • @CHIEFS_DYNASTY_
      @CHIEFS_DYNASTY_ 6 років тому +4

      bonehead4348 me fr

  • @neoman289151
    @neoman289151 6 років тому +3635

    "Hopsin is a lyrical genius and all of his albums are masterpieces"
    Holy shit

  • @MrYeezy77
    @MrYeezy77 7 років тому +4001

    *10 years later speedin bullet to heaven becomes a 10*

    • @WraithTimid
      @WraithTimid 7 років тому +70

      NEVAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

    • @harambechungus5531
      @harambechungus5531 7 років тому +71

      Yeezy Yeezy *10 minutes

    • @FFjean
      @FFjean 6 років тому +4

      It gets a new point evey year

    • @FoxyChariot
      @FoxyChariot 6 років тому +47

      Kids See Ghosts is a 10 though

    • @simonhudak3763
      @simonhudak3763 6 років тому +8

      And now kid cudi got a 10 what do ya know xDdddd

  • @karmadelivery4407
    @karmadelivery4407 7 років тому +920

    you better stop changing your mind! my friends are gonna think I'm bipolar if I suddenly start liking something, when 3 weeks earlier you told me not to like it. Don't do this to me man I've got a good thing going, they think I'm some kind of music sensei

    • @monstr1710
      @monstr1710 7 років тому +8

      karma delivery lol

    • @absmokes4167
      @absmokes4167 7 років тому +10

      lmfao

    • @MADARAISEPIC1
      @MADARAISEPIC1 7 років тому +21

      issa ironic joke

    • @sosman747
      @sosman747 7 років тому +33

      So ... your saying you relay everything this guy says to your friends as if it's your opinion on the albums to gain your friends respect ... *FucKiNg gENius*

    • @DDPK
      @DDPK 7 років тому +8

      kodaliner the joke just went way past your head lmao

  • @ProfessorBoswell
    @ProfessorBoswell 6 років тому +1648

    "I didn't realize how dark and nihilistic I DON'T LIKE SHIT I DON'T GO OUTSIDE was."

  • @danielallen7988
    @danielallen7988 7 років тому +4081

    please look through your glasses not over them

    • @oOZAPPXVOVAOo
      @oOZAPPXVOVAOo 6 років тому +429

      Never gonna unsee that. Thanks.

    • @cjhenline1623
      @cjhenline1623 6 років тому +117

      He tries bro, he tries 😂

    • @beaupoopoo256
      @beaupoopoo256 5 років тому +44

      Devlin Asiedu it’s because he doesn’t need glasses and he wears them for ass•theTTT•icccccc

    • @mukesh_bombay
      @mukesh_bombay 5 років тому +7

      Daniel Allen defeats the purpose of glasses

    • @lukem118
      @lukem118 5 років тому +11

      DRINKING GAME: Take a dhot every time he pushes up his glasses!

  • @millerischris2247
    @millerischris2247 7 років тому +2316

    Thank you, melon guy, for giving me the opportunity to change my opinion on 10 albums.

    • @Tompa8989
      @Tompa8989 7 років тому +126

      t. /mu/

    • @DjCzubaka
      @DjCzubaka 7 років тому +53

      he forced us to change opinions about 10 albums at the same time, thats tough, man

    • @hilgahendrix7984
      @hilgahendrix7984 7 років тому +1

      Maciej Gutowski are you joking or Fr? Lmao I see this in the comments all the time

    • @jklinger410
      @jklinger410 7 років тому +1

      b a s e d

    • @DjCzubaka
      @DjCzubaka 7 років тому +8

      KINGTHONY FANTANO CONTROLS WHAT I LIKE

  • @coffdrop77
    @coffdrop77 6 років тому +6679

    Woah woah woah Anthony, it's alright if you want to change your opinion on To Pimp a Butterfly, but please don't call Kendrick the n-word.

  • @paul.andre24
    @paul.andre24 7 років тому +3805

    21:12 - *My beautiful dark twisted fantasy*

    • @fuckingchump8975
      @fuckingchump8975 6 років тому +474

      Crazy how he gave it a 9/10 then proceeded to call communists cucks while also throwing a few actual communists off a helicopter, I don't like communists either but everyone is allowed to have views that are different other than that good video 11/10 would watch again

    • @lukedbs44
      @lukedbs44 6 років тому +28

      Guck you 😭

    • @microcassettes
      @microcassettes 6 років тому +19

      oooooooh you got me

    • @AdamF072
      @AdamF072 5 років тому +6

      Almost got me

    • @halfaworldaway
      @halfaworldaway 5 років тому +70

      21:12 - 2112 by Rush

  • @drager980
    @drager980 7 років тому +1222

    I can't believe he dropped Rodeo from an 8 to a 6 because Kanye was featured on it.

    • @shazz9703
      @shazz9703 5 років тому +6

      Drager underratedcomment

    • @evanwladkowski5386
      @evanwladkowski5386 4 роки тому +25

      What’s ironic is the Kanye track is prob the worst song off rodeo

    • @nektarpanagiotis6707
      @nektarpanagiotis6707 3 роки тому +5

      I thought it was because he is a devoted supporter of the Ku Klux Klan campaign against decent African-American represantation. Oh well, maybe Anthony was the good guy on this video.

    • @nektarpanagiotis6707
      @nektarpanagiotis6707 2 роки тому +3

      @@LaloDoesArt (That's the point of these comments?)

    • @nektarpanagiotis6707
      @nektarpanagiotis6707 2 роки тому +1

      @@LaloDoesArt It's ok don't worry

  • @juliancalvo203
    @juliancalvo203 4 роки тому +1307

    1:16 2 Chainz - Based on a T.R.U Story
    2:56 Danny Brown - The Hybrid
    5:02 The Knife - Shaking the Habitual
    6:08 Tom Waits - Bad as Me
    9:10 Radiohead - King of Limbs
    11:05 Beastie Boys - The hot sauce committee
    12:24 Earl Sweatshirt - I don't like shit I don't go outside
    14:51 Mac DeMarco - 2
    16:27 Death Grips - Government Plates
    18:02 M.I.A - Maya

  • @IsaacP150
    @IsaacP150 7 років тому +1754

    whoa was not expecting Anthony to call pound syndrome the defining work of our time
    Fuck me was not expecting all these likes

    • @KjvYaBoii
      @KjvYaBoii 7 років тому +79

      IsaacP150 lmfaoooooooooo bro this is funny asf

  • @Griffbo
    @Griffbo 7 років тому +2656

    Makethony your mindtano

    • @Jimmy-es8bc
      @Jimmy-es8bc 6 років тому +82

      more like makeupthony yourmindtano. please check your privilege and get your meme format correct in future.

    • @Jimmy-es8bc
      @Jimmy-es8bc 6 років тому +8

      COLTON SHIELDS - Please don't assume their gender! We're outchea trying to smash the patriarchy and you're throwing pronouns around like you have the right to speak freely or some shit. Also, 11 months is plenty of time to have learnt from the error of their ways. Let's hope they've done so.

    • @papagrimbo4457
      @papagrimbo4457 6 років тому +1

      Your username is my nickname. I like this.

    • @starlinzyzy6038
      @starlinzyzy6038 6 років тому

      Jimmy What are you a feminist

  • @matthewmclaughlin4609
    @matthewmclaughlin4609 6 років тому +645

    Dude why did you change DAMN. from a 7 to a Revival/10

    • @ianearl9128
      @ianearl9128 5 років тому +36

      Because it was made by a black person, obviously.

    • @jumalakohtuotsus4174
      @jumalakohtuotsus4174 5 років тому +1

      @@ianearl9128 GOT EM

    • @spamsingles5948
      @spamsingles5948 4 роки тому +2

      He actually did change his mind now. Lol

    • @chilihotdog7257
      @chilihotdog7257 3 роки тому

      @@shittelevision2384 you should probably look up the definition of a "joke"

  • @vollsticks
    @vollsticks 6 років тому +410

    Damn that Danny Brown Hybrid record has some awful-ass sleeve art. It looks like those early 2000's turntablist albums covers

    • @lukesegovia6310
      @lukesegovia6310 5 років тому +31

      vollsticks 100% true, the cover look like some horrible 2000s kids show

    • @lateblume4208
      @lateblume4208 5 років тому +38

      It looked SO old even when it came out.

    • @loganjames7736
      @loganjames7736 4 роки тому +33

      Especially compared to atrocity exhibition. That album's cover art is just so perfect

    • @gcwens
      @gcwens 2 роки тому +4

      it looks like a bad flash game

    • @vollsticks
      @vollsticks 2 роки тому

      360 fuckin' likes?! This is one of my highest achievements in life... And I had no idea 'til I was just notified on a new comment by G. C Wens. Cheers, G. C!

  • @supa4ys843
    @supa4ys843 7 років тому +1335

    I only came for IDLSIDGO by Earl Sweatshirt.

    • @man4437
      @man4437 6 років тому +266

      IDLSIDGO is the worst acronym I've ever seen.

    • @poop_storm
      @poop_storm 6 років тому +297

      MAN technically the full thing would be IDLSIDGOAABES

    • @BlizzardOfBlackRain
      @BlizzardOfBlackRain 6 років тому +12

      The violence towards women on the album just makes it terrible for me now.

    • @gabeliveforever
      @gabeliveforever 6 років тому +106

      Im Dead Inside okay all of the violence is just blunt sexual euphemisms like the jackknife line being a sex position

    • @TheseBitchesWantNikes
      @TheseBitchesWantNikes 6 років тому +72

      OneArmedScissor How? He doesn’t talk about raping or even killing women anymore like he did on epaR on Earl.

  • @jorgep7747
    @jorgep7747 7 років тому +1554

    That Danny Brown album is dope but god the cover art is terrible

    • @c4shguy224
      @c4shguy224 5 років тому +319

      Jorge P it looks like 2006 in an image

    • @cashmereofficial6230
      @cashmereofficial6230 4 роки тому +12

      I agree

    • @BlueThe1up
      @BlueThe1up 4 роки тому +89

      @@GranolaSloth imagine defending the hybrid's cover art

    • @arlostein1000
      @arlostein1000 4 роки тому +135

      It's a great looking skating game for the ps2

    • @Lucas-dy5mt
      @Lucas-dy5mt 4 роки тому +44

      It really gives me the 2000's vibe, It's not bad but not so good.

  • @MontTheBeatMaker
    @MontTheBeatMaker 7 років тому +1460

    Danny probly cheesin with all 4 teeth right now

    • @CipherSerpico
      @CipherSerpico 5 років тому +15

      MONT. Holy shit this made laugh like a fukin hyena

    • @BubbaGump7854
      @BubbaGump7854 5 років тому +15

      MONT. not anymore. He got that dental plan

    • @ac8911
      @ac8911 4 роки тому +5

      @@BubbaGump7854 Danny needs braces!

  • @max-beckett
    @max-beckett 7 років тому +135

    I love how I can scroll through the comments now knowing that I'm not gonna see any spoilers for the actual video. Kinda sad too tho...

  • @geezuzmayne
    @geezuzmayne 7 років тому +298

    knew that earl album was fucking good

    • @rashotcake6945
      @rashotcake6945 7 років тому +15

      SLMAIN fav part of the video

    • @playboimarty
      @playboimarty 7 років тому +6

      SLMAIN tbh skipped to that re-review

    • @GulaszWLazience
      @GulaszWLazience 7 років тому +16

      That was actually my favourite album of the year. It's good to see that fantano understood more of earl's greatness

    • @undisclosedbeats2685
      @undisclosedbeats2685 7 років тому +1

      yeah about time. That album is so underrated in so many ways it's unbelievable.

  • @alara4006
    @alara4006 3 роки тому +93

    He admitted that MAYA influenced/predicted all of his favourite artists of today. We won.

    •  2 роки тому +10

      fr, i'm satisfied for today

  • @LOGASISful
    @LOGASISful 6 років тому +489

    “On second listening, i realize was too hard on Cory Feldman. Angelic 2 The Core is a defining genre masterpiece, and i recommend you check it out.”
    wow anthony, your opinions really do a change

    • @herbertwilliams4463
      @herbertwilliams4463 4 роки тому +4

      This comment made my night! Thank You Lol!!! 🤣😂🤣👌🏻

  • @nickmahoney179
    @nickmahoney179 7 років тому +969

    Oh shit he said TPAB is a 2 now time to change my opinion.

    • @slimmychoo2878
      @slimmychoo2878 7 років тому +25

      Nick Mahoney are you dumb? He said that it's a "Not Good" now

    • @nickmahoney179
      @nickmahoney179 7 років тому +65

      The Squeaky Roaster I believe he said it's "objectively inferior to any Corey Feldman album".

    • @jagvirj8515
      @jagvirj8515 7 років тому +5

      i thought that was true but than i looked at the liked-dislike ratio

    • @DeepestCoconuts
      @DeepestCoconuts 7 років тому +1

      just say the fuck9ing album u fucking bitch

  • @cumpy
    @cumpy 7 років тому +225

    Damn, Corey feldman is now a 10/10?

    • @Tw1ZTid360
      @Tw1ZTid360 7 років тому

      cumpy yeah, he doesn't know good music

  • @HejSofia
    @HejSofia 5 років тому +565

    M.I.A is seriously underrated and forgotten today. Unique and original artist who isn’t afraid of having ”unpopular” views.

    • @lilith2598
      @lilith2598 4 роки тому +5

      Fr

    • @lukemartin7891
      @lukemartin7891 4 роки тому +5

      100%

    • @talbino7821
      @talbino7821 2 роки тому +17

      Her first two albums are insanely brilliant. No musician out there who writes and sings from her perspective I can think of.

    • @thepants1450
      @thepants1450 Рік тому

      It's because she married a Bronfman, abandoned her values and became a born again Christian

    • @atlassolid5946
      @atlassolid5946 Рік тому +9

      ough

  • @sensitivewhiteboy
    @sensitivewhiteboy 7 років тому +62

    Saw TKOL in the title, got excited that Memethony had finally come to his senses.
    Fantano giveth, and Fantano taketh away.

  • @darkshippuu
    @darkshippuu 6 років тому +104

    Mia was so ahead of the curve. Blending abrasive production with lyrics about internet culture. Using middle eastern music as a base for her music. Creating music videos and artwork with an internet culture aesthetic to it. It might have not fully realized but it was still pretty bold for the time

  • @Jonny2by4
    @Jonny2by4 7 років тому +883

    Glad to see you came back around and gave DAMN a 10. Good on ya, Baldtano!

    • @CentinalxGaming
      @CentinalxGaming 7 років тому +43

      Salami Man same! I've been waiting on this for years.

    • @jbdbibbaerman8071
      @jbdbibbaerman8071 6 років тому +2

      Am I the only one who hates that album? Or is everyone just being ironic now?

    • @Rohishimoto
      @Rohishimoto 6 років тому +3

      JBDBIB Baerman Nobody hates it, that's just you. Most people admit it isn't as good as his other albums tho.

    • @professorchannel6359
      @professorchannel6359 6 років тому

      Sorry, but that album is easily Kendrick’s worst album. Even though I’ll admit, I was originally a lot more negative on the album than I am now, you have to be crazy to give it a 10. It has sooo many flaws, lyrically and on a beat scale

    • @Rohishimoto
      @Rohishimoto 6 років тому

      ProfessorChannel how is GKMC possibly worse than section 80. Bit saying section 80 was bad, but IMO it's his weakest project.

  • @chase_like_the_bank
    @chase_like_the_bank 6 років тому +490

    That's right melon man. Earl sweatshirt is dank.

  • @doorframelizard3633
    @doorframelizard3633 6 років тому +1788

    "Oh man he finally figured out The King of Limbs!"
    "..So yeah, I like it even less"
    There is no hope for this man

    • @lamestudiosinc418
      @lamestudiosinc418 5 років тому +22

      Doorframe Lizard #stan

    • @Th0tSlAyErIII
      @Th0tSlAyErIII 5 років тому +145

      It sucks. Radiohead is my favorite band and I can agree... That album is pretty trashy.

    • @fahntuh1399
      @fahntuh1399 5 років тому +93

      Live From The Basement is so much better, the studio version blows

    • @L251125
      @L251125 5 років тому +1

      Lmao

    • @ThatOneGuy7550
      @ThatOneGuy7550 5 років тому +8

      The only good song is Codex. The rest of it is trash.

  • @srturtle1668
    @srturtle1668 7 років тому +1144

    thanks for giving MBDTF a 10 like it deserves. Thanks melon!

  • @AlannaGabby
    @AlannaGabby 7 років тому +141

    MIA was so ahead of her time always. I still enjoy some of her stuff. The hardest part was getting Maya to be more palatable but if you really let it standalone it's not bad at all.

  • @eac-ox2ly
    @eac-ox2ly 7 років тому +2237

    Tran-
    -Sformers.

  • @tinita1919
    @tinita1919 7 років тому +96

    M.I.A.'s Maya is such a masterpiece

    • @captainmoondog1947
      @captainmoondog1947 3 роки тому

      eh idk, Teqkilla is really annoying to me, it could be waaaay shorter, but it's 6 minutes with only noise

    • @marcsoren7
      @marcsoren7 3 роки тому +10

      BORN FREE such a killer track

    • @jandcstopmotion7774
      @jandcstopmotion7774 Рік тому +5

      @@captainmoondog1947nah TEQKILLA is the greatest song ever made

  • @davidsant433
    @davidsant433 7 років тому +101

    Im kinda dissapointed Mr. List didn't host this video

  • @dustycomputer1806
    @dustycomputer1806 7 років тому +376

    >I don't like shit in thumbnail
    >I don't like shit vinyl on display
    I KNEEWWWWWW ITTTTTT

  • @dannydark0
    @dannydark0 7 років тому +198

    "Bones is the greatest rapper of our generation, and all of his mixtapes are 10s in my book"
    Wow, didn't expect that.

  • @mackenziethomas3206
    @mackenziethomas3206 5 років тому +115

    My beautiful dark twisted Anthony

  • @nomaddd123
    @nomaddd123 7 років тому +360

    internet's busiest mind-changer

  • @ericgordon9718
    @ericgordon9718 7 років тому +121

    1. 2 Chainz - Based on a T.R.U. Story
    2. Danny Brown - The Hybrid
    3. The Knife - Shaking the Habitual
    4. Tom Waits - Bad as Me
    5. Radiohead - The King of Limbs
    6. Beastie Boys - The Hot Sauce Committee Part Two
    7. Earl Sweatshirt - I Don't Like Shit, I Don't Go Outside
    8. Mac DeMarco - 2
    9. Death Grips - Government Plates
    10. M.I.A. - Maya

    • @tranebur5450
      @tranebur5450 7 років тому +1

      support my boy Antoan Fantoan and watch the video

  • @nado100
    @nado100 6 років тому +175

    Whoa there, didn't expect you to call pound syndrome the album of the century

    • @nielsbaumann6485
      @nielsbaumann6485 5 років тому +4

      He has a point though

    • @lukesegovia6310
      @lukesegovia6310 5 років тому

      niels baumann tru

    • @novanebula8004
      @novanebula8004 5 років тому

      I'm a big fan of Hopsin and even I'll admit Pound Syndrome didn't age well but I thought No Shame was much better

  • @JELL0521
    @JELL0521 7 років тому +203

    Thank God he changed his mind about earl. I was bumping that album the other day thinking "why is this melon so ignorant?"

    • @chefsweaty6744
      @chefsweaty6744 5 років тому +22

      I have no fucking clue what hes talking about when he said there's "so much violence against women" in the album. I've listened to the album at least 100 times and I dont think I ever noticed him talking about domestic violence or anything alarming. Earl hasn't rapped around edgy shit like that since his first albun

    • @mickestiler
      @mickestiler 5 років тому +13

      @@chefsweaty6744 maybe hes talking about metaphorical violence, especially rapping shit bout his mom and his ex. Also talks about women like bitches which really shows off his introverted, reclusive and trust-broken personality. Off top demonstrates this idea especially with his first few lines. I agree its not like his earl mixtape

    • @chefsweaty6744
      @chefsweaty6744 5 років тому +3

      Yung Dice I still dont agree man. I've seen earl wear makeup so hes obviously on the respecting women train. Earl may have dropped a few suggestive lines but I dont think there was actual intent or hatred behind them

    • @wilmabaird3816
      @wilmabaird3816 4 роки тому

      Coming from the guy who only listens to rap calling someone ignorant. Comedic

    • @GuysOfFilm
      @GuysOfFilm 4 роки тому +17

      @@chefsweaty6744 wearing makeup doesn't automatically mean you respect women...

  • @heysimone
    @heysimone 7 років тому +248

    I can't stop thinking about how mythony niggatano is sitting in a chair in all his vids

  • @twopoundfish
    @twopoundfish 7 років тому +517

    yo wheres Cashew Chestnut at i havent seen him in a while

  • @Mikey-xy2tv
    @Mikey-xy2tv 7 років тому +698

    Seeing no MBDTF makes me mad

    • @aphextwinpeaks13
      @aphextwinpeaks13 6 років тому +10

      Mikey4106 im triggered

    • @sukka4pain
      @sukka4pain 6 років тому +7

      Brendan Allie LR, CD, Graduation >>>> MBDTF.

    • @DZZZZZ
      @DZZZZZ 6 років тому +25

      The Brain MBDTF doesn't have Barry Bonds and Drunk And Hot Girls.
      LR = CD = MBDTF > rest of Kanye's discography

    • @thegooseinator9614
      @thegooseinator9614 6 років тому +6

      The Brain fuck outta here with that shit, Graduation is way worse than MBDTF and College Dropout is at best equal to it.

    • @RikardKarlssonYoutube
      @RikardKarlssonYoutube 6 років тому +3

      Maybe because it does sucks? Ever thought of that little dude?

  • @niqart
    @niqart 7 років тому +31

    M.I.A. Maya album was absolutely different from critically and commercially successful Kala. Very noise and experimental after several spins Maya surprisingly becomes her best.

  • @nyloluckycat
    @nyloluckycat 7 років тому +47

    why wasn't Floral Shoppe in this vid?

  • @kraftpunk2710
    @kraftpunk2710 7 років тому +48

    See, Corey Feldman is great. Glad you changed your mind Anton.

  • @buffdaddddddddy
    @buffdaddddddddy 6 років тому +40

    M.I.A BEEN AHEAD OF THE CURVE OFF. THE. BAT.

  • @tximinoman
    @tximinoman 7 років тому +20

    I had the same experience with MAYA. When I first listened to it I was weirded out by it. Specially because Arular and Kala are so "normal", you know. But after listening to Matangi (which I think many people hate but it's by far my favourite) I went back and ended up appreciating it a lot more.

    • @nicholasmicheloto3589
      @nicholasmicheloto3589 7 років тому

      Matangi is a fan favorite lol
      For me Arular > Matangi > Kala = MAYA > AIM

  • @bornon18
    @bornon18 7 років тому +282

    Totally different story fro me with The King Of Limbs. Though I initially felt the labum was sorta boring and flat, I ended up loving the hell out of every single song of it.

    • @Dynoboards2
      @Dynoboards2 7 років тому

      Simple Guy q

    • @GuadalupePicasso
      @GuadalupePicasso 7 років тому +14

      Simple Guy I'm the same. In Rainbows is still my favorite Radiohead album, which automatically made any follow-up a difficult feat to successfully pull off, largely because IR was so damn good, that no matter how good the follow-up would be, it would de facto pale in comparison.
      With that said, King Of Limbs was a bore to me at first. About half-a-year later, though, it grew on me. Massively. It still pales in comparison to In Rainbows, but it's a damn fine album, w nary a boring track on it, imo.
      I saw them live on both tours, both times near Cleveland, and I even liked the KotL setlist and show better than IR.

    • @NotCaleb602
      @NotCaleb602 6 років тому

      What's a labum?

    • @mcintosh1719
      @mcintosh1719 6 років тому +15

      Yeah, I didn't quite agree with his points against it either. I think he focused too much on things like "what genre the album was going for" or "what it meant to their career as a whole", which aren't a good measure of the quality in my opinion. I thought it had some interesting ideas. There were definitely some extremely cool rhythmic concepts on this album. It's the only time I've ever seen two drummers implemented in a non gimmicky way. They actually created beats that cannot be done with one person, and just did really cool stuff like mixing different subdivisions simultaneously. I wish he would have given SOME credit to that creativity. I think Fantano listens to music very differently than I do, and that's sort of why I like hearing his opinion, but I don't know, I just thought he focused on the wrong things with King of Limbs.

    • @samsonmcgloughlinakira1749
      @samsonmcgloughlinakira1749 6 років тому +5

      Live from the basement is soooooooooo fucking good, like if you don't even like the album there's a good chance you'll like it from the basement. It was overproduced and live it sounds fucking phenomenal.

  • @JasonDChenJDCIQ
    @JasonDChenJDCIQ 7 років тому +895

    speedin bullet 2 heaven is a 11/10

  • @vaishakhkallattil9468
    @vaishakhkallattil9468 7 років тому +112

    Anthony Fantano gives every album a 6/10 confirmed.

  • @lortomcon
    @lortomcon 7 років тому +123

    Do Tom Waits worst to best! no idea you were such a fan

    • @lukeslabaughsports
      @lukeslabaughsports 7 років тому +4

      lorcan conroy yesssssss

    • @mickeybreezy
      @mickeybreezy 6 років тому +4

      You didn't ask me, but Frank's Wild Years is my absolute favorite from him. Followed by Swordfishtrombones and then Small Change in third. After that, let's be honest, you don't care what I think. Have a great day!

    • @DaHatBat
      @DaHatBat 6 років тому +3

      franks wild years is so underrated

  • @TheLuxma
    @TheLuxma 7 років тому +195

    My opinion on your hairline remains unchanged tho

  • @readylikebettyspaghetti
    @readylikebettyspaghetti 7 років тому +44

    Not surprised about IDLS, it has been and will always be one of hip hop's most emotionally raw and unique albums.

  • @nicholaslittle5696
    @nicholaslittle5696 7 років тому +79

    top 10 twists in anime

  • @mrwaldoful
    @mrwaldoful 7 років тому +16

    im really glad u talked about how good the Earl album was. reallllly love that thing MELOn

  • @sweetg3377
    @sweetg3377 7 років тому +104

    Saw IDLSIDGO and had to click

    • @dr.mantistoboggan3265
      @dr.mantistoboggan3265 7 років тому

      Sameee

    • @notemo212
      @notemo212 7 років тому +1

      Sweet G lol what a goofy looking abbreviation

    • @littlebigphil
      @littlebigphil 6 років тому

      An initialism is an abbreviation, but an acronym isn't an initialism. Your original statement was correct (though not as specific as it could have been).

  • @jedski116
    @jedski116 7 років тому +34

    this could be a semi-regular series, surely your opinion changes for a lot of albums

  • @philthethrill5640
    @philthethrill5640 7 років тому +36

    Thanks for telling me about MIA - Maya. I never knew she made music like that and it fuckin' rules

    • @emilypollock7990
      @emilypollock7990 6 років тому +1

      Phil The Thrill one of my favoritea for sure

    • @slothstradamus89
      @slothstradamus89 6 років тому +2

      I still think Caps Lock is her best track. So chill, so GOOOOODDDDD

    • @mothra__13
      @mothra__13 5 років тому

      still my favorite album of hers

    • @hootemanny1165
      @hootemanny1165 5 років тому +3

      I still go back to Steppin' Up as a pump track. Why it was never released as a single is beyond me.

  • @DangerMenace
    @DangerMenace 6 років тому +3

    Thank you for giving credit to The Hybrid, Anthony!
    Very underrated album. XXX is easily my favourite hip-hop record of all time, and Hybrid was a very nice jumping off point so it's cool hearing praise!

  • @LJStudioslj
    @LJStudioslj 7 років тому +638

    I don't see all of childish gambino's discography on this list

    • @zobrantley6672
      @zobrantley6672 7 років тому +82

      KdSk Show Because it's still trash

    • @zobrantley6672
      @zobrantley6672 7 років тому +6

      Cashew #TheReturn #GambinoAGod I'm triggered? Nah son. Just stating facts. Gambino fans adore him too much...his catalog isn't that great

    • @nodude8312
      @nodude8312 7 років тому +3

      he is trash

    • @aidanbrondo530
      @aidanbrondo530 7 років тому +11

      no dude. No dude no that's false

    • @nodude8312
      @nodude8312 7 років тому +1

      +Aidan Brondo no dude

  • @somalipiratewhopiratedyour8513
    @somalipiratewhopiratedyour8513 7 років тому +341

    No MBDTF, you know what this means, right ? prepare all your pitchforks. we're going to overthrow this melon.

  • @nick-kd2yx
    @nick-kd2yx 7 років тому +305

    Is this the guy who gave mbdtf a 6?

    • @ChrisStoneinator
      @ChrisStoneinator 6 років тому +73

      How dare he like something less strongly than you? Guess you have to stop liking it now.

    • @CipherSerpico
      @CipherSerpico 5 років тому +11

      I still don’t understand the hype around Twisted Fantasy. I’m saying it’s overrated, I’m just saying I don’t get it.

    • @gregnuttall2268
      @gregnuttall2268 5 років тому +2

      JR 07 I disagree it’s my favourite album and it’s so amazing so still

    • @declansmyth1973
      @declansmyth1973 5 років тому +3

      @JR 07 you could say that about fucking anything

    • @ugonwigwe5136
      @ugonwigwe5136 4 роки тому +2

      @@CipherSerpico its so hyped because its really really really really good lol. give the album a listen and see what you think, it'll blow you away. people just aren't content with the 6/10 at all when it's arguably kanye's best produced, best featured album, and every single track on it is mesmerizing. i respect his opinion of course, and im not offended by his rating personally, but i understand why it was so controversial then and today

  • @SEGAClownboss
    @SEGAClownboss 7 років тому +26

    Glad to hear changes of heart for Mac DeMarco's 2 and Govt. Plates, they are rad

    • @katiieeardley
      @katiieeardley 4 роки тому +3

      I especially loved '2' when it came out and saw Mac live, and I only watched his review of it yesterday and I was like 'hm, well that feels very incorrect in my subjective opinion but oh well whatever'... then I look at my related videos and I see this video, with the title and the album cover in the background of the thumbnail and I was like 'HAHAHA'

  • @jonmarc11
    @jonmarc11 7 років тому +244

    *Sees no MBDTF*
    *Unsubscribes*
    Me: "But wait, the new Lorde..."
    *Reluctantly resubscribes :/*

  • @memcore1312
    @memcore1312 7 років тому +107

    government plates is now an 11

    • @mrpwnen
      @mrpwnen 7 років тому +10

      Derrick Nevarez GETS SO FUCKING DARK IN HERE

    • @asifanwar9921
      @asifanwar9921 7 років тому +4

      feels like a wheel

    • @sudevsen
      @sudevsen 7 років тому +9

      Derrick Nevarez 9/11

    • @Jbourbz
      @Jbourbz 7 років тому

      Its still one of my favourites if we are gonna talk real here..

    • @yung-stephen
      @yung-stephen 7 років тому

      ***** HARD SHIT, FUCK I SAID FUCKER DON'T START SHIT

  • @lucaschnaidler
    @lucaschnaidler 5 років тому +28

    The King of Limbs is one of my favorite and I'm sorry

  • @GodsNode
    @GodsNode 7 років тому +8

    Glad you came around to Maya. Ive loved it since 2010.

  • @allvinmx8302
    @allvinmx8302 7 років тому +151

    Where the hell is SB2H, Melon?!?!?!

    • @djdj696
      @djdj696 6 років тому +1

      Lol. That ain't gonna happen.

    • @FoxyChariot
      @FoxyChariot 6 років тому +3

      Kids See Ghosts is close enough

  • @joekelly1903
    @joekelly1903 7 років тому +47

    I see IDLSIDGO in the thumbnail u better like it melon boi

  • @zsto144
    @zsto144 6 років тому +1

    Stumbling upon theneedledrop opened my eyes to so much great music that I was missing out on. I greatly appreciate what you do man. You're the GOAT of music reviewers in my opinion

  • @oldboy65637
    @oldboy65637 7 років тому +1

    I appreciate this video a lot, and the intent behind it (as well as what you said about the 2 Chainz and Danny Brown records), even though I still like Hotsaucecomittee a lot, and i think King of Limbs is tied for my favorite (with AMSP, and lately, Kid A) of Radiohead, but more so, their "most flawless" record, and one of the weirdest dance albums ive ever heard. It's mood is so hard to characterize, because it's tense and a little empty, but cathartic and haunting. i love the rhythm-based direction theyve been going in this century, and this record helped me get through some rough mental health times with its strange, minimal inspiration to dance and ponder and be sad, until the 2nd part of Separator where the guitars come in ("i fell open/i laid under") and feels like a little bit of hope drips in to a dreary everyday life. idk, i like how economical the songs and production are, like the Robert Bresson idea of "getting rid of all but what's essential from the work." it's grown a lot on me over the years (weirdly, the opposite of OK Computer for me.)

  • @anuragarya6416
    @anuragarya6416 7 років тому +249

    Is the album format dying? Should we bring back the singles age again? Should we shorten the album in the age of digital streaming? Do a video on this.

    • @patrickharris1375
      @patrickharris1375 7 років тому +62

      Anurag Arya Absolutely not. The last hung we need is to shorten people's attention spans further.

    • @John-wb1ny
      @John-wb1ny 7 років тому +7

      Patrick Harris there has been so many albums that have a good core, but then lull along to completion. Plus with how media is today, albums aren't as iconic today as the artists singles are.

    • @gordoesgtheboycott
      @gordoesgtheboycott 7 років тому +9

      Anurag Arya album a dying format? lol have u looked up artist album sales these days? albums are doing just fine haha..also alot of quality albums are still coming out

    • @DEFxRECON
      @DEFxRECON 7 років тому +14

      Anurag Arya no fuck you

    • @joeperson6244
      @joeperson6244 7 років тому +14

      I'd say it's changing not dying. Albums are needing to become more of an experience as opposed to a collection of songs in order to be successful as a whole. So I think we'll see people that aren't inherently interesting in forming a whole project just release singles and we'll see people who are into making albums continue to add more detail and nuance to the album structure and release process

  • @loxeggcheese
    @loxeggcheese 7 років тому +3

    that earl album is one of my favorites, the production, the near singular flow and that it loops into itself conjure the cyclical nature of that mood so well. He also does so much subtle mixing in the low end that just blows my mind

  • @Bottles7
    @Bottles7 7 років тому +66

    I still think you're sleeping on Hiatus Kaiyote Fantano

    • @4lanimoyo553
      @4lanimoyo553 7 років тому +1

      IAmTheBaneFish tell em

    • @BibleStorm
      @BibleStorm 6 років тому +7

      That review was the worst opinion I've ever heard

  • @kyleranger3860
    @kyleranger3860 4 роки тому +2

    This turned me onto the Hybrid when it originally came out, **youtube recommendation**, and it’s one of my favorite albums. Thank you melon❤️

  • @alex132FIN
    @alex132FIN 7 років тому +47

    Whoa, you finally acknowledged that MBDTF is a 10/10? DAMN.

  • @Flip-a-dip-dip
    @Flip-a-dip-dip 7 років тому +246

    Can you please do modest mouse best -> worst?

    • @samcrumpit3081
      @samcrumpit3081 7 років тому +4

      He hates modest mouse :(

    • @Flip-a-dip-dip
      @Flip-a-dip-dip 7 років тому +1

      Evan Lekkas if thats what were doing
      Good
      Dead
      Long
      Moon
      Lonesome
      Building
      And strangers

    • @IFeelWeak
      @IFeelWeak 7 років тому +3

      1. Lonesome Crowded West
      2. Good News For People Who Love Bad News
      3. This is a Long Drive For Someone With Nothing To Think About
      4. Building Nothing Out Of Something (I don't consider it a comp album)
      5. The Moon and Antarctica
      nothing else exists. their EPs stand on a list by their own
      1. Everywhere and His Nasty Parlour Tricks
      2. No One's First, and You're Next
      3. Sad Sappy Sucker
      4. The Fruit That Ate Itself

    • @13dirty666
      @13dirty666 7 років тому +3

      1. LCW
      2. M&A
      3. WWDBTSES
      4. TIALDFSWNTA
      5. STO
      6. GNFPWLBN

    • @IFeelWeak
      @IFeelWeak 7 років тому +1

      i want whatever drugs you're on

  • @noodles2732
    @noodles2732 7 років тому +17

    I seem to have almost opposite music tastes to you and that's why I love watching your videos you push my boundaries and get me to listen to a shit ton of music out of my normal zone

    • @janedoe5615
      @janedoe5615 6 років тому +2

      Chicken Wings and Deadlifts yeah same i always check out albums he hates and usually love em

  • @lamontcoleman4304
    @lamontcoleman4304 6 років тому +2

    So glad to see IDLSIDGO on here. Was very surprised by your initial vid on it.

  • @clever-username
    @clever-username 7 років тому +8

    2:23 - 2:36 your take on 2 Chainz is exactly how I feel about Riff Raff. At least the old Riff, his lyrics aren't as whimsical anymore.

  • @muzza307
    @muzza307 7 років тому +31

    smh no LIL UZI VS THE WORLD???
    get a grip fandango

    • @thejustinoshow7908
      @thejustinoshow7908 7 років тому +3

      muzza307 or the Perfect LUV Tape. There's some bangers on there

  • @BegbieMusic
    @BegbieMusic 7 років тому +15

    i always liked m.i.a.'s third record and alsways wondered why everybody hated it so much. didn't see that death grips connection before, though. now that you've mentioned it, it is quite obvious :-D

  • @XoihaOsla
    @XoihaOsla 4 роки тому

    Stepping Up by M.I.A. I loveeee, thankful you rethought this album!! The intro reminds me of something from a TOBACCO album. I love The Knife also lol one of my favorite artists.

  • @casulrekr6340
    @casulrekr6340 7 років тому +4

    I've been echoing your sentiments on the MIA album for YEARS. THANK YOU FOR SPREADING THE WORD ANTHONY

  • @TheIronMan01LBP
    @TheIronMan01LBP 7 років тому +100

    14:09 DAMN

  • @elcucuy7825
    @elcucuy7825 7 років тому +1

    I dig tony turned around on earl. Took me sometime to appreciate him too. Excited to hear more of his work.

  • @EyeTunz
    @EyeTunz 4 роки тому +9

    Separator from King of Limbs is my favorite Radiohead song.

  • @RegularRyy
    @RegularRyy 7 років тому +38

    you need to revisit Cilvia Demo

  • @BarnacleButtock
    @BarnacleButtock 7 років тому +99

    hey guys, *deathony gripstano here*

  • @MrDrPepper4ever
    @MrDrPepper4ever 6 років тому +149

    TOOL: Worst To Best
    It would be awesome

    • @fleshmotorcycle9427
      @fleshmotorcycle9427 5 років тому +16

      They haven’t made enough albums yet XD

    • @L251125
      @L251125 5 років тому +4

      @@fleshmotorcycle9427
      And they never will lmao

    • @rybanberr2770
      @rybanberr2770 5 років тому +12

      Maybe once he’s Oldthany Mantano they’ll have 2 or 3 more albums out and he can do it

    • @djed7235
      @djed7235 5 років тому

      @@fleshmotorcycle9427 eh they have 5 if u count opiate so i could see it :)

    • @reecerice3033
      @reecerice3033 5 років тому

      It would be cool

  • @jasonlitherland4270
    @jasonlitherland4270 7 років тому

    Thanks for the turn towards earl sweatshirt. Hadn't heard that one yet.

  • @bigrichard698
    @bigrichard698 7 років тому +19

    Surprised he gave Beautiful Thugger Girls a 12

  • @zacharypaulus3135
    @zacharypaulus3135 7 років тому +17

    Did anthony see that video by the Washington Post about that negative Sgt Peppers review?

  • @vincentstephen3716
    @vincentstephen3716 7 років тому +1

    Anthony, I'm really glad you said what you said about the MIA record. I thought it was fucking amazing when it came out and still love it, for most of the reasons you mention. If you've never seen the footage of her doing Born Free on Letterman you should check it out

  • @BigStinky69
    @BigStinky69 7 років тому

    Proud of you coming to your senses on mac demarco's music. You should revisit salad days too