I'm gonna trigger the Snyder bros but his version of Superman was flat out boring. There was nothing to his character at all. Watching paint dry is more interesting than Snyder's Superman. Tyler Hoechlin is hands down the best modern Superman. It's crazy that the CW gave us a better Superman than the DCEU. But my all time favorite Superman is the DCAU version. Christopher Reeve's Superman is also fantastic. He's definitely the best movie version.
unfortunately a lot of ppl find it appealing but I just can't rock with a version of Superman that doesn't feel like Superman at all 😂 I need him to be hopeful or at least happy LMAO
All the Superman Projects I own Ranked 1. Superman: The Movie 2. Superman ll 3. Superman: The Animated Series 4. Smallville 5. Justice League: Apopculise War 6. Man of Steel 7. Injustice 8. Batman Vs. Superman 9. Superman Returns
Thanks. Superman Returns was a continuation of the the Reeve movies but with a different actor, something a lot of people didn't like including myself. However, I did like Routh as Superman. I just wished was had seen more of him when he played the kingdom come Superman. But we didn't and that's why he ranks lower for me.
I had a whole section about young justice superman that I didn't put in the video 🫠 honestly the whole storyline with superboy was interesting but the fact superman basically ghosted him was kinda weird to me, understandable, but weird. seemed kinda out of character for superman to barely be able to look him in the eye. they change it up later but still. Also Ive been slacking on the absolute comics but I gotta read them soon especially absolutele batman. Feel free to join my discord if you wanna talk about it once I catch up 👍🏼😁
In my opinion Brandon Routh's Superman Returns suit was not very good, like at all. Horrible color choices, its the most saturated bright bubblegum blue paired with period stain brownish/maroon red, like wtf, like if Christopher Reeve's suit tasted sweet, this one is bitter. The colors in that movie in general was just not it, the whole movie just gave off the words "dull" and "lifeless". His Kingdom Come version is beautiful tho i gotta admit
Honestly you're 100% right I just personally watched JLU a lot more both growing up an even sometimes now I'll give it a rewatch, compared to STAS which I only really watched once or twice, that's the only reason I put it higher 😬👍🏼
You missed several versions of Superman, including the first *actual* live-action version played by Kirk Alyn in two serials in the 1940s, a number of cartoons that also came out in the 1940s, a TV Series from the 1960s, another TV series from the 1980s, and the various Super Friends versions in the 1970s and early 1980s. I assume Smallville and early 1990s Superboy didn't even count, but unless I missed it (hard to tell as you sometimes make it unclear which Superman you are discussing or even where he appeared), you also missed Lois and Clark from the mid 1990s. You also missed Young Justice Superman.
Young justice Smallville and Lois an Clark are all there, I'm just now realizing I must've saved Kirk alyn an superboy as the wrong image file cause I had it saved but it wasn't uploaded to the tier list 😔
@@Praia. I must have missed seeing them then. Sorry, it was sometimes hard to tell what exact version you jumped to next at times. I even missed your Superman the animated series mention initially and had originally included that but caught that one in time. Some did go by a bit quickly for an old duffer like me to keep up with. :)
I feel that you are a bit inconsistent. But I agree with perhaps 60% of your tier choice. We have the same opinion about Brandon Routh's Superman which I also consider to be better than Henry Cavill's Superman in character design, character personality, suit, and story. Too bad they decides to reboot it. But I strongly disagree about Tyler Hoechlin's superman to be equal to Brandon Routh's and Christopher Reeves'. As Superman, Tyler doesn't look as tall and commanding appearance as the other two. As Clark Kent, he doesn't look as awkward and geeky as the other two.
I agree that he doesn't look as commanding as superman BUT as Clark Kent I think he really embodies him well, not so much in general look but in his actions. but yea Brandon routh was MILES better than Cavill in a lot of ways 😂 appreciate the input though bro!
I'm gonna trigger the Snyder bros but his version of Superman was flat out boring. There was nothing to his character at all. Watching paint dry is more interesting than Snyder's Superman. Tyler Hoechlin is hands down the best modern Superman. It's crazy that the CW gave us a better Superman than the DCEU. But my all time favorite Superman is the DCAU version. Christopher Reeve's Superman is also fantastic. He's definitely the best movie version.
you not wrong!!
@@Praia. I genuinely don't understand the hype of the Snyderverse. It's nothing but edgelord reddit fanfiction.
unfortunately a lot of ppl find it appealing but I just can't rock with a version of Superman that doesn't feel like Superman at all 😂 I need him to be hopeful or at least happy LMAO
@@Praia. It's mostly edgelords that have this idiotic belief that Homelander is what Superman should be.
😭😭
Easily my favorite video you have created locked in with this edits ! 💪🏻
Preciate you 👍🏼 it's only gonna get better from here 🔥
All the Superman Projects I own Ranked
1. Superman: The Movie
2. Superman ll
3. Superman: The Animated Series
4. Smallville
5. Justice League: Apopculise War
6. Man of Steel
7. Injustice
8. Batman Vs. Superman
9. Superman Returns
Decent list tbh, why superman returns so low? also I love Smallville
Thanks. Superman Returns was a continuation of the the Reeve movies but with a different actor, something a lot of people didn't like including myself. However, I did like Routh as Superman. I just wished was had seen more of him when he played the kingdom come Superman. But we didn't and that's why he ranks lower for me.
that makes sense, an yea seeing him appear as kingdom come superman was awesome wish we got more!
Thoughts on Young Justice Superman, and absolute Superman?
I had a whole section about young justice superman that I didn't put in the video 🫠 honestly the whole storyline with superboy was interesting but the fact superman basically ghosted him was kinda weird to me, understandable, but weird. seemed kinda out of character for superman to barely be able to look him in the eye. they change it up later but still. Also Ive been slacking on the absolute comics but I gotta read them soon especially absolutele batman. Feel free to join my discord if you wanna talk about it once I catch up 👍🏼😁
My live action Superman Ranking
1. Christopher Reeve
2. Tyler Hoechlin
3. Tom Welling
4. Henry Cavill
5. Brandon Routh
6. Dean Cain
this is pretty solid, i think almost everyone agrees dean cain is dead last 😭
Dean Cain was the weakest Superman and Henry Cavill was the weakest Clark Kent.
Definitely agree
I let out the loudest "YUPPP" at that Cavill ranking
Tyler Hoechlin is the best Superman.
He's very good, I'm rewatching his show rn so I can watch the new season 4 with everything fresh in my mind
PLAYERS GET CHOSE
DIAMONDS OVER GOLD
In my opinion Brandon Routh's Superman Returns suit was not very good, like at all. Horrible color choices, its the most saturated bright bubblegum blue paired with period stain brownish/maroon red, like wtf, like if Christopher Reeve's suit tasted sweet, this one is bitter. The colors in that movie in general was just not it, the whole movie just gave off the words "dull" and "lifeless".
His Kingdom Come version is beautiful tho i gotta admit
Bro his cameo in the cw shows as kingdom come superman was SO fresh to see
Wait how is JLU S-TIER and S:TAS version is only A? Big disagree. It should be S, too.
Honestly you're 100% right I just personally watched JLU a lot more both growing up an even sometimes now I'll give it a rewatch, compared to STAS which I only really watched once or twice, that's the only reason I put it higher 😬👍🏼
Word
@@Praia.They are supposed to be the same Superman, kinda like at Batman from BTAS is the same as JL and JLU Batman
Yea I know I just put it slightly higher since I watched JLU a lot as a kid an even now I watch it so personally I rank it slightly higher
You missed several versions of Superman, including the first *actual* live-action version played by Kirk Alyn in two serials in the 1940s, a number of cartoons that also came out in the 1940s, a TV Series from the 1960s, another TV series from the 1980s, and the various Super Friends versions in the 1970s and early 1980s. I assume Smallville and early 1990s Superboy didn't even count, but unless I missed it (hard to tell as you sometimes make it unclear which Superman you are discussing or even where he appeared), you also missed Lois and Clark from the mid 1990s. You also missed Young Justice Superman.
Young justice Smallville and Lois an Clark are all there, I'm just now realizing I must've saved Kirk alyn an superboy as the wrong image file cause I had it saved but it wasn't uploaded to the tier list 😔
@@Praia. I must have missed seeing them then. Sorry, it was sometimes hard to tell what exact version you jumped to next at times. I even missed your Superman the animated series mention initially and had originally included that but caught that one in time. Some did go by a bit quickly for an old duffer like me to keep up with. :)
@jasontoddman7265 I appreciate the feedback though fr, as I make more content I'll try to keep everything a little bit easier to follow
Thank the heavens you put emo superman in his place 😅
😂
I feel that you are a bit inconsistent.
But I agree with perhaps 60% of your tier choice.
We have the same opinion about Brandon Routh's Superman which I also consider to be better than Henry Cavill's Superman in character design, character personality, suit, and story. Too bad they decides to reboot it.
But I strongly disagree about Tyler Hoechlin's superman to be equal to Brandon Routh's and Christopher Reeves'. As Superman, Tyler doesn't look as tall and commanding appearance as the other two. As Clark Kent, he doesn't look as awkward and geeky as the other two.
I agree that he doesn't look as commanding as superman BUT as Clark Kent I think he really embodies him well, not so much in general look but in his actions. but yea Brandon routh was MILES better than Cavill in a lot of ways 😂 appreciate the input though bro!
Stas and jlu superman are the same person 😭
You right, I just personally have spent more time watching jlu than stas so I put it higher
@@Praia. They are voiced by different people though, so maybe that qualifies as making them different enough even if you didn't know that.