P Chidambaram's Speech in Parliament on Budget 2025, Suggestions to The Finance Minister
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 лют 2025
- Former Finance Minister P. Chidambaram, speaking in the Rajya Sabha, called the Union Budget “politically driven” while refraining from elaborating further. In his critique, he questioned the government’s economic vision and policies. However, Rajya Sabha Speaker Jagdeep Dhankhar interrupted, pointing out that Chidambaram did not congratulate Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on presenting the Budget. Watch Chidambaram’s full speech. #PChidambaram #UnionBudget #RajyaSabha
Join The Wire's UA-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
All these questions makes so simple and sense to common man. Excellent
@@rohitswamy4402 Mr. Chidambaram is regarded as a Brahmn Gyani among the Parliamentarians. His speech was on expected lines.
Brahma Gyan - Knower of things that don't change with time. (First mentioned in Ganga Upanishad). Change is constant - this is NOT applicable to everything. Mr. Chidambaram understands Brahma ('Absolute' in English)
It’s a pity many crores of Indians don’t get to listen to this brilliant speech
Excellent, elightening and most authentic speech on Budget from an illustrious former FM Chidambram Sir. My huge congratulations, Sir.
Excellent , enlightening and authentic --- then it can definitely not be a chidabaram 😅😅😅 as he served india a place in fragile five economies
What was he doing when he was FM.
An eminent lawyer and an economist.
What an analysis!! So powerful
Government must declare “BharatRatna” to Hon Late Dr Manmohansingji immediately..!, 🌺
For what , being the most disgraceful person to sit on PM chair ?? 😂😂
@@subhashthakur862 I support this. We live in an economy created by him.
Union Budge 2025, presented by our dear FM is truly a masterclass in optimistic arithmetic and creative accounting. With grandiose promises of growth and "ease of living," it somehow managed to sidestep the elephant in the room: rising unemployment and inflation. The cherry on top? A tax structure so convoluted that even seasoned economists needed a flowchart. Bravo for turning fiscal policy into a magic show - perhaps the great PC Sorcar would have known a thing or two to pull the proverbial, national debt, rabbits out of hat !
One is both into the sutra of soothsaying, weaving the threads of fate with uncanny insight, while the other is a well-aged chrematist, crafting fortunes with the precision of a seasoned trader and the vision of a financial sage.
Excellent 👌🏻
Very well explained 👏👏
Learn something from the veteran! 👍
He was a fugitive for 2 days , the first cabinet minister to go absconding, what can you learn more from him 😂😂
Yes, we wouldn't even have digital transactions today if he was there. I criticize Nirmala too, but Chidambaram was useless
@@BoforskaChorKaunThaso was your Mongiji. He was banned from entering US until he was chosen as PM 😂
@@akashbudapest-lw1nu during his tenure gdp growth touched double digits. compare the modi period to manmohan period
The Finance Minister's roasting is not only spectacular but also eye-opening, shedding light on some harsh realities.She is the least bothered, arrogant FM to poor people's facing problems.
Excellent speech by P C, has hit the bullet right on the spot. Knowledgeable person.👍🏼
There is nothing more important than power in their priority list. It is clear from the budget.
P Chidambaram has raised important points concerning common men i.e. reduction in GST rate, tax cut on diesel and petrol, increase in minimum wages and MGNREGA.
Current finance minster will reach out to her husband to explain what ex finance minster taught her 😂😂😂
Absolute stunning speech on Budget 2025 ❤❤❤
Our FM should attend his classes after office hrs daily
Great rebuttal ❤
Great speech by Chidambaram, wish people like him or Shashi Tharoor led opposition party 👍
Wah kya speech hai .....whataa speech man
NOBODY in the current ruling dispensation can speak with such clarity and command on the economics of India; not even in Hindi!!!😅
It’s a shame
Nailed it❤
No better person to be a Finance Minister for India than P Chidambaram. Excellent Speech..
Only CONGRESS PARTY HAVE MOST EDUCATED LEADERS
Those were the days, Manmohan, Chidambaram and Arun Jaitley was also better, current one is incompetent and arrogant.
FM Sitaraman is in a tough position. How to answer questions on mistakes she was forced to do, by the hon'ble PM!
@@AnirudhSingh-q717j she definetly knows what she is doing but cant overrule her supreme leader note
@te20ja04 She has lost control of the ship (Titanic). It's gone. Direction is wrong and, presumably, can NOT be reversed.
Sitaraman' tenure marks india being 4th biggest economy , she does not needs learning from failed FM like Chidambaram who's only achievement was to make india a member of fragile five economies
lol I read horrible PM.
We know her answer: humko ka malum ji, hum tto naukri nai karta ji, hum tto kucch nai kareedta ji humko sabb freeeee hai ji
Very true interpretation
Very well explained our ex FM. Be Blessed Stay Blessed always ❤❤❤
Already Dr Manmohan singh is achievers of life his wisdom,,his served the nation....he was well renouned not only in india but internationally.Late.Dr Manmohan singh will not identify by bharat ratna but becauseof his work...great statesman great human being.
Those were the days ....when we had such a brilliance in the parliament itself.
Sir said very well...
Do you think since 2014 the budget is for welfare of the people?? It's just for vote bank laste year for Bihar and Andhra, now for middle class for Delhi election, next for UP and Bihar vote bank 😂😂
P Chidambaram was the best Finance minister in Indian History who gave highest returns in Indian stock market.
Excellent
This shows the intellectual and logical superiority of Sh PC
Super sir.,
Nimo thai needs aloevera, she just got burnt
Chidambaram, you should understand that this govt neither understand economics nor understand your English 😂.
The chair of RS is such a joker!! shameless person...
Correctly said. Only two faces were not lookable. One is upper house chairman & other is IFM.
Why is this Jagdeep behaving like a last bench student eager to hear the day's end bell and get out of the class? 🤔
Well researched
Speech
# Share karo aur poora video viral kardo jise Desh ki janta jagaruk ho sake 🙏🙏🙏🙏
# Mission Jago Bharat
Great speech by p chidambaram
The man to be acknowledged for his well-prepared speech revealed how they engaged in window dressing to give the impression that they had controlled the fiscal deficit. To manage the deficit, they made significant cuts to capital expenditures, it is very shocking that even slashing scholarships for SC and ST students.
A master class on how to analyse the budget . Even how to make the budget
He is a master absconder , Good only in corruption plans which ofcourse pappu and his corrupt brigade likes and understands 😂😂
Schooling is going on, by the Principal !! Budget one on one!!
First time the Chair hear entire Speach without any Bias.
Shri P Chidambram is one of the best FM of India, he is the authority in Finance.
Sir dont give them ideas. They dont have brains to implement what u say. But they will borrow ur thoughts and implement it during election time!
Very nice sir
Our FM should consider all these points.
Awesome data presented by P chidambaram sir
Well explained for the common people.
Brilliant. Very well explained. This government should do away with GST.
Then it will be enormous ly a deficit budget which even.
PC would not have attempted if he was theFm
Sir
Providing water
Provided houses
Provided toilets
Who's going to check the government's figures
His speeches are worth every other engagement
Income tax paid by richest 5% of salaried class was given a cut.
A gst cut would have been an honest move to boost consumption.
He is so much smarter than Nirmala. It's so obvious
She is very successful by giving a budget which helped the BJP to capture Delhi. Voters of delhi fooled very nicely. Nobody understood what this up to 12 tax exemption benefitting 3.5crore people. This is what she had been doing after the departure of Jaitley. Experienced oxford educated economist Chidu ba ram very nicely explained in depth her failures. No body from treasury benches could oppose his narrative that initself speak lot about the inefficiency & utter failure of FM
Dekh lene ko aap jita v hota to bjp wale LG milke kam krne nahi deta, ab dekh tee 5 saal kya krte hai bjp
There are crores of people in India working nothing but for the victory of the ruling party. What do they eat? Sand or stone or soil? Money doesn't grow on trees, they say. So you know what I mean.
Chairman seems to be under great strain.
Taxes are being paid right from the birth till death. When we pay income tax then why other taxes and GST. The elected leaders are befooling general public especially poor, middle and lower middle class. Nobody ask them to pay taxes themselves. They do not pay income tax, lot of free facilities are being enjoyed by them including number times pension that too at the cost of tax payers. What type of sewa they are rendering except divide and rule. The real defenders of India get salaries ( price of their blood) after deduction of income tax . The defence forces also have to pay numerous taxes and GST. They get only one pension that too after certain years of service ( Agniveers are not included. They are not entitled to pension). Why this disparity among people of the same country.
This government has no real plan for any real development for the country and it's people.
Proper speech to a flop finance minister.
The price of petrol price & LPG prices will come down just before the announcement of Bihar elections as Diwali gift from the PM for the nation. Take screenshot of this comment! U can thank me later!
Okay. Any prediction on how much it will come down?
Great economist leader at this worst times of India. 👍🏼
1.83 lakh crore cut on "capital" expenditure. 1 lakh crore tax cuts given as relief. What sense do 'you all' make of this?
Genius
Chidambaram a genius Nirmala Seetharaman no answers to his questions people cheated with daying middle class budget it is for Delhi elections
GST cut is not soley in hand of FM but it can only be decided in GST council where states are also one of stakeholders
😮Greek and Latin; the Economics is for FM😳. Commerce is Barbarian for her according to Subramanian Swamy of RSS…. Probably she forgotten to blink while you spoke these stats!!!😂😂😂😂
may be if external minister son comes like this he might protest..
Nothing of this is reaching Andhbhakts
😅their agenda is different
Mr. Dhankar, Dare to interrupt NON BIOLOGICAL PERSON once.
Trust me Urga Maami wouldn't have understood a word.
Dhankar ji seemsto be lost on the subject.
dhankar ke sar ki upar se guzar rha h sab ...
She is shocked definitely and will study more ,gets more degree I Economics at Yale University again😅😂
If there is no answer to many allegations of opposition make fun of them,talk about dead persons and manage the show.
Dhankar ji seemsto enjoying the cut in SC/ST cut.
Such detailed analysis will not go into the head.So shout against qoute past instances and manage the show.
USDINR had a breakout today, 87 level is broken. Rupee's fall is currently underway. || Will 90 level be broken?
Indeed, falsehood is bound to vanish. (Quran 17:81)
I ❤ Support💪 BJP Bt P Chidambaram Was 1 Of D Finest FM Of 🇮🇳 Brought More Than ₹90k Cr Black ⚫ ₹ Back in D 90's.. So Nirmala Sitaraman Should Think About D Suggestions 🎉
Ye pyaz lahusan nhi khata g
People who commit crimes, gone illegally, no questions asked to them, those touts involved in this crime against nationals nothing against them.
FM should have told US to proceed against those as per their laws and get them back after having finished punishments.
How were the deprtations done in 2009 to 2014.?
Isko bolte hai khol khol ke …😅
Double engine is becoming engine less only depends on religious sentiments.
One engine is opposite to the other.
Maybe she was asked to focus!
Meri marzi
My fear
May be amit shah put him jail once again😢
Fm ko rula diya ham to 2019 se bol rahey hey ki kuch kam nahi huva hey
.
sadly
.
...no one understands him
Prime minister employment program is PM giving employment to those who do photo shoots & his pr person it wing etc
Every thing Mr.Modi does is for elections and 24 by 7 he is messaging his bhakts. The country is suffering.
Iyengar versus chettiar
Fragile 5 guru giving gyan on Economics 😄
Mr chidambaram showing fm the mirror,
How a educated person interpret data
And how a propagandist performs magic
Why we went into the mess before that to come out and working on instructions of IMF and WB and speak their language.
Look @ #RangaBilla MoShah MoDani MoBani pilla in high chair!
THERE IS NO MARGIN MONEY IS BEING RELEASED FOR PMEGP BENEFICIARY WHO HAVE TAKEN LOANS MORE THAN TWO YEARS AGO
Bss information nikal lo k kitne log 12 lac se ooper kmate hain, Budget ki saari story clear ho jayegi