Nabilah Yusof I think the best kpop era was around 2006 to 2013 idk wai al of the songs in that era were😍😍, but this era is not bad at all, there are a lot of amazing songs like "Tell me what to do" from Shinee or "Ill be your man" from BTob :D (if my english is bad is bcs im from Spain)
와...음색봐봐.....진짜 b1a4는 진짜 새벽감성 터뜨리는 노래임..해뜨기전에 약간 어둑어둑 할 때 들으면 내가 7~8살 때 감성이 다시 살아남.. 그 때는 sky폰 쓸 때였는데 오빠가 깔아준 노래가 b1a4노래 밖에 없어서 새벽에 혼자 깼을 때 하늘 보면서 틀었는데 그 때 그 느낌 분위기가 너무 좋았음....
2024 Anyone? Idkw I'm nostalgic for old songs and I'm having a marathon of B1A4 songs. Im really likes their song until nowww btw this song is my lullaby ^^
You see, at that time, viewers on UA-cam wasn't really unnecessary. But now, viewers are everything. And if the idols get a low viewers, they'd get mocked. I miss the second generation of K-pop T.T
Well, nowadays they indeed are. Wen they debuted, they were a real thing. they had a huge fan-club, way bigger than over a year groups, even before their debut. But they are flower boys. Now with all the hip hop hype on, and B1A4 didn't fell for it (thank God, cause this isn't them), they flopped. This really makes me sad, B1A4 is, and will always be my favorite group, and I feel sorry for the Korean fanbase
There is only cnu, sandeul and gongchan left. Baro and JinYoung left the group (probs because of personal reason which is I’m not sure of.), but B1A4 was once my fave and will always have a special place in my heart and memory.
OT5 forever 🎉 Jinyoung, Baro and Sandeul , 3 of them deny they have leaves the group. Besides, WM never announced BANA 2 members have quieted the group
i was in 7th grade when i listened to b1a4 almost all the time and now i'm a college freshman. i came back because i was curious how are they doing now, it hurts because 2 members left. i forgot all the song titles but remember immediately when i listen to the songs, they are all very familiar. now i miss them so much and also my younger self atm it was the happiest time of my life
lol.. me too, i still remember that moment when this MV just release.. I was in the middle of lesson and I secretly download this MV.. so nostalgic 😂😂😂😂
Baro's rap is soooo awesome!!~~ Sandeul's voice is sooo daebak!! Gongchan's visual is no joke!! Shinwoo's hairstyle is soo hot!! and Jinyoung my prince!! everything about this boys is my oxygen!! I need a comeback!! #B1A4ComebackBingo #BanaInternationalUnited
What about A Lie? I think that song is truly a masterpiece. If I had to choose just one favorite kpop song out of ALL the kpop artists, A Lie is probably the song I will choose (despite B1A4 not being my favorite band).
나 혼자 이렇게 널 두고 오는 길 잊을게 지울게 까맣게 타버린 내 사랑 그런 표정 짓지 마 너와의 마지막 대화 실망은 하지 마 그래 나 같은 놈 이젠 만나지 마 나 먼저 가볼게 점점 멀어져 가네요 점점 사라져 가네요 쉽게 잊지는 말아요 내가 너무 아프니까 니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다) 니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다) 나 혼자 이렇게 널 두고 오는 길 잊을게 지울게 까맣게 타버린 내 사랑 사랑이 떠나나 봐 이 바람 타고 저 멀리 날아가나 봐 모든 게 변하나 봐 너도 나처럼 이렇게 또 변하나 봐 그래도 나 아파도 후련하다 이 기분 조차도 난 지금 버겁다 불안한 듯 바라보는 떼를 쓰는 아이 같이 그대 눈물이 돌아서는 내 어깨를 잡는다 이별은 달지만 난 괜찮아 아프지만 그대 그림자 안에서 발을 빼 우리 반지도 빼 점점 멀어져 가네요 점점 사라져 가네요 미워하지는 말아요 내가 너무 아프니까 Baby 니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다) 니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다) 아 프 다 너무나 그립다 간다 간다 떠나간다 너는 아직 모르겠지 알지 못하겠지 힘겨워하는 너를 보면서 내가 더 아파서 이렇게 널 보낸다 눈물이(눈물이) 흐른다(흐른다) 너와 나(너와 나) 너무 사랑했으니까 니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다) 니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다) 니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다) 니가 떠난 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다
So basically the B1A4 Concert was incredible and I got to meet them all and now when I watch they're mvs I want to scream and squeal so hard because they were all so sweet and wonderful ^-^ I bought balcony seats but it closed and they moved us right behind the pit and we got high touch, it was the best weekend ever!
animearigatoo Before the concert started Baro was my bias, then once the concert started I started to notice Jinyoung and Gongchan more, but then Baro kept rapping all sexily and what not but I was still conflicted. After meeting all of them it's a tie between Baro and Gongchan!
Allan Captor Ok. I havent seen that yet. But i know it will be sad... I will watch it.. I just need time to get ready to see things i know will be sad... And i have WAY to many dramas on my "want to watch" list :P
I'm missing this song so much. I'm such a big fan of b1a4's old songs. Came here because watching all their medley in Ding Music. K-pop no longer produced this kind of music & song anymore 😭😭
baro - that face, that voice simply does not add up. how on earth does someone so cute have such a sexy, deep, thick voice? he reminds me so much of vixx's ravi. they both have such unique vocals that simply don't match their faces and it's hot
Jinyoung penned this song way too early in his career.. it's so underappreciated :/ I wish this song was out this year after all the exposure he got in Produce 101 and Moonlight drama, also Sanduel with his singing programs and CNU in Mask Singer. They could've topped the charts with this one :/ Hopefully their new songs for the comeback are even better than this one
So true its sad. I love this song so much and Jinyoung is too amazing. He composed a song as perfect as this so early that the fandom wasn't even ready. Hopefully they can become big again with the next comeback and stay big :)
Ikr im still new to the group but around last year I unconsciously listened to B1A4's songs and liked it and when i checked all those songs date release it was like 2014 and this 2012.. I wish I discovered this group sooner ;(
100% agree!! Tbh, Oh My Girl's Closer reminds me of B1A4's Tried to Walk; aside from some similarities in the concept/MV/song, both were amazing title tracks but are still so underappreciated. Probably due to the fact that both songs were promoted very early in their careers :-(
Jinyoung made this song even before turning into 21, that’s pity now kpop fans sleep on this kind of quality music and group! They are still popular with their solid resumes into individual fields, true talents will turn them into legends in later days ! 👊🏻👊🏻🎉🎉
Ikr! Baro and gochan are my biases but jinyoung is so good and unique!! i love the whole group 😍😘 ONE of the best singers yes, the BEST singer is a no XD
2016 and this is still one of my favourite kpop songs it is just so beautiful.This is also the song that tied me to b1a4 #bana forever.pls comeback soon we miss all of u
I’ve not heard this song in yeaaaars and literally just saw it while going on a nostalgia journey and i’m surprised i still remember everything, the lyrics the music. Used to love this song so much and hearing it now i love it again!
내가 이노래를 애정하고 아직도 찾는 이유 중에 하나가 중학교 때 도서관에서 공부하고 밤 10-11시 넘는 시간에 혼자 눈 내리는 거 보면서 집으로 가고 있었는데, 조용히 아무도 없는 곳에서 이 노래를 들을 때 나도 모르게 심취해서 집에 바로 들어가고 계속 아파트 단지 안에서 눈 밟으며 걸어 다녔던 기억 때문에 주기적으로 듣게 됨 그때 그 느낌 그 감정들을 추억하기 위해서
I used tp sing this song out loud walking to my school, I was 14-15. I'm almost 22, still love them. This brings back memories, specially now it's turning cold and I fell in love with this song during the winter
If you listen to this song in 2020, we are instantly friends.
all of b1a4 tbh,i dont stan but they have bops and are undderated
Hey friend
Throwback to sophomore year ✋😂
@@zi9586 i heard they're popular domestically
Hello
이때의 감성은 다시 되돌아 오지 않는다는게 씁쓸하다
진짜 ㄹㅇ이다...
그니까요..
크.. ㅇㅈㅇㅈ...
2010년대 초반 감성..
이때 감성이 ㅈㄴ 그립다 진짜 에이핑크 걸스데이 이때 ..
2023 and now 2024 still love this masterpiece !! 14 years in kpop, thank you for living the golden age.
Yes. One of my favorite groups
2023 and I miss them. This is still on my playlist.
je me suis fait des playlist avec juste leurs chansons. c'est super!!!
Fr b1a4 was the best of their time, K-pop don’t hit like this anymore /:
i discovered them last year and was one of the best things
@@dominiquemaitre131 moi aussi
OT5 🎊
정진영은 천재임이 분명하다 내 친구들 아직도 이 노래 부르면 떼창할 수 있을 정도로 기억에 남아있고 다들 지금 들어도 노래 너무 좋다고 그러는데 그때마다 너무 자랑스러움ㅜ
안효리 그니까요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 비원에이포 개좋아햇는데 ,,,,
진영 졸라 잘생김 하
This is the most peaceful group to stan in this cold world we call kpop
So true 😆
SO TRUE.
so TRUE
yeahh... agree much....
true :) BANA is also peaceful fandom
i miss kpop era around 2011-2014 😢
Me too . The best era i've ever had
Nabilah Yusof I think the best kpop era was around 2006 to 2013 idk wai al of the songs in that era were😍😍, but this era is not bad at all, there are a lot of amazing songs like "Tell me what to do" from Shinee or "Ill be your man" from BTob :D (if my english is bad is bcs im from Spain)
sameeeee
Kn, 😅
aku punn . hurmm
If you’re listening to this in 2021, we’re reliving our memories together 😭😭
Hey 😭😭
yessss😭
Yes 🤒😭
Oh my heaven, hiiiii everyone!!!!!! hahahahahahaha.
Yooo👋😭❤️
오랜만에 뮤비 다시보고 엄청 울었다
진영 신우 산들 바로 공찬 대박 비원에이포
외치던 때가 생각났다
지금도 모두를 응원한다.
함께 있어서 함께 해줘서 계속 있어줘서 너무 고맙다
영원히 행복하자
LET’S FLY B1A4
진정한 바나시군요♡저는 내안의 그놈보구 진영씨 팬되서 b1a4노래 알게되었어요~팬으로서 많이 슬프셨을것 같아요~최고의 멤버였어요♡♡♡
_쁽 2013년도 팬이었는데 어느새 2019년이고 세명밖에 안남았네요 .. 노래듣다가 급 생각나서 뮤비 돌려보면서 우는중입니다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
비포 좋아한 이후로 다른 아이돌 파본적이 없어요ㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 비원에이포는 완벽한 그룹이였음..
내가 처음이자 마지막으로 열광하던 아이돌인 비원에이포 ㅠㅠ 옛날에 내 전부였던
학생때를 비원에이포로 살았던 저도 응원구호 외치고 있었어요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
와...음색봐봐.....진짜 b1a4는 진짜 새벽감성 터뜨리는 노래임..해뜨기전에 약간 어둑어둑 할 때 들으면 내가 7~8살 때 감성이 다시 살아남..
그 때는 sky폰 쓸 때였는데
오빠가 깔아준 노래가 b1a4노래 밖에 없어서 새벽에 혼자 깼을 때 하늘 보면서 틀었는데 그 때 그 느낌 분위기가 너무 좋았음....
너무 몽환적이라 좋아요우 ㅠㅠ
@@-a-b-c-d- B1A4 오마이걸...... 너무 좋다
@@존벅믹스티비 갓발짝
😢
첫소절듣고 소름돋았어..이걸듣고 흥얼거리며 첫 아이돌 덕질하던 초4는 이제 고3이 됩니다 ;x
+)초5가아니라 초4때들었었네요
야 너두 ? 나두
야나두
걸본때 초5면 지금 스무살인뎅
헐 동갑친구들 중에 똑같은 사람들 많네여
이지수 초5입니당 저도 초5때들었는데 고3이네요ㅠㅠ
이때 초1이었지만 지금은 중3이되어 벌써 고등학교 내신준비중.....ㅠㅠ
2022 and still love this 😭
It's good to know I'm not the only one still listening to them ❤️
X3
same
Same!!
Yassss
I come back again in 2020. The feeling is different this time.
Feb 1, 2020
29 FEB
6 March 2020
March 8 2020
March 12
와 앞으로 한 10년 더 지나서 B1a4 노래들으면 심정이 어떨까 궁금하다 ..
그것도 좋은데 그러면 ㄹㅇ슬플듯 시간이 너무 빨리 감ㅠㅠㅠ
벌써 11년 전이네요
Glad to know that I'm not the only one who still listening to this nostalgic song
Same. This group shall be appreciated.
you're rite😂
ofc
2024 Anyone? Idkw I'm nostalgic for old songs and I'm having a marathon of B1A4 songs. Im really likes their song until nowww btw this song is my lullaby ^^
초6때 들었는데 이젠 21살이 되네요
노래는 정말 과거의 기억과 추억을
가져다주네요
저랑 동갑 안그래도 저때 중1을 앞둔 초6이어서 막 감정도 뒤숭숭한 그런때였는데
초딩 때 저거 바로 속사포 랩 잘하고 싶어서 노래방 갈때마다 연습했었는데 개추억이다 진짜 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
헐 미친 저도 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 아직도 구현할 수 있음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@givemejongkang 아직 가사도 드문드문 다 기억남.....
+목소리 세상 낮게....
Wt3🇮🇹🇺🇸🇯🇵🇩🇪🇨🇳🇰🇷🇬🇧🇷🇺🇪🇸🇫🇷
10🇺🇸🇺🇸🇨🇳🇩🇪🇯🇵🇰🇷🇬🇧🇷🇺🇮🇹🇪🇸🇫🇷
WM은 진짜 B1A4 한테 고마워 해야 했다...
솔직히 WM 그렇게 서포트 잘 해주지도 못 했는데 이렇게 뜬거 진짜 대단한 거고...
오마이걸이랑 온앤오프 데뷔 시킬 돈 벌어준게 B1A4지 ... 진짜 B1A4는 레전드였다ㅠㅠㅠ...
Almost the end of 2024, suddenly find this song again after 12 year.... How fast years goes by, keep on fighting guys on being successful in our life.
Watching all these "old kpop" songs just make me sadder and sadder. (Sep 2016 TOT)
CS L 😫same. So many disband and member changes going on now
CS L Idols going to military service too TT
♥
You see, at that time, viewers on UA-cam wasn't really unnecessary. But now, viewers are everything. And if the idols get a low viewers, they'd get mocked.
I miss the second generation of K-pop T.T
Same here, miss when kpop wasnt about youtube 🤷🏻♀️
i miss when kpop wasn't about chart, breaking records, rank, etc. we just enjoy their artwork
@@straysals4346 and enjoy their craziness for being themselves.
This is the prove of quality & quantity.. ✨✨
And these views are legit, rather than the same people playing it over and over on different devices
오빠들 좋아하던 초딩이 벌써 성인되서 술 퍼먹는데 술 집에서 오빠들 노래 아직도 나와요 ㅠㅠ 진짜 그럴때마다 마음이 찡 ~ 내 처음이자 마지막 연예인이 비포 오빠들 .. 알라부
They were way ahead of their time
if these song were released now it would have been a hit
Really miising them 😭😭😭
Please, support them. They just released a new single called "10 Times". 👍 please, check MV if you still can't watch ❤️ it's a masterpiece
gosh i miss them as 5 too
OT5 🎊
Yes
B1A4 music's sounds so fresh even after so many years
True, I'm still listening to this, Only Learned Bad Things and Beautiful Target 😂
Jinyoung composed this. He is so talented.
yeah! so true!
B1A4 in KPOP society is way too underrated!! They're the BOmb!
yasss!!
+Ao koto yasss!!!
Well, nowadays they indeed are. Wen they debuted, they were a real thing. they had a huge fan-club, way bigger than over a year groups, even before their debut. But they are flower boys. Now with all the hip hop hype on, and B1A4 didn't fell for it (thank God, cause this isn't them), they flopped. This really makes me sad, B1A4 is, and will always be my favorite group, and I feel sorry for the Korean fanbase
;-; preach.
I love those flower boys. I want a come back so much it hurts
This song is totally a bop. B1A4 is a talented group. They need more recognition. 2020 still here reminiscing old kpop.
There is only cnu, sandeul and gongchan left. Baro and JinYoung left the group (probs because of personal reason which is I’m not sure of.), but B1A4 was once my fave and will always have a special place in my heart and memory.
@@jfmylane2990 I know that B1A4 are 3 in their latest song. But they are still 5 in our hearts. Lets support B1A4 no matter what happens
#BANA FOREVER
OT5 forever 🎉 Jinyoung, Baro and Sandeul , 3 of them deny they have leaves the group. Besides, WM never announced BANA 2 members have quieted the group
i was teenager when i stan them and now im adult T_T time surely flies
Relate 😭
i was in 7th grade when i listened to b1a4 almost all the time and now i'm a college freshman. i came back because i was curious how are they doing now, it hurts because 2 members left. i forgot all the song titles but remember immediately when i listen to the songs, they are all very familiar. now i miss them so much and also my younger self atm it was the happiest time of my life
sya time flies and glad that our memories with B1A4 still there
Same..I was in 9th grade i.e 14y.o...now I'm 20
@@crookedprojects same..
2016 and still watching this. Never got tired.
same
yesssss
Me toooo
love this song
Same here
I need B1A4 comeback
Sincerely own fans want B1A4 comeback in the future
We miss gen2
이때 바로 머리 개좋아했는데
솜사탕 같음
초딩 때 나의 활력소...
남돌이 이래야징... 요즘은....
ㅇㅈ요 요즘 남돌은..
몇년이 지나도 b1a4 노래들은 다 좋은듯 ㅠㅠㅠ
예전에는 바로 랩 엄청 빠르게 느껴져서 뭐라하는지 몇번을 돌려들어도 몰랐는데 지금 들으니 느린거였어..
이뮤비보고 바로 입덕했는데 머리색부터 엔딩,옷까지....
이거때문에 이상형이나 잘생긴사람이 목티입으면 진짜 좋음
I miss kpop gen 2😢😢 being a kpoper since 2010❤ miss u kpop gen 2❤
Baro's voice in this is amazing! Also random MV girl how dare you make my Baro cry?!
ikr ugghhh
aw I was obsessed w this when I was on highschool now I'm in 3rd year of my college
FUCK ITS STILL SO GOOD I CANT BELIEVE I FORGOT ABOUT THIS SONG FOR YEARS
me too omgg
sameee hereee
lol.. me too, i still remember that moment when this MV just release.. I was in the middle of lesson and I secretly download this MV.. so nostalgic 😂😂😂😂
Me too! Good old days :D
I missed B1A4 so much, their music style, their vocals, they don't have bad songs, too bad their time was so short :(
다시 돌아와 눈 감고 있을테니까 다시 돌아와줘요 걸어본다 뜨자ㅠㅠ
2019 anyone?
I love this song
Raflisha Lee me💖
Here❤️
Hey
Baro's rap is soooo awesome!!~~ Sandeul's voice is sooo daebak!! Gongchan's visual is no joke!! Shinwoo's hairstyle is soo hot!! and Jinyoung my prince!! everything about this boys is my oxygen!! I need a comeback!! #B1A4ComebackBingo #BanaInternationalUnited
2023年、5人のことが忘れられません。今もこれからもずっと大好きです。
I think this is my favorite B1A4 song~ They really had their own color in music and I loved it. I miss those days
What about A Lie? I think that song is truly a masterpiece. If I had to choose just one favorite kpop song out of ALL the kpop artists, A Lie is probably the song I will choose (despite B1A4 not being my favorite band).
@@trish5830 Well this is the beauty of music~ Everyone has their own favorites. A Lie is a pretty good song too
나 혼자 이렇게
널 두고 오는 길
잊을게 지울게
까맣게 타버린 내 사랑
그런 표정 짓지 마
너와의 마지막 대화
실망은 하지 마
그래 나 같은 놈
이젠 만나지 마
나 먼저 가볼게
점점 멀어져 가네요
점점 사라져 가네요
쉽게 잊지는 말아요
내가 너무 아프니까
니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다)
니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다)
나 혼자 이렇게
널 두고 오는 길
잊을게 지울게
까맣게 타버린 내 사랑
사랑이 떠나나 봐
이 바람 타고
저 멀리 날아가나 봐
모든 게 변하나 봐
너도 나처럼
이렇게 또 변하나 봐
그래도 나 아파도 후련하다
이 기분 조차도 난 지금 버겁다
불안한 듯 바라보는 떼를 쓰는 아이 같이
그대 눈물이 돌아서는 내 어깨를 잡는다
이별은 달지만 난 괜찮아 아프지만
그대 그림자 안에서 발을 빼
우리 반지도 빼
점점 멀어져 가네요
점점 사라져 가네요
미워하지는 말아요
내가 너무 아프니까 Baby
니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다)
니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다)
아 프 다 너무나 그립다
간다 간다 떠나간다
너는 아직 모르겠지
알지 못하겠지
힘겨워하는 너를 보면서
내가 더 아파서
이렇게 널 보낸다
눈물이(눈물이)
흐른다(흐른다)
너와 나(너와 나)
너무 사랑했으니까
니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다)
니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다)
니가 없는 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다)
니가 떠난 거리를 걸어 본다 (본다
Merci!
I love Baro's versatile faerie prince hair
今日職場でK-POPの話で盛り上がって久々に聴きたくなって見に来てしまった……5人のびっぽ最高だよ……私の青春……
How this group enchanted me in a special way, what a shame everything that begins ends. Listening 03/15/2024
So basically the B1A4 Concert was incredible and I got to meet them all and now when I watch they're mvs I want to scream and squeal so hard because they were all so sweet and wonderful ^-^ I bought balcony seats but it closed and they moved us right behind the pit and we got high touch, it was the best weekend ever!
So happy for you ^^ I have only gotten to see them perform 1 song (Baby I'm sorry) at music core, but they were AMAZING live ;) and i fell for them
animearigatoo Before the concert started Baro was my bias, then once the concert started I started to notice Jinyoung and Gongchan more, but then Baro kept rapping all sexily and what not but I was still conflicted. After meeting all of them it's a tie between Baro and Gongchan!
kanashehimori Hehe. Ok. It is not suppose to be easy. CNU was my bias for a long time. Jinyoung only took the lead after i saw "Miss granny" ;)
Allan Captor Ok. I havent seen that yet. But i know it will be sad... I will watch it.. I just need time to get ready to see things i know will be sad... And i have WAY to many dramas on my "want to watch" list :P
I'm so jealous of you right now. I can't even...ugh you're so lucky ;~;
Maan Kpop was different back then. Or maybe it’s just me and the memories I associate with it 😔 I miss the old days.
same here):
Same 😭
Same..i miss 2010~2012
No matter what happened to this group, I still love them
me too❤
yaremm\ me too 😍
Just hope they will do comeback ot5 soon💝 because jinyoung and baro says that they still a part of B1a4
Same.
I'm a kpop stan since 2014 and honestly... I miss this kind of music. 2024 and I always listen to it. So good.
진짜 저 시즌 바로 머리 지디님 따라했다고 팬싸움 엄청났던거 기억난다구...그것마저도 너무 추억이야 ㅜㅠㅜㅠ다시 뭉칠 그날을 기다립니다..
Sandeuls voice just amazes me. He's so cute
One of my fav kpop songs forever. This song is always beautiful and brings back so many memories
Balam Dal same with you
Me too. Too beautiful
Balam Dal 바람달 sme with me to!
바람달Balam Dal same
in this vid I took my first kpop screenshot and set it as my lockscreen
This song has a big bang - blue vibes..
十年後來看這mv依舊不過時！真的製作得很精緻❤
I'm missing this song so much. I'm such a big fan of b1a4's old songs. Came here because watching all their medley in Ding Music. K-pop no longer produced this kind of music & song anymore 😭😭
you’re legend if you still stream to this in 2020.
I miss them so bad.....
@@DMCVitale I cry every time
@@DMCVitale yeah mee too can't believe they disbanded 2 years ago.. it felt like yesterday they did
here i am :'(
@@bryanleal1475 they didnt disband tho😂
2018 and I'm still here. I remember I stan B1A4 since 2012, time past fast and I still love them. FIGHTING!!! B1A4!!!
Jayne Lim fighting💪🏼
Omg it’s 2020 and i’m still crying over this song
2024 and still this song never get old
any Bana's who's listening to this at Jan 2020?😂
Meeee🙆🙆
Meeee :D
Meeeeee :)
🤘🏽
Me
Tried to Walk and Lonely are the must-play B1A4 songs. The emotions~
omg my top faves and winter go to music whenever the season comes!!
baro - that face, that voice simply does not add up. how on earth does someone so cute have such a sexy, deep, thick voice? he reminds me so much of vixx's ravi. they both have such unique vocals that simply don't match their faces and it's hot
AGREE!!!
Agree!!!
Praise!!!
chanyeol eh
even tho im not a fan of exo. ive had a crush on chanyeol n his unique voice before
I was crazy over BARO here when this was released!! LOVED HIS PINK HAIR ERA! I remember how i love this song! They're all great singers ❤
The look on Baros face makes me want to cry I don't like seeing my favorite people sad. >.
Jinyoung penned this song way too early in his career.. it's so underappreciated :/
I wish this song was out this year after all the exposure he got in Produce 101 and Moonlight drama, also Sanduel with his singing programs and CNU in Mask Singer. They could've topped the charts with this one :/ Hopefully their new songs for the comeback are even better than this one
This song deserved to win all the music shows tbh!! :(
So true its sad. I love this song so much and Jinyoung is too amazing. He composed a song as perfect as this so early that the fandom wasn't even ready. Hopefully they can become big again with the next comeback and stay big :)
Ikr im still new to the group but around last year I unconsciously listened to B1A4's songs and liked it and when i checked all those songs date release it was like 2014 and this 2012.. I wish I discovered this group sooner ;(
100% agree!! Tbh, Oh My Girl's Closer reminds me of B1A4's Tried to Walk; aside from some similarities in the concept/MV/song, both were amazing title tracks but are still so underappreciated. Probably due to the fact that both songs were promoted very early in their careers :-(
Jinyoung made this song even before turning into 21, that’s pity now kpop fans sleep on this kind of quality music and group! They are still popular with their solid resumes into individual fields, true talents will turn them into legends in later days ! 👊🏻👊🏻🎉🎉
it's been four years... but i still love this song
oh...me too!!!
사랑해 B1A4 🎉🎉🎉
This is one of the first kpop songs i ever heard that got me hooked!
Cant wait for B1A4's new comeback... #Lonely.
Jinyoung isnt my bias in B1A4 but I love his voice so much personally I think he's one of the best singers in Kpop
+Lover4Kpop I know right! His voice is very unique. All of their voices are. ^^
I think Both leaders of B1A4 and INFINITE have realllyyyy unique voices,
So proud to be a InspiritBANA
You're wrong. Yoseop is.
+Steve Walters bruh she said ONE OF the best singers..
Ikr! Baro and gochan are my biases but jinyoung is so good and unique!! i love the whole group 😍😘 ONE of the best singers yes, the BEST singer is a no XD
CNU so gorgeous
Coming here again after 10 years. What a memory 😊
2016 and this is still one of my favourite kpop songs it is just so beautiful.This is also the song that tied me to b1a4 #bana forever.pls comeback soon we miss all of u
They're def coming *^^*
B1A4 songs will be forever classic never get old 💘
어쩌다 추억의 그룹으로 남겨진거니..... 좋아하고 싶어도 흩어져버린, 그렇게 끝나버린 내 첫 아이돌...
Hearing it again in 2024. The fact that I can remember the title...the first kpop group I stan
My first first kpop group bias. Aaaaaaaaa soooo nostalgic
My first song ftom B1A4... and I'm already in love >.< So beautifuuul ! ~
2021 is coming soon and i still here for you B1A4.. Miss them at all😭
Still listening after 12 years🖐🏻
BARO NO.... OMG HE LOOKS SO FLUFFY THEN HE RAPS WTF ITS LOWER THAN THE OCEAN GOOD GOD
Sameee! He is a lil bit of errthing
he looks soooo sweet but then he starts rapping ..Nd I'm just blown away
I’ve not heard this song in yeaaaars and literally just saw it while going on a nostalgia journey and i’m surprised i still remember everything, the lyrics the music. Used to love this song so much and hearing it now i love it again!
2022 ..the song that make fall in love with b1a4
내가 이노래를 애정하고 아직도 찾는 이유 중에 하나가
중학교 때 도서관에서 공부하고 밤 10-11시 넘는 시간에 혼자 눈 내리는 거 보면서 집으로 가고 있었는데, 조용히 아무도 없는 곳에서 이 노래를 들을 때 나도 모르게 심취해서 집에 바로 들어가고 계속 아파트 단지 안에서 눈 밟으며 걸어 다녔던 기억 때문에 주기적으로 듣게 됨
그때 그 느낌 그 감정들을 추억하기 위해서
THIS IS SUCH A MASTERPIECE COMPOSITION BY JINYOUNG. LIKE, HOLY SHIT, SO GOOD
still remember the first time I listened to it. . good memory 💕
#B1A4ComeBackBingo #BANAinternationalUnited
懐かし。確かこの歌が出たとき、確か私が幼稚園の年長さんのときだった。。 幼稚園のときお姉ちゃん達がよく歌ってたから覚えてる。。。久しぶりに聴くと泣ける。
I used tp sing this song out loud walking to my school, I was 14-15. I'm almost 22, still love them. This brings back memories, specially now it's turning cold and I fell in love with this song during the winter
Watching this mv 2019☺️☺️👏
2020
This is the first KPOP band I've listened to really...
And I love this
i remembered this was my all time fav mv. until now actually.
I love your name ... OMG..
B1A4 is back maderpakers sameee!
Samee
happy 12th anniversary to this masterpiece..
CNU STOP BEING SO FREAKIN GORGEOUS T_T
I miss them all ( TДT)
Jinyoung! CNU! Sandeul! Baro! Gongchan! Daebak! B1A4!
Geez! it's 2023
My middle school song~ I miss this song! TT ♡
좋다 말로는 다 못해
I'm glad most of the members kept their single eyelids. ^^
ikr esp channie's uneven eyelid :p
kimchidollie D which one is channie ?
gongchan
What do you mean "most"? Did one of them get plastic surgery?
Eyes B1A4 sooo beautiful, Channie´s uneven eyelid is special
Baro is my Bias. I miss them 😭❤
시간이 지나도 전혀 질리지않는 명곡ㅠㅠ
I really inspired this song after 10 years plus since 2012. Very touching 🎉