You state B46's Roller cannot carry Prime's rifle - but he can. You have to turn the rifle sideways and there are holes on the sides of the rifle to plug in the peg on Roller into.
Have both of these and I really love both, I honestly can't choose one and say it's better than the other. I can appreciate the "premium styling" of the NA and the more rugged material of the MS.
@@mrdude88 MS I'd fairly new, while David has been out for a while longer. The most recent David recolor has improved elbows as well, but I would still say MS has the better display options
@@theonepstein5100NewAge is better quality but not better transformation. I have both and if it wasn't for the cheap plastic, Magic Square would win this easily. NewAge is made more complicated because of the tight spaces you have to transform around. There's a reason why Magic Square's Masterpiece version is considered the best Optimus Prime and this little guy is the exact same, only in Legends Scale.
Just gotta say, I absolutely love your reviews. It feels like you put a lot of effort into your scripts; your discussion points show a sophisticated understanding of Transformers that goes far beyond “look at this toy.” Instead your videos feel like wonderfully composed essays. Even when you have the rare mistake in your wording, your confidence never lets it distract from the flow of your review. You also perfectly complement your words with appropriate visuals, and wonderful poses - I love the humorous moments, like size comparisons to the legs of Titans. Between your writing, your filming (focus pulling, holy crap!), and your production values, you are EASILY in the top 5 UA-cam Transformers content creators! My only complaint is that you don’t have more videos up yet!
Wow, Mike, your words are priceless, thank you so much. I used to use grammarly to check errors, should start using it again, and be more careful when scripting. Uploading UA-cam videos is addictive, a weekly cycle of getting a new toy, trying new editing tricks, making new friends in the comment section, and waiting for the next new toy, and your kind words just make this journey so much more fulfilling, it's what all UA-camrs are after. The Transformers realm carries our shared memory, it's where everyone of us could just be the inner child that we want to be, sharing our precious toys and the fantasies about them, I am so glad that you're here.
@@OptimusLegends There are other toys I’ll buy on occasion for the nostalgia, but none of them combine that feeling with the thrill of novelty and discovery as well as Transformers do. I never mind buying multiple versions of the same character as long as they find new ways of doing the same thing. As for writing errors, don’t worry about it. I only caught a few, but I have a sharper ear for it than most, and even now I can’t quite remember what they were. That said, I’d also be happy to give your scripts a once over, if you’d like. Sometimes the human eye can catch things that Grammarly will miss.
Hi Mike, sorry for the late reply, just completed the latest episode, I am inviting you to give it a review when you have time: ua-cam.com/video/b9MX6ouKA58/v-deo.html. It's a start of a massive construcitcon review project, and just like you said, the same characters over and over, but better and better. I am trying to improve on the production quality, which requires me to make the script concise so that I could complete a review in a week, hope that reduces the mistakes that I make. Really like your comment, it makes me think, much appreciated.
Thank you Scholar!! I guess it's Magic Square to blame, they really should just remove the price of the repairing bay instead of actually removing it from the box, it's trouble, and it made the fans wait for the re-release.
I love MS-B46 so much! I’ve been anticipating this guy since it was announced. For me, it’s my all time favorite G1 prime, beating TE-01 and MP-44. If they upscaled it, I’d buy it in a heartbeat. I don’t have any legend figures, so buying prime only would make it feel out of place. I hope they get a g1 toy styled repaint like newage did. Newage is great, but it’s not my style if I’m going for cartoon accuracy. Usually I’m not big on cartoon accuracy anyway, but if I’m going for cartoon accuracy, I’d want it as close as possible. I don’t mean to diss newage at all, because it’s still an amazing figure, but I just prefer ms-b46 so much more, since it’s trade offs compared to newage are worth it for me. I also prefer the MS transformation, since there’s almost no fake parts
I guess if Magic Square listens, they should really upscale this guy into the masterpiece scale, people want it. B46 has great potential to be the best Prime, hope Magic Square could use it well enough to serve different fans with it. Repainted versions should come out soon, Nemesis is coming. And agreed, I like how they designed the transformation in a more logical way, using fewer fake parts.
While MS will be repainting this V2 mold a couple of times like they did with their V1 (ms-b18), I don't know if they would do a toy repaint.. A Nemesis v2 repaint is about to be released this month, we'll have to wait and see what's in store for us next.
Because of you, I ended up buying MS-B46! It hasn't arrived yet but I'm extremely excited to get him. This has really opened my eyes and made me curious about collecting Legends figures. Great review!
Nice review. One thing you forgot to mention though: on b46, the repair bay doubles as a stand. If you take the entire top part off, you can plug the black stem piece into prime and get some more dynamic poses if you don’t have your own stand
Excellent review. Since NewAge recently made a version 2.0 of BumbleBee, it's not out of the question that after milking the H27 mold, maybe in a year they'd make a H27 2.0 version of it that resolves the deficiency in the design like a bigger trailer and increase its size by 5 % more. Honestly I'd like a supersized version of the H27. If NewAge can make the H27 Ultra Magnus, they can make an H27 Power Master Optimus Prime with an upgraded trailer similar to how Magnus integrates to his trailer. I'd rather have a backpack like PowerBaser Prime than a pregnant G1 PowerMaster Optimus Prime that's similar to Magnus' power armor. IMO, the H27 is more designed for Magnus than Prime's release.
Thanks, Jon. Good point about NewAge Magnus, just watched a review of it, I like the robot leg better on Magnus, looks more complete. And I think you are right, there would be a new Optimus figure from NewAge, there are just things they need to improve on this figure compared to Magic Square.
@@OptimusLegends For some reason they delayed the release of H27 Prime by months and released Ultra Magnus and Nemisis first, with a leg transformation which I believe was how it was originally designed for this mold. They completely redesigned the lower body for Prime, I think for articulation. H27 is optimised for robot mode and arguably it has better leg articulation than magic square. In terms of the truck mode the the Ultra Magnus mold is actually the best out of the three. If we go by cartoon accuracy, then magic square hands down. As a toy, I prefer Magic Square due to its unbreakable material, it is practically indestructible.
I appreciate your positivity. Thank you for that. It’s becoming a superpower these days. Along with common sense. Great video. And I couldn’t agree more with your final analysis. Stay you. Thank you.
I love these legends figures 3p's are dishing out, but by the time i can afford them- I won't be able to afford them lol. Hope they have some affordable reissues by the end of summer
27F is the budget version with the minimal configuration, B46 black version just came out with just the gun and ax. And there will definitely be more simpler versions for fans to get the figures they love.
I spent a couple of hours watching your videos. You might be my favorite reviewer. Your cinematography is top notch and does nothing to help my plastic crack addiction.
As always, I'm very pleased with your simple and informative review. It seems like I'm compelled to get a B46 just for my table play Optimus Prime. Keep up your great videos and more power to your channel.
I got mine (full set) a few days ago and I have to agree. This thing is great. I was completely satisfied playing with the standard hands but on a whim decided to mess with the optionals. Holy crap that made this thing even better. Way to go OP Legends for a spot on review of this amazing little toy. Now waiting for the inevitable metallic repaint. You know, one for the office. Haha
Glad you are happy with this Prime! But this is a dangerous move... once I got used to the look and feel of nylon, I couldn't stop buying products from this line!
Newage Prime is personally my favorite. His robot mode proportions match up closer to the cartoon design compared to MS and I prefer to more MP44 style truck. However that's just me
@@Anduril1974 it just depends on the person, to my eye Newage's stuff always seems more accurate. They have more "anime" proportions to me which I think matches more
New Age has made many great figures recently and some are just more superior than MS, but in some cases, like this, in my opinion, MS wins this round. I love both companies, in fact I build my collection based on which character looks the best between the two companys. Like, I have MS Megatron leading NA star scream and constructicons. To me, I have no sides, but only when it comes to the look and the playability of the figures.
Can't agree more. I see fans invested too much, sometimes even themselves into a brand, clouding their judgement and missed what it is supposed to be, the fun of these toys. I only collect legend scale figures causally, and missed a lot, should take a look at MS Megatron.
If I had known about these figures much earlier I would have based my collection on these. I have the original Hasbro ones; but for size, beauty and looks, these are much better.
I really like how that this version Optimus has Starscream's head and shoulders as I remember seeing that episode on Hasbro's UA-cam channel, and Screamer did a pretty good job posing as Optimus.
B46 is the better option for me looks like the G1 show in vehicle and robot and saturated colors reads well, especially with the Nylon. #Hasbro #Takara
I don’t like newage as much for a few reasons. 1. The vehicle, robot and paint. -• the robot mode mold seems to be based on g1, being retooled for the EX version. With that being said, he has a semi realistic paint job and an attempt at a realistic truck mode. The robot mode is great (minus the chest) but the paint isn’t cartoony, and the truck is a bit disproportionate and doesn’t show up in the robot much, so you get a decent robot mode and truck mode, with the paint only really fitting the truck. If they focused on one or the other (realistic vs cartoon), I bet it would look great and more solid imo. David normally is kinda disappointing, but the EX version is awesome, and I haven’t seen many figures as commuted to the toy look as this retool/recolor. 2. The faux chest -• this guy is similar to MP-44 because of its proportions and lack of real parts. The chest is fake, and its sacrifice doesn’t seem as worth it for the robot mode’s gap in the chest. That’s not what I look for in a transformer. Although the rest of the figure isn’t bad at all, it just has some weaknesses that stop me from liking him so much. Newage has some great other figures like agamemnon and black rain. However I did read a comment somewhere here that said newage falls behind because it was optimized for octavian, not david, so they made trade offs for a good octavian. I think for that, newage gains some extra points. As a whole company too, they have the better repaints and retools, and the EX figures look phenomenal.
Yeah.. those are the things that disappointed the fans. I went for EX because I was just so keen to have a modern rendition of the G1 toy, and it fits the bill. But the paint chipping is just so annoying, so I went for 27F, as a transformation double, and it's okay for the price. And I agree, this is very much designed for the Ultra Magnus release, not quite for Optimus, maybe there is another version of Optimus from NewAge down the line?
I'm really torn on these 2 figures - I like the Magic Square robot mode better (as it matches my MP-44), and I prefer the NewAge alt-mode (as it's a better looking truck). Great video, as always...thank you!!!
I think it's worth pointing out that magic square is very likely to release a metallic/painted version their B46, much like what they did with their first attempt at a legends scale prime. I'm personally waiting for that version of the mold.
It's a separate 5 dollar purchase for the bay, most stores who carry B46 have them, but sold separately for the production issue. Yeah, that's a new trick I just learned to help viewers to navigate through the video, hope it's useful.
Interestingly enough, the G1 cartoon Prime truck doesn't have a silver/grey stripe on it. Never actually realized it because I'm so used to seeing it on toys.
Its a crime against God we didn't get a masterpiece scale version of these... INCREDIBLE FIGURES, BETTER THEN ANY OTHER OPTIMUS, THESE ARE THE 2 BEST, NOTHING GETS THESE MANY THINGS RIGHT!
I finally got MS Prime!!! 😁 It's so good that I had only one problem with the heads not being removable, but I was able to pop the heads in and out several times, and now my problem is gone. No breakage, not much paint chip, and so much fun. It's truly just Prime. 😀 And Optimus Legends, thank you so much for your seperate MS Prime video, it helped me a lot to transform the figure the first time.
For me its Magic Square B46. It’s the action poses…I don’t like the look of the David when looking down from the top. The chest makes a weird line right under the chin. Love the clean look of B46!
Just got the newage h27 and I absolutely love him. The 1 I got doesn't have the metal spine but I still love him...them...I actually bought 2 from Ebay on sale. Now...I wanna get this dude. Lol
Magic Square probably is not going to do it but I would love to see them making the G1 toy accurate version just like David 27EX, that would look amazing
aside the knee joint i greatly prefer magic square over new age Knee joint of b46 make the leg look like it break in half really wish they make mp scale to fix this problem Oh i think if they go for extreme cartoon arcurate they can remove some truck detail to get a cleanner bot mode
I guess in legend scale it will be rather difficult to manage a better sculpt for the knees, and agreed, by scaling up, there should be a better solution. Not sure how many repaint would come out, they are sharing the same mold and truck details I guess.
If it wasn’t for magic square’s plastic, I’d pick Magic Square’s offering over Newage. But as long as they continue with this plastic and that finish, I’m always gonna choose Newage over Magic Square.
That kamehameha pose though. Never knew I needed to see that. They both look great but I think personally for me Magic Square has the better figure. Might get that sometime. Edit: Upon further viewing, the NewAge figure does have positives too. Kinda wish we could combine the positives to get a figure with the best of both.
I remember when you reviewed the magic square Optimus, he didn’t have the Bay station but now you have it? Because I bought the no-bay version day 1 and I want to know where to get the Bay
Hi Knight, it's a separate 5 dollar purchase, it's available at most stores who carry B46, they just sell them separately for the production issues on the repairing bay.
I've been waiting on Magic Square to get B-46 back in stock and they finally did. Ordered immediately as I love the toon accuracies. I have the Masterpiece scale of Optimus Prime and Nemesis Prime as well and they're fantastic. This little guy is just as good but way smaller and with a trailer. I love NewAge version, especially the premium look and paint but that chest kills it for me. That's probably the only reason I didn't buy him. A year later and now I have NewAge David and sold my Magic Square. The plastic was just so flimsy that it felt very cheap. Still think MS does it better but chose the premium quality of NewAge over accuracies and cheap unpainted plastics.
For my money I split the difference. Got the regular h27 and also bought ms46b scourge to get the best of both worlds. Plus the antagonist aspect of it all.
I don't know about anyone else,but I'd go with magic square MS-B46 Optimus. He's cleaner,and more cartoon accurate. The new age on the other hand is just ok. To many gaps in vehicle mode and the foe chest wind shield is my biggest grip. And its not as clean in robot mode as magic square B46. The things I do like about new age is the paint detail and new age did go for the traditional 80's G1 look. But all in all I prefer the magic square B46.
Nice vids anyway @optimus legends do you think there will be bigger scale like earthrise scale of this G1 accurate model? I really like MAGIC SQUARE but i find the scale small
B46 is my second Magic Square figure, I used to collect NewAge without a second thought, until MS Hound came out, masterpiece mindset for designing legend scale figures.
NewAge's toy deco is superb. Just gorgeous. Magic Square's is definitely better on the cartoon side. Legends scale collectors continue to win in either case here.
Very true, I just realized it only recently as I was reviewing these legend scale figures, that we could get back to the fun we used to have when we were kids playing with transformer toys, we never cared about paint chipping, we didn't have to pay extra attention and try not to break this delicate piece, we know nothing about engineering or materials, we just fumbled with this thing, flipped between modes and had fun. A huge difference between collecting MPs and legends.
The bs46 IS THE 2.0 VERSION for $80 !! It is important to note that. There is another “repaint” version that is $50 on showzstore and THAT IS NOT THE ONE IS THIS VIDEO!!
I have all of the Newage prime versions and ultra Magnus recolours, and I just bought the Magic Square Nemisis v2.0. I have to say Magic Square wins this one for me. First of all, for cartoon accuracy, there is no comparison. Magic square version is also more clean in my opinion, less transformation joints and gaps etc in both modes. It has virtually no faux parts, except for the front fender/hip, even the gas tank transforms into the larger gas tank, which is very clever. I never liked the back end of the Newage prime's truck mode, just does not look right and the upper cover doesn't lock into position when you try to lift it. As a toy, I also find I enjoyed play with Magic Square a lot more, the material is very tough and I was not afraid to use force. It is virtually indestructible. The Newage design has a flaw, the screws go lose all my versions on the front wheel arc part. I also found that some paint on the silver parts of the waist got rubbed off after a few days of play and transformation. Usually I find Newage gives better transformation experience than magic square for most of their transformers. This is not the case for Optimus. The tabs on the H27 (and variants)'s legs are way too tight, almost impossible to transform if you don't have strong finger nails, fingers feel painful afterwards. Overall I find transforming Magic Square prime much more pleasant experience. Overall, QC issues aside (Newage has better QC), I feel Magic Square takes this one with a healthy margin. For Newage to catch up in their 2.0 release I think they need to redesign.
Thanks for a mini review, the points are spot on. Like many fans said, H27 is more of an Ultra Magnus design, rather than a Prime dedicated mold, I guess it makes sense. NA used to be my go to brand for legend scale figures, but a few of their recent designs fell behind, especially when I was exploring the Devastator options, I was shocked how NA could release a set like that, hope they could get back to the old NA that fans love, maybe with a 2.0 Optimus.
@@OptimusLegends Totally agree. When I started collecting legends it ALL NewAge. Then a few MS crept in, and now, months later, it's 90% Magic Square. In my opinion their recent releases have almost entirely surpassed their NA counterparts - even with the oft-criticised choice of plastic (which i've never understood). What a time to be a legend collector!
still without Ex color magic square prime wins!! in terms of accuracy, design, articulation, quality and durability . nylon doesnt break easily and no paint chipping
I prefer the MS one mainly because I can’t get over how the newages chest looks with that weird faux chest. They’re both good, but that chest puts me off.
I just orders the new Optimus Prime figure from Newage (David) and that trailer is more cartoon accurate then the version you showed in this video, i gues you don't have the new one yet so it's a unfair competition. I would have liked Magic Square figures if they would use paint but they don't, so Newage is the winner for me.
I like the fact that b46 doesn't look like an action figure he looks like he jumped out of the screen and into my hands and it's more clean than newage's primethe only bummer of b46 is the line on the truck mode it's not accurate so I might just remove it
Why are you comparing to the NA EX? I think the MS is going for the Heroic chest look a bit, so it’s proportions are not “better”. That’s complete opinion. One can not say one looks definitely more proportionate. The lack of a transparent chest on the MS is killing it for me. I don’t like their materials, and I agree that it looks kind of cheap.
You state B46's Roller cannot carry Prime's rifle - but he can. You have to turn the rifle sideways and there are holes on the sides of the rifle to plug in the peg on Roller into.
Thank you Peter for pointing that out, I missed it.
thanks peter
thank you peter
All this video did was convince me to get both.
These legend scale figures are getting better and better, really amazing work.
All this video did for me was convince me legends scale collecting is the best way to go
Lol right!? I came here trying to see if I bought the best one. I have newage prime. Now I’m going to buy MS prime lol
Facts I have both as well. As well as both Megatron's. Legend scale has me seriously considering downsizing my MP collection
transformers not going anywhere.. wait a few yrs they be even better😁
Have both of these and I really love both, I honestly can't choose one and say it's better than the other. I can appreciate the "premium styling" of the NA and the more rugged material of the MS.
Yes, feeling exactly the same. It's a good time to collect legend scale figures.
I see it instantly when both stands together. Better G1 style, more extras, a collectors card and the Winner is: Magic Square!
Ah yes, I should include the collector card in the comparison.
Which one came first and how long ago was it released? Just asking because usually the second to be release has better QC and more stuff.
@@mrdude88 MS I'd fairly new, while David has been out for a while longer. The most recent David recolor has improved elbows as well, but I would still say MS has the better display options
Newage is better. Better quality and transformations.
@@theonepstein5100NewAge is better quality but not better transformation. I have both and if it wasn't for the cheap plastic, Magic Square would win this easily. NewAge is made more complicated because of the tight spaces you have to transform around. There's a reason why Magic Square's Masterpiece version is considered the best Optimus Prime and this little guy is the exact same, only in Legends Scale.
Just gotta say, I absolutely love your reviews. It feels like you put a lot of effort into your scripts; your discussion points show a sophisticated understanding of Transformers that goes far beyond “look at this toy.” Instead your videos feel like wonderfully composed essays. Even when you have the rare mistake in your wording, your confidence never lets it distract from the flow of your review. You also perfectly complement your words with appropriate visuals, and wonderful poses - I love the humorous moments, like size comparisons to the legs of Titans.
Between your writing, your filming (focus pulling, holy crap!), and your production values, you are EASILY in the top 5 UA-cam Transformers content creators! My only complaint is that you don’t have more videos up yet!
Wow, Mike, your words are priceless, thank you so much.
I used to use grammarly to check errors, should start using it again, and be more careful when scripting.
Uploading UA-cam videos is addictive, a weekly cycle of getting a new toy, trying new editing tricks, making new friends in the comment section, and waiting for the next new toy, and your kind words just make this journey so much more fulfilling, it's what all UA-camrs are after.
The Transformers realm carries our shared memory, it's where everyone of us could just be the inner child that we want to be, sharing our precious toys and the fantasies about them, I am so glad that you're here.
@@OptimusLegends There are other toys I’ll buy on occasion for the nostalgia, but none of them combine that feeling with the thrill of novelty and discovery as well as Transformers do. I never mind buying multiple versions of the same character as long as they find new ways of doing the same thing.
As for writing errors, don’t worry about it. I only caught a few, but I have a sharper ear for it than most, and even now I can’t quite remember what they were. That said, I’d also be happy to give your scripts a once over, if you’d like. Sometimes the human eye can catch things that Grammarly will miss.
Hi Mike, sorry for the late reply, just completed the latest episode, I am inviting you to give it a review when you have time: ua-cam.com/video/b9MX6ouKA58/v-deo.html.
It's a start of a massive construcitcon review project, and just like you said, the same characters over and over, but better and better.
I am trying to improve on the production quality, which requires me to make the script concise so that I could complete a review in a week, hope that reduces the mistakes that I make.
Really like your comment, it makes me think, much appreciated.
Awesome comparison. It's weird that you're still the only guy to review the Magic Square Optimus in English.
Thank you Scholar!!
I guess it's Magic Square to blame, they really should just remove the price of the repairing bay instead of actually removing it from the box, it's trouble, and it made the fans wait for the re-release.
Hooray I’ve been looking forward to this! You seriously are the best TF reviewer on UA-cam !
Thanks!! Really glad you liked the video!
magic square really made the best optimus prime figure ever created so far
I would agree, MS-B46, the slight QC issues aside, it is currently the best G1 Optimus in ANY scale.
@@tonglianheng So glad there’s an MP scale version too
I love MS-B46 so much! I’ve been anticipating this guy since it was announced. For me, it’s my all time favorite G1 prime, beating TE-01 and MP-44. If they upscaled it, I’d buy it in a heartbeat. I don’t have any legend figures, so buying prime only would make it feel out of place. I hope they get a g1 toy styled repaint like newage did. Newage is great, but it’s not my style if I’m going for cartoon accuracy. Usually I’m not big on cartoon accuracy anyway, but if I’m going for cartoon accuracy, I’d want it as close as possible. I don’t mean to diss newage at all, because it’s still an amazing figure, but I just prefer ms-b46 so much more, since it’s trade offs compared to newage are worth it for me. I also prefer the MS transformation, since there’s almost no fake parts
I guess if Magic Square listens, they should really upscale this guy into the masterpiece scale, people want it.
B46 has great potential to be the best Prime, hope Magic Square could use it well enough to serve different fans with it. Repainted versions should come out soon, Nemesis is coming.
And agreed, I like how they designed the transformation in a more logical way, using fewer fake parts.
@@OptimusLegends yeah, I found 2 pics of prime with clear windows, but yt won’t let me link it
While MS will be repainting this V2 mold a couple of times like they did with their V1 (ms-b18), I don't know if they would do a toy repaint.. A Nemesis v2 repaint is about to be released this month, we'll have to wait and see what's in store for us next.
OH DO I HAVE GOOD NEWS FOR YOU
@@PhantomPraetor I SAW
Thanks to your awesome review I decide to pre-order the magic square!
Good choice! Hope you will enjoy the figure!
Because of you, I ended up buying MS-B46! It hasn't arrived yet but I'm extremely excited to get him. This has really opened my eyes and made me curious about collecting Legends figures. Great review!
Glad I could help! And enjoy!
Nice review. One thing you forgot to mention though: on b46, the repair bay doubles as a stand. If you take the entire top part off, you can plug the black stem piece into prime and get some more dynamic poses if you don’t have your own stand
Excellent review. Since NewAge recently made a version 2.0 of BumbleBee, it's not out of the question that after milking the H27 mold, maybe in a year they'd make a H27 2.0 version of it that resolves the deficiency in the design like a bigger trailer and increase its size by 5 % more. Honestly I'd like a supersized version of the H27. If NewAge can make the H27 Ultra Magnus, they can make an H27 Power Master Optimus Prime with an upgraded trailer similar to how Magnus integrates to his trailer. I'd rather have a backpack like PowerBaser Prime than a pregnant G1 PowerMaster Optimus Prime that's similar to Magnus' power armor. IMO, the H27 is more designed for Magnus than Prime's release.
Thanks, Jon.
Good point about NewAge Magnus, just watched a review of it, I like the robot leg better on Magnus, looks more complete. And I think you are right, there would be a new Optimus figure from NewAge, there are just things they need to improve on this figure compared to Magic Square.
@@OptimusLegends For some reason they delayed the release of H27 Prime by months and released Ultra Magnus and Nemisis first, with a leg transformation which I believe was how it was originally designed for this mold. They completely redesigned the lower body for Prime, I think for articulation. H27 is optimised for robot mode and arguably it has better leg articulation than magic square. In terms of the truck mode the the Ultra Magnus mold is actually the best out of the three. If we go by cartoon accuracy, then magic square hands down. As a toy, I prefer Magic Square due to its unbreakable material, it is practically indestructible.
You mentioned that fans of the MS figure have wanted a masterpiece-scale one, and it seems like that's exactly what's happening now with MS-02
Bro thought we wouldn’t notice 0:50
I remember back when the legends line was a simple bulkier design to adapt to the size. Seeing how far it’s come is just baffling
The new Core line from Hasbro/Takara Tomy is still bulk size lol, the one that improves are these 3rd party kits
I appreciate your positivity. Thank you for that. It’s becoming a superpower these days. Along with common sense. Great video. And I couldn’t agree more with your final analysis. Stay you. Thank you.
I love these legends figures 3p's are dishing out, but by the time i can afford them- I won't be able to afford them lol. Hope they have some affordable reissues by the end of summer
27F is the budget version with the minimal configuration, B46 black version just came out with just the gun and ax.
And there will definitely be more simpler versions for fans to get the figures they love.
I spent a couple of hours watching your videos. You might be my favorite reviewer. Your cinematography is top notch and does nothing to help my plastic crack addiction.
It's such a honor, thank you so much Artimus.
This is a healthy addiction, welcome to the support group.
As always, I'm very pleased with your simple and informative review. It seems like I'm compelled to get a B46 just for my table play Optimus Prime. Keep up your great videos and more power to your channel.
I got mine (full set) a few days ago and I have to agree. This thing is great.
I was completely satisfied playing with the standard hands but on a whim decided to mess with the optionals.
Holy crap that made this thing even better.
Way to go OP Legends for a spot on review of this amazing little toy.
Now waiting for the inevitable metallic repaint. You know, one for the office. Haha
Glad you are happy with this Prime!
But this is a dangerous move... once I got used to the look and feel of nylon, I couldn't stop buying products from this line!
should i get the NA H27M David or mp10
If only we could get a B46 figure with the materials and paint of H27
Till all are one!
what a great video production. very thoughtful comparisons and good voice.
Thank you so much! Hope you find it useful and entertaining.
Newage Prime is personally my favorite. His robot mode proportions match up closer to the cartoon design compared to MS and I prefer to more MP44 style truck. However that's just me
Only it isn't. MS is more accurate to the cartoon, this is demonstrable . He even admits to this in this video.
@@Anduril1974 it just depends on the person, to my eye Newage's stuff always seems more accurate. They have more "anime" proportions to me which I think matches more
New Age has made many great figures recently and some are just more superior than MS, but in some cases, like this, in my opinion, MS wins this round. I love both companies, in fact I build my collection based on which character looks the best between the two companys. Like, I have MS Megatron leading NA star scream and constructicons. To me, I have no sides, but only when it comes to the look and the playability of the figures.
Can't agree more.
I see fans invested too much, sometimes even themselves into a brand, clouding their judgement and missed what it is supposed to be, the fun of these toys.
I only collect legend scale figures causally, and missed a lot, should take a look at MS Megatron.
If I had known about these figures much earlier I would have based my collection on these. I have the original Hasbro ones; but for size, beauty and looks, these are much better.
MS has also beat NA with Soundwave specially the tapes. Its almost a no contest.
@@heavyhitter5538 I definitely agree with this too
Thanks for the video.
Thanks to this, I'm getting the Magic Square B46.
The downside of Newage for me is the chestpiece.
Hi Jay, hope you enjoy your new micro masterpiece Prime!
I like how you've finally got the repair station for MS-B46.
MS B46 for me.
I really like how that this version Optimus has Starscream's head and shoulders as I remember seeing that episode on Hasbro's UA-cam channel, and Screamer did a pretty good job posing as Optimus.
B46 is the better option for me looks like the G1 show in vehicle and robot and saturated colors reads well, especially with the Nylon. #Hasbro
#Takara
I don’t like newage as much for a few reasons.
1. The vehicle, robot and paint.
-• the robot mode mold seems to be based on g1, being retooled for the EX version. With that being said, he has a semi realistic paint job and an attempt at a realistic truck mode. The robot mode is great (minus the chest) but the paint isn’t cartoony, and the truck is a bit disproportionate and doesn’t show up in the robot much, so you get a decent robot mode and truck mode, with the paint only really fitting the truck. If they focused on one or the other (realistic vs cartoon), I bet it would look great and more solid imo.
David normally is kinda disappointing, but the EX version is awesome, and I haven’t seen many figures as commuted to the toy look as this retool/recolor.
2. The faux chest
-• this guy is similar to MP-44 because of its proportions and lack of real parts. The chest is fake, and its sacrifice doesn’t seem as worth it for the robot mode’s gap in the chest. That’s not what I look for in a transformer. Although the rest of the figure isn’t bad at all, it just has some weaknesses that stop me from liking him so much. Newage has some great other figures like agamemnon and black rain.
However I did read a comment somewhere here that said newage falls behind because it was optimized for octavian, not david, so they made trade offs for a good octavian. I think for that, newage gains some extra points. As a whole company too, they have the better repaints and retools, and the EX figures look phenomenal.
Yeah.. those are the things that disappointed the fans.
I went for EX because I was just so keen to have a modern rendition of the G1 toy, and it fits the bill. But the paint chipping is just so annoying, so I went for 27F, as a transformation double, and it's okay for the price.
And I agree, this is very much designed for the Ultra Magnus release, not quite for Optimus, maybe there is another version of Optimus from NewAge down the line?
@@OptimusLegends perhaps, if it somehow manages to best b46 in the aspects it specializes in, my mind would be blown.
I'm really torn on these 2 figures - I like the Magic Square robot mode better (as it matches my MP-44), and I prefer the NewAge alt-mode (as it's a better looking truck). Great video, as always...thank you!!!
Sounds like you need both, double the fun.
I think it's worth pointing out that magic square is very likely to release a metallic/painted version their B46, much like what they did with their first attempt at a legends scale prime. I'm personally waiting for that version of the mold.
Agreed, it's inevitable, and hope it's not too pricy since this version is already too expensive for a legend scale.
B46 I love it and David, 27 I have both they both worth the cop.
Thank you for the video! You convinced me to wait a little longer in hopes for a B46 that is painted.
Glad I could help! B46 is worth the wait.
Wait where did you get the Magic Square repair bay?? I also didn’t notice the bottom has little sections for the video
It's a separate 5 dollar purchase for the bay, most stores who carry B46 have them, but sold separately for the production issue.
Yeah, that's a new trick I just learned to help viewers to navigate through the video, hope it's useful.
These Prime versions made me think of:
MSquare = HG
NewAge = RG 😋
Welcome to the club, Gundam fan!
MP44 = PG
@@unknownguy2051 yes! THIS! xD
@@NeoSlashott KBB MP10V = MG
Was really looking forward to this one, and you definitely delivered. Awesome work as always, dude.
Thank you Bishop for always being there, and glad you liked the video!
Interestingly enough, the G1 cartoon Prime truck doesn't have a silver/grey stripe on it. Never actually realized it because I'm so used to seeing it on toys.
There is a strip in one of the cartoon draft, since it was following the toy design.
So in the cartoon, some scenes there was the stripe, some not.
Its a crime against God we didn't get a masterpiece scale version of these... INCREDIBLE FIGURES, BETTER THEN ANY OTHER OPTIMUS, THESE ARE THE 2 BEST, NOTHING GETS THESE MANY THINGS RIGHT!
Couldn't agree more! Hope MS hears our voice of upscaling these figures!
I love you review style. Subscribed.
IMO, MS prime wins for adding special effects. can't go wrong with both but the effects is an extra plus! thx for the vid!
Excellent work; so much of what you do, if not all, is what I look for in a reviewer.
Thanks! I appreciate that!
The Newage figure is really fun to transform, I'm looking forward to the Magic Square version.
Some great posing there man!! Nice review!!
Thank you! Great articulation on both figures.
MS-B46, hands down the best G1 incarnation of Prime - which is what I want. I absolutely love him!
Agreed, and hope you get yours soon!
Incredible comparing video. Thank you for making this video! It helped me a lot to decide which Prime to get. 🙂
Glad it was helpful! And hope you get your Prime soon!
@@OptimusLegends Thanks! Already pre-ordered with a Megatron. 😁
I finally got MS Prime!!! 😁 It's so good that I had only one problem with the heads not being removable, but I was able to pop the heads in and out several times, and now my problem is gone. No breakage, not much paint chip, and so much fun. It's truly just Prime. 😀
And Optimus Legends, thank you so much for your seperate MS Prime video, it helped me a lot to transform the figure the first time.
For me its Magic Square B46. It’s the action poses…I don’t like the look of the David when looking down from the top. The chest makes a weird line right under the chin. Love the clean look of B46!
Magic Square definitely has it. Better looks, better articulation, no faux parts.
Agreed. Especially no faux parts.
I have both. Newage had the better presentation, better materials and fun transformation. And it feels premium.
Also I’m gonna give it too B46 I prefer the classic design and it looks smoother in my opinion by a lot
Just got the newage h27 and I absolutely love him. The 1 I got doesn't have the metal spine but I still love him...them...I actually bought 2 from Ebay on sale. Now...I wanna get this dude. Lol
Hi Cody, enjoy your new Optimus!
Magic Square probably is not going to do it but I would love to see them making the G1 toy accurate version just like David 27EX, that would look amazing
How did you get the repair bay for MS Optimus?
aside the knee joint i greatly prefer magic square over new age
Knee joint of b46 make the leg look like it break in half
really wish they make mp scale to fix this problem
Oh i think if they go for extreme cartoon arcurate they can remove some truck detail to get a cleanner bot mode
I guess in legend scale it will be rather difficult to manage a better sculpt for the knees, and agreed, by scaling up, there should be a better solution.
Not sure how many repaint would come out, they are sharing the same mold and truck details I guess.
If it wasn’t for magic square’s plastic, I’d pick Magic Square’s offering over Newage. But as long as they continue with this plastic and that finish, I’m always gonna choose Newage over Magic Square.
That kamehameha pose though. Never knew I needed to see that.
They both look great but I think personally for me Magic Square has the better figure. Might get that sometime.
Edit: Upon further viewing, the NewAge figure does have positives too. Kinda wish we could combine the positives to get a figure with the best of both.
Awesome. Thanks for the review. The Magic Square B46 looks amazing!
Thanks for watching! And really glad you like the video.
I remember when you reviewed the magic square Optimus, he didn’t have the Bay station but now you have it? Because I bought the no-bay version day 1 and I want to know where to get the Bay
Hi Knight, it's a separate 5 dollar purchase, it's available at most stores who carry B46, they just sell them separately for the production issues on the repairing bay.
ordering a magic square soon.
I picked Magic Square because the transformation doesn’t involve faux parts.
I've been waiting on Magic Square to get B-46 back in stock and they finally did. Ordered immediately as I love the toon accuracies. I have the Masterpiece scale of Optimus Prime and Nemesis Prime as well and they're fantastic. This little guy is just as good but way smaller and with a trailer. I love NewAge version, especially the premium look and paint but that chest kills it for me. That's probably the only reason I didn't buy him. A year later and now I have NewAge David and sold my Magic Square. The plastic was just so flimsy that it felt very cheap. Still think MS does it better but chose the premium quality of NewAge over accuracies and cheap unpainted plastics.
Does the trailer of newage Can enter in the magic square optimus ?
This is the the review I was waiting for. Good job as always I can say even if you are new to the game. Thank you very much
Glad you enjoyed it, dom! Hope you get your favorite Prime!
I am sad I can't pick the og b46 up cuz b46e has no axe or extra hands
For my money I split the difference. Got the regular h27 and also bought ms46b scourge to get the best of both worlds. Plus the antagonist aspect of it all.
Good choices, Nemesis won't let you down.
I like both the same, although I might get the recolored version of magic square optimus
So do we have to buy the repairing station separately for the Magic Square ver. ?
No Gundam, the new re-release would include the repairing station, coming in June.
Magic square one is just perfect wow!
great comparison....magic square for me on this one...
Thanks! Good choice.
I don't know about anyone else,but I'd go with magic square MS-B46 Optimus. He's cleaner,and more cartoon accurate. The new age on the other hand is just ok. To many gaps in vehicle mode and the foe chest wind shield is my biggest grip. And its not as clean in robot mode as magic square B46. The things I do like about new age is the paint detail and new age did go for the traditional 80's G1 look. But all in all I prefer the magic square B46.
Nice vids anyway @optimus legends do you think there will be bigger scale like earthrise scale of this G1 accurate model? I really like MAGIC SQUARE but i find the scale small
Thanks!
MS and NA have their own scales, smaller than the official lines, maybe you can try MFT? Slightly larger scale.
I feel like this review sums up every Newage and Magic Square figure.
B46 is my second Magic Square figure, I used to collect NewAge without a second thought, until MS Hound came out, masterpiece mindset for designing legend scale figures.
Thank you so much for this review :)
Glad you liked it!
Whelp this didn’t help me at all, because now I bought both!
NewAge's toy deco is superb. Just gorgeous. Magic Square's is definitely better on the cartoon side. Legends scale collectors continue to win in either case here.
Very true, I just realized it only recently as I was reviewing these legend scale figures, that we could get back to the fun we used to have when we were kids playing with transformer toys, we never cared about paint chipping, we didn't have to pay extra attention and try not to break this delicate piece, we know nothing about engineering or materials, we just fumbled with this thing, flipped between modes and had fun.
A huge difference between collecting MPs and legends.
Absolutely love your videos. Thanks for the thorough comparison.
Thanks Mr. Bawk! Hope it's useful!
It’s 2024. Magic Square just released a new repaint as MS-B46A with metallic paint and vivid blue windshields. I have payed for mine already.
Does it come with a jet pack?
@@johnstrife7nope :(
@@saanyoun that's the only thing I want from the previous versions of this mold, axe, gun and the jetpack
@@johnstrife7 it’s a repaint reissue, with blaster, axe, replacement smokestacks. No new hands, no trailer, no jetpack.
Maybe hoping for MS premium color version? =)
Yeah, it should come, hope sooner than later.
The bs46 IS THE 2.0 VERSION for $80 !! It is important to note that. There is another “repaint” version that is $50 on showzstore and THAT IS NOT THE ONE IS THIS VIDEO!!
I have all of the Newage prime versions and ultra Magnus recolours, and I just bought the Magic Square Nemisis v2.0. I have to say Magic Square wins this one for me.
First of all, for cartoon accuracy, there is no comparison. Magic square version is also more clean in my opinion, less transformation joints and gaps etc in both modes. It has virtually no faux parts, except for the front fender/hip, even the gas tank transforms into the larger gas tank, which is very clever. I never liked the back end of the Newage prime's truck mode, just does not look right and the upper cover doesn't lock into position when you try to lift it.
As a toy, I also find I enjoyed play with Magic Square a lot more, the material is very tough and I was not afraid to use force. It is virtually indestructible. The Newage design has a flaw, the screws go lose all my versions on the front wheel arc part. I also found that some paint on the silver parts of the waist got rubbed off after a few days of play and transformation. Usually I find Newage gives better transformation experience than magic square for most of their transformers. This is not the case for Optimus. The tabs on the H27 (and variants)'s legs are way too tight, almost impossible to transform if you don't have strong finger nails, fingers feel painful afterwards. Overall I find transforming Magic Square prime much more pleasant experience.
Overall, QC issues aside (Newage has better QC), I feel Magic Square takes this one with a healthy margin. For Newage to catch up in their 2.0 release I think they need to redesign.
Thanks for a mini review, the points are spot on.
Like many fans said, H27 is more of an Ultra Magnus design, rather than a Prime dedicated mold, I guess it makes sense.
NA used to be my go to brand for legend scale figures, but a few of their recent designs fell behind, especially when I was exploring the Devastator options, I was shocked how NA could release a set like that, hope they could get back to the old NA that fans love, maybe with a 2.0 Optimus.
@@OptimusLegends Totally agree. When I started collecting legends it ALL NewAge. Then a few MS crept in, and now, months later, it's 90% Magic Square. In my opinion their recent releases have almost entirely surpassed their NA counterparts - even with the oft-criticised choice of plastic (which i've never understood). What a time to be a legend collector!
still without Ex color magic square prime wins!! in terms of accuracy, design, articulation, quality and durability . nylon doesnt break easily and no paint chipping
Many people don't like the look and feel of nylon, but if that doesn't bother you, this Prime is just simply the best one.
Get both! MS for cartoon and NA ex for toy
Yeah.. that's what I thought.. but have to have another transformation double for ex, really don't want to sacrifice the paintwork for transformation.
What are the big Optimus at 7:30?
Magic square MS-01 and MP-44
What a beauty of figures. Too bad I didn't know them before. If I did I would only collect those. Better than the masterpiece and the size I like. 💜
Hi Daya, they are new products came out early this year, and they showed how much transformer figures improved.
Thanks for the comparison! Did you have to apply your own decals?
Thanks! And yes, they didn't come with faction logos.
@@OptimusLegends Where'd you get your stickers from?
@@OEAgent01 I got it from a Hasbro authorized company called Ocean Design, I think their logos are more accurate.
Have you considered reviewing Agamemnon EX?
Hi Bonnie, I definitely will put him in the plan, at the moment I have 3 other bots in the queue, if Magic Square Jazz didn't come out too soon.
@@OptimusLegends Haha ok, good luck on those!
@@toybonniesfm Thanks!
Magic square
Good choice!
Both figures scale well with Devastator or Bruticus
I love your videos!! Keep up the work
Thank you!! Will do!
How tall is the MS in CM?
About 12-13 cm.
I think the B27F but with the thighs/crotch/ribs painted slightly metallic like the EX and the head sculpt of the B46 would be damn near perfect.
Where can I buy these?
NewAge should be more available, MS is currently being sold without the repairing station for its flaws, the re-release comes out in June.
Where can you buy the magic square Optimus prime ?
It's available for pre-order in most online stores, comes out in June.
I prefer the MS one mainly because I can’t get over how the newages chest looks with that weird faux chest. They’re both good, but that chest puts me off.
I just orders the new Optimus Prime figure from Newage (David) and that trailer is more cartoon accurate then the version you showed in this video, i gues you don't have the new one yet so it's a unfair competition. I would have liked Magic Square figures if they would use paint but they don't, so Newage is the winner for me.
Yes, the major reason that drives fans away from MS is the material and paint, it does not look premium.
NewAge is a very good option too.
I like the fact that b46 doesn't look like an action figure he looks like he jumped out of the screen and into my hands and it's more clean than newage's primethe only bummer of b46 is the line on the truck mode it's not accurate so I might just remove it
You lucky and happy bastard.
Why are you comparing to the NA EX? I think the MS is going for the Heroic chest look a bit, so it’s proportions are not “better”. That’s complete opinion. One can not say one looks definitely more proportionate. The lack of a transparent chest on the MS is killing it for me. I don’t like their materials, and I agree that it looks kind of cheap.