The question: 'were they created by nothing or were they their own creators' is a loaded question (like the question when did you stop beating your wife), it assumes: that those who do not believe in Allah, may think that everything came from nothing and also assumes an act of creation as the only option. The better question would just be 'does the universe have a creator?' We don't know enough about the universe, and only in recent times have come to understand somethings about space and time. It can easily also be said that the universe is where the buck stops as the necessary entity. When we look at things we observe we see matter just changing form, nothing really has a beginning or end. Energy is neither created nor destroyed.
Brother Yusuf, in spite of their fallacies and swearing out some sahabes we still accept Iran as a muslim country. Because they take sahadah. We should not be too strict. Allah will decide about them in the thereafter. But some of the Shias (Nusayries and gulaths) do not believe Allah CC and Mohammed PBUH, and believe that Hz Ali as a propheth or Allah, they are kâfir and not muslim. Their 12th imam belief is a hurafah and wrong. There are some differences in the worshipping. May Allah give them hidayah.
Do you base anything you just said from the Quran and Sunnah? I'm an iranian Muslim revert believing in the true Sunnah and follow the Salaf. The shia reject over 40% of all authentic hadiths and commit Shirk through calling upon the dead in prayer.
I would advise you read about the beliefs of the twelver Shia in Iran. Concerning their worshiping Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Hussain رضي الله عنهم. Also ascribing knowledge of the unseen to the family of the prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم and their imams. Also the cursing of the companions رضي الله عنهم. It is important that a person is aware of the Shia before defending them.
@@YusufHaamid-ck5mc I am not defending the Shiaits but telling the fatva of ahli sunnah for them. I am a Sunni. İf they accept the 6 pillar of emaan and 5 pillar of İslam they are muslim. We have to accept this.
We must understand that swearing and cursing the companions. Is cursing those who Allah has praised and is pleased with. Those who the prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم loved. Those who spread and conveyed the whole of Islam to mankind. Also they don’t stop at cursing the companions, declare many of the companions as apostates and disbelievers.
Nowadays it is a "fashionable trend" among "some" Iranian youth to claim they are athetist, agnostic, anything except muslim.
The question: 'were they created by nothing or were they their own creators' is a loaded question (like the question when did you stop beating your wife), it assumes: that those who do not believe in Allah, may think that everything came from nothing and also assumes an act of creation as the only option. The better question would just be 'does the universe have a creator?'
We don't know enough about the universe, and only in recent times have come to understand somethings about space and time. It can easily also be said that the universe is where the buck stops as the necessary entity.
When we look at things we observe we see matter just changing form, nothing really has a beginning or end. Energy is neither created nor destroyed.
Does the energy have knowledge, ability and intent?
@@YusufHaamid-ck5mc have you not studied any physics at school? Energy is not a person!
Smh it’s always the Iranians
Brother Yusuf, in spite of their fallacies and swearing out some sahabes we still accept Iran as a muslim country. Because they take sahadah. We should not be too strict. Allah will decide about them in the thereafter. But some of the Shias (Nusayries and gulaths) do not believe Allah CC and Mohammed PBUH, and believe that Hz Ali as a propheth or Allah, they are kâfir and not muslim. Their 12th imam belief is a hurafah and wrong. There are some differences in the worshipping. May Allah give them hidayah.
Do you base anything you just said from the Quran and Sunnah? I'm an iranian Muslim revert believing in the true Sunnah and follow the Salaf. The shia reject over 40% of all authentic hadiths and commit Shirk through calling upon the dead in prayer.
I would advise you read about the beliefs of the twelver Shia in Iran. Concerning their worshiping Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Hussain رضي الله عنهم.
Also ascribing knowledge of the unseen to the family of the prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم and their imams.
Also the cursing of the companions رضي الله عنهم.
It is important that a person is aware of the Shia before defending them.
Iran is a countr5 full of apostates, its not a Muslim country.
@@YusufHaamid-ck5mc I am not defending the Shiaits but telling the fatva of ahli sunnah for them. I am a Sunni. İf they accept the 6 pillar of emaan and 5 pillar of İslam they are muslim. We have to accept this.
We must understand that swearing and cursing the companions. Is cursing those who Allah has praised and is pleased with. Those who the prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم loved. Those who spread and conveyed the whole of Islam to mankind.
Also they don’t stop at cursing the companions, declare many of the companions as apostates and disbelievers.