Exactly this, I have watched about 10 different ones and while majority do say it could have imploded this was the only man to be honest and say look rescue is practically impossible even if theyre alive which is what was on my mind to begin with.
David Pogue is a legend. Former technology reporter for the New York Times, former columnist for Scientific American, presenter for many episodes of Nova. He is a superb addition to CBS News Sunday Morning.
Yes that is very true. I saw his piece when he went down and I thought “holy crow” very glad he didn’t have troubles and wish nobody did. God this is awful
I am a researcher involved in making sonar / communications instruments for these types of vehicles. I vividly remember my lab looking at the Titan and thinking it was a disaster waiting to happen...they didn't adhere to the established safety standards seen on other such submersibles such as WHOI's alvin
It sounds like that even if they are alive there’s no plan in place to actually retrieve them since there aren’t many subs that are prepared to go that deep for a rescue. That’s absolutely crazy. Why would someone have something like this with no resources for a possible rescue?
@@dazzaboy04how much would a sub that could do some rescue like that even weigh? I'm guessing more than those tanks they put in military choppers. Can something be modified to tow the submersible even find it?
You aren't getting rescued from 13k feet under the water. It isn't happening. No military sub can even get close to that deep. What are you going to use? The vehicles that go that deep have little tiny maneuvering propellers.
@@gametime2473 they're only chance is if they somehow re-surfaced. Even if they did, it would still be hard to find them. People don't realize how vast the oceans are. They could be hundreds of miles from the point where they were initially submerged.
He explained all this very well: basically, they're searching for the sub on the surface only because if the occupants are still alive on the ocean floor near the Titanic, they will certainly die there, in which case future dives to the Titanic will be seeing a second, smaller wreck cotaining five skeletons at the site.
@@khalidelgazzar I believe the original commenter assumed a situation where the Titan hadn't imploded but just sat helpless but otherwise intact on the ocean floor.
@@khalidelgazzar Yeah, although it's crazy to hear David Pogue basically spell out the Titan's fate long before it was made official. All that hope was completely fake in the first place. I imagine it must have been a difficult decision for the Coast Guard to even move out when they already knew perfectly well (via the US Navy) that the submersible had imploded. I would have wanted to see that press conference, with some rear admiral basically going all Michael Falk on the assembled audience (referring to the Onion News "obviously dead hikers" video) :D
It failed the first time……. But a couple days later he was actually onboard a successful trip to the titanic wreck….. it’s actually on UA-cam and it ends with him talking about the next trip being “this summer” meaning this man missed death by one trip 😳
If I get in an elevator too quickly I have a panic attack. I can’t even begin to imagine the heart stopping claustrophobia I would feel when they closed the hatch and started bolting it closed. I would rather jump out of a plane with no parachute than spend even 5 seconds at the bottom of the sea floor in a dark cold coffin with 4 other people waiting to asphyxiate. Let’s hope for all their sake that it imploded at depth and they all died in a nanosecond
I was just telling my dad last week about how people pay money to go view the wreck and how stupid you’d have to be. I can’t believe a week later this happens.
Well after hearing that I think the kindest thing would be it imploded for all of them, being stuck at that depth unable to be rescued and eventually running out of air isn't a good way to go. Thoughts with the families
Yeah this was my thought exactly. I couldn’t imagine being stuck at the bottom of the ocean for 96 hours, huddled inside this tiny thing with 4 strangers and nothing to do except wait to die..I wouldn’t wish that on anyone.
Actually being alive at the bottom would be a blessing. This would give them enough time to pray to God, confess their sins and repent. So they square things up with him before they get to meet him. If they die before purifying their souls then it's not so good a thing. We all will face our mortality. The desire should not be on how we die. But more on how we leave to be received by him.
i think theres non 5 mile cord? the other thing i was wondering was why doesnt it have sattellite communication. if it did, you would know whether it was at the surface or not.
At 6:00 something chilling went down my spine. He spoke about the truth and it is scary and sad at the same time! It's terrifying to imagine what the 5 men went through and what their families are going through right now!
They wouldn't have felt it because it was instantaneous. The human body could not survive those depths. Their bodies woulda been crushed from the pressure. In the same way that if you were in space without protective equipment, the lack of pressure would do the oppossite and instantly pop your blood vessels. That makes recovering the bodies out of the question. Their bodies woulda been mangled at that depth.
@@SpaceRanger187 those are dirt poor people in need fleeing from grave danger. If you are comparing them to filthy rich idiots seeking out a thrill, you are a pathetic excuse for a human.
I hope these high risk adventure companies have insurance to cover the costs of rescues associated with their expensive trips. It is probably costing millions to search for these people. May they be found safe soon.
I wish we could say the same that it costs billions and billions to rebuild states hurricane areas with construction and typologies that don't hold up to the weather.
Rich folk should post bonds prior to departure, for their rescue efforts. I'm at work while these douches are in a submarine, messing around at the Titanic? Their estates can cover the tab.
As someone who worked in insurance for years, I can confidently tell you that no insurer would EVER touch this with a 39.5 foot pole. Not even a specialty insurer like Lloyd's. You couldn't even price the risk.
Strange and eerie how the Titanic was considered unsinkable and now we have a Titan that was thought to be unsinkable as well. I'd say there is some strange related energy around these two oceanic vehicles.
At least if it was a catastrophic failure, it would be instant death without much thought or suffering. Even at only 2/3 the way to the wreck, that's still 3500psi of pressure.
@@megannoe2057 Nope... hopefully it was catastrophic failure, and not a slow pinhole leak or just loss of power and sinking, sitting at the bottom. Ugh.
0:41 Boeing, NASA and UW have said that they had nothing to do with the engineering on the pressure vessel itself or any checks on engineering. He (Stockton Rush) basically lied about all that.
I'm a diver. The Titanic is a Grave, not a tourist attraction. And now she has claimed 5 more. I am 99.9% sure that She imploded. God bless them. it was painless.
The wealthy individuals who can afford to spend $250k on a journey have willingly put themselves in that position, fully aware of the risks involved. It's comparable to paragliding where, if you happen to fall, you understand that as a human being, you're meant to be on the ground and not in the air like a bird.
This is a very sad and scary situation. The crew of the Titan and their families are in my thoughts. It's worrying that the submarine hasn't come back up yet, even though it has many ways to do so. The idea that the submarine might be stuck at the bottom of the sea or that it might have broken apart is really scary. They only have four days of air, and two days have already passed. Finding and saving the crew will be hard. The submarine is very deep and not many machines can go that far down. Also, the submarine can't be opened from the inside which makes things harder. We hope for the best, but this shows how risky deep-sea exploration can be. It reminds us how powerful the ocean is and how brave the people are who explore it. Prayers🙏
Were your thoughts with the families of the 300 people that died in the Mediterranean earlier this month? or are your thoughts just with the rich and privileged?
David Pogue says his trip only went 37 feet down and then there was a mechanical problem and had to get hoisted back up. That should have been the first and last warning for the CEO Rush Stockton.
It really shouldn't be though. They didn't even have a third party inspect their equipment. Their only way to communicate with the outside world is an emergency sandbag. So many needless risks.
bro this sub is like an highschool project so many loopholes and he even sugarcoated it well wtf the fact that it doesn't have enough safety features for each situation is legit dumb. experimenting with lives RIP
Really? Man and here I was trying to hike Mount Everest only with a hoody,football cleats and a gallon of water for precaution but you've changed my mind
I have almost no appreciation for what the main street media says, but this man saying that all these high level adventures are dangerous, is a great statement. Add climbing Mt. Everest.
Why anyone would climb inside -- let alone be bolted into -- this claustrophobic-inducing box is beyond me. What happens if you develop leg cramps, have a medical event, get nauseaus, have a panic attack, etc.? There is nothing anyone can do to help you until several hours later at the earliest. I think people who choose to do this type of thing are off their rockers.
The BBC's documentary, all 43 minutes of going submersible with this actual one. They had problems with the controller and instead of forwards/backwards it was going round in circles. This looks like a disaster that was waiting to happen.
The news keeps saying they have this many hours of air left but with a electrical failure the scrubbers on the sub wont work and without the scrubbers theres no breathable air
@@Zed-qk2vt That is what they always say...just to be kind to the family...look up submarine deaths and how they were found...it's like being buried alive...slow leak slow death...
@@Zed-qk2vt Honestly, I think some or all are already dead just from the pure terror of being in the dark knowing that you are going to die and you are leaving sons and daughters behind. It would be hard not to go into a panick attack and then cardiac arrest. I feel very sorry for them.
Super rich people can't even let the dead rest in peace. They have to go down there and knock. So the ghosts have finally opened the door and said "come on in". Ghost: We'll they keep on insisting and insisting....
(4:22) "co-designed with NASA & UW-APL" The hull that failed was built in 2020 by Electroimpact and Janicki Industries in Seattle and designed with Collier Aerospace's Hyperx FEA software all subcontractors to OceanGate. NASA and UW-APL did not design the hull that failed, Pogue is simply regurgitating Rush's egregious name-drops. Do some journalism David, please.
I don’t get it. It’s not like they were gonna be able to get out of this death trap and walk around the titanic. They could have seen it on the same documentary I saw.
So sad. I so hope the out come is a good one prayer for the passengers on board this submersible. Prayers for peace of mind for the families that wait for the miracle they deserve 🙏 ❤️
That's kind of a silly question imo when she asked him why don't they send something down there to look for them . What can they send they're deep in the waters of the ocean.Even he seemed baffled when she asked that.
People really act like this is standard procedure and common practice driving 12,000 ft into the ocean. Why didn’t they just send another team down to grab the vessel? Because there is only ONE vessel in existence and even if there were two this thing weighs 10 tons and cannot be brought back up
Because it is 😂😂 they have made this trip regularly to the titanic for the last 40 years. They have made thousands of similar journeys not to titanic but at other places. Every time they have all come back up safe and sound. This is a one of freak incident There isn’t only one. The UK has five subs which are more than capable. The problem is they are not on sight. And america being america of course we are holding everything up instead of allowing the people who are skilled in this stuff to take charge
Apparently they aren't that smart to not build an emergency beacon or noisemaker countermeasures is just amazing. It should be equipped with a horn at the minimum.
You would think that they would have a cable hooked to the ship to the submersible, just in case something like this happens? I’m thinking it cracked under the tremendous pressure, and it exploded and crushed.
that's actually very unlikely, we really have pressure vessels down at this point, and, as sketchy as the Titan is, it's a good pressure vessel. There's a chance that some part of it flooded, though even then, that would likely just damage the electronics. If they weren't able to float to the surface, then the most likely scenarios is actually just them stuck at the bottom of the ocean, or drifting thousands of feet underwater, waiting to die.
@@hunterra217 at that depth if a gasket in the hatch failed, even just a tiny hole, the interior would fill up with water so fast that releasing all of the ballast would not allow it to float back up to the surface. as the water enters it compresses the air inside the sub to the point where the high pressure crushes the crew to death before they can drown.
@@hunterra217 they said they lost contact, an hour an 45 minutes into the dive? An expert who made the journey in the same submersible claimed it takes about 2 hours and 15 minutes to reach the bottom. So something must have happened before they reached the bottom? If it was the power that went out, they would have immediately used their manual method of reaching the surface? If they have they must be bobbing in the waves and they have no way of opening the hatch? And that’s the best scenario!
@@joemasse4568 I'd agree except previous riders and some staff have confirmed that losing contact at those depths is basically normal for this craft, that's why it took many hours before anything was reported. Really anything could have happened, you're right that that's the best case scenario, though that would be a horrible way to go, slowly suffocating to death like that.
The company just released a statement: Near, far, wherever you are I believe that the heart does go on Once more you open the door And you're here in my heart And my heart will go on and on
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
That dude gave the most real response I’ve ever heard. I need to see more of him.
Exactly this, I have watched about 10 different ones and while majority do say it could have imploded this was the only man to be honest and say look rescue is practically impossible even if theyre alive which is what was on my mind to begin with.
How refreshing to see someone with intelligence on morning news speak clearly and knowledgeably.
one of the best reporters out there.
That "dude" is a legend. No wonder he was Steve Jobs's favorite media guy.
Edit: Alongside Walt Mossberg, of course
David Pogue is a legend. Former technology reporter for the New York Times, former columnist for Scientific American, presenter for many episodes of Nova. He is a superb addition to CBS News Sunday Morning.
Who in their right mind willingly pays $250k to get in something like that?
I would, but not on the first trips. Maybe a year later when hundreds have gone. dude u only live once, your not going to live forever
@@SpaceRanger187 yeah. Be a horrible death for me ...a watery grave is the worst way to die for me. So go ahead
Tax the rich-its for their own good
@@Thecrazyvaclav look up the amount of trash and ish those selfish and bored jerks leave at Everest.
They are probably thinking that right now!!!
He basically said they’re gone without actually saying it. Always keep hope but remain realistic
❣❣❣❣❣
That's right bro! :(
he also said that in his trip they lost communication but reestablished the connection?
Best not to sugar coat in these circumstances & be realistic
Right!!!
david is good at explaining things.
And laid it out straight, saying what others don't want to
Good that they have someone who has actually been on the sub.
yes definitely
Yes that is very true. I saw his piece when he went down and I thought “holy crow” very glad he didn’t have troubles and wish nobody did.
God this is awful
Lol he was dumb enough to get in that thing. He should be counting his blessings.
This guy didn't sugar coat the seriousness of this situation.
’’even if they are found, they can’t be rescued’’
RIP all!
unless they're found on the surface, which is really the best case scenario.
guess they should stop looking
i watched it 3 times. beautifully articulate. a true art form. David Pogue is the man
The impenetrable hull meets the unsinkable ship. Hubris garners the same rewards.
I am a researcher involved in making sonar / communications instruments for these types of vehicles. I vividly remember my lab looking at the Titan and thinking it was a disaster waiting to happen...they didn't adhere to the established safety standards seen on other such submersibles such as WHOI's alvin
That's interesting! What do you think happened?
By the way thay explain the sub its astonishing it was allowed to actually go ahead. Would love to see the papers they signed...
Exactly, The Alvin has an awesome emergency separation mechanism that would automatically surface which the Titan does not.
@@natalieluke8148 It's a private craft in international waters. Who would have the authority to say they can't go ahead?
I'm also curious what do you think went wrong so that they lost communication and didn't surface.
It sounds like that even if they are alive there’s no plan in place to actually retrieve them since there aren’t many subs that are prepared to go that deep for a rescue. That’s absolutely crazy. Why would someone have something like this with no resources for a possible rescue?
It's not just that. The vehicles capable of getting down there take weeks to prepare. They don't have weeks. They have 40 hours
@@dazzaboy04 I was including that when I said “prepared”.
@@dazzaboy04how much would a sub that could do some rescue like that even weigh? I'm guessing more than those tanks they put in military choppers. Can something be modified to tow the submersible even find it?
You aren't getting rescued from 13k feet under the water. It isn't happening. No military sub can even get close to that deep. What are you going to use? The vehicles that go that deep have little tiny maneuvering propellers.
@@gametime2473 they're only chance is if they somehow re-surfaced. Even if they did, it would still be hard to find them. People don't realize how vast the oceans are. They could be hundreds of miles from the point where they were initially submerged.
When he said they were bolted in from the outside I was like bruh this is not a submarine not even a 'submersible'. It's a carbon-fibre coffin 💀💀
Exactly.
Enough for me when they close the plane's door. To be bolted from outside, no way!
Maybe I'm naive but is that 'normal' for egress from a submersible to require external help? 😳
He explained all this very well: basically, they're searching for the sub on the surface only because if the occupants are still alive on the ocean floor near the Titanic, they will certainly die there, in which case future dives to the Titanic will be seeing a second, smaller wreck cotaining five skeletons at the site.
Unfortunately there will be no skeletons. The pressure is 400X and that's so huge that nothing will be left. That's sad but true.
@@khalidelgazzar I believe the original commenter assumed a situation where the Titan hadn't imploded but just sat helpless but otherwise intact on the ocean floor.
@@CC3GROUNDZERO yeah. Got it. That comment was placed while the search was still in progress.
Five skeletons, Buckrolly? Ugh. So stupid. 🤦♀️
@@khalidelgazzar Yeah, although it's crazy to hear David Pogue basically spell out the Titan's fate long before it was made official. All that hope was completely fake in the first place. I imagine it must have been a difficult decision for the Coast Guard to even move out when they already knew perfectly well (via the US Navy) that the submersible had imploded. I would have wanted to see that press conference, with some rear admiral basically going all Michael Falk on the assembled audience (referring to the Onion News "obviously dead hikers" video) :D
I find 3 people interviewing one person somewhat chaotic. Very insightful answers though.
Someone finally said it: "if we find them, there is no way to rescue them."
You can tell that he's glad that his adventure failed in 35 minutes versus what's happening now.
right?!
It failed the first time……. But a couple days later he was actually onboard a successful trip to the titanic wreck….. it’s actually on UA-cam and it ends with him talking about the next trip being “this summer” meaning this man missed death by one trip 😳
My claustrophobia would never allow me to be in that vehicle. Hoping they find it.
If I get in an elevator too quickly I have a panic attack. I can’t even begin to imagine the heart stopping claustrophobia I would feel when they closed the hatch and started bolting it closed. I would rather jump out of a plane with no parachute than spend even 5 seconds at the bottom of the sea floor in a dark cold coffin with 4 other people waiting to asphyxiate. Let’s hope for all their sake that it imploded at depth and they all died in a nanosecond
Me either. You can't even sit up normally. I would start panicking the second they closed the hatch.
Sounds like a five man casket at the bottom of ocean
I knew that I had seen this before. David Pogue did a very good job on the original story and is being very professional in his response here.
I m not certain about
Really?
6:47 Even Gayle King shook her head on stoopid this floating and submerging mechanism in this thing
I was just telling my dad last week about how people pay money to go view the wreck and how stupid you’d have to be. I can’t believe a week later this happens.
These are supposed to be the smart people?!
I'll look at the pics and stay on Terra firma
can you tell your dad that a random guy who replied to your comment become super rich and live happily ever after and livid a happy long life ?
I had no idea people were doing this.
You can send a vessel down without people, just a camera and then watch the video on your TV while sitting on the couch.
Well after hearing that I think the kindest thing would be it imploded for all of them, being stuck at that depth unable to be rescued and eventually running out of air isn't a good way to go. Thoughts with the families
Agreed
Yeah this was my thought exactly. I couldn’t imagine being stuck at the bottom of the ocean for 96 hours, huddled inside this tiny thing with 4 strangers and nothing to do except wait to die..I wouldn’t wish that on anyone.
Actually being alive at the bottom would be a blessing. This would give them enough time to pray to God, confess their sins and repent. So they square things up with him before they get to meet him. If they die before purifying their souls then it's not so good a thing. We all will face our mortality. The desire should not be on how we die. But more on how we leave to be received by him.
@@arttorrez5548 Lol
The fact that it's not tethered to the main ship is unbelievable to me. Why was it not tethered???
i think theres non 5 mile cord? the other thing i was wondering was why doesnt it have sattellite communication. if it did, you would know whether it was at the surface or not.
@@NguyenPham-ru6ncNo problem at all to get 5000m line on special order, only money is needed…
@@NguyenPham-ru6nc not working under water
Not tethered because it restricts movement of craft, one "expert" said.
@@NguyenPham-ru6nc Satellite and radio waves do not work under water. Definitely not that far under water.
The most honest words I've heard yet. Thank you!!
Titanic is still taking casualties 100 years later
Don’t blame it on her 😂
The Titanic was never blamed. It has always been hubris and irresponsibility of people.
96 hours is awfully short duration for getting lost so deep in water.
At 6:00 something chilling went down my spine. He spoke about the truth and it is scary and sad at the same time! It's terrifying to imagine what the 5 men went through and what their families are going through right now!
They wouldn't have felt it because it was instantaneous. The human body could not survive those depths. Their bodies woulda been crushed from the pressure. In the same way that if you were in space without protective equipment, the lack of pressure would do the oppossite and instantly pop your blood vessels. That makes recovering the bodies out of the question. Their bodies woulda been mangled at that depth.
@@DibIrken
They became liquid in a fraction of a second.
What a great interview, no nonsense, clear and precise answers, the way it should always be
I agree - I’ve been Down a Titan rabbit hole for days and it was refreshing to hear him speak plainly and honestly w non scientific jargon.
If they`re rescued alive, make them pay all rescue expenses, they`re all filthy rich.
No you and me will foot that bill
what about the millions spent rescuing illegals
they're extremely dead
@@SpaceRanger187 those are dirt poor people in need fleeing from grave danger. If you are comparing them to filthy rich idiots seeking out a thrill, you are a pathetic excuse for a human.
@@SpaceRanger187 Illegals are usually fleeing from dure circumstances, and, bottom line, they don't have the ability to pay.
4:20 there’s a statement that didn’t age well.
Never have I ever been glad I'm broke.. I hope they are all okay.
I hope these high risk adventure companies have insurance to cover the costs of rescues associated with their expensive trips. It is probably costing millions to search for these people. May they be found safe soon.
I wish we could say the same that it costs billions and billions to rebuild states hurricane areas with construction and typologies that don't hold up to the weather.
Rich folk should post bonds prior to departure, for their rescue efforts. I'm at work while these douches are in a submarine, messing around at the Titanic? Their estates can cover the tab.
As someone who worked in insurance for years, I can confidently tell you that no insurer would EVER touch this with a 39.5 foot pole. Not even a specialty insurer like Lloyd's. You couldn't even price the risk.
No there is not. That's why there's a waiver to sign before you even leave the mainland.
What a horrible way to go, may god help them… 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Not gonna happen.
Nah, an implosion is painless and instant. There's many worse ways to
die at sea.
If it imploded, they died before the signal from their brains to their nervous system, even had time to arrive. They did not feel a thing.
No god can or will help them. They pretty much designed that thing so no miracle could happen.
God created this.
As a commercial diver, i'd never get in a sub like this. Nothing short of a Navy boat.
0:38 "we worked with Boeing, and NASA and the University of Washington"
Those are outright lies.
This is so terrifying.
This was THE best explanation & answers on this nightmare...by far.
Thank you, Mr. Pogue.
6:14 She's really having this conversation with the context of "there may have been an explosion." 😂
So stupid. Lack of education.
And still making more than you and living a much better life.
@@krimsonedit3272 That very well could be true. Won't change the fact that she is a silly goose.
I got more info from this video than dozens of other ones I've watched combined. David Pogue is a very interesting and knowledgeable guy.
Strange and eerie how the Titanic was considered unsinkable and now we have a Titan that was thought to be unsinkable as well. I'd say there is some strange related energy around these two oceanic vehicles.
Personally, I would have given it some other name.
Technically the Titan is very much sinkable since it is submersible and supposed to go underwater..
Names can be spooky but Stockton's bragadocious refusal to safety certify the vessel was also a questionable choice.
That "strange related energy" is over confidence and arrogance!!
The titan a submersible was unsinkable? Do you not understand your own comment? 😂
Great interview! It's so informative!
i watched it 3 times. beautifully articulate. a true art form.
At least if it was a catastrophic failure, it would be instant death without much thought or suffering. Even at only 2/3 the way to the wreck, that's still 3500psi of pressure.
They'd have absolutely no idea with that pressure. Shewww.
@@megannoe2057 Nope... hopefully it was catastrophic failure, and not a slow pinhole leak or just loss of power and sinking, sitting at the bottom. Ugh.
Was thinking the same thing. At least it would be instant.
3500 psi....
I think I'd rather that than being lost on the ocean bed in darkness
Only a miracle 🙏🏾
Don't worry - "miracles" are god's stock in trade!
0:41 Boeing, NASA and UW have said that they had nothing to do with the engineering on the pressure vessel itself or any checks on engineering. He (Stockton Rush) basically lied about all that.
Been a huge fan of Mr. Pogue since his Macworld writing. I even read his obscure novel called "Hard Drive". Still have the copy!
I'm a diver. The Titanic is a Grave, not a tourist attraction. And now she has claimed 5 more. I am 99.9% sure that She imploded. God bless them. it was painless.
It’s nice of him to make the rounds and inform people. This is just tragic
The wealthy individuals who can afford to spend $250k on a journey have willingly put themselves in that position, fully aware of the risks involved. It's comparable to paragliding where, if you happen to fall, you understand that as a human being, you're meant to be on the ground and not in the air like a bird.
This is a very sad and scary situation. The crew of the Titan and their families are in my thoughts. It's worrying that the submarine hasn't come back up yet, even though it has many ways to do so.
The idea that the submarine might be stuck at the bottom of the sea or that it might have broken apart is really scary. They only have four days of air, and two days have already passed.
Finding and saving the crew will be hard. The submarine is very deep and not many machines can go that far down. Also, the submarine can't be opened from the inside which makes things harder.
We hope for the best, but this shows how risky deep-sea exploration can be. It reminds us how powerful the ocean is and how brave the people are who explore it. Prayers🙏
There's been a lot of companies go down there over the last 30 years bringing up artifacts if you see in the museum
When prayers are invoked, you know the situation is dire.
Was the risk worth it
Were your thoughts with the families of the 300 people that died in the Mediterranean earlier this month? or are your thoughts just with the rich and privileged?
Would it explode/implode at certain pressures? I think I'd rather that than be lost at the bottom of the Ocean. How scary is that!
Protect this man. He’s such a special person. He has a kind and loving soul.❤
Nobody needs to protect anyone lol being kind and loving is a NORMAL feature of humanity.
Burelson doesn’t get enough credit for asking great questions. Always on top of it.
Miss him in NFL commentary but glad to see him killing it
His presence is pointless at that table. Another black athlete trying to pretend he’s smart and look intellectual lmao
David Pogue says his trip only went 37 feet down and then there was a mechanical problem and had to get hoisted back up. That should have been the first and last warning for the CEO Rush Stockton.
There is a first time for everything for something like this.
It really shouldn't be though. They didn't even have a third party inspect their equipment. Their only way to communicate with the outside world is an emergency sandbag. So many needless risks.
And taking your child with you. Hence the waiver. So sad.
This same thing happened when we tried to go to space, and *will* happen when we try to go to Mars.
06:11 the statement before she asked the question he answered specifically this question....wow
This entire story gives me the creeps so bad 😳 I can’t even imagine being down there in pitch black! Terrifying! Those poor people 💔💔💔💔💔
bro this sub is like an highschool project so many loopholes and he even sugarcoated it well wtf the fact that it doesn't have enough safety features for each situation is legit dumb. experimenting with lives RIP
This is making me reassess my plans to spend two weeks at the center of an erupting volcano.
Really? Man and here I was trying to hike Mount Everest only with a hoody,football cleats and a gallon of water for precaution but you've changed my mind
Lol!
These people wanted the Titanic experience and they got it , literally
I have almost no appreciation for what the main street media says, but this man saying that all these high level adventures are dangerous, is a great statement.
Add climbing Mt. Everest.
Why anyone would climb inside -- let alone be bolted into -- this claustrophobic-inducing box is beyond me. What happens if you develop leg cramps, have a medical event, get nauseaus, have a panic attack, etc.? There is nothing anyone can do to help you until several hours later at the earliest. I think people who choose to do this type of thing are off their rockers.
Yep. Utter madness for the super rich
I want the sub that has titanium walls, not carbon fiber walls.
I always running out batteries from my xbox controller, I’m not making a joke out of this.
James Cameron should use all his resources and knowledge to go looking for them.
The BBC's documentary, all 43 minutes of going submersible with this actual one. They had problems with the controller and instead of forwards/backwards it was going round in circles. This looks like a disaster that was waiting to happen.
I’m glad David has experienced this submarine so we have some insight on what could be happening I feel bad for everyone except the ceo
Yeah the CEO seems to have the same concern with safety as the operator of a pop-up carnival in a parking lot.
That submersible is like a nailed coffin buried at sea.
Wow, this is nuts.
The news keeps saying they have this many hours of air left but with a electrical failure the scrubbers on the sub wont work and without the scrubbers theres no breathable air
Having a breech in the metal and it being crushed inwards like an aluminum can is a horrible death.
It would happen so fast they wouldn’t have a clue
@@Zed-qk2vt That is what they always say...just to be kind to the family...look up submarine deaths and how they were found...it's like being buried alive...slow leak slow death...
@@Zed-qk2vt Honestly, I think some or all are already dead just from the pure terror of being in the dark knowing that you are going to die and you are leaving sons and daughters behind. It would be hard not to go into a panick attack and then cardiac arrest. I feel very sorry for them.
@@Zed-qk2vt Agreed
Five rich people in a lost submersible get more attention than 500 refugees in a sunken ship...
People shouldn't be down there disturbing those souls anyway.
Are the "souls" actually down there, or are they in heaven?
Super rich people can't even let the dead rest in peace. They have to go down there and knock. So the ghosts have finally opened the door and said "come on in".
Ghost: We'll they keep on insisting and insisting....
(4:22) "co-designed with NASA & UW-APL" The hull that failed was built in 2020 by Electroimpact and Janicki Industries in Seattle and designed with Collier Aerospace's Hyperx FEA software all subcontractors to OceanGate. NASA and UW-APL did not design the hull that failed, Pogue is simply regurgitating Rush's egregious name-drops. Do some journalism David, please.
I think there was a breach in the hull And the sub imploded . That means everybody died in a 10th of a second that's why no distress Signal was sent
The controller ran out of battery💀
The Kursk sank in just 100M of water an nobody survived. Unfortunately, I don't think this story will have a happy ending.
I don’t get it. It’s not like they were gonna be able to get out of this death trap and walk around the titanic. They could have seen it on the same documentary I saw.
So sad. I so hope the out come is a good one prayer for the passengers on board this submersible.
Prayers for peace of mind for the families that wait for the miracle they deserve 🙏 ❤️
I hope that prayers for the people in the submersible have more effect than they had for the passengers of the Titanic.
@@Steevee14well the prayers were answered because many survived the Titanic :)
OOPS.......WRONG AGAIN ATHEIST :)
@@kleeamd8274 1) Steevee never said they were an atheist. 2) Over two-thirds of the crew and passengers of the Titanic lost their lives.
@@novaava 1. Their words say everything 2. 700+ survived by God's grace :)
@@kleeamd8274you are totally right. Poseidon works in a mysterious ways 😊. Hope he can help this time also.
How fortunate are we, that David Pogue wasn’t on the recent dive?
"We're mobilizing and exploring all options to bring the crew back safely."
Now if we just knew where they were...
That's kind of a silly question imo when she asked him why don't they send something down there to look for them . What can they send they're deep in the waters of the ocean.Even he seemed baffled when she asked that.
Omg, why would anyone get in there?! Really so sad.
Why would anyone attempt to climb Mt. Everest, where hundreds are known to have died due to exposure to harsh elements.
@@Steevee14 Because it is there.
damn he was 100% right about the implosion
I saw the clip about the sub and how improvised it is. I would never go into that thing. So sad others trusted it.
R.I.P
A drinking game should be made around the number of times Gayle says “whoa” to something she already covered in a previous segment*.
This was the best informational vid I've seen about this
A crushed sub can't surface...
Praying for that miracle!! 🙏🙌
We pray for them to b found n safe . 🙏
At that depth there's no chance they're alive. Even the guy said if they were found there is no way to rescue them.
That man rlly said the easiest explanation I’ve heard so far
People really act like this is standard procedure and common practice driving 12,000 ft into the ocean. Why didn’t they just send another team down to grab the vessel? Because there is only ONE vessel in existence and even if there were two this thing weighs 10 tons and cannot be brought back up
And because they wouldn't even know where to send the rescue vehicle.
Because it is 😂😂 they have made this trip regularly to the titanic for the last 40 years. They have made thousands of similar journeys not to titanic but at other places.
Every time they have all come back up safe and sound. This is a one of freak incident
There isn’t only one. The UK has five subs which are more than capable. The problem is they are not on sight. And america being america of course we are holding everything up instead of allowing the people who are skilled in this stuff to take charge
When reached for comment, OceanGate said "new phone, who dis".
$250K to die like this
Apparently they aren't that smart to not build an emergency beacon or noisemaker countermeasures is just amazing. It should be equipped with a horn at the minimum.
You would think that they would have a cable hooked to the ship to the submersible, just in case something like this happens? I’m thinking it cracked under the tremendous pressure, and it exploded and crushed.
*imploded
that's actually very unlikely, we really have pressure vessels down at this point, and, as sketchy as the Titan is, it's a good pressure vessel. There's a chance that some part of it flooded, though even then, that would likely just damage the electronics. If they weren't able to float to the surface, then the most likely scenarios is actually just them stuck at the bottom of the ocean, or drifting thousands of feet underwater, waiting to die.
@@hunterra217 at that depth if a gasket in the hatch failed, even just a tiny hole, the interior would fill up with water so fast that releasing all of the ballast would not allow it to float back up to the surface. as the water enters it compresses the air inside the sub to the point where the high pressure crushes the crew to death before they can drown.
@@hunterra217 they said they lost contact, an hour an 45 minutes into the dive? An expert who made the journey in the same submersible claimed it takes about 2 hours and 15 minutes to reach the bottom. So something must have happened before they reached the bottom? If it was the power that went out, they would have immediately used their manual method of reaching the surface? If they have they must be bobbing in the waves and they have no way of opening the hatch? And that’s the best scenario!
@@joemasse4568 I'd agree except previous riders and some staff have confirmed that losing contact at those depths is basically normal for this craft, that's why it took many hours before anything was reported. Really anything could have happened, you're right that that's the best case scenario, though that would be a horrible way to go, slowly suffocating to death like that.
Say goodbye to Ocean Gate. The lawsuits are coming. Why no Pinger?
Bolted from the outside,Coffin no thanks RIP❤
Wow, the person who build it also was there right?
Yep. Kind of heavenly justice in the end.
The company just released a statement:
Near, far, wherever you are
I believe that the heart does go on
Once more you open the door
And you're here in my heart
And my heart will go on and on
Not right now.
Its now confirmed implosion happend under the sea. Rest In Peace.
I pray to God they are found soon. I hope for the best.
Maybe the end caps press inwards..but laminated carbon fibre is not designed for compression, only tension.