여기 댓글 올리신 모든샤월분들! 요거는 립싱크 맞는 것 같습니다. 근데 원래 sm그룹들은 컴백하고 일주일동안은 퍼포먼스를 위해 립싱크하고요. 그리고 음악방송, 즉 뮤뱅, 엠카, 음중, 쇼챔에서만 라이브합니다. 왜냐면 매일 음방뛰고 거기에다 요런 행사 비슷한거까지 라이브로하면 다 목상해요,특히 샤이니노래는 고음이 많고 퍼포먼스도 쩔어서 만약 라이브까지하면... 그러니까 샤이니 예쁘게 봐주세요!
라이브네~ 샤이니 아이돌계 라이브 장인이지~ 종현아~ 애 많이 썼어~ 여기저기 해외 스케줄로 샤이니는 해외 콘서트ᆞ 해외 공연ᆞ행사ᆞ각종 예능 등등 해외로만 다니니 다른 연예인들보다 훨씬 더 지치고 힘들었지... 종현아~ 넘 많이 보고 싶고 사랑한다~ 일찍 하늘의 별이 되긴 진짜 아까운 별이야~ 너무 빨리 하늘로 갔네... 안타까워서 ... 종현아 ~ 큰소리로 펑펑 울면서 네 이름을 외쳐도 ... 너를 다신 볼 수 없고.... 항상 열심히 매사에 최선을 다하고 고생만 하다간 종현이..... 이젠 못하겠다고 손 놓고 많이 번 돈으로 여행을 다니면서 새로운 에너지를 여행지에서 받아서 새롭게 좋아하는 음악을 시작 할 수 있었을텐데.... 아깝다...너의 재능과 음악의 대한 열정...사랑한다~♡
Hah~ I love to see that SHINee really can't lip sync correctly~ my babies have an awful lip sync, but that makes me happy idk why. I know they are really tired and this is a really strong and hard performance so, It's fine for them to lip sync they need to rest =). We all know that SHINee is one of the best when it comes to live performances~ Fighting babies!
Yes! We know they can sing it live and a good one. :) It's okay for them to lip sync. They are not doing it always so for me it's ok I know it is hard to dance and sing at the same time and I know they are tired from traveling back and forth from KR to JP. When Jjong threw his mic at the end ... EPIC! XD So fierce :DDD
I love how shawols are so protective x) well, i dont care if they're lipsync or singing live because i knew how awesome are they to even care -.- they're so tired. Poor my babies :'(
omfg i N E V E R get tired of watching their live performances of this song gfajsgagfasd it doesn't matter how many times i watch it, i'm always fangirling hard ;A;
If They "do" that then there must be some reason..We All Know that SHINee is Super Busy Last & This year.. I think They are the busiest Idol from last year..It's like Yesterday - Japan, Today - Korea, Tomorrow - Japan again, the day after - Hongkong, the day after - Korea again, they day after - somewhere again and so on.. THE POINT IS We All know THEY CAN SING WHILE DANCING SOME SONGS IN A ROW WITH STABLE VOICES !! Everyone has acknowledged their Voices..It's just a matter of hectic schedule!!
Are you kidding me what was that at the end why was there no reaction like if I was there I would have screamed so loud 😂😂😂but no all we get is a “Yeah” are you serious 😒
Lipsync or not, as a Shawol we should be able to see the pain of SHINee. They've been flying so much the past year I doubt they've gotten rest between songs. We know SHINee has the skills and the energy to perform live, there's billions of proofs from their debut to now. Plus, SHINee hates to lipsync but if they have to they have to. Only lipsyncing can help protect their vocals for more grand performances. Jonghyun obviously hates lipsync because he rips the mic off to show it was lipsync.
ㅋㅋㅋ 이건 누가봐도 립싱크지.. 노래가 원곡 그대론데 근데 립싱크라서 애들 퍼포를 더 집중해서 볼 수 있는듯 셜록 진짜 극악 안무다.. 동작 이어지는 거나 잔상 남는 거나 무대 곳곳 뛰어다니는 거야 알고 있었지만 하이라이트에서 진기랑 종현이 자리 바꾸는 거 진짜 대단하다 그렇게 뛰면서 퍼포하고 후다닥 자리 바꾸고 다시 뛰고 와... 와중에 기범이 손동작 깔끔한 거랑 표정 너무 셜록 그 자체고 민호 기범이 뛰어넘는 동작도 너무 깔끔하고 진기도 퍼포에 집중했구나, 표정이나 동작이나 영감 영감 아니잖아.. 태민이야 대단했던 거 다 알구.. 알아도 진짜 대단하구.. 태민이가 센터에서 춤 추는 거 보면 너무 짜릿함 역솔남이 우리 그룹 아이돌이에요 부럽죠ㅠㅠ 저 때가 데뷔 4년찬데 얼마나 대단했던 거야 새삼 자랑스럽네.. 고생했어 대단해 사랑해
I personally think this was one of their worst performance, but its still a five star act. Their worst is actually super freaking amazing. Their naturally born entertainers! :D SHINee!!!
then you should know that SHINee need a break! lip sync is our last problem. I want SHINee to take a break before they break! And beside that they sang live during their concert tour, the showcase in Japan and during the japanese music show "Happy Music" and many other concerts. But they will have a comeback in Japan again soon...I'm happy to see new stuff and even more happy because it's a ballad song (an easier choreo and the boys can take a rest) but still...they seriously need a break
are you sure YOU are a fan? Do you even now how busy SHINee lately are? I even doubt that they sleep more than 2 hours a day. I think the last thing we should do is to complain about lip sync
Yes I am, since they were rockies and I was 19, but that doesn't mean I don't have an opinion, I love them and I know they can sing, I'm not saying they should sing every time, but the amount of times they have been lip syncing lately is ridiculous! I just wish that they sing live more often like they used to. Be a fan does not make me a conformist, I still have expectations because I know they have the potencial and I don't think that does make me a bad fan. i still love them though ^^
Did they sing live and just put music over it? or did it sound like this during the performance at the site? cuz it feels like performances loose intensity when its not live, and the recorded music sounds to clear.
i don't think they sing it live.. didn't hear the 'grrrr' sound from jonghyun.. and if this is a live performance, i don't think jonghyun can just rip his mic like how he did in this video because there will be something attach to the mic.. but who care, we know they can sing it live and a good one^^
![[샤이니 태민] 착한데 성질이 더러워...? 그러니까 성질이 더러운데 착하다는 거지?](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/onemiZc59EQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![[GDA/Golden Disk Awards] SHINee (샤이니) - Sherlock (셜록)](/img/n.gif)
여기 댓글 올리신 모든샤월분들!
요거는 립싱크 맞는 것 같습니다.
근데 원래 sm그룹들은 컴백하고 일주일동안은 퍼포먼스를 위해 립싱크하고요.
그리고 음악방송, 즉 뮤뱅, 엠카, 음중, 쇼챔에서만 라이브합니다.
왜냐면 매일 음방뛰고 거기에다 요런 행사 비슷한거까지 라이브로하면 다 목상해요,특히 샤이니노래는 고음이 많고 퍼포먼스도 쩔어서 만약 라이브까지하면...
그러니까 샤이니 예쁘게 봐주세요!
김성희 사이다♡
립싱크고 뭐고 저긴 애초에 라이브 퍼포를 할 음향시설 자체가 안갖춰져있을걸요.....
ㄱ..김종현 마이크 뜯는 거 봐 미친 심쿵
저런멋진두부를본적있는가...
역시립싱크는 어색하구나ㅋㅋㅋ 라이브왕 샤이니 최고♥
역시 종현이의 박력이 굿
2012 shinee was SO CAMP
최고다 샤이니 안무는
한명한명 다 빛나는 샤이니 사랑해♥♥♥
립싱크보다 라이브를 잘해서 립싱크가 티 나는 그룹ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 립싱크를 하든 말든 상관없으니까 행복하게 활동해 줘라~
라이브네~ 샤이니 아이돌계 라이브 장인이지~ 종현아~ 애 많이 썼어~ 여기저기 해외 스케줄로 샤이니는 해외 콘서트ᆞ 해외 공연ᆞ행사ᆞ각종 예능 등등 해외로만 다니니 다른 연예인들보다 훨씬 더 지치고 힘들었지... 종현아~ 넘 많이 보고 싶고 사랑한다~
일찍 하늘의 별이 되긴 진짜 아까운 별이야~ 너무 빨리 하늘로 갔네... 안타까워서 ... 종현아 ~ 큰소리로 펑펑 울면서 네 이름을 외쳐도 ... 너를 다신 볼 수 없고....
항상 열심히 매사에 최선을 다하고 고생만 하다간 종현이..... 이젠 못하겠다고 손 놓고 많이 번 돈으로 여행을 다니면서 새로운 에너지를 여행지에서 받아서 새롭게 좋아하는 음악을 시작 할 수 있었을텐데.... 아깝다...너의 재능과 음악의 대한 열정...사랑한다~♡
Minho is super gorgeous but more so when his hair is black!
와 마무리 존 멋
What was with the audience's reaction? SHINee was and is Awesome! 👏👏👏👏👏❤SHINee❤🤟
가끔 생각나서 보러오는데 진짜 존나 간지난다;;;
빛나는샤이니♥
딱 샤이니는 립싱크 특징이 있음 라이브할때는 입모양을 그렇게까지 크게 안하는데 립싱크는 라이브보다 입모양을 크게함 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 립싱크티난다 기여운샤이니 와 근데 김종현 립싱크라 마이크 던지는거바 개간지다
Wow 👏👏👏👏
Hah~ I love to see that SHINee really can't lip sync correctly~ my babies have an awful lip sync, but that makes me happy idk why. I know they are really tired and this is a really strong and hard performance so, It's fine for them to lip sync they need to rest =). We all know that SHINee is one of the best when it comes to live performances~
Fighting babies!
Yes! We know they can sing it live and a good one. :) It's okay for them to lip sync. They are not doing it always so for me it's ok I know it is hard to dance and sing at the same time and I know they are tired from traveling back and forth from KR to JP.
When Jjong threw his mic at the end ... EPIC! XD So fierce :DDD
Bless you, coordi noonas. Those are wonderful pants. It's about time!
멋있다 샤이니💟💟💟💟💟
I love how shawols are so protective x) well, i dont care if they're lipsync or singing live because i knew how awesome are they to even care -.- they're so tired. Poor my babies :'(
Onewwwwwwwwww♥
카메랔ㅋㄱㅋㅋㅋㅋㄱㅋㅋㅋ
종현아❤️
헐 이태민...♥
또 생각나서 보러왔어 23년
0:13 와 저땐 몰랐는데 마농 완전 아가네👶🏻
이상하게 찍고 카매라맨들 실망 감독님들 실망..ㅠㅠ 조금더 이쁘게 잡아주시지...
rest in peace
SHINee’sBACK💎
love the outfit,love shinee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
really miss them！！！
샤이니 밀어줍당♬♪꺄꺄꺄 ^0 ^
omfg i N E V E R get tired of watching their live performances of this song gfajsgagfasd it doesn't matter how many times i watch it, i'm always fangirling hard ;A;
If They "do" that then there must be some reason..We All Know that SHINee is Super Busy Last & This year.. I think They are the busiest Idol from last year..It's like Yesterday - Japan, Today - Korea, Tomorrow - Japan again, the day after - Hongkong, the day after - Korea again, they day after - somewhere again and so on.. THE POINT IS We All know THEY CAN SING WHILE DANCING SOME SONGS IN A ROW WITH STABLE VOICES !! Everyone has acknowledged their Voices..It's just a matter of hectic schedule!!
Are you kidding me what was that at the end why was there no reaction like if I was there I would have screamed so loud 😂😂😂but no all we get is a “Yeah” are you serious 😒
므찌다 므쪄 증말
꺄악!!샤이니♥
종현오빠마이크뜻지마...아프지않아?.........ㅜ
jonghyun's chest is bursting omgggggg
카메라 파트 ㅎ멤버 헷갈리지 않는것만이라도 뭐
음이 딱 걍 노래 파일이구만 머.. 립씽크가 머가 어때서 걍 인정할건 인정합시다
Lipsync or not, as a Shawol we should be able to see the pain of SHINee. They've been flying so much the past year I doubt they've gotten rest between songs. We know SHINee has the skills and the energy to perform live, there's billions of proofs from their debut to now. Plus, SHINee hates to lipsync but if they have to they have to. Only lipsyncing can help protect their vocals for more grand performances. Jonghyun obviously hates lipsync because he rips the mic off to show it was lipsync.
their energy in this performance never fails to impress me
lol I just wanted to post the same comment XDDD he was too into the song so he just released energy HAHAHA I loved it
oh i miss them so much!! TT__TT great performance!
아니요 ㅎ 바지찟어진건 가요대전?인가 거기에욬ㅋㅋ
SHINee!!!!!!!!!!
태민이 머리 너무 아름다운 듯. 종현 오늘따라 힘이 넘치는데..ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 카메라 너무 구려요. 가요 프로그램 아니라지만 너무 구림...
ชัดดี..จัง..น่ารัก..
C: SHINee just made my morning. I feel fierce! Now, I can go deal with students lol.
This stage makes me think of. . .
Cool
SHINee
Insuperables
MinHo
굿ㅠㅠ
Did Jonghyun just threw his mic???!!!!!! cool!!!!
성희김님 말이 맞아요 머라하지마세요~
ㅋㅋㅋ 이건 누가봐도 립싱크지.. 노래가 원곡 그대론데 근데 립싱크라서 애들 퍼포를 더 집중해서 볼 수 있는듯 셜록 진짜 극악 안무다.. 동작 이어지는 거나 잔상 남는 거나 무대 곳곳 뛰어다니는 거야 알고 있었지만 하이라이트에서 진기랑 종현이 자리 바꾸는 거 진짜 대단하다 그렇게 뛰면서 퍼포하고 후다닥 자리 바꾸고 다시 뛰고 와... 와중에 기범이 손동작 깔끔한 거랑 표정 너무 셜록 그 자체고 민호 기범이 뛰어넘는 동작도 너무 깔끔하고 진기도 퍼포에 집중했구나, 표정이나 동작이나 영감 영감 아니잖아.. 태민이야 대단했던 거 다 알구.. 알아도 진짜 대단하구.. 태민이가 센터에서 춤 추는 거 보면 너무 짜릿함 역솔남이 우리 그룹 아이돌이에요 부럽죠ㅠㅠ 저 때가 데뷔 4년찬데 얼마나 대단했던 거야 새삼 자랑스럽네.. 고생했어 대단해 사랑해
yeah you got me!
♡o♡ our perfect boys♥
아우 카메라;
와 종현 마지막에 인이어 빼는거 ㄷㄷㄷ
Dubulge ♥♥
I personally think this was one of their worst performance, but its still a five star act. Their worst is actually super freaking amazing. Their naturally born entertainers! :D SHINee!!!
이게그 모델들 걸어나와서 웃었단거 아닌가? 왜 모델분들이 안나오시지??
넌 구글에서도 샤이니...ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
minho
then you should know that SHINee need a break! lip sync is our last problem. I want SHINee to take a break before they break! And beside that they sang live during their concert tour, the showcase in Japan and during the japanese music show "Happy Music" and many other concerts. But they will have a comeback in Japan again soon...I'm happy to see new stuff and even more happy because it's a ballad song (an easier choreo and the boys can take a rest) but still...they seriously need a break
WHO IS BEATING 2012 KIBUM HE'S UNHINGED
They were really lousy with lip synch. Makes me smile especially when Jonghyun threw his mic piece
Anyone noticed that the shirt taemin is wearing is actually the same shirt had when they performed a special stage cover on Super Juniors Sorry sorry
dubludge...
everywhere...
@3:33 alskdalsdkas Jong!!! ese movimiento de pecho lo aprendiste de Taemin xDD
KEYY O__O TAEMINNN O_O JONGHYUN O___O ONEW O___O MINHO O___O
whoaaaaaaaa they look perfecttttttttt
Ok i get you, I respect your opinion, you have a point, that's true I never said you were wrong I just gave my opinion.
外套都蓋不住鐘鉉的💪🏽❤️
BUNNYYYYY XD
onew
are you sure YOU are a fan? Do you even now how busy SHINee lately are? I even doubt that they sleep more than 2 hours a day. I think the last thing we should do is to complain about lip sync
Jonghyun ripping out his microphone and doing that fucking sexy head spin at the end O______O
카메라 ....ㅠㅜ
라이븐지 립싱큰지 어케 알고 말하는건지 ㅎㅎ 샤이니는 라이브실력 인정받은 그룹인데
I think the cameraman is a fan of Bling Bling
Oh, i know they can sing:D and really well too, even from their debut! but i just thought they lack intensity when they dont...thats all
Yes I am, since they were rockies and I was 19, but that doesn't mean I don't have an opinion, I love them and I know they can sing, I'm not saying they should sing every time, but the amount of times they have been lip syncing lately is ridiculous! I just wish that they sing live more often like they used to. Be a fan does not make me a conformist, I still have expectations because I know they have the potencial and I don't think that does make me a bad fan.
i still love them though ^^
i miss jong whit long hair y.y but TAEMIN IS SO HOT :Q_
Did they sing live and just put music over it? or did it sound like this during the performance at the site? cuz it feels like performances loose intensity when its not live, and the recorded music sounds to clear.
The thumbnail xD
Jjong dont like when lip sync in stage tat why he throw his own mic :)
wow wow wow Jonghyun, just rip that mic off
i don't think they sing it live.. didn't hear the 'grrrr' sound from jonghyun.. and if this is a live performance, i don't think jonghyun can just rip his mic like how he did in this video because there will be something attach to the mic.. but who care, we know they can sing it live and a good one^^
립싱크라서 종현이 마이크 던진거구나..ㅋㅋㅋ 보다가 깜짝 놀랐넼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
soy un dorito
XD
2:19-2:20 Kim Jomghyun LOL
카메라 진짜 마음에 안 든다 애들 화면에 나오는 것 보다 더 이쁜데 이따구로 찍으시면 ㅠㅅㅠ
omfg jjong 2:19??????????????
중간에 모델걸어나왔다는데 안나오네?
그건 드림걸..
화면을 요따우로밖에 잡을수 없나?