+rachel coban I personally think Luke's dream was Bail Me Out (Ft. Joel Madden) by All Time Low but yeah this is probably giving his a seizure+chest pains as well
I love how the music has been arranged, so different from how 5SOS does it live, but I prefer the emotion that 5SOS puts into the song when they sing this. Don't get me wrong, the Madden Brothers' vocals are on point. Would love to hear this arrangement with 5SOS' vocals...
+TeamVincent TeamRadke actually, talented songwriters are able to write songs (read: "stories") without actually having lived the situation (for instance, writing a story that isn't real) - like an author. it's part of being creative. don't discount 5sos' performance just because they didn't write the song - that doesn't mean their emotions are automatically fake - any single person singing this song who relates to it on an emotional level has very real emotions when performing it - not having written it doesn't make them any less real.
+TeamVincent TeamRadke they wrote a song specifically for 5SOS, tbh, at their age, considering their relationships, this song is more about teenage feelings - that's why I believe the maddens wrote it without necessarily basing it on a real life occurrence. i still wouldn't use the word fake at all - in quotations or not. all you're really trying to say is that (in your opinion) the maddens perform this song better from an emotional standpoint than 5sos ;) doesn't mean you should discount the 5sos boys' emotions. just means that you connect emotionally better with one band's performance over the other. as for vocally - i'm a huge fan of GC and a fairly big fan of 5SOS - but i have to be brutally honest and say i don't believe either of them have particularly good live vocals.
+TeamVincent TeamRadke sweetheart, please stop talking shit. you can't call an artist's emotions while singing "fake" - do you know why? because you're not that fucking musician and you don't personally know that musician. not being the writer or creator of a piece does not mean your emotional connection to the piece should be discounted and if you were a performer, you would know this. if you think 5sos are shit, then so be it, that's your opinion, but your opinion holds no grounds on whether the emotions that a band exude on stage are "fake" or not. do you think i'm a fucking teenager like yourself? i've listened to GC for the past 16 years and seen them many many times. they are not strong singers live (and have admitted that many many times at their shows) and their more recent albums were fairly shit because they tried to appeal to mainsteam radio-based audiences. please do not assume to know anything about me, especially since judging by your childish username, that you are considerably younger than myself. please continue to stay the fuck away from my channel and take your immature nastiness with you. thanks.
I haven't listened to a proper live Version since I saw 5SOS. It legit reminds me so much of ROWYSO, so Beautiful. I actually love Joel and Benji. GC were my second ever concert and for Joel and Benji to sing 'Amnesia' has made my heart melt
this is why i really in love with 5SOS's song Amnesia, when i first listen to this song, i dont know ,i just felt like i knew it deep about the song and words, and there they are, Benji & Joel. that's the reason
good charlotte should include the song in the new album, cause is one of the most incredible song they've ever wrotten, and it sounds even better when they sing it...
In 2009 I saw Good Charlotte live and it was one of the best concerts I've ever been to. In 2015 I saw 5 Seconds of Summer live and it was amazing. I'm really happy that 2 of my favorite bands work together and create that great music!
It may sound stupid but I like this more when the Maddens are singing this. I love 5SOS but it just has some sort of throwback to Good Charlotte to me, I guess? I don't even know...Or maybe it's just the fact that this song consists of Benji's and Joel's words...Either way I love it even more when they sing it than 5SOS...
I feel the same. Don't get me wrong, I love 5SOS but the magic of the song isn't there when they sing it and that magic is there when The Madden Brothers sing it for me
I respect your opinion and I'm just saying mine now. Even though some people like this version better, I like 5sos' version better because I feel the emotion behind the lyrics and I don't feel as much with the Madden Brothers :)
This reminds me of when Ed Sheeran did Little Things by One Direction. Except you can actually hear the music over the crowd this time. I like stuff like this because it gives you a taste of what the song might have sounded like before it was recorded, while it was still being written. I also really like what they did with the rhythm guitar section. Makes me wish I could play.
I do love the original song But my person taste in music is more towards the madden's rendition I really wish they'd record it, I'd buy it in a heart beat
+Phillip Parche makes no difference mate. the official registered performer of Amnesia is 5SOS, and therefore it is their song so anyone else performing it would make it a cover.
I like this, I really do, but they have this rock element to their voices. Like they were made to be in a rock band. This totally suitz 5sos' voices. They're voices are softer with this song and I feel it suits it better. NO HATE :)
"its not a cover" yes it is. yes they co wrote it, but the rights are in 5sos' name. legally and officially, this song belongs to 5sos, it is theirs. doesnt matter if they didnt write it. for example, ed sherran co wrote a lot of "love yourself" for justin bieber. he is one of the songwriters of the song but it is nonetheless a justin bieber song, the rights are in justins name, not ed sherrans. so, this is a cover as it is not the madden brothers song.
the main difference is the voices joel and benji have, the majority of the chord payerns are the same you can just hear more of the bass and drums because there's only mainly one guitar being played until the end
no they did not. check the songwriting credits. Amnesia was written by the madden bros and another songwriter, no part of the song was created by 5sos. they simply got given the song for their record pre-written.
Sure the Madden Brothers version sounds better. It's their song to begin with. Also both of them are 38 and have 15-20 years of touring and rock experience and are grown up with grown up voices. Same way Hanson sounds incredible now singing MMMbop if you don't believe just look it up they do. So no dis to 5SOS their version is very cool but sounds like kids recording it because they basically were when they did. I'd imagine in 10-15 years they will sound much better singing it as well.
the only properly good song and least cheesy 5sos ever had is written by madden brothers. they sound rock, but lyrically they re cheesy. they need to make good song so people will finally accept them as a band. till then they re cheesy boyband
In my opinion, their first album was pretty crap since they were very young at the time and all the songs had a teeny-boppy naive vibe, but their new album is a lot deeper with a good number of tear-jerking and spirit-lifting songs, like Broken Home, Safety Pin, Invisible, Outer Space/Carry On, etc. I suggest you check out their newer stuff, you may take a liking to it :)
in my opinion, i think the maddens can't sing but make really good songs, i do love them. but i think 5sos sing this song better and I'm only saying this because I'm part of the 5SOSfam.... but if you disagree please keep it to yourself... thanks
+Narry Storan GC ALL DAY EVERY DAY!!!!! FUCK THOSE LITTLE FUCKBOYS!!!! Joel and Binji are amazing and don't ever say that those 5 whatever fucksticks are better
"They became like little brothers to me" that part was just beautiful :3
That part made me tear up they're just like babies aawwww😌I love them
Lukes dream has offically come true
+rachel coban I personally think Luke's dream was Bail Me Out (Ft. Joel Madden) by All Time Low but yeah this is probably giving his a seizure+chest pains as well
im so proud of him and the boys
Yeah
That's a lie
Anonymous Alto whats a lie?
Never knew amnesia belong to them. Glad I know now, one of my FAVOURITE of all time. Amnesia
I love how the music has been arranged, so different from how 5SOS does it live, but I prefer the emotion that 5SOS puts into the song when they sing this. Don't get me wrong, the Madden Brothers' vocals are on point. Would love to hear this arrangement with 5SOS' vocals...
I feel the same :)
+TeamVincent TeamRadke actually, talented songwriters are able to write songs (read: "stories") without actually having lived the situation (for instance, writing a story that isn't real) - like an author. it's part of being creative. don't discount 5sos' performance just because they didn't write the song - that doesn't mean their emotions are automatically fake - any single person singing this song who relates to it on an emotional level has very real emotions when performing it - not having written it doesn't make them any less real.
+TeamVincent TeamRadke they wrote a song specifically for 5SOS, tbh, at their age, considering their relationships, this song is more about teenage feelings - that's why I believe the maddens wrote it without necessarily basing it on a real life occurrence.
i still wouldn't use the word fake at all - in quotations or not. all you're really trying to say is that (in your opinion) the maddens perform this song better from an emotional standpoint than 5sos ;) doesn't mean you should discount the 5sos boys' emotions. just means that you connect emotionally better with one band's performance over the other.
as for vocally - i'm a huge fan of GC and a fairly big fan of 5SOS - but i have to be brutally honest and say i don't believe either of them have particularly good live vocals.
+TeamVincent TeamRadke sweetheart, please stop talking shit. you can't call an artist's emotions while singing "fake" - do you know why? because you're not that fucking musician and you don't personally know that musician. not being the writer or creator of a piece does not mean your emotional connection to the piece should be discounted and if you were a performer, you would know this. if you think 5sos are shit, then so be it, that's your opinion, but your opinion holds no grounds on whether the emotions that a band exude on stage are "fake" or not.
do you think i'm a fucking teenager like yourself? i've listened to GC for the past 16 years and seen them many many times. they are not strong singers live (and have admitted that many many times at their shows) and their more recent albums were fairly shit because they tried to appeal to mainsteam radio-based audiences. please do not assume to know anything about me, especially since judging by your childish username, that you are considerably younger than myself. please continue to stay the fuck away from my channel and take your immature nastiness with you. thanks.
TeamVincent TeamRadke you bitch
As a person who grew up listening to GC then grew to love 5SOS, I love both versions.. 💗
I love how Benji basically told the crowd to shut up and they told him they love him and he said I love you too how sweet
Back here in 2021!
I haven't listened to a proper live Version since I saw 5SOS. It legit reminds me so much of ROWYSO, so Beautiful. I actually love Joel and Benji. GC were my second ever concert and for Joel and Benji to sing 'Amnesia' has made my heart melt
this is why i really in love with 5SOS's song Amnesia, when i first listen to this song, i dont know ,i just felt like i knew it deep about the song and words, and there they are, Benji & Joel. that's the reason
this is amazing
yeah, the 5SOS boys didn't actually write it, it was Benji and Joel and a couple of other co-writers :)
This explains why I love that song, been listening to GC since 5th grade, I'm 22 now
They write it for 5sos I think
littlethingss11 They wrote the whole thing
Crystal wright They did. That is why they can play it
i'm blown away!!! would kill for a studio version❤️sooo good!
This is the most amazing cover on here. Amnesia is Cal's song and The madden brothers' too :) I love this coverrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
It says cover but they wrote it so its not exactly a cover but its not their song
Nghi Dinh yeah, but if they wrote it and gave it to another artist, it becomes the other artists song. so they are technically "covering" it.
Nghi Dinh Really?
Eve Michele Correct
+Nghi Dinh they co wrote it i believe
+Alex G they wrote the song but didn't think it suited them so they gave it to 5sos because it matched their voices better and 5sos had no part of it
I wann meet them so bad omfg
5sos i the reason I know them, love this song ♥
good charlotte should include the song in the new album, cause is one of the most incredible song they've ever wrotten, and it sounds even better when they sing it...
In 2009 I saw Good Charlotte live and it was one of the best concerts I've ever been to. In 2015 I saw 5 Seconds of Summer live and it was amazing. I'm really happy that 2 of my favorite bands work together and create that great music!
I love when things come full circle!
I'm proud of our boys, their dreams have come true
It may sound stupid but I like this more when the Maddens are singing this. I love 5SOS but it just has some sort of throwback to Good Charlotte to me, I guess? I don't even know...Or maybe it's just the fact that this song consists of Benji's and Joel's words...Either way I love it even more when they sing it than 5SOS...
I feel the same. Don't get me wrong, I love 5SOS but the magic of the song isn't there when they sing it and that magic is there when The Madden Brothers sing it for me
they make me miss Goodcharlotte...
I respect your opinion and I'm just saying mine now. Even though some people like this version better, I like 5sos' version better because I feel the emotion behind the lyrics and I don't feel as much with the Madden Brothers :)
+Rebecca Ho same
This reminds me of when Ed Sheeran did Little Things by One Direction. Except you can actually hear the music over the crowd this time. I like stuff like this because it gives you a taste of what the song might have sounded like before it was recorded, while it was still being written. I also really like what they did with the rhythm guitar section. Makes me wish I could play.
I love this song, this version is so good.
The madden brothers WAS the best 5sos time
Benji's smile kills me 😍😍
omg Love love love this version! GC will always have my heart!
Song starts at around 4:47, you´re welcome.
thanks
That chick was so fucking annoying
I know no one who can sing this song beautifully as 5sos does until i watched this ...
This made me shed a tear ..idk why.
I would be glad if they would made studio version of it.....
Oh geeze their voice is amazing! :D
I do love the original song But my person taste in music is more towards the madden's rendition I really wish they'd record it, I'd buy it in a heart beat
+cassie849 same.
❤❤❤
❤️❤️
wow awesome song I love it
😢 I’m feeling so emotional right now
you sing really good my favorite good when you going french ??!
Who’s Doing This Bit: A Tale Of Twin Singers 😂 also the song sounds so good
OH, gosh...did you go on Friday night? I was sitting in the fourth row from the front on the right
YES! Row D for me!
:D
They are actually good
IM SHITTING MY PANTS THESE DUDES RULE OH MY
+none of your bussiness I KNOW RIGHT 😂😂
ok thayre v adorable
+Saundra Audrina datum this is rally rally good
Quiero esta canción cantada por los Madden pero en buena calidad bien grabada
This is NO cover. The Madden Brothers wrote this song!
+Phillip Parche makes no difference mate. the official registered performer of Amnesia is 5SOS, and therefore it is their song so anyone else performing it would make it a cover.
Technically from what I heard they co-wrote it.But I could be wrong.
+Bonnielynn Marie (Little Distraction) yes they did in the amnesia track by track Luke said they wrote it
+Bonnielynn Marie (Little Distraction) ash starts telling how the got it at 0:16
they wrote it with another songwritter but 5sos sang it
It’s not really a cover it was their song that 5sos received from them
It would be better if this song would be recorded by good charlotte
I didn’t know they wrote this song lol 😂 wow
Thank you Mate's
No hate to them, but I prefer Calum's voice in amnesia over theirs
hermoso
4:45 to skip to music
Did you work with one directchion
ps thanks for sharing!
you're welcome! :)
I love it, it’s so good
Didn’t they help write it though
Erin Vincent nah, solely the madden bros and another songwriter :)
I like this, I really do, but they have this rock element to their voices. Like they were made to be in a rock band. This totally suitz 5sos' voices. They're voices are softer with this song and I feel it suits it better. NO HATE :)
"its not a cover" yes it is. yes they co wrote it, but the rights are in 5sos' name. legally and officially, this song belongs to 5sos, it is theirs. doesnt matter if they didnt write it. for example, ed sherran co wrote a lot of "love yourself" for justin bieber. he is one of the songwriters of the song but it is nonetheless a justin bieber song, the rights are in justins name, not ed sherrans. so, this is a cover as it is not the madden brothers song.
This is correct, however despite it being their song, 5SOS did not write it and are not credited as doing so.
@@iamcheerbear i know :) i said they co wrote it because there are other songwriters on the credits listed besides the brothers.
i love the 5sos one better just hey, that's just my opinion ;)
4:35
natural and so
how can this video can even get 4 dislikes O_O
I hate the world
Is this what the song was originally supposed to sound or...
the main difference is the voices joel and benji have, the majority of the chord payerns are the same you can just hear more of the bass and drums because there's only mainly one guitar being played until the end
wow thanks
No they cowrote it with 5sos
no they did not. check the songwriting credits. Amnesia was written by the madden bros and another songwriter, no part of the song was created by 5sos. they simply got given the song for their record pre-written.
No offence to 5SOS or 5SOS fan but I think that The Madden Brothers version of Amnesia is better. Don't hate me for this. It's just an opinion.
Big 5sosfan right here but I do agree with you it may aound weird but I feel like when the madden brothers sing it it has more emotion
+laila zwier I agree, has more emotion because they wrote it.
Wow they sound amazing too I love this technically it isn’t a cover if they wrote it lol 😂 even
Prefer this over the 5sos one tbh
Kyle hi buddy one
Sure the Madden Brothers version sounds better. It's their song to begin with. Also both of them are 38 and have 15-20 years of touring and rock experience and are grown up with grown up voices. Same way Hanson sounds incredible now singing MMMbop if you don't believe just look it up they do. So no dis to 5SOS their version is very cool but sounds like kids recording it because they basically were when they did. I'd imagine in 10-15 years they will sound much better singing it as well.
Incase anyone didnt know that joel and benji were 5sos mangers and the twins actually wrote the song for them
They are better than 5sos but 5sos are cool too no H8 SCREAMS LYRICS!!
Epic! haha n.n
Молодцы очень качественная пародия.P.S Смотреть с 4.40,до этого болтовня.
Debieron lanzarla ellos no venderla a 5sos
Fucking allergies
the only properly good song and least cheesy 5sos ever had is written by madden brothers. they sound rock, but lyrically they re cheesy. they need to make good song so people will finally accept them as a band. till then they re cheesy boyband
They did. Like Jet black heart.
In my opinion, their first album was pretty crap since they were very young at the time and all the songs had a teeny-boppy naive vibe, but their new album is a lot deeper with a good number of tear-jerking and spirit-lifting songs, like Broken Home, Safety Pin, Invisible, Outer Space/Carry On, etc. I suggest you check out their newer stuff, you may take a liking to it :)
listen to 5sos second album sounds good feels good then tell me the lyrics are cheesy yeah....
Kinda wanna slap you with a little jet black heart. Not trying to be mean or anything but yeah... Kinda wanna slap you with a little jet black heart.
I get where you're coming from, check out their new song Jet Black Heart
luke probably shit himself watching this
in my opinion, i think the maddens can't sing but make really good songs, i do love them. but i think 5sos sing this song better and I'm only saying this because I'm part of the 5SOSfam.... but if you disagree please keep it to yourself... thanks
+Narry Storan GC ALL DAY EVERY DAY!!!!! FUCK THOSE LITTLE FUCKBOYS!!!! Joel and Binji are amazing and don't ever say that those 5 whatever fucksticks are better
Motorcycle Lover no need to be an asshole about it, people have different opinions
Narry Storan if your allowed to have your opinion so are other but if you disagree please keep it to yourself
I like their voice they harmonize so well.. it's their style of singing maybe. Plus they got Michael Buble voice lol
The Maddens always do it better (no hate if u don't fucking like it, ignore it )
omg that terrible bass