Another great review Eric. Good job! I am really enjoying these and find you versus videos really interesting. Some are long but don't feel anywhere near as long. Keep it up your channel is great!
Pretty smart having to go to the place where people go the most intoxicated having some alien thing be there would just make people think they are drunkenly looking at a cosplayed or somethin
The director of Sonic does want to expand the movie's world, so it is possible that we might explore more of Sonic's world as well as other worlds that were shown on Sonic's map.
He actually did want to include the chaos emeralds,but the fact that this will leave new fans with the only choice of playing 6 games to have a chance to know the relation between the human and sonic world
Yea, but even if they expand the world building in the sequel(s), this movie would still have the exact same problem. I would rather have them go all out with the world building and sonic references than play it safe and sound only drip feed us a few references and the possibility of a sequel.
@KJ Beast Super Mario with a good budget and producers,directors,etc. could totally work in a live action and after seeing Sonic and Pokémon in live action i 100% sure of it i never in my life dreamed of seeing Pokémon or Sonic live actions movies being so good i almost fainted of joy holy shit...
@@NotTheNexus1991 i respect your opinion but i like mario and sonic the same i played the game i know all the characters in the games but 1993 mario movie was 💩 and the sonic movie was really enjoyable cant wait for the sequel and cant for the animated mario movie in 2021 or 2022
Yeah never texting about ego because that a low blow Ryan Reynolds did good movie on budget money. So let it go with Jim Carrey he should replace with a character that matching his video game Counterpart of Dr Eggman not Robotnik that all.
To address 2 things about your SONIC Conclusion: -In a recent Interview with one of the writers of the movie, they said that the Green Hill citizens had an even bigger part in the final battle at the end, but they cut it down a bit so it’s more Sonic’s time to shine. -Also, the Olive Garden joke, was NOT actually product placement. Olive Garden didn’t pay them for that. The Writers just thought it was a funny joke to throw in at the end, they eventually added on to it later as sort of a running gag.
@@Seablobel8 actually not,sonic did much better in the opening weekend and snatched 2 records from detective pikachu,sonic is the new grossiest vedio game adaptation.Sonic surpassed detective pikachu.
Yeah it was forced to have Detective Pikachu run away for what he thought he did and Tim doesn't even care so what's the point of Pikachu/Tim's father to run away, Sonic on the other hand argued with Tom because he doesn't want him to abandon greenhill and leave the people without a good officer Overall Sonic The Hedgehog Movie was fun to watch when I saw in theaters, Detective Pikachu was meh and I was a bit disappointed with that film but the pokemon did look good in live action
MeAndEverything When I went to the theatre to see the movie a kid actually laughed when Sonic did the floss. When the movie was over that same kid went in front of the screen and started flossing.
Thank you so much. I've been waiting for this match up. I enjoyed both films, though i personally liked Sonic more due to being a bigger fan of that franchise than Pokemon.
Its a very good suggestion. I DID consider ranking the DC movies recently, the Marvel movies will be a much bigger challenge as they have SO MANY movies. But yeah, I will definitely do some ranking videos at some point.
It sounds awesome so far. I LOVED The Long Halloween comic and much like The Dark Knight, this new Batman movie seems to be taking inspiration from it. I also trust the Director Matt Reeves. He made the two recent Planet of the Apes movies and his directing and overall visual style seems PERFECT for a character like Batman. So I can't wait to see it. It's just a shame that the movie is gonna take much longer to come out as they only finished 25% of filming.
Eric Carter lets hope that they’ll use the time they have to improve on what they already have (also I saw leaks of the set, and it turns out that the police blimps from Batman TAS are going to be in this movie’s version of Gotham).
I really gotta say I loved this review, it felted real, unbiased and honest. You did a fantastic job with this review! My rating for this review is a 10/10. I think you should compare Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory vs Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.
Great video Eric! I loved the style the titles and music had with the actual video! I honestly love ur channel so much and i think u r so underrated!! Btw, I have a question. U mentioned months ago that u were making a ghostbusters VS video and we haven't heard anything since. Is that still being worked on eric or is something else happening? Thank u for this amazing video buddy!! :)
Thanks for all of your music suggestions guys! I got LOADS of music suggestions from you and I went through ALL of them. And I’m sad to say that they did not really fit with the style of videos that I make. So after much pondering and searching I decided to go with unofficial orchestra music of the original and iconic Sonic themes. Aswell as music from Pokemon The First Movie and Pokemon 3 The Movie. I hope you guys enjoy the video!
Awesome video!! I didn't think these movies would interest me in the slightest, and Sonic still doesn't, but Pikachu was quite impressive. Thanks for making this!
When I saw this pop up in my notifications, I stopped the UA-cam video I was watching to see this one. I've been waiting SO LONG for this video to come out, and I'd been so eager to hear your thoughts on it! :D Also, with regards to the question you had about how Tails would've looked with the old design: he actually hadn't been designed yet. When Paramount released the first trailer, showing off Sonic's old design, all the footage in that trailer was the only footage where they inputted CGI at the time, insinuating that they didn't create Tails for the end-credits scene yet, which means that he didn't get added in until way after Sonic got his redesign. But if Paramount didn't change Sonic's design, then Tails would've been made with a more disturbing incarnation as well, but thankfully, he wasn't.
You are actually wrong. Tyson Hesse (the guy that made Sonics new movie design) said that there was also a Tails design made and they had to redesign him as well.
@@eguyigbin6987 Oh, did he? I heard from a UA-cam channel who did lots of research into the Sonic movie that Tails' appearance at the end was what they had originally planned from the start, but that they hadn't made the CGI for him yet. If Tails actually DOES have an old design, then I wonder what he would've looked like, too.
Personally, I prefer Pokémon: Detective Pikachu for a few reasons: Better World Building. More Refrences to the Video Games and TV Adaptations. Better Cast (Not Counting the Villain. Jim Carrey is the E.G.G.M.A.N.) Better VFX. Better Action. Better Soundtrack.
I love your verses videos why I don't agree with your birds of prey opinion I love the amount of work that goes into it and I love be watching them, it has inspired me to make one on Minecraft dungeons vs Minecraft Storymode season 1
I want them to make a Yu-gi-oh live action movie. That would be great. I grew up more with Digimon then Pokemon, but I did see the Pokemon movie with Mewtwo in it; all those evil versions of different Pokemon was pretty neat.
That's going to be kind of tricky to do. I'm not sure how the general audience will except things like how the fate of the world tends to lie on a children's card game. Sure fans will know and get stuff like it being a ancient game from Egypt and all but not everyone else. Also the hair. U can't do Yugi without the hair. Anime hair tends to not translate to live action as shown with what happened to Gokus hair in that film I won't say the name of.
I Think they'd do a disservice to digimon and people would write it off as an even more pokemon clone than they already thought it was Plus it would just be a humans and monster pets who fight together just like pokemon Yu gi Oh would be much better and original!!
@@cocodragonblazedtea7803 hmmm GX huh? Sure Jaiden/Judai does have the more standard hair, but he's not as recognizable to the general Audience as Yugi.
16:59 Yes Tails has a original design, I remember the director of the sonic movie said that it was always going to end like that. Tyson just helped redesign tails including his tracker into a one handed miles electric
Are you ever gonna review the third season of Series of Unfortunate Events, I loved the first two videos and would like to know your opinion on the conclusion.
17:30 Uh Eric? The world of pokemon presented in Detective Pikachu IS the fictional world. Edit: Okay, I feel i should clarify so I don't sound like a jackass. I understand what you mean by wanting video game movies to only take place in the their fictional world, basically remove any human or "real" elements, but when it comes to pokemon it'd be kinda difficult to do that since humans always had a major presence since the start. Sure, there are games like pokemon mystery dungeon where it's just the pokemon w/o humans. but still.
Both are good, but Detective Pikachu is just better in almost every way for me. The chemistry between Tim and the Pikachu is really good and the story is a lot more interesting to me.
Yeah it is good. Hell the fact that we got 2 Amazing videogame movies back to back. Detective Pikachu even has a lot of hidden subtleties to it, that can actually make watching it more then once reveal a ton of revelations.
Am I the only one who thinks that a Sequel for the Sonic Movie would actually be far better than the first? The way they set it up makes me in think it might actually focus more on Sonic's world and will have more effort put into the writing.
I'm so glad someone other than me pointed out how unfunny and forced the fart joke in Sonic was. I even begged the director on Twitter not to include any in the sequel. Also, Detective Pikachu DOES take place in a completely fictional world, dude!
Hey I know you mainly just do movies that have recently come out but I just watched Upgrade the other day and thought it would be cool if you did a vs video between Upgrade and Venom. Since they have a lot in common.
I wouldn't say it's forced since it suprisingly fits well with his character in the movie. And it was only added because the movie was written like 3 years ago when flossing was still a pretty popular trend.
Eric Carter, In the Japanese continuity of the sonic franchise, Sonic and co. have always lived with humans on Earth, so it would have been cool to see a re-imagined Earth with fantasy elements to modern cities and the zones from the sonic stages, as well has have humans and mobians (what the American continuities called the anthropomorphs) coexist. It would have made the biker bar scene make more sense, as there would have been mobians in the bar as well, and sonic could be in disguise because the government had him "wanted" because they though he was Shadow the Hedgehog. Just something I wanted to say, Great video!
I Have to Agree with you I both enjoyed Sonic The Hedgehog and Detective Pikachu (for Video Game movies there pretty good) I can't wait to see what next for Video Game movies since there is a sign that the video game movies are getting better.
I think the joke with the people at the bar not being able to realize that sonic is actually not a human was a nice call back to the adventures of sonic the hedgehog where sonic would dress up in gimmicky outfits and confuse the villains much like a classic cartoon character, I don’t think it was intended to be taken seriously.
@@EricCarter12 wait they have? Huh, well the reviews always change all the time, but you didn’t get the joke, which also symbolises that you don’t have a dirty mind The joke is 69
The Detective Pikachu film does take place in the Pokémon world from the game/anime. They even reference that Mewtwo escaped from the Kanto region. Ryme City is also the city from the Detective Pikachu game.
I mean I get why you wouldn’t want a sequel to Detective Pikachu But at the same time I want another live action Pokémon movie. (Not detective Pikachu) but something else??? You know what I mean?
Yeah I know what you mean. And I agree. I just think THIS particular Pokémon world with these particular characters should not have another movie. I mean if they come up with a smart way of continuing the story then by all means, they can go ahead and make another one. Otherwise they should just leave it here. Thanks for watching buddy!
Dude, you should DEFINITELY watch Bill Nighy in About Time. His performance is great and his character is so nice and heartwarming, you wanna hug the sh*t outta him. Btw, I also enjoyed both movies a lot, but I do believe it was kind of an unfair match. You see, the Pokémon franchise has already had many movies, with some very successful ones, even though they're all animated. Nintendo did pick their movies well after Mario Bros. Sega didn't. They basically said "you wanna make a movie about our beloved franchise? Suuuuure, bring me the money!", thus we had those vomiting inducing things. And even though I believe Sonic is the most iconic of both, you never really had a "bad pikachu game", Sonic on the other hand... :( Also, funny thing about them both being kind of paired on the Smash Bros Ultimate game.
@@teknomax7883 I mean, he is a member of the highest grossing media franchise ever and with a majority of it having his face on it, I'd say that he's probably more popular than the franchise has almost 17 times less sales than him.
Well done review! This is a hard one to chose! Both are amazing! Can you do next the Shining vs Doctor Sleep! 👍🏻 I hope you are safe, be carefull and take care! ❤️
Another great review Eric. Good job! I am really enjoying these and find you versus videos really interesting. Some are long but don't feel anywhere near as long. Keep it up your channel is great!
My only question I have: How damn drunk do the people in the bar have to be in order to not see a blue hedgehog?
It's cartoon logic. Remember Woody Woodpecker, when he wore a wig and everyone thought he was human. It's suspension of disbelief.
@@littlebunnyvideoproduction2278 true
It makes sense now :)
As drunk as you'd need to be to start a fight with one
Pretty smart having to go to the place where people go the most intoxicated having some alien thing be there would just make people think they are drunkenly looking at a cosplayed or somethin
The director of Sonic does want to expand the movie's world, so it is possible that we might explore more of Sonic's world as well as other worlds that were shown on Sonic's map.
He actually did want to include the chaos emeralds,but the fact that this will leave new fans with the only choice of playing 6 games to have a chance to know the relation between the human and sonic world
They are making a new movie
Yea, but even if they expand the world building in the sequel(s), this movie would still have the exact same problem. I would rather have them go all out with the world building and sonic references than play it safe and sound only drip feed us a few references and the possibility of a sequel.
@@criticaldel well they confirmed the title of the sequel and it has an emerald hill remix so maybe the second movie will foccus on sonics world.
Hi, I’m from the future and I’m here to say that the sequel came out. Knuckles is also in the movie too!
Sonic the Hedgehog was GREAT except....one thing....one SMALL thing....Jim Carey did NOT say "PINGAS!"
So it needs to happen in the sequel.
Yes
"Weeniers" need to be said too...
Pingas!
Pingas
No matter what movie you like most, pikachu or sonic. Just remember
We've reach the point of human evolution where video game movies are actually good
But the question is, will the new Mario Movie mess that up again?😳
i hate mario i like sonic
Super Mario Manuel it’s also being done by Illumination, or so I heard.
@KJ Beast Super Mario with a good budget and producers,directors,etc. could totally work in a live action and after seeing Sonic and Pokémon in live action i 100% sure of it i never in my life dreamed of seeing Pokémon or Sonic live actions movies being so good i almost fainted of joy holy shit...
@@NotTheNexus1991 i respect your opinion but i like mario and sonic the same i played the game i know all the characters in the games but 1993 mario movie was 💩 and the sonic movie was really enjoyable cant wait for the sequel and cant for the animated mario movie in 2021 or 2022
I didn’t grow up with Pokémon, so I just kind of naturally liked Sonic more. Plus, obviously, Jim Carrey makes the whole movie better!
I grew up with pokemon, but i enjoyed sonic more, the jokes, the characters, jim carrey, the action scenes, i liked every part of it
Yeah never texting about ego because that a low blow Ryan Reynolds did good movie on budget money. So let it go with Jim Carrey he should replace with a character that matching his video game Counterpart of Dr Eggman not Robotnik that all.
I grew up with both Pokemon and Sonic and when I saw both the movies in theaters I enjoyed them
The sonic bar scene where he is dressed up is a reference to the old sonic cartoons!!!
But it doesn't explain the stupidity of everyone in the bar.
69 likes...nice
@@bro-be3bd
Probably because they seen too many movies about aliens and they decided to not question it. Like Rick and Morty episode Rick Potion #9.
To address 2 things about your SONIC Conclusion:
-In a recent Interview with one of the writers of the movie, they said that the Green Hill citizens had an even bigger part in the final battle at the end, but they cut it down a bit so it’s more Sonic’s time to shine.
-Also, the Olive Garden joke, was NOT actually product placement. Olive Garden didn’t pay them for that. The Writers just thought it was a funny joke to throw in at the end, they eventually added on to it later as sort of a running gag.
TheGuyWithNoNickname Productions yeah but pikachu overall still did it better. And the mention of Olive Garden still isn’t funny that much.
@@Seablobel8 actually not,sonic did much better in the opening weekend and snatched 2 records from detective pikachu,sonic is the new grossiest vedio game adaptation.Sonic surpassed detective pikachu.
Ahmad Kazan I said in quality it still did it better and they both made pretty much the same 140 million and 144 million
@@Seablobel8 Sonic made 20M more in the opening.It is your opinion but it is official that sonic did better than detective pikachu.
Ahmad Kazan I never said financially
The day has come.
I grew up on Sonic, not Pokemon, so I’m obviously quite biased
Same but with pokemon
Me too but with pokemon
I Like both so oof
I grew up with both and preferred sonic along with yu gi oh. Much better in my opinion.
For me it's the opposite I grew up on Pokémon not sonic.
As a big sonic and Pokémon fan I had a blast seeing both in the theaters
What do you like more
As a fan of cute things i had a blast seeing detective pikachu in the theaters
"both these movies are set on earth" Eric, THE POKEMON GAMES ARE SET ON EARTH WİTH HUMANS
so are some sonic games.
New Sonic movie is better because it doesn’t have that bullshit “arguement before rejoicing to climax” scene like Detective Pikachu did!
Yeah it was forced to have Detective Pikachu run away for what he thought he did and Tim doesn't even care so what's the point of Pikachu/Tim's father to run away, Sonic on the other hand argued with Tom because he doesn't want him to abandon greenhill and leave the people without a good officer
Overall Sonic The Hedgehog Movie was fun to watch when I saw in theaters, Detective Pikachu was meh and I was a bit disappointed with that film but the pokemon did look good in live action
Agreed Imagine that in the sonic movie
Yeah, but Sonic has a fart joke that no one laughs about and two unnecessary flosses
MeAndEverything When I went to the theatre to see the movie a kid actually laughed when Sonic did the floss. When the movie was over that same kid went in front of the screen and started flossing.
@@theminecraft2516 I'm sorry you had to witness that
I remember being bored watching Detective Pikachu all the way through. For Sonic, I got more enjoyment out of it.
I prefer Sonic, was raised with the sonic character so it’s my preferred movie and I enjoyed the movie a lot more than pikachu but I enjoyed both
Glad Sonic did better then Birds of Prey at the box office
Weird how Honest Trailers came out with Sonic the same time as this.
Yh that’s what I also thought I clicked on this and I got the honest trailers notification right adter
Amazing video. Can't wait for the next one. (You inspired me to try and buy these movies on DVD so thanks😃)
Yo my favorite UA-camr uploaded :o
Awesome music choices for this video. Especially the Tears of Life and Three on Three from the first Pokemon movie
Such underrated soundtracks
My favorite is the Lugia song
I like how nobody acknowledged the fact that you said Tim instead of Tom, but hey his dentist calls him Tim lol
Thank you so much. I've been waiting for this match up. I enjoyed both films, though i personally liked Sonic more due to being a bigger fan of that franchise than Pokemon.
One Like Sonic, One Comment Detective Pikachu
SONIC
Even though I'm a sonic fan, I watched both of these movies and I personally agree with everything you said.
I actually found Sonic the hedgehog more funny
Me too
Agreed
Pikachu: "I know you're out there, and I know you're real!"
Sonic: "No I'm not!"
I honestly do prefer Sonic
Another banger! Also Eric, would you consider doing ranking videos? Such as ranking the mcu or the conjuring universe films. Just a suggestion though!
Its a very good suggestion. I DID consider ranking the DC movies recently, the Marvel movies will be a much bigger challenge as they have SO MANY movies. But yeah, I will definitely do some ranking videos at some point.
Eric Carter what are your thoughts on the upcoming Batman movie?
It sounds awesome so far. I LOVED The Long Halloween comic and much like The Dark Knight, this new Batman movie seems to be taking inspiration from it.
I also trust the Director Matt Reeves. He made the two recent Planet of the Apes movies and his directing and overall visual style seems PERFECT for a character like Batman.
So I can't wait to see it. It's just a shame that the movie is gonna take much longer to come out as they only finished 25% of filming.
Eric Carter lets hope that they’ll use the time they have to improve on what they already have (also I saw leaks of the set, and it turns out that the police blimps from Batman TAS are going to be in this movie’s version of Gotham).
@@EricCarter12 Really? If so I can't wait!
I really gotta say I loved this review, it felted real, unbiased and honest. You did a fantastic job with this review! My rating for this review is a 10/10.
I think you should compare Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory vs Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.
Great video Eric! I loved the style the titles and music had with the actual video! I honestly love ur channel so much and i think u r so underrated!! Btw, I have a question. U mentioned months ago that u were making a ghostbusters VS video and we haven't heard anything since. Is that still being worked on eric or is something else happening? Thank u for this amazing video buddy!! :)
Thanks for all of your music suggestions guys!
I got LOADS of music suggestions from you and I went through ALL of them. And I’m sad to say that they did not really fit with the style of videos that I make. So after much pondering and searching I decided to go with unofficial orchestra music of the original and iconic Sonic themes. Aswell as music from Pokemon The First Movie and Pokemon 3 The Movie.
I hope you guys enjoy the video!
Can u do an Insidious vs video with all of the sequels
Or the conjuring vs conjuring 2
Can you please make Spider-Man ps4 vs Batman : Arkham Knight
My plan with The Conjuring is to make a three way versus video when the third movie comes out. So I'm gonna hold off on that one until then. ;)
Yay mines got in!! Thanks Eric carter love your content.
Eric Carter ok the director of la Larona directed the 3rd so I won’t be surprised if it is awful
Awesome video!! I didn't think these movies would interest me in the slightest, and Sonic still doesn't, but Pikachu was quite impressive. Thanks for making this!
When I saw this pop up in my notifications, I stopped the UA-cam video I was watching to see this one. I've been waiting SO LONG for this video to come out, and I'd been so eager to hear your thoughts on it! :D
Also, with regards to the question you had about how Tails would've looked with the old design: he actually hadn't been designed yet. When Paramount released the first trailer, showing off Sonic's old design, all the footage in that trailer was the only footage where they inputted CGI at the time, insinuating that they didn't create Tails for the end-credits scene yet, which means that he didn't get added in until way after Sonic got his redesign. But if Paramount didn't change Sonic's design, then Tails would've been made with a more disturbing incarnation as well, but thankfully, he wasn't.
I saw the notification come up when I was watching pyrocynical’s video on ‘hunt down the freeman’
Also, we’re all are glad that they canned the old design before tails was given a design like that
You are actually wrong. Tyson Hesse (the guy that made Sonics new movie design) said that there was also a Tails design made and they had to redesign him as well.
@@eguyigbin6987 Oh, did he? I heard from a UA-cam channel who did lots of research into the Sonic movie that Tails' appearance at the end was what they had originally planned from the start, but that they hadn't made the CGI for him yet. If Tails actually DOES have an old design, then I wonder what he would've looked like, too.
@@Terrifyger I think that they didn't fully render Tails design
Anyone who seen the sonic movie trailer when it first came out would have never predicted it would turn out this good
Finally entertainment thank you Eric
Your welcome buddy!
@@EricCarter12 Charlie and the chocolate factory vs willy wonka and the chocolate factory
Thanks for the vs video looking forward to the next one
Not to be rude, but all I heard from that vid was nitpicking.
Another great video! Really good work, man! I wonder what the live-action Uncharted film and TLOU HBO miniseries will look like...
I love your video and keep up good work
Ryan Reynolds: 43
Justice Smith: 23
He just 20 years older and is his dad? OK...
My dad is only 17 older than me
Arty Castro Or maybe he’s not the same age. Or you just want to suck sonic’s ring.
Sonic is totally the best
Personally, I prefer Pokémon: Detective Pikachu for a few reasons:
Better World Building.
More Refrences to the Video Games and TV Adaptations.
Better Cast (Not Counting the Villain. Jim Carrey is the E.G.G.M.A.N.)
Better VFX.
Better Action.
Better Soundtrack.
I love your verses videos why I don't agree with your birds of prey opinion I love the amount of work that goes into it and I love be watching them, it has inspired me to make one on Minecraft dungeons vs Minecraft Storymode season 1
I want them to make a Yu-gi-oh live action movie. That would be great. I grew up more with Digimon then Pokemon, but I did see the Pokemon movie with Mewtwo in it; all those evil versions of different Pokemon was pretty neat.
That's going to be kind of tricky to do. I'm not sure how the general audience will except things like how the fate of the world tends to lie on a children's card game. Sure fans will know and get stuff like it being a ancient game from Egypt and all but not everyone else. Also the hair. U can't do Yugi without the hair. Anime hair tends to not translate to live action as shown with what happened to Gokus hair in that film I won't say the name of.
I Think they'd do a disservice to digimon and people would write it off as an even more pokemon clone than they already thought it was
Plus it would just be a humans and monster pets who fight together just like pokemon
Yu gi Oh would be much better and original!!
@@joshchiang5995 maybe they could do GX? He has the least crazy hair out of all the yu gi oh protagonists (not that newer one with green hair)
@@cocodragonblazedtea7803 hmmm GX huh? Sure Jaiden/Judai does have the more standard hair, but he's not as recognizable to the general Audience as Yugi.
@@joshchiang5995 fairs
16:59 Yes Tails has a original design, I remember the director of the sonic movie said that it was always going to end like that. Tyson just helped redesign tails including his tracker into a one handed miles electric
I liked Sonic more and that is only because of Jim Carrey
The sonic movie is fun, but the detective pikachu is richer in my opinion
Hey, What About The Sanic Meme Drawing?
I was sooo excited when I clicked this
Sonic movie 2 vs detective Pikachu now
Eric, please do Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle vs Jumanji: The Next Level.
The next level is better
Don’t worry I asked the same thing and he said he was working on it
I hope we see the shining vs doctor sleep next. I LOVE THOSE FILMS
Good job Eric
Are you ever gonna review the third season of Series of Unfortunate Events, I loved the first two videos and would like to know your opinion on the conclusion.
I'm working on that video next. ;)
I'm going to get back to watching the rest of the show whilst simultaneously working on other videos.
to me detective Pikachu was better i want a sequel to the movie
17:30 Uh Eric? The world of pokemon presented in Detective Pikachu IS the fictional world.
Edit: Okay, I feel i should clarify so I don't sound like a jackass. I understand what you mean by wanting video game movies to only take place in the their fictional world, basically remove any human or "real" elements, but when it comes to pokemon it'd be kinda difficult to do that since humans always had a major presence since the start. Sure, there are games like pokemon mystery dungeon where it's just the pokemon w/o humans. but still.
Both are good, but Detective Pikachu is just better in almost every way for me. The chemistry between Tim and the Pikachu is really good and the story is a lot more interesting to me.
I haven't seen Detective Pikachu. So I have to say I love Sonic the Hedgehog more.
Actually you should watch detective Pikachu it's a really good movie I totally recommend it
Yeah it is good. Hell the fact that we got 2 Amazing videogame movies back to back. Detective Pikachu even has a lot of hidden subtleties to it, that can actually make watching it more then once reveal a ton of revelations.
@@joshchiang5995 now to the monster hunter world and mario by illumination,uhhh.
Am I the only one who thinks that a Sequel for the Sonic Movie would actually be far better than the first? The way they set it up makes me in think it might actually focus more on Sonic's world and will have more effort put into the writing.
Have you seen the trailer?! It is gonna be so amazing!!
@@ladyofnoxus6733 yes. This comment aged well thankfully
@@Jonkstrap right! I was hesitant but with how well the first one was im excited for the second.
@@ladyofnoxus6733 hell yea
I'm so glad someone other than me pointed out how unfunny and forced the fart joke in Sonic was. I even begged the director on Twitter not to include any in the sequel. Also, Detective Pikachu DOES take place in a completely fictional world, dude!
Why it was forced and unfunny?Nothing was forced in the movie,even the floss was explained.Also that's the most jokes sonic says in sonic colors.
@@ahmadkazan7994 It wasn't funny though.
Hewy Toonmore You begged the director on twitter? Get a life dude
it really reminds me of intro cutscene from Smash bros ultimate where Sonic tries to save Pikachu from disappearing
Who do you prefer Sonic or Mario
Sonic. But I like Mario's younger brother Luigi, more than I like Mario. XD
Mario
Hey I know you mainly just do movies that have recently come out but I just watched Upgrade the other day and thought it would be cool if you did a vs video between Upgrade and Venom. Since they have a lot in common.
I made a Venom VS Spider-Man 3 video and I give a little mini review and comparison of Venom and Upgrade in that video. ;)
@@EricCarter12 you should watch chronicle 2012 it is really good
I watched it years ago. I agree, it was very good. Its a shame that the director's next film after that was Fan4stic.
Detective Pikachu actually got me into the Pokemon franchise believe it or not.
this is my favorite Eric Carter video!
Thanks Ben. I'm glad you enjoyed the video. :)
I think Sonic flossing was forced, cringey, and stupid.
I wouldn't say it's forced since it suprisingly fits well with his character in the movie. And it was only added because the movie was written like 3 years ago when flossing was still a pretty popular trend.
Wow so video game movies are actually doing well now a days I remember the days of the Mario bro’s movie.
Lol I never seen it before but I heard it was bad.
@@SuperSaiyanMaster2024 ha saying its bad is an understatement it doesnt even look or feel like Mario bros apart From Mario and Luigi's suits atleast
@@SuperSaiyanMaster2024 it was not just bad it was a disaster
@@gamalsaad1545 I disagree. It is a guilty pleasure
I think another reason why called the sheriff donut lord was that Chris Pratt was suppose to play the part
Cool
Great analysis on both movies dude👍.
Thanks buddy!
Eric Carter, In the Japanese continuity of the sonic franchise, Sonic and co. have always lived with humans on Earth, so it would have been cool to see a re-imagined Earth with fantasy elements to modern cities and the zones from the sonic stages, as well has have humans and mobians (what the American continuities called the anthropomorphs) coexist. It would have made the biker bar scene make more sense, as there would have been mobians in the bar as well, and sonic could be in disguise because the government had him "wanted" because they though he was Shadow the Hedgehog. Just something I wanted to say, Great video!
I like both movies equally but Sonic The Hedgehog is a little better
Same here
Exactly
Yes soo happy we have a vs video
I Have to Agree with you I both enjoyed Sonic The Hedgehog and Detective Pikachu (for Video Game movies there pretty good) I can't wait to see what next for Video Game movies since there is a sign that the video game movies are getting better.
I think the joke with the people at the bar not being able to realize that sonic is actually not a human was a nice call back to the adventures of sonic the hedgehog where sonic would dress up in gimmicky outfits and confuse the villains much like a classic cartoon character, I don’t think it was intended to be taken seriously.
16:30 The product placement was SUPPOSED to be so obvious it was funny! (with olive garden, that is)
Awesome also I have an Idea for a vs battle
I like how you mentioned hop
the reason why detective pikachu was way better is cus pikachu didnt do the floss
Felt like he had some bias during this video cause he hasn’t gone in depth with Sonic but more so over with Detective Pikachu.
Sonichu!
Was once again never notified of this video
And yes I have the notifications on
7:58 actually Detective Pikachu does take place in the the Pokémon universe
0:14 nice
Thanks. I wanted to make sure that I got the music for both Sonic and Pokémon in the opening of the video.
@@EricCarter12 well, yeah, that to...
@@EricCarter12 if you don’t get the joke, then... uh... well, the rotten tomatoes will tell you
@@sharkwar4284 The critics score have gone down a little now is the only thing that I can see. Is that it?
@@EricCarter12 wait they have? Huh, well the reviews always change all the time, but you didn’t get the joke, which also symbolises that you don’t have a dirty mind
The joke is 69
Both were about equal IMO. I love both and am glad to finally have good live action video game films.
Sorry about your skin condition once BTW.
The Detective Pikachu film does take place in the Pokémon world from the game/anime. They even reference that Mewtwo escaped from the Kanto region. Ryme City is also the city from the Detective Pikachu game.
Hey Eric, have ever considered doing a Rise of Skywalker vs. video with Endgame or Return of the Jedi?
I love that one of the parts you like of detective pikachu is that the Pokémon are on drugs lmao
Team sonic
Just imagine a crossover movie btw Pikach and Sonic with the help of Tom, Tim, Maddie, and Lucy to battle another villain.
Sonic was a lot better than I expected and detective Pikachu was a lot worse than I expected
Now that the second Sonic movie has been scheduled for April 2022, I can't wait to see if you're planning on making a versus video on it
UA-cam: New Eric Carter video uploaded
Me: I'll take that very much, please
Will you be doing a comparison video of Sonic 1 and 2?
I mean I get why you wouldn’t want a sequel to Detective Pikachu
But at the same time I want another live action Pokémon movie. (Not detective Pikachu) but something else??? You know what I mean?
Yeah I know what you mean. And I agree. I just think THIS particular Pokémon world with these particular characters should not have another movie.
I mean if they come up with a smart way of continuing the story then by all means, they can go ahead and make another one. Otherwise they should just leave it here.
Thanks for watching buddy!
I'm most interested in the fact that Ryan Reynolds (Pikachu) and Ben Schwartz (Sonic) portrayed their respective characters through motion capture.
1:32/5:43/5:57/6:16/16:07/16:52
Eric Carter if Digimon would ever have its own live action film, what are your suggestions on how to make it great?
Dude, you should DEFINITELY watch Bill Nighy in About Time. His performance is great and his character is so nice and heartwarming, you wanna hug the sh*t outta him.
Btw, I also enjoyed both movies a lot, but I do believe it was kind of an unfair match. You see, the Pokémon franchise has already had many movies, with some very successful ones, even though they're all animated. Nintendo did pick their movies well after Mario Bros. Sega didn't. They basically said "you wanna make a movie about our beloved franchise? Suuuuure, bring me the money!", thus we had those vomiting inducing things.
And even though I believe Sonic is the most iconic of both, you never really had a "bad pikachu game", Sonic on the other hand... :(
Also, funny thing about them both being kind of paired on the Smash Bros Ultimate game.
Props on how long that comment is XD
I'd say Pikachu is alot more iconic
@@superdude899 not really. Well known it is. But Pikachu doesn't represent Nintendo. Maybe Gamefreak... Sonic does represent Sega.
@@teknomax7883 I mean, he is a member of the highest grossing media franchise ever and with a majority of it having his face on it, I'd say that he's probably more popular than the franchise has almost 17 times less sales than him.
Peter Griffin: shut up Mandy.
Well done review! This is a hard one to chose! Both are amazing! Can you do next the Shining vs Doctor Sleep! 👍🏻
I hope you are safe, be carefull and take care! ❤️
Thanks buddy! I hope you stay safe too.
Maybe one day. But right now I have a lot of other videos that I want to make.
99% of the comments = I like Sonic better because I was raised with Sonic.
I mean yeah something that have been part of your life and your childhood ofc they would like sonic better but they are quite biased tho