"I Was Wrong, Hamas DOES Represent Palestinians": Dr Einat Wilf
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 жов 2024
- Dr Einat Wilf talks to Ollie about how the hypothesis that land/gestures for peace could result in a peaceful settlement between Israel and the Arabs has been empirically disproved. Together they discuss what needs to be done to tackle the roots of the Israeli-Arab conflict, the need to keep UNRWA defunded, as well as the antisemitism and ignorance around the world.
![[UA] NAVI vs MOUZ | BO5 | IEM Rio 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CMBYk0cbGoA/mqdefault.jpg)
Such an important video. I admit that about a year ago I use to go to protests with a shirt that says “looking the occupation in the eye”. I believed that with the right leaders and a lot of hard work - peace would be possible. And then came the 10.7 attack. And I saw Palestinian hatred manifest into something so monstrous, so horrifying that it left me speechless, hopeless and forever changed. You cannot witness such evil and not go through a change. It’s impossible.
Alas... so many rejoice. U chose to go to a protest without knowing facts thus contributing to colkectove trauma, death and persecution of the true victims. What allowed you to fall prey to such lies?seek within. And welcome to awakening.the only other victims are the children of the haters.. who dont know better.
It takes a lot of maturity to change a strongly held belief.
This was clear to rational people from pre 1948 but I can understand how some people convince themselves of anything in exchange for hope. Jared Kushnir serving under Trump was the first political leader who understood that the path to a better future lay not in the Palestinians or in appeasing Iran, but with the Sunni gulf states. Alas, the American Jews still supported the Democrats who have taken the middle east back down the old dark path.
I turn 44 today. As a somewhat aware adult I have witnessed the tail-end of the 1st Intifada, the start of the second, the second war on Lebanon... till today.
I always wanted a Palestinian state AND a safe Israel, but after choosing violence every single time my simpathies with the Palestinians are gone. They truly want the Jews exterminated and they are not even subtle about it.
@mdmommy The narrative of the media, probably. Not everyone learns this in school, and this conflict is so complex and historically charged, you won't understand if you do just a little research. You have to really commit and do *a lot* of very detailed research (history of the region, political entanglements of organizations like the UN, influence of religions on the conflict, identity and ideology of the individual groups, details of warfare and military statistics, human rights, definitions of words like genocide, occupation and apartheid, history of attacks and who started what in reaction to another attack, the mindset of Hamas with willingly endangering their own people, etc.) - that much research takes time and an open mind. Not many people choose to do that in their free time when it's convenient enough to protest 'against bombing' and 'for peace' to feel like a good person, without understanding any of the political background.
I think it's admirable the OG commenter openly admits having been wrong and having grown so much as a person.
A single protester cannot do much harm - now the person will be a thoroughly informed advocate for the other side.
“You can’t want for them what they never wanted for themselves”.
Are you talking about the Palestinian kids?
@@Platypus_Warriordont play dumb.
if you genuinely cared about people from that part of Earth you would not adress those kids in the way you adress them. 😊
@@Platypus_Warrior Palestinian kids want what their parents teach them to want.
@@Ollies2CentsWardill they are kids !! They have nothing to do with grown up conflicts.
Try to think for once
@@Platypus_Warrior But they do have, their parents wont them to be involved . It's a strategy.
I wish more people would realize what Hamas is instead of believing what they want them to be.
Obviously, you don't have a clue
@@chrisgreene2623 He knows more than you...
@@chrisgreene2623assumption is the mother of f up.
Very profound comment! So true!
@@chrisgreene2623 It's not hard to see Hamas is a branch of the Muslim Brotherhood that wants to dominate the world.
The Allies in WWII did not provide any humanitarian aid to Germans and Japanese until they were defeated and surrendered..
@@NeraBuffy Yep , zionism is a very dark satanic death cult. I agree with you
They also didn't worship a demon that causes generations upon generations to behave the same way
@@WalterSpilman nope you never agreed with me and I never agreed with you
Am Yisrael Chai. All the civilised world is zionist.
@NeraBuffy your very strange what do you believe?
I have loved and supported Jews ever since I was born after WW2. My father died fighting Hitler. I am now a Christian and still love Israel. Christ was a Jew.so how can I not love Jews! I know they are God's chosen people. You are the scientists, the inventors, the most Incredible of all people.
Well said.
Would Jesus be cool with bombing children? Jesus would have been pro- Palestine.
They created the Christian religion to conquer the Roman Empire , it worked so well that they conquered Europe and soon the world . Christ is the jewish Messiah , his return means the death for all non-jews : they want the whole planet all for themselves , and only keep a few of us as slaves : that's what every single rabbi says, , not only extreme of fringe ones .
Belief in Christ means that you are a willing slave , that you want to be a servant to these monsters : they ALL think that non-jews (= 99.9 % of the planet ) are sub-human animals , and that only jews have a soul , our gentile souls come from absolute evil : that's why they MUST clean the world from us non-jews .
shush.. chosen people bullshit common land thieves, thankfully thank's to the ICJ that's about to change THANK GOD the ICJ CHOOSE ZIONISTS TO GET OFF THE WEST BANK
May the Creator bless you for your pure heart and moral clarity.
The memory of your Father is a blessing for all the living.
Hamas doesn’t just represent the Palestinians, it’s the essence of what being a “Palestinian” is all about… October 7th is the reason this nationality is was invented for
So true! Former PLO leaders have said that Palestine ONLY exists for strategic, tactical and geopolitical reasons. They get aidmoney from the West, they can attack and kill Jews when ever they want and be a needle in the eyes of Israelian people. Palestine is the Islamic Republic of Irans puppets. They don’t get it that they are being used.🧐
Weird because they are only a few years old.
Yoo are wishing and hoping but remain TRULY ridiculous, making random, unsupported statements.
And what about April 9th? Deir Yassin...
@@stopato5772 How about 1944-48 ziowar against British who were fighting nazis at same time!
Hamas represents palestinians , BECAUSE THEY WERE ELECTED@@Ondolite
As a Christian born and raised in Morocco in the 60s and 70s I would like to share my testimony about my upbringing and my experience among a society shared by mostly 3 Communities ( with the exception of some animists Berbères ) : the Muslims , the Christians ( mostly Catholics ) and the Jewish .
We were taught in my family to respect and interact and with all members of the said communities without prejudice and we in fact did !
We went to school together and shared festivals and foods and there was no political debate among us nor in our family .
This all changed after we moved to France in the mid seventies when I started attending a grammar school . This is were I learned that I was potentially a “ fascist “ or a “catho “ ( worse than being just a Catholic for some reason 😅 ) in the schoolyard !!!
A Communist student was present at the entrance of our school most of everyday distributing pamphlets to encourage us to participate in political meetings held at school !
I personally saw him as an old unhappy/ angry soul and never attended any of the meetings .
However the pressure was such that I did change the way I dressed to fit into the leftist mold and started to learn about different causes especially that of the Saharaouis and the Palestinians because they were pressed in us on a daily basis . There were regular petitions in the streets of Paris for these causes .
As an adolescent you do want to fit in and be considered a “ good person “ fighting for the right causes . Be “ morally “ correct .
Unfortunately ( or happily ) I am now realizing that the narrative they fed us all these years is biased and wrong and that the teachings of my parents were right .
How I wish I could speak up for Israel without being called a fascist and a colonialist every time I try to share my thoughts on this issue .
God bless us / you all
I had participated in that mess. It leaves me angry, in a good way, that I was duped so heavily with sheer nonsense, but not funny nonsense, deadly nonsense.
I'm a foreign Christian currently in Morocco and it is awesome here
Thanks for sharing your story. You can speak up. You just have to get good at refuting the points by knowing your history, geography and religion very well. The more people who do speak up, the better.
Lucky you. It would be nice if everyone could feel like that... including Jews.
@@grevisse6757
As long as the Moroccan king heads the country Christian’s should be safe there ; however I belong to the wave of Europeans who were “ encouraged “ to leave the country we were born into following what was called at the time the “ marocanisation “ in the mid seventies. As you may know the “ droit du sol “ doesn’t apply there 😢
My Palestinian friends, who have long lived in Switzerland and who have become thoroughly Swiss with Swiss values, strongly support Israel.
You mean your Arab-Muslim friends who have long lived in Switzerland...
Palestinian-Swiss folks who strongly support Israel. Not just support but *strongly* support.
That's some complete believability there mate.
@@anna-tn8mg well, I see your point, but they describe themselves as ‘Palestinian’
Exactly
@@morganlefey Well, the description must be legitimate to stay. I am tempted to describe myself as the Queen of the Universe, but I am pretty sure the Universe won't call me this way.
Your interviews are always great. Dr. Einat have done a brilliant work. Well done both of you. Long live Israel 🇮🇱
Thank you for being able to listen to the amazing program. May God Almighty have mercy on His people, Israel. From South Africa! Praying for Israel all the time! ❤❤❤
It won't live very long .. this criminal state
@@marlenemuller4472you fundamental people you are sick people this state is criminal state period..
She is CORRECT! Nothing meaningful can occur on that playing field until the Palestinian MINDSET OF DEADLY BELIEFS is changed. She is 100% correct.
Well how about peace? Something the previous non_zionists jews gave the Palestinian Arabs and were rewarded for. The problem is Zionism
I wish my country Norway could send our foreign minister Espen Barth Eide to Dr Einat Wilf for some adult education. He has so many blind spots and there is so much he does not understand.
Norway, Ireland and Spain should know better. Either their governments are ignorant or they are aware of reality and are cheering on Israel's destruction Also these three countries have mistakenly taken in so many Muslim immigrants that they are afraid of the fifth column they have now in their midst.
Norwegian current government is antisemitic
Your Foreign Minister understands well international law, and that the violations of the apartheid Israeli military occupation regime (according to UN reports) against international and humanitarian law through the daily massacres it commits against the Palestinians is unacceptable and must be stopped in accordance with international law and the humanitarian pledge not to repeat the tragedy of the Jews in the Holocaust against anyone. Another people. It is understood that this woman, with her clear lies, justifies the killing of Palestinians and depriving them of the right to self-determination
nobody owes Palestine jack shit, you could give them a mountain of gold and it would still be a failed state
Thank you for having Einat Wilf on. She is amazing
She is an academic charlatan with her risible historical revisionism.
I'm from Croatia and I really have to applaud the logic and clarity of Dr Einat on this matter, especially what she said in the end. BRAVO!!!
She is good
I agree the closing statements were extremely poignant
Croatian too! I just love the common sense, wisdom, eloquence and the lack of hatred that the other side have in abundance.
Jewish people are intelligent, good and always ready to help; the people we should all look up to!
Am Yisrael Chai from your loyal friend and supporter ❤🇮🇱
I'm from Croatia, and as a Christian I say, we should not take the fall for what those two merchant tribes are up to. Let the two merchant tribes brawl it out among themselves. Israel can easily win if other countries didn't get involved and kept Israel on a leash. It's like someone wants to prolong this war for as long as possible. Taking a more defensive stance requires more weapons than just going offensive and taking care of business.
We as Christians are not supposed to get involved in merchant business. But it seems that weapon merchants are making big bucks right now from our hard earned money. It's a scam.
The attempt to differentiate Palestinians from hamas is nothing but a wishful thinking of Israelis who simply want to believe that peace is possible and of Westerners who don't have the capability of understanding non democratic/non Western cultures.
All you have to do is listen to what Palestinians are saying themselves and not make assumptions.
Exactly I’ve watched a channel from Israel Cory is his name and he talks to all the Palestinians in Gaza they all say no they will not share nothing it’s their land it don’t belong to Jews they occupied them and stole their land which we all know is a big lie and a joke ! To say they Jewish people are not the original indigenous people is so absurd do these Palestinians learn proper history? Obviously not
@@shoponadimellc3413 yes the Ask Project channel is very informative and has been going for over 10yrs.
@@shoponadimellc3413it's called The Ask Project and is very informative.
The Ask Project is a youtube channel where they interview real people on both sides of the argument. It's fascinating tbh and has been going for years.
I think in previous generations and there was less of an echo chamber. You had some Palestinians who dogmatically wanted to destroy Israel and you had some who were more modern thinking less dogmatic and we’re OK to work with and for the Israelis but overtime that second way of thinking, evaporated up as Gaza and the PA became Echo Chambers and fewer and fewer Palestinians had interaction with actual Israelis.
Dr Einat Wilf you are Israel’s and the Jewish People’s voice of clarity! Thank you 🙏🏼 💙👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼✡️✡️✡️🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🎗️🎗️🎗️🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼💙 Am Yisrael Chai ✡️🎗️🇮🇱
Israel.
Do not give land back.That belongs to Israel.Don't make the same mistake again.Love israel❤
Land does not belong to Israel.
White people are not indigenous to the region.
It is not about land. It is all about murder and establishing caliphate.
do not give land back? It wasn't theirs! Do you hear yourself?
@@perimotilaran3228 Sure, Israel is ours, Arabs were invaders who stole it from us, the rightful owners.
I agree. Look what happened to all of those people who got kidnapped soon after Netanyahu made a ceacefire agreement with Hamas leaders in hopes of finallly establishing peace in Israel. How many more ceacefires is it going to take that are not being honored by Hamas and how many more rockets having to be shot down is it going to take before the majority of people officiating in the U.N. finally are getting what is really happening to the detriment of all people living in that region. That region which is being coveted by one after another foreign leader who only wants to rename the region for themselves while pretending to care for the becoming more disadvantaged there all the time people as result.
What a phenomenal guest. I’m very impressed. An amazing interview. Thank you both. :)
From a non-Jewish believer in the God of Israel, a believer in His assignment of the land to Israel, and a supporter of Israel.
Brilliantly summarised by Einat, as usual! She has a crystalline ability to explain the core of the problem in Israel.❤
This is the best interview I have heard for months. She’s amazing and hits so many topics statehood Jewish “place”!in society,
UNWRA is the most frustrating part. Listening to him talk in Parliament after all that has been exposed with these scammers.. they must know
They behave same way in Malmo Sweden, France, Germany and soon uk ireland and Spain. Those countries locals better beware during Octobers. They opened their doors like a collective Lebanon.
yes , but it's Israel who is bringing them in Europe : they create permanent wars to destabilize these arab countries , and then the IDF and Israeli NGO's bring the " refugees" in Europe , while they force our politicians ( lobbying , corruption , blackmail .... ) to keep our borders wide open for the last 20 years !
You are so right! I go to Malmö twice a year and it’s appalling.
Here in England, we are already screwed.
In 711 Muslim forces invaded and in seven months conquered the Iberian peninsula.
@@Avagardner2608 because jews opened the gates of alll the cities
FACT: On October 7th, Palestinians celebrated in the streets, distributed cakes, and helped kidnap Israelis to Gaza, into the tunnels. They also, in exchange for money, kept the kidnapped individuals in their homes to blend them into the population.
Every time the IDF went into Gaza with bombs the Israelis would have barbecues and cheer when a bomb landed and killed civilians. Boy what double standards.
@@smcbridemtlby the standard of defense.
@@smcbridemtl provide incontrovertible proof, we're all waiting!
@@stevenlafavor9823 ua-cam.com/video/sAMFaCO5OoI/v-deo.htmlsi=FDaOPYkoAnMaFe8e
@@stevenlafavor9823 ua-cam.com/video/bkkEm_8LZTM/v-deo.htmlsi=LwXJJuMlJVmkt0nZ
I lived through the 2nd Intifada, to this day I am not supporting the 2 state "solution". We let them into Israel, make income and what did that get us?
I am not jewish, but I stand with ISRAEL. which is damn right on all points.
i wonder how long you will be standing..she's on fire! your borders are shrinking & bibi heading off to america with a cartoon drawIng of a bomb saying iran is only a couple month's away from the ...BOMB! ive heard this over 40 year's now
What about the kids in Palestine?
@@Platypus_Warriorwhat about israeli kids who were massacred and kidnaped to Gaza?
@@Platypus_Warrior ask hamas, the responsibles of this mess
@@Platypus_Warrior could it be that their parents, who have radicalized them and want them to die martyrs, have SOME responsibility here? WHY is it that Palestinians are the only groups of people on earth who never have ANY responsibility for ANYTHING they do?
Einstein Wilf is my favorite person to listen about all these issues, she is brilliant.
Thank you so much for your work !
All the lies melt like snow in the sun when confronted with the crystal-clear and rigorous logic of Dr. Einat Wilf. Bravo!!!
That is so beautiful said❤
She got ripped apart at Oxford 😂
@@jesse5457 By woke idiots for telling the truth.. 🇮🇱👍💪
NO! I WON`T BE MUSLIM.
David Lammy says almost 200 UNRWA staff have died in the conflict, but who started the conflict and took an active part in it? He might be "appalled at the allegations that UNRWA staff took part. He prefers to believe that they're all well-meaning. Does he have any idea of how school lessons are structured, and what the textbooks are like? It's time someone showed him the UNRWA Summer Camp video.
Israel so far has not presented convincing evidence and thus more and more nations are refunding UNWRA
My friend did not believe me when I told him that Hamas governed Gaza. Hopefully he did some research since then.
Einat Wilf so much reminds me, in her clear-headed thoughts and brilliant analyses, of Golda Meir. I seriously hope she will run for PM when the next Israeli elections loom!
I would vote for her, but 60% of this country are morons and would have criminals and anarchists in power 😔
Thank you!!! Much love from Israel ❤❤❤
I feel like Jews who settled the area then called "Palestine" a lot of times got the land that the Arabs themselves saw as valueless.
Yet the settlers transformed the land, turned desert into fertile land using water irrigation, and built cities on sand dunes. This is what has made it possible to sustain a growing population, of all ethnicities. Then the Palestinian Arabs come and claim all this, that they themselves didn't put effort into, but nonetheless just benefitted from - via trade with Israel. Stating that they have a right to the land as a people and a nation. When their leaders can't even get along.
My conclusion is that if Israel would ever go away, then the area would collapse and cause suffering for millions of people who aren't prepared to run their own country.
You are a racist with a colonial settler ideology
@@gkappa4085 Jews were refugees fleeing for their lives not colonists looking for adventure.
Jews _DID_ create land out of nothing, practically, not only for themselves, but for Arabs too.
At the time, MANY ARABS WERE GRATEFUL FOR HOW JEWISH ADVANCEMENT BOOSTED THEIR PROSPERITY AND HEALTH AND LIFE EXPECTANCY.
It would turn into a shit hole like all Muslim countries
@@paultoseland9524amen. It would. Their ideology is so twisted and backwards that every izz lamb ic country has failed.
@@gg_riderwell said
Dr. Wilf is 100% correct.
I agree!
If they were born in Gaza and live in Gaza how are they refugees?
Ask the UN
Refugee status is inherited for Palestinian's
The world is run by a conglomerate of criminal organizations who took over their countries. They're in league and so they get to determine the policy.
A Palestinian born in Gaza among their own people are called refugees.
@forever it seems paultoseland9524
Not Jewish heren 🖐🏾...but l most definitely stand with Israël. I always will 🇰🇪❤️🇮🇱🎗🎗
This was a brilliant informative discussion. Evidence and truth and clarity
Wonderful talk❤
Love from Israel ollie😊❤
Thanks!
I have heard people saying essentially that the Jewish claim to the land of israel is illegitimate because the British didn’t have the right to give it to Jews. Interestingly, I haven’t heard anyone say a single peep in the same regard about what is now called “Jordan.” Hmmm…. I wonder why?
The British only halfway "gave it to the Jews". More lies.
One, the ENTIRE land was never inhabited by either Arabs or Jews. One map shows spotty settlements of Arabs in green and Jews in blue. The main color is white, nobody.
Two, it was NOT sovereign territory of the residents. It was territory of the Turkish Empire, down thru much of Saudi Arabia, until the Turks ceded it to the British. The British DID have the right to divide the land .. that's how they created Jordan, on 75% of the land that they were allocated to manage.
2.5 the Arabs did not have a state and had never constructed a sovereign state, so the whole point of the British being there was to help them, which they did.
2.6 Even with help from the British and French, the history of Syria after World War 1 was building alliances and breaking alliances, and military coups and forming a new Republic with Egypt and abolishing that Republic, bitter rivalries between the Iraqi baath and the Syrian baath parties,
Three, when the Turks were in control for 400 years, the Turks sold or gave some land to Jews. So did some Arabs. So did some British.
Fast forward through decades of fedayeen violence and k__ng.
The British had enough of Arab mob violence, so they REVERSED all their policies about (also) helping Jews as well as Arabs, and clamped down on Jewish migration in 1937 .. effectively they were assisting the Nazi Final Solution by blocking Jews from escaping Europe.
Jews began to join the Muslim methods, by deploying limited violence against the British.
After World War 2, British packed up to go home, without creating the state of Israel. Brits punted to the United Nations.
The UN proposed the 2nd partition. The British wave goodbye on May 13th. Israel declared itself into existence (it had already been functioning for 9 years) on May 14th. The Arabs launched the war on May 15th.
All they know is, Balfour proposal, British present, presumably a functioning Arab State existed until the British help the Jews break it, and everything began in 1948. Photos of British Palestine maps and a British Palestine airport and British Palestine coins prove that "the Palestinian people" (who rejected that identity until 1964) were a thriving independent sovereign society and nation long before the 1948 war.
Total malarkey.
The British mandate was about Israel, but in the end, Israel received only a fraction of the land intended for her. The Arabs got most of it. And now they want even more. All of it, in fact.
If the British didn't have the right to give it to the Jews, then what right would they have to give it to the Arabs? The fact is, the British had no such right. They were given a trust by the League Of Nations to see through the establishment of a Jewish state. It was a responsibility to be carried out under Int'l law. The British reneged and tried to give it the Arabs, who BTW, called themselves the Arabs. BTW, what gave the British the right to divide up Greater Syria and create Palestine and then trans-Jordan? The Arabs complained about it. They said there was never a country called Palestine and they said they themselves were Syrians. What gave the Arab muslims the right to invade and colonize Jerusalem and put a mosque on the Temple Mount?
@@jefffeldsteincoz it’s where all the arabs are!! Europeans are from Europe!! Why does everyone have German names and not Hebrew names??
The jews have no place in jehuda?
Fantastic, illuminating and thought provoking discussion. Thank you. One point I want to confirm: as a Christian here in Sydney, Australia, I am yet to speak to another Christian who does not believe in the Zionist cause. We love Israel. ❤❤
Thank you all from Israel❤
I have read a few of Einat books and she is brilliant. The end of the podcast the clarity of what to say and do is incredible.
I love these intelligent guests you have on. Suddenly, the political left and right identities fall away, and we see the deeper issue.
This an amazing conversation, your questions are excellent and Einat is someone that should be listened to by everyone, well done Ollie. ❤
Wow she’s so brilliant in every word she utters. I literally took notes. I would love to see her debate the top Palestinian debater
Wow. This woman is truly wise.
Einat explains everything so clearly and to the point. I could listen to her forever
What a brilliant woman. This has been a great synopsis of the issue.
I also felt that Biden should not have said thatthe palestinians were not hamas when he went tIsrael
Why? Is all Isrealis Orthodox ? I answer is no? Then Biden was right !
Awesome she is in your show! ❤🎉
Einat Wilf!!!!!
😂@@nadakbar
I love Prof. Einat, she is a genious.
Back when I was a leftist with "compassion" supporting Palestinians in the American streets, I too was under the delusion that they ONLY wanted a chair to sit down, a place to stand, a sovereign state with self-rule.
That is what Dr James Lindsay characterizes as the Motte and Bailey propaganda strategy, stating the "reasonable" view when confronted and defensive, then reverting to the unreasonable insane arguments when in safety among comrades in the lush valley.
I was unfamiliar with the semantics and history of the so-called "Palestinian identity", so I could not grasp that the subtext of that identity, an identity (Palestinian) that they REJECTED in the 1930s, really meant nothing less than "annihilate all the Jews" and "Khaybar, Khaybar.." or at bare minimum, totally abolish Jewish sovereignty and self-determination on even one square kilometer of that land area ...
... With the underlying argument that "Mohammed said so" though Einat puts less weight on Islamism and more weight on other intersectional Left ideologies.
When someone says to me "God (any God) said so, so it's true"...I have many doubts.
This is really insightful
Fantastic talk!!!
As always, Einat Wilf eloquently simplifies and breaks down all of the salient issues. Every time I hear someone call for a two-state solution, I think "and just how do you accomplish THAT when the people on the other side not only are not interested in having their own state but want to destroy the Jewish state that exists."
Incredible discussion. Thank you.
No true Christian can be anti-Zionist or antisemitic. God is faithful to keep His covenants with His people. If He is able to break His covenants with Israel, He can just as easily break them with us. But He is faithful!
This!!!
This woman is awesome I've listened to her many times ❤
Thank you, Ollie and Dr Wilf for you great conversation. Long live a strong and vibrant Israel! There is much forgiveness and repentance needed from and for many early Christians and some present day Christians regarding the dismissal and derogatory perspectives on the Jews, and the sometimes devastating destructive results of those perspective. I am a Jew who converted to Catholicism through a many decades long journey that is much too long and convoluted to describe here. I have learned that there are some contradictory ideas that have been around since the beginning of Christianity. I know Catholics who believe that the Jewish people AND ISRAEL, itself are ESSENTIAL to the culmination of humanity's redemption before the Lord. In fact, I read a book several years ago (darn, I wish I could remember the author or the name of the excellent book), written by Jewish convert to Catholicism, who stated what many, many present day Protestant Christians and Catholic Christians believe: that it was necessary, in God's redemptive plan, for the Jews to be the last to accept Jesus as Messiah, otherwise the Gospel would not have spread to the rest of the world, but would have simply become a Jewish sect, kept apart from the rest of humanity. I will stop here so as not to become too verbose. One of my main points is that history and humanity are very complicated and beware of making over-simplifications and over-generalizations. I, as a Christian and a Catholic, stand strong and firm with and for Israel and in deep faith in God, the Almighty! Amen
Fascinating analysis. Thank you!
Shes so right!!
The Palestinians voted for hamas!
And over 80% of them approved of the acts committed by Hamas on October 7. If it walks like a duck it is a duck.
They voted for Hamas 17 years ago. Since then there has been no elections.
What a woman! I think she is really honest and she has a good way to point out politics. Thanks!
Brilliant eye opening and educational!
I would love to see Dr. Einat Wilf sit down and interviewed by Charlie Kirk!
Wow. Fantastic talk. Thank You for making such rational ideas easily understood. Much appreciated.
For me, It’s refreshing that a leftist could analyse and come to this conclusion; to see what is obvious to the people on the right or religious. It’s not about poor, dispossessed ‘Palestinians’ and victimhood, it’s fundamentally about Islamic conquest since 7th century. I recently read the autobiographies of Ariel Sharon, Benjamin Netanyahu and Ehud Barak and garnered helpful insights to this conflict. I am amazed how many on the left in the west and tragically even in Isreal are naive and support the false premise of Arab/Palestinian propaganda against the Jews.
I mean Sharon pulled Isreal out of Gaza, Barak withdrew from Lebanon and the violence has paradoxically escalated, yet Barak would want to handover Jerusalem to the Arabs, still believing that would solve the problem. Clinton was flabbergasted when Arafat said Jews didn’t have a temple in Jerusalem historically!
Thats how much they can lie and propagate it if it serves their purpose-Taqiya.
Einat, you’re a gem. We are so lucky to have you.
By far the best explanation of the conflict. Wilf is amazing.
I like and admire Einat but I disagree with her remarks at minute 55. People have no knowledge of the Arab war of conquest and the brutal impossibility of living with Salafists.Most people are soft hearted and are in a delusion that Jews and Islamists can live peacefully if only Jews would try harder.Lamy was lying deliberately , just a big ignoramous.
Einat is of the belief that Islam _can_ change, though not that it will change anytime soon.
I think it was Haviv who talked about an Islamist party in Israel that was the most militant, but the leader completely flipped to the reverse. In a nutshell, that Israel exists so that is the will of Allah.
There's a short video on Twitter of a Saudi man saying the same thing, for a variety of his own reasons, that Palestinians have no legitimate claims on anything, and he calls them despicable, not just regarding Israel but overall.
@@gg_rider
It hasn’t changed in 700 years. Granted, the majority of its adherents don’t really know in depth, what’s written in their book and the Hadiths, otherwise, some would walk out of it, given a choice. The water is poisoned at the very source, there’s no amount of decontamination that would change it downstream.
This conflict is 1400 years old.
The moment we acknowledge this fact is when we are able to tackle the true nature, the source, a 1400 year old book, from which all this stems.
Exactly!!!
Everything started with their fake prophet Muhammad 😒
Let us review the Torah and the violence. Amalek for an example spouted by Bibi and his crew.
@@smcbridemtl Hamas and everyone who helped them , are Amalek indeed !
And that's exactly what Israeli politicians meant.
Do you have any other stupid comments ? 🤔🧐
@@Mj19861 Yes I have another stupid comment. How are children deemed Amalek? There are rabbis in Israel who preach the children can be killed. The IDF have a T shirt with a pregnant muslim women with a bulls eye..saying one bullet, 2 kills. You have your share of sick puppies.
That's if you want to consider that the Jews are the true religion. But they're a religion. They're one story of many. And a story of justification for taking land just like the colonizers who used the Bible. BUT, if you remove the idea that their God is true one then it no longer matters. It comes down to the FACT that no matter who you are, you are NOT an owner of any land in this world, you INHERITED it and your people most likely conquered it, too. So neither people in this day and age could use history to their favor. They're both descendants of common ancestors. And here we are. The real question isn't who's right, it's how can this be resolved without either group being marginalized? The current war will make the matter worse. Netanyahu doesn't think so, but 70% of Israelis do think so. With a new leader, they are hoping for less collateral damage, peace deal, and hostage release. The problem is the collateral damage has increased the support for HAMAS. How will this play out? I have no idea.
Einat is such an excellent resercher with a great articulating ability. Thank you.
You are great, Einat. I will listen to you always!
Fascinating talk!!! Very intelligent and informative. Very powerful, clear and to the point.
Einat Wilf 👑👑👑👑💌💌💌
Ollie, I completely agree with your point of view (and that of Yishai Fleisher). Thanks so much.
She's absolutely brilliant, thought provoking. Thank you very much .
Excellent conversation based on 'facts'.
I agree with the interviewer. Israel cannot take the risk of continuing with this status quo of 'two states solution'.
Gaza was a 2 states solution and we all saw what happend.
I literally hate what the early so called Christian’s did to the Jewish people and the Jewish peoples land! I am a Christian and I’ve always been taught to love the Jewish people minus all this weird hatred of Jews and Judaism it’s so weird! The Christian Bible literally only speaks of all good things Jewish! The books are all scripture wrote by Jewish people in the land! It’s crazy to me how many issues it’s caused to our Jewish friends! I am disgusted by it tbh! It’s done so much harm to them, we must ask for forgiveness for our early Christian church that did these things to them! Wow! Makes me feel sorrow that it went this way and we see the damage it created when Christ came for the complete opposite! I pray for the Jewish nation to rise above all of this as they will and always have !
There is forgiveness and repentance needed from many early Christians and some present day Christians regarding the dismissal and derogatory perspectives on the Jews, and the sometimes devastating destructive results of those perspective. I am a Jew who converted to Catholicism through a many decades long journey that is much too long and convoluted to describe here. I have learned that there are some contradictory ideas that have been around since the beginning of Christianity. I know Catholics who believe that the Jewish people AND ISRAEL, itself are ESSENTIAL to the culmination of humanity's redemption before the Lord. In fact, I read a book several years ago (darn, I wish I could remember the author or the name of the excellent book), written by Jewish convert to Catholicism, who stated what many, many present day Protestant Christians and Catholic Christians believe: that it was necessary, in God's redemptive plan, for the Jews to be the last to accept Jesus as Messiah, otherwise the Gospel would not have spread to the rest of the world, but would have simply become a Jewish sect, kept apart from the rest of humanity. I will stop here so as not to become too verbose. One of my main points is that history and humanity are very complicated and beware of making over-simplifications and over-generalizations. I, as a Christian and a Catholic, stand strong and firm with and for Israel and in deep faith in God, the Almighty! Amen
Breaking News - Jesus was a Jew.
@@joso7228 Absolutely!
Bless your heart
Fascinating insights. Stuff I have never known. Thanks to you both 🙏🌻👏👏
She is a national treasure! Thank you so much for having her
Einat very bright and knowledgable! Her book " The War of Return" clears out the delusion about " palestinian cause". Its a must read.
I love you, Dr. Einat Wilf. Thanks, for your evidence. I agree with you. You are brilliant and courageous.
I agree 100% with Dr Wilf.
Agree with Dr Einat Wilf 100%.
Great analysis! Arabs essentially suffering from, what could be summarized as, narcissistic injury from someone they consider inferior to them
You are describing yourself.
No-one is above anyone.
The problem of people who realizes that their hipótesis is wrong after years of trying to prove it right, is the awful amount of damage, death and pain that this provokes… but they seem no to feel any remorse
Brilliant, brilliant, brilliant. Great interview.
Such a refreshing and brilliant turn of thought. That Palestinian is not an identity as much as an ideology. Palestinianism. The New red flag. Makes such clarity of a heretofore morass of emotional half baked ideas. Thank you so much.
I love this great advocate for the Jews. I am a Christian and understand fully that the Jews belong to Israel. I support and respect Zionism.
I don’t think she is right about the Christians overlooking the Jewish ruin as something essential to Christian theology. The reason the Christians did not build a church on the Temple Mount is that Jesus, the Jewish Messiah, told His Jewish disciples and Apostles that after His resurrection, the Holy Spirit of God would dwell in the believers’ hearts, not in a house. We, the church are the temple of God because when you believe that Jesus actually rose from the dead, God sends His Holy Spirit to dwell in you. It is out of respect for Jewish tradition and God that they would not replace the temple.
She is not correct in that. I agree absolutely with you.
I do believe she means the early Christians who was more violent and aggressiv then today.🧐 We have evolved as human beings since then.😅 Can’t say the same about the islamic people. Many of them still lives in the old age… hating Jews and Christians. It even okey for them to lie to infidels (Christians, Catholics, Hindus, Buddists, Jewish)!🤔
Agree. Palestinian deserve freedom and peace but not terrorist leaders
Excellent ❤
Thank you for being a Warrior of Truth, Justice and Knowledge!🙏🏼💕🇮🇱💪🏼 Keep up the good work!👏🏼🙏🏼 Am Yisrael Chai!// Love and light from Sweden 🙏🏼🇸🇪❤️🇮🇱💪🏼🌟🫶🏼🪽
Australia did same $46m. Disgusting
There’s a reason the other Arab countries don’t want them.
All ways a good listen, thanks.
Its crazy to me that despite having a Phd, despite rethinking her hypothesis, etc, she still labels her beliefs as a peace activist and a lefty…the main problem with this line of thought is that you need to be a peace activist for yourself and your people first. If the side who you have been advocating for betrays you enough to change your position, ask yourself: maybe I had an ideology that betrayed the truth…
Love Dr. Wild this was great ❤❤
Not only is hamas the same as palestine, it has became the same as islam.
And where is hamas from? If not from palestine then where from?
Einat Wilf brilliant argument ❤
Wilf speaks the truth. Clarity is so important!
Excellent. Thank you
My question to Dr. Einat Wilf is, aside from herself, what leader would she recommend to stand up to the US and the world in such a bold way. Gantz is weak and Lapid is a dimwit. Who in all of Israel can do this job? Natanyahu is continuing his efforts in Gaza despite US pressure. And yes he's not perfect but who in Israel can do a better job. Perhaps it should be DR. Wilf.
Unfortunately she already proved she cannot do the job... though she talks a big talk. She sees herself as part of the Israeli elites - and those elites she believes are only on the left - which is why she says she is still a leftist
Benet or Liberman
@@YaelGD LOL... the 2 biggest crooks in Israeli politics. And this is your sad vision for excellence in Israeli politics, are you for real?
@@YaelGD Bennet and liberman should unite. I would vote for them