The Beach Boys - "Surf's Up" - selected isolated 5.1 channels

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 167

  • @pascalrouen
    @pascalrouen 3 роки тому +46

    Van Dyke Parks was a lyrical genius. Such visual, expressive, symbolic, evocative, and beautiful words.

    • @markpatterson2507
      @markpatterson2507 2 роки тому +3

      I too am a fan of Mr Parks,who has said the lyrics are huge puns and just odd phrases

  • @DavidJackson-ux5wk
    @DavidJackson-ux5wk 8 місяців тому +5

    Amazing.... I've listened to this track for 40+ years, but this mix is stunning. Thank You.

  • @gregmock6808
    @gregmock6808 3 роки тому +32

    this is pure genius...that falsetto is pure as crystal

  • @wtdorlack
    @wtdorlack 3 роки тому +56

    This is my favorite song...ever.

  • @Claytone-Records
    @Claytone-Records 4 роки тому +42

    And here we have another version of this classic to enjoy. Sweet.

  • @richardcerbini3257
    @richardcerbini3257 3 роки тому +66

    Awesome! I really believe if SMiLE had been released, this song would be as iconic as "Hey Jude" or "Let It Be" are for the Beatles and as well known worldwide.

    • @topsyandpip56
      @topsyandpip56 3 роки тому +17

      A little optimistic. Capitol never had faith in Brian's vision and refused to promote. That's why Brian took it upon himself to hire Derek Taylor, and though Derek did manage to create a rumour mill behind Smile, it would have never gained international recognition without Capitol's backing. It would have been a similar story as Pet Sounds; widely loved in the UK and select pockets of Europe, and completely ignored by the American public.

    • @richardcerbini3257
      @richardcerbini3257 3 роки тому +5

      @@topsyandpip56 please keep in mind they were on top of the world musically at this point in time, even besting the Beatles in England in a polll for Worlds Most Popular Band. Rubber Soul, Pet Sounds, Revolver, Good Vibrations, Pepper. they were slugging it out creatively and the Boys bounced back from Pet Sounds sales disappointment with Good Vibrations #1 Million seller here in the US. Momentum was on their side to be sure. Capitol made a commercial for record distributors stating "We're sure to sell a million units...in January!" They had pressed 500,000 plus album covers for SMiLE so you can bet they were planning on massive promotion for that record.

    • @Barryislarge
      @Barryislarge 3 роки тому +7

      I think so too, The album is wild and really experiemental for the time, like vegetables and heroes and villains are strange, not to mention the elements. But it in no way was too experimental for the time. I think people would have appreciated it for what it was, a wild strange masterpiece. todays rendition of SMiLE by Brian and his band is incredible even by todays standard, it kicks the crap out of Pet Sounds and leaves it in the dust, IMO

    • @richardcerbini3257
      @richardcerbini3257 3 роки тому +11

      @@Barryislarge I always remember the Dennis Wilson statement about SMiLE, "It makes Pet Sounds stink, that's how good it is".

    • @matthall7359
      @matthall7359 3 роки тому +4

      @@topsyandpip56 let it be was trashed when it was released as a mediocre follow up that just imitates hey Jude but with less soul.
      Don’t give so much importance on what the media thinks, had this seen actual release it would have changed the face of music radically just as those tracks did.

  • @kenni123064
    @kenni123064 3 роки тому +16

    Total Brian, just haunting, a story of man, things unforeseen, and just beautiful. Somthing different was lurking in Brian’s soul and whatever it was , call it “Angelic “ or call it “The unexplained “ This was Brian’s last encounter with this whatever it may have been!

  • @justinherbert9146
    @justinherbert9146 Рік тому +12

    The best version of this song is Brian playing the piano and just him singing - it was filmed, looked like he was at home, must have been 1966 or 1967 -- amazing footage

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  Рік тому +2

      Yep, that was definitely his home, I think December 1966, filmed for the Inside Pop documentary that aired on CBS. (And that was NOT Leonard Bernstein's voice narrating but David Oppenheim's.) That was actually the SECOND time they filmed Brian singing it: the first time was the studio demo that eventually became the second half of the song. But they used the home performance for the doc instead.

  • @peterwasemiller7654
    @peterwasemiller7654 3 роки тому +64

    Carl sang the first part; Brian came in on “dove nested towers the hour...”

    • @DennisNedryisStillAlive
      @DennisNedryisStillAlive 3 роки тому +8

      They’re voices sometimes sound alike. Do you know who sings ‘Til I Die?

    • @kenni123064
      @kenni123064 3 роки тому +14

      @@DennisNedryisStillAlive agreed very hard sometimes to separate! That’s the beauty of Brian and Carl 😉 Dennis had suck a incredible unique tone! It was the scars of a fragile soul!

    • @kenni123064
      @kenni123064 3 роки тому +8

      One word “GENIUS “ not only Brian, but Van Dyke Parks!

    • @ProjeKtCamus
      @ProjeKtCamus 3 роки тому +5

      Brian sings the solo vocal lines "it kills my soul" etc and is in the vocal stack (the second highest falsetto part).

    • @michaelfrazia4569
      @michaelfrazia4569 3 роки тому

      @@DennisNedryisStillAlive my fave song Brian has written

  • @mustomax
    @mustomax 3 роки тому +27

    What a Masterpiece!

  • @andrewcarnegie589
    @andrewcarnegie589 3 роки тому +102

    Please let me wonder if Mike Love ever figured out wtf "columnated ruins domino" means

    • @fn9six
      @fn9six 3 роки тому +16

      Im still trying to decode Feel flows lol

    • @whiteandright1958
      @whiteandright1958 3 роки тому +45

      Mike is still trying to figure out the hidden meaning of a papa ow mow mow

    • @user-cm9nn9mf6s
      @user-cm9nn9mf6s 2 роки тому +31

      he’s gone bald thinking about it

    • @azami123
      @azami123 2 роки тому +12

      To think that Mike Love didn't want to sing this ...wow!

    • @yoblol
      @yoblol 2 роки тому +14

      Brian: Canvas the town and brush the backdrop
      Mike: Keenvus the tawun iyn bruuuush the beekdrooop

  • @smautomat
    @smautomat 3 роки тому +14

    0:35 - The picture shown is Brian, not Carl.

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  3 роки тому +9

      Okay, for about the seventy-fourth time in the comments here...WE KNOW. That was the JOKE -- it's from a magazine article that mis-identified Brian as Carl. There's another in which Al is mis-identified as Carl.

    • @brmh1667
      @brmh1667 3 роки тому

      @@scatteredfrog Well, be fair, Dennis does look like Mike so calling him Al is a mistake anyone could make.

  • @riespee8634
    @riespee8634 3 роки тому +14

    Master piece.

  • @kimberley1449
    @kimberley1449 2 роки тому +5

    This is one of my favorites. There are a lot of great songs on this album!!!! Still missing all who we have lost and loved!!!

  • @laurencesnow-xh7yh
    @laurencesnow-xh7yh Рік тому +1

    One of the most beautiful vocals ever. Angels from heaven!

  • @AntheaCarson
    @AntheaCarson 3 роки тому +9

    Beautiful

  • @lowden7268
    @lowden7268 2 роки тому +1

    Hauntingly beautiful.

  • @josephharnett5075
    @josephharnett5075 2 роки тому +1

    Your right promoting Pet Sounds And supporting Smile would have made a big difference Also Surfs 🏄‍♂️ Up is a brilliant song my favorite too and would have been a bigger hit

  • @willharris3798
    @willharris3798 2 роки тому

    this sounds real good, thanks scatteredfrog. good work.

  • @pascalrouen
    @pascalrouen 3 роки тому +8

    3:18 wow

  • @davie5045
    @davie5045 2 роки тому

    kahskskd the description is very expressive

  • @jeffcampbell4602
    @jeffcampbell4602 3 роки тому +15

    in my opinion this is the high water mark for Western Civilization. Pure beauty.

    • @DennisNedryisStillAlive
      @DennisNedryisStillAlive 3 роки тому +2

      Yes, The Beach Boys/Brian Wilson’s magnum opus is Surf’s Up in my opinion. The harmonies between the brothers are unbelievable.

  • @FishyTheKid
    @FishyTheKid 9 місяців тому +1

    the falsetto on "columnated ruins domino" is so high and beautiful. I really can't sing that yet. I really hope I can some day

    • @FishyTheKid
      @FishyTheKid Місяць тому

      Update: I can sing it now, though still need to really think about it

  • @brmh1667
    @brmh1667 3 роки тому +3

    Great video, thanks very much. However, the photo at 0:35 secs is of Brian, not Carl as captioned.

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  3 роки тому +7

      I know. That's the joke. It's a scan from a magazine article. I think Al was also misidentified as Carl in another article somewhere.

    • @charliestoops8815
      @charliestoops8815 3 роки тому

      Yeah, isn’t that the “Carl Wilson” photo you used? Al?

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  3 роки тому +3

      @@charliestoops8815 YES! I forgot I included that. :) (Been three years since I did this thing!)

    • @brmh1667
      @brmh1667 3 роки тому +1

      Gave myself a thumbs up there... fair enough!

  • @capitolemiproducer
    @capitolemiproducer 5 років тому +15

    00:40 Not Carl

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  5 років тому +7

      Take it up with whoever captioned that magazine article. :) (You'll see another point when poor Al gets mis-captioned as Carl.)

  • @jeankavanagh1485
    @jeankavanagh1485 9 місяців тому

    Them gorgeous Wilsons ❤❤❤

  • @Wolfsky9
    @Wolfsky9 3 роки тому +24

    1st part is Carl ---------------------2nd part is BW ------------------with Mike coming in at the ending.---------------WolfSky9, 74 y/o

    • @1401minstrel
      @1401minstrel 3 роки тому +5

      @Wolfsky9 Mike comes in singing bass on the third part, but it's Al singing lead on that part.

    • @lowden7268
      @lowden7268 3 роки тому

      contact me Wolfsky9 aka Lowden

    • @darthjesus420
      @darthjesus420 3 роки тому

      @@1401minstrel shit I literally was coming here to say, man I really don’t like mike love, but that lead vocal on the song ending is beautiful (thinking it was mike), now knowing from what you said that that is actually Carl on the song ending, I have nothing good to say about mike love lmao! “Bummer” I guess because I thought I was starting to see what people were saying about him being talented. and, sure I know there are people who like is performance on a lot of songs but through my experience of The Beach Boys catalog so far, I don’t see anything that is really unique or that stands out. Anyways who cares what I think. Just thought that was funny lmao

    • @1401minstrel
      @1401minstrel 3 роки тому +3

      @@darthjesus420 Please re-read my comment. It's Al singing lead at the end, not Carl, and not Mike.

    • @TheCabinEssence
      @TheCabinEssence 26 днів тому

      @@1401minstrelI thought it was Bruce

  • @petsmile_123
    @petsmile_123 5 років тому +17

    If I may, how did you make such a clear, spacious mix? I have the 5.1 Surf's Up mix off the EH DVD, but it sounds nowhere near as good as this. Could you possibly send this to me? Thanks!

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  5 років тому +5

      I just combined two of the channels, nothing special.

  • @pat9333
    @pat9333 3 роки тому +3

    Carl love .

  • @1401minstrel
    @1401minstrel 2 роки тому +1

    Here is the section from Wikipedia describing who the lead singers are for each of the three sections of the 1971 released version of Surf's Up. Bottom line: First two verses - Carl; Bridge - Brian; Coda - Al.
    "Carl ultimately overdubbed a lead vocal onto the song's first part, the original backing track dating from November 1966, as well as backing vocals. Two organ overdubs were also recorded.[48] The second movement was composed of the December 15, 1966 solo piano performance by Brian,[47] augmented with vocal and Moog synthesizer overdubs.[52] Carl reworked the refrain from another unreleased Smile song, "Child Is Father of the Man", into the coda of "Surf's Up".[48] Bruce Johnston recalled, "We ended up doing vocals to sort of emulate ourselves without Brian Wilson, which was kind of silly."[53] Al Jardine sang the lead vocal on this section.[37] Rieley said, "we all got involved in [the final tag]. ... I'm on it [and] a guy who worked for us part-time, Bill DeSimone, is on it. He just sings 'Hey, hey.' But it is integral to the tag on the record. That was a lot of fun ...".[49] Writing in a 1996 online Q&A, he wrote that Brian had "stated clearly that it was his intent all along for Child to be the tag for Surfs Up."[54]"

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  2 роки тому

      Nobody's disputing that here.

    • @1401minstrel
      @1401minstrel 2 роки тому +2

      @@scatteredfrog I should have posted this as a reply to the person who commented that Brian sings the whole song in this version.

  • @shirleyhubbert5547
    @shirleyhubbert5547 4 місяці тому

    I want this song played at my funeral...❤😢❤😢

  • @twoblacklabs904
    @twoblacklabs904 6 місяців тому +2

    Mike Love isn’t qualified to carry Brian’s sheet music.

  • @julioaranton461
    @julioaranton461 3 роки тому +4

    Family,♡🙏

  • @jonathanmanuel5461
    @jonathanmanuel5461 3 роки тому +16

    Time Traveler: *moves a chair*
    Timeline: 0:35

  • @vickielawson3114
    @vickielawson3114 Рік тому +2

    At 0:27 that’s Al not Carl.
    At 0:35 that’s Brian not Carl.
    Jeez, what’s the deal with that? Great song, anyway.

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  Рік тому +2

      The deal is ignorant magazine photo captioners from the '70s.

  • @Unclemort1
    @Unclemort1 6 років тому +7

    Very clear, but the CITFTM coda sounds weird

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  6 років тому +4

      A CHILLLLLLL-REN'S SONG...

    • @josebelindo1641
      @josebelindo1641 5 років тому

      That was another song from SMILE that was added on

    • @josebelindo1641
      @josebelindo1641 5 років тому +1

      3:08 MIKE THE COOL ONE SINGS

    • @zachsmith3
      @zachsmith3 3 роки тому

      @@josebelindo1641 No this is part of Surf's Up

  • @markpatterson2507
    @markpatterson2507 2 роки тому +1

    The lyrics were by Van Dyke Parks who has said they are just huge puns with odd phrases.A reading of the lyrics will show he is,of course correct.He never took himself that seriously

    • @DavidCKendall
      @DavidCKendall 9 місяців тому

      But the beauty is also that we listeners take it seriously as an art form, with free association available. The song means nothing and everything. Personally, I feel and learn something new & profound every listen.

  • @jocknarn3225
    @jocknarn3225 2 роки тому +1

    Attracted the attention of Leonard Bernstein. No greater endorsement for this progressive pop masterpiece

  • @brucerothwell7944
    @brucerothwell7944 3 роки тому +2

    The pic of Brian, labeled as "Carl Wilson". How did that happen??

  • @a1chemist1
    @a1chemist1 3 роки тому +1

    Not really. This is the 1970/71 overdub. In 1967 Brian sang it all, except a short bridge by Carl. IMO better.

  • @Roseheartworks.
    @Roseheartworks. 2 роки тому

    Thank you

  • @stephensimington479
    @stephensimington479 2 роки тому

    Carl Wilson: actually it's All Jardine
    Carl Wilson: actually it's Brian

  • @scottcyoung
    @scottcyoung 3 роки тому +1

    Carl Wilson in text next to Brian wilson photo?

  • @RedGrant2008
    @RedGrant2008 8 місяців тому

    A very off-beat disjunct tune. I don't know what to make of the incredibly bizarre tune, but there was definitely some heavy LSD involved - I can feel that.

  • @modernchampionmusic81
    @modernchampionmusic81 3 роки тому +3

    I think some of the fifths n thirds in vocal mix are lost here

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  3 роки тому +4

      I'm sure of it. This is only two of the six available channels.

  • @roqueiii645
    @roqueiii645 4 місяці тому

    genial

  • @josebelindo1641
    @josebelindo1641 5 років тому +32

    0:34 that's Brian

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  5 років тому +4

      100% Carl. Brian didn't participate in the vocal overdubs.

    • @ymirheiss3602
      @ymirheiss3602 5 років тому +10

      scatteredfrog You missed the point. At that time mark your video shows a clear photo of Brian with the name Carl Wilson next to it. Strange. Was it this way in the original photo? You seem too much of a Beach Boys aficionado to have missed that.

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  5 років тому +12

      Ah, okay - you're referring to the caption. :) (I thought you meant the vocal.) That picture came from a magazine article from the '70s, where Brian was mis-identified as Carl. You might have noticed that a few seconds earlier there's a picture of Al that is also mis-captioned as Carl. :)
      One thing about being a Beach Boys fans is there's all kinds of craziness like that. (Perhaps the most cringeworthy is watching a local cable access channel when it showed a local ice skating school's recital. One group of kids was doing an ice skating routine to "Fun, Fun, Fun," which the PA announcer identified as a Jan and Dean song. Ughghgh...)

    • @ymirheiss3602
      @ymirheiss3602 5 років тому +2

      scatteredfrog Lol...

    • @Wolfsky9
      @Wolfsky9 3 роки тому

      Sir---------------this is Carl-----------not BW. obviously, you've not listened to The Boys enough. -----------The 2nd part is BW ------------but that 1st, is Carl.---------------From the '71 Album, " Surf's Up " ---------------------WolfSky9, 74 y/o

  • @mtdouthit1291
    @mtdouthit1291 3 роки тому

    Why is the regular version from the CD always so QUIET????

  • @somebonehead
    @somebonehead 3 роки тому +1

    Can you provide a download link to this mix?

  • @cynthiarowley719
    @cynthiarowley719 Рік тому

    Hilarious 😂🎉😊

  • @elbalajazz
    @elbalajazz 2 роки тому

    it's not carl, is Brian

  • @markpatterson2507
    @markpatterson2507 2 роки тому

    At 031 AL is not Carl ir Brian....lol

  • @Paul-dw2cl
    @Paul-dw2cl Рік тому

    Carl!

  • @jameshesterberg7800
    @jameshesterberg7800 9 місяців тому +2

    Pet sounds was a masterpiece and before Sgt.Pepper.i am a Beatles fan but Pet Sounds beat it.

    • @FishyTheKid
      @FishyTheKid 9 місяців тому

      Absolutely. Pet Sounds is more consistent

  • @scernik
    @scernik 3 роки тому

    Someone has listened this un 5.1??

  • @bebe8404
    @bebe8404 3 роки тому

    ''surfs up'' Carl lead version is worst than the ''SMiLE Sessions'' one, singed by Brian Wilson.

  • @adlap0152
    @adlap0152 3 роки тому +7

    Mike Love’s part is so insignificant that he doesn’t deserve much, if any creative credit for this masterpiece.

  • @josebelindo1641
    @josebelindo1641 5 років тому +1

    Whats going on didn't Brian sing on the original recording solo ? Where they both on it ?

    • @josebelindo1641
      @josebelindo1641 5 років тому +1

      1:22 wheres Dennis sleeping

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  5 років тому +7

      For what it's worth, Brian technically DID sing on the original recording solo - the second half of the song that's almost nothing but piano IS Brian singing, and that was recorded in December 1966.
      The first half was recorded, I think, in January 1967, with all vocals overdubbed in 1971 for the Surf's Up album. As far as I know, Brian's only participation in the 1971 completion was that his car keys were used as percussion during the overdubs.

    • @thomaspappalardo7589
      @thomaspappalardo7589 5 років тому +4

      The second half of the song is Brian’s original piano and vocal demo from 1966 with the rest of the band overdubbing harmonies, percussion, and Moog bass.

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  5 років тому +4

      And Brian's car keys. :)

    • @runnersdialzero1244
      @runnersdialzero1244 3 роки тому

      The tag section on the 1971 version happened because of Brian taking initiative when the rest of the band was finishing the song. Other reports say Brian attempted the vocal for the first section twice but ultimately decided to hand it over to Carl.

  • @gomogo2000
    @gomogo2000 3 роки тому +7

    As a nutritionist I really wish I could talk to Brian. He would benefit tremendously from a Carnivore Diet, or at least traditional Keto Diet (animal-based). It's been apparent for years, by his looks and demeanor, that he's lacking many key building blocks and mortar for brain and body. Drugs, chemicals, and S.A.D. have so many people depleted today, including vitamins and minerals. I just worry, with him living in Cali, that he gets the wrong message that somehow plants are the key to health. Especially as a person of Northern European descent, he would benefit also by removing Mediterranean plants, which have naturally occurring toxins that are too hard on his more delicate cells.
    I just want to see him happy again...

    • @runnersdialzero1244
      @runnersdialzero1244 3 роки тому

      Go vegan.

    • @dingdangdata
      @dingdangdata 3 роки тому +3

      I get that you want the best for him and I'm really not trying to attack you personally - I'm sure you do what you do out of a desire to help people. But I don't think a Carnivore or Keto diet is going to: a) help his mental illness; b) repair damage done by years of recreational drug use and over-medicating by Landy; c) reverse the aging process. As someone who has struggled with mental illness for 30+ years and tried a hell of a lot of diets, therapies, and medication in both mainstream and alternative medicine, there's nothing more invalidating than being told that eating a certain way will help you. Nutrition is absolutely an important part of managing physical and mental health...but like like I said, super invalidating to a person who's been doing everything they can just to stay alive. I know I speak for a lot of people with mental illness when I say we do not need nutrition advice unless we ask for it. Even then, what we need is client-centered goal setting that meets us where we're at. Sometimes the goal is as simple as getting groceries once a week so you have fresh food or, when you're really depressed, remembering to eat at all.

    • @gomogo2000
      @gomogo2000 3 роки тому +1

      @@dingdangdata I cured my lifelong (55 years) mental illness with the diet and superior supplements. I had anxiety, panic, depression, psychotic break, and 25 years depersonalization. So I was VERY sick! Same with most of my physical ailments. This is partly why I am confident in stating what I did. It's also because the science backs it up! It's very sad that we're being lied to today about the connections between food and chemicals and health.
      Like I said, I am a nutritionist. But I relearned most of what modern Medicine taught me in an effort to heal myself...what they could never do. I have found the medicine, the fountain of youth all packed into a traditional diet. This means rejecting S.A.D., and eating like my Northern European ancestors. The second half is to avoid as much chemicals as you possibly can. Pesticides and solvents literally remove our amino acid serine, which be ones our happy neurotransmitter seratonin. Besides making us actually happy, it does other important things in the body like balancing blood sugar. Taking serine took away my hopelessness and the alienation I had created with loved ones. Those relationships are restored! W.H.O. declared Type 2 Diabetes a worldwide pandemic in 2010. T2D is the #2 comorbidity for Coronavirus (comorbidities are required for deaths). Imagine all the people who didn't have to die if they were told that they could cure their blood sugar dysregulation with a healing delicious diet and some superior supplements (including Benfothiamine). I don't get sick anymore, and don't fear viruses.
      I could write a book about this, but I think I've made my point. Here are some amazing resources to help you on your healing journey.
      Tendler5.wix.co/highlysinediet
      Www.westonaprice.org
      Dr. Ken Berry
      Dr. Derrick Lonsdale
      Dr. Darren Schmidt
      Mike Mutzel
      New Paradigm Nutrition (my FB page. Peruse for lots of great articles going back).
      We all have great potential for healing as this is what the body is designed to do. We just need to learn where that path is. One last thing...ketones are the KEY to health! Best of health to you! xo

    • @pascalrouen
      @pascalrouen 3 роки тому +1

      I agree with everything except for Ketosis. Ketosis is good when temporary, long-term has been known to lead to such disorders as adrenal failure. I eat carnivore however, in addition to plant foods. I primarily eat raw meat, eggs and dairy with a healthy portion of plant foods on the side such as legumes, fruits, and vegetables.

  • @wink853
    @wink853 3 роки тому +4

    Could have fit right in on Pet Sounds

  • @whiskeyd7
    @whiskeyd7 3 роки тому +5

    It sounds like Carl to me.

  • @josebelindo1641
    @josebelindo1641 5 років тому +6

    0:26 AL jARDINE IS THE BEST SINGER IN THE WORLD TODAY

    • @thomaskemer8109
      @thomaskemer8109 3 роки тому +1

      Always loved his vocal on Blue birds

    • @ovandolf
      @ovandolf 3 роки тому +3

      Yeah, but is Carl and Brian singing on this.

    • @1401minstrel
      @1401minstrel 3 роки тому +3

      @@ovandolf Carl sings the first part, Brian sings the second part, and Al comes in on lead in the third part, beginning with the words "A children's song, have you listened as they play?"

    • @zachsmith3
      @zachsmith3 3 роки тому

      That was Carl

    • @runnersdialzero1244
      @runnersdialzero1244 3 роки тому +1

      The falsetto part you're referring to is Carl.

  • @josebelindo1641
    @josebelindo1641 5 років тому +6

    2:15 MIKE THE COOL ONE

  • @robbyblack2699
    @robbyblack2699 3 роки тому +4

    All wrong. This is Brian Wilson on every word. Brush up on your research.

    • @scatteredfrog
      @scatteredfrog  3 роки тому +16

      We did. That's how we know that the first half is Carl.

    • @runnersdialzero1244
      @runnersdialzero1244 3 роки тому +2

      lol what? No. Carl does the lead vocal on the first section.

    • @matthall7359
      @matthall7359 3 роки тому +1

      Maybe on the version from smile sessions but the actual release of surfs up from the album of the same name was Carl

    • @darthjesus420
      @darthjesus420 3 роки тому

      How can you not hear the difference? That is clearly Carl. And like everyone has said 100 times. It is practically carved in stone that Carl did vocal overdubs for the specific surfs up album version. Yes the original surfs up song was all Brian in the beginning. But regardless of that Brian didn’t even sing the whole thing because the ending part of the song in both versions had Mike love singing over the harmonies

    • @1401minstrel
      @1401minstrel 2 роки тому

      Almost right. The lead vocal on the tag is Al, not Mike.