Beolab 9 vs Beolab Penta Sound Test for Music and Movies - B&O's greatest "Real World" Speakers?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 58

  • @soundsheavenly
    @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +2

    Please join Steve from Sounds Heavenly to hear Beolab 9 and Beolab Penta side by side in this video - these are two of Bang & Olufsen's most capable music and movie loudspeakers. Every cable you will ever need for your Bang & Olufsen speakers can be seen on Steve's website here: soundsheavenly.com If these videos have helped you to enjoy your Bang and Olufsen products, please consider buying Steve a coffee at www.buymeacoffee.com/soundsheavenly - many thanks!

  • @pauldavies6999
    @pauldavies6999 2 роки тому +4

    Hi Steve, thanks for another great comparison. I can certainly hear the tinkle of glass breaking more effectively on the 9, but the Penta sounded big and more 'theatre'. Bass extension on both speakers is impressive. The music comparison really threw me, as the speakers, to my ears, sound completely different (heard through an AV amp and B&O H6 headphones). So much more high frequency sounds on the 9, it made the Penta sound dull. It was like the band were playing higher frequency drums on the 9. As a Penta owner, I'm not sure if I should be disappointed ! I'm so used to B&O speakers having a certain laid-back signature. I like the fact you'll end up with both sets (eventually). I'm not going to let my Penta go just yet, it's only been 36 years. Cheers, Paul

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +1

      Thanks Paul! Yes, there is certainly a difference is the sounds presentation between the two speakers, but there is nothing wrong with the sound of the Pentas at all. Beolab 9 is clearer and the high frequencies come through with more punch, but that won't be to everyone's liking. I will also be keeping my own Pentas for many more years!

  • @urokurok8323
    @urokurok8323 Рік тому +1

    Hi Steve, it is always a pleasure to watch your new posts concerning B&O from new to old devices, considering your professionalism and, above all, your passion for the brand. I love old models because they are affordable, timeless in design and still powerful. But I am a bit disappointed that you never posted a comparison between Beolab Penta and Beolab One, while the latter was the successor of the former, and so the comparison was necessary ! Can you comment on that ? Thanks you.

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  Рік тому +1

      Thanks for your kind words, I'm glad you like my videos! The problem with comparing Penta to Beolab 1 is they are such big heavy speakers - I need to find somewhere locally that has both speakers together so that I can test them!

  • @michaelsnelling2918
    @michaelsnelling2918 2 роки тому +1

    Hi Steve my bete noir of watching movies is when surround effects drown out the ‘middle’, in particular speech … what the Penta’s lack in middle definition I have compensated with a powered centre speaker with its own volume control … this allows you to ‘dial in’ the middle without raising the surround level … you would be amazed how just a small change in centre speaker volume improves the overall experience … as they say ‘sound is half the picture’

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +1

      Thanks, that is a very interesting idea! I will try that out in my workshop to see what effect an extra centre speaker can give...

  • @skodbolle
    @skodbolle 2 роки тому +3

    Love the 9's but I have to go with the Penta's, the more mellow treble is much more my style then the sharp edgy treble of the 9's. And design wise there is no competition. And I completely agree that these two are the champions of Bang(and Olufsen) for your buck! :D

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +2

      Yes, these are both great speakers, probably the best value for money of any B&O speakers out there. I love my Pentas, I will be keeping them for many years to come!

  • @Smog104
    @Smog104 Рік тому +1

    How I missed this video ??
    I agree totally with your analysis Steve I think if I was gonna own Pentas I’d add a sub possibly a Beolab 11 and a pair of Townshend Supertweeters for listening to music .
    The Beolab 9 got a 5 star review is what HIFI it is of course a more modern speaker by a couple of decades , I’ve listened to the sound test with my BnO EX on and the 9s are more detailed absolutely but there’s a lovely warm sound to the Pentas . Having said that I’ve found Bang and Olufsen speakers in general to have a very nice signature sound my partner says it’s smoooooooth !!!!
    But detailed .
    I imagine sat in a listening room the Pentas due to more drivers and much taller , if both 9 and Pentas were stood on the floor , the Pentas would sound better to someone say in a chair .
    Beolabs 11 are a great little sub for music they are no good really for film but a very musical sub , paired with Pentas and a Townshend Supertweeters I’d plumb for the Pentas
    Upstairs I have aLG tv on a Beovision 7 stand with a Stage but if the tv was on its own I’d probably plumb for the 9s ??
    How do you find Beolab 20 relating to beolab 9 and Pentas ??
    Cheers mate

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  Рік тому +3

      Thanks, glad you found the video! I haven't had a good chance to listen to Beolab 20, but they are on my list of speakers to try. I will have to get a pair into the workshop for testing and put a video together once I have had a proper listen!

    • @Smog104
      @Smog104 Рік тому +1

      @@soundsheavenly that be interesting Steve cheers Simon

  • @bulentolcay6837
    @bulentolcay6837 2 роки тому +2

    Very simple but effective movie sound test. Thank you for the video. For me, beolab penta is the best buy. Could you please inform us which preamplifier are you using with these active beolab speaekers.

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +1

      Thank you! These tests were done with a simple Media PC using a Behringer 302USB external sound card.

  • @MattHorn59
    @MattHorn59 2 роки тому +1

    Can you do actual sound tests with all of the B&O lineup you have access to? I’d love to hear whole clips of genres to really get a feel for how impressive these speakers are

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +2

      That is an interesting idea... The problem with sound testing high end speakers is that listeners will almost always be hearing the sound on lower quality systems than the ones being tested, which greatly skews the results. For Beolab 28 and above, the best option is to go to a store to hear the speakers for yourself.

  • @Auto_Funk
    @Auto_Funk 2 роки тому +1

    Great comparison Steve! It’s hard to say without hearing them in person but to my ears the treble response from the 9’s was slightly better… With the bank of x4 mids in each Penta it stands to reason they would have a sweeter mid range than the 9’s. Also I suspect the DSP in the 9’s scoops the mid somewhat which is a more ‘modern’ sound if that makes any kind of sense!

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +2

      Many thanks for the loan of these superb speakers! Yes, I think that is a good description of the sound. I have linked to your Facebook page in the video description so that anyone who may be interested in buying the Beolab 9s is able to contact you!

    • @Auto_Funk
      @Auto_Funk 2 роки тому +1

      @@soundsheavenly Thank you :)

  • @michaelrosenlundjensen5016
    @michaelrosenlundjensen5016 2 роки тому +3

    For me The Penta is an icon, a classic that was The best from B&O back when i started to pay attention to B&O
    The beolab 9 have never touched me in design. There simply much to Less of aluminum and to much plastic
    B&O speakers have to have nice materials too. And I think they are the baddest looking active speakers together with beolab 4 that B&O have made the last 30 years
    So my choice based on these feelings have to be Beolab Penta

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +1

      Hi, I agree with you on design, but Beolab 9 certainly sounds good!

  • @marcelhannover3
    @marcelhannover3 Рік тому +1

    So did you buy the Beolab 9's ? I find these Beolab 9 looking comically retro like some 60's or 70's vision of the future, they remind me a bit of old sci-fi robots like Dalek from Dr. Who or Crichton from Buck Rogers. The Pentas still look like a speaker.

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  Рік тому +1

      Hi, I haven't bought the Beolab 9s yet, as the rest of my family hate the way they look....I'm still trying to persuade them! Still loving the look and sound of my Pentas though ;-)

  • @irelandgp
    @irelandgp 2 роки тому +2

    got 4 pentas and 2 beolabs 9 = no comparasing with old 88 pentas- no bass- beolab 9 are so good

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +1

      Yes, they give a very different sound, but each good in their own way

  • @saitekLT
    @saitekLT 2 роки тому +2

    From what I heard through video I was leaning towards Pentas but just because I know the price difference. The only reason I might go for 9's is design which still can look modern in todays interior while Pentas give out their age.

    • @Auto_Funk
      @Auto_Funk 2 роки тому +1

      I agree.... The way to think about it is this...
      Pentas - Value approx £500-800
      BL9 - Value approx £2000-2400
      Are the BL9s 4X better than Pentas?? Probably not in most people's opinion! In a way this video highlights what amazing bang for buck speakers a decent set of Pentas are. I firmly believe they are the best value B&O speakers money can buy in terms of £ vs performance....

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +2

      A good pair of mk.3 Pentas could cost up to 50% of the value of a pair of Beolab 9, so the difference in price may be closer than you think... I reckon the improvement in sound quality is well worth the upgrade, but certainly worth hearing them for yourself to decide if you get the chance.

    • @Auto_Funk
      @Auto_Funk 2 роки тому +1

      @@soundsheavenly That's true, you can pay more for Pentas but there are plenty around at the £500-800 price range - Even less for passive ones but then you have to factor in amplification which adds another layer of cost/complication.... Either way they are excellent value....!

    • @devilhomer
      @devilhomer 2 роки тому +2

      I cant believe@LlewelynTV is not selling them to you at a great discount at this stage 😂😂😂😂

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +3

      @@devilhomer I'm very tempted, but my good lady wife won't let me buy them! ;-)

  • @andycapo9you
    @andycapo9you 2 роки тому +1

    Hi! What is your opinion over B&O M100's? I have a couple and a couple of Penta's and I fimd the M100 a bit more clear and open . Bass is way better

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +3

      Hi, I actually haven't heard the M100 speakers yet - I will try to get to listen to a pair (ideally on video) as soon as I can. Thanks for the suggestion!

  • @gepflegtesgequatsche1922
    @gepflegtesgequatsche1922 2 роки тому +1

    I strongly recommend Eric Neveux‘s „Once upon a forest“. My Pentas make the air vibrate… music to feel

  • @NhkNguyễn-g1b
    @NhkNguyễn-g1b 9 місяців тому +1

    audio/ video of bang olufsen penta what doing?

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  9 місяців тому +1

      Hi, the Audio/Video switch under some Penta models just sets the display to work with either a B&O TV or a B&O music system. It won't affect the sound.

  • @divakarsingh70
    @divakarsingh70 Рік тому +1

    Well explained...thanks 🙏

  • @NhkNguyễn-g1b
    @NhkNguyễn-g1b 9 місяців тому +1

    guide to connection penta 1,2,3 with beomaster 5500 ỏ beomaster 9000

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  9 місяців тому +1

      Good idea, I will look at making that video soon.

  • @NhkNguyễn-g1b
    @NhkNguyễn-g1b 9 місяців тому +1

    guide detail another connection

  • @nerkbaker
    @nerkbaker 2 роки тому +1

    I love my Penta speakers!

  • @NhkNguyễn-g1b
    @NhkNguyễn-g1b 9 місяців тому +1

    you help me

  • @kurthill7030
    @kurthill7030 2 роки тому +1

    Penta for me 👍

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  2 роки тому +1

      Agreed! They still look and sound incredible

  • @snowti3294
    @snowti3294 Місяць тому

    The sound from the Penta sound very confined - it’s giving me the vibes of a small Bluetooth speaker where the sound doesn’t come forward at all.
    Which is very strange.

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  Місяць тому +1

      That certainly isn't how they sound in real life, I suspect you may be using small speakers or budget headphones to listen to the sound comparison? This video is only intended to give you an idea of how the speakers differ, it won't let you hear how they actually sound.

    • @snowti3294
      @snowti3294 Місяць тому +1

      @@soundsheavenlyI use the HX headphones - and i feel like when the 9’s play they violently drags me inside the movie and to the concert.
      Whereas i feel like the Penta’s aren’t doing the same.
      They are less direct and not as alive at all.

    • @soundsheavenly
      @soundsheavenly  Місяць тому

      @snowti3294 thanks for clarifying, yes that makes sense now 👍🏻