It is so easy to criticize - could you sing this better than Jonas Kaufmann? I love this version, but of course, everybody has the right to have his own opinion! Il est facile de critiquer! Sauriez-vous chanter mieux cet air? Bien sûr, tout le monde a le droit d'exprimer son opinion, mais il est si facile de critiquer! Jonas Kaufmann a une voix superbe et bien dosée! Quel merveilleux interprète! Voilà mon opinion! Ja, es ist müssig, zu kritisieren! Oder könnten Sie diese Arie besser singen als Jonas Kaufmann? Nun, jeder hat das Recht, seine Meinung zu äussern und die Geschmäcker sind halt verschieden. Ich finde, dass Jonas Kaufmann ein hervorragender Interpret ist und die Musik nicht nur singt, sondern lebt! Kindest regards / meilleures salutations / beste Grüsse Meggy from Switzerland
Could I sing it better? In this opera I sing Plunkett so I would never sing this little aria. Anyway I've only sung a shortened concert version of Martha. Kaufmann is usually considered the best tenor alive. I am one of those who so consider him. But none of this is fair. This aria goes better in German but most of the recordings by famous tenors have sung it in Italian. Wunderlich's version is probably the best (big surprise). Wunderlich sang a lot of operetta and had a lighter, sweeter voice than Kaufmann. I'll bet if you asked Kaufmann he'd agree.
@@gkj13 The plot is about Lady Harriet, a lady who pretends with her friend to be country maids. Lady Harriet calls herself Martha. She meets with a farmer called Lionel, with whom she enters a contract of service. Later on, back as Lady Harriet, she is seen by Lionel at a hunting party, and he declares his love for her. He also states that she is bound by the service contract. Harriet declares that the young man is mad. Everything comes right, when it is discovered Lionel is in fact a nobleman. They get married and live happily ever after. The aria is considered by many as the number one tenor aria. It is also called M'appari, the Italian version. Everyone has sung it, including Mario Lanza, Caruso, Gigli, Pavarotti and of course, Fritz Wunderlich. It is a favorite as background when someone is getting bumped off in Mafia films, such as in Al Capone.
Ach! so fromm, ach so traut, Hat mein Auge sie erschaut; Ach! so mild, und so rein Drang ihr Bild in's Herz mir ein. Banger Gram, eh' sie kam, Hat die Zukunft mir umhüllt, Doch mit ihr blühte mir Neues Dasein lusterfüllt. Weh! Es schwand, was ich fand, ach! Mein Glüch erschauf ich kaum, Bin erwacht und die Nacht Raubte mir den süssen traum. Martha! Martha! Du entschwandest, und mein Glück Nahmst Du mit Dir; Gib mir wieder, was Du fandest, Oder theile es mit mir. Sounds:
Therein lies the problem with comparison. Every voice and interpretation is different. Have your preference but it's wrong to diminish his version because it's not what you prefer.
this shows how beautiful and romantic a male voice can be. Wonderful. 🍀💚
Beautiful voice!
His first CD . What a jewel.
I don't like to compare, for me TODAY he is the best.
Jonas Kaufmann has inherited opera's throne !
Merci pour ce clip.... Super!
Helene ADAM drei tenööre
The best M'appari i'ave ever heard!!!
I am speechless with wonder♥
come mi piace quando canta così ! :-)
Sehr schön!
Wunderbar!
Bravo Jonas !!! Sveden
Ich freue mich, dass es so gute Nachwuchssänger gibt, die dieses Liedgut pflegen und weiter geben! Danke Jonas Kaufmann!
So beautiful 🎉🎉
Grande entre los grandes !!!!
Siete tutti fenomenali...
Genial maestro
non ci sono parole
Grande...applauso
The shirt is nice
The voice is powerful but is Jonas a spinto tenor or a dramatic tenor (heldentenor)?
Bradley Monroe lyric with swallowed tongue
La mejor version que escuche hasta el momento, iniguable Jonas, que cantante por favor!
Excellent! Also check out Fritz Wunderlich doing the same aria!
i agree with jonas kaufmann on this one
It is so easy to criticize - could you sing this better than Jonas Kaufmann? I love this version, but of course, everybody has the right to have his own opinion!
Il est facile de critiquer! Sauriez-vous chanter mieux cet air? Bien sûr, tout le monde a le droit d'exprimer son opinion, mais il est si facile de critiquer! Jonas Kaufmann a une voix superbe et bien dosée! Quel merveilleux interprète! Voilà mon opinion!
Ja, es ist müssig, zu kritisieren! Oder könnten Sie diese Arie besser singen als Jonas Kaufmann? Nun, jeder hat das Recht, seine Meinung zu äussern und die Geschmäcker sind halt verschieden. Ich finde, dass Jonas Kaufmann ein hervorragender Interpret ist und die Musik nicht nur singt, sondern lebt!
Kindest regards / meilleures salutations / beste Grüsse
Meggy from Switzerland
Could I sing it better? In this opera I sing Plunkett so I would never sing this little aria. Anyway I've only sung a shortened concert version of Martha.
Kaufmann is usually considered the best tenor alive. I am one of those who so consider him. But none of this is fair. This aria goes better in German but most of the recordings by famous tenors have sung it in Italian.
Wunderlich's version is probably the best (big surprise). Wunderlich sang a lot of operetta and had a lighter, sweeter voice than Kaufmann. I'll bet if you asked Kaufmann he'd agree.
Joseph Schmidt In den 30iger Jahren , bevor er durch die Nazis und die Schweiz in den Tod getrieben wurde.
Volevo vedere il suo sorriso prima di chiudere..
wundervolle Interpretation . gibt es einen subtileren Tenor als Jonas Kaufmann.?
super shirt!!!
Kaufmann matiza mas que nadie tiene una voz que llega dentro del corazon
Just right.
WHAT A COMPLETE ARTIST JONAS KAUFMANN IS ...!!!
Una delicia escucharlo
Fantàstic escoltar això
Aunque soy seguidor del arte Kaufman prefiero la version de F.Wunderlich...el mejor tenor lirico que haya escuchado.....
Von Flotow is very good.
what's it about? they never show it hear at The Met.
@@gkj13 The plot is about Lady Harriet, a lady who pretends with her friend to be country maids. Lady Harriet calls herself Martha. She meets with a farmer called Lionel, with whom she enters a contract of service.
Later on, back as Lady Harriet, she is seen by Lionel at a hunting party, and he declares his love for her. He also states that she is bound by the service contract. Harriet declares that the young man is mad.
Everything comes right, when it is discovered Lionel is in fact a nobleman. They get married and live happily ever after.
The aria is considered by many as the number one tenor aria. It is also called M'appari, the Italian version. Everyone has sung it, including Mario Lanza, Caruso, Gigli, Pavarotti and of course, Fritz Wunderlich. It is a favorite as background when someone is getting bumped off in Mafia films, such as in Al Capone.
Ach! so fromm, ach so traut, Hat mein Auge sie erschaut; Ach! so mild, und so rein Drang ihr Bild in's Herz mir ein. Banger Gram, eh' sie kam, Hat die Zukunft mir umhüllt, Doch mit ihr blühte mir Neues Dasein lusterfüllt. Weh! Es schwand, was ich fand, ach! Mein Glüch erschauf ich kaum, Bin erwacht und die Nacht Raubte mir den süssen traum. Martha! Martha! Du entschwandest, und mein Glück Nahmst Du mit Dir; Gib mir wieder, was Du fandest, Oder theile es mit mir.
Sounds:
Thank you for the lyrics, I was about to look for it.
Красота
Anche quando non canta...mi piace
Jonas is the best of the best!
nel mio cuorr
seiil migliore
e 'come il buon vino il buon cibo il buon canto
Lecker.
Bello sei
Only you.
A domani o piu' in la'...mua'
Au top ......
Maestro!!! Grande Jonas!!!
Not a real bright Tenor sound. Schmidt Wunderlich Lanza Fuegel Pavarotti di Stefano Kiepura... owns this Aria.
Florian Stollmayer MUSIC he has a fake sound
Der beste ist für mich Peter Anders . Und Wunderlich nicht vergessen ;)
National Konservativer .... Und Rudolf Schock 🎵🎵🎵
SIE mussen singen.
super late reply, but… kaufmann is a helden, and this sound is typical of that very rare voice type.
so frommmmm
adesso sono un frullino
alt sono io e marta...giusto?
Potrebbe spostarsi un po' là di dietro...prego
Io le mantengo le promesse...oppure non ne faccio
an Kiepura reicht nur Joseph Schmidt heran R i P
la mia omonima?...mi scoccerebbe
volevo metterle una collsna di fiori
dalla camicia del direttore é roba di secoli fa ahha
Mua
persa..
6
Anzi 2 adii adidu
A me appari marte...ahah
Sorry, reicht nicht an Peter Anders heran....
Genau !
Kiepura sang this aria best.
x te...
Non male.
cattivi...
not as good as Kiepura
Compared to the Kiepura version, this is but a grunt and bellow attempt
Therein lies the problem with comparison. Every voice and interpretation is different. Have your preference but it's wrong to diminish his version because it's not what you prefer.
Reicht nicht an Fritz Wunderlich ran .
What Willy wonka sings
man könnte sich ja vorher rasieren- bitte !