New Air Defense RIM-162D VS Garpun (30mm) & JRNG-6 CIWS | Air Defense Comparison | Modern Warship

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
  • Supported by Artstorm
    Thanks For Watching!
    Have a great day!
    Modern Warships New Update
    Command your warship in epic online sea battles!
    The mightiest modern fighting ships are waiting for you! Fight with your friends in the realistic online action game Modern Warships. You'll become the captain of a modern battleship. All game models are made strictly according to the drawings and look like real ships. The game has a wide range of weapons, including missiles, machine guns, rockets, and many more. And you'll be able to pilot deck helicopters and fighter jets!
    #MWCreator #MWPartner #modernwarships
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Want to join MW Community?
    Modern Warships Official Discord: / discord
    Modern Warships: Official Facebook Group / modernwarshipsofficial
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Social Media:
    Discord: Hail Hydra# 9803
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Frequently Asked Questions(FAQ)
    A: What device do you use?
    Q: PocoX3 Pro 8Gb RAM/256GB ROM
    A: How to be Alpha Testers?
    Q: Alpha tester is closed, there's no way to be alpha testers.
    A: Where are you from?
    Q: Indonesia
    For business inquiries: cakrabirawa.business@gmail.com
    Join this channel to get access to perks:
    / @cakrabirawach.
    Thank you if you guys want to spare some money for me, but it's better if you donate here:
    kitabisa.com
    www.unicef.org
    Music:
    -Modern Warships - Skycarrier Theme.
    • SkyCarrier mode offici...
    -Modern Warships - Islands of Iceland.
    • Modern Warships - Isla...
    Disclaimer
    This channel does not give any guarantee about the completeness, reliability and accuracy of information on every test and comparison.
    Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
    Pan Spatial Teton
    CN Huaqing Battleship
    Modern warships new update
    modern warships new event
    Modern warships pc
    modern warships alpha test
    April Battlepass Modern Warships
    New Update
    alpha test
    May Battlepass
    USS Arkansas (CGN-41) cruiser
    V-247 Vigilant helicopter
    F-117A Nighthawk strike fighter
    Maritime Strike missile
    RIM-162D anti-aircraft missile

КОМЕНТАРІ • 42

  • @pgch0089
    @pgch0089 4 місяці тому +6

    Hey Cakrabirawa, I really enjoy your comparision videos - the test setups are well chosen and the videos are professionally produced!
    If you don't mind I'd like to make some remarks / suggestions.
    1) I think that the missile vs. AA game mechanics involves some random factors or some other non-deterministic behaviour, that factors into chance of the AA shooting down an incoming missile. For example, the comparison of RIM-162D vs Croctale showed an incredibly bad performance of the RIM versus the Black Plague (over 30 seconds), while the same test in the comparison video RIM-162D vs Garpun / JRNG-6 passed in just 11.4 seconds, winning the first place. So maybe the same test should be repeated several times (for example 10 times) and the results should be averaged to give a more meaningful assessment. Of course this will require a lot more time for these kinds of tests, so maybe that's not an option.
    2) Beside the missiles fired by enemy ships, the AA should be able to handle incoming aircraft attacks as well, especially since many of these missiles cannot be flared. Maybe you can add additional tests, with aircraft firing missiles at the AA testing ship, one test with the aircraft staying out of range of the AA and one test with entering the AA range. Because I got the impression that most AAs focus on the planes once they locked onto them and completely ignore incoming aircraft misiles.
    3) In most tests against the X51 Wavewrider, the damage still is applied to the ship although the missile was destroyed. I made some tests myself (Varyag as attacker vs. Massa over 10km) and got this effect only in very rare occasions. Is this effect a ping issue?
    And finally a test request :) I recently started using the T2 OSA-M AA on my Massa an got the impression, that it performed better than T3 AA (Croctale / Garpun / JRNG-6). It has an extremly fast reload of 1.75s, locks on multiple targets and the damage of 325 is enough to destroy any T3 missile. The low range of 2.77km reduces the chance of locking on enemy aircraft, focusing on incoming missiles. I would really like to see a comparison vs Croctale and JRNG-6.
    Cheers and keep up the awesome work!

  • @sleep_deprived_stormworker
    @sleep_deprived_stormworker 2 місяці тому +3

    so the RIM is the best for anti aircraft, but the JRNG is best for missile defense.

  • @Lexypizy
    @Lexypizy 4 місяці тому +3

    JRNG still my fav AA, cause cheap hehe

  • @4rya7_1Cvx97Nw
    @4rya7_1Cvx97Nw 4 місяці тому +1

    There is no expectation that JRNG CIWS can be superior to Garpun considering that the two are at different levels

  • @sherlyoctavianyputry
    @sherlyoctavianyputry 4 місяці тому +3

    *Hyunmoo-3C VS Maritime Strike*

  • @dianasaparani5904
    @dianasaparani5904 3 місяці тому

    Your try air defens cortole vs rim 162D please

  • @Ramzan95MW
    @Ramzan95MW 4 місяці тому

    Which is better?

  • @MARSHALDAZAM
    @MARSHALDAZAM 4 місяці тому +2

    jrng is the beast air

  • @Scorpion.A.
    @Scorpion.A. 4 місяці тому +2

    Лайк Бро. Как всегда топовые обзор - сравнение.

  • @GameFreak_305
    @GameFreak_305 4 місяці тому +16

    New stuff always bad

    • @yardandevin2217
      @yardandevin2217 4 місяці тому

      Fr

    • @MirrorMan369
      @MirrorMan369 25 днів тому

      Something, sometimes depends the ship too, sometimes more expensive doesn't mean more efficient.

  • @ksa1crypto613
    @ksa1crypto613 4 місяці тому +2

    hey thanks , rim 162d vs crotale R440 ,,,, crotale R440 vs jrng-6 ciws

  • @Naraveya000
    @Naraveya000 4 місяці тому +3

    test pan spatial redrum air defense please

  • @DestructSean
    @DestructSean 4 місяці тому +9

    The RIM did really well. I’m testing it thoroughly on all my ships. I feel like it’s a great option, like the JRNG and Crotale.

  • @Dog_watcher
    @Dog_watcher 27 днів тому

    Why pay more?
    JRNG good enough

  • @Xprodude
    @Xprodude 4 місяці тому +3

    I dont get it why is jrng better than garpun even tho rarity of them is a difference legendary and epic😮

    • @zzz1041
      @zzz1041 4 місяці тому +4

      Cuz its dollar item

    • @StarLinx9740
      @StarLinx9740 4 місяці тому +4

      well tbh man i think dev just dont know how to made different in the same tier so they just slap Rarity to weapons, planes, Ships etc because they dont know where they gonna put it so Rarity doesn't matter it just thing to lure players who dont know to buy it ... just look at Pyotr Velikiy they Flag Ship(dev are russian) but it just stuck at Rare Rarity for no reason

    • @namluong9739
      @namluong9739 4 місяці тому +1

      Do Yamato or Missouri (legendary rated) stronger than Massachusett (epic rated) ?
      Of course no
      Thats the answer

    • @wahyuwirawan727
      @wahyuwirawan727 3 місяці тому

      Old items like garpun always power creeped by newer items. Amongst old items, garpun is a legendary tier but not amongst the newest items. Another reason is, garpun is a free item while other items are paid items

  • @HoaNguyen_Manucian
    @HoaNguyen_Manucian 4 місяці тому +2

    Jrng is the best❤❤❤❤

  • @robertusmaharyady2810
    @robertusmaharyady2810 4 місяці тому +9

    Lot of work to make this comparision.. thank u brother..
    Cheers... ❤..
    When compare one by one.. jrng and rim clearly good..
    But same result like before..
    In the simultaneous condition garpun looks better 😂...
    Jrng have a tendency/focus to shot the plane..
    While garpun and rim like more allround switching neither plane or missile.. and have faster missile reload...

  • @shahrulnizam5263
    @shahrulnizam5263 4 місяці тому

    Legendary should be superior than epic😂

  • @rafiraihan8808
    @rafiraihan8808 4 місяці тому

    Parah banget delay nya haha~ 🐦💧

  • @juneedd_5858
    @juneedd_5858 4 місяці тому +4

    Can the garpun test be repeated? because what I saw was that the plane flared its missiles twice, so garpun was in last place

    • @namluong9739
      @namluong9739 4 місяці тому +1

      thats the consequence of reloading missiles too fast that in some case Garpun can not use its missile appropriately. Moreover, Garpun's missile didnt have good maneuverability like JRNG or RIM152D so its really hard to fight against highly maneuverable targets

  • @doleparsito
    @doleparsito 4 місяці тому

    garpun🤦🏻

  • @rf-fy2rz
    @rf-fy2rz 4 місяці тому +2

    why do you always use atmaca when testing?

    • @Nogitsune_Yako
      @Nogitsune_Yako 4 місяці тому +11

      One of the most popular and overall good missile.

  • @ABDESALAM07
    @ABDESALAM07 4 місяці тому +2

    JRNG VS CROTAL pls

  • @Nogitsune_Yako
    @Nogitsune_Yako 4 місяці тому +10

    This game is waste of life.