Listen to the oldest known recording of a human voice | BBC Global

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 лип 2024
  • Thomas Edison is often credited with being the first person to record sound.
    But it was in fact a Frenchman named Edouard-Léon Scott de Martinville who invented sound recording via his phonautograph in 1857 - 20 years before Edison invented his phonograph.
    Subscribe to BBC Global: ua-cam.com/users/bbc_global?...
    For the latest news, analysis and features visit: www.bbc.com
    #bbc #science #inventions

КОМЕНТАРІ • 988

  • @Shootingstarcomics
    @Shootingstarcomics 8 днів тому +1428

    No auto tune back then, just raw talent.

  • @coastofkonkan
    @coastofkonkan 13 днів тому +1110

    All the way from recording audio on a metal sheet to now streaming it on the internet throughout the world. What an astonishing feat of humanity.

    • @arthurvanparijs6121
      @arthurvanparijs6121 12 днів тому +51

      And it all happened in less than 200 years. Crazy how fast technology progresses!

    • @leinster22
      @leinster22 9 днів тому +56

      Now if humanity would only desist from violence and wars maybe we would have even greater feats

    • @QuarrellaDeVil
      @QuarrellaDeVil 8 днів тому +8

      I remember watching the early photos and whatever else from the New Horizons visit to Pluto on my phone, amazed that, as a kid, this was some cold rock in waytheheckout, and there I was, watching it not on the small black and white screen in my childhood home but a much smaller screen with higher resolution, just a few decades later.

    • @marcmarparran7753
      @marcmarparran7753 6 днів тому

      ​@@leinster22 ⬅️ Found the communist!

    • @zamar2158
      @zamar2158 6 днів тому +1

      Europeans were good with curiosity and making workable applications of their concepts. You guys are aliens, with those alien brains lol.

  • @kerimbozkurt3301
    @kerimbozkurt3301 6 днів тому +831

    Please someone remind the young audience that cassette player is not the ancient recording device from 1860s.

  • @suzylux
    @suzylux 11 днів тому +877

    Incredible. A long dead voice being exhumed after almost 170 years.

    • @-kattya-
      @-kattya- 8 днів тому +23

      Uh, it sounds eerie and magical😊

    • @lilybond6485
      @lilybond6485 7 днів тому +42

      @suzylux: Little did he know that human beings, over the entire plane in the future, could listen to him sing that song. It wouldn’t even have been conceivable to him that would even be a possibility.

    • @jacobrivers5728
      @jacobrivers5728 7 днів тому +20

      Who said he was dead? Don’t go jumping to conclusions.

    • @Ea-Nasir_Copper_Co
      @Ea-Nasir_Copper_Co 6 днів тому +20

      @@jacobrivers5728Settle down, Dracula.

    • @geigertec5921
      @geigertec5921 6 днів тому +10

      An archeologist found an ancient clay pot from several thousands years BC. It had a pattern on it that had been made with a stick. The grooves made on the pot contained analog information from vibrations transcribed into the clay. He put a laser to the pot and turned it and was able to replay the sound from inside the ancient pottery shop. It didn't sound like much, but it's from the time before the Roman Empire, not bad.

  • @williamlarochelle6833
    @williamlarochelle6833 9 днів тому +780

    The first play was better than the second.

    • @robandrews4815
      @robandrews4815 7 днів тому +64

      That's what I thought too!! Couldn't understand the second. At all.

    • @brianxyz
      @brianxyz 6 днів тому +49

      @@robandrews4815 Second one sounded like a ghost.

    • @Asterra2
      @Asterra2 6 днів тому +29

      I mean... shrug? If you played it back at 4x speed it would sound even better. Obviously halving the speed is going to halve the represented frequencies and make it sound more muffled. If the guy had ever envisioned that his recordings would be used for more than simply studying waveforms on paper, perhaps he would have finetuned it to pick up higher frequencies better, but we got what we got.

    • @Cjnw
      @Cjnw 6 днів тому

      ​@@brianxyzI paid just $23, you've been bamboozled!!!

    • @Lexluthor2024
      @Lexluthor2024 6 днів тому +17

      The first goth song ever.

  • @PLuMUK54
    @PLuMUK54 5 днів тому +186

    I was expecting, "Your call is very important to us. You are currently number 29 in the queue. Please wait 170 years for the next operative."

    • @evanstar84
      @evanstar84 3 дні тому +5

      I was expecting “we’ve been trying to reach you about your car’s extended warranty.”

    • @PTANV-x2g
      @PTANV-x2g 2 дні тому +1

      *buggy

    • @PilotDamian
      @PilotDamian 2 дні тому +1

      😂

    • @brettbuck7362
      @brettbuck7362 День тому +1

      Oh, you are a Comcast customer, too?

  • @petergibson2318
    @petergibson2318 12 днів тому +435

    It sounds like a wasp trapped inside a jam jar desperately trying to get out.

    • @AliAthar-rm2pm
      @AliAthar-rm2pm 8 днів тому +8

      hahahahaa hahahaha you made my day

    • @slacktoryrecords4193
      @slacktoryrecords4193 8 днів тому +14

      Yeah. People who throw around the term “lo-fi” today to mean “sparse arrangement” have NO IDEA what lo-fi really means, and they need to listen to this ass recording and get educated.

    • @BAztid
      @BAztid 7 днів тому +5

      Singing potato.

    • @bradmetcalf5333
      @bradmetcalf5333 7 днів тому +4

      Thats exactly what 1860 France was like. Stuck in a jar

    • @justme6655
      @justme6655 7 днів тому

      😂

  • @lutello3012
    @lutello3012 12 днів тому +465

    And now we can play it back. [pushes record]

    • @vincentvega5686
      @vincentvega5686 12 днів тому +93

      thats what happens when you ask a gen z to make a vid about old tech lol

    • @easylee
      @easylee 11 днів тому +15

      Hahahah this is too right

    • @e32b61
      @e32b61 9 днів тому +61

      “That was the last surviving copy.”

    • @GentlemanLife-Beyotch
      @GentlemanLife-Beyotch 9 днів тому +10

      Just go back and dele. . .

    • @butterblood
      @butterblood 8 днів тому +26

      I don’t hear anything. Oh my bad, I accidentally recorded over it.

  • @MemphiStig
    @MemphiStig 12 днів тому +246

    Their A&R man said, "I don't hear a single." The future was wide open.

    • @vailpcs4040
      @vailpcs4040 11 днів тому +20

      The sky was the limit.

    • @rescuegirl
      @rescuegirl 11 днів тому +17

      Into the great wide-open.

    • @LordKlektar
      @LordKlektar 8 днів тому +17

      Under them skies of blue

    • @rescuegirl
      @rescuegirl 8 днів тому +15

      A rebel without a clue

    • @QuarrellaDeVil
      @QuarrellaDeVil 8 днів тому +18

      "Experts believe they can make out another voice, saying something about 'more cowbell'".

  • @brianarbenz1329
    @brianarbenz1329 6 днів тому +72

    Play it backward and see if you can hear, "Paul is dead!"

  • @herzogsbuick
    @herzogsbuick 7 днів тому +123

    ...i don't think you have to be over 30 to realize that the the guy presses record on the cassette deck at the end, and in fact you would hear nothing.

    • @Patrick3183
      @Patrick3183 7 днів тому +1

      😂

    • @RavenMobile
      @RavenMobile 5 днів тому +1

      Usually hitting play and record was for dual cassette decks in order to record from one tape to the other. I dunno what play + record would do on a single tape recorder.

    • @herzogsbuick
      @herzogsbuick 5 днів тому +7

      @@RavenMobile it would record. on that model most likely from a built-in microphone, though it probably had RCA in as well as an external 1/8" microphone jack

    • @marc37921
      @marc37921 День тому

      I did hear nothing so this theory checks out

  • @terrancekayton007
    @terrancekayton007 3 дні тому +18

    Man. I wish I was that encouraged to explore a topic enough to realize an unknown fact of a matter. Bravo to these people.

  • @haileymoore3428
    @haileymoore3428 6 днів тому +48

    this never fails to bring tears to my eyes - can you imagine? of all of the powerful voices of the 1860s - all of the politicians and generals and celebrities - the one voice that has been saved from that time isn't the voice of someone powerful. It's the voice of an ordinary man singing claire de la lune. The first recording we have and it''s a song.

    • @nathueil1
      @nathueil1 3 дні тому +3

      😢

    • @user-uz8sn1qv8y
      @user-uz8sn1qv8y 2 години тому

      makes me wonder about 'aliens' locating that gold record we sent to space......and hundreds of years from now, them finally sitting up all night to hear "i cant get no......satisfaction''''''' 🤣

  • @indigohammer5732
    @indigohammer5732 5 днів тому +46

    The syncing with the tuning fork is very clever

    • @cryptocuz5705
      @cryptocuz5705 3 дні тому +3

      That's also what caught my ear. I instantly thought damn that's good.

    • @brinta2868
      @brinta2868 День тому

      I thought it was a bit daft to play another sound while recording, and I don't quite how they did that without interference.
      They could have used a purely mechanical device (like a clock) to draw on the paper at certain intervals.

  • @cidweinberg
    @cidweinberg 6 днів тому +36

    Fascinating. Standing in my kitchen eating dinner in San Francisco, California 7/16/2024. Listening

  • @martinkinsella6484
    @martinkinsella6484 6 днів тому +49

    Sounds like an angry bee.

  • @FurlogTheGiant
    @FurlogTheGiant 7 днів тому +156

    you dont press record on a tape recorder to play

    • @mrcydonia
      @mrcydonia 6 днів тому +32

      He's recording over the precious tape! Somebody stop him!!

    • @Mumblix
      @Mumblix 4 дні тому +4

      Thank you! I thought I was going nuts.

    • @kuldas9299
      @kuldas9299 4 дні тому +6

      Also a tape recorder was in no way used in this process.

    • @rob-time
      @rob-time 2 дні тому +3

      Anyone who knows how to use one of those old tape recorders understands that TWO buttons are required for record, not one. The Play button AND the Record Button.

    • @Tausug101
      @Tausug101 15 годин тому

      I dont think that's the ACTUAL TAPE that records the audio being played. Maybe its just one of those stock videos to show its playing.
      The one we are hearing is the recorded from that old machine

  • @samuelburleigh1895
    @samuelburleigh1895 6 днів тому +35

    This should be no 1 in the charts.

  • @charlesolver303
    @charlesolver303 13 днів тому +184

    @3:12 - someone accidentally pushes the "RECORD" button and erases the tape...

    • @sforza209
      @sforza209 12 днів тому +12

      Freakin amateurs

    • @007Julie
      @007Julie 11 днів тому +16

      That’s what I thought, he’s recording over whatever they recorded

    • @TesserId
      @TesserId 10 днів тому +11

      That was so obvious I knew someone would comment on that.

    • @QuarrellaDeVil
      @QuarrellaDeVil 8 днів тому +4

      They could use that bit if they do something about the Watergate tapes.

    • @MomMom4Cubs
      @MomMom4Cubs 7 днів тому

      ​@@QuarrellaDeVilI think we're past that.

  • @calabrais
    @calabrais 7 днів тому +260

    Why was I expecting the voice to say "We've been trying to reach you about your cars extended warranty"

    • @cintsscha5899
      @cintsscha5899 6 днів тому +4

      😂😂😂😂😂

    • @davidthedeaf
      @davidthedeaf 6 днів тому +1

      Because you are sleepy GenZzz

    • @Colorado_Native
      @Colorado_Native 6 днів тому +7

      Good question. The recording is 170 years old. Perhaps it would be, ""We've been trying to reach you about your horse and buggy's extended warranty."

    • @sgrant39
      @sgrant39 6 днів тому

      OMG

    • @jillschaefer1360
      @jillschaefer1360 5 днів тому

      💀

  • @theboombapkingdom8628
    @theboombapkingdom8628 5 днів тому +47

    That's incredible! As a recording engineer and music producer I have seen the evolution of audio technology in the past 30 years but to think it all started here makes me understand and marvel at how far the technology has come. Thanks for making this piece.

  • @Lexyvil
    @Lexyvil 11 днів тому +97

    Summary: Édouard-Léon Scott recorded his voice in 1860 by marking the vibrations (caused by his voice) onto a cylindrical surface. There was no way to play it back, so thanks to this guy in the interview, Patrick Feaster, in 2008 he managed to decode and read from it, resulting in hearing the recorded sound from 1860 for the first time. That's amazing tech, and what is even crazier is knowing it has not yet been 200 years since that discovery. Stories like these really baffles me in how far technology has gone the past few centuries since the industrial revolution.

    • @lilybond6485
      @lilybond6485 7 днів тому

      @Lexyvil: Can’t help but think that something else has been at play here. I don’t believe human beings developed this technology on their own merits. I’m not sure what.

    • @lilybond6485
      @lilybond6485 7 днів тому +5

      @Lexyvil: Thanks for summarizing that.

    • @erikkibler3466
      @erikkibler3466 7 днів тому

      Yeah,they were recording the new slowed down version on a tape recorder.they weren’t using that tape recorder for playback

    • @memathews
      @memathews 7 днів тому +2

      Important Addendum: Scott used the stable frequency of a tuning fork recorded in a track alongside the voice track to remove variations in the hand-cranked speed of the recording. This may be the first known application of frequency clocking, which is used today in all digital applications.

    • @Yamsek
      @Yamsek 5 днів тому +3

      Technically they were not trying to record a voice, they were just trying to ‘see it’ mapped out as the device drew the vibrations for visual representation. It’s remarkable this guy even thought to reverse the process and try to play it!

  • @celltech161
    @celltech161 4 дні тому +6

    Brought to you by the same technology used at drive through windows across the US.

  • @cosmicraysshotsintothelight
    @cosmicraysshotsintothelight 7 днів тому +20

    It is wild as one can hear the "big bowl" sound that the chamber he crafted introduced into the "output transducer". That would qualify as the first audio transducer, in fact. A transducer is a device which converts one form of energy into another. In this case sinusoidal auditory vibrations against a flat membrane "drum head" which then 'transduces' into linear mechanical motion set up to cause a 'stylus' to engrave the vibrations onto a linear 'tape', appearing again to match the sinusoidal signature of the original stimulus. Now we do it with electrons, just like Antonio Meucci did.

  • @RICKONORATO
    @RICKONORATO 10 днів тому +74

    That is truly astounding. Like listening to the voice of a ghost

  • @Plflybit
    @Plflybit 4 дні тому +6

    People ’feel’ a voice. It’s vibratory. Hearing aids went from hon-looking funnels to digital. They weren’t capturing noise, they were capturing vibrations on a grand scale. Bravo.

  • @JustWowNick
    @JustWowNick 8 днів тому +19

    Somehow that second version of the recording is harder to understand.

    • @slacktoryrecords4193
      @slacktoryrecords4193 8 днів тому

      Yeah, the speed-corrected one sounds like straight ass compared to the double-speed.

    • @ER-uy7ct
      @ER-uy7ct 4 дні тому +1

      Yes!

  • @user-vp1sc7tt4m
    @user-vp1sc7tt4m 12 днів тому +18

    How many of the commenters here actually got that we may have been been "Listening to the oldest known recording of a human voice" ??

  • @leaedt7614
    @leaedt7614 13 днів тому +12

    You can even hear him rolling the r's when he says 'Pierrot'.

  • @GeneRauXxX
    @GeneRauXxX 14 днів тому +31

    I think BBC should really learn improving memory techniques, if you look at the title.

  • @Jeff-66
    @Jeff-66 11 днів тому +114

    Still better than most modern music.

    • @SpiderxPunk
      @SpiderxPunk 8 днів тому +11

      Most modern music won't last 50 years, let alone 170

    • @TonysMusic1974
      @TonysMusic1974 8 днів тому +6

      ​@@SpiderxPunkthe best music of every generation lasts for centuries. 99% gets lost.

    • @weirdnomad8868
      @weirdnomad8868 7 днів тому

      Truth

    • @MagicToenail
      @MagicToenail 6 днів тому

      @@SpiderxPunkPlenty of music from 50 years ago has survived. As for 170 years ago, 99.995% has not survived

    • @asloii_1749
      @asloii_1749 4 дні тому

      @MagicToenail and it’s getting worse by the day. It really sucks

  • @Zerpersande
    @Zerpersande 3 дні тому +4

    3:14
    Just pushed ‘Record’
    There goes THAT historic recording.

  • @binghobson7122
    @binghobson7122 7 днів тому +12

    I remember hearing this some while ago on a Radio 4 programme. The presenter couldn’t stop herself laughing about it sounding like a bee trapped in a jam jar.

    • @HowardLeVert
      @HowardLeVert 6 днів тому

      Indeed - Charlotte Green in 2008.

  • @bwhog
    @bwhog 7 днів тому +39

    Now they need to digitally enhance that recording to reveal the undistorted voice.

    • @Asterra2
      @Asterra2 6 днів тому +10

      If you'd ever heard the earliest versions of this recording, you'd already know that they did _considerable_ cleanup on the recording for this video. The original has crackle and pops like the most damaged audio you ever heard from film.

    • @BenvolioCapulet9
      @BenvolioCapulet9 6 днів тому +7

      Autotune. “Lorde ya ya ya sittin on a Wednesday”

    • @ZEROGRAVITY80
      @ZEROGRAVITY80 5 днів тому +4

      ​@@BenvolioCapulet9"Ya Ya Ya, I am Lorde, Ya Ya Ya"

  • @MichaelTavel
    @MichaelTavel 4 дні тому +2

    'Recognizable' is a very generous description of that recording

  • @christianwheeler5920
    @christianwheeler5920 9 днів тому +15

    Gave me chills. Wow.

  • @tselengbotlhole750
    @tselengbotlhole750 14 днів тому +115

    The background music is absolutely unnecessary. It is annoying

    • @cdl0
      @cdl0 13 днів тому +9

      Agreed: it is pointless, intrusive, and annoying.

    • @ericschmid
      @ericschmid 12 днів тому +4

      Ah now I can't unheard it!

    • @gergoturan4033
      @gergoturan4033 12 днів тому +3

      It is unnecessary but I don't find it annoying

    • @lutello3012
      @lutello3012 12 днів тому +7

      FAR better than the dogshit on TikTok.

    • @jhonwask
      @jhonwask 11 днів тому +1

      That happens in so many videos and television commercials. I'd rather have dead silence in between spoken word.

  • @bart-v
    @bart-v 4 дні тому +3

    From the time when BBC was still a quality label.

  • @AdrianHertz
    @AdrianHertz День тому +2

    I was hoping the voice will say
    "Never gonna give you up"

  • @lilybond6485
    @lilybond6485 7 днів тому +17

    Little did that guy know that people in the future, all over the planet, could listen to him sing that song, on a small device they could hold in their hand. It would not even have been conceivable to him that would even be a possibility. What is it now - that we cannot even conceive of that will be an everyday thing 100 years from now ?

    • @Black.Sabbath
      @Black.Sabbath 7 днів тому +1

      The mark of the beast

    • @evanshannon
      @evanshannon 6 днів тому +1

      @@Black.Sabbathlol wut

    • @Nirrrina
      @Nirrrina 23 години тому +1

      It's breathtaking to wonder just what will be available & it's scary too.
      I just hope it's mainly wonderful stuff rather than scary things.

  • @markmalasics3413
    @markmalasics3413 8 днів тому +4

    It doesn't sound any different that a typical Taylor Swift recording.

  • @BETTERWORLDSGT
    @BETTERWORLDSGT 7 днів тому +3

    Wow! And that was around 50 years before the advent of the automobile!

  • @SteveI-fg5qt
    @SteveI-fg5qt 6 днів тому +2

    This reminds me of an old Mythbusters episode where they tested the idea that sounds may have been recorded as vibrations on ancient pottery being made. It didnt work but a tantalizing idea.

  • @leemelone6482
    @leemelone6482 7 днів тому +13

    So that’s what Ozzy 🤘sounded like in the early dayz

  • @danielryan4520
    @danielryan4520 7 днів тому +8

    Can’t believe we got 1876 “Clair de la Lune” before GTA VI 😔

    • @memathews
      @memathews 7 днів тому

      But which was in development longer?😂

  • @AALavdas
    @AALavdas 12 днів тому +35

    This is a wonderful story, which I have followed for years. But I have a question: what's the point of the clip with the cheapo cassete player in the end? Are we supposedly hearing the voice through this thing? And, if we are, why is the hand pressing the RECORD button?!? Just "play" would suffice...

    • @funnynews6718
      @funnynews6718 10 днів тому +12

      It was probably used as a prop for the video or the clip was taken from another video. Not the best choice.

    • @realryder2626
      @realryder2626 10 днів тому +18

      'Stock footage' filler

    • @cosmicraysshotsintothelight
      @cosmicraysshotsintothelight 7 днів тому

      They should have used a sped up video of a big drip of tar detaching from a big viscometer and falling.

  • @AdrianHertz
    @AdrianHertz День тому +1

    I was hoping the voice will say
    "is free real state"

  • @wesleysanders8570
    @wesleysanders8570 14 днів тому +42

    Interesting short video- but its not about memory?

  • @memofromessex
    @memofromessex 8 днів тому +3

    There's a recording of a Prussian noble who was born in the 18th century.

  • @DropBox-jx6yr
    @DropBox-jx6yr 23 години тому +3

    03:13 You’re welcome.

  • @jpvq31
    @jpvq31 4 дні тому +1

    This is beyond amazing. Edouard-Leon must be so proud.

  • @TinLeadHammer
    @TinLeadHammer 12 днів тому +55

    Combing, wrong focus, low resolution, horrible oversharpening, reels and cassettes to illustrate a 19th-century audio, playback is illustrated by pressing record button? What a mess.

    • @jhonwask
      @jhonwask 11 днів тому +8

      I thought I was the only one to notice.

    • @MildMisanthropeMaybeMassive
      @MildMisanthropeMaybeMassive 10 днів тому +6

      As someone with bad OCD, you are my kind of nitpicker.

    • @user-il8qp7px5f
      @user-il8qp7px5f 10 днів тому +2

      Given that the tape recorder indicates it has “One Button Record” I’d assume that given the fact the Play button is already pressed the Record button is functioning as a Pause switch. Although I certainly don’t understand why they would introduce another layer of noise by recording the voice to a cheap tape recorder and replaying the song on it.

    • @Marig_The_Mage
      @Marig_The_Mage 10 днів тому

      @@user-il8qp7px5f It'll be free royalty free stock footage

    • @realryder2626
      @realryder2626 10 днів тому +1

      What's your opinion on politics? I bet you don't miss much

  • @y2an
    @y2an 10 днів тому +4

    So, Edison didn’t invent the phonograph? 😂 Half right. His had playback.

  • @cenedraleaheldra5275
    @cenedraleaheldra5275 14 днів тому +49

    How is you title about memory, any thing to do with recording the voice…

    • @yugandali
      @yugandali 12 днів тому +12

      Maybe they made a mistake and fixed it, because the title I see, one day after you, is Listen to the oldest known recording of a human voice.

    • @petergibson2318
      @petergibson2318 12 днів тому +3

      A recording is a memory.

    • @Lexyvil
      @Lexyvil 11 днів тому +2

      Seems like they fixed the title.

  • @georgecovetskie6717
    @georgecovetskie6717 2 дні тому

    That guy was just 1 step short of creating the 1st record and/or phone.
    Genius anyway. Great stuff. Thanks for sharing.

  • @donpeters9849
    @donpeters9849 8 днів тому +13

    Dude explained it beautifully.

  • @andrewst9797
    @andrewst9797 12 днів тому +4

    👎 for the background music.

  • @jeffj2495
    @jeffj2495 9 днів тому +5

    Interesting to hear BUT
    no reel to reel, and no cassette, and NO OTHER magnetic tapes were used. Just some BS in this presentation. Heck, why not show a CD or DVD while they were at it.

    • @memathews
      @memathews 7 днів тому

      Or a wire recorder?

  • @JonnoPlays
    @JonnoPlays 4 години тому +1

    The first version sounded better though

  • @MiHiFiDi
    @MiHiFiDi 12 днів тому +4

    I'm listening to someone dead since 1850+?
    I need to hear the whole audio

  • @almezini1997
    @almezini1997 14 днів тому +31

    I forgot what this video was about by the end.

    • @zm12123
      @zm12123 11 днів тому +12

      I would probably get that checked out; something is seriously wrong with your brain. Maybe early onset dementia?

    • @chiarosuburekeni9325
      @chiarosuburekeni9325 8 днів тому

      @@zm12123brain rot is real. These mfs have attention spans shorter than fruit flies 💀💀

    • @BAztid
      @BAztid 7 днів тому +3

      It built to the singing potato.

    • @JhonNye96
      @JhonNye96 6 днів тому +1

      Go see a doctor

  • @simonsimon325
    @simonsimon325 14 днів тому +4

    In a weird way it worked. It reminded me of Charlotte Green's fits of laughter while reading the news after hearing this recording. So it sort of exercised my memory.

  • @Evemeister12
    @Evemeister12 3 дні тому +1

    Sounds like my stomach after a mutton vindaloo.

  • @geologyjoerocks
    @geologyjoerocks 12 днів тому +2

    Just can’t escape auto tune these days, lol

  • @bozolito108
    @bozolito108 6 днів тому +6

    “Uh yeah it’s gonna be a no for me dog”

  • @michman2
    @michman2 10 днів тому +13

    While interesting, this is akin to someone writing a book in ink that can't be seen or read. Edison knew that to be useful, the sound has to come back out and be recognizable.

  • @yunush
    @yunush 2 дні тому

    How fascinating.. and you can feel all the excitement, glee and joy in Dr Patrick’s voice as he is describing the discovery.. what a smart team of researchers

  • @shaggydawg5419
    @shaggydawg5419 13 годин тому

    "Hello, we are calling to offer you an extended car warranty..."

  • @slacktoryrecords4193
    @slacktoryrecords4193 8 днів тому +4

    I’m confused as to why that tape recorder in the last shot needed to have its ‘Record’ button pressed if all it was doing was playing back the cassette… ?

  • @stephenkz498
    @stephenkz498 9 днів тому +9

    Many things are often attributed to Edison of which he was not the first.

    • @sgrant39
      @sgrant39 6 днів тому

      They played it back in 2023. Edison did it about 150 years ago.

  • @modernarcheology2868
    @modernarcheology2868 7 днів тому +2

    I read that Edouard-Léon Scott de Martinville visited the white house and demonstrated this device to Abraham Lincoln. This means that the potential exist for there to be a sound wave diagram of Abraham Lincoln's voice. Wouldn't that be something to hear?

  •  3 дні тому

    Since the first time I knew about this, in my childhood, this piece of recording gave me goosebumps even before hearing it for the first time. I had to wait for the internet to be a thing to search for it. It's one of very few things in the world that is difficult for me to listen.

  • @gabbleratchet1890
    @gabbleratchet1890 7 днів тому +7

    164 years for people to hear that he was singing flat.

  • @gefloigle
    @gefloigle 6 днів тому +3

    So…recorded on a potato.

  • @lo_fye
    @lo_fye 9 годин тому

    They screwed up the last bit of the video by showing the person hit "record" on the cassette deck instead of just play. That would actually have recorded over the audio on the cassette instead of playing it back.

  • @wintermoonomen
    @wintermoonomen 8 днів тому

    Absolutely amazing! Thanks for sharing this piece of history.

  • @moonbeam7702
    @moonbeam7702 5 днів тому +6

    All I really heard was several vibrations rather than a man’s voice

    • @ladybirdlee3058
      @ladybirdlee3058 2 дні тому

      Yes. It doesn't sound like a voice when played slowly.

  • @somecuriosities
    @somecuriosities 14 днів тому +8

    Looks like someone made a woopsie with the video titles and what got uploaded

  • @Wikusvandemerwe-ny4fk
    @Wikusvandemerwe-ny4fk 3 дні тому

    Glad to see casettes are still being used!

  • @TehDawg
    @TehDawg 2 дні тому

    "When played back, is still understandable" Not one single person on this planet could understand a single word of that if you played it to someone who never knew the tune.

  • @pippetdog
    @pippetdog 14 днів тому +6

    Mistitled but very fascinating.

  • @teckwailee819
    @teckwailee819 11 днів тому +5

    Looks like the BBC is capable of clickbait as well

  • @hewgrebe4771
    @hewgrebe4771 5 днів тому

    Amazing to hear a man from so long ago, singing a good song.

  • @exclamationpointman3852
    @exclamationpointman3852 7 днів тому +1

    Voice starts at 3:15
    You know they have to stuff it with Styrofoam

  • @Harderanger
    @Harderanger 13 днів тому +6

    Fascinating. And still higher quality than 2024 phone calls 🙃

  • @Shahnanagans
    @Shahnanagans 14 днів тому +7

    How does this relate to memory? Has quality control been lost everywhere?

  • @rickys6770
    @rickys6770 2 дні тому

    "We've been trying to contact you about your vehicle's extended warranty"

  • @madmanonwheels5150
    @madmanonwheels5150 День тому

    And so they corrected and released the new version, which now sounds like a fly buzzing around your ears.

  • @syedmoheelraza4161
    @syedmoheelraza4161 14 днів тому +9

    "How to improve your memory" It's a question BBC is asking its viewers, cuz they have absolutely no idea.

  • @kwd3109
    @kwd3109 7 днів тому +3

    How ironic that the modern audio in this video ìs almost worse than the 1850s recording with the low voice of the presenter making it hard to hear him and the unnecessary and distracting music in the background.

  • @tatersncorn
    @tatersncorn 4 дні тому

    Gosh this is so beautiful. Now imagine if technology got so good we could find ancient recordings in fossils

  • @arias6720
    @arias6720 2 дні тому

    I used to have a mini cassette recorder,I’m hoping it’s in a box in my mom’s garage, I miss it.

  • @y2an
    @y2an 10 днів тому +5

    Try AI to remove the noise.

  • @FlushGorgon
    @FlushGorgon 11 днів тому +6

    You can't 'discover' records that were never lost. Achievements don't need to be embellished. Also, magnetic tapes represent neither 1860 nor today.

    • @SvenDansk7
      @SvenDansk7 9 днів тому +1

      Well, stock footage of a hard drive wouldn't be very visually appealing, would it?

    • @slacktoryrecords4193
      @slacktoryrecords4193 8 днів тому +1

      Yeah, are they suggesting that to play back this recording, the guy used a portable cassette tape recorder from the 80s? (Not to mention that the person in the video presses ‘Record’ to play it back??!)

    • @cosmicraysshotsintothelight
      @cosmicraysshotsintothelight 7 днів тому

      It is simply to convey the term "recording". You sticklers are far more stupid than the choices made by the video composer.

  • @richardcrosby6682
    @richardcrosby6682 17 годин тому

    I remember this sound with the man on the horse going and then he looks back at you while on the horse.

  • @Yamsek
    @Yamsek 5 днів тому

    Thats pretty amazing… I thought how could it possibly be older than the first Thomas Edison recording? Remarkable

  • @dad_jokes_4ever226
    @dad_jokes_4ever226 12 днів тому +3

    " Hi this is Alexander Graham Bell .Im not at home right now , but please leave your name and number after the beep and I'll get right back to you " . Beeeeep

  • @adrianrevill7686
    @adrianrevill7686 12 днів тому +4

    Shame the person at the end did not know how to operate a cassette recorder. You have to press play aand record

  • @user-pw3if8jh4z
    @user-pw3if8jh4z 7 днів тому +1

    I missed the voice of my late grand grandma born in 1897 n passed on in 1993

  • @fod2011
    @fod2011 5 днів тому

    The end of the video have me the
    'You're recording over it!'
    Fear