Actually I'm really glad that leeseo has the confidence to sing the other members lines when they don't sing them I hope she doesn't get hate that shuts her down and makes her lose her confidence
liz slaying even when’s crying. they’re singing just fine considering they’re crying. i’m actually impressed with wonyoung considering all the hate she gets for being bad at singing
I'm not their fan, but now I'm research about them (watching many of their contents) , cause I'm curious why they got so many hates? 🤷 All of them are talented, professional, all pretty and have their own uniqueness, they are funny and cute, dance very well, sing beautifully, great performers, good team work, good relationship, hard working. So why? 🤔 I just don't understand why lot of people throw their inner trashes, pains & insecurities on others and really harsh.
Guys let’s not forget they’re literally ALL crying, rookies, and probably super excited and nervous for this win! The fact that they all stood up there strong and still did their best says a lot ✨💕 this group is definitely going far and I can’t wait for them to perform more!
6. leeseo (💪💪didnt cry, comforting her unnies) 5. gaeul (wiped a tear but was vibing afterward 💪) 4. wonyoung (holding back a few tears💪) 3. liz (some tears) 🥉 2. rei 🥈(some more tears) 1. YUJIN🥇🥇🥇🥇(everybody comforting her within first few seconds, lot of tears) (there were some random cries during them all singing but idk who they were 😭😭😭so this inaccurate 😍👍)
glad to see them sing live in encore! it's very admirable for them to do despite the many hate and doubt from the audience that they will inevitably get. their vocals are rlly good esp for a group that debuted not long ago
Their vocals arent as powerful and good live as I expected but they are pretty good for a group that just debuted with most of them barely having a training time , plus most of them were crying. I'm sure that in the future their vocals will be even more powerful 💖💖 stan IVE
I mean I understand that it was emotional and all that, but I am noticing that rei has dodged that high note so many times and never sings it without a backing track.
I am sorry but some times I feel like when idols cried it’s just to avoid singing live so when ppl heard them will say “oh they are crying that’s why they sound bad” ........ lol
Lol I totally see what you mean xD this definitely felt weaker than I would've thought but the blond girl (forgot her name) was good even while crying; Yujin sounded good after she stopped crying (and why would she cry on purpose when it just makes her sound worse lol), same goes for Leeseo (I hope that's her name XD) and Rei. It's a bit strange xD
Not gonna lie some of they’re voices are not that great, although they did debut not long ago so they just need more vocal practice. I believe not all of the emotional moments were staged, but it does seem pretty suspicious how they avoid the high notes by “crying” or “wiping their tears”. Also it has happened multiple times in their other videos. No hate to them though because some of them are still pretty young and they just got started.
I need to tell you that there are a lot of groups that sing even worse than them and they get no hate. Please respect them even thought I'm not a fan of IVE
i mean they’ve been in training for awhile which is why i don’t like the theyre rookies excuse. i’m mostly disappointed in wonyoung it’s been 3 years and she hasn’t improved much just sad :/
idk man. you ever tried to sing while sobbing and being emotionally overwhelmed? i can hardly talk when im this emotional. most people would sound like dying whales. eh but, who’s thinking about logic here really.
I think they lip sync while dancing, they are not singing good without dancing, so, how they sing very good while Dancing and notes are perfect while dancing
Usually debut stage is pre recorded and for the other stage, they use backup vocal but they still need to sing it... So it's not 100% lipsync You can check their vocals while performing here👇 ua-cam.com/video/vpPSY-8zY0E/v-deo.html
so if they sang yall would be pressed af and be like "they have no emotions", and when they do sing you're also pressed af but now its "they can't sing" like ?????!?!?
Their voices are so damn amazing they don't need auto tuned at all... I've been listening to the studio version and couldn't believe their voices are so beautiful but this live version shows it really is true they have some amazing voices
Exactly. Some are ignoring that and some are saying she sang the worst. Like comeon after liz yujin and wonyoung were the best. They just don't want to appreciate her.
It’s actually sad how many K-pop fans assume Wonyoung can’t sing over a clip of her in a show… But if they took the time to watch teh encore stages they would see that Wonyoung is pretty stable after warming up her vocals.
@@laissa9372 it’s all about jealous. she is young, beautiful and talented. idk why people hating her, they think that she’s so fake and “pick me” but guys she’s just 17... i think she is a good person
“IVE can't sing” says by someone who only watched this video of them singing live. They were being emotional here cuz it's their first win. I couldn't even talk while crying. If you think they can't sing watch their recording at 1,2,3 IVE so y'all can shut your mouth 💀 Plus they we're just rookies here, literally debuted days ago and they improved a lot today
Bruh people make a bunch of excuses for kpop idols. They are literally supposed to be singers. They aren't even singing some Whitney Houston type of song. They went to the studio, recorded that song with their own voices and somehow they are unable to sing it live? 😭 Please. Sorry but they just feel so comfortable not singing live because they think they'll have a back up track/lyp sync all the time.
They are literally are crying because they win, did u even question why they are crying this much? And straight up judging them because of your insecurity
@@trynaletgo9450 It's obvious they were “crying” to avoid singing, lmao. Rei has avoided singing her high note in many different ways already. You have to be really dumb or a brainwashed fan to not see how they were looking at each other trying to look for clues on what to do. They were “crying” but there was no tears or the physical reaction when a person genuinely cries. Don't be dumb
Crazy how bg stans are in here criticizing this girls cracking when the song they are singing has many low tones and the girls are literally crying on stage.
Eventho they have won in izone era, somehow to start over is never easy like you aren't from those top agencies, probability to get hit is 50:50. many graduated from these kind of temporary groups and not yet get the place where ive now.. so their crying are understable.. and most of them still nervous to be in the encore stage for the very first time in their debut day
Why is people hating them in the comments, like bruh you guys are acting you all have good singing voices when in reality your voice is probably much worse and you can't even control it at all, and also this is their first win and they're overwhelmed by happiness so of course they can't sing properly their literally crying and shit, like all of you have eyes, maybe if you use it right you can see it that, but I guess you all are blind but a little abnormal type of blind because you all have the power to see the letters in your phone or keyboard to type shitty words, but when it comes to actually praising people for their hard work you all are overwhelmed by lazyness unlike when you hate something.
It is weird that they started almost whining during Rei high note (aka a note that she has always dodged), so I do think it is overexagerated to a point but I don't think it is completely acted.
... ummm?? Do you know how happy someone would be if they got their first win with their debut song in a new group AND broke itzy’s dalla dalla record? Especially if they were an idol, someone who is out in the world to be judged by millions of people? If i exposed myself to the whole world, i’d be hella happy too if people expressed they liked my talent by giving me my first win. This couldve gone so wrong yet it turned out well. Im sure many would be glad to have a good outcome
![[2022 MAMA] IVE&Kep1er&NMIXX&LESSERAFIM&NewJeans-ELEVEN+WADADA+O.O+FEARLESS+Hypeboy | Mnet 221129 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IJks7TIDfnk/mqdefault.jpg)
liz just casually cries in high note
Deadass 💀
XDD main vocalist stuff
Actually I'm really glad that leeseo has the confidence to sing the other members lines when they don't sing them I hope she doesn't get hate that shuts her down and makes her lose her confidence
who is lesso
@@lemonsweettae 1:32 is leseoo
thank you
@@s7960 that light high note was so nice
@@lemonsweettae a member of IVE
How can liz still sound so beautiful even with she's crying. She's blessed
no one is talking abt yujin’s high note 😭 that was amazing
Liz has the main vocal type
Trueeee 🪴💕
She's their main vocal
@@maryjane3411 no its Yujin
@@linoo44 no, it’s Liz
@@maryjane3411 no its yujin
I'm here after HYBE gg's encore😂😂😂
which one?
@@hatake.uchihaILLIT
@@hatake.uchihale ssera
BABYMONSTER @@hatake.uchiha
The blonde girl and the other one one in pigtails really carried this
True Liz(blonde hair girl) has really good vocals!
@@baengkiwi Main Vocalist :)
@@baengkiwi I see
Liz and rei😂
liz (blonde girl) rei (the one in pigtails)
Everyone: **sniff sniff** 😭
Leeseo and gaeul: 😀
The fact that you even saw Gaeul this encore is surprising ☠️
liz slaying even when’s crying. they’re singing just fine considering they’re crying. i’m actually impressed with wonyoung considering all the hate she gets for being bad at singing
Liz’s vocals tho
why don't everybody tell me that IVE live encore is so real- like all of them sound very incredible
lee seo really doesn't get enough praise for how good and stable her vocals are
People really deluded themselves into thinking their singing here was bad 😂 I cant believe how silly yall were at this time
im not a fan, and i thought they were fine, were people really thinking this was bad? ive seen wayyy worse
this one is actually super good tho
WHEN I HEAR THE WORD ENCORE, I ALWAYS THINK ABOUT THIS
People were hating on this encore but IVE is still better compared to Illit and Le Sserafim's encore. I'm shocked how bad Illit and LSF's vocals are.
Who is the blonde one? I really like her voice
Liz
I'm not their fan, but now I'm research about them (watching many of their contents) , cause I'm curious why they got so many hates? 🤷
All of them are talented, professional, all pretty and have their own uniqueness, they are funny and cute, dance very well, sing beautifully, great performers, good team work, good relationship, hard working. So why? 🤔
I just don't understand why lot of people throw their inner trashes, pains & insecurities on others and really harsh.
Liz voice very clearrr
Yujin cries like it was the first time she won a win
Lol
ummmm First time in Ive, it's a new start so.... ye
IVE as a brand new group is breaking the produce curse so it’s pretty understandable
She felt proud as a leader now
u shud watch their predebut video where she leads everyone lmao
Guys let’s not forget they’re literally ALL crying, rookies, and probably super excited and nervous for this win! The fact that they all stood up there strong and still did their best says a lot ✨💕 this group is definitely going far and I can’t wait for them to perform more!
Liz’s voice is super soft even when she’s crying
6. leeseo (💪💪didnt cry, comforting her unnies)
5. gaeul (wiped a tear but was vibing afterward 💪)
4. wonyoung (holding back a few tears💪)
3. liz (some tears) 🥉
2. rei 🥈(some more tears)
1. YUJIN🥇🥇🥇🥇(everybody comforting her within first few seconds, lot of tears)
(there were some random cries during them all singing but idk who they were 😭😭😭so this inaccurate 😍👍)
SO PROUD OF MY GIRLIES
Liz her vocals are so good❤❤
leeseo's voice sounds pleasant in this
It’s crazy how comments are like these when ive sound perfectly fine here. You know how people want to bring them down so bad back then.
What they sound so good wtf are ppl talking about
0:35 1:00 1:27 1:33 2:00 2:07 2:27 that high note r u kidding?
wony was stable asf
exactly 😂 they wanna to hate just to hate. they dont even believe themselves in reality that they sung bad lol
glad to see them sing live in encore! it's very admirable for them to do despite the many hate and doubt from the audience that they will inevitably get. their vocals are rlly good esp for a group that debuted not long ago
Their vocals arent as powerful and good live as I expected but they are pretty good for a group that just debuted with most of them barely having a training time , plus most of them were crying. I'm sure that in the future their vocals will be even more powerful 💖💖 stan IVE
it’s bad
@@moamoaoz oh my god this the second time i saw you under IVE LIVE VOCAL videos 😭😂 you must be obsessed with them😳
They’re literally crying what do you expect
@@cheen2413 still they were bad
They were literally crying or sobbing?? People barely can talk and cry too tf
I mean I understand that it was emotional and all that, but I am noticing that rei has dodged that high note so many times and never sings it without a backing track.
Same with Wonyoungs bridge (it was Yujin singing it, if I am not competely wrong). It is probably too difficult for them to sing
yea but she couldve just been insecure or nervous to sing that line
Facts!
Facts!
Do you even know what is high notes?
2:27 someone pls tell me who sang the whoawoahwwoaa cuz their vocals while crying r just ✨👌
I think it's Yujin since it's also her part
@@NicoloPaganini1003 tyy
No one can do it as good as Yujin 🔥
Yujin (girl farthest in right) is singing and Liz (blonde hair) is doing the high note
@@shroodley no? It’s the opposite
If you guys are thinking they can't sing live then just go watch 1,2,3 IVE episodes in which they do raw live vocal recording.🥰thank you
Aahh Truee 😭😭
But in this encoure they are really good whats wrong with these people?
you really need to sing live to record your vocals what are u talkin about 😭😭😭
@@Aa-uf5do yeah,plus they were crying and they still have years to improve
they were really good here tho considering they are not wearing ear pieces and are crying.
I am sorry but some times I feel like when idols cried it’s just to avoid singing live so when ppl heard them will say “oh they are crying that’s why they sound bad” ........ lol
Maybe it’s true sometimes, but I don’t think everyone does it :/
Lol I totally see what you mean xD this definitely felt weaker than I would've thought but the blond girl (forgot her name) was good even while crying; Yujin sounded good after she stopped crying (and why would she cry on purpose when it just makes her sound worse lol), same goes for Leeseo (I hope that's her name XD) and Rei. It's a bit strange xD
Rei’s cry seems so fake lol
Not gonna lie some of they’re voices are not that great, although they did debut not long ago so they just need more vocal practice. I believe not all of the emotional moments were staged, but it does seem pretty suspicious how they avoid the high notes by “crying” or “wiping their tears”. Also it has happened multiple times in their other videos. No hate to them though because some of them are still pretty young and they just got started.
When they sing live it's so awkward and that's not even hate, the only one I like hearing is the blonde one
@@sammi5801 yeah I love Liz’s voice
It's called pitch and belt not high notes pls!!
I need to tell you that there are a lot of groups that sing even worse than them and they get no hate. Please respect them even thought I'm not a fan of IVE
i mean they’ve been in training for awhile which is why i don’t like the theyre rookies excuse. i’m mostly disappointed in wonyoung it’s been 3 years and she hasn’t improved much just sad :/
Yujin and Liz are the only stable ones
Lesseo was actually good
wonyoung
I think the reason why Wonyoung is unstable is bcs she's crying (?)
They're actually crying so don't hate on them lol
someone really said 'their live vocal are no joke' HAHAHAHA
BYE-
That's so mean😭😭😭😭😭
Huh? I think this is still better than the others though lol
idk man. you ever tried to sing while sobbing and being emotionally overwhelmed? i can hardly talk when im this emotional. most people would sound like dying whales. eh but, who’s thinking about logic here really.
They sound better then anyone while crying and singing y'all just want to be mean 😑
Liz and yujin are the best !!!
Liz and Won voicee
Liz is so amazing
WHY IS GAEUL SO SMOL OMG😭❤️
I think they lip sync while dancing, they are not singing good without dancing, so, how they sing very good while Dancing and notes are perfect while dancing
Yes
Usually debut stage is pre recorded and for the other stage, they use backup vocal but they still need to sing it... So it's not 100% lipsync
You can check their vocals while performing here👇
ua-cam.com/video/vpPSY-8zY0E/v-deo.html
Hey I wanna say that they are crying so that's why there vocals are not stable 💜
@@jasreetkaur9723 but in live singing where they were not crying was also like this
I'm not fan of IVE but I will support this talented girls they deserved to be successful
so if they sang yall would be pressed af and be like "they have no emotions", and when they do sing you're also pressed af but now its "they can't sing" like ?????!?!?
Aww Liz is so sad I Love Liz so much 😊❤
Wonyoung’s vocal improved a lot!!!
Their voices are so damn amazing they don't need auto tuned at all... I've been listening to the studio version and couldn't believe their voices are so beautiful but this live version shows it really is true they have some amazing voices
Ppl complaining "they didnt sing well" like, bruh they're in the midst of crying, u can't even talk properly in that state 😂😂
Yess!💕💕
they sing well tho
Fr😭😭
Some of the crying seemed fake and I'm not trying to hate on them, the blonde sounded really really good tho
@@sammi5801 don't assume something you don't know
A crying chain, one cries and the rest starts hahahahaha awww
IVE under emotions still sing much more better than ILLIT in normal conditions
My queen Yujin was proud of them 💕
Liz 🎶✨
Why no one is talking about wonyoung? She did amazing. While everyone was crying she was singing beautifully.
Exactly. Some are ignoring that and some are saying she sang the worst. Like comeon after liz yujin and wonyoung were the best. They just don't want to appreciate her.
It’s actually sad how many K-pop fans assume Wonyoung can’t sing over a clip of her in a show…
But if they took the time to watch teh encore stages they would see that Wonyoung is pretty stable after warming up her vocals.
they did SO good! love them, congrats ive!
why is no one talking about wonyoung like she was so stable at her part...
Yes she was so stable, ppl criticized her so much that now she's not confident anymore to sing live in their encores ☹️
@@laissa9372 it’s all about jealous. she is young, beautiful and talented. idk why people hating her, they think that she’s so fake and “pick me” but guys she’s just 17... i think she is a good person
@@laissa9372 but she has improved now so much. She really works fast on the feedbacks
@@aileen456 She really does. Her singing has improved so much
Without Liz it could have gone very bad
They were just crying ☠️☠️
It was like she's carry the whole group lol😂
LIZ ❤️_❤️
LEESEO literally already knew they would win XD
Yujin-ah don't cry ❤️✨
0:48 UHH I'M SORRY
they’re crying yall.. you should try singing while crying😀
Keep hating on young girls. It’s a real good look for y’all
1:14 leeseo good job 💕
WOWWWWWW LIZ SOUNDS AMAZING
If someone says they don't song live again I'll sue
“IVE can't sing” says by someone who only watched this video of them singing live. They were being emotional here cuz it's their first win. I couldn't even talk while crying. If you think they can't sing watch their recording at 1,2,3 IVE so y'all can shut your mouth 💀 Plus they we're just rookies here, literally debuted days ago and they improved a lot today
I hope those people who said they cant sing have a BIG SLAP of REALITY where IVE is now at...❤❤❤
@asifityourlast7846 I guess you havent watch their performances in Universities where they sing it live,,,
❤❤❤so good live ❤❤❤vocals ❤❤❤
REI IS TOO CUTEEE
Bruh people make a bunch of excuses for kpop idols. They are literally supposed to be singers. They aren't even singing some Whitney Houston type of song. They went to the studio, recorded that song with their own voices and somehow they are unable to sing it live? 😭 Please. Sorry but they just feel so comfortable not singing live because they think they'll have a back up track/lyp sync all the time.
They are literally are crying because they win, did u even question why they are crying this much? And straight up judging them because of your insecurity
@@trynaletgo9450 It's obvious they were “crying” to avoid singing, lmao. Rei has avoided singing her high note in many different ways already. You have to be really dumb or a brainwashed fan to not see how they were looking at each other trying to look for clues on what to do. They were “crying” but there was no tears or the physical reaction when a person genuinely cries. Don't be dumb
@@trynaletgo9450 they’re literally pretending lmao
Crazy how bg stans are in here criticizing this girls cracking when the song they are singing has many low tones and the girls are literally crying on stage.
i hope they grow more confident in the future bc they have so much potential
and they did
Why the heck did Gaeul not get any camera time in the encore???!! Ugh 😒
P.s. So happy for the girls and their first win! 💓 🏆
Gaeul be like :- peice of cake...!!!
liz’s vocals are so beautiful
Wonyoung is so pretty
Even tho yujin cried she ate
They did a great job in this and other encores I’ve seen. What is the problem???
Ikr? They are fantastic in all their performances!
best actresses))))))))
Eventho they have won in izone era, somehow to start over is never easy like you aren't from those top agencies, probability to get hit is 50:50. many graduated from these kind of temporary groups and not yet get the place where ive now.. so their crying are understable.. and most of them still nervous to be in the encore stage for the very first time in their debut day
Why is people hating them in the comments, like bruh you guys are acting you all have good singing voices when in reality your voice is probably much worse and you can't even control it at all, and also this is their first win and they're overwhelmed by happiness so of course they can't sing properly their literally crying and shit, like all of you have eyes, maybe if you use it right you can see it that, but I guess you all are blind but a little abnormal type of blind because you all have the power to see the letters in your phone or keyboard to type shitty words, but when it comes to actually praising people for their hard work you all are overwhelmed by lazyness unlike when you hate something.
The only member who can sing is the blonde one the other don’t try to sing 😂😂😂😂
LIZ SLAYING IN 1:23
Liz penyelamat 🤣
Liz and wonyoung killed this
wony didn’t even sing her bridge lol
@@user-ib1is7ny7r eh you don't have ears?
are they crying so they don’t sing
fr everyone except for liz is trying so hard to cry
Wonyoung and Gaeul really stayed pretty for the show, barely saw any tears come out of their eyes💀
They are good actually
Wow They have vocals
I love you ❤❤❤ ive 😭😭🥹🥺🫶🏻
Liz and lesseo vocal are gold
beria sgt nangis tu .. masa ni lah nk dgr suara betol 😅 tgk mv mmg sedap belaka😂 huhuhu
Liz ❤️❤️
LIZ POWEEEER!!!!!
live love ive
YUJIN'S HIGHNOTE OMGG
Song is perfect for their vocals. Love to see it 👌🏾
They r over acting and I feel they r crying to not sing and get criticized 4 their singing
Ummm I don’t think so…..
they got very emotional as they didn’t expect to win so fast, coming from a not so big company
@@baengkiwi maybe
It is weird that they started almost whining during Rei high note (aka a note that she has always dodged), so I do think it is overexagerated to a point but I don't think it is completely acted.
...
ummm?? Do you know how happy someone would be if they got their first win with their debut song in a new group AND broke itzy’s dalla dalla record? Especially if they were an idol, someone who is out in the world to be judged by millions of people? If i exposed myself to the whole world, i’d be hella happy too if people expressed they liked my talent by giving me my first win. This couldve gone so wrong yet it turned out well. Im sure many would be glad to have a good outcome
Can you even talk while crying?💀
Liz carried
from crying at first music show win to first daesang woww
Liz！！！！！！