Dr, karmi. Dear ma'm. I am sri lankan , today i had finish read ur " book of serch of fatima" its very painful to my heart and i feel proud for you even i m deference nationality. I can imagine u and ur childhood life. May allah bless you . .
Kemp supports war criminals, it's also why he's a FOI. He's responsible for wanting to stop prosecution of soldiers committing war crimes ...he has weak immoral arguments ....it's why the only clapping for Kemp was a rich old white guy, singular...it was so obvious to all....it was embarassing
Wrong, the Palestinians have been failed by everyone. We the people failed them, the governments world wide failed them. My condolences to all Palestinians.
Blue Star lol “fakestenians” says the moron who drives people out of their land and houses because of the false notion of sky daddy saying “that is your home o chosen people”.
This one and Lowkey'e were deffo the best. Arab government are not doing much? Yes. But is not the people is the ones higher up. (and btw is not like any other countries are doing much either. The first one was talking about all the money given, it must have been lost on the way, because if this Palestine gets that much help every year it must have been reconstructed by now..) All GOVERNMENTS are failing Palestinian people.
these two are paid liars by some Arabic organization for your information. Palestiniasn refugees where not given their rights ifn Lebabon Syria and Jordan. Read about Black September How king Hussien murdered most of those Palestinians. Also, did you know there were 856,000 Jewish refugees which fled the Muslim Arabic countries since 1947 compare to 711,000 refugees from Palestine. What do you say about that ? Did any Jewish person ever demanded to go back home to his arabic home to g et his rights back ?
Were those Jewish not primarily of the Roman democratic mentality? This is confusing...why would one gratefully accept living in someone's house and then redecorate it and kick them out?
The real history of propaganda and lies. wake up... Lebanon, Syria Jordan slaughtered Palestinians refugees read about Black September how King Hussein murdered thousands of Palestinians do not let anyone brain wash you
And no one talks about the quarter million Arab Palestinians ethnically cleansed from Kuwait, by other Arabs!!!!! A big thank you to Yasser Arafat for that tragedy.... @@ramleri1
1948 was a long time ago. How is it, then, that Palestinians are still living in festering refugee camps to this day if indeed Arab governments are working so hard for the Palestinian cause?
Because the International world with U.S. Veto power and direct complicity do not hold I$rael accountable for their illegal settlements, violence and now current war crimes.
@@asaf0125 people died because of the war , not because of the Palestinians... People were murdered because of the islamists that Israel used to help and heal in the Golan heights.
Please accept us we lost our homes and family that's what jewsh people's wrote on their ships and the Palestinians people's tooks them home to lived with them for few years that's the crimes the Palestinians people's committed against jewsh people's
why because she is a good liar? she live a few months at age 9 in an arab country and says arabs gave her the opportunity.....she went straight to britain. Palestinians live in arab countries as refugees for 70 years....... while a turk like your father came to europe to work a few years and god his nationality.....you could go to kuweit or qatar etc for 100 years you dont get shit. She is a liar....no credibility
@@mikailkhan5454 DUDE, I'm going to respect your intellect and insinuate that you understood what I meant. I guess you just have that urge to correct me, and prolly are influenced by some feminist nonsense.
This woman is an ignorant dishonest liar. She should improve here historical study before coming to lecture in Oxford. She humiliated the institute with her presence
Israel with out the American support , and some Euorpeian countries can't make this crimes into Indegioneus people , but we are the Arab have the same responsibility too, our regimes don't take the right way,,, Palestine fore ever...
Lin Yan because arabs aren’t all they same. Palestinians have their own culture. They had land and a history there for 1,000 of years. Just like Chinese aren’t the same as Japanese.
The most interesting argument is linking the Palestinian problem to the Nazis. An anti-Semitic world provided compensation to the Jews of Europe by imposing the cost of resettlement in the Arab world. Not an argument I had considered before.
Dino Ramzi Most Israeli Jews were refugees from Arab lands, Morocco, Yemen, Algeria, Egypt and Syria. Many Jews of Iraq were massacred in the Farhud Massacre of 1941
@@loaded8588 ancestry does not equate ownership. Zionists have no problem owning Indigenous land in America, Canada and Australia. These places are not their historic homeland, but they have no understanding property rights suddenly. If they truly practiced what they preached, they would give back the historic homeland to the natives in these countries. (Oh wait they won't, bc it was never actually about history)
Excellent point, Unfortunately some Palestinians still have a certain opinion about jordan not doing enough for them, I don't want to use this platform to discuss that, I am sure you know that being a Zomot from Jordan.
she didn't mention each by each country and left Jordan aside. She actually only mentioned Syria because she+her family fled to Syria so she is speaking about her first hand personal experience
Most of Palestine is within Jordan borders so that’s where Palestinians belongs today, it’s Arabic, Muslim and forbidden for Jews, so it’s a win for everyone.
800k jews wich expelled from the arab countries in 1948 were setteled in Israel - no one talk about them ... In the year 2019 Oxford still talks about Palestinian refugees which born in the sea...
They were terrorists that bombed government buildings , cinemas and public buildings . They were not expelled , they were Zionists that chose to leave , and they were not 800 thousand , that one big fat lie.
@@canaannoah4712 You can invent any story you want and even believe in it ...But you cant change the history and you can not change and reality today - Israel is a strong country with a strong people. Too strong for you !
@@jbrown7813 we have a good relationship with the world , but we are not depend in no one .thats all .the day we will be under freat of distraction , the all world and humanity will go down with us . There wont be a world without Israel anymore .
It's so funny that she says indigenous Palestinians but she forgot to mention that Palestinians was referred to as Jews before 1967 and then the political invention of so called Palestinian people. Which most of them are Jordanian
Great speach but,There is a need to emphasize the identity of the Palestinians because debates revolving around Palestine often assume an Arab identity. I don't blame people for this assumption, as if you go to Palestine now, they speak Arabic. Their shops, roads, and even television programs are all in Arabic. To someone from a Western country or an Orientalist, it is difficult to differentiate between Palestinians and Arabs because they speak the same language and look similar. However, in reality, the skin tones of Arabs and Palestinians differ. The communities in the Levant, including Palestinians, generally have lighter skin tones compared to the Arabs in North Africa, who tend to have darker skin tones. There are similarities due to interactions over the years, facilitated by the spread of Islam and the expansion of Arab empires in these regions. Emphasizing the identity of Palestinians is crucial, especially in the context of the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians, as both claim that this area is their homeland. The basis of their claims often takes a historical side, except for the Israelis, who also take a theological side, claiming that this land was given to them by God. Historically, the Israelis claim that their great ancestor, Jacob, migrated with other Hebrew families from the city of Ur, in modern-day Iraq, and settled in Canaan, which in the 1920s was referred to as Palestine. Historical Canaan is the area that today comprises the state of Jordan and Israel. The Hebrews or Israelis claim they settled there and interacted with the Canaanites, finding them in a position of power. After the Bronze Age collapse, primarily caused by the Sea Peoples from the Aegean Peninsula, the Canaanite civilization was unable to regain control. Consequently, the Hebrews, or Israelis, became predominant in government matters, forming the Kingdom of Judea and the Kingdom of Israel. Over time, there were power vacuums and shifts between empires, including the Greeks, Romans, Persians, Arabs, Turks, and Kurds. Palestinians claim that they are descendants of the Canaanites, a Semitic people like the Arabs. However, despite some linguistic similarities, they are not the same. Palestinians have taken DNA tests, and it was found that almost 60% of their DNA is Canaanite, with the rest being a mix of Egyptian, Iraqi, Turkish, and about 5% Arab DNA. These tests, conducted by private agencies like 23andMe, confirm that most Palestinians are not Arabs. Before 1920, the term "Arabs" referred to people living in the Arabian Peninsula. Outside this area, regions like Lebanon or Palestine were not considered Arab lands or their people Arab. An Arab country was one under Arab leadership, geographically situated in the Arabian Peninsula. An Arab is anyone with a deep connection to the Arabian Peninsula, tracing their heritage and culture back to this region. Therefore, the cultures of Yemen, Oman, and Saudi Arabia are similar, but outside the Arabian Peninsula, distinctions become apparent. The Islamic and Arabic influence over the centuries caused the local languages and identities to evolve. Some people believe they are descendants of Arabs, even though they aren't. Using the Arab League's standard for identifying Arab countries includes places like Somalia, although Somalians are not Arabs. For Palestinians to achieve autonomy and regain control over their land, they must emphasize their unique identity. Assuming an Arab identity and relying on Arab countries for support may not be effective. Out of 22 Arab countries, only 7 (Saudi Arabia, Oman, Qatar, Kuwait, Bahrain, United Arab Emirates, and Yemen) might intervene, and these are predominantly Arab countries except for Jordan. The Jordanian monarchy acquired land through occupation during the British mandate of Palestine in 1920. Abdullah ibn Hussein requested an audience with the British Prime Minister, resulting in the division of Palestine, with Eastern Palestine given to the Arabs (Transjordan) and Western Palestine to the Zionist Jews, forming the state of Israel. Many Palestinians do not see eye to eye with Jordanians, despite the latter granting them citizenship. The division of their land involved no native Palestinians, leading to the formation of local militias fighting the occupation on both sides. The Jordanians crushed these revolutions, while the Israelis, with Western support, managed to persist. Significant revolutions, like Black September orchestrated by Yasser Arafat, leader of the Palestinian Liberation Organization, highlight the continued struggle.
Did you know since 1947 there were 856,000 Jewish refugees from Arabic Muslim countries and compared to 711,000 Palestinian refugees. Did you ever hear about those refugees ? You know why you did not, because those poor jewish refugees settled quitely in all parts of the world and continue with life. Jerry Sinfeled , Enrico Massias, Bernard Henry Levi are all Children of refugees of Arabic countries But no one talks about it. They rather make Israel to be guilty Shame on those who use Palestinians as a propaganda tool
@@ramleri1 we all know that and we are against it because everyone have the right to live free in the countries they were born and lived in for centuries. But let’s be clear too Jews throughout history lived in arab countries for centuries in peace ( Mohamed the 5th king of Morocco refused to give marrocan Jews to hitler at the expense of his own life, does your history talk about that?)but with the establishment of Israel at the expense of the indigenous people Arab leaders kicked the Jews in their countries out. True it was unfair but let’s not forget the atrocities committed by Israel to the Palestinians who have nothing to do with the arab leaders
Problem has no chance be solved by blaming forces involved in. Solution is from estimation of the cultural, scientific and technological achievements of the nations Egypt, Libya, Syria, Iraq, Somalia, Ethiopia and Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan compare states of Western civilisation and Israel as part of it.
She’s not anti-Semitic at all. Israel retracted from Gaza, even dug up graves to move to Israel, left greenhouses, farmland for Palestinians. There are 2 million Palestinians who live and work in Israel. 1.5 million come across to work and earn money each day.
The fact that the Arab Islamist Army invaded the Holy Lands doesn't get a mention as if it didn't happen, but it did & no amount of time since then gives Arabs the right to call themselves indigenous to the Lands that clearly belong to the Israelites.
Ohhh stop blaming hamas for everything. The fact that it didn’t exist until yeeeaaasrs later after Israël was established is evidence enough to proof that if Israel was fair to the indigenous people, hamas wouldn’t even exist. Can you please stop using this old rusty argument and talk facts on the ground. The world is waking up to the horrors of Israel. And please don’t use the other argument that Israel is treating the Palestinians better than other arab states with the minorities. Because we all know that the arab world is unstable and ruled by military dictators. We’re talking about the Palestinians rights to live free in their homes and lands
her argument makes sense if you forget that the expulsion of the palestinians came after a bloody war for survival on the part of Isreal, led by arab nations that wanted to diviide it up amongst themselves. That in mind, thher argument completely falls down
What about England , USA and the rest of the world the UN ???? I don’t blame Israel I blame the one who recognize Israel ,,,,, just a point from a saudi man 🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦 and Israel won’t be for too long .
of course it has.. it's the only reason they're there. either accept a border and sign a peace treaty or relocate them to another arab country. stop bothering israel and stop annoying the rest of the world.
no arguments...it was begging. she is also a liar....she lived a few months in an arab country ( likely syria ) she is half syrian. she came straight to britain....so who gave her opportunities? Dont be a dumb arab if genetically possible
really smart example showing how hospitable and humanitarian Syria is... from the moment she said that everything sounded like "lies lies and more lies".
It's only a lie to racist westerners bc they like paint Arabs as "barbaric" even the europeans are the ones that stole Palestinian land, Americans invaded Iraq and Afghanistan, stole their oil, murdered 100,000 civilians and bombed their country. Narcissists love making their victims to look the like the bad guy.
i love how she elegantly left out the fact that Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon invaded Israel in 48. she portrait them as passive, reactionists to the situation while in truth they were the catalyst.
You meant Palestine. Israel is the name the european settlers use for Palestine. It was the Arab world trying to defend themselves from european invaders. That's like when the Americans called the Native people "savages" when they tried to genocide them. Colonizers gaslight and say their victims are the aggressors while Colonizers are literally trying to kill them.
Israel's map back in 1948 included Jordan, parts of Syria, Lebanon, and Egypt. The zionist greed and aspirations were also a direct threat to all the surrounding nations to Palestine. Still is.
Laughter is truly the best medicine. After a tough week, I watched my favorite UA-cam comedy clips - Jackie Mason, Rodney Dangerfield, Lewis Black, Louis Anderson, Dr. Karmi, Joan Rivers, and Benny Hill. Totally relaxed now.
“Before the Balfour Promise, when the Ottoman rule [1517-1917] ended, Palestine’s political borders as we know them today did not exist, and there was nothing called a Palestinian people with a political identity as we know today”, historian Abd Al-Ghani stated.
There was a Palestinian congress held in 1911 to complain about the infux of European Zionist settlers into Mandatory Palestine. I presume it was attended by Ghosts.
Palestinians were fishermen from Crete living in the city of Gaza. Egypt was Coptic at that time. The indigenous people of the land of Israel are the Jews. For many centuries the Jews suffered and got expelled many, many times. Just a small community managed to live in Jerusalem. The WWII influenced the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948. Palestine a name given for land by the British. Even the borders were not correct. Palestine was Israel. At that time there were not even mosques. The mosque that is built is on the Holy Soil of the Jewish Temple. It was a British mandate. Iraq as well. Syria and Lebanon were a French mandate (1928). In 1928 the Ottoman Empire collapsed caused the mandates. However, Eretz Israel exists for over more than 4.000 years. The Arabs don't care for the Arabs living in Gaza. Once, land for peace. The Arabs who call themselves Palestinians got land which is previously Egypt, but forgot about the peace. The West do care about these Arabs because they are an easily bargain to the Middle East and for their own politics at home as well. That will change when ALL cars have a battery pack instead of gas tank. The Arab leaders got and get billions of Dollars. What happens to all that money. From the Qatari tranche, the Arabs received a one time payment form their leaders. $ 600,- for a married couple and $ 200,- for those who are single. Investments? Where? The leaders enrich themselves with million dollars mansions, private jets. Not only Qatar sends money. Iran as well. Iran facilitates Hamas. Iran facilitates Hezbollah which means that both are proxy-armies of Iran. Playing the victim card and the behave of an entrepreneur is in fact the humiliation of a people. And actually two. Eretz Israel is the biblical, ancient and the eternal land of the Jews.
Why no facts at all? if you ask any Syrian they would tell you the same facts she said; that Palestinians living in Syria where given even more rights than Syrians themselves. From citizenship to economic prosperity
full of historical lies and contradictions open history books and lear there were 856,000 Jewish refugees from Arabic countries. They never complained. they settled quitely and never demanded their right Why cant the palestinian refugee settle like the 856,000 Jewish refugees ? they fled to US, they fled to France, to Canada, to Israel etc. Leren History before praise liar who have the courage to distort facts
@@ramleri1 if "the jews settled quietly" in other areas" why cant the palistinians. it seems they have no where to go? can they leave gaza and go elsewhere? i am interested in learning more, rebecca
Dr Ghada Karmi really need to read some history, her speak was a big propaganda act, but did not reflect historical facts. In short, she tells from the beginning a false historic narrativ.
Watch the full debate here: ua-cam.com/video/WCttBM2jK_E/v-deo.html
Speaking truth to power! What a force.
Dr, karmi. Dear ma'm. I am sri lankan , today i had finish read ur " book of serch of fatima" its very painful to my heart and i feel proud for you even i m deference nationality. I can imagine u and ur childhood life. May allah bless you . .
Look at Kemp self congratulating and smiling proudly at his "expertise" before Kharmi delivered the blow.
Karen Ward
Colonel Kemp is a hundred times more knowledgeable that the Karmi witch.
She sounds like a Hamas operative, with her propaganda.
Daughter of Jerusalem what. You can’t even acknowledge the face palm.
Kemp supports war criminals, it's also why he's a FOI. He's responsible for wanting to stop prosecution of soldiers committing war crimes ...he has weak immoral arguments ....it's why the only clapping for Kemp was a rich old white guy, singular...it was so obvious to all....it was embarassing
Dr Ghada Karmi is wonderful , she speak a lot of truth about Palestine
Thank you Dr. Ghada, very nicely said
The Truth Speech Dr. Ghada Karmi ❤
Her emotive manner of speaking brought me to tears. Her experience touched me. Her delivery was perfect
Too bad she is such a bad liar.
Only for the gullible.@Blue Star
Sarrah Mohammed: Like acting, do you?
@Sarrah Mohammaed Ghada Karmi is Amazing and extremely on point in her examples and analysis!
The UK created, perpetuated and sustained the horror.
why did brexit happen? did it happen or did covid stop it?
Wrong, the Palestinians have been failed by everyone. We the people failed them, the governments world wide failed them. My condolences to all Palestinians.
Thats true
Blue Star lol “fakestenians” says the moron who drives people out of their land and houses because of the false notion of sky daddy saying “that is your home o chosen people”.
This one and Lowkey'e were deffo the best. Arab government are not doing much? Yes. But is not the people is the ones higher up. (and btw is not like any other countries are doing much either. The first one was talking about all the money given, it must have been lost on the way, because if this Palestine gets that much help every year it must have been reconstructed by now..) All GOVERNMENTS are failing Palestinian people.
these two are paid liars by some Arabic organization
for your information. Palestiniasn refugees where not given their rights ifn
Lebabon Syria and Jordan. Read about Black September How king Hussien
murdered most of those Palestinians.
Also, did you know there were 856,000 Jewish refugees which fled the Muslim Arabic countries since 1947 compare to 711,000 refugees from Palestine. What do you say about that ? Did any Jewish person ever demanded to go back home to his arabic home to g et his rights back ?
@@ramleri1 lowkey isnt a paid liar i dont know much about the subject but dont discredit him like that as a person
Fled due to what?
Genocide? Or cuz they want to leave to Israel
Were those Jewish not primarily of the Roman democratic mentality? This is confusing...why would one gratefully accept living in someone's house and then redecorate it and kick them out?
@@ramleri1 856,000 Jewish refugees fled or wre they expelled? please say more rebecca
From the "Israeli foreign ministry" 😂😂
Saurav Rai from the saudi people 🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕 and 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦
She told it like it should be said time and time again
Thanks Dr Gadha Karmi for creating awareness about Palestinian issue and Thanks tp the channel for uploading it
The real history of colonialism.
Arab Colonialism.
The real history of propaganda and lies.
wake up... Lebanon, Syria Jordan slaughtered Palestinians refugees
read about Black September how King Hussein murdered thousands
of Palestinians
do not let anyone brain wash you
And no one talks about the quarter million Arab Palestinians ethnically cleansed from Kuwait, by other Arabs!!!!! A big thank you to Yasser Arafat for that tragedy....
@@ramleri1
If what she said had anything at all to do with factual history, yes. But she told a false historic narrative, a narrativ the world have never seen.
@@ramleri1 liar
I love listening to ghada karmi .
From the “Israeli Foreign Ministry” 😂 that was good, sounds like she is from hogwarts but it was accurate
What a strong figure full of eloquence and knowledge 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Magnificent speech by Ghada Karmi.
1948 was a long time ago.
How is it, then, that Palestinians are still living in festering refugee camps to this day if indeed Arab governments are working so hard for the Palestinian cause?
Because the International world with U.S. Veto power and direct complicity do not hold I$rael accountable for their illegal settlements, violence and now current war crimes.
I cannot agree more with this lady, she is totally right . Million of thumbs UP
The King of Jordan hired the Pakistan army to kill the Palestine Refugees in 1967.
Whether you like it or not, Syria and Lebanon are the countries that defended the Palestinian cause the most, both militarily and ideologically.
And look at lebanon and sirya now.....just saying
@@asaf0125 if you imply that there is a causality, I highly doubt it.
@@eddy6626 are you for real? How many people were murdered last war in sirya? And lebqnon. ...you cant be that blind and deaf.
@@asaf0125 people died because of the war , not because of the Palestinians... People were murdered because of the islamists that Israel used to help and heal in the Golan heights.
And they still are to this day. Notice how they the ones who arent western puppets.
Please accept us we lost our homes and family that's what jewsh people's wrote on their ships and the Palestinians people's tooks them home to lived with them for few years that's the crimes the Palestinians people's committed against jewsh people's
She Nailed this perfectly!
This should be translated to every language.
This woman is amazing
why because she is a good liar? she live a few months at age 9 in an arab country and says arabs gave her the opportunity.....she went straight to britain. Palestinians live in arab countries as refugees for 70 years....... while a turk like your father came to europe to work a few years and god his nationality.....you could go to kuweit or qatar etc for 100 years you dont get shit.
She is a liar....no credibility
The only thing that's amazing about that woman is her conviction of her lies. She is the Cover Girl for Delusional Magazine
best argument because it’s simply the truth
Dr. Ghada Karmi is a Great Author Too. Humanity First.
Every human being who has humanity supports Palestine until its land is returned to it
She is a strong intelligent woman who has witnessed the Nakba.She has advocated for the rights of the Palestinians and been their voice.
Wow
That woman is more of a man than every other weasel facing her. MashaAllah, My Allah Protect and guide her.
More of a man???
Respect her femininity
@@mikailkhan5454 DUDE, I'm going to respect your intellect and insinuate that you understood what I meant. I guess you just have that urge to correct me, and prolly are influenced by some feminist nonsense.
I love Dr. Karmi
I have learned a lot from this video. Thank you Dr. Ghada
This woman is an ignorant dishonest liar. She should
improve here historical study before coming to lecture in
Oxford. She humiliated the institute with her presence
You have learned from this demagoguery ? Time to 'unlearn'
@@lamoitte1 stop whining
Israel with out the American support , and some Euorpeian countries can't make this crimes into Indegioneus people , but we are the Arab have the same responsibility too, our regimes don't take the right way,,, Palestine fore ever...
then why didn't whose Arabic people integrate with Palestinian why are they still living in camp till today
Israel created the conflict , mostly European zionists and they don't belong here , they are not even Semitic as they claim.
Lin Yan because arabs aren’t all they same. Palestinians have their own culture. They had land and a history there for 1,000 of years. Just like Chinese aren’t the same as Japanese.
Are Europeans all one individual ethnic group? Being an Arab is not a race nor an ethnicity.
By the same token, why didnt Europe and th US not integrate ALL the Jewish refugees after WWII??
Absolutely a 1000% correct!!!
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
The most interesting argument is linking the Palestinian problem to the Nazis. An anti-Semitic world provided compensation to the Jews of Europe by imposing the cost of resettlement in the Arab world.
Not an argument I had considered before.
They were offered a 2 state solution and turned it down. Israel is the historic homeland of the Jewish people
Dino Ramzi
Most Israeli Jews were refugees from Arab lands, Morocco, Yemen, Algeria, Egypt and Syria. Many Jews of Iraq were massacred in the Farhud Massacre of 1941
@@loaded8588 ancestry does not equate ownership. Zionists have no problem owning Indigenous land in America, Canada and Australia. These places are not their historic homeland, but they have no understanding property rights suddenly. If they truly practiced what they preached, they would give back the historic homeland to the natives in these countries. (Oh wait they won't, bc it was never actually about history)
@@loaded8588 it's not the homeland of zionism..
What a eloquent women!!!
A really good point she explained, but she forgot mention Jordan who has dealt with 80% of the problem was mentioned
Excellent point, Unfortunately some Palestinians still have a certain opinion about jordan not doing enough for them, I don't want to use this platform to discuss that, I am sure you know that being a Zomot from Jordan.
she didn't mention each by each country and left Jordan aside. She actually only mentioned Syria because she+her family fled to Syria so she is speaking about her first hand personal experience
Most of Palestine is within Jordan borders so that’s where Palestinians belongs today, it’s Arabic, Muslim and forbidden for Jews, so it’s a win for everyone.
unfortunately, the title of this debate is not "Israel". Stick to the topic, the brotherhood.
All roads lead to Rome...
How to rewrite history ! A True lie !
What an argument
800k jews wich expelled from the arab countries in 1948 were setteled in Israel - no one talk about them ... In the year 2019 Oxford still talks about Palestinian refugees which born in the sea...
They were terrorists that bombed government buildings , cinemas and public buildings .
They were not expelled , they were Zionists that chose to leave , and they were not 800 thousand , that one big fat lie.
@@canaannoah4712 You can invent any story you want and even believe in it ...But you cant change the history and you can not change and reality today - Israel is a strong country with a strong people. Too strong for you !
@@allondb Germany was the strongest nation in the planet. Israel can't stand without the west.
without the west you wouldn't be there in one day.
@@jbrown7813 we have a good relationship with the world , but we are not depend in no one .thats all .the day we will be under freat of distraction , the all world and humanity will go down with us . There wont be a world without Israel anymore .
L.Breitbart 😂😂😂😂😂🙄
It's so funny that she says indigenous Palestinians but she forgot to mention that Palestinians was referred to as Jews before 1967 and then the political invention of so called Palestinian people. Which most of them are Jordanian
And this is what it should be played-taught at schools all around the world. The actual truth
really respect dr. karmi
Great speach but,There is a need to emphasize the identity of the Palestinians because debates revolving around Palestine often assume an Arab identity. I don't blame people for this assumption, as if you go to Palestine now, they speak Arabic. Their shops, roads, and even television programs are all in Arabic. To someone from a Western country or an Orientalist, it is difficult to differentiate between Palestinians and Arabs because they speak the same language and look similar. However, in reality, the skin tones of Arabs and Palestinians differ. The communities in the Levant, including Palestinians, generally have lighter skin tones compared to the Arabs in North Africa, who tend to have darker skin tones. There are similarities due to interactions over the years, facilitated by the spread of Islam and the expansion of Arab empires in these regions.
Emphasizing the identity of Palestinians is crucial, especially in the context of the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians, as both claim that this area is their homeland. The basis of their claims often takes a historical side, except for the Israelis, who also take a theological side, claiming that this land was given to them by God. Historically, the Israelis claim that their great ancestor, Jacob, migrated with other Hebrew families from the city of Ur, in modern-day Iraq, and settled in Canaan, which in the 1920s was referred to as Palestine. Historical Canaan is the area that today comprises the state of Jordan and Israel. The Hebrews or Israelis claim they settled there and interacted with the Canaanites, finding them in a position of power. After the Bronze Age collapse, primarily caused by the Sea Peoples from the Aegean Peninsula, the Canaanite civilization was unable to regain control. Consequently, the Hebrews, or Israelis, became predominant in government matters, forming the Kingdom of Judea and the Kingdom of Israel. Over time, there were power vacuums and shifts between empires, including the Greeks, Romans, Persians, Arabs, Turks, and Kurds.
Palestinians claim that they are descendants of the Canaanites, a Semitic people like the Arabs. However, despite some linguistic similarities, they are not the same. Palestinians have taken DNA tests, and it was found that almost 60% of their DNA is Canaanite, with the rest being a mix of Egyptian, Iraqi, Turkish, and about 5% Arab DNA. These tests, conducted by private agencies like 23andMe, confirm that most Palestinians are not Arabs.
Before 1920, the term "Arabs" referred to people living in the Arabian Peninsula. Outside this area, regions like Lebanon or Palestine were not considered Arab lands or their people Arab. An Arab country was one under Arab leadership, geographically situated in the Arabian Peninsula. An Arab is anyone with a deep connection to the Arabian Peninsula, tracing their heritage and culture back to this region. Therefore, the cultures of Yemen, Oman, and Saudi Arabia are similar, but outside the Arabian Peninsula, distinctions become apparent.
The Islamic and Arabic influence over the centuries caused the local languages and identities to evolve. Some people believe they are descendants of Arabs, even though they aren't. Using the Arab League's standard for identifying Arab countries includes places like Somalia, although Somalians are not Arabs.
For Palestinians to achieve autonomy and regain control over their land, they must emphasize their unique identity. Assuming an Arab identity and relying on Arab countries for support may not be effective. Out of 22 Arab countries, only 7 (Saudi Arabia, Oman, Qatar, Kuwait, Bahrain, United Arab Emirates, and Yemen) might intervene, and these are predominantly Arab countries except for Jordan. The Jordanian monarchy acquired land through occupation during the British mandate of Palestine in 1920. Abdullah ibn Hussein requested an audience with the British Prime Minister, resulting in the division of Palestine, with Eastern Palestine given to the Arabs (Transjordan) and Western Palestine to the Zionist Jews, forming the state of Israel.
Many Palestinians do not see eye to eye with Jordanians, despite the latter granting them citizenship. The division of their land involved no native Palestinians, leading to the formation of local militias fighting the occupation on both sides. The Jordanians crushed these revolutions, while the Israelis, with Western support, managed to persist. Significant revolutions, like Black September orchestrated by Yasser Arafat, leader of the Palestinian Liberation Organization, highlight the continued struggle.
TELL ME THIS LADY DOESNT SOUND EXACTLY LIKE SLAVO ZIZEK
She is beyond the pale. "Refugees" in Jordan, Syria, Lebanon for 70+ years without citizenship, free movement, economic development.
You really do not need to be an Oxford graduate to understand the basic facts, unless you like telling your self little lies.
Did you know since 1947 there were 856,000 Jewish refugees from Arabic Muslim countries and compared to 711,000 Palestinian refugees.
Did you ever hear about those refugees ?
You know why you did not, because those poor jewish refugees settled quitely in all parts of the world and continue with life. Jerry Sinfeled , Enrico Massias, Bernard Henry Levi are all Children of refugees of Arabic countries
But no one talks about it. They rather make Israel to be guilty
Shame on those who use Palestinians as a propaganda tool
@@ramleri1 we all know that and we are against it because everyone have the right to live free in the countries they were born and lived in for centuries. But let’s be clear too Jews throughout history lived in arab countries for centuries in peace ( Mohamed the 5th king of Morocco refused to give marrocan Jews to hitler at the expense of his own life, does your history talk about that?)but with the establishment of Israel at the expense of the indigenous people Arab leaders kicked the Jews in their countries out. True it was unfair but let’s not forget the atrocities committed by Israel to the Palestinians who have nothing to do with the arab leaders
Just finished reading her extraordinary memoir.. a must read.
the first minute was the most entertaining one
Problem has no chance be solved by blaming forces involved in.
Solution is from estimation of the cultural, scientific and technological achievements of the nations Egypt, Libya, Syria, Iraq, Somalia, Ethiopia and Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan compare states of Western civilisation and Israel as part of it.
Arab world did failed Palestine people 😢.
She’s not anti-Semitic at all. Israel retracted from Gaza, even dug up graves to move to Israel, left greenhouses, farmland for Palestinians. There are 2 million Palestinians who live and work in Israel. 1.5 million come across to work and earn money each day.
The fact that the Arab Islamist Army invaded the Holy Lands doesn't get a mention as if it didn't happen, but it did & no amount of time since then gives Arabs the right to call themselves indigenous to the Lands that clearly belong to the Israelites.
Ohhh stop blaming hamas for everything. The fact that it didn’t exist until yeeeaaasrs later after Israël was established is evidence enough to proof that if Israel was fair to the indigenous people, hamas wouldn’t even exist. Can you please stop using this old rusty argument and talk facts on the ground. The world is waking up to the horrors of Israel. And please don’t use the other argument that Israel is treating the Palestinians better than other arab states with the minorities. Because we all know that the arab world is unstable and ruled by military dictators. We’re talking about the Palestinians rights to live free in their homes and lands
They betrayed them
very powerful speech. what a great mind
@Blue Star nah she's telling the truth
Kal Omar
She is spouting lies and revisionist history. If you cannot tell that, then you know nothing of the history of Judea and Jerusalem.
her argument makes sense if you forget that the expulsion of the palestinians came after a bloody war for survival on the part of Isreal, led by arab nations that wanted to diviide it up amongst themselves. That in mind, thher argument completely falls down
Lol and your argument makes sense if you forget the previous 30 years of incredible terrorism of the haganah levi yishuv etc.. way BEFORE 1948
What about England , USA and the rest of the world the UN ???? I don’t blame Israel I blame the one who recognize Israel ,,,,, just a point from a saudi man 🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦🇸🇦 and Israel won’t be for too long .
❤🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
of course it has.. it's the only reason they're there. either accept a border and sign a peace treaty or relocate them to another arab country. stop bothering israel and stop annoying the rest of the world.
Fantastic argument from Dr. Karmi, also damn the boy in the beige fleece is a babe
no arguments...it was begging. she is also a liar....she lived a few months in an arab country ( likely syria ) she is half syrian. she came straight to britain....so who gave her opportunities? Dont be a dumb arab if genetically possible
Your inappropriate language gives you out.
Wow, her argument is on another level.
Hypocrisy
really smart example showing how hospitable and humanitarian Syria is... from the moment she said that everything sounded like "lies lies and more lies".
It's only a lie to racist westerners bc they like paint Arabs as "barbaric" even the europeans are the ones that stole Palestinian land, Americans invaded Iraq and Afghanistan, stole their oil, murdered 100,000 civilians and bombed their country. Narcissists love making their victims to look the like the bad guy.
i love how she elegantly left out the fact that Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon invaded Israel in 48. she portrait them as passive, reactionists to the situation while in truth they were the catalyst.
You meant Palestine. Israel is the name the european settlers use for Palestine. It was the Arab world trying to defend themselves from european invaders. That's like when the Americans called the Native people "savages" when they tried to genocide them. Colonizers gaslight and say their victims are the aggressors while Colonizers are literally trying to kill them.
@@poisonivy745 no.
Invaded?!!!! They tried to free Palestine of the East European Zionist invasion you mean. How twisted you people are!!
Israel's map back in 1948 included Jordan, parts of Syria, Lebanon, and Egypt. The zionist greed and aspirations were also a direct threat to all the surrounding nations to Palestine. Still is.
@@JupiterMoon777 where did you learn this bullshit? harry potter?
AbdelwAhab
Laughter is truly the best medicine. After a tough week, I watched my favorite UA-cam comedy clips - Jackie Mason, Rodney Dangerfield, Lewis Black, Louis Anderson, Dr. Karmi, Joan Rivers, and Benny Hill. Totally relaxed now.
Yep a history lesson is a joke to you.
OK here's a fun fact for you.
Did you know leprosy was not a part of the curses?
Old liar. What a shame. So much lie
“Before the Balfour Promise, when the Ottoman rule [1517-1917] ended, Palestine’s political borders as we know them today did not exist, and there was nothing called a Palestinian people with a political identity as we know today”, historian Abd Al-Ghani stated.
There was a Palestinian congress held in 1911 to complain about the infux of European Zionist settlers into Mandatory Palestine. I presume it was attended by Ghosts.
Pathological liar. The word Palestine is from the 5th century.
Palestinians were fishermen from Crete living in the city of Gaza. Egypt was Coptic at that time. The indigenous people of the land of Israel are the Jews. For many centuries the Jews suffered and got expelled many, many times. Just a small community managed to live in Jerusalem. The WWII influenced the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948. Palestine a name given for land by the British. Even the borders were not correct. Palestine was Israel. At that time there were not even mosques. The mosque that is built is on the Holy Soil of the Jewish Temple. It was a British mandate. Iraq as well. Syria and Lebanon were a French mandate (1928). In 1928 the Ottoman Empire collapsed caused the mandates. However, Eretz Israel exists for over more than 4.000 years. The Arabs don't care for the Arabs living in Gaza. Once, land for peace. The Arabs who call themselves Palestinians got land which is previously Egypt, but forgot about the peace. The West do care about these Arabs because they are an easily bargain to the Middle East and for their own politics at home as well. That will change when ALL cars have a battery pack instead of gas tank. The Arab leaders got and get billions of Dollars. What happens to all that money. From the Qatari tranche, the Arabs received a one time payment form their leaders. $ 600,- for a married couple and $ 200,- for those who are single. Investments? Where? The leaders enrich themselves with million dollars mansions, private jets. Not only Qatar sends money. Iran as well. Iran facilitates Hamas. Iran facilitates Hezbollah which means that both are proxy-armies of Iran.
Playing the victim card and the behave of an entrepreneur is in fact the humiliation of a people. And actually two. Eretz Israel is the biblical, ancient and the eternal land of the Jews.
She is talking nonsense
You are wrong. Very wrong.
Silly old women
The worst speaker of the series and speaking out of hate. No facts at all.
Why no facts at all? if you ask any Syrian they would tell you the same facts she said; that Palestinians living in Syria where given even more rights than Syrians themselves. From citizenship to economic prosperity
The fault lies with whomever forgot to lock the door to this woman's rubber room.
Really that all you got ignorance
Hypocrite. The issue here is the Arab brothers of Palestinians not helping them.
Amazing
full of historical lies and contradictions open history books and lear
there were 856,000 Jewish refugees from Arabic countries. They never
complained. they settled quitely and never demanded their right
Why cant the palestinian refugee settle like the 856,000 Jewish refugees ?
they fled to US, they fled to France, to Canada, to Israel etc.
Leren History before praise liar who have the courage to distort facts
@@ramleri1 if "the jews settled quietly" in other areas" why cant the palistinians. it seems they have no where to go? can they leave gaza and go elsewhere? i am interested in learning more, rebecca
Dr Ghada Karmi really need to read some history, her speak was a big propaganda act, but did not reflect historical facts. In short, she tells from the beginning a false historic narrativ.
Peter, you are full of shit. Luckily, you are not on the receiving end of an israeli rifle butt, like so many Palestinian kids.
well said Dr Karmi!
This woman is distorting history. Open history books, and find out there were
much more jewish refugees from Arabic countries than Palestinian