Sangita Myska debates caller claiming 'muslims live peacefully in Israel' | LBC
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 січ 2024
- 'Your characterisation of life as a Muslim in Israel is optimistic.'
Sangita Myska debates with caller Samantha, who claims that Muslims can 'live freely and happily' in Israel. Samantha made some strong accusations - Sangita had some experiences to hand...
Listen to the full show on Global Player: l-bc.co/ListenNow
#SangitaMyska #IsraelPalestine #Gaza #Jerusalem #TelAviv #Palestine #Debate #LBC
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
As a Palestinian Arab living in Israel, I can assure you that we do not have the same rights as Jews there is literally the Nation State Law, and "going shopping in Tel Aviv" isn't exactly a measure of equality, peacefulness and harmony...
I am also a palestian arab with the israeli citizenship, and i also 100% feel we dont have the same rights. Especially now with this war, we were being taken over likes on posts sympathizing with gaza and were targeted
@@Iamarandomguyonyoutube exactly, let’s not talk about the censorship and the prosecution of Arab students in Israeli universities
@@aame6643Unlike Israeli students in Arab universities ? Oh wait...
Why would you go to telaviv? its 98%jewish,or go to Jerusalem its 73%jewish.Israel still has rights.Its a democratic legal country
THANK YOU! I am South African and I see Apartheid style behaviours and I hear the manner of talking that tells me absolutely that you are not treated the same. Stay strong. ❤
People tend to hate the people oppressing them, it’s not rocket science.
Then why don't the Palestinians hate Hamas. Smh.
@@gary8306 I’m sure some do.
hurt me = hate you.
yep, the math works ...
Simple fact. But the unfathomable problem is that the oppressor hate the oppressed because they don't accept to be subjucated! They expect them to be grateful because the oppressor is "chosen" to be superior even when they do bad things👍
@@gary8306 why should they hate? The only resistance who are fighting their rights 😂
Scary thing about Samantha is that she's so convinced by her lies
What's scarier is that people actually think only one side is lying.
There’s a word for that: self-delusion.
Over 20% of Israeli citizens are Arab. How many Jews are left in Arab countries? Get a sense of perspective.
@@aleph8888Should be alot more than 20%.
Kasim.
Samantha is saying the truth.
Sangista is lying!!
Israel has never supported a two state solution and the one state solution they support does not include Palestinians.
Je pense que c’est le contraire.
@@mireillelanglois6947 Nah, if you think the opposite, you aren't thinking at this point, Frenchy.
Israel offered a two state solution in 2000, the Palestinians walked out without a counter offer.
@@mireillelanglois6947 ARE YOU STILL LIVING IN YOUR BUBBLE???
@@dech8220i think you’re in the bubble. have you tried to read the news that don’t come from SM?
The only Arab friends Samantha has are in her head.
"I don't have a problem with ignorance. We are all ignorant about a variety of subjects we are not currently aware of. The real problem is when that ignorance is wilful, intentional and used as a weapon against anyone who disagrees with you, or anyone who has the nerve to present facts you don't want to accept."
- anyone who actually cares about verifiable reality
Well put. Thank you.
😂
There are demonstrations in Tel Aviv with palestinian flags for years, what are you talking about ?
@@3cosmohow many Palestinians are dead as a consequence???
"The Palestinians have the right to hate the ones that destroyed their lives"
- Prof Norman Finkelstein
If Norman Finkelstein have had said '... destroyed their great grandparents lives' he'd be 20% correct
well the blockade, which is a seige because they can turn the tap off and are willingly not turning it on like david cameron said, means they are forced on diet starved, unable to get life saving equipment, why wouldnt they have a reason to hate the isrealis
@@fernandez6143
@@fernandez6143 so you think nothing happened in the past 75 years??
@@ehabl8816 Lots of things happened, including all surrounding arab nations trying to annihilate Israel and the jews. But things got even worse for both sides when terrorism became tougher. Till the 80's there were freedom of movement for palestinians. The fear and reaction to terrorist attacks became the main cause of this dire situation
Gaza is an occupied land. Food, water, electricity restrictions for decades before October 7th. No right of return, not allowed to have an airport, not allowed to navigate the sea... Current Gazan lives are destroyed. Current. @@fernandez6143
im spanish, been to Israel and was treated badly because they thought I was Arab
So sorry for what happened..idk why they seems aggressive towards “Arab look”
Sangita is the kind of journalist that can put her head on her pillow with a healthy satisfied conscience. She is using her voice for the voiceless, and refusing to support the spread of misinformation. Complete respect for Sangita a true journalist.
👍🏾👍🏾
She been quiet since the Israeli spokesperson interview. Has she been silenced?
yes
This caller is living in her own bubble milions of miles from the reality.
So is Sangita. So is you.
...As long as we retain kindness and conscience
The Divine will not forsake us
Searching
I’ve traveled throughout the world
My restless heart is still searching-
Where is the origin of life?
Why do people seem to be acting in a play?
I want to find the true meaning of life
Human beings are by no means
made for fame and fortune
As long as we retain kindness and conscience
The Divine will not forsake us
2010
***
I Sing for You
Friend, I whole-heartedly sing for you
Fifty years of lies can build a Red Wall
The bandit can eclipse the radiance of five
millennia of civilization
But Truth, Compassion, Forbearance
can never be touched by it
Don’t believe so easily the one-voice propaganda
of the Party’s mouthpiece
Right or wrong must be measured
with your compassion
Once you learn the truth
That will be your hope of salvation
Friend, what I sing is the truth
The Divine is evaluating each and every person
In history, sinking into depravity
has been all the same
What is destroyed is the corrupted dynasty
What is restored are the civil and kind
Step out of the confusion brought by the lies
Don’t be buried with the Red Bandit
The truth is compassionate salvation
Learning the truth is the hope of salvation
2007
***
...At the moment of danger and calamity,
everyone is making a choice-
To be eliminated or to return to kindness
"The Truth Is Spreading
Please treasure this predestined bond
In the truth lies your age-old hope
At the moment of danger and calamity,
everyone is making a choice-
To be eliminated or to return to kindness
Perhaps we really share a karmic tie
Compassion won’t let me leave you in danger
Long years can bury one’s memory with dust
People forget who they are,
Where their true home is,
And when they came to the human world
Learning the truth can dispel the haze and fog
What lives awaited and worried over
has all arrived
The divine ones’ vows are being fulfilled
2008"
Master Li Hongzhi (Hong Yin III, from Falun Dafa teachings)
Unfortunately, Pro Zionism is a bubble millions of miles from reality.
Meanwhile bombs are being dropped on little ones in Gaza.
Ignorance cannot even be an excuse when the entire world has seen and reported on what is happening in that region to innocent civilians en masse.
Notice how it’s always “me myself and I” with Zionists. Not a word of condemnation for what the apartheid state are doing and how many lives they have killed
Its just lack of compassion and regard for all humans as equal. Genocidal cheerleaders have always existed
The caller is CLEARLY speaking from a position of privilege and being part of the dominant society. This story is all to familiar and sadly will not change because of the one sided control of the narrative.
I think the narrative has escaped some of the Israeli control and the truth is becoming ever more clear.
I think many come from this point although I would agree they don't want a 2 state because it means giving up on this idea of a greater Israel dominated/total control by those who are Jewish but cannot have a one state where both are equal simply because of the numbers would mean no dominance anymore. Instead they opted for creating conditions where neither can happen but they can still exert control. I wonder if they swapped places for a year whether they would still be talking such nonsense. You can find endless videos of police smashing people up simply for praying. Men, women even children are all fair game and so many not only show no compassion but sheer cruelty & even enjoyment out of attacking/abusing them.
Oh lady , israeli Jews & Gazans doesn't have the same privilege. Gazans get checked of their movements , wat comes in by sea, by air & by land transportation .
@@supernova7848well perhaps the gazans may well be part of the Hamas organisation
@@richardlewis7498 Perhaps they are innocent civilians and perhaps you are at best a troll.
I have recently been to Jerusalem in the summer 2023. I am a Muslim, and I am not Palestinian, and the minute I landed in Tel Aviv, I noticed the discrimination I had to face, I went with my teenage girl, and they gave my visa after so much integration and they kept my daughter waiting for 6 hours. She was really traumatised 😢 I missed my taxi. I had to pay extra for the taxi. Even a taxi man was terrified. He told us not to speak Arabic, even though I can't speak any Arabic. I'm not from an Arab country. Coming back at Tela Aviv Airport was a very bad experience. We were told to stand somewhere someone would do security checks. Then, one of the guys kicked my luggage to move quickly. It was a bad experience, I wasn't aware, it would be like that. We were treated like animals. Now I see what Palestinian are facing.
Very true my brother my nephew from South Africa went to work on a kibbutz in the Negev He is a Catholic Christian but his first name is Anver.Boy did they interrogate him they kept him at the airport until the supervisor of the kibbutz came. That nephew came back not liking the Israelis and then he saw how the Palestinians were discriminated very similar to our people under apartheid
Well done sangita for nailing the truth down and not letting the lies flow.
Actually, Sangita did not nail the truth down, she only whacked a nail through the heart of the truth.
Racism thinly veiled as rose tinted glasses. Well done Sangita for the clever rebuttal.
Shows these Jews in Europe did not accept Germans and the rest of European also, just this was only the Nazis who started a war with the Jews,
Sagita is wrong with all mher facts. The Nova festival, that suffered hundreds of deads was a festival al for peace. Children in Israel learn peace songs since they are born. Search for anything like that within the Palestinian. If you do not know the facts Sagita, don't agree to disagree - learn them!!!
Yeah well done for quoting unnamed and probably non existent she apparently spoke too.
@RosenbergSharon yeah right 😂😂😂 and I am the king of illegal occupied land call Israel 😂😂😂😂 From the river to the sea, Palestine 🇵🇸 will be free INSH'ALLAH
@@freepalestine7630 It will indeed.... under Israeli rule.
Why can't we hear from people who are honest, and acknowledge the apartheid conditions that the Palestinians are subjected to?
Why can't we hear from people who are honest that apartheid conditions don't exist in Israel?
I know, this woman hasn't a clue.
There is NO Apartheid in israel!!!
@oldskoolrools1353 because that sentence doesn't make sense. It would be a dishonest statement, and you know that. We will never achieve anything when there is such a blatant disregard for reality.
It offends them to think that they're not paragons of humanity. That's why.
What an impressive host. Made very clear how much she didn't accept the caller's narrative, without it turning into a pointless argument. Bravo.
She completely and blatantly lied without shame, which most Israeli’s do …
What did she lie about?
@@Billyb0b557 every thing .
@@ahmedzia4361 so nothing seeing as you can't answer
A great example of when an illiterate person argues with a literate person
Sangita counter argument is just as bad as Samantha's argument.
Sangita is clueless I'm afraid.
Yes the caller being the literate.
@@Stan-mv1tyYou mean the caller being the literal liar
the hosts face is full of hate@@kriissyy09ify
People like this caller call for war but would beg for peace if it was at their doorstep.
She didn't call for war though?
Nor a ceasfire
Exactly
They don't care about their neighbours
@@kriissyy09ify she explicitly said hamas should dissolve. That is a call for war in its most innocent appearance
I've been there too, Samantha. If you didn't see the difference in treatment it's because you chose not to see it. The Palestinian who needs to show papers 3 times to move 2 blocks is not going to be allowed entry into Israel let alone allowed to move around freely. Samantha is not being optimistic. She is lying for a purpose.
What? You mean like land borders that every country have? Israel let 2 millions Palestinians to come and work (they don't have to) because of their history they have to have security to check who they're letting in. In what world would you let the animals who did October 7th to move around freely in your country
🤣 land borders you say
@@Billyb0b557 Israels have never stated where there borders are. Palestinians have to get where they can to support their families ;ike all breadwinners. As for animals and massacres, I respectfully ask you to refer to: 'The 1982 Sabra and Shatila Massacre' for which Ariel Charon was held responsible. Oct 7 pales in comparison.
These type of callers need to be confronted harshly
The caller saying she has Muslim friends that live in israel is the equivalent of white americans saying they have blk friends when the want to be passive aggressive about racial issues.
Quite literally, such an ignorant statement
I noticed Sangita's eyes widen rapidly when she heard that from the girl
😮
@@-xirx- because she knew it was a lie.
I bet her Palestinian "friends" are employees of her Israeli family to whom she's cynically attributing zionist talking points
"I have friends in Israel that tell me..." that's the key detail. caller insists she knows about life in Israel based on 2nd hand accounts vs someone who actually been there and seen it for herself.
Oh really! Now I am supposed to rely on one person who has been to Israel...I have the feeling that even if the caller lived in Israel, the interviewer would find an excuse to dismiss her because it wouldn't fit her picture of approx. 8 million bad vicious Israeli Jews.If pro Palestinian means to totally discredit the Israeli Jewish side, it becomes problematic.
😂😂she said she s been there 5 times, I very been there and every time there was an attack in Jerusalem by some Muslim person against jews, every time! Not the opposite. I m not saying individual attacks might not exist, but intifada type terror attacks are routine in Jerusalem killing or injuring a plurality, not one on one fight. But ppl in the West don't know this stuff. Now you may say it s because they re oppressed etc, but then why not organize a protest peacefully, do petitions, appeal to organizations etc there are many means rather than terrorizing fellow inhabitants.
@Mpc5061 lies. Your actually saying the media is pro hamas? Get real. Ps bibi propped up hamas go read and come back
@@Mpc5061 People in the west know way more than you think. Tell us how many Jews have been killed by Hamas attacks and then compare it to how many Palestinians have been killed by Israel sounds like you need the education....
@@Mpc5061 they have protested many times, they get shot, anyone organizing a petition gets arrested and interrogated.
I heard this live today, Sangita many thanks for calling out her BS. Over the years on radio and the mainstream media there's been many times voices like "Samantha's" have gone totally unchallenged and therefore allowed the "its complicated" excuse to fester, which has allowed Palestine to basically shrink faster than a melting iceberg on a beach. Once again, many thanks Sangita.
Wow! This caller is fooling no one. She is a liar..
That caller is just a liar. I went there and it is an apartheid state in very sense of the word. This is why I will never go back again and boycotted Israel for many years (including Israelis products like many start doing).
The audacity to call with such an arrogant attitude and making lies is just upsetting. I wish we had someone from Israel sharing a honest balance view.
That caller just embarrassed herself miserably.
🎯
More apartheid than Afghanistan? or Jordan or where? Name me 1, only 1 arab state that has any iota of jews living in peace?
What evidence of apartheid within Israel did you see?
@@mcbudget if really you are interested and not adopting a certain rhetoric, Amnesty International published a report written by Agnes Callamard which explains why Israel should be considered an Apartheid State.
It seems to miss something called EQUALITY. There’s literally videos of Palestinians not being allowed to walk on the same streets as Israelis.
If she walked into Gaza rn, her life would be in way more danger from the IDF than the Gazans.
Ain’t that the truth 😂
I literally thought that's what Sangita was gonna say. She's a better person than me because I would have said it.
If anyone strolled into Gaza pre Oct 7, their life would be over. Likewise for any Israeli entering any Area A towns/cities in the W Bank. There are even signs outside these Area A towns saying entrance to Israelis at risk of death. So who exactly is the victim of apartheid here?
Didn't you hear about the German tourist who drove into Ramalla with an Israeli hire car (Israeli number plates) he was lucky to get out alive. Was nearly lynched.
@@sharonmiller7803 Rachel Corrie was ran over by an Israeli bulldozer in Rafah & the Israeli government said that it was fine.
Samantha does not have any Muslim ‘friends’ living in Israel.
Oh and how do u know that ?
There's hundreds on UA-cam though saying how great their lives are in Israel but no doubt you'll say they're paid plants
@@Billyb0b557the truth hurts them so they deny it
@@RenyH716 doesn't help when we have presenters on main stream media pushing their narrative like Sangita
@@Billyb0b557 - she's an impeccable journalist and, frankly, very respectful to that dimwitted caller...also - this isn't a mainstream media outlet - what're you talking about?
Caller "I want them to have the freedom to love Israelis unconditionally, as they should!"
Every accusation is a confession!
Yes!...and 1000x worse
Saying someone hates you sure comes across like an excuse to have hate in your own heart for them.
❤
lol
@@T.E.S.S. stop the nonsense. Let's start to work to fix this.
Free Palestine ✌️
Ironic
it's the only excuse they ever have for it.
Well done for debunking the callers claims. Once again their lies being exposed and dismantled
There was a time when presenters would allow them to say anything they wanted, and even agree with it, but fortunately the days of walking on eggshells around them have gone, they've been exposed and seen for what they really are
What was Samamtha lying about?
Arab Israelis shopping in Tel Aviv? That's not a lie
"Every accusation is a confession". Remember that anytime a Zio tells you anything about Palestine or Palestinians
You're right
In the 3 times I've been to Israel in the past, I've seen discrimination both overt and covert. It's most evident when you need to cross borders or checkpoints of any kind. It's presumptuous to claim that just because people aren't overtly oppressed, that they don't experience discrimination or racism of some form.
Is there discrimination in the UK?
No checkpoints. No restrictions of movement based on ethnicity. No one has to walk an hour to buy a loaf of bread which would've ordinarily taken 5mins like in Hebron. No 10hr wait and be humiliated at Airport immigration here based on skin colour. No Christians are being spat on here. None of our MP's call another ethnicity "animals". No one puts anyone in houses based on ethnicity here or steal property like fat Yakob from NY does, etc etc.
@Steve_Baker_Jones the checkpoints are there for a reason... remember the bus bombers
@@amontalasLoL what are you on about, checkpoints have existed since long before the first intifada, sure they ramped it up in the 2000's , but that's not when they came into existence.
Yep, the checkpoints are the big ones I've experienced too. When the IDF comes into the bus and how they treat Palestinians compared to Western passengers
Natanyahu never accept two state solution. He knows the moment he accepts it, his political carrier will be over.
It’s already over
Ohh and Hamas accepted a two state solution ? 😂 aww
@@RenyH716
We all how the Oslo accord was ruined
His career is over the minute this ends.
That is why the entire world recognises that he is highly motivated to continue.
He's said it's a 1.5 state solution for years before this conflict so I'm surprised people are surprised
Wouldn't it be interesting for Samatnha to bring her Muslim friends who live in Israel...the ones she says have all equal rights as Israeli's...onto a show where they can all be interviewed together?
Watch the ASK PROJECT for some answers.
They would be arrested if they spoke honestly about their experiences under Israel's apartheid laws. If they do, they would have to remain anonymous. I'm not even joking about this.
I have been to Israel. Israeli Arab towns (not West Bank or Gaza) do not get the same funding as the rest of Israel. There is an element of discrimination even there.
I understand they don't have hospitals, cinemas or even their own schools. They have to travel miles.
@@The_Voice_of_Reason748they have their own schools . Dont lie
From someone who saw the inception of Hamas more than 2 decades ago, I feel the general public is not aware of : Who allowed them to emerge ? Who funded them ? Who used them as opposition force to PA back 2005\6, Who was fully aware of their plans for Day-1? Who saw it coming and waited for them to execute so they can legitimize their future plans in the middle east?
Just few simple question worth mentioning 😅!!
Please provide solid evidence for this simple question. Foolish people always do not accept baseless hearsay as truth.
@user-uv9tl4jt8w Just Google it. It is common knowledge how the elections in 2006 came about and how Hamas didn't even want to participate. And then were pushed to do so. And how they surprisingly won. And then how this triggered economic sanctions and a blockade the day after.
President Jimmy Carter oversaw the elections and said they were done correctly and fair.
What was not fair is that some powers didn't like the outcome and felt the need to immediately pose sanctions on Gaza, never giving them a chance to thrive with their newly formed goverment
Spot on. I believe exactly as you. All part of the Great Zionist Plan for a Greater Israel without Palestinians. Question: Since inception, has Israel ever defined and officially
stated where its borders are?
@@user-uv9tl4jt8w It doesn't take much effort to find information backing most of this up its even mostly in the wikipedia page on Gaza politics if you take the time to read it. None of whats lead us here is exactly hidden from public view its just most people refused to see what was happening and what was the likely outcome of the situation. When a people are oppressed for a long time its not uncommon for that people to fall under the rule of the extreme view 'strong men' types in order to 'fight back'. Back any living creature in to a corner and as soon as it feels its best or option option is to fight it will do exactly that. Hamas as horrible as they are aren't the cause of this they are the effect the reaction a symptom of the wider problem, You can stitch up a bullet wound but it won't help if your still being shot in much the same way as you can destroy Hamas but if your still occupying and oppressing a people they will still try to stop you
A Jew living in England in a free society. But thinks apartheid is ok and the oppressors are the victims.
Apartheid???!!. Smh bro.
@@gary8306apartheid state of Israel . As amnesty intl and other human rights groups have said
apartheid was an english invention, after all
@@gary8306Ahhh Gary. The brainless snail from SpongeBob Square pants 😂
Sangita, a lioness speaking the truth.
It didn’t take long for the callers true colours to show. Well done Sangita
“I have no mercy or compassion in me for a society that will crush people, and then penalize them for not being able to stand up under the weight.”
-Malcolm X-
❤️🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Thank you Sangita for calling out the lies of this clearly misguided woman caller.
The lies are coming from sangita
What lies?
All the caller said was the truth
@@alexp8372 Per the UN, per human rights watch, per Bet’Selem, and many other human rights organizations, Israel is an apartheid state. Read Ilan Pappe, listen to Israeli journalist Gideon Levi.
@@eshanieoffice2802 per human rights watch, betselem and other human rights orgs, Israel is an Apartheid state. The caller lives in an alternate reality.
Did Muslim / Jews / Christian live peacefully side by side ?
Answer= yes in a place called Palestine between 1299 - 1922 (600+ years)
Hahahshshahaha!
False !
Back in 1985 went on holiday to Isreal and witnessed a Palistian woman being threatened by the IDF for no reason . This was before Hamas existed. Hundreds of abuses have never been reported in the west. This fact . Isreali Jews can not deny this . Well I expect they can.
Well spoken Sangita you are one of the few that doesnt let the lies go unchallenged
And hamas and the palestinians never lie??? In your dreams,they are consummate liars
The caller has no sense of reality.
The caller has no sense of YOUR reality... what isn´t the same at all
@@olmaBLN No, the caller has no sense of objective reality. Some of the things she said are a matter of opinion, but others are demonstrably false.
@@jfm14 No, the caller has a sense of reality, not matching your reality, knowledge about the facts.
The idea of "peace" is one group completely dominating the other.
The caller's "solution" is the current reality, with Israel in total control, and Palestinians living in concentration camps, with no freedom of movement, in constant fear for their lives.
Your a credit to humanity. We are proud of you Sangita.
Unfortunately discrimination is a big problem in Israel and elsewhere.
In group preference is completely normal around the World.
@@evolassunglasses4673 discrimination is not the same as in group preference. pretty troubling that you would equate the two.
@@19rudy73it's 'group preference' when it favours you and 'discrimination' when it doesn't, right? 👍🏻😅
@@apemoon1731don't mind that person, nobody is perfect so we are all guilty.
Have you ever discriminated against someone?
Anyone heard the Israeli children’s choir sing about bombing Gaza?
This caller 100% hasn’t talked to an Arab Israeli let alone a Palestinian.
I guess you did, and so… please don’t hesitate to share your knowledge.
I want to know why the Israelis think they have the right to decide FOR Palestine what kind of government or who governs them?
Because now they have a terror government and Israel can’t allow that October 7th will happen again
Agreed they should just send them to Jordan and Egypt instead since this is what the Palestinians would do if the power roles were reversed.
@@virtunus7950 They can't "send" them anywhere, the Palestinians are already home
Whereas the "Israelis" can all go back to Brooklyn and Poland
Don't blame them !! Get off our land lol
arrogance, left unchallenged, becomes hubris ...
Liar,liar pants on fire
Palestinians have been killed with complete impunity for decades, and the abuse of administrative detentions means that thousands (including children) are held hostage in Israeli prisons. The caller’s sense of victimhood is wildly misplaced.
The caller is liar. Jewish can.come to palestine freely but palestinians are not allowed to go freely to israel..
The solution is give Palestinians equal freedom and full rights in ALL THE LAND by removing the current system of apartheid and Jewish supremacy.
There is absolutely no possibility that they would allow one street under jewish rule.
You either don't understand the politics in the area or a massive anti-semite. Which one?
@sa palestinians living in israel would vote to dissolve the state of Israel if they were given equal voting rights as the jews.
@@kriissyy09ifythe old anti semite card, won't be played much longer
@@kriissyy09ifythe more you pull that card the less value it holds.
1 state with equal rights for all. If you disagree with that then you support discrimination on the basis of race and religion.
🎯
What's wrong with 2 states with equal rights for all
@@sergioaguero7113 the main problem is that what's left of Palestine is so thoroughly settled that there's not really much left to build a separate state out of, unless you forcibly remove millions of Israeli settlers. It was still possible in the 90s, but it's really unclear if it's even possible now, since Israel has turned the West Bank into "Judea and Samaria" in order to make a separate and functioning Palestinian state essentially unfeasible. It seems they have been largely successful in this goal
@@Muzikman127 Unless I'm mistaken, the settler numbers are 800,000. Since they are illegal to every single country the World over, they should be asked/forced to either return to Israel proper or become Palestinian (with no dual citizenship of both countries allowed). Israel was allowed to forcefully remove 750,000 Palestinians in 1948, so the forceful removal of 800,000 should be relatively easy in 2024.
@@sergioaguero7113 I posted a second comment clarifying the number and going into much more detail as a follow-up, but judging by its zero upvotes vs the other one's 6, it is hidden/shadow deleted. Very irritating
You are right, by the way, and my first sentence was "sorry, not millions, around 800,000". Let me know if you can see that comment, I think it's been caught by the c 3 n s 0 r
On mobile right now, but I'll see if I can edit and get it to post later when I'm at a computer if it's not there
Every accusation is a confession.
Samantha , don't be silly . The Arab-israeli is treated as a second class citizen.
Wow 😮 her friends paint a beautiful and harmonious picture, shopping and coffee together?!?!?
never happens.
I lived in Israel and it does happen all the time.
Arab israelis are living the best life possible in the Middle east. They even have their own party in the israeli parliment
@@RenyH716 are you an Arab Israeli??
Well said Sangita!!
Which bit?
What a pathetic apologists for Israel. Absolutely no clue what so ever about the true history.
Sangita is absolutely amazing. Well done, this is journalism at its best and what we have lost in the western bias news outlets
Dude, she's bias towards the terrorists and we know why.
*biased
No Hamas in the west Bank so isrealis end occupation in west Bank???😢
You're wrong. Hamas is in the west bank strongly. That's the reason why Palestinian Authority don't allow elections
@@fernandez6143source: I MADE IT UP
@@automaticcaptions Muhammad Abbas has spoken about this in different ocasions
@@fernandez6143 who?
Wdym who?
Samantha is a liar.
Samantha is lier with capital L!!!
I don't think she's a liar, I think she's very naive. If she has Muslim friends who won't complain to her about their treatment in Israel, that tells me that they think she won't believe them so they choose to keep quiet.
Considering her reaction, that seems to be the case.
@@blackkn1ght the Muslim friends are figments of her imagination.
💯
I don't think so. Just severely brainwashed.
Sangita i have spent more than 9 months in Israel and you are 100% right.
A one state solution is the only answer - the callers argument is fundamentally flawed - Israel simply granted equal privileges to window dress 1/3 indigenous Palestinians to reflect a democratic utopian state. Give the other 2/3 the same and guaranteed the conflict will disappear - take South Africa as an example. It will mean Israel will need to abandon its apartheid ideology. The problem does not lie with the Palestinian's it is with Jewish nationalism.
Wow Sangita 🙌🏿🙌🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿... Slam dunk.... They never admit to apartheid that exists in Isreal... I'm South African by the way😂
There isn't apartheid. Every country in the world has apartheid then because of racism? Tell me the apartheid that is going on?
@@Billyb0b557 any Jew in world can become an Israel citizen overnight, have right to own land, yet an Arab Isrealite cannot naturalise another Arab (from the Westbank even) to become a citizen through marriage, even their children will not appear on the population register in Isreal once they become an adults ... This is one of the different laws based ethnicity.
Isreal is a classic colonial project, a one state solution would mean giving the same rights to Palestinians is West Bank and Gaza since isreal is an occupying power (u wanna argue that too?) , if that happens Pakestinians will become a majority giving an end to a Jewish state, a two state would mean a soveign Palestine according to 1967 UN recognised borders which means a right to self govern and self defense, right to have army.
The alternative is oppression
Israelis never question their government for letting this to happen.
They are doing, a group of Israelis (parents and survivors of 7-10) are taking senior IDF to civil court for blatant failures on their part but sadly they will be shut up after time.
Some Israelis do not support their government. Unfortunately too few though. I wonder how many Israelis are aware of the atrocities the IDF is committing in their name, in Gaza. The mainstream Israeli media isn’t telling them and they may not bother to look at contrary information on the internet. A bit like Russia.
Actually some do protest but the leadership zionists just bat them aside like annoying bugs.
Because they have been indoctrinated into accepting this as the norm since they are on the domanant and privileged side of the apartheid laws and violent occupation.
They're in the middle of the war. The difference is, when there's a war, israelies come together like no other. There will be questions and enquiries after the war but right now, the country is one fighting the war
You can hear her lose focus the second her "have you been to Israel" gotcha did not work. Considering she has never been to Israel
Wow, well done Sangita!
You completely invalidated her argument!
Evidence? The " Friendship Song " 2023 sung by Israeli children on international days . Is that not indoctrination????
Has she heard the ‘Friendship’ song, sang by Israeli kids when this whole ordeal started. You give me a song, Palestinians children ever sang with similar lyrics?
The caller is lying about life in Jerusalem.
That women caller is very late to the gaslighting party.. where has she been and who is she trying to kid ????
Why not discussed who created and funded Hamas back in 1975...Israel with US financing
Hamas was established in 1987. Stop spreading lies.
I would like to ask this caller if there wasn't legalized discrimination and regime of apartheid and brutality you wouldn't have to worry about entities like Hamas
🎯🎯🎯
Nice to see this presenter actually challenging these genocidal Israeli sympathisers
They Are Hypocrites And Always Victims. I Don’t Know How They Can Live That Moral Easily
that woman is such a liar
This caller sounds like the same lady that James dismantled.
I thought that too!
Oct 7th happened because for decades they have been occupied by a brutal depraved military apartheid
Samantha is such a liar. She does not have Muslim friends in Israel that say that they have the same rights as Jews.
it's actually a little frightening how they lie with such ease....
Also the assumption that everyone should believe them just because they say so.
This channel is absolutely genius, i call this channel a challenger.
Sangita was very kind to her it wasn't a rosey picture Samantha presented she was just l ying.
Hamas ratified a new charter in 2017. The original charter became a non-working document in the 1990s when Hamas agreed to the 1967 borders.
Myska, you're too intelligent
In another words know your place as a Muslim in our Jewish state. They all seem to be blind to the fact that to get respect you must give respect.
Free Palestine
They genuinely think that they are a superior race and should be bestowed superior rights based on that.
@@kicunya12what do you mean think. They are. Smh.
LBC radio hosts are the most patronising and smug people on the planet
Someone should tell Samantha Israel literally has laws against miscegenation in order to maintain the ‘racial purity’ and demographic majority of Jews within Israel. That’s pretty weird for a peace loving democracy to do.
Samantha brain washed
Keep forgetting the Palestinian Christians
So have i, friend of mine from the uk went to israel, let everyone through customs aside from him, but because his name had khan in it they detained him for brutal security checks lets say he wont be going back in a hurry, he said he felt persecuted and threatened
I couldn't help but think when she said a number of times how Isrl is viewed from the other side, why do you think that is?
The woman over the phone makes absolutely no sense.
Someone should tell that caller about all the hatred and dehumanization that all of the Ethiopian Jews in Israel deal with on a daily basis. Or even some of the trouble that Christians deal with. Rose colored glasses indeed.
She sounds very English...she's loyal to a foreign country because they share the same religion. Absolutely nuts belief system.
Samantha is clueless.
lol she lives in London and talkes about Gaza lol she is delusional
She claims she has visited and they all live lovely together
Have you visited Ramle? Lod? They do live together in harmony there. You can hear the Muslim call to prayer, see women in hijabs, hear church bells peal, they are mixed cities