I broke two separators and then later learned that a good whack with the hammer (under pressure) is the secret. Not knowing that yet, I used a pickle fork, which I had to modify by shortening the tines. Worked great.
Hello I’m wondering how many hours these replacements took in total? And do you think it will be possible with the stock struts, being that the struts in stock suspension is longer than coil overs?
I love it! If you work on your cars enough to find yourself using jack stands several times a year, the QJ is well worth the investment. So much easier and safer to work with.
Your rotors were swapped when installed. The fins inside the rotors should be sucking in air, the way you have them installed they do not cool as efficiently.
Nice video, I did mine just last weekend. Use a dead blow since I was replacing the whole arm. Wondering where did you get that ball joint separater... everywhere I look they are 2 and 1/4 max depth and that is not even enough for your tie rods.
Thanks! The big one is the Schwaben 20-80mm ball joint removal tool. Ordered from ECS here: www.ecstuning.com/b-schwaben-parts/ball-joint-removal-tool-20-80mm/008958sch01a~sch/
I have a BAD vibration at just under 1000 rpm and it gets a little bit smoother at higher rpm. I just replaced my giubo and center support bearing but the vibration did not go away. It vibrates even while revving in park. Could it be the thrust arms?
Im sure you can, if you manage to get the right angles in these tight spaces and dont care about potential damage to aluminum parts. The tool is worth every penny. I used a hammer and pickle fork with ball joints on my E30 once, and that was enough to never do it again. You could also rent these tools from your local auto parts store, usually free of charge, if you dont think you will use it more than once.
Control Arm Bolt - BMW 31303450534, Shock Absorber Mounting Bolt - BMW 33521092072, Self-Locking Hex Nut - BMW 31106769443, Control Arm Bolt - BMW 31121092105, Control Arm Locking Collar Nut - BMW 33306760349, Self-Locking Collar - 33326760376, Hex Nut with Flange - BMW 33306760587
Thanks so much with your helpful video.l have been trying to replace the control arms with the help of Autodoc video above.although l have the same type of ball joint seperator,l couldnt use it because it was so quick that l could replace mine.anywhere l ended up thinking that everything was loosened for the purpose of filming.l was desperate until l learnt of a biger wishbone seperater.Thanks and Well done.
![How to change front suspension arm / front control arm on BMW 520i (E39) [TUTORIAL AUTODOC]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Jw_6CNtnet4/mqdefault.jpg)
I broke two separators and then later learned that a good whack with the hammer (under pressure) is the secret. Not knowing that yet, I used a pickle fork, which I had to modify by shortening the tines. Worked great.
thanks for the great video. took notes on the torque values, couldn't find t hem otherwise. your a life saver
Hello I’m wondering how many hours these replacements took in total? And do you think it will be possible with the stock struts, being that the struts in stock suspension is longer than coil overs?
Is it all the same with e39 not M5 just regular e39 1998 model
Great video, thanks!
Спасибо, полезное видео.
Nice video, many thanks. Quick question, what do you think of the quick jack?
I love it! If you work on your cars enough to find yourself using jack stands several times a year, the QJ is well worth the investment. So much easier and safer to work with.
Great video mate. Id got it mostly apart before I found this which is exactly what I needed. Thanks Lee
Glad it helped. Thanks for watching!
My friend, could you tell me please how large is the first joint separator you used? Joint thickness 20mm or 30mm? For normal e39 not M
Your rotors were swapped when installed. The fins inside the rotors should be sucking in air, the way you have them installed they do not cool as efficiently.
Schwaben - Ball Joint Removal Tool 20-80mm
Cool video man 👍
Nice video, I did mine just last weekend. Use a dead blow since I was replacing the whole arm. Wondering where did you get that ball joint separater... everywhere I look they are 2 and 1/4 max depth and that is not even enough for your tie rods.
Thanks! The big one is the Schwaben 20-80mm ball joint removal tool. Ordered from ECS here: www.ecstuning.com/b-schwaben-parts/ball-joint-removal-tool-20-80mm/008958sch01a~sch/
Hallo, i'm from Indonesia.
Good job.
@@NoGaragE30 it looks like you need an extractor about 70mm tall to fit it over the control arm at 3:47, is that right? or would 50mm work?
@@gigel99324 Correct. The standard ball joint separator goes to 51mm and that wasn't enough, which is why I ordered the Schwaben that goes up to 80mm.
Better change everything at once so you only need alignment once
Where did you get the large ball join seperator from? Cant seem to find it
www.ecstuning.com/b-schwaben-parts/ball-joint-removal-tool-20-80mm/008958sch01a~sch/
Did it fix the vibrations? I keep having vibrations at highway speed with freshly balanced wheels
Absolutely. I also have all new suspension components by now, but that is a common issue with these cars.
I have a BAD vibration at just under 1000 rpm and it gets a little bit smoother at higher rpm. I just replaced my giubo and center support bearing but the vibration did not go away. It vibrates even while revving in park. Could it be the thrust arms?
if you're revving in park then presumably you're not moving.. so I wouldn't think it's any suspension components.
You ever figure it out?
Can you give a name of those control arms producer. And how good is thw quality?
This are Lemforder parts. OE quality/supplier. I got the kit from FCPeuro.com and I have included part numbers in video description.
Nice job
Is ball joint seperator necessary? Could i just hammer the ball joint out :D?
Im sure you can, if you manage to get the right angles in these tight spaces and dont care about potential damage to aluminum parts. The tool is worth every penny. I used a hammer and pickle fork with ball joints on my E30 once, and that was enough to never do it again. You could also rent these tools from your local auto parts store, usually free of charge, if you dont think you will use it more than once.
Where can I find the ball joint separators? I can only find the small variant.
This is the Schwaben 20-80mm tool. Got mine from ECS tuning: www.ecstuning.com/b-schwaben-parts/ball-joint-removal-tool-20-80mm/008958sch01a~sch/
Hey do you have the part numbers for the hardware you replaced? Thank you. (bolts and nuts)
Control Arm Bolt - BMW 31303450534, Shock Absorber Mounting Bolt - BMW 33521092072, Self-Locking Hex Nut - BMW 31106769443, Control Arm Bolt - BMW 31121092105, Control Arm Locking Collar Nut - BMW 33306760349, Self-Locking Collar - 33326760376, Hex Nut with Flange - BMW 33306760587
Thank you so much!
Thanks so much with your helpful video.l have been trying to replace the control arms with the help of Autodoc video above.although l have the same type of ball joint seperator,l couldnt use it because it was so quick that l could replace mine.anywhere l ended up thinking that everything was loosened for the purpose of filming.l was desperate until l learnt of a biger wishbone seperater.Thanks and Well done.