'Who Said For Them To Be Inside And Not Outside?': Carlos Giménez Questions Top PA Police Official
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 жов 2024
- At today's House Security Committee hearing, Rep. Carlos A. Giménez (R-FL) questioned Pennsylvania State Police Commissioner Christopher Paris about the assassination attempt on former President Trump.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
This stops when we stop treating evil as incompetence
Nailed it!
Exactly
Every patriot needs to be a secret service agent for Trump. Ordinary civilians spotted the danger - not the elite security.
Bingo
Deliberate incompetence just like the withdrawal from Afghanistan
Nothing will happen. MAYORKAS still has his job. He should in Jaill
Welp the Democrats control the Senate we cant just fire them.
The House impeached Mayorkas but SEN Chuck Shumer stopped it once it reached the Senate.
There was a video posted online -now deleted presumably by UA-cam- by a PHD acoustic expert. He analysed in great detail every shot in the sequence. He aslo said he was putting himself at risk by posting. Said first three shots came from similar position to the shooter but below the roof as the trajectory had an upward angle. No echo of roof from these shots. It is why the bullet that has been seen whizzing past Trump and nicked his ear was able to continue to hit the elderly man higher up on the outside of the bleaches. Now we find out the SS were inside this building. Interesting in the words of sergeant Shultz.
According to the expert, the next five shots had an extra echo consistent with being on the roof. Consistent with five cartridges found on roof, although FBI claims 8 were found. I wonder if all 8 cartridges have same markings.
Also there are videos - also removed - that show someone on the water tower moving out then disappearing. FBI say no one on water tower I believe.
This is all highly conflicting.
@@melodydgates There is another video out showing that the shooter did not shoot the first three shots. You can see there was not recoil from his weapon when the first three shots were fired. Sadly, UA-cam will not allow me to post the link here as they do not believe in the 1st amendment.
Treason has its own justice
To refer to these leaders as incompetent,is an insult to the incompetent people I have met in life.
By overusing pity as a motivation, liberals have elevated incompetence into a virtue that disguises evil.
I believe Joe Biden is faking dementia to avoid prosecution and to stay in office. I suspect the Bidens are getting kickbacks from Zelensky, meanwhile.
The liberals have indoctrinated us to not attack incompetent destructive people.
We need to respect the natural laws that mandate negative consequences for incompetence.
Pretty competent, they got aaway.
This was not a series of mistakes and failures, we have been lied to over and over again about that roof. First it wasnt guarded because of a slope, then it was guarded but they left because it was too hot, now they were told to go look for Crooks and Crooks somehow knows exactly when they are gone and goes up on the roof and shoots. No, BS.
I’m wondering if that police officer that climbed up and got the rifle pointed at him, indirectly ruined their plan. He got scared and rushed the shots and once he started shooting the counter snipers had no choice but to eliminate him
@@Hablonoenlgles. Interesting question! We can add it to the others they’re not answering!
Agree. This was not a series of mistakes and failures.
@@Hablonoenlgles Yes. That policeman who climbed up to that roof ruined the plan. And threw it off somehow. And maybe if that hadn't happened. I see .
ALL LEOs failed that day. Stand up for yourselves and tell the whole truth. You mean to tell me you hear all the radio traffic and no one responds to that area??? Where is DIRTY HARRY when we need him. Stand up and tell all you know needs to be said and live the rest of your life like warriors ...not like quiet chumps.
Does anyone believe our Nation is truly safe n secure anymore???? I don’t
No. Were not. 100 dead from fentanyl coming over from Mexico and nothing being done to stop it
Unfortunately - it seems like that depends on your party affiliation
When was the last time you did?
Don’t believe your nation.Period. Lol
Thats what you get with the leftist in power
sorry, but TOO MANY so-called convenient 'coincidences' here...
It was an “Inside “ Job, ………They should have been Outside!!……..Was it by Accident ?….Hmm.
Reminds me of epstien death
We know the call to allow a threat location to be free, at the same time, the threat person knows it is free to use the threat location, it is NOT a coincidence. It is a PLAN. We know to NOT use drones to cover a threat location, so the threat can use his drone is a PLAN. Especially since the team inside left their post without leaving one to continue to survey is a PLAN. The fact that not one SS Officer was in the crowd that saw the threat get on the roof is a PLAN. The fact that they allowed President Trump to go on stage, even though a threat with a range finder was revealed, is a PLAN. The only part that wasn't in the PLAN was the Holy Spirit of God, giving President Trump the unction to move his head slightly. May every one involved receive God's Divine Judgment.
I wonder, if my comments are always removed, because I am a black person who writes the truth and exposes the devil?
@@ohsnap6506 Yes, likely the same cabal.
These are not mess ups. This is purposeful.
And nothing will happen
Maybe so, this is the lesser of the 2 options. ...they cannot just say we took shots, and missed...therefore, it must be incompetence.
I believe if Trump gets reelected we will be treated to watching (among others) Mayorkas being publicly humiliated as he's convicted of many many crimes, stripped of all pay and allowance and sentenced to life in prison. They know this is coming so they tried to unalive him but in keeping with his failure rate of protecting Americans, he messed this up too. Thank God.
The timeline is everything, it proves they led him out there to be taken out.
Absolutely!
PresidentTRUMP is an AMERICAN BADASS with YUUUUUUGE Red White & Blue Patriotic Balls!! That’s the man I’ll be peacefully & patriotically voting for come November!!
They don’t want another leader. They got a taste of having a puppet as president and want to keep it like that
INSIDE JOB, makes me so sick
Who ordered the #3 counter snipers to remain inside the building?
To ensure the roof was clear for the 20 year old? Even a ladder was provided.
Ordinary untrained civilians spotted the shhoter but not the elite security force. yeah ok - sure.
Many dems called for his secret service protection to be removed a few months ago after the sham trial because he was a “convicted felon”. There is nothing only one reason they would call for that. A child could connect the dots here. Yet look how many adults they get to buy their bs everyday. I’m actually surprised that they are even trying to pretend to take this seriously.
kool it with the conspiracy crap until we get all the info ... i mean you saw how incompetent the lady was
@@websitemartianwe need answers and fast!
@websitemartian lol. They've definitely never tried to off someone "accidentally".
The fact that the sniper was taken out within seconds of the first shot proves the secret service had the sniper in their sights and killed him so he couldn't talk. End of story.
Not really! The sniper hesitated until he saw the rifle
Except there were 8 shots from 3 weapons. 2 shooters.
@@Chuck68ify go away democrat
Oh shut up!
MKULTRA
This guy is hiding something.
hiding because he's afraid his ass being kick.
I believe they are all in on it from Biden to local cops facts Pennsylvania is liberal LEFTIST SOCIALEST state always was and always will be !!!!!!!
This guys dept was not in charge of the SS security plan.
The Colonel seems to be an expert in not knowing things.
What should he know? He wasn't in charge of the event. His agency wasn't responsible for the overall security plan.
@@SpartacusColohe should've showed up with a timeline at the very least.
Er lügt wie gedruckt !
Giménez didn't let him answer.
He's there to oh golly shucks we screwed up sorry next time we'll do better. Everyone knows this was deliberate.
We The People want the answers and accountability...
Go back to Fox News where they cry for that day and night yet did not do that right after January 6.
So, wait for the inquiry to be completed, rather than jumping to conclusions.
We haven't gotten the truth for President Kennedy. We will never get the whole truth, nothing but the truth.
These agencies get their direct orders from the sitting , er in this case, Planted president.
I've watched this guy for some time. Let's be honest. He's only mildly honest. Only a little bit more than Kimberly Cheatle.
I got that vibe. Somewhat honest at times, not much more forthcoming than Cheatle
Nobody wants prison
He's in charge of the state police. He probably wasn't even at the event. He's asked, "Who was in the command center?" He doesn't know. He wasn't there. A lot of these questions should have been thrown at the USSS. "Why was the team inside the building ordered out?" He doesn't know. He wasn't in charge. The officers inside the building weren't from his agency.
PA police had to cooperate with the SS in this assassination plot. Democratic governor Shapiro, no doubt, is in on the scheme.
@@SpartacusColoIt's been a week. These are his people. If he doesn't know it's because he hasn't asked the people involved because he doesn't want to know. That way they can testify I know nothing!
Wouldn’t it make more sense to bring everyone who was there in at once for questioning? Why are people who get info second hand the ones being questioned here?
@SoulPatchProduction Plausible deniability! 😮
"I do not have a specific timeline" seems to be part of a script.
Trump 2024🇺🇲 vote and volunteer to watch sites
💯 PERCENT. WE HAVE TO BE EVERYWHERE TRUMP IS.
And campaign for him too
Sooooo many on the ground and in the background who are COMPLICIT & CORRUPT.
😈👿🇦🇺
So, now we have officers being pulled away from the exact area/building that Crooks gained access to
Yes, part of their evil PLAN. BUT GOD!!! BUT GOD!!! HALLELUJAH!!!
Sorry for the other loss of life. So thankful he belonged to Christ.🕊
@@PastorIhaza JESUS SAVES THEN GOD SAVES. Rest EASY
They were asked to go and search the building.
THIS IS ABSOLUTELY UNBELIEVABLE
Yet secret service and no police have the radio communications from that day😮
Secret service has records of audio from all communications from every mission to protect protectees, except this event
They relied on cell phones apparently..
Communication what?
That's what the Cloudstrike operation was, a clean up.
😮@@Chuck68ify
Two snipers inside conveniently leave their post that over look the roof crooks was crawling on. They were inside and not outside. Need their names and their supervisors
Sound like a inside job- aka Jeffrey Epstein's 'so called' death!!! Conveniently... ALL GUARDS LEFT THEIR POST...that the same time... ummm, strange!!
Exactly
No one said that the officers in that building were counter snipers, OR that they were stationed at the window that was shown in the video,
@@ataxpayer723 ESU OFFICERS WERE , THIS MAN TESTIFIED TO THAT
It can take a year-long investigation to find that out, ... apparently.
Intentional negligence
Why was that building even considered "outside of the perimeter "
Because thats how SS drew the perimeter. Very small and to EXCLUDE the one building worth guarding. Very sneaky and convenient...
@@kmeccat this is the correct answer
@@kmeccat The perimeter they drew up literally looks like a Pac-Man. Or a pizza with a slice missing. Whatever.
They pulled a sniper team to go look for "The suspicious person"? Brilliant!
No one said that those guys were counter snipers...
@@ataxpayer723 I must have heard him wrong, they made it sound like they had a team on that 2nd floor...
@@ataxpayer723"Paris said that two officers with the Butler County Emergency Services Unit, a tactical force with sniper capabilities, left their posts in the building to look for a suspicious individual they spotted first and alerted to other law enforcement. That person was Crooks."
@@brionhannan1204They did.
Is there one person or team or agency in charge of this investigation?
*They shot the patsy, but the assassin got away!*
I believe so, too.
Now he's on a promised vacation.
Just like Oswald.
The fact that there was a massive short sell of Truth Social stock the day before shows that this went straight to the top of our government... ☹️
We need to hear from the PEOPLE THERE! not the Bureaucratic Dept Heads
Who from the Secret Service was in charge that day? That is who they need to be talking to.
💯💯💯
I wish the House Speaker had the guts to investigate this entire administrations capacity to run and how it has ran this past 3 years. I want answers, serious answers. They haven't even begun questioning the FBI and does someone wanna tell me why nobody has been talking about the CIA???
Because they're all compromised
CIA is not supposed to operate on the homeland, the equivalent of the CIA on domestic land is the DHS
@@Buzz420 and one will get the comprised people out of our government except Trump. Especially Kamala. No one else will even investigate these people snd figure out who's corrupt. Congress is not exercising their contempt powers and allowing people to not answer questions, they won't cooperate with congressional oversight because they no there'll be no consequences
We need to investigate Ronald McDonald, he was probably involved too.
@@mhxxd4 Ah, they're not, but we all know they do.
Federal charges need to be filed
By WHO?
DOJ?
FBI?
SS?
DHS?
It appears they are all relatives of the same family, backing each other up, right or wrong. ALL alphabet egencies need to be purged or disbanded.
“Hey that guy over there looks suspicious.”
“Yeah, we better send some snipers to talk to him.”
This makes sense to whom?
"The guy with the ladder we saw before, who lased the CS teams behind the stage with the Range Finder? Yeah, he is suspicious. That's why we texted the photo of him to you."
Cops stop citizens just for loitering, but a guy with a drone and a range finder doesn't warrant any questioning apparently.
And not one sniper stayed at their post lol. This is too easy to figure out
We want the ESU team that left the roof because it was too hot to be subpoenaed. Let America see these idiots for who they are.
It would not surprise if there are self deletions before that happens.
How can somebody be inside and won't hear someone scrolling on the rooftop?
Our home security cameras are better than what these "experts" used for surveillance. Cameras could have covered all the roof tops .
Success has a thousand fathers, failure is an orphan.
Between this state police guy and the ss I'm not sure that there is a single functioning braincell. I'd love to know what the taxpayer pays these people.
serial stupidity is a sign of conscious intent
How many competent/smart managers do you know of? I know a lot of competent and able people who don't want to be managers because of the office politics involved.
That entire day was nothing but a very bad circus
Circus dont WANT TO KILL PEOPLE!!@ HUGE MASSIVE difference!!!
Who chose the Butler venue? It was a sniper's paradise from rooftop to the surrounding tree lined meadow. And who short sold Trump's stock just before the attempt and scrubbed the evidence of the trade? Somebody knew an attempt on Trump's life was in the works and the time line.
Why did jill biden have city police, casino security and 10 secret service agents when she was at a ballroom event at the Rivers Casino?
They do a lot of venues and have been doing it for year, the location is not the issue they just should have secured it properly
They purposely did not secure it and now scratch their heads in denial.
@@mhxxd4Peter Navarro said in an interview that originally it was going to be at an airport like those fly thru rally’s he has done before but someone changed it. He said they should have never had the rally there. Too much security risk with the layout.
ANSWER. Trumpski's campaign chose that venue.
The moment grassy knoll conspiracy theories seem plausible.
@@moonlightmelodrama that’s whats missing…the grassy knoll !
Conspiracy theories is truth. The people accountable don't want PUBLIC accountability. It is in fact THEIR JOB.. treasonous or not
It's been 10 days and nobody has the timeline???? How is that possible? It is not that difficult to question 10-20-30 people under your command, check the communications and draw the whole picture within hours, not days. Someone is not doing their job and really have to go.
The political answers from everyone in every inquiry ever. I yearn for the day when people just answer the questions with truth and without having to skirt around and dance around the answer.
I’m so sick of the games these criminals play.
You can get GPS data on everyone there, and get a timeline. Just ask the NSA. Lol
And they can get cm level gps accuracy with rtk data from nearby. I'll certain that they had rtk somewhere nearby for such a large event
The sound footage from people recording at the event would identify the position of the shots fired
@@caddystube true... the know exactly how many flies were at each trashcan on site, the cell phone data of every Trump supporter in attendance, but somehow just lack any pertinent info on this coordinated effort to snipe Trump out of the race... absolutely effin' corrupt to the effin' core!°
Absolutely nothing will be done! They have gotten away with everything since 2015😡
since 1963...
They have gotten by, not away.
I believe that the retribution is coming on 31May-1June Pentecost 2028.
Isaiah 26:19-21, Isaiah 13:9,19, Zephaniah 2:1-3, Revelation 6:3-4.
Amen! I wanted to know that also. Great question!
I have 300 people on radios at work. There are 12 frequencies.
Maintenance is on 3, paint is on 4, assembly line 1 is on 5, assembly line 2 is on 6, finish line 1 is on 7, funish line 2 is on 8, a d so on. Anyone can communicate to everyone on any frequency instantly. If some gets on and yells "FIRE! FIRE! FIRE!", all 1500 people get the news in seconds. Sometimes before the alarm can be pulled.
Point being, they had the means and the tume to protect Trump if that had been their desire.
Does Butler County not hv recordings of their own communications that day??
Probably not, it probably all went thru the SS command center and they were responsible for the recordings
They do record which is probably why they weren't allowed inside the SS command center. SS didn't want Butler recording evidence of a conspiracy.
Why is this man here?? He wasn't there. Pull the cops in that were there!!! Dam!!
Shade tent on roof...60 bucks
Bucket hat from any police supply company-$25.00. Add a camelback for hydration. Done
There are people behind these decisions. Those people should be held accountable, and they won't.
ANYONE, that can't answer simple questions like this, almost two weeks after the incident, should be fired immediately! We know that won't happen, because every living sole that works for President Bribem, is either totally incompetent or willfully negligent.
Whatever the outcome, the truth will never be revealed. Lies will go unopposed and butts properly covered.
God bless this public servant.
Not all public servant are good people majority is, but they’re bad apples and every basket
Thank you Carlos!
All departments have got lazy and it starts at the top
Excellent ser of questions.
Who's getting fired and charged with this
HOW ABOUT...bring all the people ACTUALLY THERE, in at the SAME TIME, so they can contradict each other at the SAME TIME?
SS says ESU, DHS or FBI said or did something, DHS,ESU/FBI can say yes or no, immediately!
SAME DAY. Put them at the same table. Easier to point fingers at each other that way.
Save time, save money and MAYBE get to the truth.
Oh, and have police there to ARREST the liars!
Politicians grandstanding, nothing more.
Maybe so, but the witnesses (in all these useless hearings) constantly lying and getting away with it is worse.
Handicapped ramps have steeper slopes than that roof. Nothing but EXCUSES!
Right?!
Disappointing times! Worried for our President Trump!
When are we going to hear about the ballistic report? It would certainly explain the question everyone has about the shooter or shooters! I haven’t heard a single word about that? 🤔🤔🤔
What is the end result of all these questions and investigations going to be? A year from now , when we look back at this , will anything have changed? This will run the normal 2-3 week shelf life of news reporting and reader interest until people get bored or another shocking event happens.
"They would always rather be seen as incompetent than criminal". Ryan Christian, The Last American Vagabond.
4:25 dude on the right “crap they are going to find out I hired the kid!”
Investigate him immediately he’s freaking tf out inside
@@Hablonoenlgles something definitely triggered him lol your on live tv homie get the composure!
Great questions! Must find those answers.
THEY ARE BUSTED
Not even close. They already destroyed all the crucial evidence like the radio communication recordings and operating plans
Why do they always dodge questions and lie with a smirk on their face as if they know there will be NO consequences. Makes me want to vomit!
I saw a couple videos which showed a sound analysis of the bullets. it seemed there was 3 shots with a noticeable echo and 3 or 4 shots with no echo then the shot which got crookes. 2 different guns? are there videos which get taken down?
An excellent, honest witness that actually answers the questions!
Were the radio communications from that event recorded?
Cops will never admit they were wrong
I KEEP SEEING THIS COMEDY SKIT IN MY HEAD WHERE A GROUP OF SECRET SERVICE AGENTS ARE CLEVERLY HIDING INSIDE OF A STAKEOUT BUILDING AS A SKINNY YOUNG INEPT ASSASSIN IS SNEAKILY WALKING PASSED SEVERAL WINDOWS OF THAT BUILDING CARRYING A RIFLE AND A LADDER UNNOTICED AS YOU SEE SILHOUETTES OF AGENT BODIES INSIDE THE BUILDING THROUGH THE SAME WINDOWS OF THAT BUILDING. A GREAT COMEDY SCENARIO!!!
The Secret Service is totally RESPONSIBLE for everything.
Carlos Gimenez on point with his line of questioning.
He didn't let the guy answer the most important question he asked. Who made the call not to put someone on that roof?
@@heidiw8406And who okayed Trump to be brought out on stage when there was an Armed Suspect around?!
Hummmm. I guess from hearing this for days now, "We don't need no stinking timeline."
The problem is it is an insider job. And hire is based on diversity not on real merit
They don’t have answers and they never will. That’s the whole point.
Mayorkas should do the decent thing......and resign too.
Biggest question, Why were the ESU officers allowed to leave their over watch post to go outside to look for "a suspicious person"? When you are assigned to over watch, you NEVER abandon that job.
If they would have stayed on their over watch position, the shooter would have never been able to shoot Trump!
3:30. But what if local police can’t figure out the basics like guarding a small building??
The "mess ups" were perfectly synchronized with Crooks' activities.
Does anyone NOT believe that security was intentionally reduced in the hopes that well, you know.... thingy..... an unfortunate event caused by some random nutjob assassin might ... you know.... eliminate "the substantial threat to democracy (Trump)"?
It's a longer mental reach to believe it was unintentional then intentional. Too many coincidences point towards hit job on Trump
@@indydave1849 It's wasn't a 'hit job' in the technical sense. Team Biden did not hire a hitman, like was done in the movie, 'The Day of the Jackel' (1973). What they did was sow the seeds with "He's Hitler!" rhetoric and the sent the B-team Secret Service to lamely protect him, but even the B-Team spotted the gunman, so Team Biden gave the 'let's wait and see' command in the hopes that this unknown nutjob would actually get lucky and rid them of Trump but with plausible deniability for them. However, just like in the movie, the target moved his head at the last second and the gunman missed. Now, Team Biden is playing dumb, but the American people aren't dumb.
many , many of us are thinking that. Thank you .
@stevelangstroth5833 I never meant it to be a soprano style hit.. it was a carefully planned "situation" where any investigative path never would lead back to the FBI, DOJ, or SS. All the convicting evidence followed behind the grey matter leaving Cookes skull
Why are there more questions than answers? Why aren’t the people being questioned have at least some answers. It’s been 9-10 days now and why hasn’t anyone who was there during the shooting asked these same questions and get their own answers?
Can you remember what you were doing 10 days ago at exactly 2.35pm in the afternoon?
@@ataxpayer723 yes, if I was in a position of authority when someone was shot.
@@ataxpayer723 yes!
amazing how many of these people "in charge" of these agencies don't seem to know very much...I've seen retail workers held to higher standards
So...... ANOTHER stuttering low info guvment employee says absolutely NOTHING!!
Time lines are so important. Why didn’t anybody bring one to this hearing. Couldn’t they say, the FBI will have the final one?
Secret service agents were all inside that building Well that makes sense.
They were in the building because that's where the coffee was ! And they were NOT doing their job !!!
Follow the coffee and doughnuts and that’s where the not so secret service were skritching, just itching to kill Trump, because he has their number and they’re backed into a corner when he wins. It’s a do or die situation for them and Trumps life means nothing compared to their positions, power, careers and retirements, plus most if not all will be hung if brought before military tribunals. It’s really coming down to rule of law or the anarchy the New world order is pushing and we all as Americans need to push back or it’ll be an uncivil war because of the power hungry zealots. I’m praying that those who have swarm to protect us from enemies foreign and domestic will start or resign and let people who will rightfully take over from their lack of commitment and actions. Are there not patriots and hero’s left or are they just in old movies. 🎥
As if these officials weren't briefed by the ATF and CIA and all the ABCs together
No one answered the questions fire them all
You are in great shape!
Blaine County Sheriff's Department did the same thing during COVID lock down signs were placed on the wrong end of the County. In my opinion passive aggressive behavior by individuals who are supposed to protect us. Just a not so very polite way of saying 🖕 Trump especially in Blaine County Idaho. Full of "not my President types"
another big nothing burger commitee.
Wow, this guy just answered the questions. How unusual.
was trump shooter right or left handed ?
Pretty sure his head/cheek was on the left side, usually that means right handed
Why didn't the rep. let him answer the question? I would like to know who told people to not be on the roof.
Government incompetence at its finest...
No, more sinister than that.
They lie for each other!!their all corrupt !!they should all be jailed!! What a JOKE!!😨