Thank you, Lexi! The Phyto Shine lipsticks are one of my top fav formulas! I love their colour range more than Chantecaille. While some people think these are similiar to the Lip Chics, I really prefer the Sisley!
I think the new Sisley eyeshades look very similar. I like them, but I’m not into glimmer or shimmer. My fav that I enjoy ‘the most’ is #14. It’s in the purple family in a satin formula. No sparkles. I have two of the Phyto Rouge lipsticks, Rosewood is still my standout shade. And finally, I have three of the Le Phyto Rouge colors: Rose Noumea (21), Rose Portofino (20) and (# 24) not named but a deeper rose/mauve. Thanks for showing your stash - helps remind me I have lots to play and experiment with in my own! Great video! You’re the very best at these comparisons ❤
Hi Lexi !! These are one of my favourite top lipsticks love the formula. The eye crayons are also so easy and long lasting . Great swatches , the Ginger and coral are on my list 🤗💕
I have oily deep set & hooded eyes and these sticks are amazing! Only time I’ve ever done a look in the am, & it’s all still there in the pm. Their shadows and liners layers so great over them, too.
Hi Lexi, great video with tons of insight and comparisons. The shimmer in the eye sticks is pretty as is the shine and shades of the lip products. 😊✨️❤️
excellent video Lexi! REALLY appreciate you showcasing the latest and previous Phyto-Rouge Shine Lip products and the newest eye twists are so pretty 😍 Awesome swatches ... so so helpful! Thank you 🤗
I’ve only tried this brand a few times from Beautylish and Nordstrom, as they are expensive. But the mascara and lipsticks I’ve tried so far, I really love. Will definitely try these these new eye and lip shades. I got the Valentino and Givenchy concealers after watching your video, and I’m so so happy, I finally found concealers that work on me! Thanks Lexi! 🥰🥰🥰
This video was very helpful. I have been wanting to purchase one of the lip shines, since I tried one on in Saks a while back. I’m going to order the ginger color, through your link since it would go with my ND Bronze, and Gold palette. If the formula is HG status, and better than my lip chic, I’ll order more when I can. Happy Mother’s Day!
Thank you! I'm so glad it was helpful! Please let me know what you think of the formula. I find it to be more moisturizing over time than the Chantecaille lip chics.
Surprisingly the Sisley have some really great cooler shades too that you might like. It's interesting but the Chantecaille and Sisley do not seem to have any "dupe" shades that I have found yet.
Lexi, so happy you did a video on these new shades. The Sisley website doesn’t help much. I really like the eye & lip shades. You have quite the Sisley lip collection which is so helpful for swatches. I have some of the Phyto eye twists but I don’t reach for them often. But they are easy for that one done look. I need to use them more. Thank you for the review and the swatches!! 😊🌺
@@LexiJong Funny I have that one, Pearl & Copper. I wonder how close Fawn & Sunset are to Copper. I don’t know why Sisley doesn’t have a swatch or picture of the shade on a model. 😆
I have been hesitant to purchase some eye twists for fear that they will pull my eyelids and slacken the skin. I had a bunch of Laura Mercier and Bobbi Brown sticks and ended up throwing them out because I felt like they were putting a lot of pressure on my lids when I tried to get the colour on. I would like to get your opinion on whether or not you think that the Sisley product is gentler on the eyelids than other brands, or if it is similar to the other eyeshadow sticks out there. I really love the single eyeshadows and have quite a few of them. I keep watching your eye looks and see how nice it looks when you combine the two Sisley formulas in a look. Thanks in advance for reading my long comment.
Hi Sarah! I think the Sisley is more gentle on the lids than the other brands personally. If you are going to like any eye crayon, this would be it imo. See if you can go to a counter and try the testers on your hand so you can see how creamy they are.
@@LexiJong that's a great idea. I really do like the way you layer them. I have been thinking about the steely shade for a while. I did buy Lisa Eldridge's grey colored liquid lurex but it is really intense and I personally find that liquid shadows in dark tones are difficult for me to work. Thank you for responding.
HI Lexi - so nice to be able to watch a beauty video again after some time out and seeing there was a Sisley one I was so excited to see this! I do feel those eye shadow sticks are rather too warm for me and orange/stronger hues just don't suit me. Even though you favour cool tones the warm ones also look fabulous on you Lexi! Lovely to see another line up of the Phyto shines - I refer to your older one very often. I fairly recently bought the Petal shade and loved the formula but it seemed to lean rather peach-toned on me and I didn't like it. Funnily enough I just sold it on Ebay today and will look for another shade and I know you recommended Rosewood to me before ( I should've listened 🤣) I have to say I agree with one of your other subs who said she thought the Chantecaille lip chics weren't in the same league. The Sisley are lovely and creamy and feel nourishing to me. Having said that I still have a soft spot for Rose Bourbon colour and I wanted to ask you, since you have both, whether Rosewood is a close match? I had the feeling that it was perhaps a tad warmer than the Rose Bourbon which on me is more neutral/slightly cool. Thanks for your great video 😊👍
@@LexiJong Thank you for your kind words and also for putting the swatches on your community tab that was really helpful and confirmed to me that the Sisley one is warmer than the Bourbon Rose - I like the slight coolness to the Chantecaille but love the Sisley formula more! I really appreciate you doing that and I also benefited from seeing the highlighter comparisons too. I don't have the Chanel but I love my WA Lit stick - I'm coming to an end with that one unfortunately - I love how it can be used in so many different ways 😊
Lexi do you ever wear liners with these shine lipsticks? I am going to wear Sheer Raspberry to a dinner this weekend and I would like to wear a liner but feel like it might look too harsh.
@@LexiJong thanks for letting me know. I actually found that with the sheer character of the lipstick, you can use whatever you want with it. I did have a Chanel liner in almost the same shade which did not change the tone of the lipstick - so that was good.
Lexi thank you for swatching all of the lipsticks again. I wasnt going to pick up Cocoa because I heard it was a warm tone. Now that you confirmed it is cool, I will definitely add it to my collection. I think that the two new shades are really disappointing and that they could have done better.
Their packaging is such a visceral turn off for me with that zebra 🦓. I don’t know why maybe it’s the Jersey Shore era in me but I can’t do it lol. I don’t mind it as much with the gold and white one and that formula is so lovely. Great video Lexi thanks for always sharing the new new ❤
I don't l ike the packaging either but I love the products enough that I can look past it. However, it took me a while to try some of their items for the exact same reason!
I really love the eye colors. The little bits of glitter I have to stay away from. Turning 60 (a tad older now) I have sensitive eyes. Sadly. I can’t wear anything in water line as well. I love the phyto lip tho. I have 22 or 24. Ha can’t remember older.
Maybe I’m bias in favor of Sisley because I like the brand a lot more, but the Chantecaille lip chics are just lipsticks with minimum color that don’t do anything for your lips. I have two and for the price they are regrets for sure. The Sisley lip shines feel nourishing even though they are not technically a balm, same with the lip twists. Your lips feel conditioned afterwards. With the Chantecaille lip chics, once it wears off your lips need something on otherwise they are just dry. I wouldn’t buy a Chantecaille lip chic again, and please don’t think you are getting something similar for a better price. Sorry for the rant. Lol.
I have a handful of Chantecaille Lip Chics and recently purchased 2 Sisley. I enjoy both, but maybe like Sisley a tiny bit more. I thought the lip chics were supposed to be sheer by design. Both brands are overpriced but nice luxury items if you want to spend the $$. Appreciate swatches of the new colors!
Thank you, Lexi! The Phyto Shine lipsticks are one of my top fav formulas! I love their colour range more than Chantecaille. While some people think these are similiar to the Lip Chics, I really prefer the Sisley!
I do too, they are a better version imo of a similar product.
Thanks Lexi! Loved all your color swatches so I can make a wise decision on my color choices. They're absolutely beautiful!
Thank you Lorrina!
I think the new Sisley eyeshades look very similar. I like them, but I’m not into glimmer or shimmer. My fav that I enjoy ‘the most’ is #14. It’s in the purple family in a satin formula. No sparkles. I have two of the Phyto Rouge lipsticks, Rosewood is still my standout shade. And finally, I have three of the Le Phyto Rouge colors: Rose Noumea (21), Rose Portofino (20) and (# 24) not named but a deeper rose/mauve. Thanks for showing your stash - helps remind me I have lots to play and experiment with in my own! Great video! You’re the very best at these comparisons ❤
Thank you Maureen! You have a great selection.
Hi Lexi !! These are one of my favourite top lipsticks love the formula. The eye crayons are also so easy and long lasting . Great swatches , the Ginger and coral are on my list 🤗💕
Thank you so much Bridget! I think these are a truly great formula!
I have oily deep set & hooded eyes and these sticks are amazing! Only time I’ve ever done a look in the am, & it’s all still there in the pm. Their shadows and liners layers so great over them, too.
I'm so happy to hear that! They are such a wonderful product imo!
Hi Lexi, great video with tons of insight and comparisons. The shimmer in the eye sticks is pretty as is the shine and shades of the lip products. 😊✨️❤️
Thank you so much Pam!
I think the Sisley are definitely preferable. I'm actually getting frustrated with Chantecaille but more on that soon!
excellent video Lexi! REALLY appreciate you showcasing the latest and previous Phyto-Rouge Shine Lip products and the newest eye twists are so pretty 😍 Awesome swatches ... so so helpful! Thank you 🤗
Thank you! So glad it was helpful!
I’ve only tried this brand a few times from Beautylish and Nordstrom, as they are expensive. But the mascara and lipsticks I’ve tried so far, I really love. Will definitely try these these new eye and lip shades.
I got the Valentino and Givenchy concealers after watching your video, and I’m so so happy, I finally found concealers that work on me! Thanks Lexi! 🥰🥰🥰
Sisley definitely has some amazing products! They are one of the most consistent brands imo. I'm so glad the concealer video was helpful!! Enjoy!
I just purchased n10 and I love it. Great formula.
I'm so glad to hear that!
This video was very helpful. I have been wanting to purchase one of the lip shines, since I tried one on in Saks a while back. I’m going to order the ginger color, through your link since it would go with my ND Bronze, and Gold palette. If the formula is HG status, and better than my lip chic, I’ll order more when I can. Happy Mother’s Day!
Thank you! I'm so glad it was helpful! Please let me know what you think of the formula. I find it to be more moisturizing over time than the Chantecaille lip chics.
Thank you, as always, Lexii!!!
Thank you for watching!
Fantastic review as always! Sisley products are an investment, so I appreciate a thorough review ❤
Thank you for watching!
So glad you made this video Lexi!!! I just saw these and was wondering about these! Ty❤
I'm so glad it was helpful!
I love the bright colors, thanks
Thank you for watching!
Hey lexi fab video .. I love the Sisley shadow sticks .. have a great day 🤗🤗
Thank you! Have a great day!
I love Chantecaille lip chic for the variety of colours, i find a lot to be cooler leaning, which i prefer. I like them.
Surprisingly the Sisley have some really great cooler shades too that you might like. It's interesting but the Chantecaille and Sisley do not seem to have any "dupe" shades that I have found yet.
Lexi, so happy you did a video on these new shades. The Sisley website doesn’t help much. I really like the eye & lip shades. You have quite the Sisley lip collection which is so helpful for swatches. I have some of the Phyto eye twists but I don’t reach for them often. But they are easy for that one done look. I need to use them more. Thank you for the review and the swatches!! 😊🌺
Thanks Lora! I just ordered a new Topaze in the eye twists today. It's my favorite!
@@LexiJong Funny I have that one, Pearl & Copper. I wonder how close Fawn & Sunset are to Copper. I don’t know why Sisley doesn’t have a swatch or picture of the shade on a model. 😆
@@loralee3232 i broke my last one and ruined it. This is my third though, classic i always come back to.
Thank you, Lexi! This is so helpful!
Thank you for watching!!
I have been hesitant to purchase some eye twists for fear that they will pull my eyelids and slacken the skin. I had a bunch of Laura Mercier and Bobbi Brown sticks and ended up throwing them out because I felt like they were putting a lot of pressure on my lids when I tried to get the colour on. I would like to get your opinion on whether or not you think that the Sisley product is gentler on the eyelids than other brands, or if it is similar to the other eyeshadow sticks out there. I really love the single eyeshadows and have quite a few of them. I keep watching your eye looks and see how nice it looks when you combine the two Sisley formulas in a look. Thanks in advance for reading my long comment.
Hi Sarah! I think the Sisley is more gentle on the lids than the other brands personally. If you are going to like any eye crayon, this would be it imo. See if you can go to a counter and try the testers on your hand so you can see how creamy they are.
@@LexiJong that's a great idea. I really do like the way you layer them. I have been thinking about the steely shade for a while. I did buy Lisa Eldridge's grey colored liquid lurex but it is really intense and I personally find that liquid shadows in dark tones are difficult for me to work. Thank you for responding.
HI Lexi - so nice to be able to watch a beauty video again after some time out and seeing there was a Sisley one I was so excited to see this! I do feel those eye shadow sticks are rather too warm for me and orange/stronger hues just don't suit me. Even though you favour cool tones the warm ones also look fabulous on you Lexi!
Lovely to see another line up of the Phyto shines - I refer to your older one very often. I fairly recently bought the Petal shade and loved the formula but it seemed to lean rather peach-toned on me and I didn't like it. Funnily enough I just sold it on Ebay today and will look for another shade and I know you recommended Rosewood to me before ( I should've listened 🤣) I have to say I agree with one of your other subs who said she thought the Chantecaille lip chics weren't in the same league. The Sisley are lovely and creamy and feel nourishing to me. Having said that I still have a soft spot for Rose Bourbon colour and I wanted to ask you, since you have both, whether Rosewood is a close match? I had the feeling that it was perhaps a tad warmer than the Rose Bourbon which on me is more neutral/slightly cool. Thanks for your great video 😊👍
Hi Annie! I will post a swatch comparison on the community tab bettween the two shades. I'm glad to see you are back and I hope you are doing well!
@@LexiJong Thank you for your kind words and also for putting the swatches on your community tab that was really helpful and confirmed to me that the Sisley one is warmer than the Bourbon Rose - I like the slight coolness to the Chantecaille but love the Sisley formula more! I really appreciate you doing that and I also benefited from seeing the highlighter comparisons too. I don't have the Chanel but I love my WA Lit stick - I'm coming to an end with that one unfortunately - I love how it can be used in so many different ways 😊
@@anniewhitmore7627 I am so glad they were helpful!
Between this and Tom Ford new liquor lipstick 💄, what do you prefer or what do you recommend???
I prefer these over the Tom Ford personally.
Can’t afford Sisley now cos I have lost my job… enjoyed your video and swatches❤
I'm sorry to hear that. Thank you for watching!
Lexi do you ever wear liners with these shine lipsticks? I am going to wear Sheer Raspberry to a dinner this weekend and I would like to wear a liner but feel like it might look too harsh.
I wear a liner with these lipsticks most of the time. I had one on in this video (it was actually an eyeliner but close enough, lol).
@@LexiJong thanks for letting me know. I actually found that with the sheer character of the lipstick, you can use whatever you want with it. I did have a Chanel liner in almost the same shade which did not change the tone of the lipstick - so that was good.
Lexi thank you for swatching all of the lipsticks again. I wasnt going to pick up Cocoa because I heard it was a warm tone. Now that you confirmed it is cool, I will definitely add it to my collection. I think that the two new shades are really disappointing and that they could have done better.
Thank you for sharing Sarah! I hope they add a soft lavender pink sometime.
@@LexiJong that is a great idea 💡. See they need you as an advisor.
@@sarahpenz3739 I wish! That would be a great job!
Their packaging is such a visceral turn off for me with that zebra 🦓. I don’t know why maybe it’s the Jersey Shore era in me but I can’t do it lol. I don’t mind it as much with the gold and white one and that formula is so lovely. Great video Lexi thanks for always sharing the new new ❤
I wish they would change the packaging as well.
I don't l ike the packaging either but I love the products enough that I can look past it. However, it took me a while to try some of their items for the exact same reason!
I agree!
Jersey shore era 😂 omg too funny! I could never put my finger on it but nevertheless I do love many of their products. It is a bit garish, though.
I really love the eye colors. The little bits of glitter I have to stay away from. Turning 60 (a tad older now) I have sensitive eyes. Sadly. I can’t wear anything in water line as well. I love the phyto lip tho. I have 22 or 24. Ha can’t remember older.
I love the phyto-lips too! I think 24? is my favorite!
I fall in love with your swatches I go buy and end up not liking the colors. Must be from the lighting.
I'm sorry to hear that. I try to keep my lighting as accurate as possible.
👌❤️👌
Thank you!
Maybe I’m bias in favor of Sisley because I like the brand a lot more, but the Chantecaille lip chics are just lipsticks with minimum color that don’t do anything for your lips. I have two and for the price they are regrets for sure. The Sisley lip shines feel nourishing even though they are not technically a balm, same with the lip twists. Your lips feel conditioned afterwards. With the Chantecaille lip chics, once it wears off your lips need something on otherwise they are just dry. I wouldn’t buy a Chantecaille lip chic again, and please don’t think you are getting something similar for a better price. Sorry for the rant. Lol.
I personally prefer the Sisley too although I don't have issues with the Chantecaille lip chics. There is just something inferior imo.
I prefer the Sisley too! I'm glad I'm not the only one. I think they are both nice products but the Sisley is just better.
I have a handful of Chantecaille Lip Chics and recently purchased 2 Sisley. I enjoy both, but maybe like Sisley a tiny bit more. I thought the lip chics were supposed to be sheer by design. Both brands are overpriced but nice luxury items if you want to spend the $$. Appreciate swatches of the new colors!
For you, Sunset rather than Fawn.
Thank you!