Isn’t it crazy too think about red velvet’s last comeback before Chill Kill was beautiful Christmas and that was last year?? It was about to be a whole year since we have a red velvet comeback…
They were on tour for the first half of the year so it made sense. Since Chill Kill is a full album, the recording process and preparation takes time so it is fair compared to how long other groups have gone without producing songs before but technically Red Velvet was still active
@@nveeously yea i can tell youre a 2019 luvie😭 you dont know how YUMMY it was being a reveluv back then during their first years, even if sm was always shitty they were better w the vlogs and vlives💔i cant complain ig bc this happens to every sm group when they debut another one
I mean, it’s the definition of a perfect distribution based on vocal talent. What more can be said? It’s exactly how it should be in a vocal heavy group. Plus with all the joint choruses they sing, Yeri and Irene are still singing a lot during the songs anyway, so it’s not like in other groups where all you have is their solo lines.
@@jeffersongarcia_ I don’t believe it needs to be. Their songs are consistently sang well and no member is being used beyond their capabilities. An equal distribution shouldn’t be the goal, that just ignores differences in ability.
@iloveminjeong01 you think RV is SNSD or what? You can literally hear Yeri's voice in the choruses and wherever they sing together. Even in the recording behind videos you can see Irene and Yeri record the chorus parts, double for those parts in higher and lower keys, etc. Either you don't know better or you're basing it off of big groups like SNSD.
@@peterr7447 First, for each member, you have to calculate the number of seconds divided by the number of songs they participated. Then, you put in all of the inputs inside a circle graph. That’s how you get the percentages for the average line distribution. If you want to know about the variation, you find a standard deviation calculator and input all of their percentages. Afterwards you divide the standard deviation given to you divided by the mean, which is all of the percentages combined divided by the number of members there are.
@@peterr7447 I’m sorry if this took so long to reply to you. When I try to explain this to someone, my reply becomes hidden (Sometimes, until the viewer look at all the comments form newest first).
If you could next time, add 4 more songs - Milky way, see the stars, future and another OST whose name was in Korean. It would complete their group discography. But thank you so much for including "I will leave" and "close to me remix". People always forget those great songs. 😇
It will look better if you count when they sing together in the line distribution too. Because when you see Yeri or Irene sing 20 seconds in the song, it does not mean they sing only 20 seconds; they sing more than that in the chorus together. Not to mention that for many songs, Yeri, Irene, Joy are ones who carry the chorus becasue Wendy and Seulgi are busy with adlib, high-note, and others.
i don't get why y'all don't include yeri in happiness and be natural? they already have versions of it with her and it's been 8 years, she should be included in these
These line distributions are only for studio versions which they haven't re-recorded with Yeri. Yeri has only performed those songs on live stages and concerts, those aren't official studio versions.
@@WomensIconnYou are blind there are 5 in red velvet before in the be natural era there were 4 now there are 5 Irene, Seulgi, Wendy, Joy and Yeri are 5
It took Wendy 4 years to surpass 3000 seconds despite being the main vocalist of a 5 member group. Then Dayeon from Kep1er surpassed that amount in less than 1 year, and she doesn't have any vocal or rap position.
Have you considered the fact that they are a vocal based group and the lines are fitting for vocal skills? I'm not too big a fan of this distribution, yeri and Irene could've gotten a little more, but it makes sense.
@@Iris-ls5bg I don't want to take them out, just point out, the members probably received similar size parts when it comes to actual lines. Adlibs are often improvised or done on the spot. It was for the people that were complaining about the distribution. So there is no unfairness happening, truly just adlibs.
it took 12 releases for Irene to get a first and Yeri 16 releases to get a first 🥲 Edit: And the fact that Yeri only has 2 firsts while Irene has 1 first Edit 2: Out of 127 songs... Wendy has 69.4% of the first places, Seulgi at 15.3%, Joy at 12.9%, Yeri at 1.6%, and Irene at a 0.8% Seulgi has 53.6% of the second places, Wendy+Joy at 19.2%, Irene at 7.2%, and Yeri at 0.8% Joy has 58.6% of the third places, Seulgi at 24.1%, Wendy at 9.5%, Yeri at 5.2%, and Irene at 2.6% Irene has 57.3% of the fourth places, Yeri at 28.2%, Joy at 8.1%, Seulgi at 4.8%, and Wendy at 1.6% Yeri has 66.4% of the last places, Irene at 25%, Joy at 4.3%, Seulgi at 3.4%, and Wendy at 0.8%
its quite literally the opposite of wild...maybe open a dictionary lmaoo she's the main vocalist i dont see people complaining why wendy doesnt get center position or main dance position or screentime in other videos but people always want to complain about line distribution when wendy is THEE main vocal and the girls have said themself that no one compares
![Red Velvet ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from HAPPINESS to COSMIC]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BTElkVO-wKo/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Velvet ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from HAPPINESS to COSMIC]](/img/tr.png)
![Girls' Generation ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from Into the New World to FOREVER 1]](/img/n.gif)
it took yeri two albums to achieve what wendy has in two songs
I mean yeri's good but the weakest vocalist anyways...
It's always #1 Wendy, #2 Seulgi, #3 Joy, #4 Irene, #5 Yeri, coming to vocals.
You really can't compare those two.
i know about the vocals guys but less than 10 seconds of lines is a shame
@@redvelvet__ but not all songs are made of 100% vocal, if that was true, Irene whose a rapper, would have the same amount of lines as Yeri
not yall acting as if they are on the same level for her to achieve what wendy has
Normal people: watch Line Distribution
Me: Watching the Red Velvet logo spin
Isn’t it crazy too think about red velvet’s last comeback before Chill Kill was beautiful Christmas and that was last year?? It was about to be a whole year since we have a red velvet comeback…
They were on tour for the first half of the year so it made sense. Since Chill Kill is a full album, the recording process and preparation takes time so it is fair compared to how long other groups have gone without producing songs before but technically Red Velvet was still active
you wouldnt survive the drought between psycho and queendom
@@iii9591so true i was dying
@@iii9591well we had monster, like water, and hello so we were fed a bit 😭 (coming from a reveluv since 2019)
@@nveeously yea i can tell youre a 2019 luvie😭 you dont know how YUMMY it was being a reveluv back then during their first years, even if sm was always shitty they were better w the vlogs and vlives💔i cant complain ig bc this happens to every sm group when they debut another one
Considering the fact Wendy and Seulgi get a lot of ad-libs, I think this line distribution is pretty fair 👍🏽
It’s also very fair considering their positions and the fact that everyone has been first and last at least once
Joy doesn't sing lots of adlibs and long phrases. Still got 3500.
I mean, it’s the definition of a perfect distribution based on vocal talent. What more can be said? It’s exactly how it should be in a vocal heavy group.
Plus with all the joint choruses they sing, Yeri and Irene are still singing a lot during the songs anyway, so it’s not like in other groups where all you have is their solo lines.
What you said it's true, but still, it could be better
@@jeffersongarcia_ I don’t believe it needs to be. Their songs are consistently sang well and no member is being used beyond their capabilities. An equal distribution shouldn’t be the goal, that just ignores differences in ability.
@@Lewis-hl9qw well, in Red Velvet there's a big gap in vocals abilities. Wendy is a great vocalist and yeri is just decent
@iloveminjeong01 you think RV is SNSD or what? You can literally hear Yeri's voice in the choruses and wherever they sing together. Even in the recording behind videos you can see Irene and Yeri record the chorus parts, double for those parts in higher and lower keys, etc. Either you don't know better or you're basing it off of big groups like SNSD.
@iloveminjeong01 not really, u can clearly hear irene voice in rv choruses. yeri also did a lot of harmonizations
1000 seconds:
Wendy ~ 2:14
Seulgi ~ 2:56
Joy ~ 3:32
Irene ~ 5:47
Yeri ~ 7:05
I love all members so much, but I really think Irene and Yeri should get more lines
um no
Shouldn’t better singers sing more lines?
@@zanek6358irene, Wendy, Seulgi & Joy yes. Yeri No.
Average Line Distribution per song
Wendy: 40.3 | 29% (-0.2%)
Seulgi: 33 | 23.8% (-0.1%)
Joy: 28.6 | 20.6% (+0.1%)
Irene: 19.9 | 14.3%
Yeri: 17.1 | 12.3% (+0.2%)
Variation: 34.2% (-0.7%)
how you did this?
@@peterr7447 First, for each member, you have to calculate the number of seconds divided by the number of songs they participated. Then, you put in all of the inputs inside a circle graph. That’s how you get the percentages for the average line distribution. If you want to know about the variation, you find a standard deviation calculator and input all of their percentages. Afterwards you divide the standard deviation given to you divided by the mean, which is all of the percentages combined divided by the number of members there are.
@@peterr7447 I’m sorry if this took so long to reply to you. When I try to explain this to someone, my reply becomes hidden (Sometimes, until the viewer look at all the comments form newest first).
@philip0w0hoang Thank you so much, I tried to ask this to so many people and you are the only one who replied
Thank you ❤️
If you could next time, add 4 more songs - Milky way, see the stars, future and another OST whose name was in Korean. It would complete their group discography.
But thank you so much for including "I will leave" and "close to me remix". People always forget those great songs. 😇
It will look better if you count when they sing together in the line distribution too. Because when you see Yeri or Irene sing 20 seconds in the song, it does not mean they sing only 20 seconds; they sing more than that in the chorus together. Not to mention that for many songs, Yeri, Irene, Joy are ones who carry the chorus becasue Wendy and Seulgi are busy with adlib, high-note, and others.
Even still, they just get more lines, it stays proportional.
I'm actually happy that their discography is well distributed in overall
This line distribution design is very nice and slow!
best discography
울 와니ㅠㅠ🐿🐿
10:27 misheard lyric: f*****g side eye
Wendy soon 5000s 🎉
Slayyyyy ❤
OMG 58 SECS AGO IM GOJNG CRAZY RN AHHHH
Tf
@@lachainedestrucsnulle1211 ?
Can you make red velvet all songs from happiness to cosmic? 🙏
Yeri beeing first more times than Irene is Something Kinda Crazy to me
Yea but Irene being in 2nd place has way more than yeri being in 2nd place
thank you
86 TIMES FIRST? thats wild lmao
Huge vocal difference between wendy and rest of the group, ofc she would be first a lot of times
lol wendy is really the backbone of RV.
Wendy >>>
13:13 What's happening?!
yeri and irene wasnt included in that song, only the three sang it so they were skipped
I am from Pakistan but i like all you
124 songs
1000
Wendy
seulgi
joy
lrene
yeri
Someday hope to see NCT 127 and WayV all songs line distribution 😭😭😭
Where is psycho
wdym irene was the last in candy
wendy❤❤❤❤❤
future?
Every member owns one place
💙: 1st
💛: 2nd
💚: 3rd
💖: 4th
💜: 5th
will i ever se you again is wrong and zoom too
Atleast Main Vocalist is on top 🎉
Not u again
@@chae.vibess then?
i don't get why y'all don't include yeri in happiness and be natural? they already have versions of it with her and it's been 8 years, she should be included in these
Well it wasn't released like officially i think
These line distributions are only for studio versions which they haven't re-recorded with Yeri. Yeri has only performed those songs on live stages and concerts, those aren't official studio versions.
Those songs should be protected as ot4 not ot5. But I love yeri ❤️
BECAUSE RES VELVET IS OT4!!!!!!!!
@@WomensIconnYou are blind there are 5 in red velvet before in the be natural era there were 4 now there are 5 Irene, Seulgi, Wendy, Joy and Yeri are 5
irene is not last in will i ever see you again
Seulgi is first in RBB, so wtf
Now do EXO songs please
no joy in would u😢😢😢
Yeah because her filming drama, it's sm station song
She couldn't give the time to record it for being busy in her kdrama shooting.
i know. joy is my bias in rv and would u is one of my fave. hoping for ot5 version
when u know all their songs
if irene n yeri was chinese, then toxic stans will say sm mistreat chinese
wendy29134
Wendy lost so many lines in the zimzalabim - psycho era. She should have more lines that time !! 🤬
must be bc im a baetokki but irene being fifth is so weird to me😭i always remember her lines the most!!
Irene is fourth
one kiss is wrong scenary is wrong
It took Wendy 4 years to surpass 3000 seconds despite being the main vocalist of a 5 member group.
Then Dayeon from Kep1er surpassed that amount in less than 1 year, and she doesn't have any vocal or rap position.
stop dragging other idols lol
@@___6.20ndayeon didn't even surpass 700 seconds(this is for the comment writer not you, sorry)
Lol dayeon 3000 seconds? 😂😂😂😂😂 joking
She doesn't even have 700 seconds LMAO
don't ever speak on DAYEON of Kep1er.
considering they are only a 5 member group... this is pretty bad
Have you considered the fact that they are a vocal based group and the lines are fitting for vocal skills? I'm not too big a fan of this distribution, yeri and Irene could've gotten a little more, but it makes sense.
its still terrible. could be much better...@@gamerxarmymultistan
@rdpa4019 its not terrible, it's okay. Could be better definitely but it's not terrible. Good line distribution ≠ equal lines.
I don't think it's that bad. We are so used in 4th gen groups that have equal lines. This is fair for me tho.
@@coziamsaltysweeeeet so sur because 4gen has better distributions it excuses the other gens to have shitty ones?
Good for yeri.. she doesn't need to sing alot.. queen maknae
Exactly. She should stay in catering
LIke yeah its awful but I am sure if we take out the insane adlibs the lines are not as bad.
Why are people so obsessed with taking out adlibs?
@@Iris-ls5bg I don't want to take them out, just point out, the members probably received similar size parts when it comes to actual lines. Adlibs are often improvised or done on the spot. It was for the people that were complaining about the distribution. So there is no unfairness happening, truly just adlibs.
Irene needs more lines because she’s leader
Stop mistreating leaders of groups!
No ❤
She deserved the “sub vocal” position
@@WomensIconnStop hating Red Velvet, they did nothing wrong to you
I don't understand what the leader's position has to do with line distribution ?
it took 12 releases for Irene to get a first and Yeri 16 releases to get a first 🥲
Edit: And the fact that Yeri only has 2 firsts while Irene has 1 first
Edit 2: Out of 127 songs...
Wendy has 69.4% of the first places, Seulgi at 15.3%, Joy at 12.9%, Yeri at 1.6%, and Irene at a 0.8%
Seulgi has 53.6% of the second places, Wendy+Joy at 19.2%, Irene at 7.2%, and Yeri at 0.8%
Joy has 58.6% of the third places, Seulgi at 24.1%, Wendy at 9.5%, Yeri at 5.2%, and Irene at 2.6%
Irene has 57.3% of the fourth places, Yeri at 28.2%, Joy at 8.1%, Seulgi at 4.8%, and Wendy at 1.6%
Yeri has 66.4% of the last places, Irene at 25%, Joy at 4.3%, Seulgi at 3.4%, and Wendy at 0.8%
Yeri doesn’t even have half as much lines as wendy has 😭💀
Vocal yeri was awful.
@@WomensIconn no
Wendy being last only in 9 song in 9 literal years is WILD.
bc she's the main vocalist
Not really wild considering her position and skills.
its quite literally the opposite of wild...maybe open a dictionary lmaoo she's the main vocalist i dont see people complaining why wendy doesnt get center position or main dance position or screentime in other videos but people always want to complain about line distribution when wendy is THEE main vocal and the girls have said themself that no one compares
She was last in 1 song according to this