Brothers and Sisters! Don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah! Support Me and The Channel: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern
Akhi, I think you need a notebook on hand. When guys like him comes with these silly notions you should show him your book and have in it that he is a goat, so because it's in a book then he must believe it
⚠ Being a MUSLIM does NOT mean one will go straight to PARADISE Those MUSLIMS who have REPENTED for their SINS and die in the state of following GOD'S commandments will go straight into PARADISE Every MUSLIM who dies in the state of NOT following GOD'S commandments will most likely get punished for their disobedience by getting thrown into HELL, until they have paid the price of their disobedience and then put into PARADISE forever ONLY those who believe in ONE God ( MUSLIMS ) will enter PARADISE Those who worship IDOLS or JESUS will enter HELL forever ( Just imagine how the ONE true GOD who created us will be feeling after seeing people worshipping IDOLS or JESUS instead of him )
kuzzie they know their books r mashed up their own scholars confirm this. the reason they try to find faults with ours (even tho there are none) is because of pure jealousy and hate...
@@regidon6816 although I’m sure some people feel this way. I think a vast majority are just afraid of realizing there whole life was a lie. And it can be uncomfortable to realize they have been indoctrinated into a lie
He's insincere and very close minded to me at least. He admitted he's wrong just so that other people take him as an honest person while he's not in reality, he's a hypocrite. May Allah guide him
@@NR12345-x I have to agree. I try to give people the benefit of doubt, and generally do for vast majority of people who appear on brother Muhammed's videos. But in order for anyone to be sincere they have to first let go of their ego. The Dr but not a doctor failed to do so throughout. His whole argumentative premise was flawed, from how he researched and formed his opinion to how he presented it in this video. And I'm not even talking about the facts, before brother Muhammed asked what he knew of how the Quran was put together the dr assumed what he knew was factual despite clearly not checking or confirming with a learned person. That's not sincere, that's arrogance. He also said he prefers written words instead of the spoken words of someone else. How does he know the written words are correct? In the case of the tafsir if what brother Muhammed said is correct, then the abridged tafsir is the interpretation of an interpretation. How is that better than brother Muhammed verbally telling him the primary sources? And when confronted with the flaws in his methods he shifted the blame to the Quran being in Arabic. Not a single moment did I see an ounce of sincerity in this man. His mind is already made up, and he took an easy out when brother Muhammed rightfully ended the conversation when it was apparent it's pointless to speak to someone who isn't willing to learn. My two cents anyway. Always willing to be proven wrong.
he seems like a good guy, but ego is not easy to let go especially when you were fed a lie your whole life, hopefully he will get past this denial phase
True, it can't be easy to let go of what you were told your entire life, however he was inconsistent. He said he doesn't trust people, but it was people who wrote the bible, yet still he can't seem to let go of it.
I think it was just German people being very blunt, direct and his accent was a little harsh, so brother Ali thought he was being rude. A cultural barrier I feel.
@momonasri8611 I don't agree with you. This guy was 100% opened to learn and was asking genuine questions. I don't see how he was cocky at the end. I just felt that the brother Muhammad Ali just brushed out completely all what he brought after his research as not completely true. And that's not fair even if it contains some inconsistencies. He should rather be more gentle and generous and say some of what you said are true and most of it are wrong. Better than saying everything is wrong when we all know that what the guy said about the history of the Quran was not completely false. Assalamu alaykoum
@@mohamedbakoussakoma2993 Actually what he said was simply wrong and if he had gone and watched the video Muhammad mentioned and then researched he would find it obvious rather than just arguing by saying I know what I have read and why Allah don't make it easier even before researching after watching the video he was given but just assuming things and waste time while in the reality Allah made it easier to him when he made people like Muhammad Ali and many others do streams like this and talk to people And it was obvious Muhammad mentioned the video to not waste time in thing he has said over and over before and if he has taken what he told he would be able to ask the other question about morality and after doing his research he could ask again if he had problems.
I felt that the German gentleman did raise some valid questions and I believed him to be sincere and I pray to Allah to guide him to the truth, but unfortunately I think brother Ali came across as condescending and somewhat patronizing. This conversation could have been conducted with much more finesse.
with all due respect to all of you guys I think it´s pretty easy sitting there and making judgements about behavior and intentions of people tackling fundamental topics. I saw our German friend being ignorant about a lot of important issues and brother M.A. being very direct and respectful. Even when the "Dr." had emotional responses he never got arrogant or disrespectful imo. May allah swt give him Hidaya and keep our intentions clean
Finally people from Germany seek guidance. Dawah here is dead I have not seen Dawah tables in my region of Baden-Württemberg for months and the Masjid in my city has 7-10 people show up only for Asr prayer and Maghrib if lucky 15 people. German Dawah needs to get pushed or we will keep having empty Masjids and more and more liberal Muslims. Apparently I am in the top 5 Islam channels in Germany with only mere 64 000 subscribers that is how dead the Dawah scene in Germany is. May Allah guide more Germans to Islam. Ameen.
Currently he didn't seem honest. When given the answer, he refused to accept it. May he overcome his ego. At first the way he spoke seemed like he wanted to know the truth. As we go further in, we see him having an agenda to disprove Islam.
@@syad911 He was honest - Mohammed unfortunately took a very antagonistic stance instead of correcting him gently ("EVERYTHING YOU SAID WAS FACTUALLY WRONG") - it wasnt all wrong. He said that Umar collected the Quran and then burnt the rest - he's right about the act, not the person (Uthman did that not Omar). When Mohammed told him he's wrong about it even I who was a Muslim was like what??? Just correct him properly and say it was Uthman not Umar and give the reason why.
He cannot be honest because he's saying ibn katheer said false things about the preservation of the Quran. He twists true information to make it seem that that very information that is proof of the preservation to be the proof of its corruption.
Please do your research Dr. Hamburg. But don’t forget it is all a learning process. Keep up your good work. And don’t forget to ask god to guide you. All love and respect. -Muslim
@@dr.truthhamburg5082 Yeah, Ich war heute gerade erst bei deinem Gespräch mit Ali dabei. Was ist war den los, dass du wieder die Geschichte mit Erz-Engel Gabriel rausholst, war doch schon geklärt oder was genau war denn dein Anliegen/Sorge?
“I am skeptical about anything that is written down” Two mins later… “I read it in a book” - it is not the eyes that are blind but the heart. May Allah open his heart to Islam.
The level of self-control of this Muslim man is truly incredible. If I were in his place, I would immediately lose my temper, but he remained respectful and patient until the end and tried as much as possible not to make him feel insulted. May Allah bless him ❤❤❤
The problem with xians for the most, is that they do not use context, hermanuetics, or exegisis for how they come to any conclusion. They are again for the most, triggered if questioned about why they believe what they believe. In churches (if they even have a bible study) questions are not allowed, or in other words, questions are severley discouraged). Blind faith.
That is what separates Islam with other religions. Our religion has in depth discussions and has structure for everything when it comes to the Quran and Hadiths.... And we have tens of thousands of verses and hadiths, only. Not including other sciences related to those 2 core sources of Islamic knowledge.
The first word in the first verse that Allah revealed to Muhammad, peace be upon him, was “Read.” Surah Al Alaq Meaning that all of us should read, research, and think before believing in any faith! If you have unanswered questions keep searching until you find the truth!
“O Allah, I take refuge in You from anxiety and sorrow, weakness and laziness, miserliness and cowardice, the burden of debts and from being overpowered by men.” (Al-Bukhari)
the guy looked sincere.. in the end i waited for him to drop all the act as i thought he might be like that "hafiz" guy, who claimed being hafiz.. it bound to happen.. he will end up muslim in sha allah, last few minutes gave me the feeliing that he is sincere but were actually struggling due to language
Dr. Hamburg seems like a genuine person. May Allah guide him to Islam. As a revert I understand where he is coming from with his queries. That’s why it’s important to deal with these type of people with patience. MashaAllah bro Muhammad did a good job. جَزاكَ اللهُ خَيْراً
Thank you Muhammad for running this channel may allah protect you. And thanks to dr. Hamburg for coming with such questions and all those who sincerely come with questions.. may allah guide all...these dailogs and this channel has truly helped me as a muslim also ... subhanallah ,Allah helps people from sources that they can't even imagine.
Salaam Alykum brothers and sisters. Pls don't forget to say du'as for our brothers and sisters in Gaza, Sudan, Syria, Yeman and everywhere. May unite the muslim Ummah, May Allah bless and protect our muslim brothers and sisters aamen. My heart aches for the suffering of our brothers and sisters in War zones :-( Ya Rab forgive us all aameen. Thank you brother Mohamed for spreading the deen. May Allah reward you and keep u in the right path aameen.
I am very happy to see this kind of discussion. That's why I am not really into debate or shouting like how in speaker's corner. This is how civilised people talk and discuss. There are tensions, but we deal it in a good manner. The whole point is to figure out truth.
I would love to see the next conversation with Dr. Hamburg, he seems really sincere in his search of the Truth. I really enjoyed it. May God help him in his search. Jazaka Allahu kheir.
In the day of judgement we responsible for what we do, our job is only spread the message not convince people, but for some reason some people come and like " try convince me!, "I don't believe what you say!" "Thats not true!", "I know the truth!" Like brother whatt?? Its like they dare us to convince them. In fact we dont even get any benefit if somebody believe or not thats your choice and for your own benefit. May allah guide us all
Honest inquiry. May Allah guide him because he seemed sincere. Brother should have explained the ibn Katheer text he was referring to. He would have accepted the reasons why the Quran dialect was chosen. Inshallah next time. JazakAllakhair brother Mohamed.
This "Dr" was very reasonable person I really would like him join the conversation with The Muslim lantern onece more time and that he will be given more time, very good discussion, thank you both!
Dr.Hamburg i don’t know if you’re gonna read my comment but you are on the right path as long as you keep your mind opened you will one day become one of us Insha Allah
He was a great guy, looks like he wants to sincerely learn but we all have barriers especially when confronted with change , may Allah guide him to the right path.
Something that I heard recently really stuck with me regarding the argument about if the Quran or Bible are preserved. Many denomination of Christianity have different bibles with different combinations or the books. But even the different sects of Islam read from the same exact Quran with 114 surah.
13:32 Nothing can convince such line of reasoning. Everything become subjective. It is truly important to establish what someone believes as evidence and what do they deem as truth.
I'm 39 I accept Islam 36 before I was Baptist in the seventh day Adventist church went to a catholic high school with all of dat I came to know dat Islam is the truth
I feel alot of these things are like WHATS THIS IN MY HAND? ,while holding a bottle of water and the guest answers"THAT'S WATER" and then the brother goes "THAT IS A WRONG STATEMENT THIS IS ACTUALLY H20 AND THIS IS THE PROBLEM WITH PEOPLE WHO MISUNDERSTAND..." alot more could have been spoken and answered probably even opened his understanding of islam hence you can see the irritation in the guest's response.
Seems like a fair minded guy, he is already way ahead of the curve since he is at least trying to read the Quran and Tafsir, answering questions and intending to keep reading. Glad he will investigate thoroughly and not just take a word at face value. Insha'Allah brother will be guided to the Haqq
Akhi mohammad Do you think u can make a video explaing the seven ahruf and what they are exactly? Ive seen of them, and some changes end up changing words and meaning of sentences. I really would like to have an explanation to this is it is sitting uneasily on my heart God bless you
For some reason the guy thought you are questioning his intelligence when you were just questioning and correcting the "sources" that he claims he read and pointing out that it's not reliable ! Everyone comes with their own package indeed .
Salam there brother Mohammad, anytime ppl said they read something from quran or hadith sahih or wherever, I would suggest that they bring the material. In that case, we really know that is what we refering to. Which verse, which page, etc. Coz in ibn kathir he also explain the wrong things and at the end, he mentiond the hadith was daif or mawdhu
Deutschland auch.. viele aus Deutschland haben denselben Akzent wenn sie Englisch Sprechen... May Allah bless you brother The prophet's and people in bible who had context with angels and the lord... No different to the reaction of the prophet Muhammad (saws)... Daniel's Encounter with an Angel 10:7-9: "I, Daniel, was the only one who saw the vision; those who were with me did not see it, but such terror overwhelmed them that they fled and hid themselves. So I was left alone, gazing at this great vision; I had no strength left, my face turned deathly pale and I was helpless. Then I heard him speaking, and as I listened to him, I fell into a deep sleep, my face to the ground." Also Isaiah's initial reaction was one of fear and a profound sense of unworthiness. Till they all had different time to calm down but daniels encounter was... wow... 1 Overwhelming Terror: Daniel's vision was so terrifying that those with him, although they did not see the vision, were overwhelmed with fear and fled to hide. This reaction underscores the sheer intensity of the divine encounter. 2 Physical Impact: The vision left Daniel physically incapacitated: his strength drained away, his face turned pale, and he fell into a deep sleep with his face to the ground. This level of physical reaction highlights the extraordinary fear and awe induced by the encounter. 3 Isolation and Helplessness: Daniel was left alone and helpless, which further intensified his fear. The sense of isolation in the presence of such a powerful vision added to the overall dread and helplessness he felt. I've sometimes heard Christians say that they were amazed at the reaction of the Prophet (saws)... among them there were often people who said that they had read the Bible and then said: "In contrast to Muhammad, is the meeting with God or an angel, something that immediately brought peace to the prophet and not like Muhammad." Then I knew that they had never read the Bible, only heard it from others. Very, very, very many had fear, anxiety and even terror fear afterwards from Jeremiah, Zechariah etc. Often also by those who deny that Abraham, David, etc. were prophets, even though that is clearly stated in the Bible.
This guy man ! I Will trust scripture but not people .. 😅 . And your trust issues its not a islamic problem its your personal problem . May allah guide us all . Ameen
Brothers and Sisters! Don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah!
Support Me and The Channel:
www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY
www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern
Can you link your video re: compilation of the Quran here or description please?
Akhi, I think you need a notebook on hand. When guys like him comes with these silly notions you should show him your book and have in it that he is a goat, so because it's in a book then he must believe it
wow....that was simply brilliant really.
⚠ Being a MUSLIM does NOT mean one will go straight to PARADISE
Those MUSLIMS who have REPENTED for their SINS and die in the state of following GOD'S commandments will go straight into PARADISE
Every MUSLIM who dies in the state of NOT following GOD'S commandments will most likely get punished for their disobedience by getting thrown into HELL, until they have paid the price of their disobedience and then put into PARADISE forever
ONLY those who believe in ONE God ( MUSLIMS ) will enter PARADISE
Those who worship IDOLS or JESUS will enter HELL forever ( Just imagine how the ONE true GOD who created us will be feeling after seeing people worshipping IDOLS or JESUS instead of him )
Love your work
It’s fair to question the Qurans preservation. But before Questioning the Qurans preservation, question your own faiths book first.
According to the Quran, our book is very well preserved.
And who cares if quran preserved or not ? It's a satanic book anyways
kuzzie they know their books r mashed up their own scholars confirm this. the reason they try to find faults with ours (even tho there are none) is because of pure jealousy and hate...
@@regidon6816 صدقت يا اخي جزاك الله خير
@@regidon6816 although I’m sure some people feel this way. I think a vast majority are just afraid of realizing there whole life was a lie. And it can be uncomfortable to realize they have been indoctrinated into a lie
I don't like this method of comparison. I don't think it leads to objective evidence
To admit being wrong in his approach at the end is a very brave thing to do. I Hope he keeps researching. May god guide him to the right path.
And Think about what? God give place to some of the people in Muslim family's and sends some into the disbelievers. 🙂
He's insincere and very close minded to me at least. He admitted he's wrong just so that other people take him as an honest person while he's not in reality, he's a hypocrite. May Allah guide him
@@NR12345-xdo not assume wrong of people, this man is not completely fluent in English and therefore may lead to certain misunderstanding
Aameen
@@NR12345-x I have to agree. I try to give people the benefit of doubt, and generally do for vast majority of people who appear on brother Muhammed's videos. But in order for anyone to be sincere they have to first let go of their ego. The Dr but not a doctor failed to do so throughout.
His whole argumentative premise was flawed, from how he researched and formed his opinion to how he presented it in this video. And I'm not even talking about the facts, before brother Muhammed asked what he knew of how the Quran was put together the dr assumed what he knew was factual despite clearly not checking or confirming with a learned person. That's not sincere, that's arrogance.
He also said he prefers written words instead of the spoken words of someone else. How does he know the written words are correct? In the case of the tafsir if what brother Muhammed said is correct, then the abridged tafsir is the interpretation of an interpretation. How is that better than brother Muhammed verbally telling him the primary sources?
And when confronted with the flaws in his methods he shifted the blame to the Quran being in Arabic.
Not a single moment did I see an ounce of sincerity in this man. His mind is already made up, and he took an easy out when brother Muhammed rightfully ended the conversation when it was apparent it's pointless to speak to someone who isn't willing to learn.
My two cents anyway. Always willing to be proven wrong.
as a german I feel dr hamburg his struggle i feel like he wants to be sincere, may God guide him to the truth
He is very interesting Brother from Hamburg may Allah guide him ❤
Ja, ich bin sehr überrascht dass ein deutscher Zuschauer überhaupt erreicht wurde lol..
Yh he seemed nice❤
I WISH HE HAD MET WITH SOMEONE AS SINCERE AS HIMSELF AND NOT THIS LANTERN GUY. WHO IS JUST HERE TO SHOW OFF AS A BIG SHOT AND TO MAKE UA-cam VIEWS.
@@sangeenshahkhanI think your comment doesn’t make sense and it is just egoistic
Muhammad Ali, may Allah preserve you and keep you steadfast on the religion. You’re a true inspiration brother. ❤️
he seems like a good guy, but ego is not easy to let go especially when you were fed a lie your whole life, hopefully he will get past this denial phase
True, it can't be easy to let go of what you were told your entire life, however he was inconsistent. He said he doesn't trust people, but it was people who wrote the bible, yet still he can't seem to let go of it.
He was asking fair questions and when he was corrected on his ignorance he got cocky and arrogant Subhanallah
I think it was just German people being very blunt, direct and his accent was a little harsh, so brother Ali thought he was being rude. A cultural barrier I feel.
@momonasri8611 I don't agree with you. This guy was 100% opened to learn and was asking genuine questions.
I don't see how he was cocky at the end. I just felt that the brother Muhammad Ali just brushed out completely all what he brought after his research as not completely true. And that's not fair even if it contains some inconsistencies.
He should rather be more gentle and generous and say some of what you said are true and most of it are wrong. Better than saying everything is wrong when we all know that what the guy said about the history of the Quran was not completely false.
Assalamu alaykoum
@@mohamedbakoussakoma2993
Actually what he said was simply wrong and if he had gone and watched the video Muhammad mentioned and then researched he would find it obvious rather than just arguing by saying I know what I have read and why Allah don't make it easier even before researching after watching the video he was given but just assuming things and waste time while in the reality Allah made it easier to him when he made people like Muhammad Ali and many others do streams like this and talk to people
And it was obvious Muhammad mentioned the video to not waste time in thing he has said over and over before and if he has taken what he told he would be able to ask the other question about morality and after doing his research he could ask again if he had problems.
I felt that the German gentleman did raise some valid questions and I believed him to be sincere and I pray to Allah to guide him to the truth, but unfortunately I think brother Ali came across as condescending and somewhat patronizing. This conversation could have been conducted with much more finesse.
with all due respect to all of you guys I think it´s pretty easy sitting there and making judgements about behavior and intentions of people tackling fundamental topics. I saw our German friend being ignorant about a lot of important issues and brother M.A. being very direct and respectful. Even when the "Dr." had emotional responses he never got arrogant or disrespectful imo. May allah swt give him Hidaya and keep our intentions clean
Finally people from Germany seek guidance. Dawah here is dead I have not seen Dawah tables in my region of Baden-Württemberg for months and the Masjid in my city has 7-10 people show up only for Asr prayer and Maghrib if lucky 15 people. German Dawah needs to get pushed or we will keep having empty Masjids and more and more liberal Muslims. Apparently I am in the top 5 Islam channels in Germany with only mere 64 000 subscribers that is how dead the Dawah scene in Germany is. May Allah guide more Germans to Islam. Ameen.
Ameeen. Brother 🤲🤲
Take initiative and Allah will grant you support from places you don’t expect.
Start the dawah where you are do not wait for others.
Hier in Frankfurt ist leider auch tot 🙁
Ma-sha-Allah (as God wills)❤ love your channel
To be honest, this guy seemed to be honest. I hope he will enter the next stream in sha Allah
Currently he didn't seem honest. When given the answer, he refused to accept it.
May he overcome his ego.
At first the way he spoke seemed like he wanted to know the truth.
As we go further in, we see him having an agenda to disprove Islam.
did u even watched the full video ? 🤣 he's far from being honest.
@@syad911 He was honest - Mohammed unfortunately took a very antagonistic stance instead of correcting him gently ("EVERYTHING YOU SAID WAS FACTUALLY WRONG") - it wasnt all wrong. He said that Umar collected the Quran and then burnt the rest - he's right about the act, not the person (Uthman did that not Omar). When Mohammed told him he's wrong about it even I who was a Muslim was like what??? Just correct him properly and say it was Uthman not Umar and give the reason why.
He cannot be honest because he's saying ibn katheer said false things about the preservation of the Quran. He twists true information to make it seem that that very information that is proof of the preservation to be the proof of its corruption.
he is beating around the bush. Muhammad is right to do what he did @@mobytrice
الى كل مسلم في العالم انتم اخواني المسلمين الموحدين احبكم في الله
نحبك والله ❤❤❤
أحَبَكَ الله الذي أحببتنا فيه
بارك الله فيك ياأخي، الله يحفظك والمسلمين جميعا!!!
And we love you for the sake of Allah too ❤
Please do your research Dr. Hamburg. But don’t forget it is all a learning process. Keep up your good work. And don’t forget to ask god to guide you. All love and respect. -Muslim
I will call again
@@dr.truthhamburg5082 Yeah, Ich war heute gerade erst bei deinem Gespräch mit Ali dabei. Was ist war den los, dass du wieder die Geschichte mit Erz-Engel Gabriel rausholst, war doch schon geklärt oder was genau war denn dein Anliegen/Sorge?
@@dr.truthhamburg5082 und was willst du noch wissen?
@@dr.truthhamburg5082May God bless you brother and guide us all - you look like an honest man
“I am skeptical about anything that is written down”
Two mins later…
“I read it in a book” - it is not the eyes that are blind but the heart. May Allah open his heart to Islam.
And not just a book. JUST a book. Didn't even bother cross referencing with other texts.
If you read this;
Say "SubhanAllah" 33x
Say "Alhamdulillah" 33x
Say "Allahu akbar" 34x
May Allah reward you.
And you too. amin
So much respect for your patience, perseverance and knowledge brother Mohamed Ali.. Allahumma barik 🤲🏻
The level of self-control of this Muslim man is truly incredible. If I were in his place, I would immediately lose my temper, but he remained respectful and patient until the end and tried as much as possible not to make him feel insulted. May Allah bless him ❤❤❤
May Allah guide us all
The problem with xians for the most, is that they do not use context, hermanuetics, or exegisis for how they come to any conclusion. They are again for the most, triggered if questioned about why they believe what they believe. In churches (if they even have a bible study) questions are not allowed, or in other words, questions are severley discouraged). Blind faith.
That is what separates Islam with other religions. Our religion has in depth discussions and has structure for everything when it comes to the Quran and Hadiths.... And we have tens of thousands of verses and hadiths, only. Not including other sciences related to those 2 core sources of Islamic knowledge.
The first word in the first verse that Allah revealed to Muhammad, peace be upon him, was “Read.” Surah Al Alaq
Meaning that all of us should read, research, and think before believing in any faith!
If you have unanswered questions keep searching until you find the truth!
@@youssefgamal6560 something my mother stated many times. "Question everything. Do not allow anyone to ""brain wash"" you". Inshallah
Nah bro they just hypocrite at this point, truths seeker even from Christianity background will agree so many thing with quran
@@kwamegordon1448 don’t put words in our mouths lol
Go research before you talk
The only religion that tells you think before you believe is Islam
“O Allah, I take refuge in You from anxiety and sorrow, weakness and laziness, miserliness and cowardice, the burden of debts and from being overpowered by men.” (Al-Bukhari)
Brother Muhammad Ali is a gem. He is so intelligent may Allah reward him
Barakallahu feekum. May allah protect him from evil eyes
aminnnnn
may Allah bless you Mohamed Ali. I love ur channel
JazakAllah'u khairan brother 🇵🇸🤲🏻
the final conclusion is spot on,
I love how he gives the questioner time to ask without interrupting until he gets his question across. very respectful
May Allah guide him to Islam
jazakallah khayr brother ali
the guy looked sincere.. in the end i waited for him to drop all the act as i thought he might be like that "hafiz" guy, who claimed being hafiz..
it bound to happen.. he will end up muslim in sha allah, last few minutes gave me the feeliing that he is sincere but were actually struggling due to language
Dr. Hamburg seems like a genuine person. May Allah guide him to Islam. As a revert I understand where he is coming from with his queries. That’s why it’s important to deal with these type of people with patience. MashaAllah bro Muhammad did a good job. جَزاكَ اللهُ خَيْراً
He said he don't know much English but I can see he perfectly speak English with good accent
MasyaAllah
Well said brother Muhammad
Jazakallah Khair
Thank you Muhammad for running this channel may allah protect you. And thanks to dr. Hamburg for coming with such questions and all those who sincerely come with questions.. may allah guide all...these dailogs and this channel has truly helped me as a muslim also ... subhanallah ,Allah helps people from sources that they can't even imagine.
Thanks
Salaam Alykum brothers and sisters. Pls don't forget to say du'as for our brothers and sisters in Gaza, Sudan, Syria, Yeman and everywhere. May unite the muslim Ummah, May Allah bless and protect our muslim brothers and sisters aamen. My heart aches for the suffering of our brothers and sisters in War zones :-( Ya Rab forgive us all aameen. Thank you brother Mohamed for spreading the deen. May Allah reward you and keep u in the right path aameen.
JazakAllahu khair❤
جزاكم الله خيرا brother Ali and team
I am very happy to see this kind of discussion. That's why I am not really into debate or shouting like how in speaker's corner. This is how civilised people talk and discuss. There are tensions, but we deal it in a good manner. The whole point is to figure out truth.
الحمد لله على نعمة الاسلام العظيم و بارك الله فيك اخونا علي
إنَّ هَذِهِ الْقُلُوبَ أَوْعِيَةٌ فَاشْغَلُوهَا بِالْقُرْآنِ ، وَلا تَشْغَلُوهَا بِغَيْرِهِ.
I would love to see the next conversation with Dr. Hamburg, he seems really sincere in his search of the Truth. I really enjoyed it. May God help him in his search. Jazaka Allahu kheir.
May Allah bless you Brother mohamed
Alhamdulilah for everything
Dr. Hamburg very respectful he seems genuine and doing his own research may Allah guide him to the truth 🤲
I like how respectful he is
.. respectful?...lol .. did u watch beyond the first 5 mins?... as soon as he's challenged the typical xtian attitude becomes apparent.
@@Total_Entropy36am talking about Muhammad i like how smart and respectful he is , and keeep things rational and make sens
@@Total_Entropy36 well at least he listened without interrupting in contrast to many islamophobes who just screams and screams
@@Total_Entropy36also the other guy was respectful too not same but understand , its a debate about faith, and he did way better than some rude ppl
He said his English being not so good. I thought he was being dishonest from the get go.
Edit: I thought you meant the guest.
In the day of judgement we responsible for what we do, our job is only spread the message not convince people, but for some reason some people come and like " try convince me!, "I don't believe what you say!" "Thats not true!", "I know the truth!" Like brother whatt?? Its like they dare us to convince them. In fact we dont even get any benefit if somebody believe or not thats your choice and for your own benefit. May allah guide us all
"The History Of The Quranic Text| A Breakdown From Revelation To Compilation"..........this is reminding me of the next parts inchaAllah
May God guide us all. el hamde li Allah on the blessing of Islam.
Leaving comment for the algorithm.
السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته
Honest inquiry. May Allah guide him because he seemed sincere. Brother should have explained the ibn Katheer text he was referring to. He would have accepted the reasons why the Quran dialect was chosen. Inshallah next time. JazakAllakhair brother Mohamed.
Jazak Allahu Khair brother ❤
As-salamalaikum akhi. May Allah bless you
Jazak allah khyrain
جزاكم الله خيرا
جزاك الله خيراً يا محمد
Jazakallah Khayrun
Your facial reactions are the best, speaks so many words.
May Allah bless you
Masha Allah brother Mohamed Ali Allah give you long life insha Allah we love you for the sake of Allah
May Allah Sobhano guide Dr.Hamburg and open his heart to the truth. Ameen
"Seek first to understand than to be understood.“
JazakAllahu khair barakAllah feek
This "Dr" was very reasonable person I really would like him join the conversation with The Muslim lantern onece more time and that he will be given more time, very good discussion, thank you both!
Language is the key to open the heart of people. Sheikh Ahmed deedat may God mercy on him
Thank you, *Brother Muhammed Ali* ♥️♥️♥️♥️
اللَّهُمَّ إِنِّى أَسْأَلُكَ بِأَنِّى أَشْهَدُ أَنَّكَ أَنْتَ اللَّهُ لاَ إِلَهَ إِلاَّ أَنْتَ الأَحَدُ الصَّمَدُ الَّذِى لَمْ يَلِدْ وَلَمْ يُولَدْ وَلَمْ يَكُنْ لَهُ كُفُوًا أَحَدٌ
اللَّهُمَّ إِنِّى أَسْأَلُكَ بِأَنَّ لَكَ الْحَمْدَ لاَ إِلَهَ إِلاَّ أَنْتَ الْمَنَّانُ بَدِيعُ السَّمَوَاتِ وَالأَرْضِ يَا ذَا الْجَلاَلِ وَالإِكْرَامِ يَا حَىُّ يَا قَيُّومُ
" _O Allah, give guidance to all not yet Muslim and let them embrace Islam_ ” • *Zonnorain* ♥️
آمين يا رب العالمين ▪️
♥️🇵🇸 FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸♥️
جزاكم الله خيرا • بارك الله فيكم ♥️
Brother Ali did not provide a satisfactory answer this time. The man seems genuine and came with genuine questions but left without getting anything.
I’m a black American and I learned the Arabic.
It was a good conversation
May Allah guides us to the truth
An honest and humble man. May Allah guide him.
Thank you for youre Videos Ali❤️🇨🇭
Masha'Allah TabarakAllah
I like this man. He is respectful and sincere
Dr.Hamburg i don’t know if you’re gonna read my comment but you are on the right path as long as you keep your mind opened you will one day become one of us Insha Allah
Ma Sha Allah
He was a great guy, looks like he wants to sincerely learn but we all have barriers especially when confronted with change , may Allah guide him to the right path.
Something that I heard recently really stuck with me regarding the argument about if the Quran or Bible are preserved.
Many denomination of Christianity have different bibles with different combinations or the books. But even the different sects of Islam read from the same exact Quran with 114 surah.
May Allah guide us All.. Ameen
Great Dawah brother
When people say they are open-minded, i can't help but be skeptical
Masallah my brothers and sisters ❤
13:32 Nothing can convince such line of reasoning. Everything become subjective. It is truly important to establish what someone believes as evidence and what do they deem as truth.
I'm 39 I accept Islam 36 before I was Baptist in the seventh day Adventist church went to a catholic high school with all of dat I came to know dat Islam is the truth
Alhamdulillah
I feel alot of these things are like WHATS THIS IN MY HAND? ,while holding a bottle of water and the guest answers"THAT'S WATER" and then the brother goes "THAT IS A WRONG STATEMENT THIS IS ACTUALLY H20 AND THIS IS THE PROBLEM WITH PEOPLE WHO MISUNDERSTAND..." alot more could have been spoken and answered probably even opened his understanding of islam hence you can see the irritation in the guest's response.
I love how he humbly and respectfully puts them in check 😅
Alhamdulillah for Islam
الله اكبر والعزة لله
Seems like a fair minded guy, he is already way ahead of the curve since he is at least trying to read the Quran and Tafsir, answering questions and intending to keep reading. Glad he will investigate thoroughly and not just take a word at face value. Insha'Allah brother will be guided to the Haqq
Akhi mohammad
Do you think u can make a video explaing the seven ahruf and what they are exactly? Ive seen of them, and some changes end up changing words and meaning of sentences. I really would like to have an explanation to this is it is sitting uneasily on my heart
God bless you
الحمد لله على نعمة الإسلام
He sounds sincere may Allah guide him to the truth. Amiin
😵😵😵 May Allah guide him and make it easy for him to understand 🤲
May Allah (God) guide Dr.Hamburg❤
For some reason the guy thought you are questioning his intelligence when you were just questioning and correcting the "sources" that he claims he read and pointing out that it's not reliable !
Everyone comes with their own package indeed .
Damn.. you were brulatty honest in the end...to the cheeky Christian...!!! 😅😅👍
Angels are created from light (Nur) while the devils were created from smokeless fire. Christianity is severely lacking in all respects
Salam there brother Mohammad, anytime ppl said they read something from quran or hadith sahih or wherever, I would suggest that they bring the material. In that case, we really know that is what we refering to. Which verse, which page, etc. Coz in ibn kathir he also explain the wrong things and at the end, he mentiond the hadith was daif or mawdhu
Good work Mohammed, God bless you
Deutschland auch.. viele aus Deutschland haben denselben Akzent wenn sie Englisch Sprechen...
May Allah bless you brother
The prophet's and people in bible who had context with angels and the lord... No different to the reaction of the prophet Muhammad (saws)...
Daniel's Encounter with an Angel
10:7-9:
"I, Daniel, was the only one who saw the vision; those who were with me did not see it, but such terror overwhelmed them that they fled and hid themselves. So I was left alone, gazing at this great vision; I had no strength left, my face turned deathly pale and I was helpless. Then I heard him speaking, and as I listened to him, I fell into a deep sleep, my face to the ground."
Also Isaiah's initial reaction was one of fear and a profound sense of unworthiness. Till they all had different time to calm down but daniels encounter was... wow...
1 Overwhelming Terror:
Daniel's vision was so terrifying that those with him, although they did not see the vision, were overwhelmed with fear and fled to hide. This reaction underscores the sheer intensity of the divine encounter.
2 Physical Impact:
The vision left Daniel physically incapacitated: his strength drained away, his face turned pale, and he fell into a deep sleep with his face to the ground. This level of physical reaction highlights the extraordinary fear and awe induced by the encounter.
3 Isolation and Helplessness:
Daniel was left alone and helpless, which further intensified his fear. The sense of isolation in the presence of such a powerful vision added to the overall dread and helplessness he felt.
I've sometimes heard Christians say that they were amazed at the reaction of the Prophet (saws)... among them there were often people who said that they had read the Bible and then said: "In contrast to Muhammad, is the meeting with God or an angel, something that immediately brought peace to the prophet and not like Muhammad."
Then I knew that they had never read the Bible, only heard it from others. Very, very, very many had fear, anxiety and even terror fear afterwards from Jeremiah, Zechariah etc.
Often also by those who deny that Abraham, David, etc. were prophets, even though that is clearly stated in the Bible.
Baraka ALLAHU fikoum
Bismallah - Ya Allah ❤❤❤❤❤❤
This guy man ! I Will trust scripture but not people .. 😅 . And your trust issues its not a islamic problem its your personal problem . May allah guide us all . Ameen
لا إله إلا الله ❤
I feel like Brother Muhammad Ali could have explained it to him in a much better way, but Allah knows best