Did Dutch Prefer Arthur or John?🤔

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 січ 2025
  • Ever wondered if Dutch van der Linde had a favorite between Arthur Morgan and John Marston? 🤔 Benjamin Byron Davis, the voice behind Dutch, shares his thoughts on the iconic Red Dead Redemption 2 characters.
    #rdr2 #dutchvanderlinde #shorts #gaming #interview
    You can watch the full interview on the Fandom Spotlite channel.

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @thatterrariaguidenpc8054
    @thatterrariaguidenpc8054 7 днів тому +6712

    That answer was the most Dutch answer ever

    • @BigSylvester
      @BigSylvester 6 днів тому +83

      Well, it’s Rockstar. They make sure that the actors become the characters and it shows even years after their projects are finished. The high standards that Rockstar maintains for everything. And then there’s Ubisoft.

    • @ShinoMorales
      @ShinoMorales 6 днів тому +5

      ​@@BigSylvesterat least its not blizzard

    • @boomboom9065
      @boomboom9065 6 днів тому +1

      Not really, Dutch is in love with Micah, and he didn't say it.

    • @BigSylvester
      @BigSylvester 6 днів тому

      @ No.

    • @Ompang09
      @Ompang09 5 днів тому

      I know 😂 He definitely knows his character

  • @idlompekgames1835
    @idlompekgames1835 8 днів тому +6065

    Atleast he didnt say Micah

    • @tytheyoutubeguy8415
      @tytheyoutubeguy8415 8 днів тому +92

      That would've been hilarious.

    • @The-Spanish-Inquisition490
      @The-Spanish-Inquisition490 7 днів тому +86

      He's my favourite.... just because he's played so well. It takes a lot of effort to be that unlikable.

    • @MatthewKiyatkin
      @MatthewKiyatkin 7 днів тому +13

      This is such an underrated comment. I am dieing laughing.

    • @Unsaid86
      @Unsaid86 7 днів тому +14

      Dutch had no care or love for Micah. He only saw the logic Micah was making and agreed with it, there is not even one heartfelt scene between Micah and Dutch like there is with Arthur, Hosea, John or any of the other gang members.
      Doesn’t hate but doesn’t like him either (wouldn’t be surprised if he saw him as no more than a tool or a extra gun)

    • @TheWhooshman
      @TheWhooshman 6 днів тому +4

      I dont think he ever trusted Micah wholeheartedly imo. Micah did just enough to stay around as long as he did.

  • @alfreddavis850
    @alfreddavis850 6 днів тому +2048

    "Arthur only at the end, always doubtin"- dude he KNOWS Dutch i love it!!

    • @LeeRenthlei
      @LeeRenthlei 5 днів тому +52

      Well he is Dutch lol.

    • @4589dude
      @4589dude 5 днів тому +15

      It's almost like he's required to by his job

    • @TraveIIer
      @TraveIIer 5 днів тому +7

      That's because he is Dutch

    • @capy_corri
      @capy_corri 5 днів тому +18

      Ironically there's a lot of actors out there who actually don't remember a thing about their own characters after they are done with the project

    • @lucasbrown2656
      @lucasbrown2656 4 дні тому +2

      @@4589dudewell Steven Ogg doesn’t know shit about Trevor and for some reason hates it. So no, it isn’t really required by their job to really dive deep and enjoy their blessing of a job. It’s actually quite awesome to see the RDR cast enjoy their lives and their work.

  • @airborneandrowdy
    @airborneandrowdy 5 днів тому +505

    My brain: I insist you watch this again.
    Me: Oh, you insist?

  • @AndreRhynes
    @AndreRhynes 7 днів тому +1073

    " HE'S LYING! HE'S LYYYYIIINNG!"

    • @Radu.Mapping
      @Radu.Mapping 4 дні тому +2

      583 likes and no comments???
      Let me fix that❤️

    • @Jotape-h6m
      @Jotape-h6m 4 дні тому +1

      LIAH LIAH YOU LIAH

  • @omega-xk4gj
    @omega-xk4gj 6 днів тому +398

    That snort from Roger is something i can see Arthur doing

  • @AMIRA-99999
    @AMIRA-99999 7 днів тому +2091

    "John is a constant source of disappointment" ☠️

    • @umcaraqualquer3640
      @umcaraqualquer3640 6 днів тому +79

      To be fair, John was the one constantly questioning Dutch since the start, so it makes sense

    • @SoldadoHyliano141
      @SoldadoHyliano141 6 днів тому

      ​@@umcaraqualquer3640True, but he was supposedly the golden boy

    • @analex4044
      @analex4044 6 днів тому +32

      @@umcaraqualquer3640and he also left before the game started

    • @Owen2108
      @Owen2108 5 днів тому

      @@analex4044 That was in fact the second time he left his wife and kid. Instead of for a year this time though, he went to have a boxing match with Timber Wolves for the weekend.

    • @kal-eldritch
      @kal-eldritch 4 дні тому

      ​@@umcaraqualquer3640That's not true, Dutch explicitly states Arthur has been doubting his moves for a while from the beginning of the game, imploring him to have faith. It's Arthur who has to tell John in Chapter 2 that their way of life is dying, and they likely will too.

  • @SamLaGrange
    @SamLaGrange 7 днів тому +798

    Seeing so many of these RDR Voice Actor Clips this makes me really want to play RDR2 again tbh

    • @Silent_princess
      @Silent_princess 7 днів тому +15

      This is the way.

    • @sap9255
      @sap9255 7 днів тому +19

      Do it. I am too. Let's ride brother. One last time.

    • @loadingstars
      @loadingstars 6 днів тому +7

      He is not only a voice actor, he did everything in the character

    • @DylanHart8
      @DylanHart8 6 днів тому +2

      Same but my Xbox is glitched and won’t let me download rdr2 for some reason even though I own the game and have more than enough hard drive space.

    • @Cervidae
      @Cervidae 6 днів тому +2

      he's acted, not just voice acted. they rarely were in the booths.

  • @Skibiditoilet9894
    @Skibiditoilet9894 7 днів тому +115

    Love that he answered in character, was definitely expecting him to say Micah instead of Arthur

    • @Muircetach
      @Muircetach 4 дні тому +5

      Benjamin Byron Davis is an actor's actor. This means that immersion in the character is important enough to him that he has worked out how his character fundamentally thinks, the character's values and how they think of everyone. It's a very holistic approach.
      So it's not even that he's answering in character, it's that he's answering what he knows to be the character's way of thinking, which is pretty charmingly professional.

    • @oui2611
      @oui2611 2 дні тому

      nah, in the end dutch shot micah, he knew micah was a rat and shot him.

  • @ZakFromFunkyCryptidProductions
    @ZakFromFunkyCryptidProductions 6 днів тому +23

    They're all just so happy to fall into their roles for the fans. Love to see it.

  • @bigbadbusta3871
    @bigbadbusta3871 6 днів тому +30

    Clarks scuff at the end lol. That was his Arthur Morgan coming out scoffing at Dutch 😂

  • @johnthcrada
    @johnthcrada 8 днів тому +228

    he gave the best answer 😅

  • @Dro.1971
    @Dro.1971 5 днів тому +15

    “Always doubting” if that ain’t Dutch 😂

  • @Mamuff5
    @Mamuff5 5 днів тому +6

    You can see Arthur's VA so happy with that answer

  • @Hani0240
    @Hani0240 7 днів тому +473

    Why did it feel like the actors are immersed 😂😂
    Look at roger its as if he was arthur hearing ducth speak 😂

    • @ATR1830
      @ATR1830 7 днів тому +24

      Because I believe the filming process of the game took about 4 years. So a lot of these actors had a lot of time to get into character, and they spent a lot of time in character together. They know their characters inside and out and probably have a great attachment to them. So honestly Roger probably at least felt a little of what you’re describing

    • @Hani0240
      @Hani0240 6 днів тому +3

      @@ATR1830 well spoken

  • @MatthewKiyatkin
    @MatthewKiyatkin 7 днів тому +40

    Mine also is by far is Hosea. He is smart, and a good person. Very well written

  • @fredyM-zh6hi
    @fredyM-zh6hi 4 дні тому +18

    top 5 Dutch favorites
    1. himself
    2. money
    3. His Goddamn Plan
    4. Tahiti
    5. Arthur

    • @Tboneman
      @Tboneman День тому +1

      you got to have FAITH

  • @l.a.freeman520
    @l.a.freeman520 6 днів тому +5

    You can hear everyone get sad flashbacks at the end lmao

  • @davyjones5068
    @davyjones5068 5 днів тому +3

    What's make the character great is the actor knows the character like his own personality

  • @Arthurmorgan1887-q9e
    @Arthurmorgan1887-q9e 7 днів тому +34

    Thanks Dutch

  • @benmccumstie7833
    @benmccumstie7833 5 днів тому +2

    You can tell they loved being in this game

  • @Gomezable
    @Gomezable 6 днів тому +10

    Arthur gave you everything he had Dutch! 😢

  • @MichaelBellisnotarat
    @MichaelBellisnotarat 8 днів тому +90

    I thought it was me Dutch

  • @aesopivan
    @aesopivan 6 днів тому +4

    Bros a fucking tank

    • @DieselDrinker45.
      @DieselDrinker45. 4 дні тому

      Yeah he's 6' 5"... imagine if dutch was actually that tall

  • @merkhadia6370
    @merkhadia6370 4 дні тому +2

    he definitely should be the first and the last Dutch Actor.no one else can play the character as good as him. And He's not answering the questions based on his personal opinion. But he answered that question as Dutch himself. I knew Rockstar picked the right actors for RDR2. I really cant wait for RDR3. I hope the story would be we play as young Arthur and how he meet Dutch and Hosea and formed the gang and recruits everyone we see and being mentioned in RDR2.

    • @skylerwhitworth-edwards7474
      @skylerwhitworth-edwards7474 2 дні тому

      That would be awesome. Then it should end right after blackwater and right before the beginning of the second game

  • @Hydan16
    @Hydan16 8 днів тому +84

    You know his favorite is Micah

  • @TONYSTARK-q2c
    @TONYSTARK-q2c 6 днів тому +8

    I thought Dutch liked Tahiti!

  • @julianprasaja2227
    @julianprasaja2227 6 днів тому +3

    "I beleve that bear is wearing people's clothes."

  • @VIConRDR
    @VIConRDR 7 днів тому +18

    You didn't have to put john down like that 😂

  • @larrysmith7197
    @larrysmith7197 7 днів тому +3

    Remember he has a plan 😂

  • @jorgedeanoperez2997
    @jorgedeanoperez2997 День тому

    It made me so happy, hearing him in that one episode of Creature Commandos

  • @Subject.13
    @Subject.13 4 дні тому

    This is got to be the best short I've seen all day 😂❤

  • @That1Guy-b7e
    @That1Guy-b7e 8 днів тому +50

    “You know I love all you boys the same Arthur”
    “But dutch! John left! To get McDonald’s”
    “But his kid stayed alive my boy”
    “HOSEA! DUTCH IS BULLYING ME”

  • @bradenfredrick2720
    @bradenfredrick2720 5 днів тому

    I can imagine all of them playing rdr online as there own characters that would be hilarious tbh

  • @sourabhkulkarni1995
    @sourabhkulkarni1995 3 дні тому

    The doubting, THE DOUBTING....!

  • @MichaelWitehira-k8b
    @MichaelWitehira-k8b 5 днів тому

    Please make more of these, I love this stuff

  • @Insanequickdraw
    @Insanequickdraw 8 днів тому +20

    Thats crazy

  • @josephblasko7309
    @josephblasko7309 3 дні тому

    He should have said something about John just not dying getting shot or attacked by wolves that would
    Have been hilarious

  • @blackice7050
    @blackice7050 2 дні тому +1

    Dutch threw him of the moutain in RDR1 coz of how disappointed he was in John

  • @bruhmasterlol
    @bruhmasterlol 4 дні тому

    "DUTCH YOU LEFT ME TO DIE"

  • @kejbyy2505
    @kejbyy2505 4 дні тому

    Atleast he didnt said that he had a plan

  • @personne2122
    @personne2122 3 дні тому

    John was the golden boy but we never saw that part of him

  • @maleexile9053
    @maleexile9053 43 хвилини тому

    We gave him all we had

  • @Dannymanny2005
    @Dannymanny2005 6 днів тому

    Bro gave him the Asian roast to John 😂💀

  • @aleckim9337
    @aleckim9337 5 днів тому

    "Ohhh the doubting, the dounbting"

  • @WhyRyouGae
    @WhyRyouGae 4 дні тому

    Have some goddamn FAITH Arthur!!!

  • @richjc7004
    @richjc7004 3 дні тому

    Not very noticeable on the first playthrough but Dutch was already going crazy since chapter 1 and John was the only one who noticed it hence Dutch was always disappointed with him

  • @Wheezall
    @Wheezall 5 днів тому

    I thought he was gonna say Micah and cause a riot 😂

  • @Regis1603
    @Regis1603 7 днів тому +1

    Answering the question as Dutch, brillant

  • @HandheldGamingHQ
    @HandheldGamingHQ 4 дні тому

    he should've turned to Roger and said "have you lose faith in me ??"

  • @SndjjwwejWdbbwene
    @SndjjwwejWdbbwene 3 дні тому

    This man is a legend

  • @oOBubblyOo
    @oOBubblyOo 4 дні тому

    Damm Dutch VA is a daddy

  • @byebeybyebey
    @byebeybyebey 3 дні тому

    Dutch: "I love all my children equally!"
    Earlier that day...
    Dutch: "I don't care for John..."

  • @nathankiley8206
    @nathankiley8206 4 дні тому

    Arthur was around before John and never left. It's obviously Arthur

  • @Lucifer.2163
    @Lucifer.2163 5 днів тому

    always doubting, never Tahiti😤

  • @sonofdutch9.
    @sonofdutch9. 5 днів тому

    Always doubting 😂😂😂

  • @Lastwalker01
    @Lastwalker01 7 днів тому +1

    Well Dutch in fact liked John pretty much and everyone knows that because everyone called John “the golden boy”

  • @iRenz0
    @iRenz0 4 дні тому

    Oh the doubt…THE DOUBT

  • @3rdrick
    @3rdrick 5 днів тому

    The doubting... the doubting..m

  • @GJW2011
    @GJW2011 6 днів тому

    The fact he let arthur die at the end

  • @Revanent_6
    @Revanent_6 4 дні тому

    Love the kayfabe brother 😂

  • @SilverHarlow
    @SilverHarlow 5 днів тому

    Shame he didnt say "the second is the money"

  • @reggiemacc5695
    @reggiemacc5695 4 дні тому

    Always doubting

  • @hondaboy8018
    @hondaboy8018 3 дні тому

    It’s true tho. Before the game even starts John had left and come back to the gang at least once

  • @aluzuka
    @aluzuka 6 днів тому

    this is dutch if he didn’t lie

  • @kanwarsinghgill1298
    @kanwarsinghgill1298 5 днів тому

    "As dutch my favorite is my plan"

  • @KennstWohlKeinSarkasmus
    @KennstWohlKeinSarkasmus 5 днів тому

    All voices are sooooo awesome to hear. What do americans to get such a great voice?

  • @dionallen7787
    @dionallen7787 7 днів тому +1

    He did, he always did… you didn’t have his

  • @NUGGETkid88
    @NUGGETkid88 6 днів тому

    You sure about that he cared more about Lenny when he died then when Hosea died

  • @J.Jonah.Jameson.
    @J.Jonah.Jameson. 7 днів тому

    I wonder how Arthur would have reacted to seeing how far Dutch would go on to fall, during Red Dead 1

  • @oscarp1981
    @oscarp1981 5 днів тому

    this could be an exctract audio from the game

  • @mrbrightkills
    @mrbrightkills 6 днів тому +2

    In the beginning of RDR2 the disappointment is fatherly because he abandoned Jack and the Gang for a year. In the end it was because John woke up and became a good man and saw through Dutch's catch 22

  • @JinWBO
    @JinWBO 6 днів тому

    For some reason I expected him to say Micah was his third favourite

  • @rakeemnaidoo4358
    @rakeemnaidoo4358 6 днів тому

    John always need saving and then points a gun at Dutch more then once

  • @AGPKj
    @AGPKj 5 днів тому

    Say something Dutch

  • @Masterofthedark1782
    @Masterofthedark1782 5 днів тому

    When your high put this up to your ear and close your eyes and you will see Dutch talking not bbd

  • @agent-fire
    @agent-fire 6 днів тому

    Bro he literally is dutch in irl

  • @Henry_Kezo
    @Henry_Kezo День тому

    Definately Micah 😂

  • @joelr2214
    @joelr2214 6 днів тому

    Arthur should never have duches back. There should even be a third ending where you can walk away from the gang and not die at all. I like most enjoy a good villain. However there was already to many then him its just way to much for alot of people. Its the one part that i didn't like not being able to make the logical choice. Leave i know the story calls for what happened to happen but thats just a argument for not make a prequel as the second game. When you actually look at it they done well making you feel as though your choices matter right until you find out your forced into a ending meaning you never had any control at all.

  • @DU-Rban
    @DU-Rban 7 днів тому

    Dutch doesn't even understand how much he LOVES Micah, he's that brainwashed

  • @erixon8090
    @erixon8090 6 днів тому

    What a goated answer

  • @Jj7th
    @Jj7th 7 днів тому +2

    At the beginning of rd2 I don’t think he had one towards the middle he did n it was prolly aruthur n at the end well pretty self explanatory💀

  • @MaskedMenace830
    @MaskedMenace830 6 днів тому

    The more I hear Ben Davis speak, the more I come to realise that the written character of Dutch Van der Linde was likely influenced by the human that voiced him.

  • @ArthurMorgan-m7r
    @ArthurMorgan-m7r 3 дні тому

    John Disappoints me too dutch

  • @zipiaro
    @zipiaro 7 днів тому

    well, if you INSIST

  • @mateusloubach
    @mateusloubach 2 дні тому

    Dutch`s favorite is Micah.

  • @coldslayer1303
    @coldslayer1303 7 днів тому

    I think dutch's actor saying I don't think arthur because "he doesn't have some godamn faith" would have been phenomenal as well as funny.

  • @ddt4u2
    @ddt4u2 5 днів тому

    Tahiti !!!

  • @TheeIdol
    @TheeIdol 6 днів тому

    John is the favourite cos Arthur calls his "the golden boii"

    • @UnshakenBuck
      @UnshakenBuck 6 днів тому

      Didn't dutch leave him to die like three times and also his wife.

    • @TheeIdol
      @TheeIdol 6 днів тому

      @UnshakenBuck that's when Dutch started going insane and started to hate John. But he loved him the most. John started questioning Dutch as soon as chapter 2 while Arthur would never get away with that

    • @UnshakenBuck
      @UnshakenBuck 6 днів тому

      @@TheeIdol LOL have you evergone just antagonising Dutch over and over, all he does it's get a bit mad.

  • @Chriswatt313
    @Chriswatt313 6 днів тому

    Ppl look on UA-cam for they not like dutch(Kendrick Lamar song)spoof with the rdr2 gang it’s brilliant

  • @TheLamana39
    @TheLamana39 7 днів тому

    I had a God damn plan!

  • @derstatiker1164
    @derstatiker1164 3 дні тому

    Because Arthur has no goddamn faith in the plan

  • @Warthog.edu.
    @Warthog.edu. 5 днів тому

    All jokes aside I think Dutch still loved Arthur up until his death but hated John and Abigail

  • @echothealien9740
    @echothealien9740 6 днів тому

    Okay but why did his actor say that? Does he remember his own story? Clearly his favorite is Arthur. He literally left John to die, that wouldn't have happened if it was Arthur except for the final chapter before the epilogue.

  • @ZStranger188
    @ZStranger188 7 днів тому

    I feel like dutchs favourite would be Arthur

  • @cosmicbilly
    @cosmicbilly 3 дні тому

    That man has a godly jawline and beard😅 its almost mythical.
    I like to imagine Dutch with the same beard but just dyed black.😂
    That would be awesome.
    Especially after coming back from Guarma.

  • @comedybuzz1672
    @comedybuzz1672 5 днів тому

    Dutch character is a lot better than the voice character

  • @srivastava6400
    @srivastava6400 7 днів тому

    Would have been funny if he said he didn't like arthur after he insisted

  • @OwnLaneTre
    @OwnLaneTre 5 днів тому

    NO MORE DUTCH!!! AND NO MORE YOU

  • @SOWEGAGuy
    @SOWEGAGuy 6 днів тому

    Micah, for sure. He just let Micah railroad the whole damn thing. He couldn’t see just how shit Micah really was, then didn’t listen to his two closest friends