"Talking Without Words in the Old West" (2009)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 73

  • @lauranicholls9421
    @lauranicholls9421 11 місяців тому +2

    Sign language is a very beautiful way of communicating. Thanks for sharing..🔥

  • @zhenxinbei726
    @zhenxinbei726 Рік тому +2

    I substitute, and as the class is studying particular tribes of Native Americans, I asked a thinking question ... which was to name different ways they communicated.
    Once I got home, I looked and ran across this informative video! I never knew sign language or hand talk was used. This was so interesting, I plan to share it next time I see them. ,,😊🤔😊

  • @gruberjens4354
    @gruberjens4354 2 роки тому +11

    This is fascinating to learn. I'm blown away just the concept of having a organized sign language to make interactions between different nations/tribes less difficult

  • @judemorales4U
    @judemorales4U 2 роки тому +5

    8 yrs ago and still informative, interesting and enlightening!

  • @bennorton4831
    @bennorton4831 6 років тому +21

    This is so well done! Great work!!!

  • @PeggyJame
    @PeggyJame 4 роки тому +9

    There are many people and many languages

  • @KamohoaliiKannon
    @KamohoaliiKannon 6 місяців тому +1

    What a blessing. Thank you.

  • @Kris_Toffer
    @Kris_Toffer 4 роки тому +6

    That Rob Collier has a fantastic voice. I could listen to him all day.

  • @amberamour5395
    @amberamour5395 2 роки тому +2

    Amazing!

  • @opalprestonshirley1700
    @opalprestonshirley1700 2 роки тому +3

    Awesome work. It is sad to think that at some point this knowledge could be lost, this would be very sad.

  • @emilianozapata2530
    @emilianozapata2530 4 роки тому +19

    I am a Serbian,living in Vietnam and I will continue to carry love for native americans where ever i go around the world.
    There is so much in their culture,only if U.S. managed to embrace it,it would make them culturally speaking richer in every sense.But no...they decided to liberate themselves from Brits and build their house on bloody foundations.
    Everybody reaps what they sew.

    • @Debeljaca2011
      @Debeljaca2011 3 роки тому

      Zena ti cista ili mesano sa Americkom kulturom?

  • @utej.k.bemsel4777
    @utej.k.bemsel4777 2 роки тому +3

    I do a winter count since about more than 30 years for myself.
    It helps me to remember things.
    For the last year i depicted 3 syringes for the covid vaccinacions i got.

  • @Tine_of_Nice_Dreams
    @Tine_of_Nice_Dreams 6 місяців тому

    Terrific program, thank you for sharing!

  • @feralmettle1504
    @feralmettle1504 3 роки тому +8

    Love this! I'm working on a Tsinuk / Chinuk / Chinook wawa and PISL lexicon. Thank you so much for sharing this.

    • @skeingamepodcast5993
      @skeingamepodcast5993 3 роки тому

      I'm studying CW too! Would love to see your work when it's done. Are you on the Chinook Jargon Discord and/or Reddit?

    • @feralmettle1504
      @feralmettle1504 3 роки тому

      @@skeingamepodcast5993 no, not subbed to either - I'll havta checkem out

  • @NeutralZoneEnigmas
    @NeutralZoneEnigmas 5 місяців тому +1

    It was the rule..... BEFORE GENOCIDE!!!

  • @winros
    @winros 2 роки тому +4

    I'm so intrigued I am coda both my parents were born deaf so I speak American Sign language however, there was a lot of similarity in the way they signed as well common Sense can you kind of tell you that! I knew that natives used sign language however, I didn't think twice about it until tonight...and I am so over the moon!

    • @isabelsmith3775
      @isabelsmith3775 8 місяців тому +1

      i believe native american sign language had some influence on asl but dont quote me on that

    • @winros
      @winros 8 місяців тому +1

      @isabelsmith3775 Yes, it did!

  • @tommygamba170
    @tommygamba170 2 роки тому +2

    So you mean the first sign language

  • @chetawitko7031
    @chetawitko7031 2 роки тому +5

    Napé uŋ wóglaka👍
    (to speak by using hands)
    Question: in the Ikče iyapi (Indigenous languages) I've learned about the word order is so-called backwards compared to Wašičuiyapi (English) ex.
    Thípi čík'ala. = Little house.
    Mni kȟáta. = Hot water.
    So does anyone know if ikče wíyutȟapi ( Indigenous sign language) follows the same rule, or would it change with the speaker's language rules? I ask because I've seen videos where they were signing using English word order. Philámayaye.

  • @apollohmiv42
    @apollohmiv42 3 роки тому +8

    Facial expression are the same for all
    Happy
    Sad
    Fear
    Anger
    Surprise
    Disgust

  • @christopherellis2663
    @christopherellis2663 3 роки тому +9

    The USA has no official language.
    Canada has at least two.
    I have a half dozen that I am good at, and a few more that I know a little of, here in Europe

    • @mgmassey174
      @mgmassey174 3 роки тому

      Unfortunately, America is a place that eradicated other cultures, not respect them
      Heard about the Residential schools?
      In an insular, colonial culture, assimilation was the goal.
      Now, white people get mad at people if they speak their language.
      I don't even know mine because my ancestors were beaten if they spoke it
      Those are facts.
      Wabanaki People of the Dawn channel

  • @utej.k.bemsel3199
    @utej.k.bemsel3199 3 роки тому +1

    I have a winter count. Every year around new year i draw a new sign for the year just passed.
    For 2020 it`s a circle (earth) with five people around wich cough (Covid)

  • @teresafernandez9849
    @teresafernandez9849 Рік тому

    A lot of Native ppl had a sign language. Even some tribes in South West, Mexico and South America. My grandparents both used jesters at times, not often but we knew what they ment. Also the whistle language was used by the Natives.

  • @2broketim479
    @2broketim479 5 років тому +10

    what about the Indians of the East? as far as history its like they never existed.

    • @redhouse1002
      @redhouse1002 4 роки тому

      Sign language not really used among the Ind. nations in the east, not like it was on the Plains. More people were multi-lingual.

    • @terriejohnston8801
      @terriejohnston8801 3 роки тому +4

      Are you referring to the Cherokee, + dozens of tribes from Pa.NY Delaware all around our Great Lakes??? Time to do ur homework..

    • @wagonburner509
      @wagonburner509 3 роки тому

      They all got wiped out the eastern people came to the west dip shit that's where the white people started off at

  • @donjohnston3767
    @donjohnston3767 2 роки тому +1

    Anyone know the Huron or Wendat hand signs?

  • @arynnehempstock1108
    @arynnehempstock1108 4 роки тому +7

    i love so-called Indian sign language- fascinating!

    • @redhouse1002
      @redhouse1002 4 роки тому +2

      Why do you say "so-called?" Do you doubt it?

    • @patrickpregiato1794
      @patrickpregiato1794 2 місяці тому

      @@redhouse1002 because there is much debate as to whether the word Indian should even be used

    • @redhouse1002
      @redhouse1002 2 місяці тому

      @@patrickpregiato1794 I'll take you on that debate any time.

    • @patrickpregiato1794
      @patrickpregiato1794 2 місяці тому

      @@redhouse1002 There’s no debate. Columbus thought he had reached India so they were called Indios in Spanish, Indians in English. It’s a mistake that was never corrected.

    • @redhouse1002
      @redhouse1002 2 місяці тому

      @@patrickpregiato1794 No debate! Because you said so. That is the same aggressiveness that we have come to expect in relation to Europeans who came here and did the "naming" then the "renaming." It never stops. Sorry you aren't open to hearing another point of view.

  • @lilithmotherofmonsters6055
    @lilithmotherofmonsters6055 2 роки тому

    Bingeing through twinrabbit's content primed my algorithm well

  • @winros
    @winros 2 роки тому +1

    I'm curious since they did not have a language and did not speak a language and they were not Deaf just curious how their voices sounded...

  • @denepride2910
    @denepride2910 6 років тому +4

    I speak Denesuline...Cree....

  • @esperanzamarinelli2556
    @esperanzamarinelli2556 2 роки тому +1

    India sign language

  • @nelsoncorponelson
    @nelsoncorponelson Рік тому

    Estou.falando.do.Cacique chefe Takaiake q viveu.na.CALifornia. Chayenne Pele.vermelha.

  • @winros
    @winros 2 роки тому

    You have home signs...

  • @shoshonewarrior828
    @shoshonewarrior828 7 років тому +7

    Yeah, I could speak Shoshone, Ute, Bannock, English and Spanish

  • @TRUEkcctv1384
    @TRUEkcctv1384 6 місяців тому

    Us so called black people do this all the time, especially with each other

  • @PeggyJame
    @PeggyJame 4 роки тому +12

    They are not Indians they are natives

    • @redhouse1002
      @redhouse1002 4 роки тому +1

      Wrong. Who told you that, a non-Indian?

    • @orlandomorris6628
      @orlandomorris6628 4 роки тому +2

      Yup they called us indians the indian REMOVAL act WALTER PLECKER DID THAT PAPER GENOCIDE THE ACTUAL NAME IS INDIGENOUS NATIVE S BECAUSE IT WASNT CALLED AMERICAS YET

    • @redhouse1002
      @redhouse1002 4 роки тому

      @@orlandomorris6628 Just say Indian (NDN) like everybody else does! LOL.

    • @dollylyon8438
      @dollylyon8438 3 роки тому +3

      We the Ojibwa speak our language. The Cree speak theirs as well. We are NOT from India.

  • @snoqualmiepatkanim
    @snoqualmiepatkanim 2 роки тому

    my right eyelid had a strange lump in it about two weeks ago. i never saw it before and didn’t squeeze it. i just felt and saw a strange bump in the mirror. i drank beer and water and cried out my nose until the SKIN INFECTION IS REMOVED. OSMOSIS

  • @snoqualmiepatkanim
    @snoqualmiepatkanim 2 роки тому

    i just like a human to touch my back and i steal their toxic metal haha

  • @cjam3660
    @cjam3660 2 роки тому +2

    never saw a gay indian, only one I ever seen in my life. huuuh. interesting. enjoyed the video.

    • @winros
      @winros 2 роки тому +1

      Come to think of it nor have I!

  • @ABerCul
    @ABerCul 8 місяців тому

    Humans have used hundreds of ways to communicate without writing for ever and still do. With whistles, clicks, clothing, reflections, drawings, hair, structures, things they carried with them like a weapon, totem poles, stone carvings, mounds, face paint or tatoos, sign language, knots, claps, chomping teeth, blinking, hand gestures and sign language ( sign language itself has h7ndreds of different forms around the world just like the many different spoken languages), animals (pigeons, dogs, rats, pigs , almost every ani.al has been used to communicate long distance, or in war, or to communicate wi5h their Gods, smiles or frowns don't mean the same everywhere, feet stomping, and so many many many more like pins or stars on a Military uniform and the uniform itself, white lab coat, tubans and thousands of other head wear, smoke, banging sticks together, or a message stick, spinning a bullroarer instrument, and all instruments, body movements and everything else including smells

  • @donjohnston3767
    @donjohnston3767 2 роки тому

    X is the sign of the Son of Man. He is coming soon, as soon as The One God, The Creator sends Him. At His second coming: Parousia ! His sign in the clouds will be seen by all peoples on the earth.Look up! The time draws near. Can anyone translate this message into Universal sign language to get all peoples ready?

  • @nelsoncorponelson
    @nelsoncorponelson Рік тому

    Voces.nao.sabem.nada.ele.sim.sabe porque.viveu.la.a.morte nao.existe.

  • @snoqualmiepatkanim
    @snoqualmiepatkanim 2 роки тому

    women should be in charge of sugar and chocolate access at all times!

  • @Memry-Man
    @Memry-Man Рік тому

    The people used sign language to speak to other tribes that spoke differently. More importantly though they used sign language when they didn't want the wetiko to know what they were saying.

  • @TheSnoopindaweb
    @TheSnoopindaweb 6 місяців тому

    🤔🤨💬 " Tatanka Oyate Pilamaya " 🤠 Yup❕🪶 G~G. ✏ 🗳 ☑ 🇺🇸.

  • @AudioPervert1
    @AudioPervert1 Рік тому

    btw.. they were not Indians - Indians live in India. They were the indigenous original humans of the two new continents called the New World, by
    savage europeans, carrying Guns, Germs and Steel. So many of these sketches show the Natives On Horses, when there were ZERO HORSES in North and South America before the arrival of the Europeans.