Andrew Halverson, YUP!! I bet Shining Armour was happy for Cranky Doodle & Matilda, but at the same time their wedding reminds him of his own messed up 1.
+Pikasayan Concerning he got mind-raped who knows how many times by Chrysalis, got owned by Sombra and had his magic drained by Tirek, I wouldn't be surprised if he has a few issues.
6:31 - I don't think that falls short. Yeah a non-brony won't get the main joke, but it's a muffin basket. If they don't get the joke, then they get the /other/ joke that's presented: a jab at companies just offering "complimentary" things as an apology for an inconvenience, in an immediate attempt to pacify an angered consumer. I don't think it falls short, I think it's rather cleverly designed. If the main joke is missed, they get a back-up joke instead. Not as good, but still fine.
It's great that Silver brought up the fact that this episode gave enough characterization to these background ponies that from now on the writers have the option to use them as supporting characters if they so desire.
Aww, the Lyra/Bon part was my favorite part. It explains why she has so many voices and appears at certain places. I loved the fact she was a secret agent. Also other obvious reasons.
+DRWolf001 *Plays Piano Man by Billy Joel* Now, Silver Quill is a regular He’s also a friend of his He’s good with a joke or to light up a quote But his troubles are anything but a bliss He says, ‘Doctor Wolf, I am in trouble I’ve just gone and done it again Just give me a place to hide myself away And charge me the usual fee times ten’
+lordsjaak I can totally imagine Doctor Wolf, quietly sipping his tea, looking out of his office window with a frown on his face, seeing Silver Quill getting stampeded.
"That dirty pigeon is talking smack about me!" Had me cracking up. Then at the end "Feel my wrath pigeon!" xD All in all, loved this review and the cameos xD
Okay first of all... Doodle Dabble is like the cutest thing ever! secondly, cool to see Camgoespony in one of your reviews. third, I surprised you left out the part with Lyra and Bon Bon's 'Friendship" :) but still entertaining
3:06 Because you're not on Tumblr I'm already liking this review a lot. Overall, this episode may be a mixed bag but it was still hilarious and worth watching. Also, this was hilarious!
12:08 Yet, they're civilians, not trained and professional soldiers. Just take a look at all of the very tragic shootings and terrorist attacks. It's like asking "Why didn't everyone just run at the lone gunman all at once?" and you'll clearly see why they didn't. Also, there's a psychological phenomenon that the bigger the crowd, the more likely people will just stand by and not doing anything (mainly hoping someone else will step in and solve the issue). (that's also putting it briefly^^^)
Cause nobody wants to get blown up. Though some crowds aren't so shy, if some terrorist would try to cut someone up, or something, on the street here in Ukraine they wouldn't walk away in one piece. We have so many ex and active millitary and activists walking the street the Police is practicaly here only to collect the packages.
I admit that I haven’t done that much research into the phenomenon, but what little I have done suggests that it’s a misconception. This doesn’t defeat your point, though: while the chance of success is high, the chance of harm being done to oneself is quite high, so I would neither do so myself, nor would I want this strategy to ever be employed, lest someone become a victim
Personally I don't really mind the idea of the a fictional population not fighting back because not everyone knows how to fight. As great as it would be seeing the background characters contribute? I'm not too broken uo by the everyday person not being able to through a punch.
I honestly love this episode. One of the reasons being is that you can imagine this is how all the NPCs are in a tabletop game like D&D or Pathfinder. Just staring on as the Player Characters take on quests and the like. XD
Seriously Quill, you didn't get the joke about Bon-Bon? Sweetie Drops was her original Hasbro release name. Fans got the 'call back' to the original release of Bon-bons pony as Sweetie Drops, but you didn't? Ah well, i guess 'all knowing' really isn't on your list of merits. :) Enough from me, the Frank Pony
Finally a voice of reason about this episode................ Silver Quill is the voice of reason, discord must be behind this twist of reality. BTW, a mob of angry ponies wouldn't really stand that much of a chance against Queen Chrysalis, I speak from personal experience.
11:05 and that reference makes me even more sure that the way how Twilight was treated in season 4 was a reference to prince John Lackland in some adaptations of Robin Hood legend.
The ending of this episode has a special meaning for me. I was part of the writers' think tank for the Season 4 story arc. I tend to identify my work by using the word "lucky", my last name, in an unusual way.
+MLP-Silver-Quill This could just be me with my inner-rage on the awfulness of the Michael Bay Transformers movies, but I get the feeling they put that in to jab at people not conforming to the pro-macho masculinity Bay wants to emphasize incessantly.
you know this episode actually made me laugh a few times, even cause a I have a basic understanding of the fandom's involved in slice of life, oh yea! I just realized that your videos have become more evolved in the making, such as more intracity ( I think that's how you spell it) in the writing, not to mention more guest appearances. you done well silver.
Here’s something interesting to consider: After I heard the moral of this particular episode I knew the finale was going to involve time travel. Because basically the moral of this episode states how everybody plays a part in everyone’s life, so adding that to the finale: changing one thing, can change so many other peoples lives and lead to a whole different outcome.
15:25 Legit though, maybe it's because I work as a hotel housekeeper, so I have to deal with the aftermath of the insanity that are weddings, but the entire idea of weddings has faded on me. Spend all that time, money, resources, and effort on what? A single day and a dress you'll wear all of once, then never wear again? Nah, I'll skip on the wedding and use the money saved to take family and friends on a nice, non-wedding dinner.
+Doodle Dabble And you are of the charts. Have you seen what KeyFrames Channel after her collab with SilverQuill. Not a single Video content and alot of subs. Gratz to the collab
Nicely done with the humor! I love how the other reviewers inserted themselves into the review. I even got to see some faces I hadn't encountered yet. ^_^
headcannon for the derpy/ditzy/muffins thing in universe. she was born ditzibella Dupree do ( ditzy doo for short), and at some point some of her friends gave her the nickname derpy, due to a face she made once and her sometimes goofy esque mannerisms. for a time she and others were happy with the nickname, but eventually some ponies belived it to be malicious and insulting( their were both ponies who were genuanly concerned for her, and uppity easily offended snobs). not wanting to offend anyone ditzy dropped the name, but she wanted her friends to have something fun to call her, to try to make everypony happy. hence she tried names like bubbles, bright eyes, fan favorite( that raised a few pony eyebrows), snuggle bubble muffin( that got her a few really weird looks), till she finally settled on muffins( her friends just gave that a "meh"). as for silver's suggestion of "the muffin mare" she's called that in universe too- as a masked hero who fights evil using an arsenal of trick muffins that work as everything from explosives, smoke bombs, knock out gas, expanding goo, and other uses. think green arrow, but with baked goods. she thinks it's a secret, but pretty much everypony knows they just choose not to bother her about it. that and just imagine dinky in a little robin costume:)
not gonna lie, that thumbnail art is awesome! Only halfway in, you have done an amazing job collabing with others. OMC.. Mad Munchkin and Mary Sue!.. Oh man, some great great stuff in there.. I freakin love the bit you and Mary Sue have.. it cracks me up so much.. And thanks for bringing all these other OCs in on it, I see some new faces, going to check them out and subscribe.. the fun is doubled..
I do believe Silver is a special kind of reviewer. He knows just how to piss of both sides of the Show. The Canon and the Fandom. How else could a WHOLE town unite in such a way as to chase alongside their biggest fanatics after one hippogriff such as Silver-Quill? Congratulations!!! You have received a Hidden Ghost Platinum Trophy: MOST IRRITATING REVIEWER EVER TO THE MLP UNIVERSE!!! Take it!! Take it with Pride, Silver!!! Later, RDF2
If there’s one thing I love, it’s gleefully geeking out over minuscule references that some people wouldn’t get. This episode is my definition of heaven.
8:30 - I have to admit that I never bothered to watch "Dr. Who" until just last fall, when Retro TV started showing old Who eps with Dr. #1. I probably would've skipped them if not for Dr. Whooves, though.
WOO!! DAVID TENNANT!!!!! Also, who else smiles so much when they hear "Slice of Life"? Just me? Okay. P.S. Doesn't it surprise ANYONE that Discord wasn't in this episode?! WHERE IS KP?!? WERE'S MY SHIP?! WHERE THE F IS FEDEX?!?!
The best of the crossover videos from the king of crossovers is a review of one of the most epic crossover episodes. So fitting. Love the insight on marriages. This is why I prefer sacramental marriages.
Normally does not compute jokes fall short for me (pun so inteded) but I think Camgoespony did a job good enough that it pulled through. Rest of the review was great too! Loved both the points brought up and the cameos brought in! Can't wait to see princess spike, even if it is a lackluster, if enjoyable episode. Keep up the good work!
I almost went full nerd. I started a comment to protest that if you assault a time lord so soon after regenerating, he still has leftover regeneration energy and can recover. But then I realized just how fanboy it is to know this, and even moreso to point it out in a 'You are mistaken!' corrective manner.
A strong review, that brings up some interesting points, laced with the wonderful humor i've come to expect. And abuse...always the abuse. I agree with the point that I'd like to see more of the background characters. Maybe introduce one or two in some episodes, so that they become recurrent, but not ostentatious.
I don't care how long it takes you, as long as you put the time and effort into making the quality material each episode deserves, we're all better or it. I respect the fact that you don't rush out your reviews as soon as a new episode comes by just for the sake of timing.
I've gotta admit - I liked the Lyra/BonBon segments. While I do know there was no goal in mind for them, I've learned that sometimes it's the journey that matters most. (Look at Pinkie Apple Pie. The ending was a large anti-climax, while the rest of it was nothing short of hilarious.) And, besides, I couldn't help but just laugh at how inane BonBon's dialogue got, and how Lyra got more and more confused like the rest of us. The segment I disliked the most was Steven Magnet's segment, however. Yes, I get that weddings are big businesses, but he could tell she was stressed out enough. In other words, he showed just as much tact as Rainbow Dash did during Pinkie Pride, except where it fits Rainbow, it doesn't fit Steven at all. But, that's just my opinion. :P
Ah who cares about the little girls watching the show, we never did then and we won't now. All that matters is a bunch of 30 year old neckbeard bronies get the references. Edit: Lyra and Bon Bon are "friends". Sure that's what they were signifying whilst staring lovingly into each other eyes of what could possibly have been their last time together, not knowing when they'd see the other mare again, or how she could live without- ah-hem I got a bit carried off but you know what dat look in the ep was for.
I knew that some of the equations were actually pretty relevant in that scene but I never expected them all to be so relevant to the movement of a ball, someone who worked on that episode is really into physics :D Physics is the best science (In my opinion).
remember this is a 'for the fans' episode and the fans/bronies/internet say they are. (tho i dont really care for much shipping mlp, except Scootadoption by rainbow dash)
+Josh Foster Slice of life doesn't make all fan made character relationships canon. Most likely the writers just didn't think of it or never heard of it.
+Josh Foster do keep in mind they shouldn't shoehorn an out of nwoehere offscreen romance for a major recurring character out of the blue, especially not one that would have basis in some easily missed bit in a single episode. not to mention, a character should not be defined by who they romance, and shipping should not effect what goes on in the show itself.
I'm 100% the 2nd guy you showed XD I almost passed out more than once while explaining my love for a show. Singing songs, doing impressions, and explaining (with out spoiling to) plot.
***** He is the reviewer who breaks the walls of cartoon to interactwith heroes. His reviews are episodes in which he is the protagonist. In this episode he commited murder...twice. It was Doctor Whooves, but still.
Personally I've seen three different opinions on this episode: 1, "ERMAGEURD, BACKGROUND PONIES, BEST EPISODE EVAH!". 2, "God, this episode was nothing but pandering, worse than Double Rainboom, shark-jumping, worst episode ever!". And 3, "Eh, that was okay. Appreciate the thought, writers". All opinions I can completely understand, but I'm personally in the third opinion. I know it's fanservice, but I still got some entertainment and surprises out of it, even if the story did feel all over the place. It's not my favourite episode or even one of my favourites but I'd gladly watch it again if I got the chance. But like Fiery Joker said in his own review, there's no way of coming up with an objective opinion on this episode. If you were never a fan of memes or background ponies or headcanons to come out of the fandom, this episode isn't gonna do anything to sway you. But if you're a hardcore fan who eats up anything MLP-related, chances are you'll find something to like. But whether you like or hate Slice of Life, you gotta admit it is very impressive that a show called My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic reached 100 episodes. :)
Yeah that's pretty much how I acted with the Bon Bon thing lol XD Also, the reason his name is Steven Magnet is because when people watched the episode he was in using youtube subtitles, it would come up as Steven Magnet when he talked. That pretty much became a meme in itself, along with other funny youtube subtitles.
+Wad “the Eevee whovian” Wiswell The Doctor (Pony) regenerated. You can not kill what can regenerate. Besides he got new kidneys even it does not like the color.
So you're just gonna chill Doctor Who whenever you need to vent your rage also don't expect me to know these equations or what do you mean also did he said the force and pork also I watch Doctor Who and Star Wars set it OK we just need a link in a video please something that makes Luke or anybody Star Wars seriously
I always thought that Shining Armor's crying was ptsd from his own wedding.
Hmmm...
Head cannon accepted
Well that's, dark.
Andrew Halverson,
YUP!! I bet Shining Armour was happy for Cranky Doodle & Matilda, but at the same time their wedding reminds him of his own messed up 1.
Makes much more sense. Thus making it more horrifying in context.
"You have wings, why are you taking the stairs?"
Greatest line ever!
Easy: taking the stairs is healthy. He hardly ever uses of his wings.
WHAT IF.
Shining Armor cries at weddings because he has PTSD from his own?
MIND = BLOWN
+Pikasayan OMFG! your a genius! Fanfic writers! TO YOUR KEYBOARDS!
+Pikasayan Woah... Dude.. o_o
+Pikasayan Concerning he got mind-raped who knows how many times by Chrysalis, got owned by Sombra and had his magic drained by Tirek, I wouldn't be surprised if he has a few issues.
If you excuse me, I'm going to sign in to FimFiction for no good reason whatsoever…
+Pikasayan Shiny has PTSD!
"Feel my wrath pigeon" me to everyone ever.
including actual pidgeons
@@axeace1413 Same!
I know right? I kinda want to start using that as my catchphrase or something!☺️
Welcome to how I am in the tangled series about the Varian x Cass, Rapunzel, Eugene, Andrew shippers and Frederick.
6:31 - I don't think that falls short. Yeah a non-brony won't get the main joke, but it's a muffin basket. If they don't get the joke, then they get the /other/ joke that's presented: a jab at companies just offering "complimentary" things as an apology for an inconvenience, in an immediate attempt to pacify an angered consumer. I don't think it falls short, I think it's rather cleverly designed. If the main joke is missed, they get a back-up joke instead. Not as good, but still fine.
"He always cries at weddings"
Because he has PTSD from his own.
Every time Silver ticks someone off, take a shot. *drops dead*
+DeathGodRiku
You wouldn't last five minutes with that rule.
Kraigon42 to Quote Silverquill himself "NOOOOOO! I want to live!"
Moony Shenanigans He still has Firebrand's drinking game to do
+DeathGodRiku He already did. It was not pretty.
fictionfan0 I know, but there's still more town festivals to be had
It's great that Silver brought up the fact that this episode gave enough characterization to these background ponies that from now on the writers have the option to use them as supporting characters if they so desire.
Which they do with the doctor and the fact that he tries to be part of the friendship school
Aww, the Lyra/Bon part was my favorite part. It explains why she has so many voices and appears at certain places. I loved the fact she was a secret agent. Also other obvious reasons.
Omg being a reviewer (or just doing stuff in the fandom) looks like so much fun!!!
That actually made me laugh more than every other review you've made thus far Silver. Fantastic work.
+DRWolf001 *Plays Piano Man by Billy Joel*
Now, Silver Quill is a regular
He’s also a friend of his
He’s good with a joke or to light up a quote
But his troubles are anything but a bliss
He says, ‘Doctor Wolf, I am in trouble
I’ve just gone and done it again
Just give me a place to hide myself away
And charge me the usual fee times ten’
+DRWolf001 to bad you was not as scene shot in his review :P
+Matthew Blackwell It's working progress. ^_^
+lordsjaak I can totally imagine Doctor Wolf, quietly sipping his tea, looking out of his office window with a frown on his face, seeing Silver Quill getting stampeded.
Brian Random VA and that i want to see it in silver review :P
I guess you could say that the big lebowski is a...COLT classic? eh? eh?
.....
I'll show myself out.
why ;-;
Is that not what he said?
why- just NO, JUST NO
heytheresawolfinminecraft 🔫🔫🔫🔫 RUN TO INDEI (Big Bang Theory Reference)
You are dishonestly discharged.
I apologize for letting Mary Sue out of her cage. :P
It was great to hear her call him a pigeon again. ^_^
+Mad Munchkin maybe you should keep her on a leash instead or a shock collar :)
+Mad Munchkin Your voice for Mary Sue may be annoying but I love it. Glad you were in on this review. :)
At least Mary Sue is smarter than Donkey Kong
+Mad Munchkin as long as her stupidity doesn't cause another type of head ache. i'll be good
"That dirty pigeon is talking smack about me!" Had me cracking up. Then at the end "Feel my wrath pigeon!" xD All in all, loved this review and the cameos xD
9:11 "I want some Development for Flash Sentry"
THANK YOU! Yes, please, this would be wonderful!
Okay first of all... Doodle Dabble is like the cutest thing ever!
secondly, cool to see Camgoespony in one of your reviews.
third, I surprised you left out the part with Lyra and Bon Bon's 'Friendship" :)
but still entertaining
I just had a thought; could that changeling at the wedding be Thorax?
wolfclaw719 actually, thats a good point! i mean cranky befriended a serpant for crying out loud!
wolfclaw719 Sorry, but that changeling is named Kevin. And he's a friend of Matilda.
We have to date, as gernalry charecters around 3 married couples. Cadence , mayilda, and the cakes.
@@ambermargheim5726 You forgot pear butter and bright Macintosh, and I don't think we'll get any more this generation.
@@electricheartpony oh yeah!
12:07 "Okay team, let's make Celestia proud!"
3:06 Because you're not on Tumblr
I'm already liking this review a lot.
Overall, this episode may be a mixed bag but it was still hilarious and worth watching. Also, this was hilarious!
Wow of all congrats on all the shout-outs, echoing slice of life, loved it!
13:04"The names Drops. Sweetie Drops" or "The names Bon. Bon Bon."
I go to school for landscaping and floral design and the way the flower ponies act is really accurate in my eyes ha!
12:08
Yet, they're civilians, not trained and professional soldiers. Just take a look at all of the very tragic shootings and terrorist attacks. It's like asking "Why didn't everyone just run at the lone gunman all at once?" and you'll clearly see why they didn't.
Also, there's a psychological phenomenon that the bigger the crowd, the more likely people will just stand by and not doing anything (mainly hoping someone else will step in and solve the issue).
(that's also putting it briefly^^^)
Cause nobody wants to get blown up. Though some crowds aren't so shy, if some terrorist would try to cut someone up, or something, on the street here in Ukraine they wouldn't walk away in one piece. We have so many ex and active millitary and activists walking the street the Police is practicaly here only to collect the packages.
I admit that I haven’t done that much research into the phenomenon, but what little I have done suggests that it’s a misconception. This doesn’t defeat your point, though: while the chance of success is high, the chance of harm being done to oneself is quite high, so I would neither do so myself, nor would I want this strategy to ever be employed, lest someone become a victim
Personally I don't really mind the idea of the a fictional population not fighting back because not everyone knows how to fight. As great as it would be seeing the background characters contribute? I'm not too broken uo by the everyday person not being able to through a punch.
17:49 - Does Shining Armor cry at weddings because they remind him of his own, rather traumatic one?
Hehheh. You drew my brain all poofy. I love it.
+Camgoespony and now we know why you had to move channals lol
There are even people who hate or have never heard of Doctor Who
+Camgoespony Poofy because it is full of the learnings!
+MLP-Silver-Quill BEST review of Slice of Life I've seen by far. :)
+MLP-Silver-Quill poop on you
lolol0-0
k
would it be a stretch to think that changeling is thorax
Plush Thax lol
Headcannon accepted!
leopardnosepaws noooooooooo! you Think? Wow. 😯
I'm not the only one who thought that?! YES!!!!!!
I think it's Kevin, Sketchy's cousin.
I honestly love this episode. One of the reasons being is that you can imagine this is how all the NPCs are in a tabletop game like D&D or Pathfinder. Just staring on as the Player Characters take on quests and the like. XD
[3:14] After seeing Cozy Glow...
"Wow! Great color choice! Just amazing!"
Funniest and greatest review ever, and awesome cameos ^^
Bravo, bravo!
*pulls out the sack,
Now all we he to do is execute our plan to do a colab with him ;)
+Rosie Sievers (rigifan32) Show raises us one shout out eposide. Silver raises it with his own brand! I for one say.... Well worth the wait!
Looking at the joke about Derpy offering a basket of muffins, It could just be taken as a quirky and silly way of apologizing.
Seriously Quill, you didn't get the joke about Bon-Bon? Sweetie Drops was her original Hasbro release name. Fans got the 'call back' to the original release of Bon-bons pony as Sweetie Drops, but you didn't? Ah well, i guess 'all knowing' really isn't on your list of merits. :)
Enough from me, the Frank Pony
I love how in the angry mob Finn is still smiling
Finn will make sure everyone gets ice cream after the mob chase is finished.
Finally a voice of reason about this episode................ Silver Quill is the voice of reason, discord must be behind this twist of reality.
BTW, a mob of angry ponies wouldn't really stand that much of a chance against Queen Chrysalis, I speak from personal experience.
+Gungelion True, you guys are as close as MLP gets to Xenomorphs!
Actually, there is one species slightly closer. They actually possess acid in their system
Gungelion Which one was that?
Well technically you could count a certain species of spider, I'm referring to a creature that's currently locked up in Tartarus
Gungelion Those Skull Spider things>
11:05 and that reference makes me even more sure that the way how Twilight was treated in season 4 was a reference to prince John Lackland in some adaptations of Robin Hood legend.
"He cries at weddings"
What about his own wedding then?
The ending of this episode has a special meaning for me. I was part of the writers' think tank for the Season 4 story arc. I tend to identify my work by using the word "lucky", my last name, in an unusual way.
What is the video with Rainbow Dash plushie transforming into a gun?
+Pip Pip Pow It's from _Transformers: Age of Extinction_.
MLP-Silver-Quill Okay. Thanks!
+MLP-Silver-Quill This could just be me with my inner-rage on the awfulness of the Michael Bay Transformers movies, but I get the feeling they put that in to jab at people not conforming to the pro-macho masculinity Bay wants to emphasize incessantly.
+NeoDragonCount If so, then he failed twice with one scene. A bad jab in a poor movie.
+MLP-Silver-Quill There was only really one reason to watch the movie beyond that anyways. Optimus Prime riding a fire-breathing T-Rex.
you know this episode actually made me laugh a few times, even cause a I have a basic understanding of the fandom's involved in slice of life, oh yea! I just realized that your videos have become more evolved in the making, such as more intracity ( I think that's how you spell it) in the writing, not to mention more guest appearances. you done well silver.
(Siiiiiippppppppp)
+Dustykatt Rhoades would you like a crumpet with that tea Mr.Dustykatt?
+Dustykatt Rhoades What's he talking about? You've done tea parties before.
And he gets his revenge in TF2 Analysis Anarchy. SAXTON HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAALE!
+Dustykatt Rhoades Found your weakness, Good thing Bliss is scared of you
+Dustykatt Rhoades U want some coffee instead?
Here’s something interesting to consider:
After I heard the moral of this particular episode I knew the finale was going to involve time travel.
Because basically the moral of this episode states how everybody plays a part in everyone’s life,
so adding that to the finale:
changing one thing, can change so many other peoples lives and lead to a whole different outcome.
"I want a Celestia centred episode!" Well, I want a Derpy centred episode!!
15:25
Legit though, maybe it's because I work as a hotel housekeeper, so I have to deal with the aftermath of the insanity that are weddings, but the entire idea of weddings has faded on me. Spend all that time, money, resources, and effort on what? A single day and a dress you'll wear all of once, then never wear again? Nah, I'll skip on the wedding and use the money saved to take family and friends on a nice, non-wedding dinner.
Fin: WELCOME TO THE INTERNET!
Silver: ah so true.
Me: (is straight up on the floor laughing my ass off)
Fin and silver: are you okay?
the punishment quill had to take at the ending tho XDDD awesome
Yeah Every collaber And the main cast liatirly Running over him
Wait! ! What button mash history??? Did I miss something ? I've seen all the episodes and I don't see any button mash history
Shoving the OSHA Standards for Construction and Industry in my face was worth it for this vid.
+Doodle Dabble
And you are of the charts. Have you seen what KeyFrames Channel after her collab with SilverQuill. Not a single Video content and alot of subs.
Gratz to the collab
+Doodle Dabble Yeah great o see you colabing loved how you showed up looking forward to seeing more from you
Draws a mustache
*wiggles nose* (I really want to draw this now)
"Feel my wrath, pigeon." Lol I was laughing so hard
"So, neither of us know this and we're just mooching off someone else's knowledge?"
"Welcome to the internet"
Loved it, great humor as always. Love the continuing rebuilding of the sister's castle. :)
"Wife javelin competition" cracked me up
Nicely done with the humor! I love how the other reviewers inserted themselves into the review. I even got to see some faces I hadn't encountered yet. ^_^
headcannon for the derpy/ditzy/muffins thing in universe. she was born ditzibella Dupree do ( ditzy doo for short), and at some point some of her friends gave her the nickname derpy, due to a face she made once and her sometimes goofy esque mannerisms. for a time she and others were happy with the nickname, but eventually some ponies belived it to be malicious and insulting( their were both ponies who were genuanly concerned for her, and uppity easily offended snobs). not wanting to offend anyone ditzy dropped the name, but she wanted her friends to have something fun to call her, to try to make everypony happy. hence she tried names like bubbles, bright eyes, fan favorite( that raised a few pony eyebrows), snuggle bubble muffin( that got her a few really weird looks), till she finally settled on muffins( her friends just gave that a "meh"). as for silver's suggestion of "the muffin mare" she's called that in universe too- as a masked hero who fights evil using an arsenal of trick muffins that work as everything from explosives, smoke bombs, knock out gas, expanding goo, and other uses. think green arrow, but with baked goods. she thinks it's a secret, but pretty much everypony knows they just choose not to bother her about it. that and just imagine dinky in a little robin costume:)
that head canon is so good it should be canon!
Kris Lundell HEAD-CANNON, FIRE!
Kris Lundell Headcannon ACCEPTED
+Lord Felidae
(POMF!)
ehh, i think this could work, but this doesn't explain why her eyes are crossed-eyed.
not gonna lie, that thumbnail art is awesome! Only halfway in, you have done an amazing job collabing with others. OMC.. Mad Munchkin and Mary Sue!.. Oh man, some great great stuff in there.. I freakin love the bit you and Mary Sue have.. it cracks me up so much..
And thanks for bringing all these other OCs in on it, I see some new faces, going to check them out and subscribe.. the fun is doubled..
This episode was hilarious, I loved it and it made me hard to breathe.
I loved it when you went "Finny Finny Fin-Fin", that made me smile! =)
This need more Silver Q- oh wait! err...this need more...Dr Wolf?
+Buc Reviewer :)
+Buc Reviewer Agreed....
FINN! HOW IS YOUR OC SO ADORABLE?! X3
I do believe Silver is a special kind of reviewer. He knows just how to piss of both sides of the Show. The Canon and the Fandom.
How else could a WHOLE town unite in such a way as to chase alongside their biggest fanatics after one hippogriff such as Silver-Quill?
Congratulations!!!
You have received a Hidden Ghost Platinum Trophy: MOST IRRITATING REVIEWER EVER TO THE MLP UNIVERSE!!!
Take it!!
Take it with Pride, Silver!!!
Later,
RDF2
Its also super unknown shadow trophy with extra cheese.
21:10 Ponytales, read by Scribbler.
That immediately popped into my head, the second I heard this.
20:13 Never mess with any alicorn. No matter how cute. Especially Lightning Bliss and her adorable face. /)03o(\
😕🙄Once again not really.
If there’s one thing I love, it’s gleefully geeking out over minuscule references that some people wouldn’t get.
This episode is my definition of heaven.
8:30 - I have to admit that I never bothered to watch "Dr. Who" until just last fall, when Retro TV started showing old Who eps with Dr. #1. I probably would've skipped them if not for Dr. Whooves, though.
WOO!! DAVID TENNANT!!!!!
Also, who else smiles so much when they hear "Slice of Life"? Just me? Okay.
P.S. Doesn't it surprise ANYONE that Discord wasn't in this episode?! WHERE IS KP?!? WERE'S MY SHIP?! WHERE THE F IS FEDEX?!?!
Of course, we all know the REAL reason Shining Armor cries at weddings...
The best of the crossover videos from the king of crossovers is a review of one of the most epic crossover episodes. So fitting. Love the insight on marriages. This is why I prefer sacramental marriages.
How'd I miss out on getting into review?! -_-
+Mary Corin that would have been one for the photo book
+Mary Corin and on that note i am off to deviant art
Normally does not compute jokes fall short for me (pun so inteded) but I think Camgoespony did a job good enough that it pulled through. Rest of the review was great too! Loved both the points brought up and the cameos brought in! Can't wait to see princess spike, even if it is a lackluster, if enjoyable episode. Keep up the good work!
Yay! The Dango Family! I love them! They're so CUTE!
Aaand you have once again proven that you're the best. ^^
This is SO MUCH better than the average episode review that comes out within a few days.
I almost went full nerd. I started a comment to protest that if you assault a time lord so soon after regenerating, he still has leftover regeneration energy and can recover. But then I realized just how fanboy it is to know this, and even moreso to point it out in a 'You are mistaken!' corrective manner.
Babbleplay The question is, though, would time lords work the exact same in equestria?
This review was probably the most ambitious crossover in MLP fandom history
cameos.... cameos everywhere..
Now I'm shure that Finn doesn't have the abillity to get angry. ;) Great Review as always Silver.
I wounder if Sliver have Insurance? He need Flo from Porgestive or The Geco form Gieco
He'd also need Jake from State Farm.
+GMSK 758 And the guy from Allstate.
+EdXLover1 And the guy from Farmer's
bumbadabum bada bum bum bum
+EdXLover1 And the guy from Farmer's
bumbadabum bada bum bum bum
English plz.
A strong review, that brings up some interesting points, laced with the wonderful humor i've come to expect. And abuse...always the abuse.
I agree with the point that I'd like to see more of the background characters. Maybe introduce one or two in some episodes, so that they become recurrent, but not ostentatious.
I think the references were fine. I have never seen the "Big Lobowski", but I still enjoyed the bowling scene.
I don't care how long it takes you, as long as you put the time and effort into making the quality material each episode deserves, we're all better or it.
I respect the fact that you don't rush out your reviews as soon as a new episode comes by just for the sake of timing.
I've gotta admit - I liked the Lyra/BonBon segments. While I do know there was no goal in mind for them, I've learned that sometimes it's the journey that matters most. (Look at Pinkie Apple Pie. The ending was a large anti-climax, while the rest of it was nothing short of hilarious.) And, besides, I couldn't help but just laugh at how inane BonBon's dialogue got, and how Lyra got more and more confused like the rest of us.
The segment I disliked the most was Steven Magnet's segment, however. Yes, I get that weddings are big businesses, but he could tell she was stressed out enough. In other words, he showed just as much tact as Rainbow Dash did during Pinkie Pride, except where it fits Rainbow, it doesn't fit Steven at all.
But, that's just my opinion. :P
this is the best video you've ever made, at least that I can remember. it legitimately made me "lol" several times.
7:55
I never watched doctor who but when I watched the 100 episode I still found it funny
oh my. Cameos!! cameos everywhere!!
Also am so happy that you think the special agent sweety brops thing make no sense.
silver I have an interesting theory/headcannon on the changling at the wedding maybe he's thorax
The Red Pearl l Nah. Thorax was sad because he had no friends, but Kevin clearly has friends, as he was invited to a wedding.
According to the staff, he's one of Matilda's friends.
Oh man you just brought EVERYONE to the table haha. A great episode
Ah who cares about the little girls watching the show, we never did then and we won't now. All that matters is a bunch of 30 year old neckbeard bronies get the references.
Edit: Lyra and Bon Bon are "friends". Sure that's what they were signifying whilst staring lovingly into each other eyes of what could possibly have been their last time together, not knowing when they'd see the other mare again, or how she could live without- ah-hem I got a bit carried off but you know what dat look in the ep was for.
And who cares about Garvity Falls!
I do,...
They been confirmed in the comics
I knew that some of the equations were actually pretty relevant in that scene but I never expected them all to be so relevant to the movement of a ball, someone who worked on that episode is really into physics :D Physics is the best science (In my opinion).
at 18:55 who is button mash sitting next to, and why is he staring at her?
i dont know 4 sure, but since their staring at each other its more than what sweetie belle and button mash had (he paid no attention to her)
remember this is a 'for the fans' episode and the fans/bronies/internet say they are. (tho i dont really care for much shipping mlp, except Scootadoption by rainbow dash)
+Josh Foster Slice of life doesn't make all fan made character relationships canon. Most likely the writers just didn't think of it or never heard of it.
+Josh Foster do keep in mind they shouldn't shoehorn an out of nwoehere offscreen romance for a major recurring character out of the blue, especially not one that would have basis in some easily missed bit in a single episode.
not to mention, a character should not be defined by who they romance, and shipping should not effect what goes on in the show itself.
+Josh Foster oh my celestia ... *starts writting awful ship-fiction about button and that fillly*
thank you for this it makes me feel so good especially the mad munchkin Mary Sue part this is true reference at its finest
THE DANGO FAMILY! XD #Clannad
I'm 100% the 2nd guy you showed XD I almost passed out more than once while explaining my love for a show. Singing songs, doing impressions, and explaining (with out spoiling to) plot.
Silver, have you ever heard of Protagonists-centered morality?
Because I definetaly didn't root for you in this episode.
*****
He is the reviewer who breaks the walls of cartoon to interactwith heroes. His reviews are episodes in which he is the protagonist.
In this episode he commited murder...twice. It was Doctor Whooves, but still.
*****
And yet, we should root for him. It's like in Spongebob episode"Demolition Doofus".
*****
Yeah...I think the same way.
I love your video. it is amazing, and i love your collabs in this episode and you sure an amazing analyst. thank you for your time.
Personally I've seen three different opinions on this episode: 1, "ERMAGEURD, BACKGROUND PONIES, BEST EPISODE EVAH!". 2, "God, this episode was nothing but pandering, worse than Double Rainboom, shark-jumping, worst episode ever!". And 3, "Eh, that was okay. Appreciate the thought, writers". All opinions I can completely understand, but I'm personally in the third opinion.
I know it's fanservice, but I still got some entertainment and surprises out of it, even if the story did feel all over the place. It's not my favourite episode or even one of my favourites but I'd gladly watch it again if I got the chance. But like Fiery Joker said in his own review, there's no way of coming up with an objective opinion on this episode. If you were never a fan of memes or background ponies or headcanons to come out of the fandom, this episode isn't gonna do anything to sway you. But if you're a hardcore fan who eats up anything MLP-related, chances are you'll find something to like.
But whether you like or hate Slice of Life, you gotta admit it is very impressive that a show called My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic reached 100 episodes. :)
Eh, not really.
If Johnny Test made it, mlp would have too lol
Best review ever I thought you'd never have mad munchkin in an after the fact. :D
11:30 oh my god it's Mary Sue.
16:21 BUTTONMASH YES!
I don't get the who refrences
Yeah that's pretty much how I acted with the Bon Bon thing lol XD
Also, the reason his name is Steven Magnet is because when people watched the episode he was in using youtube subtitles, it would come up as Steven Magnet when he talked. That pretty much became a meme in itself, along with other funny youtube subtitles.
Not only that but that eventually became his name in the toyline too.
the hell!!!!!! you did not have to kill Matt smith Pony!!!!!!
He didn't
Ahh... he did... he dropped an anvil on him
+Wad “the Eevee whovian” Wiswell All I could think was "Eli is gonna kill him."
+Wad “the Eevee whovian” Wiswell The Doctor (Pony) regenerated. You can not kill what can regenerate. Besides he got new kidneys even it does not like the color.
... you know that that means that he died... you do watch the show, right?
18:30 Who can say No to those faces?😂
So you're just gonna chill Doctor Who whenever you need to vent your rage also don't expect me to know these equations or what do you mean also did he said the force and pork also I watch Doctor Who and Star Wars set it OK we just need a link in a video please something that makes Luke or anybody Star Wars seriously
Nice video, I just never wanted it to stop! I just about laughed my guts out!