I kind of pity him. He probably doesn’t get enough attention at home, resulting in him to turn to social media and seek the approval of others. He’s so scared of being more than ignored that he does things that he doesn’t really care to do just for a chance to be noticed. Isn’t as tragic as the other Tw characters but something I wanted to point out Anyway I’m happy he got his ramen 🍜
I kinda agree with you. He mentions his mom, but no dad. Regardless of the situation, there is no other man in the house. Cater probably feels like he has no control and being the youngest doesn't help much.
I get your point, but doesn't that kind of contradict the fact that his sisters give him a lot of attention, especially on his birthday? Unless his sisters give him a lot of attention because he doesn't get enough of if it from his dad due to his job? Maybe they try to make it up for their dad, but at the end of it all he wants it from him the most. That could explain why he uses social media so much. Gosh, that's just something I thought of. This is getting deeper than I thought it would 😔 This also might explain the end of his cerimonial robe personal story too. Edit: I made a slight change to the original paragraph to clarify a bit more. Also, I'm glad he got to eat one of his favorite foods too! I think it's safe to say he still genuinely enjoyed his birthday celebration ☺️
From the way Cater talked about his sisters in past cards and stories, it made it seem like they were really mean. But this story seems to confirm the fact that while they didn't always take into account Cater's feelings at first and have a tendancy to be selfish, they're not bad sisters and had good intentions at least. They seem like Charlotte from The Princess and the Frog. A little self-absorbed and over the top, but really sweet and caring. Or at least I hope that's what they're like. Also, his older sisters getting so excited for their little brother's birthday is so cute! I can imagine them getting ready to celebrate their adorable little brother's birthday. Also, Cater has a mother or at least had a mother when he was ten at least! I wonder what happened to her since he doesn't talk about her as much as about his sisters or dad. If Trey knew about Cater's aversion to sweets, why did he bake a birthday cake for Cater? Was it to keep a secret from the other Heartslabyul members that Cater doesn't like sweets? Or Cater wanted the aesthetic of having a pretty birthday cake but he would use Trey's unique magic to change the flavor? Is Lilia singing about unrequited love a hint towards his past or it's just a popular song topic from the Valley of Thorns?
Trey can change the taste of foods so he probably don't mind it that much and like he said others doesn't know that he hates sweets and trying to hide it
I’m going to point out the fact that after Lilia gave Cater his phone case he asked for something in return. That’s a totally fae thing to do, just further proves Lilia is a type of fae. Or he’s just that kind of person lol. Idk
@@beigehues i was going to say the same thing but maybe they're beginning and figured that this would be spoiler free. edit: ig they're not new to tw and they forgot or something
LMAO i can imagine lilia growling while singing the lyrics of a sweet unrequited love 😂😂. Ahh i wanna see little cater with his sisters 💞. ALSO SAME I DON'T LIKE SWEETS TOO
Hehe! It's nice to see sad boi hours Cater happy ^^ Seriously, I don't know why but after putting his ceremony robes card on my home screen, he sounds so depressed :') Also, did Cater just ask us out at the end? 👉🏻👈🏻
“We will chat and eat sweets at the club room after school... To be honest, we rarely play any musical instruments during the club activities” ✨✨K-ON✨✨
Aww Happy Bday Cater! I feel bad cos I'm saving up gems for the masterchef event... Also, Lilia growling of an unrequited love song??? Why do I get the feeling its gonna be sth similar to Lana Del Ray's Once Upon a Dream?
Cater is so cute;;;; I LUV HIM-!!💕💕💘💘 When im looking foward about his story BD. It came out really good! Thx for ur hard work ayumi💖💖 ((One thing that make my heart go flatter is when cater talk to yuu about like 'date' agian. Cater pls😂💓)
Lilia singing about unrequited love made me really excited cuz I based my twst oc off of a headcanon that Lilia probably had his own "sleeping beauty" and I just- asksjsjsj
Can Geography class wait a little more? Obviously! _(Thank God I already know the book content)_ *Thank you for the translation, Ayui-san! Take care!* 😊
Ngl, I think Cater is the reason I discovered I prefer eating a lot of savory foods (or at least more “natural” sweets like fruits) more than desserts.
Can you give me tips for your golden hands?? i never got ssr as easy as you😭 (lol kidding, but I'll feel glad if you tell me😆) Cater is not my fav, but i love his attitude. He never speak ill of others even if he doesn't like it (like his sisters) although bc that he became accustomed to harboring his feelings☹️ his sisters is not that bad, they're just too pushy😌. And Lilia omg he's sooooo kind! Just like a sugar daddy who can grant all your wishes lol I hope we can get to hear Lilia sing his unrequited love song😂
Happy Birthday to the boy but this made me sad for him. It's telling he wants to go to a desert place even though he doesn't care for them just to get cute pics. Doing something because its popular and will get attention not because he wants it. I wonder if this is why he can do his clone magic. To surround himself with people
Cater's sisters and mother remind me a lot of my mother and other female relatives: always more excited for events in my life than I am, "extremely loud and incredibly close" when I want my 'personal space' bubble to be as big as possible. It took FOREVER for them to not get me stereotypical girly things for my birthdays, never mind the fact that I am the only one who prefers spicy/exotic foods out of my whole immediate family. Hmm... I guess after receiving the wrong kind of love and attention throughout his childhood (i.e. supportive but smothering affection, tailored towards girls), Cater's longing to capture his "MagiCam worthy life" is an attempt to establish individual identity. He's not among my favorite of the NRC boys, but I can relate to Cater on wanting to not be judged/pitied because of who he is related to.
@@zaok970 I'm so bored so I borrowed niftys phone so I can see what are these sinners are so fond of.Thats why also this grammar is crap.Because this is my first time using the so called phone they say.
I kind of pity him. He probably doesn’t get enough attention at home, resulting in him to turn to social media and seek the approval of others. He’s so scared of being more than ignored that he does things that he doesn’t really care to do just for a chance to be noticed. Isn’t as tragic as the other Tw characters but something I wanted to point out
Anyway I’m happy he got his ramen 🍜
I kinda agree with you. He mentions his mom, but no dad. Regardless of the situation, there is no other man in the house. Cater probably feels like he has no control and being the youngest doesn't help much.
@@biancajoffre2670 He mentioned in his Halloween personal story that his dad is a banker and because of that they usually moved a lot.
@@agnesterek7530 wow that makes me feel worse for him since he isn't able to establish long term relationships
@@biancajoffre2670 your comment kinda make think of some... Sad scenario 😥
I get your point, but doesn't that kind of contradict the fact that his sisters give him a lot of attention, especially on his birthday? Unless his sisters give him a lot of attention because he doesn't get enough of if it from his dad due to his job? Maybe they try to make it up for their dad, but at the end of it all he wants it from him the most. That could explain why he uses social media so much. Gosh, that's just something I thought of. This is getting deeper than I thought it would 😔 This also might explain the end of his cerimonial robe personal story too.
Edit: I made a slight change to the original paragraph to clarify a bit more. Also, I'm glad he got to eat one of his favorite foods too! I think it's safe to say he still genuinely enjoyed his birthday celebration ☺️
From the way Cater talked about his sisters in past cards and stories, it made it seem like they were really mean. But this story seems to confirm the fact that while they didn't always take into account Cater's feelings at first and have a tendancy to be selfish, they're not bad sisters and had good intentions at least. They seem like Charlotte from The Princess and the Frog. A little self-absorbed and over the top, but really sweet and caring. Or at least I hope that's what they're like. Also, his older sisters getting so excited for their little brother's birthday is so cute! I can imagine them getting ready to celebrate their adorable little brother's birthday. Also, Cater has a mother or at least had a mother when he was ten at least! I wonder what happened to her since he doesn't talk about her as much as about his sisters or dad.
If Trey knew about Cater's aversion to sweets, why did he bake a birthday cake for Cater? Was it to keep a secret from the other Heartslabyul members that Cater doesn't like sweets? Or Cater wanted the aesthetic of having a pretty birthday cake but he would use Trey's unique magic to change the flavor?
Is Lilia singing about unrequited love a hint towards his past or it's just a popular song topic from the Valley of Thorns?
who knows? maybe riddle demanded a cake as one of the rules
Cater mentioned in his SSR Halloween that his dad is a banker and they moved a lot
Trey can change the taste of foods so he probably don't mind it that much and like he said others doesn't know that he hates sweets and trying to hide it
i think lilia just likes me to be Metal 🤘lol
I’m going to point out the fact that after Lilia gave Cater his phone case he asked for something in return. That’s a totally fae thing to do, just further proves Lilia is a type of fae. Or he’s just that kind of person lol. Idk
I think Lilia is just the kind of person to do that, because I think Ruggie or Azul would also do something like that in a way.
I literally wrote a essay for cater
Hes such a comfort character😦
Cater will be so proud of you >w< ♦️✨
Ayo where’s the essay?
@@lefandomtrash7746 in a twisted wonderland discord
Theres a cater bot fhere and i
Our phone addict looks so handsome
Wow, a little plot twist! Never expected for Carter to dislike sweets. However, salty food seems to suit more his character.
@@beigehues i was going to say the same thing but maybe they're beginning and figured that this would be spoiler free.
edit: ig they're not new to tw and they forgot or something
LMAO i can imagine lilia growling while singing the lyrics of a sweet unrequited love 😂😂. Ahh i wanna see little cater with his sisters 💞. ALSO SAME I DON'T LIKE SWEETS TOO
Well, at least Cater won’t steal any tarts from Riddle.😂😂😂
P.S. Thank you))🖤❤️🖤
I was actually kinda worried of his card, almost all birthday bois are eathing cake or tarts and Cater explains he hates sweets in chapter 1
Hehe! It's nice to see sad boi hours Cater happy ^^
Seriously, I don't know why but after putting his ceremony robes card on my home screen, he sounds so depressed :')
Also, did Cater just ask us out at the end? 👉🏻👈🏻
Yesyesyesyes!!!! 😭😭😭
“We will chat and eat sweets at the club room after school... To be honest, we rarely play any musical instruments during the club activities”
✨✨K-ON✨✨
I was having a really bad day so this really sheered me up,Happy birthday Cater! And thank you for making my day better
Aww Happy Bday Cater! I feel bad cos I'm saving up gems for the masterchef event...
Also, Lilia growling of an unrequited love song??? Why do I get the feeling its gonna be sth similar to Lana Del Ray's Once Upon a Dream?
It's best boys birthday 🎂 yaaaayyyy
he's so confident I love him
Cater is so cute;;;; I LUV HIM-!!💕💕💘💘
When im looking foward about his story BD. It came out really good! Thx for ur hard work ayumi💖💖 ((One thing that make my heart go flatter is when cater talk to yuu about like 'date' agian. Cater pls😂💓)
Thanks for the new translations! Cater has always been one of my favorites and I'm grateful to learn more about him.
I hope they give some good story behind Sebek for his birthday besides "WAKASAMAAAA" because I liked learning about Cater. thanks for translating!
Hold up i didn't even know that it's his bday and know you've translated it already
AGHH THANK YOUU. I wanted to play the gatcha but I've been saving for azul birthday later😭✋️
Thank you so much for your translation! And Happy birthday Cay-kun 🎉🎉
Lilia singing about unrequited love made me really excited cuz I based my twst oc off of a headcanon that Lilia probably had his own "sleeping beauty" and I just- asksjsjsj
Now that i read the card story, i want to have his bd card so bad, but I also need to save up for Azuls bd and the upcoming event :'(
Uwaahhh, this is Godsent! Cay-kun's one of my faves
Thank you for translating this and keep up the good work~!
(also, please take some time to rest😊)
I will❤️Thank you for caring😚
Yes otome ayui translatess
I have waited for someone to do it-
OMG!!! Cafe, Sweets, Free food and best of all a date with Cater!! Hell Yeah!!! Let's go!!
I’m melting,, he deserves the best!
I didn't have his birthday card😔
@@OtomeAyui oh my,, really? Wahh that’s a okey then! Don’t worry about it! I’ll look it up somewhere then 💕 thanks for your hard work
Thank Uuuuuuu❤❤✨
And Happy Birthday Cater-sempaii!! 🥳🥳❤✨
I've been waiting for this. Thank you very much Ayui-san😍😍😍
for a second I thought he said " I feel sad when I eat ramen"
Now that’s just sad. Ramen is comfort food...
Ilr
I got cater SSR birthday and I'm so happy...thank you for the translation Ayui-san✨✨
I LOVE HIM SO MUCH
Happy B-Day, Cater! Best Wishes!
cater is such a sweet heart forcing himself to eat sweet to make his family happy
I wanna be like him in the last picture✨, I wanna it eat a spicy rameeeeeeen🔥
I LOVE THIS SO MUCH!!
Can Geography class wait a little more? Obviously! _(Thank God I already know the book content)_
*Thank you for the translation, Ayui-san! Take care!* 😊
I will🙈💞
Never been so early 😭
Happy Birthday Cay-kun!!! 🎁🎊🎉 🍜
Ahhhh yes the trio of light music club I love it
Thanks for the video, it was fun and I love knowing that he and lilia are good friends 😆😁
3 mins ago! Wow, I didn't even have my notifications on 😲😳
His birthday card is so cuuuttteee😆💜💜
Yay!! Happy Birthday, Carter! We all luv you.
Happy Birthday to our spicy Magicam boy!
Yesss I didn't get him but I well enjoy the story
Oh so Cater like pop love song too, I’m kinda happy that we share the something I like...
Ngl, I think Cater is the reason I discovered I prefer eating a lot of savory foods (or at least more “natural” sweets like fruits) more than desserts.
AHHH IM A BIT EARLY
HAPPY BIRTHDAY CATER🎉😊
I wake up late but that doesn't stop me from clicking this💕💕
Arigatou~❤️ onee~san🥰
Happy Birthday to our magicam boy🥳
3:12 so in short Kalim, Lilia and Cater are the K-ON version of TW
🙇♀️🙇♀️Thank you for the translations🙇♀️🙇♀️
Happy birthday, Cater~ *Kiss😘💕*
Also, today is my mom's birthday~
Happy Birthday to your mom🤗❤️
@@OtomeAyui Thank you very much~😘💕
I MISSED YOUR VIDEOS YUI SAMA, TYSM 😭❤
Today us my birthday too!
So.....Let's celebrate our birthday together, Cater-kun!!!!!!!
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜
Happy Birthday to you🤗❤️
Happy b-day!
@@TheHeebeeJeebees
Thanx!!
😊😊😊😊
@@OtomeAyui
Thanx!!!
😊😊😊😊
happe birth
YEAHHHH HAPPY BIRTHDAY CATER!!!
whe-where am i???
Ah right, paradise :D
i love Cater so much 😭😭
thank you for the translation again!!
❤️❤️❤️❤️
Thanks for this video😍❤
but when we see igenhard ?
1st early and he is so amazing
Can you give me tips for your golden hands?? i never got ssr as easy as you😭 (lol kidding, but I'll feel glad if you tell me😆) Cater is not my fav, but i love his attitude. He never speak ill of others even if he doesn't like it (like his sisters) although bc that he became accustomed to harboring his feelings☹️ his sisters is not that bad, they're just too pushy😌. And Lilia omg he's sooooo kind! Just like a sugar daddy who can grant all your wishes lol I hope we can get to hear Lilia sing his unrequited love song😂
Sometimes I'm lucky sometimes I'm not😔I remember drawing for the Halloween gacha but I didn't got any of the SSR until my 100 pull HAHAHAHA
@@OtomeAyui omg 100 pull for Halloween but still don't get you want??😭😭 Surely halloween gacha in a disaster *sending virtual hug*
Happy Birthday, Cater!!
Thank you
Carter’s voice somehow reminds me of Asmo’s voice. (Obey Me!) I’m not sure why tho, to me their voices are similar I guess…
Cafe date lets go!
Happy birthday to Cater!!
Uwaaa im late!
Btw, i saw a lot of fanart that they’re cooking, is there any event or something? :0
new event this month
I salute your efforts 😌✊
Well thank you😌💞
AAAAAAAA Cater ma boyyyy!!!! Happy birthday!! Thank you Ayui san for translating this 🙏😄
Also, why did he tell some sad stories on his birthday?? 😢😢
DATE WITH CATER 🥴💜
ケイくんかっこいいー
Awww yeah. Thanks!
Happy Birthday to the boy but this made me sad for him. It's telling he wants to go to a desert place even though he doesn't care for them just to get cute pics. Doing something because its popular and will get attention not because he wants it. I wonder if this is why he can do his clone magic. To surround himself with people
Cater's sisters and mother remind me a lot of my mother and other female relatives: always more excited for events in my life than I am, "extremely loud and incredibly close" when I want my 'personal space' bubble to be as big as possible. It took FOREVER for them to not get me stereotypical girly things for my birthdays, never mind the fact that I am the only one who prefers spicy/exotic foods out of my whole immediate family.
Hmm... I guess after receiving the wrong kind of love and attention throughout his childhood (i.e. supportive but smothering affection, tailored towards girls), Cater's longing to capture his "MagiCam worthy life" is an attempt to establish individual identity. He's not among my favorite of the NRC boys, but I can relate to Cater on wanting to not be judged/pitied because of who he is related to.
Happy birthday babe
Amen 😌✋
Yay blogger boi is here
I.....don't how to say this....😓
Especially, i can't tell if he was happy... Oh well
Me and Magicam boy(Cater) birthday today👀👉🏻👈🏻🍃
Happy Birthday!!! ❤️❤️❤️
Why is your luck so good? 🥲😭
Well I bet I'm not going to get any SSR on my next gacha if I'm this lucky now-
3:35 lilia is an emo abdjajsj
Still haven't gotten cater's card yet😔😔
I hope you get him soon❤️
4:13 guess cater is Naruto fan 😂😂
Why does one watch anything?Sheer absolute boredom.
Well, well, well, looks like a killer from the 1920s is something of a weeb himself
@@zaok970 I'm so bored so I borrowed niftys phone so I can see what are these sinners are so fond of.Thats why also this grammar is crap.Because this is my first time using the so called phone they say.
I am speed
Happy birthday to Cater!!