@@jameskelly5685He can be prickly but that's absolutely not true. In fact, probably the most admirable thing about him as a reviewer is that he loves reviewing more affordable stuff and being able to point people in the direction of more affordable vinyl playback systems that still sound great.
I doubt they will do a stereo as the stereo masters are not only apparently worn out but highly treasured by the label. Hey sometimes crazy things happen.
People would even settle for cutting from 1:1 copies of the masters if tape wear is a concern. That would surely be a reasonable compromise for a stereo AAA set since those tapes surely are heavily played. Given how the people mostly interested in mono are die-hard Beatles fans, I doubt recutting from the mono tapes is that big a deal. Those tapes rarely ever got used after the 70's, hence why I bet they still sounded so good in 2014.
with the singles added to the tracklisting of each album instead of mono masters. Imagine With the Beatles with she loves you and hold your hand singles. PPM with From me to you etc.
Both a reissue of the 2014 monos and a new set of analog stereos would be supreme. I have most of the 2014 monos already but I’d love a set of new analog stereo recordings.
Thanks for this honest, in depth review Mike. As a record store owner who is a casual Beatles fan at best, I want to be able to give my customers an honest opinion when they ask our thoughts on these new releases. Obviously, they will sell regardless, but it's nice to be able to let people know they will have no worries when they buy these (other than them being dirty). We really do appreciate the work and time you put into this review. Billy-
The track list of Meet The Beatles is a great introduction to a new band. Especially compared to the track listing of the UK Please Please Me record. Just my opinion.
I really like this take. I postponed ordering my box until I got a chance to see reviews and listen for myself. I went and picked up the Target Exclusive "Meet the Beatles" on launch day, cleaned it and listened to it. Honestly to me it started out "grating' or "shrill" (Mainly A1). But then when I considered what they were play homage to and listened through the rest, I realized that this box isn't about being the "definitive Beatles collection" it's about being the "definitive Beatles US VERSION collection". Then I got it! So I'm glad to hear this take. Are these sonic masterpieces suited for audiophile equip demoing? No; but they are the best, new, clean, quality pressings of a nostalgic set LPs that mean a lot to a lot of people. And for that reason, I went ahead and ordered my box. Keep up the great reviews Mike!!!
They’re a sonic revelation compared to the original US Capitol records. I compared Meet the Beatles with a US 1st, and the original was hot garbage compared to the new ‘24 release.
I'm very happy with this release! I didn't even have to use the HumminGuru, ran a brush across them and they are some of the quietest records I have NO surface noise. My pre-order locally was cancelled so I was able to get one in two days from Amazon.
Thanks for the stellar review Mike. I was in high school when the Beatles hit and we never heard anything like them. First heard them on AM radio through my transistor radio. We never heard the word audiophile or stressed over which version sounded best. It was the music itself that appealed to us, we didn't think about the sound quality. These Capital releases are what we got and so new improved versions of them are very appealing to a lot of us. For me, this is not a "money grab", but rather a chance to improve upon one of our childhoods pleasures. I'm glad they're here.
Great video again. I'm a fan of Beatles early releases because they were still a rock n roll band. At this time (1964-65) they still gave concerts, so they were an alive band. Afterwards they were closed at Abbey road studios and their songs became more beautiful but soulless. I live for the day AI will allow Star Cub sessions to be remastered in good audiable quality.
Great, insightful review! These new 1964 Capitol releases are very good. They're good to have as the 2014 mono LPs are now the price of a king's ransom.
The later albums weren’t chopped up in the US. From Pepper onwards, the US and UK albums were identical, aside from MMT of course, which were different formats. I bought the CDs in the nineties and I’m used to the UK track listings and prefer those, but I like to listen to the Capitol on occasion. Tbh, I like the album tracks better than the “hits” from ‘63-‘64, so the UK albums will probably always be my personal go-to.
I'm sure the box set is great, but $299 for it? Come on Capital! But...who am I kidding? I'll buy it. There's something about buying Beatles records at Christmas time. No words needed.
Thanks for the review Mike! Do you know if there is typically a difference in pressing quality between the box set versions and individually purchased pressings? All of the reviews that I've seen of this box set thus far have been mostly positive, but I don't have the box set yet to compare. I did purchase an individual black vinyl copy of Meet the Beatles, and it's slightly dish-warped (which could just be bad luck), but notably, the last track in Side 1 'All My Loving' seems to sound distorted to me, especially noticeable in the vocal. Even more so than my VG+ 1964 Mono Scranton pressing, which sounds cleaner on that particular track. Does your copy of Meet The Beatles from the box set exhibit any distortion on 'All My Loving'? For what it's worth, I have the Let It Be Box set from 2021 as well as an individual pressing release of the same release, and the vinyl in that box set sounds better to me than the individually purchased copy. Just wondering if they generally put better pressings, or take more care with the vinyl that goes into the box sets vs. individual pressings, or if I've just had bad luck?
I really an enjoying the Capital reissues . Thats what us fans wanted since i grew up on them. I like the sound differences. I hope u sell alot of them..
Thanks for your review. UK based so bought "Second Album" as the one which seemed to be the great selection out of the Dexter revisions. Difficult to do "like to like" but I appreciate that, for 64-66, this is the alternate history and that's fascinating.
I would like to know how the new vinyl reissues compare to the 2004 CD box set "The Capitol Albums Vol.1" ? In that set, each CD contained both the stereo and mono versions of an album on one CD.
Bought Meet the Beatles as I’ve always wanted an original copy. Heard it was pressed from the tapes so I bought it. Really happy with the Sound. Might eventually get Second Album and ‘65
I went with the individual copies! The box set was way too expensive. I’ve been watching various videos on the box set and many say the same thing it’s not worth it. I’m glad that I went with my gut and bought them individually.
I ALWAYS listen to recording's from front to back! It just feels like I'm enjoying the work as a whole , no matter what the situation! I'm just geared that way! Even when I stream Quobuz, (which is much rarer than LP) I listen front to back! Unless it's a playlist!😊
I would say the album configurations used by Capitol was a way to squeeze out more LPs from the band’s output…an important consideration for the label, to make up for the absence of EP sales in the US market.
If you've ever heard the original Capitol albums and/or you don't demand audiophile quality, you'll be happy with the new US mono releases. I bought the albums individually and they were all clean except for Something New which had a piece of vinyl debris in the sleeve which scratched the hell out of the record.
I purchased an individual release of the '64 release,& I love it. 29.98$ much cheaper than the box set. It was lacking some bass. I adjusted it to perfection 👌. Also, the box set had no goodies inside them. Mine does. I also do not have the 2014 release. Anyway great review.
Hi. It's Eliot Wien from NY. My only comments about this box set is that it doesn't really need to be analyzed or put under a microscope. The packaging is great quality, and the liner notes by Bruce Spizer are great! As Beatle collectors we're not expecting new songs. They will re-release the same Beatle songs over and over. This is an item to just enjoy. Everybody has the right to choose what they want to purchase, The only thing as Beatle collectors that we have to look forward to is Live recordings or Demos which will probably be released in the form of box sets.
Thanks for the video Mike, as a UK listener I agree they do sound good and punchy for what they were intended to do for Capitol - sell records to young people. Unfortunately my set had skipping on 4 of the discs, 1 of which wasn't flat. They all looked clean though, unlike yours, and the box and sleeves were all perfect. Has the French record plant had issues in the past with bad pressings?
What I can't understand is why this box set is listed as $530 in Canada, vs the $300 price tag for the US. Even with the usual 1.4 exchange rate we would be paying over $100 more in Canada. The individual albums are all $54 on the official website. We always pay more but this is extra and I can't figure out why.
As a Beatles fan growing up with the original American albums and 45s (which is my preferred way of listening to them), the LAST quality I would want to hear from any medium is a "cleanliness") It was the sheer noise, the ambience that pervaded their sound that made them so wonderful to get into.
I picked up “Beatles ‘65” and “Hard Days Night”, I thought they sounded great, vinyl is stone silent, but I also noticed they are really loud. The volume on my receiver is pretty much at the same level for most of my records, I found I had to turn these two down quite a bit. They didn’t sound distorted or anything, just really loud. Is that a modern mastering thing or just how the originals sounded? The only original I have is “Meet The Beatles”, but it’s the stereo version.
I was lucky enough to get the single releases of Beatles For Sale , Sgt. Pepper and The White Album monos in 2014 when they were released individually. No way I could afford the whole box set back then. As far as this box set goes im just getting Meet The Beatles and maybe Something New. After hearing the UK versions years ago I just couldn't go back to the Capitol versions.
I got MTB and 2nd Album, just to try 'em. MTB arrived with a warp and I'll send it back. But 2nd Album is pretty nice. I have all the U.S. albums (80s pressings) in Stereo so nothing really to compare to. I'm not really a Mono guy. Was just curious.
Looking forward to your Doors box set review, although I feel like there may be a bit of bias since your doing business with Kevin if I'm being honest...we shall see.
I just got the target meet the Beatles blue vinyl, sadly warped a little bit, so I’m going to return it and hopefully get one that’s perfect, since that’s what I’m paying for
Initially, you stated that the copy of "Meet The Beatles" which was in your box set had non-fill. What happened with that????????? OK. I found a common problem with 2 different copies of the mono "Meet The Beatles" album. I bought a black vinyl copy from Amazon and the exclusive color vinyl copy from Target. Although all of the writing scribed in the deadwax is identical, what separates them is that the color vinyl version on Side 1 has the MPO logo with stamped numbers following. So, they are from different stampers. The common flaw is just before the first track, Side 1, "I Want To Hold Your Hand", there is a pop. Visibly, I can't see it on the record, although I can hear it. Moving the record, slowly, by hand, where the pop is, it doesn't show up either, like a normal flaw might. After digitizing it as a wav file, I looked at the blown-up graph of the flaw. It was definitely there. And, remember this was one 2 separate copies. This means that the flaw could go back to the original lacquer and all made from that lacquer are flawed. The scribed, identical, matrix number in the deadwax is: M2 MTB P56 0060246819718 . A . Ki R @ EAST IRiS The Target color vinyl exclusive adds: MPO 24 349482
Will these be released on CD? I noticed on Amazon there was a box set of this on CD but it was released earlier this year and originates from China....
The most extreme example of a "well-polished turd" that I can think of!!! Stereo tape re-equed and sometimes slathered with echo, then folded to mono. If I ran Apple or Universal this box would not even exist.
Now that I have and love The Beatles 1964 US Box Set Mono and the Roll Stones Mono Box Set. I would love to see a British Invasion 64-65 US Mono Box Set to complete the era. It might include a Book on the British Invasion and any subset of these: The Dave Clark Five "American Tour US" 1964 Mono The Searchers "Needles & Pins" US 1964 Mono The Hollies "Here I Go Again" US 1964 Mono The Animals "The Animals" US 1964 Mono The Kinks "You Really Got Me" 1964 US Mono The Yardbirds "For Your Love" 1965 US Mono The Byrds "Mr. Tambourine Man" 1965 Mono The Zombies "The Zombies" 1965 US Mono The Turtles "It Ain’t Me Babe" 1965 Mono That would be one Heck of a GREAT BOX SET.
I bought Something new. The packaging is great but there are 4 or 5 tracks that are the same mix as the British version (in mono which I have already) I bought this because it's supposed to be the American version. I feel ripped off. If I'm listening from the other room it doesn't bug me but when I do listen in the same room its got that flat murky sound to me. I have the CD version of the first four US Capitol albums which are honestly the best as they have both versions of each album in mono and stereo side by side on the same disc. In truth what I want is the stereo American versions with voices on one channel and backing tracks on the other. This is what I grew up with. The booklet inside the jacket tells you (after you've purchased it) that some of the tracks are the British version. Buyer beware. These are not really what you think they are. It's similar to what they did with the CD box that has the band pictured in front of an American flag. Track listing was like the US version but mixes are mostly the same as the British versions. I prefer to hear the stereo versions anyway because I can hear more of the drums and top end etc.
The only way you can truly compare these is vs the original US, didn’t they also added reverb to these for the US market? If so they will sound different beyond the track listings.
You have to read between the lines and not be emotional buying records.. yes the albums are the best versions of the capital records but is it worth owning this box set ...i pulled my order online because like many other beatles releases and this ..its not what the people want. Let's face reality. We all want the 2014 mono releases... and people ive learnt the hard way, dont emotional buy records just to have them, 1. only buy what you love and 2. what stands the test of time. Solid engineered albums and musically impeccable albums.
@@mazzysmusicooops… I ordered just one to test the waters and landed on ‘65. I almost went with Hard Day’s Night, but decided I prefer more of the songs on ‘65.
My sonic review: 'Meet The Beatles' is a disappointment. Sounds like someone threw a blanket over my speakers. But from 'The Second Beatles' Album' on, the sound is more open and dynamic. Some might say a little 'bright', but I'm a treble guy. I wanted the box, so sue me: I paid big bucks for the inclusion of 'The Beatles' Story'. Thanks for your review.
Hi Mike, my OG Monos are in excellent condition so I don't feel these new releases blow the OG's away. And I did not compare to my UK mono's as I don't think that's a fair comparison given Capitol were not given master tapes from Martin anyway. These were cut to sound as the OG's did. I heard the new as slightly better..thanks and keep rockN
OK. Please stop the Capitol’s versions to call as US issues of the UK origins. These are really just compilations, Not less,however, not even more at all ! Easy, take it or leave it.
If you really want to compare the reissue vinyl, I would honestly suggest comparing them to the early 2000’s Capitol Albums CD sets which used the same tapes (except for ‘A Hard Day’s Night’, but you can mostly use “Something New” for that, as George Martin made the same mixes available to UA and Capitol). If you’re lucky enough to run across a “Dr. Ebbetts” edition of the US Singles Collection you can judge the remaining tracks - they are very faithful reproductions of the best original copies that could be sourced.
The Beatles' Story belongs in there but the box should cost more like $230. The market is in a different place than it was in 2014 but these albums are also in less demand than the UK albums. Selling a smaller box reduces Apple's risk.
People who buy these records expecting them to be AUDIOPHILE records will be dissatisfied They sound better than the original records but they aren’t audiophile records
Of course not the purpose of the box but I think it would have been cool to have ran some sort of crazy campaign in which they used the mono masters but kept the American song order. That would have made great sounding American versions with the American covers still used. Call it “The American Capitol Albums UnDextorized” or maybe “American Beatles …Naked” ..oh..wait..that’s been used. What’s up with making the Beatles look like Veruca Salt from Willy Wonka on Meet The Beatles? Good gosh color match that one guys.
Hey Beatle fiends! Buy this watered down product that you probably already own (who knows..multiple copies of??) so that I can continue to pay my Ex off! Hard pass...
I got the “Hard Days Night” man alive it sounds atrocious. Sounds like AM radio. Also, I have a ton of inner groove distortion. I think this set is just kinda….blah. Like most Beatles releases these days. I am disappointed. It’s interesting for a deep Beatles fan, which I am….but these do not sound real good at all to me. I feel like this was a shill. These are going to go for dirt cheap in about 1 year. Just wait until the market is flooded. Btw, This highly allocated business is silly. Amazon selling no problem. Allocated maybe for indies because Apple scruffs just want easy distribution.
Great video as always. Comparing any version of the US albums to anything UK is useless. It’s like comparing apples and hammers. This is not an audiophile release and shouldn’t be compared as such. It destroys the original US albums. Period. Stop.
Great video again. I'm a fan of Beatles early releases because they were still a rock n roll band. At this time (1964-65) they still gave concerts, so they were an alive band. Afterwards they were closed at Abbey road studios and their songs became more beautiful but soulless. I live for the day AI will allow Star Cub sessions to be remastered in good audiable quality.
You know a product is good when Esposito and Fremer actually agree on something
Well the label should certainly sigh in relief
@ginntonic123 Yeah, Fremer is a an audio snob. If it's not $20,000, don't bother me!
@@jameskelly5685He can be prickly but that's absolutely not true. In fact, probably the most admirable thing about him as a reviewer is that he loves reviewing more affordable stuff and being able to point people in the direction of more affordable vinyl playback systems that still sound great.
@@davidbixenspan1909hack
They really need to just release the 2014 mono box set again or release a stereo box set...enough with this nonsense
I doubt they will do a stereo as the stereo masters are not only apparently worn out but highly treasured by the label. Hey sometimes crazy things happen.
never gonna happen. They'll release them 1 by 1 as exclusives in expensive box sets. They've already done that with the last few albums.
People would even settle for cutting from 1:1 copies of the masters if tape wear is a concern. That would surely be a reasonable compromise for a stereo AAA set since those tapes surely are heavily played.
Given how the people mostly interested in mono are die-hard Beatles fans, I doubt recutting from the mono tapes is that big a deal. Those tapes rarely ever got used after the 70's, hence why I bet they still sounded so good in 2014.
with the singles added to the tracklisting of each album instead of mono masters. Imagine With the Beatles with she loves you and hold your hand singles. PPM with From me to you etc.
Both a reissue of the 2014 monos and a new set of analog stereos would be supreme. I have most of the 2014 monos already but I’d love a set of new analog stereo recordings.
Mike thanks for all the great content!
Can’t wait for your doors review!
Many thanks Mike and all at The In Groove!! This set is a trip...
Good morning DBD, have a great day brother.
Blessings
Thanks for this honest, in depth review Mike. As a record store owner who is a casual Beatles fan at best, I want to be able to give my customers an honest opinion when they ask our thoughts on these new releases. Obviously, they will sell regardless, but it's nice to be able to let people know they will have no worries when they buy these (other than them being dirty). We really do appreciate the work and time you put into this review. Billy-
The track list of Meet The Beatles is a great introduction to a new band. Especially compared to the track listing of the UK Please Please Me record. Just my opinion.
Thanks, Mike! Honest review. Ordered something new from you since it actually was my favorite childhood record ever.
I really like this take. I postponed ordering my box until I got a chance to see reviews and listen for myself. I went and picked up the Target Exclusive "Meet the Beatles" on launch day, cleaned it and listened to it. Honestly to me it started out "grating' or "shrill" (Mainly A1). But then when I considered what they were play homage to and listened through the rest, I realized that this box isn't about being the "definitive Beatles collection" it's about being the "definitive Beatles US VERSION collection". Then I got it! So I'm glad to hear this take. Are these sonic masterpieces suited for audiophile equip demoing? No; but they are the best, new, clean, quality pressings of a nostalgic set LPs that mean a lot to a lot of people. And for that reason, I went ahead and ordered my box. Keep up the great reviews Mike!!!
They’re a sonic revelation compared to the original US Capitol records. I compared Meet the Beatles with a US 1st, and the original was hot garbage compared to the new ‘24 release.
Wash a new album why?
I'm very happy with this release! I didn't even have to use the HumminGuru, ran a brush across them and they are some of the quietest records I have NO surface noise. My pre-order locally was cancelled so I was able to get one in two days from Amazon.
Same with my copy it was extremely clean out of the poly sleeve. Plays extremely quiet.
Thanks for the review Mike. Looking forward to getting my boxset, hopefully this week! 🤞
Beatles Second is their best rock and roll album. Period. ✌🏻❤️🔥
@@mazzysmusic true Mazzy
Lookout, he said PERIOD so no comments
@@spindly79yea don’t question the jewish boomer liberal, you’ll get canceled.
Thank you for this nice testimony! A pragmatic and pleasant review : )
Thanks for the stellar review Mike. I was in high school when the Beatles hit and we never heard anything like them. First heard them on AM radio through my transistor radio. We never heard the word audiophile or stressed over which version sounded best. It was the music itself that appealed to us, we didn't think about the sound quality. These Capital releases are what we got and so new improved versions of them are very appealing to a lot of us. For me, this is not a "money grab", but rather a chance to improve upon one of our childhoods pleasures. I'm glad they're here.
Great video again. I'm a fan of Beatles early releases because they were still a rock n roll band. At this time (1964-65) they still gave concerts, so they were an alive band. Afterwards they were closed at Abbey road studios and their songs became more beautiful but soulless. I live for the day AI will allow Star Cub sessions to be remastered in good audiable quality.
Great, insightful review! These new 1964 Capitol releases are very good. They're good to have as the 2014 mono LPs are now the price of a king's ransom.
I grew up with the red double album being my only exposure to early Beatles prior to Rubber Soul. I'm going to have to put these on my Christmas list
Thanks for your review, Mike!
The later albums weren’t chopped up in the US. From Pepper onwards, the US and UK albums were identical, aside from MMT of course, which were different formats.
I bought the CDs in the nineties and I’m used to the UK track listings and prefer those, but I like to listen to the Capitol on occasion. Tbh, I like the album tracks better than the “hits” from ‘63-‘64, so the UK albums will probably always be my personal go-to.
I'm sure the box set is great, but $299 for it? Come on Capital! But...who am I kidding? I'll buy it. There's something about buying Beatles records at Christmas time. No words needed.
Thanks for the review Mike!
Do you know if there is typically a difference in pressing quality between the box set versions and individually purchased pressings?
All of the reviews that I've seen of this box set thus far have been mostly positive, but I don't have the box set yet to compare.
I did purchase an individual black vinyl copy of Meet the Beatles, and it's slightly dish-warped (which could just be bad luck), but notably, the last track in Side 1 'All My Loving' seems to sound distorted to me, especially noticeable in the vocal. Even more so than my VG+ 1964 Mono Scranton pressing, which sounds cleaner on that particular track.
Does your copy of Meet The Beatles from the box set exhibit any distortion on 'All My Loving'?
For what it's worth, I have the Let It Be Box set from 2021 as well as an individual pressing release of the same release, and the vinyl in that box set sounds better to me than the individually purchased copy.
Just wondering if they generally put better pressings, or take more care with the vinyl that goes into the box sets vs. individual pressings, or if I've just had bad luck?
I really an enjoying the Capital reissues . Thats what us fans wanted since i grew up on them. I like the sound differences. I hope u sell alot of them..
Hi Michael, great video.
Thank you for all of your hard work.
Have a wonderful Thanksgiving!
Am I thankful for you
I'm more into the psychedelic era of The Beatles 😂 Good sell job !!!!!
Financially I'll have to stick with my mini album sleeve CDs from ten or so years ago but these do look very nice.
These new Capitols are a fun listen..nuff said. Apple and orange dude!
Thanks Mike for the sharing your thoughts on the new set. Nicely done. Hope you are able to get more sets in to make up for your loss. Take care!
Thanks for your review. UK based so bought "Second Album" as the one which seemed to be the great selection out of the Dexter revisions. Difficult to do "like to like" but I appreciate that, for 64-66, this is the alternate history and that's fascinating.
I would like to know how the new vinyl reissues compare to the 2004 CD box set "The Capitol Albums Vol.1" ? In that set, each CD contained both the stereo and mono versions of an album on one CD.
Bought Meet the Beatles as I’ve always wanted an original copy. Heard it was pressed from the tapes so I bought it. Really happy with the Sound. Might eventually get Second Album and ‘65
I went with the individual copies! The box set was way too expensive. I’ve been watching various videos on the box set and many say the same thing it’s not worth it. I’m glad that I went with my gut and bought them individually.
I ALWAYS listen to recording's from front to back! It just feels like I'm enjoying the work as a whole , no matter what the situation! I'm just geared that way! Even when I stream Quobuz, (which is much rarer than LP) I listen front to back! Unless it's a playlist!😊
So in the end the new versions are really good terrible albums! Got it! ❤
One reviewer (Norman Maslov aka Mazzy) referred to the U.S. Beatles releases as compilations. And I thought, OMG, that's right!
Who's that?
A snob. I don’t trust anything he says
UK Compilations*, it cant be a compilation if they were still in many ways new records to the US audience
He’s a insufferable libtard boomer
I would say the album configurations used by Capitol was a way to squeeze out more LPs from the band’s output…an important consideration for the label, to make up for the absence of EP sales in the US market.
If you've ever heard the original Capitol albums and/or you don't demand audiophile quality, you'll be happy with the new US mono releases. I bought the albums individually and they were all clean except for Something New which had a piece of vinyl debris in the sleeve which scratched the hell out of the record.
I purchased an individual release of the '64 release,& I love it. 29.98$ much cheaper than the box set. It was lacking some bass. I adjusted it to perfection 👌. Also, the box set had no goodies inside them. Mine does. I also do not have the 2014 release.
Anyway great review.
Hi. It's Eliot Wien from NY. My only comments about this box set is that it doesn't really need to be analyzed or put under a microscope. The packaging is great quality, and the liner notes by Bruce Spizer are great! As Beatle collectors we're not expecting new songs. They will re-release the same Beatle songs over and over. This is an item to just enjoy. Everybody has the right to choose what they want to purchase, The only thing as Beatle collectors that we have to look forward to is Live recordings or Demos which will probably be released in the form of box sets.
Thanks for the video Mike, as a UK listener I agree they do sound good and punchy for what they were intended to do for Capitol - sell records to young people. Unfortunately my set had skipping on 4 of the discs, 1 of which wasn't flat. They all looked clean though, unlike yours, and the box and sleeves were all perfect. Has the French record plant had issues in the past with bad pressings?
Have cleaned & inspected all 6 titles & played 4 so far. I've got no issues so far on my MC cart/TT. All great so far. Great box set.
What I can't understand is why this box set is listed as $530 in Canada, vs the $300 price tag for the US. Even with the usual 1.4 exchange rate we would be paying over $100 more in Canada. The individual albums are all $54 on the official website. We always pay more but this is extra and I can't figure out why.
As a Beatles fan growing up with the original American albums and 45s (which is my preferred way of listening to them), the LAST quality I would want to hear from any medium is a "cleanliness") It was the sheer noise, the ambience that pervaded their sound that made them so wonderful to get into.
Just here for the watch content. Nice seamaster!
Do you have the capital albums on CD? The two volume set that came out with the stereo and mono? That's a comparison I'd like to hear about.😊
I picked up “Beatles ‘65” and “Hard Days Night”, I thought they sounded great, vinyl is stone silent, but I also noticed they are really loud. The volume on my receiver is pretty much at the same level for most of my records, I found I had to turn these two down quite a bit. They didn’t sound distorted or anything, just really loud. Is that a modern mastering thing or just how the originals sounded? The only original I have is “Meet The Beatles”, but it’s the stereo version.
Still have the original, in great shape. Listened to it the other day. Distinctly recall my sister bought it for me. $2.79
I was lucky enough to get the single releases of Beatles For Sale , Sgt. Pepper and The White Album monos in 2014 when they were released individually. No way I could afford the whole box set back then.
As far as this box set goes im just getting Meet The Beatles and maybe Something New. After hearing the UK versions years ago I just couldn't go back to the Capitol versions.
I got MTB and 2nd Album, just to try 'em. MTB arrived with a warp and I'll send it back. But 2nd Album is pretty nice. I have all the U.S. albums (80s pressings) in Stereo so nothing really to compare to. I'm not really a Mono guy. Was just curious.
Looking forward to your Doors box set review, although I feel like there may be a bit of bias since your doing business with Kevin if I'm being honest...we shall see.
I just got the target meet the Beatles blue vinyl, sadly warped a little bit, so I’m going to return it and hopefully get one that’s perfect, since that’s what I’m paying for
Didn't you only get 3% of your orders filled for this box? Did you order them separate instead ?
Initially, you stated that the copy of "Meet The Beatles" which was in your box set had non-fill. What happened with that?????????
OK. I found a common problem with 2 different copies of the mono "Meet The Beatles" album. I bought a black vinyl copy from Amazon and the exclusive color vinyl copy from Target. Although all of the writing scribed in the deadwax is identical, what separates them is that the color vinyl version on Side 1 has the MPO logo with stamped numbers following. So, they are from different stampers.
The common flaw is just before the first track, Side 1, "I Want To Hold Your Hand", there is a pop. Visibly, I can't see it on the record, although I can hear it. Moving the record, slowly, by hand, where the pop is, it doesn't show up either, like a normal flaw might. After digitizing it as a wav file, I looked at the blown-up graph of the flaw. It was definitely there. And, remember this was one 2 separate copies. This means that the flaw could go back to the original lacquer and all made from that lacquer are flawed. The scribed, identical, matrix number in the deadwax is:
M2 MTB P56 0060246819718 . A . Ki R @ EAST IRiS The Target color vinyl exclusive adds: MPO 24 349482
Mike are you sure you compared? You don’t seem to remember the albums with common songs.
Will these be released on CD? I noticed on Amazon there was a box set of this on CD but it was released earlier this year and originates from China....
i'd give a fortune to buy that harry moss re-cut of With The Beatles from 81
The most extreme example of a "well-polished turd" that I can think of!!! Stereo tape re-equed and sometimes slathered with echo, then folded to mono.
If I ran Apple or Universal this box would not even exist.
Apple originated this series.
Now that I have and love The Beatles 1964 US Box Set Mono and the Roll Stones Mono Box Set. I would love to see a British Invasion 64-65 US Mono Box Set to complete the era. It might include a Book on the British Invasion and any subset of these: The Dave Clark Five "American Tour US" 1964 Mono
The Searchers "Needles & Pins" US 1964 Mono
The Hollies "Here I Go Again" US 1964 Mono
The Animals "The Animals" US 1964 Mono
The Kinks "You Really Got Me" 1964 US Mono
The Yardbirds "For Your Love" 1965 US Mono
The Byrds "Mr. Tambourine Man" 1965 Mono
The Zombies "The Zombies" 1965 US Mono
The Turtles "It Ain’t Me Babe" 1965 Mono
That would be one Heck of a GREAT BOX SET.
The Byrds are American. No British Invasion there. California invasion.
Spoken like a true record store owner. They should’ve just called this “Beatles Holidays Product 2025.”
How does it compare to the 2004 cds? This may have been mentioned but I didn't hear it...
I bought Something new. The packaging is great but there are 4 or 5 tracks that are the same mix as the British version (in mono which I have already) I bought this because it's supposed to be the American version. I feel ripped off. If I'm listening from the other room it doesn't bug me but when I do listen in the same room its got that flat murky sound to me.
I have the CD version of the first four US Capitol albums which are honestly the best as they have both versions of each album in mono and stereo side by side on the same disc. In truth what I want is the stereo American versions with voices on one channel and backing tracks on the other. This is what I grew up with. The booklet inside the jacket tells you (after you've purchased it) that some of the tracks are the British version. Buyer beware. These are not really what you think they are. It's similar to what they did with the CD box that has the band pictured in front of an American flag. Track listing was like the US version but mixes are mostly the same as the British versions.
I prefer to hear the stereo versions anyway because I can hear more of the drums and top end etc.
The only way you can truly compare these is vs the original US, didn’t they also added reverb to these for the US market? If so they will sound different beyond the track listings.
Not a big fan of the beatles but this and a previous video was super informative
DjJoey f'n RULES...
WTF ? Makes no sense
@@davidlg0478 look harder...
You have to read between the lines and not be emotional buying records.. yes the albums are the best versions of the capital records but is it worth owning this box set ...i pulled my order online because like many other beatles releases and this ..its not what the people want. Let's face reality. We all want the 2014 mono releases... and people ive learnt the hard way, dont emotional buy records just to have them, 1. only buy what you love and 2. what stands the test of time. Solid engineered albums and musically impeccable albums.
I won’t be buying the box set but if you’re on a budget, what three records would you all recommend buying?
Meet, Second, Hard Days Night. Then Early Beatles. A Hard Days Night sounds the best
@@mazzysmusicooops… I ordered just one to test the waters and landed on ‘65. I almost went with Hard Day’s Night, but decided I prefer more of the songs on ‘65.
My comment got censored except this one.
No better way to start a Monday
why are my in groove Beatles pre-order's still unshipped? Should have been shipped to arrive last Friday
We get them today. Universal shipped these out late. I noticed the same thing with almost all online retailers.
HOW DOES THE "EMI TOSHIBA 13 BOX SET SOUND FROM 1978, I HAVE ONE UNPLAYED...????
Thanks!
My sonic review: 'Meet The Beatles' is a disappointment. Sounds like someone threw a blanket over my speakers. But from 'The Second Beatles' Album' on, the sound is more open and dynamic. Some might say a little 'bright', but I'm a treble guy. I wanted the box, so sue me: I paid big bucks for the inclusion of 'The Beatles' Story'. Thanks for your review.
Hi Mike, my OG Monos are in excellent condition so I don't feel these new releases blow the OG's away. And I did not compare to my UK mono's as I don't think that's a fair comparison given Capitol were not given master tapes from Martin anyway. These were cut to sound as the OG's did. I heard the new as slightly better..thanks and keep rockN
Who cares about the reviews. It’s a Beatles collector box and I purchased it.
Sounds like you are trying to justify the $1800 mono uk box 2014 set. For the price this is amazing. Period.
I love watching people go crazy for this ‘stuff’ 😅😅
What's with the blue faces?
OK. Please stop the Capitol’s versions to call as US issues of the UK origins.
These are really just compilations, Not less,however, not even more at all !
Easy, take it or leave it.
If you really want to compare the reissue vinyl, I would honestly suggest comparing them to the early 2000’s Capitol Albums CD sets which used the same tapes (except for ‘A Hard Day’s Night’, but you can mostly use “Something New” for that, as George Martin made the same mixes available to UA and Capitol).
If you’re lucky enough to run across a “Dr. Ebbetts” edition of the US Singles Collection you can judge the remaining tracks - they are very faithful reproductions of the best original copies that could be sourced.
Breaking news! Record store owner says new releases he has in stock are good records j/k hee heee
Love them. But a big mistake including The Beatles Story. Should have just included Help, Beatles VI, and Yesterday and Today. Done!
The Beatles' Story belongs in there but the box should cost more like $230. The market is in a different place than it was in 2014 but these albums are also in less demand than the UK albums. Selling a smaller box reduces Apple's risk.
People who buy these records expecting them to be AUDIOPHILE records will be dissatisfied They sound better than the original records but they aren’t audiophile records
Of course not the purpose of the box but I think it would have been cool to have ran some sort of crazy campaign in which they used the mono masters but kept the American song order. That would have made great sounding American versions with the American covers still used. Call it “The American Capitol Albums UnDextorized” or maybe “American Beatles …Naked” ..oh..wait..that’s been used.
What’s up with making the Beatles look like Veruca Salt from Willy Wonka on Meet The Beatles? Good gosh color match that one guys.
A brilliantly reasoned review. I'm in no way a Beatles fan. IMHO just another cash cow to fleece fans.
How do you fleece people by selling them something they want to buy?
Beatles fans taken for another ride.
...but she don't care 🎶
They broke in your house and stole the money out of your wallet too?! I demand justice!
Not a fan of Mono. I'll wait for the Stereo reissues.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Dont hold your breath!
The early albums are far superior in mono.
@@kgeo753Yes, Pre-White Album best sound is in mono.
White Album Mono and Stereo are required listening.
Go with Stereo post 1968
Why do we have to compare. You either like the songs or you don’t. Enough of the bs.
You can only make the Beatles sound so good. Crap in crap out
Hey Beatle fiends! Buy this watered down product that you probably already own (who knows..multiple copies of??) so that I can continue to pay my Ex off!
Hard pass...
Who cares.more milk the cow stuff.
Shów us something intersting stuff.
I got the “Hard Days Night” man alive it sounds atrocious. Sounds like AM radio. Also, I have a ton of inner groove distortion. I think this set is just kinda….blah. Like most Beatles releases these days. I am disappointed. It’s interesting for a deep Beatles fan, which I am….but these do not sound real good at all to me. I feel like this was a shill. These are going to go for dirt cheap in about 1 year. Just wait until the market is flooded. Btw, This highly allocated business is silly. Amazon selling no problem. Allocated maybe for indies because Apple scruffs just want easy distribution.
Great video as always. Comparing any version of the US albums to anything UK is useless. It’s like comparing apples and hammers. This is not an audiophile release and shouldn’t be compared as such. It destroys the original US albums. Period. Stop.
Picked up meet the beatles ..very disappointed..took it back..my old one sounded better
Are you the Eggman? Goo Goo Ga Joob 🎼🎸
Great video again. I'm a fan of Beatles early releases because they were still a rock n roll band. At this time (1964-65) they still gave concerts, so they were an alive band. Afterwards they were closed at Abbey road studios and their songs became more beautiful but soulless. I live for the day AI will allow Star Cub sessions to be remastered in good audiable quality.