Off The Rails: British Rail Motorail

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 259

  • @dav948
    @dav948 Рік тому +37

    Car reliability is a factor that I think is worth mentioning. In the Motorail days, some motorists didn't trust their cars to make it on very long journeys without incident. Cars would regularly overheat at 70mph. Also that's even with fewer motorways than we have today. Nowadays a modern car can just shrug a long motorway run off as a gentle cruise.
    That said, I do wish Motorail was still a thing alongside sleeper journeys. Could be quite useful if electric cars could trickle charge en route.

    • @nicholasjones9705
      @nicholasjones9705 4 місяці тому +1

      What would the wagons or transporters look like and where would the charging points be for electric cars?

  • @tominnis8353
    @tominnis8353 Рік тому +19

    Why do all the most sensible ideas rarely last?
    An excellent film. Thank you.

    • @pootispiker2866
      @pootispiker2866 7 місяців тому +1

      It makes more sense to just build more raails.

    • @EE12CSVT
      @EE12CSVT 5 місяців тому

      Tell me neither of you know anything about economics without telling me you know anything about economics

    • @pootispiker2866
      @pootispiker2866 5 місяців тому

      @@EE12CSVT Counter our arguments, then.

    • @EE12CSVT
      @EE12CSVT 5 місяців тому

      @@pootispiker2866 Um, no, the onus is on you to prove your point - as you made it first - that it would make more 'sense' (first, define 'sense' in a financial, societal, efficiency of movement, environmental, or other way) to "build more rails". I think you meant expanding the rail network, possibly redoubling, possibly improving junctions, more block sections, I don't know - 'rails' is a bit vague. BTW your reply would need to be something like a comprehensive essay on the case for "building more rails", sorry, "expanding the rail network" is how it would get published as to avoid it getting chewed apart in minutes.

    • @DubGathoni
      @DubGathoni 4 місяці тому +1

      Because sensible costs money

  • @fredericksaxton3991
    @fredericksaxton3991 Рік тому +6

    Thank you. My father took the family in his Mk 1 Jag on a 10 day camping holiday in Scotland in 1964/5. We caught the Night Motorail in London, serious stress because of poor local signage, but the overnight train up to Perth was excellent.
    I have taken my own classic Jag up to Scotland a couple times now and would appreciate a Motorail service today.

  • @lordpitnolen2196
    @lordpitnolen2196 Рік тому +12

    We took our Citröen Dyane on a single deck Motorail from Perth to London and return in the early 70s. The cars were loaded by railway employees. This resulted in our car ignition being left on at Perth and flat battery. The car was (presumably) manhandled off at London destination.
    All this was going on while we enjoyed Sleeper travel on the same train.
    I had my reservations about the wheel retainers, hammered into the wooden wagon decks, being able to hold cars but obviously they did.
    It was a great way to travel overnight.

  • @hoagy_ytfc
    @hoagy_ytfc Рік тому +34

    I wish this were still a thing - I'd love to drive onto the train down here in the south, get off the train in Inverness and have my car there waiting. The market is small though sadly, most people would either drive all the way, or fly and hire a car when they got there.

    • @johno4521
      @johno4521 Рік тому +2

      If they could combine that service with the cross Channel shuttle I think it would be well used

    • @wessexdruid7598
      @wessexdruid7598 Рік тому +3

      We used to regularly take the sleeper/motorail from Bristol to Glasgow, then drive up to Wester Ross. It was cheaper than driving all the way - the motorail charge was £30 on top of the sleeper tickets.

    • @samuelfellows6923
      @samuelfellows6923 Рік тому

      ☹️

    • @markfoxwell2411
      @markfoxwell2411 Рік тому

      😄

    • @dodahspeak
      @dodahspeak Рік тому +4

      I'd love to be able to drive my car onto the train down here as the driving 'experience' is becoming more stressful because of the road congestion and road works in this country. I've thought of flying instead of driving, but hiring a car at the other end is getting expensive because of the hikes in insurance without a big excess.

  • @robertbate5790
    @robertbate5790 Рік тому +6

    Hi, I grew up in Dorridge and remember that crash. It closed the main line for three days I believe. At the time the relief lines were still in use so traffic could get by with delay. I began my own railway career at Dorridge as a checker in the car yard in 73. I also remember the old TIERWAG car carriers in use, but they were gone by the time I started work. The CARTIC4s were also used by private shipping companies MAT, to whom I was attached at Dorridge, and Sillcock & Collins who had a depot at Bell Green in Coventry. From Dorridge we loaded cars from Longbridge, brought in by carriers, and Rover/Landrover/Range Rovers from their Solihull plant, brought in by carrier or ferry drivers. Destinations were mostly Dover or Harwich for export. Occasionally a train would be sent to Bathgate in Scotland. In the summer the company also imported Massey Ferguson hay bailers from France, loaded six to a flat.
    Sadly the traffic was moved to Bordesley, near Birmingham in the 90s, and the site is long gone, with not even a landmark remaining.

  • @thomasawl
    @thomasawl 2 місяці тому +1

    3:20 I think it’s important to note that this service only existed thanks to the factory being built near Glasgow, as the government gave money to anyone who dared to do business up there. The only problem is that the Rootes group’s headquarters, and where they made all the mechanical stuff, were in coventry. So, what ended up happening was the cars would be basically made as a bear-bones chassis and body, transported by rail down south to get the engines, gearboxes, etc fitted, before being transported back up north to Glasgow again to get the interior and other things finished.

  • @ricjuk
    @ricjuk Рік тому +65

    Every time I find myself driving from the North of England down to Cornwall, I can never understand why this is no longer a thing. To be able to relax on a train instead of spend 8 hours in the car dealing with the stress and fatigue of long distance driving and then have the convenience of your car when you arrive, seems like a no brainer to me.
    Guess it would just be prohibitively expensive at the end of the day but considering I probably spend nearly £150 in fuel on that trip, if a ticket was around that price or even slightly more, I'd be very happy to pay.

    • @mytinplaterailway
      @mytinplaterailway Рік тому +7

      I think the growth in car hire wouldn't 'help'. And of course cheaper plane travel.
      But Eurotunnel works, so there are circumstances where it does make economic sense.

    • @ricjuk
      @ricjuk Рік тому +19

      @@mytinplaterailway hmm I'm speaking purely from the 'I don't want to drive 8 hours but I still want my own car when I get there' position. I think flying to Cornwall and hiring a car would cost a lot of money and there would be the hassle of air travel/airport transfers/picking up a hire car etc.
      To be able to drive to the station, put my car on a train and then just get off the train and back into my own car would be the perfect scenario for anyone on a domestic holiday.

    • @mytinplaterailway
      @mytinplaterailway Рік тому +4

      @@ricjuk My point was the hire car business and cheap flights would make it difficult to run such a service at a profit. But it does seem to work for Euro Tunnel.

    • @axa2wa
      @axa2wa Рік тому +9

      Agreed. Driving from Glasgow to the SW is not the best start/end to a campervan holiday, hence the reason I've yet to visit. Similarly, although Eurotunnel was a breeze, the journey to get to Ashford was not. The dream would be to Cally Sleeper from Glasgow, with the 'van Motorailed behind, and wake up in France ... or Holland ... or Germany. It'll never happen 😐

    • @TrenyCwm
      @TrenyCwm Рік тому

      Too complex for the numpties that run our railways these days to manage.

  • @batman51
    @batman51 Рік тому +4

    My first trip on Motorail was from what had been Holloway Cattle Sidings joutside Kings X to Stirling. This was in covered coaches. I recall awaiting our car to be driven out at the destination when there was a loud clang and a particularly noisy Mini came out followed by a man carrying its exhaust. The second time, on flat trucks this time, was from Olympia to Perth. On this occasion, about 15 miles outside the town our car puttered to a halt. The problem was eventually traced to a loose cable which has shaken loose on the journey. One problem not mentioned was damage to car windscreens: it was found if one shattered (or was broken by a stone), the shards of glass hurtled down the train breaking every windscreen behind. After this a windscreen cover was introduced.

    • @tankmicr00man
      @tankmicr00man Рік тому +2

      Thanks for that, most informative. I would have loved to do the trip to Scotland that way.
      I've only ever experienced 'motorrail' in Switzerland in the early 1960s, going under one of the passes via a long tunnel, and sitting in the car! Wierd experience!

    • @peterrenn6341
      @peterrenn6341 Рік тому +2

      I travelled from Kings Cross to Edinburgh by Motorail some time in the mid 70s and I remember the screen covers. I'd not thought of the knock-on effect but in the days before everything had a laminated screen there could be an awful lot of glass flying about very quickly!

  • @bigturboxr3i
    @bigturboxr3i Рік тому +5

    Late 80s early 90s trains of new cars and vans would arrive at Bathgate yard where we would watch them being unloaded for hours! Cartic's and carflats, some adorned in the Silcock Express orange livery. Class 47s and 37s in all the liveries, railfreight sectors and coal sector or parcel red. I recall seeing a 47 named Silcock Express in grey or red a few times. Them long hot summers we used to get back then, we'd stand up on our bmx's or sat on the wall at the end of the yard waiting. Then an unmistakable distant racket of the metal flaps all clattering as the cars went over the wagons one after another down the ramp at the end onto the tarmac, tyres squealing as they turn around and shot up the yard to be all parked up in neat rows. There would be a squad of lads unloading so there was a non stop flow of cars until the whole train was unloaded ready for its return trip. Bloody good days.

  • @williamgeorgefraser
    @williamgeorgefraser 10 місяців тому +2

    When I was at High School in Dunfermline back in the 60s, the Edinburgh-Perth line ran past the end of the playing fields. At the time, the London-Perth motorrail service ran past around 3PM and featured the closed carriages marked "Anglo-Scottish Car Carrier" and pulled regularly by DP2 or by a Deltic. We used to pester teachers to let us go to the line to watch the "experimental" engine (DP2) close up.

  • @FriendsforFriendsUK
    @FriendsforFriendsUK Рік тому +108

    That 3D per mile would have been written 3d, spelled out as threepence and pronounced thruppence. Never ever pronounced three dee.

    • @Alan-ln3ls
      @Alan-ln3ls Рік тому +14

      You know that, and I know that. We are showing our age.

    • @Phil-Sands
      @Phil-Sands Рік тому +6

      @@Alan-ln3ls Thruppence is Thruppence, just because we are of an age excuses the wrong pronunciation, how else are millenials going to learn? 🙂

    • @FriendsforFriendsUK
      @FriendsforFriendsUK Рік тому +2

      @@Alan-ln3ls But at least farthings were on the way out when we were kids even though we had to learn them.

    • @whitesapphire5865
      @whitesapphire5865 Рік тому +8

      The ignorance of youth. God knows what will happen to our history when we're gone.

    • @GazMoby
      @GazMoby Рік тому +6

      Calm down grandad

  • @ROCKINGMAN
    @ROCKINGMAN 9 місяців тому +1

    Again, nice little film about this BR service. We used to go to Brighton and Hove in the late 60's by train, a fantastic and exciting time for a child to be growing up. I used to take in all my surroundings and was fascinated by the, trains, underground, Routemasters, RT's and RF's that were all over. Seem to remember Motorail at Olympia too whilst waiting for a train in the summer sun, the smell of trains, tarmac and Ambre Solare. Even at that time, I thought, why have a car to drive then take it on train!

  • @BoaFilmsPlc
    @BoaFilmsPlc Рік тому +12

    One location I think you did miss was Brockenhurst in the New Forest. The loading dock is still there and for many years a cycle hire firm had a GUV on a piece of track in the dock. The GUV now resides at the North Dorset Railway at Shillingstone Dorset.

  • @fredphipps9452
    @fredphipps9452 5 місяців тому +1

    How much nicer everything looked in those days

  • @vkdrk
    @vkdrk Рік тому +6

    this service (autovlak) still runs between Slovakia and Czechia and during summer there is an additional route between Slovakia and Croatia. It's great for people who don't feel comfortable driving long distances but really want to use their own car in their destination

  • @terryjacob8169
    @terryjacob8169 Рік тому +1

    Went from Kings Cross to Aberdeen, and back, via Motorail in October 1983 and thoroughly enjoyed the experience.

  • @speedypete202
    @speedypete202 Рік тому +4

    Fantastic little micro-documentary! Thank you

  • @johnkeepin7527
    @johnkeepin7527 Рік тому +6

    Apart from the Eurotunnel service (which I’ve used a few times with cars) that carries passengers in the cars, there are also open trains full of brand new cars, used by Toyota between Toton, Nottinghamshire, and other factories like Valenciennes, importing right hand drive ones for sale in the UK, and vice versa from Burnaston, Derby. So a couple of my cars travelled that way empty!

  • @jonathanmormerod
    @jonathanmormerod Рік тому +6

    Until its demolition in 1997, the former Olympia Motorail booking offce was known as Olympia Bridge Quay and was home to the offices of my family business and the Free Tibet Society.

  • @JelMain
    @JelMain Рік тому +1

    The ImperialnWar Museum has photos of WW1 tanks on flatbeds, and, of course, the very first coaches were quite literally that, horse-drawn coaches mounted on trucks.

  • @andrewdarley8988
    @andrewdarley8988 Рік тому +2

    Only sorry he didn't say more about the early days to feed my nostalgia. I was a frustrated train fan as a child but because my father always had a car I never got to go on one (except the underground central line which didn't count). Then in 1957 my mother's sister who always came on holiday with us persuaded us to go to Cornwall by motorail. Wow! The most exciting day of my eight year old life so far. Paddington to Plymouth on the Cornish Riviera (cars travelled down on a separate train the night before) behind King Edward VII, double heading from Newton Abbot over the Devon banks and feeling very superior to the nose to tail traffic on the A38. Change trains at Plymouth as the Riviera didn't stop at St Austell and the panorama from the Royal Albert Bridge. Return journey was overnight so first experience of a sleeper (pre-BR Mark one). Two years later we went from Marylebone to Perth overnight rooted by the old great Central to Leicester where we changed engines, then to York, where we changed engines, then up the east coast to Edinburgh where we changed engines. Only problem I hardly slept at all and was a complete zombie for the first day of the holiday. Return excitement from Perth to beyond Edinburgh was steam hauled but when we got back to London there was a type IV diesel on the front. Later did two more journeys to Cornwall (sadly by now steam haulage would have been a treat) and then with my own car to Inverness and back from Perth. However despite being green you can't expect the taxpayer to subsidise a loss-making service that only benefited a tiny minority of people.

  • @robertbate5790
    @robertbate5790 4 місяці тому

    Hi, thanks for this edition. I grew up in Dorridge, and remember that accident being on local TV news. I didn't actually see it myself. I later worked as a checker/shunter in the nearby goods yard. This particular accident did not involve any motorail vehicles. They were indeed carflats, but owned by a local transportation company M.A.T. who operated from the said nearby yard. On this occasion the flats had been end loaded at a bay siding at the station, an old horse and carriage dock. The forerunner of the CARTIC4s was a bogie vehicle, called TIERWAG, with a lifting central well to take two cars, which then lowered between the bogies and an upper deck loaded over. The lifting gear was electrically driven, the plug posts still being extant when I worked there. However they proved very unreliable, and impossible in winter. I remember them in traffic in my childhood as I frequently passed the yard on my way to school. They were withdrawn before I worked there. (Incidentally, Triang made a very popular model of the TIERWAG many moons ago.). However I had plenty of hands on with the CARTICS. My job was to scotch and label them for transit. The maximum load was seven sets to a train, or mixed with carflats at three flats to one cartic. Maximum flats was twenty. Most trains went to Dover or Harwich for export to the continent. Occasionally a train would be sent to Hamworthy, near Southampton, or Bathgate in Scotland. Cars were brought by road carriers from Leylands at Long Bridge, or the Rover Works in Solihull. Silcox and Collins was another user of a fleet of CARTICS from Bell Green at Coventry.

  • @jrushen4235
    @jrushen4235 Рік тому +2

    A great bit of research. Excellent footage. A super watch.

  • @RossMaynardProcessExcellence
    @RossMaynardProcessExcellence Рік тому +1

    When I was young, my parents took us on holiday from Kent to Scotland on Motorail. This was in the early to mid 1970s (possibly late 1960s but I have no memory of that). We went from Dover once but mostly from Olympia. I'm sure there were one or two departures from Euston too. We travelled to Inverness once and Stirling once or twice, but mostly to Perth. Arrival was very early in the morning. I don't remember the sleeping arrangements but they certainly weren't sleeper bunks so it must have been passenger coaches.
    It was quite expensive but saved the stress of driving 400 odd miles. It was very exciting for us kids.

  • @neiloflongbeck5705
    @neiloflongbeck5705 Рік тому +8

    The Knowle and Dorridge crash didn't involve a Blue Pullman but a locomotive hauled Pullman train. The train consisted of 9 coaches built in 1923 plus a Western locomotive.

    • @JackStackhouse
      @JackStackhouse  Рік тому +2

      From what I could find, Normally it was hauled by a Blue Pullman train, but that morning had been replaced by the Western

    • @neiloflongbeck5705
      @neiloflongbeck5705 Рік тому +5

      @@JackStackhouse the Blue Pullman set had failed at Paddington the previous day and had been replaced by the loco-hauled set as described in the accident report.

    • @TrenyCwm
      @TrenyCwm Рік тому +6

      It states all this in the video.

    • @neiloflongbeck5705
      @neiloflongbeck5705 Рік тому

      @@TrenyCwm yes, but my comment was posted before that point, you known at the point out narrator says it was a locomotive hauled 9 coach Blue Pullman. Whilst it would have been possible to haul the Blue Pullman sets bynlocomotive, the WR had few locomotives that could supply the hotel load for running the heating and other equipment and certainly a Western couldn't do it. Plus the longest Blue Pullman sets were only 8 coaches.

    • @steveluckhurst2350
      @steveluckhurst2350 Рік тому +2

      @@JackStackhouse the "blue pullman" described a fixed train set, therefore it was unlikely to haul anything.
      Semantics, I know, but the little stuff matters.

  • @neilcobb1731
    @neilcobb1731 Рік тому

    I remember there was an equivalent in France until the late 2000s. Used it twice with my family at the start of our summer holidays in 2003 & 2006 when I was still a kid. You'd get off the ferry at Calais, let the train take the strain through the night, and then by morning you were in the south of France.
    Certainly saved a lot of driving. Though that said, many of the places we visited on our summer holidays, you can now reach by plane from Edinburgh (my nearest airport) - which is probably why it no longer runs (starting at Calais, it was almost certainly aimed at Brits).
    Though using the plane does make it easier to visit places (indeed, I can be in sunny France and my dull hometown in the same day) and as much as I love flying, it's not quite as romantic as the old days.

  • @SimonPJohnson
    @SimonPJohnson Рік тому +1

    Great video. We travelled by Motorail from St Austell to Kensington Olympia in July 1969, hauled by Western Renown D1071. It was diesel hydraulic ‘heaven’ all the way to OOC. We also took the Kensington Olympia to Perth Motorail in or about 1972. The train included sleeping cars (my brother and I had bunk beds). The loco changes took place at Willesden and Crewe Basford Hall yard.

  • @Mishima505
    @Mishima505 Рік тому +3

    Austrian railways still runs a Motorail service to Germany, Switzerland, Italy, France and the Netherlands as part of its Nightjet sleeper service.

    • @G6JPG
      @G6JPG 4 місяці тому +1

      So it _is_ viable. Though is it along routes you can also drive along (nearby), or the _only_ way to access those routes?

    • @Mishima505
      @Mishima505 4 місяці тому

      @@G6JPG usually you can either drive or take the train, it depends on how the track is laid, the one famous place exception is the island of Sylt in Germany where the *only* way to get there is by train, there is no road access from the mainland. Therefore if you want to take a car, you have to use the motorail service from Westerland.

    • @G6JPG
      @G6JPG 4 місяці тому

      @@Mishima505 So most of the routes you could drive alongside if you wished. So why couldn't Britain make a profit? (Or do all the European ones run at a loss?)

    • @Mishima505
      @Mishima505 4 місяці тому +1

      @@G6JPG it was more the decision to reduce the public subsidy to railways in general than any particular thing directed against Motorrail.
      Under Maggie the subsidy was reduced by so much that BR had no option but to cut services, the long-distance night services being the most expensive.
      In Europe the situation is different, eg for cross-border services they are usually run as a co-operation between two railways and the cost is shared equally.

    • @G6JPG
      @G6JPG 4 місяці тому

      @@Mishima505 So the European ones _do_ run at a loss.

  • @johnjephcote7636
    @johnjephcote7636 4 місяці тому

    In 1968 I drove my blue Isetta bubblecar from Watford to Paddington to go via the Lawn at Paddington Staion, into a CCT and thence overnight (me in the sleeping car), Western diesel-hauled to (I think) Fowey. Also return in a week's time. Many staff at that time recognised the GW coat of arms I had painted on the front of the car, The yellow tennis ball sized hooter below had the GW 'shirt button' monogram painted on for good measure.

  • @StBlazeyModelWorld
    @StBlazeyModelWorld Рік тому +3

    Great footage my friend. I will shortly be making a video of what remains of the MotoRail terminal of my local station

  • @svenmartin840
    @svenmartin840 4 місяці тому

    When I was a kid in 1973. They had Auto Train which was separate from Amtrak. That ran from Lorton Virginia to Sanford Florida. Then Auto Trim Corporation went bankrupt period and then In 1983. Amtrak revived Auto Train and it's been going on ever since. And when you mention 1963. My dad was stationed in Germany and he just met my mom. And he was in England in 1966. And he did see the changing of the guards

  • @ThePtb1980
    @ThePtb1980 Рік тому +1

    My parents took the Stirling to Dover service in 1981 when I was just a year old, then drove on to Switzerland and back.....in a 1937 Riley 12/4. I think my dad was the mobile breakdown cover on that trip !

  • @robertstorey7476
    @robertstorey7476 Рік тому +2

    As a kid I well remember travelling overnight to Perth from Kensington Olympia with my dads Vauxhall Viva on a flat bed truck at the rear of the train. A magical experience.
    Given the range issues with electric cars I wonder if some similar kind of system might reappear.

    • @DavidMartin-ym2te
      @DavidMartin-ym2te Рік тому

      I have done that! Last time was Euston to Glasgow sadly as the M90 cut off the direct route to Perth in the mid-80s

    • @DavidMartin-ym2te
      @DavidMartin-ym2te Рік тому

      ...and now since I live 25 miles north of Perth, I no longer have to drive to the smoke....!

  • @bingbong7316
    @bingbong7316 10 місяців тому

    There was the early 1960's Anglo-Scottish Car Carrier, Holloway-Edinburgh, a while before the catchy new Motorail branding. Also, a Car Sleeper from Dover to points north, in 1962.

  • @petermostyneccleston2884
    @petermostyneccleston2884 Рік тому +2

    If I was going to the South, from North Wales, I would certainly consider using the Motorail service. Assuming that it is still available for me to use.
    To make it worth my while, the Motorail station will have to be in either Llandudno Junction, or Rhyl, instead of Crewe, and the station at the other end, will also have to be a similar distance to where I am going to, otherwise I will be spending more time traveling to and from the station, than I would be driving all the way there.

  • @markharding7466
    @markharding7466 Рік тому +2

    I remember watching the car's being loaded at the Brockenhurst terminal on a Sunday evening in the 70's as I was being sent back to school in Dorset by train often wondered where they might be going and what adventures lay ahead for there owners.

  • @chrisgreen4780
    @chrisgreen4780 Рік тому +6

    Many railways offered open and then CCTs (Covered Carriage trucks) used for initially the carriage of horse drawn private vehicles. The Great Western MOGO CCT is a case in point. Do wonder if limited electric car range could lead to a revival of motorail.

    • @JackStackhouse
      @JackStackhouse  Рік тому +1

      With the 'Offf the Rails' series, I'm planning more on covering the wackier side of BRs ventures than that of the big four, but thank you for pointing out the GWR MOGO, I wasnt aware of it before now!

  • @LordHat6030
    @LordHat6030 Рік тому +4

    You have a lot of potential, I’m subscribing

  • @532bluepeter1
    @532bluepeter1 Рік тому +3

    Having driven from Kent to Westeross I wish that this was still in operation.

  • @alanfbrookes9771
    @alanfbrookes9771 Рік тому +2

    The railways have always carried motor vehicles. It goes right back to the origin of railways when "carriage trucks" were available to send your horse and carriage by rail.

  • @PenzancePete
    @PenzancePete Рік тому +7

    Not Cartac, Cartic. Car carrying articulated vehicle.

  • @grahamariss2111
    @grahamariss2111 Рік тому +6

    Remember my dad looking at this in the mid 70s, but it was very expensive and living in the West Midlands the time needed to get to the station and load meant that you could drive in the same time to your destination. I would challenge that it was ever popular, it was one of those things BR felt it should be doing rather than a viable commercial service.

    • @robtyman4281
      @robtyman4281 Рік тому +2

      Motorail was very popular across western mainland Europe, and people in other European countries didn't grumble about it being too expensive. The big expense to them was their holiday destination - not the method of getting to it.
      But once again this is another example of us Brits being awkward and having to be different from the rest of Europe. If an idea comes over from mainland Europe - and Motorail did (even preceding LNER); we always have to criticise it or find ways to undermine it. It seems to be the 'British way.🤔🤨

    • @grahamariss2111
      @grahamariss2111 Рік тому +4

      @@robtyman4281 I think the key difference is that the UK is not so big as mainland Europe, thus harder for Motorail to make a difference, probably only viable between Southeast and Scotland.

    • @mytinplaterailway
      @mytinplaterailway Рік тому +1

      @@robtyman4281 Surely the distances covered in Europe are greater. We live on a smallish island.

    • @Mishima505
      @Mishima505 Рік тому +2

      @@grahamariss2111 if you lived In Cornwall and wanted to go touring in the Scottish highlands then it would be a great solution. Otherwise you’d take a sleeper and hire a car at the destination.

    • @amazoniaamazonia7225
      @amazoniaamazonia7225 Рік тому +2

      It was a good service and cut out a lot of boring motorway driving, and was popular with those who could afford it.

  • @murraydean2371
    @murraydean2371 Рік тому +4

    A minor point about your commentary, the U.K. pre decimal currency used the letter "d" to signify the old penny, 3d would have been pronounced as "thruppence", 2 1/2d was tuppence ha'penny and so on. The pronunciation as "3 dee" was never used. That all changed in February 1971 when British currency (thankfully in my opinion) changed to the decimal system.

    • @tankmicr00man
      @tankmicr00man Рік тому +2

      d = denarius, the Roman coin, and subsequently used to describe old pennies/pence

  • @onchnc3546
    @onchnc3546 Рік тому

    Great video. Shame its gone.

  • @kenwilliams3560
    @kenwilliams3560 Рік тому

    Pilning was the first motorail station used before the seven crossings

  • @davidjones332
    @davidjones332 Рік тому +4

    I remember the Motorail terminal at Penzance. I suspect that must have been one of the last, probably because the roads into the West Country were then hopelessy choked in summer. Still in 2023 they're nothing special with no motorway west of Exeter. Once the motorway network developed and even ordinary family cars were capable of cruising at 70 mph or more the great time advantage of rail over road in such a small country was lost.

    • @winterwatson6811
      @winterwatson6811 Рік тому +3

      Have fun in traffic! I’ll be napping on the train

  • @millercool21
    @millercool21 Рік тому +5

    Nice I think they should bring this back

    • @JackStackhouse
      @JackStackhouse  Рік тому +2

      Its definetly a viable option!

    • @steveluckhurst2350
      @steveluckhurst2350 Рік тому +3

      In a perfect world, EVs would bring about the return of Motorail. At least it would end "range anxiety"!
      Sadly, the infrastructure costs would most likely be prohibitive.

    • @neiloflongbeck5705
      @neiloflongbeck5705 Рік тому +1

      First Great Western did without much success.

  • @Spookieham
    @Spookieham Рік тому +1

    Nice potted history - thank you.

  • @SimonBanfield
    @SimonBanfield Рік тому

    Really interesting and well produced video.
    I lived opposite the Motorail terminal at Kensington Olympia a decade ago and always found it fascinating. I used the shed a few times for the car hire and there were lots of reminders of what was once there.
    Kensington Olympia's subsequent evolution to be a fully equipped International terminus - as a backup if Waterloo was unavailable - is another interesting chapter in that station's history.

  • @neilmackinnon3371
    @neilmackinnon3371 Рік тому

    I remember my dad taking us on a monorail from London to Scotland (Sterling possibly) on one of our annual visits to see family in the highlands. In the late 1980's / early 90's I thought it would be fun to do the same thing with my young family. We lived just outside Bristol and the GWR service ran from Bristol Parkway (I think) to Glasgow and so I made a phone call to get a price for a return trip, at the time the petrol to drive probably cost no more than £20 each way. The price of the tickets was HUGE, I could have bought an all inclusive package holiday for two weeks in Spain for less money. Needless to say... we drove.

  • @JamesWilson-gw2ij
    @JamesWilson-gw2ij Рік тому +1

    If that was an option to the channel tunnel terminal I’m sure it would thrive. I’d definitely use it.

  • @Clayshots12
    @Clayshots12 Рік тому

    Used it many times between Kensington to Inverness and Euston to Aberdeen, absolutely loved it and cannot understand why it stopped, when booking to Aberdeen, if you had not booked by June for October , you ewould be unlucky as it would be fully booked,

  • @xenon53827
    @xenon53827 4 місяці тому

    I travelled on that to Scotland. It was fun.

  • @Handle423
    @Handle423 4 місяці тому

    I wish we had more of those kinda services on the mainland of Europe

  • @OlanKenny
    @OlanKenny 4 місяці тому

    I heard a rumour that the owner of West Coast Railways (major railtour operator) had a makeshift motor rail ramp built in Carnforth depot so he could send his car to Fort William by rail in the summer

  • @stevenclarke5606
    @stevenclarke5606 6 днів тому

    I remember there being a Motorail depot at the Sutton Coldfield station, on the Birmingham crossing city line.
    Let the train take the strain

  • @jimmyviaductophilelawley5587
    @jimmyviaductophilelawley5587 Рік тому +4

    Good video mate. Subbed and look forward to more👍

    • @JackStackhouse
      @JackStackhouse  Рік тому +2

      Glad to hear, thank you!

    • @thedave7760
      @thedave7760 Рік тому +2

      @@JackStackhouse Really well done , I didn't know much about this very informative.

  • @mytinplaterailway
    @mytinplaterailway Рік тому +1

    Lovely old cars.

  • @MrWozzy28
    @MrWozzy28 Рік тому +1

    i remember seeing these as a kid going to and from newton abbot long the river teign , think you can still see the on off ramp at newton abbot to the left of the station

  • @michaelemery5219
    @michaelemery5219 5 місяців тому

    The Gary Newman song cars always reminds me of car transporter trains

  • @john07973
    @john07973 Рік тому

    Good video thanks👍

  • @eattherich9215
    @eattherich9215 Рік тому

    I never knew that motorail was a thing, but I used to live in a house between two rail lines, one of which shared passenger and freight traffic. One day, I looked out of a window to see a line of cars on their way to I don't know where.

  • @timbounds7190
    @timbounds7190 Рік тому

    Of course, these days, getting a car to Kensington Olympia would probably be far more hassle than taking it along the Motorway to your destination!

  • @brianrose234
    @brianrose234 5 місяців тому +1

    Why is there no mention of the service from Marylebone to Perth. This service ran from there before Kensington Olympia.

  • @kristinajendesen7111
    @kristinajendesen7111 11 місяців тому +1

    Doesn't show it but there was also Motorail from Brockenhurst which would join up in London. I presume from there on to Scotland.

  • @JohnPW22
    @JohnPW22 Рік тому +3

    Great exploration of the car-by-rail thing. One small error: the loco involved in the very sad fatal crash was a Class 52 Western, not a Class 50. Keep up the interesting presentations!

    • @hoagy_ytfc
      @hoagy_ytfc Рік тому +4

      It was correctly described as a "Class 52 Western", initially, however: @ 6:00 - so it's just the vocal equivalent of a typo (a speako?!)
      If the description of the collision as being "20 mph" is correct, the state of the Western (and sadly the crew) is shocking - that's appalling crash-worthiness, even by 60s standards.

    • @historyinfo-bites
      @historyinfo-bites Рік тому +1

      @@hoagy_ytfc But at 6.27 it is described as a Class 50

  • @atiganmires5662
    @atiganmires5662 Рік тому +3

    Interesting Video. Did you know that there was also a Motorail service running from Brockenhurst in Hampshire?

  • @G6JPG
    @G6JPG 9 місяців тому

    I had no idea bits of it were still operating into the 1990s. I often wished it _was_ still operating: Since I travelled from initially Essex, then Kent, to visit friends in Newcastle several times a year (for long enough that I wanted my car while there), I would have definitely used it, unless the cost was exorbitant. (I wouldn't have wanted the luxury shown - something like the chunnel, with just toilets and maybe vending machines, would have suited me.)

  • @dinmorejunctionmodelrailway
    @dinmorejunctionmodelrailway Рік тому +2

    Hi. An informative video which I found interesting.

  • @stackersmbe852
    @stackersmbe852 4 місяці тому

    I wish this still existed! It would reduce traffic on motorways and reduce carbon emissions from longer journeys.

  • @AliHodnett
    @AliHodnett Рік тому

    The Ramp is still in place in Fort William station

  • @jasonpetersrailadventures
    @jasonpetersrailadventures Рік тому +1

    Cool

  • @PaulSmith-pl7fo
    @PaulSmith-pl7fo Рік тому

    Hi Jack. Who doesn't like a bit of history!?

  • @stevenosimpson
    @stevenosimpson Рік тому +4

    Shame this isn't still going across the UK and in Europe.
    I moved to Austria in 2017 and there were still a few from places like Dusseldorf but sadly they are now very few and far between.

    • @SimonBanfield
      @SimonBanfield Рік тому

      I was traveling to Austria from the UK last winter and the Motorail equivalent there would have been ideal for that trap. Sadly it seemingly had been discontinued the previous year.

    • @SimonBanfield
      @SimonBanfield Рік тому

      The plan would have been to get the Eurotunnel and drive to Düsseldorf, and catch it there.

    • @stevenosimpson
      @stevenosimpson Рік тому +1

      @@SimonBanfield yep, Düsseldorf to Vienna.
      Still runs as a sleeper but not with motorail.

  • @train4905
    @train4905 6 місяців тому

    Exellent😊

  • @InverhavonRailways
    @InverhavonRailways 4 місяці тому

    When we're all driving those electric milk floats, the capability to travel long distances without incessant charging "breaks" could be very useful, especially if you could charge up the battery en route.

  • @Aengus42
    @Aengus42 Рік тому

    I used to lust after the Hornby / Scalextric (weren't they linked through Triang?) late 60's OO Motorail set!
    Ooh! Be still my beating heart!

  • @melissanewton7462
    @melissanewton7462 Рік тому +1

    Yes I had to laugh at the 3 d per mile as written and said. Thruppence in old money was 3d with D as standing for the latin Denarius.

  • @martynrussell7568
    @martynrussell7568 Рік тому

    You can still see the concrete loading ramps at Bristol temple meads opposite platform 4

  • @EpicThe112
    @EpicThe112 Рік тому

    For a Channel Tunnel Motorail the formation needs to be two class 92s between Nightstar Coaches assuming they got them from VIA rail spares or new builds

  • @cornishrider
    @cornishrider 3 місяці тому

    4:12 Beige Maxi HL with leopard skin cushion and trilby on parcel shelf- no that's a Motorailist!

  • @orys
    @orys Рік тому +2

    There was similar system on the Polish railways up to early 2000's I think. I believe this service is still on offer of Austrian and Finnish railways.

    • @alanmusicman3385
      @alanmusicman3385 Рік тому +3

      And Swiss

    • @thedave7760
      @thedave7760 Рік тому +2

      Austria has one from Bad-hof Gestein through to northern Italy.

    • @vkdrk
      @vkdrk Рік тому +2

      still running between Slovakia and Czechia

  • @TR6Telos
    @TR6Telos Рік тому

    I would go to Scotland much more often from Manchester if this existed, an hour on the M6 is enough for me.

  • @christopherbutler7588
    @christopherbutler7588 Рік тому

    Very interesting When I was at school in the seventies I done a School project on Motor rail and won a prize.

  • @Andrewjg_89
    @Andrewjg_89 Рік тому

    Motorail has been the best logistic transport transporting vehicles by rail from manufacturing plants.

    • @eattherich9215
      @eattherich9215 Рік тому

      A few years' ago, I looked out of a window from a house where I used to live and saw a fleet of cars gliding along on rails.

  • @andrewbennett7756
    @andrewbennett7756 4 місяці тому

    We took several rides on this train as my dad's perants in Paignton I travelled in to no my self being motorway were far and few between

  • @garethmatthews7939
    @garethmatthews7939 2 місяці тому

    great video but only one minor error you refered to the westrn has a 50 to the end having already called it a class 52

  • @siraff4461
    @siraff4461 Рік тому

    I think this could still work but not really in the way it was set up back then. Something more akin to the Eurostar where you drive your own car on and off would be more like it. I don't think the getting out and going into a seperate carriage and all that makes much sense unless you're going on a very long run - for a few hours it would make it a very expensive way to travel - but being able to get some rest instead of driving for hours would be a nicer way to get from one end of the country to the other.

  • @jameseadie7145
    @jameseadie7145 Рік тому

    They had one at Aberdeen on the back of the sleepers, think the headcode was 1M10, i worked it once Aberdeen to Edinburgh

  • @imrandarr1094
    @imrandarr1094 Рік тому

    I’m you’re 100th subscriber!

  • @plumtreeworks5225
    @plumtreeworks5225 Рік тому +1

    where did you find refrence to the motorail in lincoln ? ive never seen this before

  • @peterhowell7657
    @peterhowell7657 Рік тому

    Definitely think it should be reinstated. With the limited range of electric cars it would make it easy to go on long journeys e.g. on holiday

    • @Durosity
      @Durosity Рік тому

      Imagine if this service still existed, and you could plug in your EV so you were fully charged when you arrived at your destination. It’d be perfect.

  • @richardbradley2335
    @richardbradley2335 Рік тому

    I was also told that cars weren't overly caapable of travelling hundreds of miles on their own.

    • @archstanton5603
      @archstanton5603 Рік тому

      Sadly gave up both driving and my 1968 Morris Traveller three years ago.
      At one stage was clocking up 38K miles a year driving both the length of the UK (including the Outer Hebrides) and across to the continent! 🙂

    • @richardbradley2335
      @richardbradley2335 Рік тому

      @@archstanton5603 Arh sorry mate...38k is hell of a lot..greta be mad at you !

  • @saltspringrailway3683
    @saltspringrailway3683 Рік тому +5

    Even though there is a d after a number, we who lived in the '60's used the word 'pence'. We'd say Pounds, shillings and pence. I've no idea what d stands for!

    • @JackStackhouse
      @JackStackhouse  Рік тому +1

      I believe pennies were abrieviated to 'd', no idea why tho!

    • @dj_efk
      @dj_efk Рік тому +10

      @@JackStackhouse because the Latin word for this coin was 'denarius'.

    • @OverblownOverthrown
      @OverblownOverthrown Рік тому +8

      Yes, no one said ‘d’: it was ‘pence’

    • @JackStackhouse
      @JackStackhouse  Рік тому +1

      Thankyou for pointing this out! :)

    • @highdownmartin
      @highdownmartin Рік тому +2

      Livres shilling denari. LSD.

  • @train4905
    @train4905 Рік тому

    Superb

  • @johnlaws5231
    @johnlaws5231 Рік тому

    Jack, you should note that pre-decimal we used (£ s d) pounds shillings and pence why (d) for pennies I don't know, we didn't ask

  • @steveluckhurst2350
    @steveluckhurst2350 Рік тому +2

    Many factual and continuity errors, but very good. I'm sure it will improve over time.

    • @mytinplaterailway
      @mytinplaterailway Рік тому

      Will you though?

    • @steveluckhurst2350
      @steveluckhurst2350 Рік тому

      @@mytinplaterailway I don't need to! 😂😂

    • @mytinplaterailway
      @mytinplaterailway Рік тому

      @@steveluckhurst2350 Sure.

    • @steveluckhurst2350
      @steveluckhurst2350 Рік тому

      @@mytinplaterailway Unlike the OP, I don't create content.

    • @MalcolmCrabbe
      @MalcolmCrabbe Рік тому

      @@steveluckhurst2350 Steve, with all due respect it does annoy me when people sign up to UA-cam and don't create any content then feel justified to point out the short comings on the first video produced by a fledgling channel. Granted there were mistakes, but he still put together a nice, short and informative video.

  • @G6JPG
    @G6JPG 9 місяців тому

    Did the loading/unloading terminals cause traffic nightmares?

  • @peepiepo
    @peepiepo Рік тому

    The past seems to have a habit of looking futuristic somehow