The difference between classical and operant conditioning - Peggy Andover

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 822

  • @bowdencable7094
    @bowdencable7094 4 роки тому +3181

    What do you bet that for the rest of his life, whenever he hears a bell, Pavlov thought about feeding the dogs.

    • @suhaibfarooq3343
      @suhaibfarooq3343 4 роки тому +187

      I haven't seen a smarter comment in the feed ;)

    • @JM-ef5xy
      @JM-ef5xy 4 роки тому +6

      Lol

    • @gdp6580
      @gdp6580 4 роки тому +9

      @Bowden C.
      😂😂😂Brilliantly said!

    • @bidZee
      @bidZee 4 роки тому +17

      Mind = blown.

    • @jidenathan9965
      @jidenathan9965 4 роки тому +17

      Nice twist.

  • @thenerdycousins9099
    @thenerdycousins9099 2 роки тому +869

    “Tell me, I won’t get mad, I promise”
    Classical conditioning we all have

  • @aureusyarara
    @aureusyarara 11 років тому +993

    Ahhh, "We need to talk" is classical conditioning, then....

    • @LisaGallegos
      @LisaGallegos 5 років тому +6

      OMG yes

    • @havannguyen-trong
      @havannguyen-trong 4 роки тому +8

      best comment ever!!=)))

    • @gdp6580
      @gdp6580 4 роки тому +2

      😂😂😂

    • @gdp6580
      @gdp6580 3 роки тому +3

      @@nurkhairianissofeaabdrahim3856 listen to Ted Ed, then read comments...

    • @ceciliahorner2664
      @ceciliahorner2664 2 роки тому +2

      And so is randomly getting a text from someone that just says "hey." INSTANT anxiety for me.

  • @mnementh818
    @mnementh818 11 років тому +176

    Finally someone who can explain classical conditioning. I've had two different teachers who couldn't figure out how the various types of stimuli are labeled.

  • @LenLeonardo
    @LenLeonardo 8 років тому +1283

    I really like this animation style, is there a specific name for this style apart from USSR propaganda?

    • @TheBokiya
      @TheBokiya 8 років тому +245

      Constructivism.

    • @LenLeonardo
      @LenLeonardo 8 років тому +12

      nice thanks dood

    • @disrael2101
      @disrael2101 6 років тому +79

      USSR conditioning ;)

    • @tarandaasanand2444
      @tarandaasanand2444 5 років тому +5

      @비니보이 yes and it looks good

    • @ObeySilence
      @ObeySilence 5 років тому +12

      Yes, Constructivism "invented" by El Lissitzky.

  • @ljd710
    @ljd710 10 років тому +729

    Last day of study for the exam tomorrow.
    Definitely easier to understand compared to my notes.

    • @1Atlkid
      @1Atlkid 8 років тому +6

      +ljd710 So...how did it go?

    • @ljd710
      @ljd710 8 років тому +42

      1Atlkid Wow this was a while ago... But I remember doing really well in that part of the test. Passed overall

    • @walaael-hajali9112
      @walaael-hajali9112 6 років тому

      same 😂😂

    • @jonathanlai163
      @jonathanlai163 6 років тому +2

      dammmm its my turn tmr

    • @YogeshPersonalChannel
      @YogeshPersonalChannel 5 років тому +3

      My turn today in two hours

  • @ethanomcbride
    @ethanomcbride 5 років тому +37

    This came up after I watched a vid about Kafka. The graphics are (mwah, chef's kiss) perfecto

  • @somegirlfromgermany7659
    @somegirlfromgermany7659 4 роки тому +93

    Little piece of trivia: Classical conditioning is what usually teaches us fears. And it can be used to reinforce behavior as well, but it's not as effective as operant conditioning.

  • @matthewtallent8296
    @matthewtallent8296 7 років тому +2448

    This looks and feels like USSR propaganda lol

    • @dronedependence
      @dronedependence 5 років тому +72

      No. its true. You are conditioned to do things automatic.

    • @artsyrant8931
      @artsyrant8931 5 років тому +290

      You are conditioned to see this particular image style as a USSR propaganda, boom.

    • @rory7993
      @rory7993 5 років тому +50

      MHVet its more association than conditioning because it doesnt fit into the descriptions of classical or operant conditioning since there is no reinforcement nor an unconditioned response - you might, however, be operantly conditioned to make this comment after observing others making comments and getting likes/approval, so you imitate their behavior

    • @frankthetank8216
      @frankthetank8216 5 років тому +45

      @@rory7993 indeed this is association and logic induction
      USSR propaganda uses red colors and russia styled fonts
      This video uses red colors and russia styled fonts
      Conclusion: this video is probably USSR propaganda

    • @ObeySilence
      @ObeySilence 5 років тому +22

      It feels like a USSR propaganda because it is inspired by an famous communist graphic designer called El Lissitzky. Stop at 1:43 and google his name. "Beat the whites with the red wedge"

  • @waleededitz..277
    @waleededitz..277 2 роки тому +10

    Wow 😳. Your communication skill is soo good. Also teaching style is unique. U r Teaching in an specific and marvelous way, which helps to understanding and decoding it easy. Lots of Greatful From Pakistan 🇵🇰

  • @NoelSkye
    @NoelSkye 10 років тому +39

    OMG! This helped so much more then my Psych notes. Thank you for this video! I have my final tomorrow.

    • @doink4997
      @doink4997 4 роки тому +8

      I know it's been a long time since you wrote this, but out of curiosity, did you pass that exam?
      Also asking because I have had a bad experience of trying to learn from a YT videos just before examination.

    • @trin9264
      @trin9264 4 роки тому +5

      Yea did you pass? Do you have a degree or a good job now? Curious!!

    • @geneie6050
      @geneie6050 7 місяців тому

      Well, well, years later I'm here to pass mine! Cool

  • @damarisrivera2049
    @damarisrivera2049 8 років тому +4

    you have NO idea how much this helped! THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!

  • @titaniastinkerings
    @titaniastinkerings 4 роки тому +5

    That disturbingly illuminates why I want so badly to change my birth name. You hear it called enough times in a certain tone and then get yelled at for something you did wrong, hearing it in other settings still produces the same anxiety. Hurray.

  • @rachelsun3021
    @rachelsun3021 9 років тому +4

    This explains it really well... I went over and understood this in class, but I needed to go over it again before the final.

  • @ALHat22
    @ALHat22 8 років тому +184

    Trick question: if this video reminds you of communist propaganda was it positive or negative reinforcement or positive or negative punishment? What is the stimulus?

    • @poochyhd3000
      @poochyhd3000 7 років тому +20

      P H neither one of them I'd guess since there hasn't been any behavior to reinforce. I'm just guessing, but I'd say it would be a conditioned stimulus.

    • @chloefahrberger3057
      @chloefahrberger3057 6 років тому +4

      you are actually engaging in relational framing, which is an operant condition.

    • @nostrasummit5785
      @nostrasummit5785 6 років тому +2

      uraghhh!!! my brain!

    • @nicolasnauli8658
      @nicolasnauli8658 5 років тому +8

      I think its classical conditioning isn't it? You are associating or reminded of the communist propaganda by connecting it to an emotion of deceit and distrust however it was framed. So the stimulus might be the animation's colours with the maps which just really makes me think of history class

    • @LisaGallegos
      @LisaGallegos 5 років тому

      LOL

  • @OsagieGuobadia
    @OsagieGuobadia 3 роки тому +1

    Fascinating lesson about both classical and operant conditioning today on UA-cam.

  • @wissenschaft1103
    @wissenschaft1103 4 роки тому +2

    Nice style of animation. The difference demonstrated in the video is just. Which appears to be an even more distinctive feature between two demonstrated types of conditioning is that the first one occurs as subconscious activity whilst the latter represents conscious (deliberate) behaviour.

  • @toymecha4522
    @toymecha4522 Рік тому +2

    washes dishes, mom gives hug to 40 year old man, "thank you for helping me" 😂

  • @dhruvdevvarshney1438
    @dhruvdevvarshney1438 5 років тому +1

    Classical conditioning continues to have a profound influence on the fields of psychology and behavioural neuroscience. It is interesting to consider that Pavlov and his associates not only discovered the learning process of classical conditioning, they then went on to identify almost all of the major components of classical conditioning (i.e. conditioned and unconditioned stimuli and responses), developed the primary paradigms of delay, trace, simultaneous, and backward conditioning and identified and described many of the parameters that influence the process of classical conditioning. They also described acquisition, extinction, spontaneous recovery and dis inhibition, as well as higher order conditioning, second-signal systems, conditioned discrimination.

  • @anitarichmond8930
    @anitarichmond8930 5 років тому +5

    I remember learning about Pavlov's dogs while in school

  • @drakonlorek1430
    @drakonlorek1430 10 років тому +16

    Very interesting. I wonder how well operant conditioning would work on someone who is consciously aware of that it is happening. For example if I use operant conditioning on myself to encourage certain behaviour by rewarding myself after I have done something like studying. Maybe one can use operant conditioning to change habits completely? But how big of an affect will this have? I'm considering to try this with exercise.

    • @MarkiplierOfficial
      @MarkiplierOfficial 2 роки тому +2

      have you tried it big man?

    • @osmanimran458
      @osmanimran458 2 роки тому +12

      @@MarkiplierOfficial I’m guessing he’s shredded af by now

  • @ch3nre
    @ch3nre 11 років тому +4

    This video explains it perfectly. THANK YOU!

  • @TheScientistA4
    @TheScientistA4 10 років тому +3

    So by REMOVING the homework (negative reinforcement) are you also ADDING free time (positive reinforcement)? Does it really depend on how we view things? By ADDING a timeout, are we REMOVING free time etc., etc.?

    • @danilee1870
      @danilee1870 6 років тому +1

      TheScientistA4 As far as I know it depends on how the person who received the reinforcement view things... I mean, at the end of the day it keeps beings a reinforcement

    • @azi8519
      @azi8519 2 роки тому

      Yes, I find the example on negative reinforcement to be confusing. Will the act of removing the homework strengthen the person's achievement in the exam, or maybe in future exams?

  • @purplepuzzlemo556
    @purplepuzzlemo556 3 роки тому +9

    psychology class is so confusing smh

  • @ianglenn5905
    @ianglenn5905 4 роки тому +1

    I believe you are mistaken, claiming Professor Pavlov ‘showed dogs some food and rang a bell at the same time’. My understanding is that the sound of the bell preceded the feeding, not rung at the same time. I would appreciate clarification on this point as the timing of the two stimuli is central to the whole concept of classical conditioning.

    • @oxztherussianbearschnauzer3509
      @oxztherussianbearschnauzer3509 4 роки тому

      You are correct. Pavlov conducted multiple experiments. Classical conditioning occurred when a bell was rung immediately before the dogs were fed, and this resulted in the dogs salivating in response to the ringing bell later. This is the foundation of marker (or clicker) training for dogs, orcas, and other animals. When Pavlov experimented with ringing a bell while dogs were eating, those dogs made no connection between the ringing bell and being fed, and thus did not salivate at the sound of the bell later.

  • @shashankjajoo
    @shashankjajoo 5 років тому

    Glad to know no examples of punishment were shown.

  • @vivvpprof
    @vivvpprof Рік тому +1

    Pavlov was born before Soviet Russia was a thing. Pavlov wrote letters to Stalin criticising him. Still, the video gets a Soviet-Russia-vibe graphics.

  • @beverlymutize1433
    @beverlymutize1433 6 років тому +1

    wow such clear explanation thank u Peggy,l was clueless after this video l understand

  • @RMNJMHTY
    @RMNJMHTY 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks for helping AP Psychology students when their teachers can't.

  • @stormchii
    @stormchii Рік тому

    wow the animation was incredible

  • @Acquavallo
    @Acquavallo 11 років тому

    The animation is so great in this!

  • @kalpnasaxena9112
    @kalpnasaxena9112 7 років тому +8

    am I strange, as the first picture that hits my mind for the word learning is travelling on foot?

  • @chickenofcamelot
    @chickenofcamelot 10 років тому +1

    Ahhhhhhhh this makes so much sense now, thank you so much.

  • @singhsandeep1932
    @singhsandeep1932 2 роки тому

    U solve this vry easy way with marvellous

  • @njgaona
    @njgaona 11 років тому

    Short and simple thanks

  • @maxtok414
    @maxtok414 3 роки тому

    Beautiful visuals!!

  • @Kenz-x2m
    @Kenz-x2m 2 роки тому

    I enjoyed this video it was organized and easy to follow.

  • @soorayarawat7367
    @soorayarawat7367 4 роки тому

    Thanks. This is very helpful. I needed that.

  • @victorgabrielbuena
    @victorgabrielbuena 5 років тому +82

    *so my mom has been using operant conditioning on me all along*

    • @solitary2
      @solitary2 5 років тому

      Vecthur Subconsciously or with the knowledge without knowing the specifics

    • @AmmoBops
      @AmmoBops 4 роки тому

      Vecthur just because you learned about it doesn’t change it, just like how when you learn that every action you do or make is caused by releasing of chemicals in the brain etc... doesn’t take any fun or anything away or then you would just sit around and do nothing becuase you feel likes it’s pointless since you know how it works

    • @jonavuka
      @jonavuka 4 роки тому

      you have been manipulated my friend, time to revolt!

  • @pinkshadesingray3688
    @pinkshadesingray3688 5 років тому

    For those interested, read More with Paul Chance, Skinner, Ribes, Wolpe. Etc... This kind of effects occur not only with observable behavior but Also with private behavior, like thoughts and emotions, so it can be quite complicated and More interesting than people give it crédit for.
    Just think about how politicians use certain ley words to associate the "fulfillment" of a public need with their objectives, therefore associating possitive emotions with their dialogue.

  • @Henri_Ikari
    @Henri_Ikari 11 років тому

    The necessity to digest cellulose is very important for animals in the plains where glucose-providing fruit isn't available (compared to other primates who never needed to do a lot and had all their needs provided by fruit). Either that or just cook the ruminants who have the bacteria for fermenting plant fibre into amino acids usable by other animals. Thus animal products form a cheaper and more straight-forward way to obtain proteins, especially some which we cannot synthesize ourselves.

  • @jeremiahwilliamsmusic
    @jeremiahwilliamsmusic 10 років тому

    Great video - I would have likes a few more examples. Thanks

  • @rustynails68
    @rustynails68 8 місяців тому

    Elevator music, supposed to be calm and soothing but I associate it with childhood experiences at the dentist.

  • @marcelsandino5483
    @marcelsandino5483 3 роки тому

    Behaviourism is amazing

  • @anneleegirl1565
    @anneleegirl1565 5 років тому +5

    I love how this actually happened to me not to long ago only she said, "this shot is normally 1,000 dollars and it will hurt."

  • @anonymouschange287
    @anonymouschange287 4 роки тому +5

    This video teaches us that doctors who lie can traumatize kids and that saying thank you is just society making everyone feel better when they help others

  • @jyotikadam8459
    @jyotikadam8459 2 роки тому

    Thank you

  • @MzBroadway17
    @MzBroadway17 10 років тому +1

    Simple and understandable. Didn't go over negative reinforcement or positive and negative punishments though /:

    • @NanaMuffinLady
      @NanaMuffinLady 10 років тому +5

      There are two types of punishment. We called them punishment type I and punishment type II (I'm translating from German). Punishment type I is when you add something unpleasent, something negative like a punch in the face or grounding. Punishment type II is taking away something pleasant like taking away the mobile phone.
      I know it is a really late reply but I just had the urge to answer.

    • @elgostine
      @elgostine 10 років тому

      *****
      i understood it pretty well so thank you

  • @drapetomaniadrapetomania5998
    @drapetomaniadrapetomania5998 4 роки тому

    Thanks

  • @spiritwaveluna461
    @spiritwaveluna461 4 роки тому

    the pigeon art connoisseur experiment blew my mind

  • @jackpotatoe88
    @jackpotatoe88 11 років тому

    A very well illustrated video.

  • @mahilansary2001
    @mahilansary2001 5 років тому

    Alan Foreman, damn you're great! Loved the animations!

  • @Shonda-vj7qb
    @Shonda-vj7qb 4 роки тому

    Very helpful. Thanks

  • @wotanmituns33
    @wotanmituns33 11 років тому

    learning more about operant conditioning (:

  • @JimBCameron
    @JimBCameron 11 років тому

    Classical conditioning seems very similar to the mechanism underlying phobia's & I guess that's why Cognitive Behavioural Therapy seems effective in curing them?

  • @5MinutePsychology
    @5MinutePsychology 3 роки тому +1

    To an untrained eye Hess two types of conditioning can be easily confused. Both are worth studying, though!

  • @DKTurbo101
    @DKTurbo101 6 років тому

    This helped a lot! Thanks!

  • @CodyCzar1
    @CodyCzar1 11 років тому

    That was good. Thanks Peggy.

  • @diogobentes1102
    @diogobentes1102 6 років тому

    I'm going through changes!

  • @PremKumar-le5vd
    @PremKumar-le5vd 4 роки тому

    Thank you 🙏😊

  • @salmeronabraham
    @salmeronabraham 9 років тому

    Great video! Thank you!

  • @carlchan44
    @carlchan44 3 роки тому

    "學習" 在心理學上, 是基於體驗 行為改變, 分以下兩種:
    .經典條件性反射 響鈴有野食; 看肉流口水是 "本質刺激", 響鈴流口水是 "條件刺激"
    .操作性條件反射

  • @prim16
    @prim16 11 років тому +2

    I learnt this in psychology class :D

  • @nitishroy5912
    @nitishroy5912 8 років тому

    thanks for the video

  • @SkittyBlackfire
    @SkittyBlackfire 11 років тому +3

    Ah, me too! Glad I'm not alone in this :P

  • @minervaando3015
    @minervaando3015 5 років тому

    very helpful thank you

  • @mohammadadnan6374
    @mohammadadnan6374 4 роки тому

    Wow , very informative video

  • @disrael2101
    @disrael2101 6 років тому

    You claimed in 2:14 that "running from there" was a conditioned reflex, I assume it is a mistake, and it is an unconditional reflex.

  • @fireballfitness170
    @fireballfitness170 2 роки тому

    1:25.. neutral stimulus becomes a conditioned stimulus
    2:23... Operant conditioning leads to changes in voluntary behavior..

  • @bansisirkiclass.5248
    @bansisirkiclass.5248 3 роки тому

    So when some when with the intention approaches i have got conditioned to respond. I have requested several times cease doing that then the association would die. Reinforcement (ringing of bell every time food is given) does create association. And more the reinforcements more is the reflex action. These people know that and are using that to defame me.

  • @TheAnonymous63
    @TheAnonymous63 11 років тому

    I was under the impression that classical conditioning required repeated association, not just learning through one trial? So does this mean that one powerful experience on its own is able to trigger a conditioned response afterwards when a similar conditioned stimulus is presented?

    • @danilee1870
      @danilee1870 6 років тому

      Aaron Henderson it’s not usual but it can happen... also I’m not sure if it works with a similar conditioned stimulus. For example, food aversion is learned with just one trial... we can associate stomachache with any specific food and then stop eating it. Just an example, hope you understand... English is not my first language.

  • @abdullahkardas8887
    @abdullahkardas8887 6 років тому

    very good I hope teacher will ask in exam thanks...

  • @kartikrai3434
    @kartikrai3434 2 роки тому

    very helpful!

  • @TheBelmontClan
    @TheBelmontClan 11 років тому

    Energy has no options, other then the reaction to the opposite. Humans call them emotions, yet the recharging draw point is the same. So technically the exterior is just along for the ride of the interior, just as vice versa. Like atoms, the destructive force assimilates within the substructure of the collective much like an emotion. How they both react are somewhat similar. Creative or destructive forces, the emotion refers to as good or bad. The reaction is the same, physic to proxy.

  • @hitishaagoyal8447
    @hitishaagoyal8447 4 роки тому

    You guys might want to check out The Psychology of Learning course on FutureLearn. It's great!!!!

  • @nigelmckee3058
    @nigelmckee3058 11 років тому

    adore the soviet format! AND the content.

  • @Saurabh.2075
    @Saurabh.2075 5 років тому +3

    Is operate conditioning also called as INSTRUMENTAL CONDITIONING?

  • @sisosisosisosisosis1
    @sisosisosisosisosis1 10 років тому

    Easy! Thanks!

  • @MyCheeseMonster
    @MyCheeseMonster 11 років тому

    Do you want an award?

  • @dumpling1987
    @dumpling1987 9 років тому

    excellent

  • @gadgetwhore2
    @gadgetwhore2 11 років тому

    *cut and dried, amount, English, Webster. I agree with you completely.

  • @Taric25
    @Taric25 11 років тому +1

    Woah, déjà vu! We JUST learned this in psychology!

  • @hanahahmadsixthform
    @hanahahmadsixthform 11 місяців тому

    so interesting

  • @davidgreen000
    @davidgreen000 11 років тому

    No, that would be a positive punishment - the receipt (positive) of a stimulus to discourage (punishment) behaviour.
    Positive = Receive / Negative = Remove
    Reinforcement = Encourage behaviour / Punishment = Discourage behaviour

  • @chantel2689
    @chantel2689 3 роки тому

    Is classical conditioning conditioning ones reaction?

  • @beardean7655
    @beardean7655 4 роки тому

    so classical unconditioned with neutral becomes conditioned, operant is with punishment and reinforcement

  • @dtnjoker
    @dtnjoker 9 років тому

    this was awesome

  • @rajeshsrajeshs
    @rajeshsrajeshs 5 років тому +1

    Sheldon: Good job. Have a chocolate.

  • @CrystalinRose
    @CrystalinRose 2 місяці тому

    Does anyone remember the episode of The Office where Jim did this to Dwight with tic tacs or gum????

  • @yashchadda473
    @yashchadda473 Рік тому

    Isn’t operant conditioning how reinforcement learning (a type of ML) works?

  • @davedark27
    @davedark27 11 років тому

    Loved the soviet style diagrams, great video

  • @greentriumph1643
    @greentriumph1643 Рік тому

    The slide format has a certain soviet art form aesthetic to them. Coincidence?

  • @TheaDragonSpirit
    @TheaDragonSpirit 11 років тому

    I think as long as the person knows there mistakes, it's all good. I think as long as people don't forget how to communicate and understand each other. It's all good. :-)

  • @tennesseejed1969
    @tennesseejed1969 11 років тому +1

    How is your comment on his comment on his comment useful?

  • @nguri139
    @nguri139 5 років тому +1

    I didn't know it was this easy 😆

  • @emmapeterson8326
    @emmapeterson8326 10 років тому +122

    TERRIBLE analogy with the needle/mirror thing.

    • @BehaviorBender
      @BehaviorBender 9 років тому +1

      Agreed!

    • @gafaharman4157
      @gafaharman4157 9 років тому +1

      +Emma Peterson Right! Lol had me confused, sucks cause you know they could come up with something 10x better

    • @iamsoweird1357
      @iamsoweird1357 7 років тому +29

      I dunno, I thought it was good...

    • @BehaviorBender
      @BehaviorBender 7 років тому +5

      Number 58 the production was nice, but the descriptions were technically inaccurate. The opening bit about classical conditioning had the common mistake about the dog associating the bell with the food. Technically, associate means to put together, and it was Pavlov, not the dog, that associated the bell and the food.

    • @Funkroza
      @Funkroza 6 років тому +8

      Can anyone explain why is this so bad?
      I think it gets to the point

  • @halfpixel12
    @halfpixel12 5 років тому

    All i could think of was Frasier trying to prank bulldog

  • @athenaatwar475
    @athenaatwar475 6 років тому +3

    Man this is so ASMR

  • @Echo81Rumple83
    @Echo81Rumple83 4 роки тому

    I'm a bit disappointed they didn't go over the negative aspects of using very negative stimulus for punishment will actually backfire in the long run...

  • @epeTm
    @epeTm 11 років тому

    The artist could've got that idea from the fact that Pavlov is in a large role in the video, but that's just me pondering