Is This the Greatest Bass String EVER?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 134

  • @jazzbrew68
    @jazzbrew68 Рік тому +6

    I swear this video is about the strings but man... your PLAYING. So full of soul, swing and pure joy. I come back to this one frequently.

  • @Dc_94
    @Dc_94 3 роки тому +4

    You really can hear the diference and the clarity with the Pirastro!! Keep the good work and the amazing videos coming!

  • @conormurray-bassist9847
    @conormurray-bassist9847 3 роки тому +2

    Congrats Pdbass! Awesome to watch the channel grow this last year! Pirastro are awesome! I play on some Chordas and any issues i've ever had there team has been amazingly helpful!

  • @mr.larrett5197
    @mr.larrett5197 2 роки тому +4

    I had gut strings on my bass in my University days... got a great deal and loved the sound. I sure do miss them! I'm really enjoying your thoughtful content sir.

  • @marshallpeterson6565
    @marshallpeterson6565 3 роки тому +2

    Great video, always like to hear new and different demos of upright strings!

  • @6strbassplayer
    @6strbassplayer 3 роки тому +4

    What a great comparison video! Keep on keepin on! P.s...you really can walk it! Love your playing my man!

  • @NicHasegawa
    @NicHasegawa 3 роки тому +23

    I know it’s a video about strings and all….but strings aside, your technique sounds so damn good 👏👏👏

    • @jazzbrew68
      @jazzbrew68 2 роки тому

      Totally agree on this one. I spent more time going wooooooo during the comparisons. So good.

  • @georgebalmont6311
    @georgebalmont6311 3 роки тому +3

    Great video! Really good to hear such a direct comparison of the strings

  • @monz7951
    @monz7951 3 роки тому +3

    Sounds beautiful. I've been thinking about trying a naked gut G and looking for one of those Golden Spiral Charlie Haden used to play. Anyways love how you play the blues, pure fire!

  • @pietroeliabarcellona
    @pietroeliabarcellona 2 роки тому +2

    Stellar playing! Great to hearing your heart out after watching so many vids

  • @lucianoquezada22
    @lucianoquezada22 3 роки тому +4

    Awesome video! I’m playing pirastro perpetual strings currently and I’m a big fan of both arco and pizzicato sound. Congrats on 5k!

    • @carloszagal1934
      @carloszagal1934 Рік тому

      big ups to the perpetuals, I am using them with an Olive G and I am so happy with this set

  • @masonjones1506
    @masonjones1506 5 місяців тому +1

    Wow, 3 years later and that 5,000 subs is now 150k! You earned it!!

    • @pdbass
      @pdbass  5 місяців тому

      Thank you!! 🙏🏽

  • @PCKPockyi
    @PCKPockyi Рік тому

    Great review Maestro! Only a bass player and a teacher of your caliber can do it that way. Bravo!

  • @merrill-el-richmond8649
    @merrill-el-richmond8649 3 роки тому +1

    Congrats on the 5K viewers! Well deserved, Paul.

  • @cotehall9434
    @cotehall9434 3 роки тому +3

    Sounds really great!! I feel that the combination of Spiros Weich and Pirastro Oliv really lands itself on your bass! makes me wanna try it someday.
    I'm currently putting Gerold Genssler "Gut-like" strings made of silk on all 4. Used to play Spiros Weich set and they sang very well, and blightly, but when I changed them to GG strings, I felt the body of my german bass resonating literally 50% more. It's all about affinity of the bass for the strings...

  • @lownessfunk4932
    @lownessfunk4932 2 роки тому +1

    Great video and great string. I used this string for many years. I did however go to plain gut G string at some point and since then have not gone back. Bowing takes a bit of getting used to bit worth it for that tone..

  • @davidhadley370
    @davidhadley370 Рік тому

    You caused me to finally give the Oliv G a try. I decided to put it on my 1940 Juzek... And I'm sold... The string really IS that good. I've been on the wall for a few years, but your video was spot on... It's only been a day, but the tone... It's altered my thinking. An Oliv D or even a full set may be next...

  • @DaveVergato
    @DaveVergato 3 роки тому +2

    Great to hear your opinion on this string. I’ve been interested in trying one myself! Maybe I’ll get lucky and win the drawing haha!

  • @jhoffmann3015
    @jhoffmann3015 3 роки тому +1

    You sound great as always Paul. I prefer how you sound on the Weich G. I love Pirastro strings (on my bass I use the Obligato) but what you played on the Weich just got me in the feels.

  • @mikebassy
    @mikebassy 3 роки тому +1

    Thing is I think you are sounding great , it’s you doing it. You are improving every month and it’s inspiring

  • @georgerichardson7560
    @georgerichardson7560 3 роки тому +1

    Great video!! Very informative and inspiring! I've been wanting to put gut strings on my bass for ages now, just so in love with that beautiful punch so present and in your face from players like Blanton and Pettiford!! But also both players as soloists still manage to make those gut strings sing, Blanton's solo playing on Body and Soul and Pettiford's on Stardust are magic. I'm definitely planning to try Oliv's very soon, I might even try plain gut one day maybe. I'm leaning towards wrapped gut as I'm guessing it might be a little more comfortable when playing arco but we'll see! Thanks fo the great content and playing. Congrats on the 5000 subscribers and big love from London UK! :)

  • @benjaminlavoie-doyon4002
    @benjaminlavoie-doyon4002 3 роки тому +3

    I’ve had a E A spiro and D G evah pirazzi combination for the last two years, similar experience, the two types of string realy complement each other, plus the evahs are way cheaper.

  • @mule71
    @mule71 3 роки тому +3

    Congrats on reaching the 5k milestone. Well deserved! 👏👍

  • @m.hughes2521
    @m.hughes2521 5 місяців тому

    I have one bass w Spirocores and the other w BelCantos, i love em both but I'd surely like to try an Olive "G"..

  • @PabloFlores-qs5mq
    @PabloFlores-qs5mq 3 роки тому +1

    Sounds great, I’ve been a fan for a couple of months now and I really enjoy your content.

  • @ScottRanger
    @ScottRanger 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks for the great videos!

  • @FongJazz
    @FongJazz Рік тому

    I haven't had any durability trouble with Olivs. I put on Oliv D & G in September 2016 and gigged a couple times a week (not much arco) into 2020. In June of 2021 I switched to Perpetuals as I got tired of the constant tuning up of the Olivs (interesting how they go sharp when the air is dry and flat in humidity). Then in Spring of 2023 I put the Oliv G back on 'cause I craved the beef. No unwinding yet after almost 7 years! Maybe I just got a good one!

  • @vondoktor
    @vondoktor 3 роки тому +1

    Great video, as usual! Man, you give me the urge to work on my blues! Such an inspiration! Thanks for the amazing work!

  • @dfybyn
    @dfybyn 2 роки тому +1

    and longevity - I've been using the Eudoxas for 2 years - maybe the silver wrap makes them last better

  • @keithrawlings7741
    @keithrawlings7741 3 роки тому +1

    Great comparison video - the Oliv sounds glorious! I bought a used one once and it was unbelievably great sounding, but the windings were giving out at the nut. It was pretty well used though.

  • @bassnut57
    @bassnut57 2 роки тому +1

    I think that I prefer the Spirocore here. They sound a bit brighter. More articulate Nice growl.

  • @aristamanu
    @aristamanu 3 роки тому

    Cheers from southern Argentina, and congrats on the 5k milestone!

  • @robertcamp1606
    @robertcamp1606 Рік тому

    That is simply one gorgeous instrument!! Any possibility of some info & some closeups of it(front & back)??😮Thanks for that & for what U do here!!❤

  • @zubrycky
    @zubrycky 3 роки тому +2

    These Oliv G strings have a really lovely sound!

  • @BankruptBassplayer
    @BankruptBassplayer 3 роки тому

    Already subscribed.. you are a really great you tube content provider! i Play professionally for over 40 years, and can honestly say you are giving the truth, i especially liked your Leon Sylvers video.. congratulations on your subscribers.!

  • @Sprongles95
    @Sprongles95 Рік тому

    For what it's worth, and this is on a very, very old set of Weichs (w/ an equally old mittel E) on my hybrid bass, I strung the Weich G so that the ball end is facing out at the tailpiece, and it makes the whole set way more even feel wise and tonally.

  • @grahamkozak2315
    @grahamkozak2315 3 роки тому +1

    sounds great! always wanted to try the oliv g on my bass to see how/if it resonated differently

  • @craigs19721972
    @craigs19721972 3 роки тому

    Be great to try this string!! Greetings from New Zealand!

  • @ianaldridge227
    @ianaldridge227 3 роки тому +1

    great vid. ive been super impressed with a spiro weich EAD and a medium zyex G for a beefier G string. just wish the G was like 0.002" thicker

  • @richardstaving3594
    @richardstaving3594 3 роки тому

    Never tried the Olivs (or any Pirastro) but have heard all the fuss as well. Thanks for the A/B and your pros and cons!

  • @AlexHallbom
    @AlexHallbom 3 роки тому

    I play a set of spiro weichs and I'd love to try out the Pirastro Oliv G.

  • @I.O.M.
    @I.O.M. 3 роки тому +1

    Oliv G is golden but Spiro Weichs will never let you down. The issues you mentioned is why folks give up on it.

  • @SaltyMusicOne
    @SaltyMusicOne 3 роки тому

    cool video- it also makes me think that a vid on those double triplet drops would be really great :)

  • @MrDanilop45
    @MrDanilop45 2 роки тому

    ❤️ great analysis of the string. Keep doing this.

  • @Zeesboy
    @Zeesboy 3 роки тому

    Thanks. Never heard of this string. I can't detect a superiority over the Spirocore G. I prefer Spirocore mediums

  • @peepsieD
    @peepsieD Рік тому

    Oliv G a little dry vs the Spirocores to my ear. Eudoxa G or a plain gut G is a great option too. Or a Spirocore G one gauge up from whatever gauge your DAE are is also sometimes cool.

    • @peepsieD
      @peepsieD Рік тому

      Love your playing btw! On any strings!

  • @mikebassy
    @mikebassy 3 роки тому

    Just posted some videos of a jam session between me and a pianist called Robbie Taylor. This is a cassette tape from 1986 , it was probably February. Me and Rob used to go to see people like McCoy Tyner every month. I really wished he had become a full on jazz pianist because he had it then . I was 18 in this jam . Rob was a session keys guy with Chaz jankel and Imagination. He knew Norman Watt Roy a favourite bassist of mine from the Ian dury band. I want to get my message across to Rob that mate , your brilliant

  • @bassocanario
    @bassocanario 3 роки тому

    Great string review....
    Your playing in this video is stank-nastily wonderful !
    Love this channel, keep doing your thing!!!❤👍🏽

  • @mark-stefaniw
    @mark-stefaniw 3 роки тому

    WRT unraveling you want to make sure bridge and nut grooves are right sized and pencil lined generously so that the winding moves with the core. My Olive G is in great shape after 2 years of service. I'm primarily an orchestra player who also plays jazz and bluegrass.

  • @vannave5761
    @vannave5761 3 роки тому

    Both strings are greats to my ears. Nice comparison thanks !

  • @MrBrainsquash
    @MrBrainsquash 2 роки тому +1

    Man, I would love to play that free string my bass, but I am a little late here. Recently bought Obligatos and not happy with that G string. Anyway, great video, keep going.

  • @paulnicolosi4792
    @paulnicolosi4792 3 роки тому

    I love gut strings. For 30's 40's 50's and 60's music, they are the 'only' way to go. My E string is gut as well. Thump city and deeper than the Mariana trench...

  • @dexterjones4902
    @dexterjones4902 3 роки тому

    Awesome string! Awesome content as always! :)

  • @luccas_bracco
    @luccas_bracco 3 роки тому

    Your channel is awesome. I'm sure you get far beyond 5000 subs.

  • @jlmoses16
    @jlmoses16 3 роки тому +1

    Congrats on the impending landmark!

  • @TheRainmanBachelor
    @TheRainmanBachelor 5 місяців тому

    Always awesome when a black bassist installs an Olive g string.

  • @badscrew4023
    @badscrew4023 6 місяців тому

    I'm perfectly happy with Spirocore Weichs. These are ALREADY expensive enough so yeah, Oliv is not what I'll be ever buying :D

  • @johnhelman1990
    @johnhelman1990 3 роки тому

    thanks man...i admire your playing

  • @MrDanilop45
    @MrDanilop45 7 місяців тому

    What about the Ron Carter’s Labella strings? I cannot understand if they are great or not. A lot of people says that are great but unfortunately not useable with the bow. But there are very few tests on them

  • @seanriddle6408
    @seanriddle6408 3 роки тому

    I tried a near death Oliv G on my Shen hybrid strung with Spiro mittens during lockdown and man did it make my bass sound deeper. I just got a new bass and it would be interesting to hear how it sounds with an Oliv G and Spiros.

  • @johnloehrke1161
    @johnloehrke1161 3 роки тому

    This vid pretty much sums up my experience. I bought a used one, loved it, and you summed up perfectly why. It came unwound in a few weeks. I'm now about 6 months into one I bought new. So far, so good. I'm not an endorser, so if I can't get a year out of it, no dice. I'm itching to try a D if this G makes it for a year.

  • @alyoshaproductions
    @alyoshaproductions 3 роки тому

    Great review. Thanks for the info!

  • @gssong7111
    @gssong7111 3 роки тому

    Dig this setup...once had the great Dave Carpenter play my bass with this set up on a willow shen, He loved it and sounded incredible! I had that string on there for at least 2 years!
    What do you think of the old spirocore/velvet anima G set up? I still have that string...

  • @pablomillas
    @pablomillas 3 роки тому

    Loving my neighbor and your videos. Thank you PD

  • @willb3698
    @willb3698 3 роки тому

    Was about to ask “why no arco?” Now I know. Blast.
    I play A LOT of HARMONICS so thank you for telling me that it does not sing so well or at least in comparison. Beautiful stuff going on in that heArt of yours.

  • @MrBassflute
    @MrBassflute Рік тому

    Awesome as always!

  • @dfybyn
    @dfybyn 2 роки тому +1

    try the Eudoxa - pretty sumilar but much nicer on the hands (shame about the price though

  • @Markperna1
    @Markperna1 3 роки тому

    Sounds great! I like the gut-like “thup” attack. I tried one a bunch of years ago but didn’t stick with it. I ended up using a Gamut Pistoy medium gut G with Spiro D,Aand E and have never looked back. I don’t do much arco though and while the gut complements the Spiros beautifully pizz, not so much arco. It lasts longer than the Spiros though which is saying something.

  • @rickwilliams3412
    @rickwilliams3412 3 роки тому

    Great video. Hard to believe how much any of these strings cost!

  • @ry_guy_
    @ry_guy_ 3 роки тому

    Nice analysis!

  • @ibassnote
    @ibassnote 2 роки тому

    Great string. I used a g and d for a few years. Unwound at key note positions. Lovely but I’ve come to the conclusion that you either go gut or go steel with the g and d. I don’t think there is a better all-around string than a Spirocore. Does so many things well.

  • @EmanueleValente
    @EmanueleValente 3 роки тому

    Oliv strings are spectacular but sadly too expensive. Your video is very interesting even if I believe that Spirocore strings are not the winning combination with this type of string.
    The best "budget" combination IMHO is with Evah Pirazzi strings.
    Thanks for your videos are always very interesting.

  • @dfybyn
    @dfybyn 2 роки тому

    happy to compare an Oliv though :-)

  • @50CJAZZ
    @50CJAZZ 3 роки тому +1

    Sounds great.

  • @mikebassy
    @mikebassy 3 роки тому

    We jam the chicken ha ha , the Jaco vhs tutor had come out Xmas 1985 and I bought it despite not having a video cassette deck . I used to just turn up at peoples houses and ask if I could watch the Jaco tape for a bit . Hilarious

  • @sebuteo
    @sebuteo 3 роки тому

    Loved this. I’m already a subscriber. But here’s my comment, in a bid for the Oliv-G: I don’t play arco! Pizz’/finger-style only. Making me the perfect candidate for your very generous giveaway. 🤓

  • @albertotravagli
    @albertotravagli 10 місяців тому +1

    You're truly wonderful!

  • @marcobojorquez9467
    @marcobojorquez9467 3 роки тому

    Man, give the Perpetual Stark G. It has a great punchy tone and since it’s a steel string the playability is very close to Spiros but warm closer to Oliv territory. I’m pairing it with the .3885 Weichs. It’s butter.

  • @silphium5510
    @silphium5510 3 роки тому

    Great comparison -- the playing ain't half bad either ;-). I'm one of those who's looked around for alternative to spiros. I'm using Perpetuals now, and liking them. The Oliv sounds great. But I wonder: is it a realistic, practical option?

  • @alexanderliljeberg7628
    @alexanderliljeberg7628 3 роки тому

    Sounds great!!!

  • @dfybyn
    @dfybyn 2 роки тому

    and my eudoxas d and g took nearly 3 weeks before the tuning settled

  • @johnclement7473
    @johnclement7473 2 роки тому

    Hay thank you for your you tube videos just what I need to see and hear from you. I play electric bass and would love to play upright bass can't afford one at this time but will in the future. But I just want you to know your show is awesome and I'm learning so much from you and I'm so glad that the bass was calling me to come and give it a try. Bass is a great instrument and I hope you do a show on electric bass strings and how to set up a bass for playing. Like the bridge the strings and how to tune your bass. And let us know what name brand upright bass you play and what's the most expensive upright bass you've seen and who are the best upright bass makers in business. Hay keep bassing man and thank you again.🎸

    • @pdbass
      @pdbass  2 роки тому

      Thank you for watching, John! I will definitely follow up on some of your questions 🙏🏽

    • @jamesrichardson3322
      @jamesrichardson3322 2 роки тому

      @@pdbass what is your on opinion the D' Addario Helicore Orchestra Series Double Bass Strings Set 3/4 Size Medium.
      I am having my double upright bass repair, because the fingerboard and bridge fall off. This is the second time I am having my fingerboard repair. I am going to put D' Addario Helicore Strings Orchestra Double Bass Strings.

    • @pdbass
      @pdbass  2 роки тому

      @@jamesrichardson3322 I'm not a huge fan of Helicore Orchestral, but I dig the Hybrids. The Orchestrals are VERY dark and thuddy for jazz--if that's your thing. The Hybrids have more ping and sustain.

    • @jamesrichardson3322
      @jamesrichardson3322 2 роки тому

      @@pdbass The Helicore Orchestra Strings aren't good for Jazz? Hybrids are good for Jazz and classical music & other types of music and bowing??

    • @pdbass
      @pdbass  2 роки тому

      @@jamesrichardson3322 it depends on what you're looking for. IME, the orchestras had more "thump" than "bwah" for my tastes. There's a reason they're called "orchestral", but you'll have to try them out to form your own opinion. Don't base your opinions on UA-cam COMMENTS. 😉

  • @gabrielpreusse8421
    @gabrielpreusse8421 3 роки тому

    Looking forward 👌🏽

  • @evancarley5359
    @evancarley5359 3 роки тому

    Oliv sounds great but spiros just strike such a balance for me it's hard to be compelled to switch.

  • @Gangster_Club3
    @Gangster_Club3 Рік тому

    I'm a newbie, my question is if you always change the G string only? , the other three strings are not changed as often? I play only pizzicato, thank you

    • @pdbass
      @pdbass  Рік тому

      Many upright bassists mix-and-match different brands of strings. Some produce great bottom but maybe not-so-great top. Some people like to pick strings based on their instrument (i.e. bright strings for a dark bass, etc.).
      I prefer to change the set, but people often find that a lot of 'G' strings don't match the volume/resonance/balls of the rest of the set--especially the brand I use: Thomastik Spirocore. The Oliv G is really wonderful and has this amazing ability to blend in with the rest of the set. It's just too darn fragile for my tastes. Thank you for watching!

  • @OriginalTLab3000
    @OriginalTLab3000 3 роки тому

    You could get a brand new bass guitar for the price of that string 😮
    Can't believe I haven't subscribed earlier!

  • @mikebassy
    @mikebassy 3 роки тому

    When will the recording with the olive G string come out ?

  • @mendibasko
    @mendibasko 2 роки тому

    I played a baroque gig with a sinthetic set and an oliv g up top and it lasted 3 days 😔

    • @pdbass
      @pdbass  2 роки тому

      Alas. Write Pirastro. They were quick to send me a replacement!

  • @bustabass9025
    @bustabass9025 3 роки тому

    Spirocore Weichs make my $500 Chinese laminated starter bass sound like an old world master's hand carved creation, from 1930's Czechoslovakia!

  • @tildeberriogarcia2634
    @tildeberriogarcia2634 3 роки тому

    Yeahhh!

  • @Tengeresz1969
    @Tengeresz1969 2 місяці тому

    What kind of bas do you have? It seems to be a german bass 3/4 from Markneukirchen.

    • @pdbass
      @pdbass  2 місяці тому

      Pöllmann ‘72

    • @Tengeresz1969
      @Tengeresz1969 Місяць тому

      @@pdbass Very good, congratulation. This is my Emanuel Lang bass with Evah Pirazzi Weichs. ua-cam.com/video/mm0Y6NxuXnM/v-deo.htmlsi=hlXYuAhl0mPCP-S8

  • @paulfonseca1389
    @paulfonseca1389 2 роки тому

    Do you know what strings ron carter uses

    • @pdbass
      @pdbass  2 роки тому

      www.labella.com/artists/ron-carter/

  • @fabiogutierrez8319
    @fabiogutierrez8319 3 роки тому

    Had my heart broken by the Oliv G twice...not going back for thirds.

  • @TokyoTraveller
    @TokyoTraveller 8 місяців тому

    I prefer your original strings. The Oliv strings sounds a bit muddled to me....

  • @jamesoconnell7443
    @jamesoconnell7443 2 роки тому

    Hello PDBASS. I’m wondering about making a suggestion. I won’t unless you reply as I don’t want to waste your time. Thanks for all that you do. It’s easily the best education I’ve gotten on bass. Since everything and everyone’s already covered there’s not much more that I can say.

    • @pdbass
      @pdbass  2 роки тому

      Always open to hear them, James!

    • @parahycodan
      @parahycodan 2 роки тому +1

      Hello PDBASS. I'm astounded by everything you've ever said no matter who or what you choose to cover. It's rare enough to say that i've not heard anything like it before. The content aside, the experience is preternatural-uniquely yours along with very fine craft. Absolute Dynamite. It's like a PBS special or if not that then it exceeds that. I haven't told anyone except my sister.
      So, there's these two songs that are pretty rare I think. They were written and performed by a folk singer who was once famous for his having known and played with Bob Dylan. Dave Van Ronk's his name and he decided to do something more along the lines of a Pop record. It's called "Dave Van Ronk and his Hudson Dusters". There are two songs on the LP I always loved but mostly for the Bass playing of a guy known as Gregory Williams. The songs are called "Keep off the Grass" and, "New Dreams". To hear the Bass, I have to be in my car for whatever reasons as it can be heard much much better. I expect nothing nor even so much as a listen but if you do and have something to say then that's cool. When I listen to this guy in these two songs is utterly amazing. Even to this day.
      Kindly,
      James

  • @bassmonk2920
    @bassmonk2920 3 роки тому

    Spiro G just sounds better but sucks on the bowing so that would be my decision to switch....

  • @johnmontalvo9537
    @johnmontalvo9537 10 днів тому

    I began with Helli Hybrids

  • @dfybyn
    @dfybyn 2 роки тому +1

    lastly - there is a guy on talk bass from Oz that has old new stock and is selling sets for $200 AUD - so cheap!!!!!!

  • @daviddaniel3126
    @daviddaniel3126 2 роки тому

    1) I love your swing.
    2) I have had the same issue with Sprirocore's G.
    3) What does the rest of the Oliv set sound like on your bass? *
    Bonus question: I love the sound of the bass on the theme for the Monk TV show. I have been unable to find out who the bass player is, let alone his setup. Can you find out the strings used on that bass?
    * I just heard the whole Oliv set vs the Eudoxa. The Oliv EAD don't match the appeal of the G. The EAD don't speak nearly as well. (check it here ua-cam.com/video/nn9dLKqTXa4/v-deo.html)

    • @pdbass
      @pdbass  2 роки тому

      Thank you! Unfortunately, I can't afford to buy more than one Oliv string at a time. They're $$$$! I'm also pretty happy with my Spiros, and "if ain't broke, don't fix it." I did some looking and I can't find out who the bass player is on "Jungle Out There" myself. I'll let you know if I come across it. Keep in mind, Jeff Beal is in LA and it's more than likely one of the LA session cats (I believe)! Thanks for watching.

  • @CarlosRibeiroJr
    @CarlosRibeiroJr 2 роки тому

    me!!! i want it!! please