What does the Bible really say? with Dan McClellan

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 113

  • @stephentaylforth4731
    @stephentaylforth4731 Рік тому +29

    Fabulous, As an atheist I came across Dan McClellan a couple of weeks ago (thanks UA-cam algorithm) and didn't get him, His content is practically identically to many atheist channels (entirely rational and scholarly) but he identifies as a Morman / or long varient) and doesn't think too higlhly of atheists. He makes a lot more sense now and much of what he says is worth taking heed of. His take of " text has no inherent meaning , we just create the meaning in our minds" is a what I've taken away from watching this. Bravo

    • @joshuakohlmann9731
      @joshuakohlmann9731 Рік тому +5

      He doesn't seem to have an agenda or a personal axe to grind; I think that's the best thing. He's about combating misinformation whichever side it comes from - and God knows there's enough of that about.

    • @jhurt3824
      @jhurt3824 9 місяців тому

      He left that church. Now he does almost all of his content with atheists

    • @wendyleeconnelly2939
      @wendyleeconnelly2939 8 місяців тому +4

      Did he actually leave the church? I see that comment here and there but I can't find anything from him suggesting he's anything but a Mormon in good standing.

    • @jannetteberends8730
      @jannetteberends8730 5 місяців тому +1

      @@jhurt3824that he works with an atheist doesn’t mean he is.

    • @gandaruvu
      @gandaruvu Місяць тому

      @@jhurt3824 He still pinned his video regarding his church membership on his channel. If he left, he would've taken that down.

  • @stevenv6463
    @stevenv6463 Рік тому +11

    Great interview. As someone who follows professor McClellan for a while now, it's good to see some of his thinking and worldview he comes to his videos with. I also recommend his appearance on mythvision for something more in depth than his short videos.

  • @sunshowerpainting1
    @sunshowerpainting1 Рік тому +5

    Dan is a voice of reason the world desperately needs. I applaud his great undertaking in social media communities as discourse is the answer to war and the grave harm it brings.

  • @Dracapalley
    @Dracapalley 2 місяці тому +2

    This was brilliant. I regard Dan very highly, but have sometimes wondered if his video response/takedowns are the right medium for what he aims to achieve. Sometimes I've felt there is a danger in aiming to set some misinformed individual and their followers on a different path (for better) while simultaneously also reaching folks who don't believe a conspiracy but hear his negations and have their own faith worldview challenged to the point of a sort of existential crisis. This particular video is incredibly useful because I got a much deeper sense of Dan's humanity and to really understand the way he thinks about the best way to approach these ancient texts. It has helped to sort of put my head right about some things that I'd previously been feeling pretty depressed about after watching his videos on his own channel, not because I disagreed with his purpose in pouring cold water on conspiracies, but because I probably consider myself as someone in that second camp of passive watchers aforementioned. Thanks for making this interview happen. I'm grateful for your non-combative, safe space / respectful interview style that got the very best out of the opportunity to hear really helpful insights from a very intelligent guy.

  • @minaguta4147
    @minaguta4147 Рік тому +20

    Dan is such a calm voice of reason in a space that is sorely lacking in such voices. Thank your for a great interview that answered so many of the questions I had about Dan's approach to faith and the motivations behind his online activity. We need so many more like him in the public sphere.

  • @jacasadia
    @jacasadia Рік тому +13

    I follow Dan's social media and I have never seen him interviewed. This was a wonderful interview to watch. Very interesting.

  • @nealljones
    @nealljones 2 роки тому +8

    I'd love to hear Dan explain himself in great detail with respect to Paul and homosexuality. I appreciate his scholarship.

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  2 роки тому +3

      Take his class!

    • @nealljones
      @nealljones 2 роки тому +2

      @@HeadOnFirePod What class? Video series?

    • @Quack_Shot
      @Quack_Shot 2 роки тому

      I tried posting his Linktree but it didn’t work. If you go to his TikTok profile he has it. The link to his January class on his topic is on there.

    • @LapsedSkeptic
      @LapsedSkeptic 2 роки тому +2

      @@nealljones he puts on classes independently on specific topics he posts links from time to time on his channel…I think it’s February maybe January he is doing a class focusing on homosexuality and the Bible…I’m sure the relationship between King David & Jonathan will be featured but Paul/New Testament as well I’d think.

  • @LukeCartner
    @LukeCartner 2 роки тому +9

    As an atheist I find Dan's work a fasenating lens to see what the ancient experience and how it informed our history and culture was and is

  • @dalex60
    @dalex60 Рік тому +2

    The bible really says, that Jesus never taught hell fire as a form of eternal punishment...

  • @Lowlandlord
    @Lowlandlord Рік тому +1

    Comic convo when? WHEN?!?!?!?

  • @byew-byew
    @byew-byew Рік тому +4

    really awesome conversation. great questions with really nuanced answers, Dan is a gem

  • @BramptonAnglican
    @BramptonAnglican 11 місяців тому +1

    Absolutely love Dan’s content. He does amazing work.

  • @sunshowerpainting1
    @sunshowerpainting1 Рік тому +2

    What is the canvas of a life if not painted by an individuals thoughts and feelings? Every chids painting has merit and brings something noteworthy to the tapestry of humanity. Keeping our painting to our own canvas should be the first, best practice.

  • @geoffreydowdle5751
    @geoffreydowdle5751 2 роки тому +4

    When you guys were talking about people that are intolerant to irrational thoughts, I was so sure that Charles Dawkins was going to be said that when you said Neil, I was for some reason surprised lol.

  • @Jake-zc3fk
    @Jake-zc3fk Рік тому +5

    How do you give 10 thumbs up? :)

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  Рік тому

      👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

  • @glenwillson5073
    @glenwillson5073 4 місяці тому

    People trying to understand what the Bible really says, when Isaiah says they've got no hope of doing so - yep that's going to work.

  • @matejoh
    @matejoh 2 роки тому +6

    Atheist here, but just interested in the conversation. Thx.

  • @BunnyWatson-k1w
    @BunnyWatson-k1w Рік тому

    Dan looks a lot more youthful without the beard.

  • @joanlantis4497
    @joanlantis4497 11 місяців тому

    So what does Dan think Sodom waas destroyed for?

    • @TheRealBeanEnthusiast
      @TheRealBeanEnthusiast 10 місяців тому +1

      inhospitality and rape

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  10 місяців тому +3

      The thing the Bible says it was destroyed for.

    • @m.gattus-reinhart845
      @m.gattus-reinhart845 10 місяців тому

      ​@@TheRealBeanEnthusiastTrue and then there's an expansion of sin in Ezekiel

    • @jannetteberends8730
      @jannetteberends8730 5 місяців тому

      Sodom never existed.

    • @glenwillson5073
      @glenwillson5073 4 місяці тому

      ​@@TheRealBeanEnthusiast
      Yep, attempted rape of beings they thought were MEN.

  • @jimhuskins8506
    @jimhuskins8506 11 місяців тому

    No Bible scholars promote the pagan based literature and imagery that so excites you.

  • @downenout8705
    @downenout8705 Рік тому +1

    7 easy steps for determining, "what does the Bible really say":
    Step 1 From the close to one hundred versions of the Bible pick the "right" one.
    Step 2 Spread the 3,000 plus pieces (verses) on a smooth surface. Numbers will very depending on which "right" version chosen.
    Step 3 Select the "right" pieces to construct your god.
    Step 4 Return all unused pieces to the box .
    Step 5 Construct your god.
    Step 6 If your god is incomplete, take additional pieces as necessary from the box, carve to shape and use to complete construction.
    Step 7 Never ever, look at the unused pieces.
    This man definitely left 1 Corinthians 14: 33 in the box.

    • @daltondavis8759
      @daltondavis8759 Рік тому

      You think Dan believes in a God of confusion?

    • @downenout8705
      @downenout8705 Рік тому +1

      @@daltondavis8759 Yep, it's a trend amongst modern Christians. When a secular world looks a lot better than the one in your Bible, it takes considerable effort to make that square book fit into a round secular hole.

    • @kentstallard6512
      @kentstallard6512 Рік тому

      ​@@downenout8705Reality looks better than the awful mythology of the Bible.

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  11 місяців тому

      _

    • @downenout8705
      @downenout8705 11 місяців тому

      @@HeadOnFirePod A most peculiar reply.

  • @scottyvanantwerp
    @scottyvanantwerp Рік тому +1

    Looking for a prooftext to serve an ideology...damn. Boom, he said the quiet part calmly, but out loud, like it wasn't the most fatal flaw and damaging aspect of organized religion. I'm dying. Ho hum...here's the problem, let's move on.... :D

    • @dorothysay8327
      @dorothysay8327 Рік тому

      Organized religion is NOT the problem. Bad exegesis is. You’re throwing a LOT of beautiful people under the bus, with that blanket bigotry. Don’t do it.

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  Рік тому

      Thanks for listening

  • @TheDanBidondiShow
    @TheDanBidondiShow Рік тому +4

    LOL so funny, he's a Marvel fan but has no idea that each of the Marvel characters are based off actual ancient fallen angel and nephilim figures.
    A scholar knows the Bible through academia, but doesn't truly know the Bible or its spiritual application.
    ONLY the Holy Spirit can truly teach the Bible better than any school, college, university, scholar, professor, religous leader, church or religion combined.

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  Рік тому +6

      Hey, quick question, which fallen Angel or
      Nephilim figure is Moira MacTaggert based on?

  • @elijahdieker1209
    @elijahdieker1209 2 роки тому +1

    I am Elijah of Malachi 4:5-6 so any discrepancies in the Bible are ultimately decided by me.

    • @TheDanBidondiShow
      @TheDanBidondiShow Рік тому

      NO, you are not and I will tell you that to your face.

    • @elijahdieker1209
      @elijahdieker1209 Рік тому

      @@TheDanBidondiShow yes, I am and there's nothing you can to do about it.
      My wedding is already paid for and it will be broadcasted all over the world.
      Your torment will get worse until you repent or die. As long as you refuse to repent, you loved ones will be taken and just like the ret of the fake ministers, you will know you chose it

  • @dansaber4427
    @dansaber4427 2 роки тому +10

    You can be LGBT and Christian 👬

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  2 роки тому +6

      Yes you can.

    • @SylverWordSmyth
      @SylverWordSmyth 2 роки тому +2

      Allegedly God is the light, light is a pure spectrum, pure spectrum is all paint, all paint is every picture. You can be whatever is clever forever n ever Dan Saber

    • @dansaber4427
      @dansaber4427 2 роки тому

      @@SylverWordSmyth your faith has healed you. thanks for stopping by

    • @LapsedSkeptic
      @LapsedSkeptic 2 роки тому +3

      I would suggest using the word Theist over Christian but the sentiment I certainly agree with as well.

    • @TheDanBidondiShow
      @TheDanBidondiShow Рік тому +1

      NO, you can't! Whoever told you that is a liar. You can't serve to masters.
      Coming to Jesus means REPENTANCE from sin, not condoning it.

  • @irontaylor9992
    @irontaylor9992 Рік тому

    marvel is cool

  • @FishermensCorner
    @FishermensCorner 8 місяців тому

    Weird how Dan extrapolated Paul in "today", Data over Dogma, unless where it suits himself, of course. Leviticus 16 makes it clear what is moral Dan.... it requires mercy.

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  8 місяців тому

      Morality does not come from any one book.

    • @FishermensCorner
      @FishermensCorner 8 місяців тому

      @HeadOnFirePod sure, Leviticus 16 is not a book but a witness of atonement.

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  8 місяців тому +1

      @@FishermensCorner if you need a book to tell you how to be moral, and that book also has weird rules about eating shrimp and stoning people, you are not a moral person.

    • @FishermensCorner
      @FishermensCorner 8 місяців тому

      @HeadOnFirePod you mean like strawmanning someone like that? That's covered under the 9th commandment. But see, people should naturally know how to behave but they can't, so things get codified, good effort though.

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  8 місяців тому

      @@FishermensCorner so the Bible is the correct code?

  • @q.qniformq.8663
    @q.qniformq.8663 Рік тому +2

    Lots of talk about expertise and qualifications with little demonstration of either.

  • @TheDanBidondiShow
    @TheDanBidondiShow Рік тому +3

    The LDS cult, yeah he is way out of touch with the Bible. I've seen his videos and he misinterprits the Bible.

    • @vmonk2
      @vmonk2 Рік тому +1

      You can’t even spell. He can spell in biblical Hebrew and Koine greek. Sit down

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  Рік тому +1

      Disagree

  • @andypantsgaming
    @andypantsgaming 4 місяці тому

    "What does the bible really say?"
    I can't imagine a person less qualified to answer that than Dan

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  4 місяці тому +1

      Because you personally disagree with his findings or because you think he is lying about his qualifications?

    • @andypantsgaming
      @andypantsgaming 4 місяці тому

      @@HeadOnFirePod He's a mormon and therefore good at lying

    • @andypantsgaming
      @andypantsgaming 2 місяці тому

      @@HeadOnFirePod He disagrees with the bible

  • @marthadavis5068
    @marthadavis5068 2 роки тому +2

    There are two covenants.
    The old covenant is dead.
    Fullfilled by Christ.

    • @Bugsy0333
      @Bugsy0333 Рік тому +2

      Wrong “Do not think that I have come to abolish Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them.” Matthew 5:17

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  11 місяців тому

      _

  • @tonyadieker2201
    @tonyadieker2201 2 роки тому

    If you delete the mrssages sent from the mesernger of Malachi 3:1 then you reject Jesus hersrlf and you will die with the wicked. Are you going to do it again?

  • @chainedmindsasylum
    @chainedmindsasylum Рік тому

    🤗 May the ghost of Joseph Smith bind thee upon the gallows of the Chattahoochee River when the tide is high in winter 🥶 😋

    • @TheDanBidondiShow
      @TheDanBidondiShow Рік тому

      Joseph Smith was a false prophet, an occultist and freemason and a liar.

  • @oscargarcia7596
    @oscargarcia7596 Рік тому +3

    Dan is a false teacher

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  Рік тому +3

      I mean…he’s literally an expert, but go off I guess.

    • @FishermensCorner
      @FishermensCorner 8 місяців тому

      ​@@HeadOnFirePod he's a JW who rejects the power of the holy spirit and replaces it with "data."

    • @FishermensCorner
      @FishermensCorner 8 місяців тому

      Correct Oscar. He has a personal agenda, and it's not God.

    • @HeadOnFirePod
      @HeadOnFirePod  8 місяців тому +2

      @@FishermensCorner I don't even know what "rejects the power of the Holy Spirit" means in this context. But if you mean he fact checks misinformation and hate speech where people use the Bible to discriminate or sew fear, yes I agree he does that.

    • @FishermensCorner
      @FishermensCorner 8 місяців тому

      @@HeadOnFirePod If we listen, Christ will convict us.