I can definitely see that lip reading being correct. You appear to have answered an age old Tally Hall mystery and a question I've had for the whole time I've been in this fandom. That's deserving of a pin
I WATCHED THE LIVE BEFORE I LISTENED TO THE WHOLE ALBUM AND I REGRET IT SM BECAUSE NOW THATS ALL I HEAR WJEN I LISTEN TO SPRING AND A STORM AND HYMN FOR A SCARCROW 😭😭😭😭
I know. I'm not trying to say that this kind of banter isn't something they all have (e.g Zubin putting mustard in Bora's ketchup, Bora ruining Zubin's phone call, Zubin bringing attention to Joe's collar situation) I just think how drastically the two go from being the two closest members to "hating" eachother the hilarious
@@Sad.Mellohi if I'm not mistaken, they probably refer to Joe's suit's collar being slightly undone during a performance! Quoting Joe on that matter: "facing some wardrobe malfunctions"!
0:11 Why didn't Joe say that everyone likes Zubin? Or maybe I don't understand something 3:55 I like the way Ross just looks down like he's ashamed of these guys 😭
0:22 fun fact: if Joe's mocking was an attempt at sign language he got pretty close (atleast in ASL). I think "voice" would be signed with two fingers and come from your throat. He got "hear" and "my" right I think (sorry, I'm better at BSL and even then I'm not very good lol)
6:05 I believe Joe says ”come here buddy” here aswell. It’s kinda mumbled but It’s probably what he says because he gestures to Rob like ”come here” which he does :)
I mean it's a good example of their strange friendship. At the start he was busy saying how he hates Rob and telling him the guitar doesn't like him and now he's on the verge of a mental breakdown because "Bobby couldn't be here today"
I think this is obvious but the T.H.I.S clips aren't real and they're acting. They're over exaggerations of how they actually behave and shiuldnt be conflated with how they actually behave. It's just funny that they chose to write themselves like that :)
They really had a moment there. I love the way Rob was like "I like you... Playing it" like it's that scene in ratatouille (not shipping them it just sounded strangely like he was trying to cover up a crush he has on him really Disney channel-like)
My headcanon is that Rob was sent from heaven and Joe was sent from hell to have the ultimate battle of good & evil but ended up becoming besties in the process. That's what the meaning of the album good & evil is 👍 /j
No, don't worry! I'm always happy to have people telling me subtitles I missed. It helps make the video make more sense and makes it all the more easy to follow for deaf, hard of hearing and non-native English speaking people! Plus that clip where they're discussing Joe's fly is extremely confusing to follow and I was very unsure what they were saying half the time so any corrections or explanations are useful (seriously, Andrew's story made 0 sense and if my subtitles are correct he just straight up embarrassed Joe for no reason which I feel is out of character for Andrew)
omg I love how you added subtitles bc english is not my first language and this way I can understand better what they're saying!! also how you added so many clips, usually people only make videos with the boralogues or T.H.I.S clips so this is really cool, keep up the good work!!
Thank you so much! I'm really glad my subtitles have helped you understand what's being said because they took quite a long time. As a hearing, Native English speaking person, I definitely have an advantage and even then it's difficult to understand what's being said by the members in clips with bad audio quality and stuff like that so I thought I should add them. As for the clips, I believe people would get bored of Tally Hall compilations if they just saw the same few clips over and over (I know I have). Plus, T.H.I.S isn't them so if the majority of a compilation is clips of that they haven't exactly full-filled the title's promises. Anyway, I'll stop waffling now, thank you
I'm so glad the subtitles help you! I add them to all my compilations (except for one that had hardly any talking in it) because as a hearing Native English speaker I often struggle to follow what they're saying too due to bad audio quality, mumbling or talking over each other. I want my compilations to be accessible to everyone as it's pretty shit that currently a lot of the community can't consume content in the same way as the hearing and native English speaking portion of the community (not that it's anyone's fault since they're an old band and the cameras weren't high quality back then). It's a lot of work but it's worth it to unite the community and give everyone a fair chance of enjoying this band's extra content
Thank you! I have been trying to figure out the exact words said in that video and I've had a lot of trouble with it (as you can see by the amount of questions marks and over all missing dialogue). You're definitely right with that. I'm not exactly sure what they were all saying for most of it but I think for the most part I got the subtitles close enough. I also do not know what he said before "sorry to interrupt" and after "the collar stays-" lol
@@project_letters Yeah I can’t hear either what he says after ”the collar stays”. Pretty hard to make out because everyone is talking at the same time. The quality of the recording is kinda crap aswell which doesn’t make it any better LOL
Yeah, it's impressive you managed to pick up what Joe mumbled tbh. It really bothers me that I can't make what Andrew said make sense. Like he's talking about how it's embarrassing to have your fly undone during a show and then when asked about it he says it happened the other show but his fly was done up and Joe's wasn't which I doubt is what he said. Unless Andrew is extremely cruel, I assume he's saying he believed his own fly to be done up when it wasn't (even though that contradicts what he just said about being aware it was undone) but then he says something about Joe's fly being undone the whole show which implies his wasn't but that'd contradict the entirety of what he was saying???? I doubt he'd just randomly decide to embarrass Joe on stage by bringing attention to the fact that his fly was down if he wasn't also in the same boat so this clip gets more confusing every time I try to decipher it. Anyway, I'll shut up now lol
@@project_letters Thank you! I felt like a genius when I finally heard it. And yeah Andrews story is pretty confusing because of the audio quality so I don’t blame you at all😊
@@project_letters Now that i’ve listened to it more it sounds like Joe only says ”the collar stays”. Almost in like a "the collar stays up everytime tho". It fits pretty good to me because they’re talking about their fly being undone during a show. Maybe it sounds like he’s saying something after because Andrew says ”it might be worse” right after Joe finishes his sentence?
Just reached 9,700 as I posted this video. Now Idk if I can be totally sure of this but I could be (SUBSCRIBERS WISE) the most popular Tally Hall creator other than Tally Hall themselves? Like I'm not going to make a case that im more famous than Hidden in the sand, Tally ball, Tally Hal, Wahwahster, etc... since all of those are like the equivalent of a house hold names in the Tally Hall fandom and I'm definitely not on that level (no one knows who tf I am I just kind of spawned in here with a large number if subscribers. I'm an enigma) but I'm very proud of myself. I'm so close to my long term goal of 10k and that makes me so proud :D it is kind of concerning that I have so many eyes on me and it does make me panic but it's also very exciting that so many people care about me and what I have to say! Basically, thank you all so much Edit: tally all is not tally hall has more subscribers that me, but I'm atleast in second place which is crazy tbh! Also me saying this isn't to create competition. I've been at this for 9 years, creators like Tally ball seems to have only just picked this up so congratulations to them!
Congrats on 9700!!! You definitely deserve more, your content is really enjoyable and it seems like you put a ton of effort into your vids. Also I hate to be THAT person but you still have yet to beat "tallyall is still not tallyhall" in subs, so I give u good luck 🫡🫡
@@Crazyrayz thank you! Good to know I'm not the single most popular subscribers wise I guess. I'm not trying to compete here considering too many eyes on me will have negative impacts. I of course love the audience as this is a passion but I'm also a minor and am prone to do something that'll anger someone 😂
Subscribers-wise he isn't. He's extremely close as if reaching 9k but I'm a couple hundred ahead of him. He's definitely more popular in the community and impressive considering he reached my level having only started about a year ago (I've been at this for 9 years and only spent very little of the in this community). I just kind of arrived here with this following
I remember month ago I always want to make " rob and joe best moments" but there is no enough clips I could find. I’m glad I found this video and now it’s addicting tbh
Yeah, that's an example of him genuinely seeming angry at Rob. Doesn't mean he hates Rob but I guess he was angry that Rob wasn't listening to him when saying "stop" so he retaliated with violence and stormed off. Almost feels awkward to watch because it seems he was genuinely upset with Rob's punching even if he was joking. He was fine for the rest of the video though
@@project_letters i wouldn't say it's genuine? might be a bit, but it's hard to really say, joe was saying "ow" jokingly (theres 0 way that actually hurt), he could have very well just have been pretending to be mad for the camera
@@redfiretf2 yeah, you've got a point. I mean I don't think it would've genuinely hurt but it might've overwhelmed him if he was repeatedly getting touched. We saw later on that he atleast wasn't a fan of getting touched by Rob on stage when his collar was messed up. That could be just the circumstance (getting embarrassed by Zubin on stage and then having Rob come over and try sort it out would be quite patronising) or he could be the type of person that hates getting touched for whatever reason. Idk it's difficult to tell if he was playing it up but from Rob's "ow" and looking up at him like "that actually hurt" before quickly cutting the clip off and the expression on Joe's face as he looks at the camera like "don't record me" before Zubin panned away and back to Rob it definitely seemed like he actually punched Rob unexpectedly. Then again it's on the internet and if Joe was actually angry they probably wouldn't have posted it. You never know really.
Which one? Joe or Rob because they both say something. I assume you mean Joe which I didn't notice when making this but yes Joe does say something. Idk what Rob said though. Tbh I think I need you by my side while I make these video to just be my pocket lip reader /j
@@project_lettersI was thinking of Joe! And yeah I can’t hear Rob either. But I did kinda hear a ”hands off!” or something like that from Rob. Could just be my imagination tho
JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY
The “competitive” comment joe made on that audio really make people believe they hate each other’s , genuinely it’s not true. It’s a common thing imo that both joe and Rob friendship consist of that , friends but with that not perfect friendship, always a lil issue. It’s normal for people that are in band. Joe is not perfect , Rob isn’t perfect. They both seem to care and worried for each others likely. I hope people understand that.
Yeah it pisses me off how people genuinely think they hate eachother. Like number 1, this video's existence disproves that. Number 2, friends joke about hating eachother all the time. It's called banter. You insult eachother for jokes and not every friendship does it but extremely close ones tend to because they're so close that they can take these jokes. Also Tally Hall famously give stupid answers in interviews, it isn't insane to assume they weren't giving a stupid answer and Joe picked Rob because they're close. For this band to be what it is Rob and Joe must've liked eachother. Rob wouldn't have joined Joe's comedy group and Joe wouldn't have joined Rob's band. You can't even argue they grew out of each other because Joe still invited Rob back twice for miracle musical, sampled him in JHJH and tried to get him to perform live with him in 2016. Idk about right this second but I know they're definitely close just by those prices if evidence
each member has an opinion about another member (not incl themselves) so it's just 5x4=20 therefore it's 19/20 unless you consider they include themselves for some reason in which case they canonically all love themselves
It's fine, you guys! I wasn't genuinely distraught, I still love this duo... Just not when Rob pregnant or when Joe has impregnated him. As we can see here Rob doesn't want Joe to caress his face and Joe doesn't want Rob touching him. Also Rob would prefer Joe to have his fly up at all times 💀😭
I think the rest of this video answers that question? I literally am so bewildered how anyone thinks he was being genuine. The only reason Joe is even in this damn band is because him and Rob are friends (Joe let Rob into anonymous and then Rob let Joe into Tally Hall). He invited him back for solo projects that he owned so it's not even like you can make the case that they grew out of the friendship. Are you witnessing the banter they have in wall party '06? This is the same band who told interviewers that they had been dating, they started their band because they wanted to start a t shirt business and when asked to give a beat boxing sample just went like "btssuh" and ended it. You really think he isn't evidently giving a stupid answer? How chill Rob is about it makes this all even more obvious. Like I joke that I hate my friends and they're the worst thing that ever happened to me because we're so close it's funny to even suggest that. That's what Joe was doing there
Awe bro this is so awesome man I want a friend like that dude Nah wait wait wait.. I just wanna be tally hall 🔥🔥 P.s. AWESOME VIDEO! Also, captions are done well.
Are you referring to "and a very big bra" or "take you by the knickers and I'll bum your slap"? If you mean the 2nd, yes. Surprisingly, many don't know that its meaning is that Joe is going to grab and presumably pull someone in by their underwear and spank them. I have no clue how but here we are
It's from a quack media educational video called word confusion. It's extremely funny. I showed very few clips from it and I'd recommend giving it a watch
Same. Joe doesn't seem fit to perform rn. It's not impossible that over the past few months he's improved (we saw he was well enough to be posting in December) and a lot of the hints can be interpreted to point towards him. However, I think we need Joe to at least sort of return to the Joe we used to know before Tally Hall reunite. He's said and done some awful hateful and disgusting things, some alleged and some proven. You can argue they're more from a place of ignorance than hate but he's still responsible. I want Joe to return and Tally Hall to reunite as friends as much as anyone but Joe needs help right now and he needs to be given that support from a therapist or something before returning to performing imo. Though if he is there that'd be awesome (also might show he's on his path to improvement). Currently, I think we need to think of these as baby steps to a possible reunion. We had the most Tally Hall members that have ever performed together since 2011 last Saturday and, though it's confirmed that there won't be any reunion in August, we know Andrew is not alone for SL. These are all good signs that everyone's back on track and Tally Hall are on their road to reunion hopefully
It seems maybe Joe didn't like Rob too much at least at one point. I just remembered him bringing up Rob as being very competitive in the (now scrubbed off the internet) phone call. Well, at least the audio of it is. I have my own copy of the transcript. I'll paste the tail end of it here: J: So let’s get real, what did I say to Eden, other than the N word, and did she call me the N word. N: She did not, no. J: How do you know? N: That’s what she said, this is all alleged and I’m trying to confirm it with you. J: You think you know, and then Eden behind your back thinks that she is a person other than you and is quite competitive, much like Rob Cantor, who initiated your friendship? N: Uh- I didn’t want to get too off topic, I didn’t want to take too much of your time- J: Oh, I see, so this is about me, and not about you, how did you and Eden meet? N: We met because of Tally Hall? J: Okay, who initiated the friendship? *Joe hangs up.*
I'd rather not talk on controversy. I'd never heard this phone call and I can hardly understand what's even being said. He's bloody confusing to understand and definitely got some issues. They at least had an interesting friendship, I hope Joe gets help because it's not right to throw Rob under the bus like that
I have a few Tally Hall theory’s on why they haven’t come back if anyone wants to hear: 1. They decided they’d make another album when they got more money and forgot about the band. Now whenever someone brings it up they feel guilty and that’s why they don’t talk about it much. 2. They like they’re lives better as family men 3. They moved on I feel like Tally Hall was just a little project that they didn’t know would blow up. Joe has multiple times acted like he took his band for granted and wants it back. Rob has moved on. Zubin is excited to make another album if it does happen. Ross and Andrew seem indifferent. These are just theories I don’t know anything about the personal feelings of the band members
It's from the bonus episode of T.H.I.S about South x Southwest 2007. There isn't an uncensored version but I'm going to try and get my religious studies teacher who's good at lip reading to try to decipher what's being said
Basically, back in 2016 Joe tried to sorta reunite the band. His set contained multiple Tally Hall songs and just sings that required other members (like variations on a cloud). That clip is him about to sing variations on a cloud without Rob, variations on a cloud being a song you can't sing alone due to being a duet. People find it very difficult to watch one member try and sing songs he write for a band all by himself and how sad he looks on an empty stage surrounded by instruments (probably belongs to another band but it doesn't help the fact that he's singing songs like the bidding surrounded by instruments that his friends needed to be playing). TL;DR Sonic lunch in an infamously sad video and in it Joe said "Bobby couldn't be here today" before singing a song, that's supposed to be a duet with Rob and himself, alone.
5:46 pretty sure that’s Joe cause throughout the video, he’s wearing a striped shirt. If you pause at the right time (unfortunately) you will see the stripes. Correct me if i’m wrong‼️🔥
Joe doesn't own his Instagram anymore and around the time when he did have Instagram but wasn't following Rob there was a picture taken of the two together. I think it's just Joe forgot to follow him or something.
Exactly. People take that interview answer so seriously and it's actually so weird. Tally hall constantly give stupid answers to interview Like saying that they're all dating or that Ross is a robot. Like For this bloody band to exist they had to have a mutual liking of each other. They also chose to perform together for years with banter and even had songs/performances after Tally hall where they did/tried to do a duet. They obviously were always friends and were just having banter in that interview. Whatever has happened recently is a separate thing entirely that we know hardly anything about so there's no point speculating.
Wall party '06. A performance done in a fan's basement. They have some lovely Rob and Joe clips where they seem to be having some fun banter. It's lovely to see Joe not being completely out of it and instead just a fun guy
![Tally Hall but it's actually out of context [improved and expanded version] | Tally Hall](/img/n.gif)
Im pretty sure censored Rob said "I think you broke my index like jesus christ" and "you slammed my fucking finger"
I can definitely see that lip reading being correct. You appear to have answered an age old Tally Hall mystery and a question I've had for the whole time I've been in this fandom. That's deserving of a pin
W
thank you
He clearly said y*s what are you talking about
(Thanks)
mcdonalds duo
Imma order a chicken enchirito, coke green and some non-trampolines
ketchup & mustard dorks,, 🥴🥴
so ronald mcdonald is joe and rob combined
Spanish Flag, Omelette & Ham, Pizza, Devil & Angel
bloody piss brothers
Joe: I don't like Rob
Also Joe: Bobby couldn't be here today
😭
I had mental breakdown when I see this clips
Stop 😭😭
he looked so sad :(
stop you're going to make me cry
8:32 “Bobby couldn’t be here today” hits like a brick
When will Bobby be able to be here today, Joseph?! We need answers!
I WATCHED THE LIVE BEFORE I LISTENED TO THE WHOLE ALBUM AND I REGRET IT SM BECAUSE NOW THATS ALL I HEAR WJEN I LISTEN TO SPRING AND A STORM AND HYMN FOR A SCARCROW 😭😭😭😭
They're just messing with each other all the time, and honestly? What kind of friendship doesn't have this type of messing around lmfaoooo
I know. I'm not trying to say that this kind of banter isn't something they all have (e.g Zubin putting mustard in Bora's ketchup, Bora ruining Zubin's phone call, Zubin bringing attention to Joe's collar situation) I just think how drastically the two go from being the two closest members to "hating" eachother the hilarious
@@project_letters w Tally fan! ^^
@@project_letterswhat was the collar situation??
@@Sad.Mellohi if I'm not mistaken, they probably refer to Joe's suit's collar being slightly undone during a performance! Quoting Joe on that matter: "facing some wardrobe malfunctions"!
@@project_lettersagreed
0:11 Why didn't Joe say that everyone likes Zubin? Or maybe I don't understand something
3:55 I like the way Ross just looks down like he's ashamed of these guys 😭
He didn't mention zubin cause zubin is dead /j
The sonic lunch fucking jumpscared me you are cruel
I'm a very mean man (even though I'm 16 and a girl 💀)
@@project_letters Your 24 and a guy now
@@project_letters Fucking Evil
@@project_letters how could you
@@project_lettersI literally gasped and had to hold back tears 😭
0:22 fun fact: if Joe's mocking was an attempt at sign language he got pretty close (atleast in ASL). I think "voice" would be signed with two fingers and come from your throat. He got "hear" and "my" right I think (sorry, I'm better at BSL and even then I'm not very good lol)
we need an ikea duo
I'll probably do more of these with the various duos
I would give my *S O U L* for a nintendo switch duo
Imagine you get kidnapped and you just hear "JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY" and know that you're done for
Sounds like the ideal scenario
@@BeanKally very ideal.
6:05 I believe Joe says ”come here buddy” here aswell. It’s kinda mumbled but It’s probably what he says because he gestures to Rob like ”come here” which he does :)
Here you are again being good at hearing things! Thank you again!
@@project_letters Of course!! I guess i’m good at hearing things and lipreading! 😊
that's so wholesome omfg 😭
@@JustSomeoneHi right!! 😭😭
the lighting on joe in this scene 5:38 i cant
It's giving good & evil for some reason
thats what ive been saying
1:58 “x37” YOU COUNTED?!
I completely regretted that waste of time hence why I didn't do it later on in the video 😭
Im like 90% sure thats the amount of times and is said in &, gonna go double check in a bit
x3
IM SORRY BUT WHY DID YOU HAVE TO PUT THE SONIC LUNCH ONE?? THAT LITERALLY RAN ME OVER 😨😨
I mean it's a good example of their strange friendship. At the start he was busy saying how he hates Rob and telling him the guitar doesn't like him and now he's on the verge of a mental breakdown because "Bobby couldn't be here today"
i love how the whole joke of that was that "erm i dont like rob" but theyre actually best friends
“EÆH EÆH EÆH” -Joseph Robert Hawley
2:25 "joe hawley when being asked what his fanbase isnt" 😭😭
4:00, self note
I think this is obvious but the T.H.I.S clips aren't real and they're acting. They're over exaggerations of how they actually behave and shiuldnt be conflated with how they actually behave. It's just funny that they chose to write themselves like that :)
1:55 “ jolly jolly jolly jolly jolly jolly jolly”
3:31 for some reason made me think that this was a Tally Hall out of context💀
Maybe I should make that one day
@@project_letters yeah, probably
@@project_letterswhere did that clip come from?
Andrew in the background of two wuv is beautiful
Bro full on lagged. He was like 😐, then went to play an instrument, they didn't and reverted back to 😐
"We should definitely do it"
"Oh, this is ridiculous.."
"SHUT THE F*CK UP!! 😡😡 Go ahead, Andrew 😊"
I Am New To Tally Hall and I Am Convinced Joe Hawley Is A Pokemon .
3:56 Everybody grab your luck??? WTH DID HE SAY LMAOAOAO
I got no clue. I'd been trying to figure it out for subtitles but in the end admitted defeat and put "[???]"
Everybody grab a nook
he started speaking an unknown language
6:32 Mind Electric Reference
All my Tetris crumbles down the blocks are gasping under rubble.
Shrieking in the hall of blocks, thy genius saves a thirst for Tetris
@@blimpy_boog Spiraling down my block tower I beg of Rob stop distracting me.
@@ItzPokemon I was just a block, you see, I plead of thee, don’t play Tetris with me
2:42, best clip🔥
They really had a moment there. I love the way Rob was like "I like you... Playing it" like it's that scene in ratatouille (not shipping them it just sounded strangely like he was trying to cover up a crush he has on him really Disney channel-like)
@@project_lettersreal
Such an odd friendship
My headcanon is that Rob was sent from heaven and Joe was sent from hell to have the ultimate battle of good & evil but ended up becoming besties in the process. That's what the meaning of the album good & evil is 👍 /j
9:22 he says “sorry to interrupt” lmao
Yes, I added that subtitle in my next compilation upon someone explaining that to me don't worry. Thank you for telling me though
@@project_letters oh, I’m sorry, I didn’t realize that 😞
No, don't worry! I'm always happy to have people telling me subtitles I missed. It helps make the video make more sense and makes it all the more easy to follow for deaf, hard of hearing and non-native English speaking people! Plus that clip where they're discussing Joe's fly is extremely confusing to follow and I was very unsure what they were saying half the time so any corrections or explanations are useful (seriously, Andrew's story made 0 sense and if my subtitles are correct he just straight up embarrassed Joe for no reason which I feel is out of character for Andrew)
2:31 how did Joe not break Rob's fingers? The way he shut the door was enough force to break a finger fr 😭
"i like you -- playing it" WHY WAS THIS SO FUNNY LMFAO
omg I love how you added subtitles bc english is not my first language and this way I can understand better what they're saying!! also how you added so many clips, usually people only make videos with the boralogues or T.H.I.S clips so this is really cool, keep up the good work!!
Thank you so much! I'm really glad my subtitles have helped you understand what's being said because they took quite a long time. As a hearing, Native English speaking person, I definitely have an advantage and even then it's difficult to understand what's being said by the members in clips with bad audio quality and stuff like that so I thought I should add them. As for the clips, I believe people would get bored of Tally Hall compilations if they just saw the same few clips over and over (I know I have). Plus, T.H.I.S isn't them so if the majority of a compilation is clips of that they haven't exactly full-filled the title's promises. Anyway, I'll stop waffling now, thank you
SAME!!! yeah English not my first language either!
THANK YOU SO MUCH!! As a non-fluent english speaker, I wouldn't have been able to understand half of it without the subtitles lol.
I'm so glad the subtitles help you! I add them to all my compilations (except for one that had hardly any talking in it) because as a hearing Native English speaker I often struggle to follow what they're saying too due to bad audio quality, mumbling or talking over each other. I want my compilations to be accessible to everyone as it's pretty shit that currently a lot of the community can't consume content in the same way as the hearing and native English speaking portion of the community (not that it's anyone's fault since they're an old band and the cameras weren't high quality back then). It's a lot of work but it's worth it to unite the community and give everyone a fair chance of enjoying this band's extra content
9:22 It sounds like he’s saying ’sorry to interrupt.”
Thank you! I have been trying to figure out the exact words said in that video and I've had a lot of trouble with it (as you can see by the amount of questions marks and over all missing dialogue). You're definitely right with that. I'm not exactly sure what they were all saying for most of it but I think for the most part I got the subtitles close enough. I also do not know what he said before "sorry to interrupt" and after "the collar stays-" lol
@@project_letters Yeah I can’t hear either what he says after ”the collar stays”. Pretty hard to make out because everyone is talking at the same time. The quality of the recording is kinda crap aswell which doesn’t make it any better LOL
Yeah, it's impressive you managed to pick up what Joe mumbled tbh. It really bothers me that I can't make what Andrew said make sense. Like he's talking about how it's embarrassing to have your fly undone during a show and then when asked about it he says it happened the other show but his fly was done up and Joe's wasn't which I doubt is what he said. Unless Andrew is extremely cruel, I assume he's saying he believed his own fly to be done up when it wasn't (even though that contradicts what he just said about being aware it was undone) but then he says something about Joe's fly being undone the whole show which implies his wasn't but that'd contradict the entirety of what he was saying???? I doubt he'd just randomly decide to embarrass Joe on stage by bringing attention to the fact that his fly was down if he wasn't also in the same boat so this clip gets more confusing every time I try to decipher it. Anyway, I'll shut up now lol
@@project_letters Thank you! I felt like a genius when I finally heard it. And yeah Andrews story is pretty confusing because of the audio quality so I don’t blame you at all😊
@@project_letters Now that i’ve listened to it more it sounds like Joe only says ”the collar stays”. Almost in like a "the collar stays up everytime tho". It fits pretty good to me because they’re talking about their fly being undone during a show. Maybe it sounds like he’s saying something after because Andrew says ”it might be worse” right after Joe finishes his sentence?
Just reached 9,700 as I posted this video. Now Idk if I can be totally sure of this but I could be (SUBSCRIBERS WISE) the most popular Tally Hall creator other than Tally Hall themselves? Like I'm not going to make a case that im more famous than Hidden in the sand, Tally ball, Tally Hal, Wahwahster, etc... since all of those are like the equivalent of a house hold names in the Tally Hall fandom and I'm definitely not on that level (no one knows who tf I am I just kind of spawned in here with a large number if subscribers. I'm an enigma) but I'm very proud of myself. I'm so close to my long term goal of 10k and that makes me so proud :D it is kind of concerning that I have so many eyes on me and it does make me panic but it's also very exciting that so many people care about me and what I have to say! Basically, thank you all so much
Edit: tally all is not tally hall has more subscribers that me, but I'm atleast in second place which is crazy tbh! Also me saying this isn't to create competition. I've been at this for 9 years, creators like Tally ball seems to have only just picked this up so congratulations to them!
Congrats on 9700!!! You definitely deserve more, your content is really enjoyable and it seems like you put a ton of effort into your vids. Also I hate to be THAT person but you still have yet to beat "tallyall is still not tallyhall" in subs, so I give u good luck 🫡🫡
@@Crazyrayz thank you! Good to know I'm not the single most popular subscribers wise I guess. I'm not trying to compete here considering too many eyes on me will have negative impacts. I of course love the audience as this is a passion but I'm also a minor and am prone to do something that'll anger someone 😂
what about tally ball i think hes bigger
Subscribers-wise he isn't. He's extremely close as if reaching 9k but I'm a couple hundred ahead of him. He's definitely more popular in the community and impressive considering he reached my level having only started about a year ago (I've been at this for 9 years and only spent very little of the in this community). I just kind of arrived here with this following
This channel is making me a Tally Hall stan & also I can’t even with that part ( 1:02 - 1:11 - 1:20)
Top 10 scares jumpscares
Number 10 joe Hawley 5:07
I remember month ago I always want to make " rob and joe best moments" but there is no enough clips I could find. I’m glad I found this video and now it’s addicting tbh
Glad you enjoyed it! They're definitely an iconic pair (platonic). I should probably make a part 2 eventually lol
@@project_letters I would loved to see part 2 of this, I don’t thing it’s possible to find a lot of clips lol
@@SallyKhaled13 It definitely won't be as long since I am pretty thorough but it's not impossible
@@project_letters good luck wiz !!!!
The pain in his voice when he said bobby couldn’t be there 😭😭
3:25 something tells me joe actually got pissed then…
Yeah, that's an example of him genuinely seeming angry at Rob. Doesn't mean he hates Rob but I guess he was angry that Rob wasn't listening to him when saying "stop" so he retaliated with violence and stormed off. Almost feels awkward to watch because it seems he was genuinely upset with Rob's punching even if he was joking. He was fine for the rest of the video though
@@project_letters i wouldn't say it's genuine? might be a bit, but it's hard to really say, joe was saying "ow" jokingly (theres 0 way that actually hurt), he could have very well just have been pretending to be mad for the camera
@@redfiretf2 yeah, you've got a point. I mean I don't think it would've genuinely hurt but it might've overwhelmed him if he was repeatedly getting touched. We saw later on that he atleast wasn't a fan of getting touched by Rob on stage when his collar was messed up. That could be just the circumstance (getting embarrassed by Zubin on stage and then having Rob come over and try sort it out would be quite patronising) or he could be the type of person that hates getting touched for whatever reason. Idk it's difficult to tell if he was playing it up but from Rob's "ow" and looking up at him like "that actually hurt" before quickly cutting the clip off and the expression on Joe's face as he looks at the camera like "don't record me" before Zubin panned away and back to Rob it definitely seemed like he actually punched Rob unexpectedly. Then again it's on the internet and if Joe was actually angry they probably wouldn't have posted it. You never know really.
We need a bora and Joe version of this
Will do!
omg yes
edit: it has been delivered
7:20 also probably says ”oh sorry” 🙂
Which one? Joe or Rob because they both say something. I assume you mean Joe which I didn't notice when making this but yes Joe does say something. Idk what Rob said though. Tbh I think I need you by my side while I make these video to just be my pocket lip reader /j
@@project_lettersI was thinking of Joe! And yeah I can’t hear Rob either. But I did kinda hear a ”hands off!” or something like that from Rob. Could just be my imagination tho
joe hawley attacks clip is actually so scary
JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY JOE HAWLEY
@@project_letters NOO 😭😭😭 SPARE ME
@@project_letters god have mercy 😦😦
joehawleyjoehawleyjoehawleyjoehawley
When Joe says Joe Hawley too much is sounds like jolly, or ig jawley
wasn't there that one clip where he just starts singing "jingle bells, jingle bells" randomly?
im not sure actually lol
@@Azrael_azzie_ I just thought of it because of the "jolly" lol
2:33 HELP I GOT A CAR AD RIGHT AFTER THAT
1:01 the jarm c lock
i love them all it’s simple i’ve been a. tally hall fan since popped out of the womb
I couldn't care less that I've watched this video like 3 times I will continue to binge it whenever I can
😂 I should make a part 2 lol
@@project_letters I need that in my life
"bobby couldn't be here today" ok what if i cried huh O_Q
also 2:46 made me go "awww"
I wish I was alive when the band was still together and making music 😭😭😭😭
I was but I was like 5
I was 4 in 2011. WHY WASN'T I HANGING WITH ANDREW HOROWITZ?!
I was just born in 2011 :,)
i was born in 2009 dude 😭😭
@@project_lettersI WAS 2 YEARS OLD
💔💔💔
The “competitive” comment joe made on that audio really make people believe they hate each other’s , genuinely it’s not true. It’s a common thing imo that both joe and Rob friendship consist of that , friends but with that not perfect friendship, always a lil issue. It’s normal for people that are in band. Joe is not perfect , Rob isn’t perfect. They both seem to care and worried for each others likely. I hope people understand that.
Yeah it pisses me off how people genuinely think they hate eachother. Like number 1, this video's existence disproves that. Number 2, friends joke about hating eachother all the time. It's called banter. You insult eachother for jokes and not every friendship does it but extremely close ones tend to because they're so close that they can take these jokes. Also Tally Hall famously give stupid answers in interviews, it isn't insane to assume they weren't giving a stupid answer and Joe picked Rob because they're close. For this band to be what it is Rob and Joe must've liked eachother. Rob wouldn't have joined Joe's comedy group and Joe wouldn't have joined Rob's band. You can't even argue they grew out of each other because Joe still invited Rob back twice for miracle musical, sampled him in JHJH and tried to get him to perform live with him in 2016. Idk about right this second but I know they're definitely close just by those prices if evidence
HELP WHEN I FIRST JOINED THE TALLY HALL COMMUNITY I LITERALLY THOUGHT THEY WERE DATING 😭😭😭
HELP?????
I mean in another universe they could be /j
1:13 plot twist: He's about to say "Sonic Lunch"
7:10 is 4-LOM by Cojum Dip :DDDDD how cool I never noticed
3:57 bro predicted simon 😮😮😮😮
each member has an opinion about another member (not incl themselves) so it's just 5x4=20
therefore it's 19/20
unless you consider they include themselves for some reason in which case they canonically all love themselves
Self love ❤️
GAHHH THEY'RE SO ADORABLE AHSHDHHCJXKSO
"Dies of death"
I'm so sorry for bringing up primary love before you posted this 😭😭
samee 😭😭
It's fine, you guys! I wasn't genuinely distraught, I still love this duo... Just not when Rob pregnant or when Joe has impregnated him. As we can see here Rob doesn't want Joe to caress his face and Joe doesn't want Rob touching him. Also Rob would prefer Joe to have his fly up at all times 💀😭
@@project_letters ok thx!
@@project_letters Yeah, Sally will never come to be!
@@Mushroomelixir sally got sent to the coal mines we wont see her ever again
I need to know if he was serious with that first clip or not 😭
I think the rest of this video answers that question? I literally am so bewildered how anyone thinks he was being genuine. The only reason Joe is even in this damn band is because him and Rob are friends (Joe let Rob into anonymous and then Rob let Joe into Tally Hall). He invited him back for solo projects that he owned so it's not even like you can make the case that they grew out of the friendship. Are you witnessing the banter they have in wall party '06? This is the same band who told interviewers that they had been dating, they started their band because they wanted to start a t shirt business and when asked to give a beat boxing sample just went like "btssuh" and ended it. You really think he isn't evidently giving a stupid answer? How chill Rob is about it makes this all even more obvious. Like I joke that I hate my friends and they're the worst thing that ever happened to me because we're so close it's funny to even suggest that. That's what Joe was doing there
@@project_letters Ohhh ok yeah I have a hard time deciphering emotions lol. Also why is that copypasta worthy?
I have a fear of getting copypasta-fied. However, if I gotta choose something I said to be copypasta'd this is pretty decent
I've spotted you in the wild
9:20 "The collar stays bent- sorry for interrupting."
me and her core (i love her
Idk who "her" is but I'm curious who's who
8:56 “Guitary and I are- Okay , sorry..”
4:03 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAÆAAAA
Bro unlocked opera mode
Awe bro this is so awesome man
I want a friend like that dude
Nah wait wait wait..
I just wanna be tally hall 🔥🔥
P.s. AWESOME VIDEO! Also, captions are done well.
Thank you and that "I just want to be Tally Hall" is so relatable 💀
I can’t believe One time tally hall told me that I should be a member of their band
4:42 EUEEHUEHEHUEHHHEUEHHEE
"Eh, that's freaking me out"
3:33 only now have i understood the lyrics lmao-
Are you referring to "and a very big bra" or "take you by the knickers and I'll bum your slap"? If you mean the 2nd, yes. Surprisingly, many don't know that its meaning is that Joe is going to grab and presumably pull someone in by their underwear and spank them. I have no clue how but here we are
@@project_letters the second one lol
The modern lennon and mccartney
I NEED TO KNOW WHERE YOU FOUND ROB DRESSED A A SCIENTIST I NEED IT
It's from a quack media educational video called word confusion. It's extremely funny. I showed very few clips from it and I'd recommend giving it a watch
I hope they get back together someday, perhaps in the sonic lunch concert if Joe also performs with the gang? (I know rob will definitely show up)
Same. Joe doesn't seem fit to perform rn. It's not impossible that over the past few months he's improved (we saw he was well enough to be posting in December) and a lot of the hints can be interpreted to point towards him. However, I think we need Joe to at least sort of return to the Joe we used to know before Tally Hall reunite. He's said and done some awful hateful and disgusting things, some alleged and some proven. You can argue they're more from a place of ignorance than hate but he's still responsible. I want Joe to return and Tally Hall to reunite as friends as much as anyone but Joe needs help right now and he needs to be given that support from a therapist or something before returning to performing imo. Though if he is there that'd be awesome (also might show he's on his path to improvement). Currently, I think we need to think of these as baby steps to a possible reunion. We had the most Tally Hall members that have ever performed together since 2011 last Saturday and, though it's confirmed that there won't be any reunion in August, we know Andrew is not alone for SL. These are all good signs that everyone's back on track and Tally Hall are on their road to reunion hopefully
Their so silly & joyous bro
It seems maybe Joe didn't like Rob too much at least at one point. I just remembered him bringing up Rob as being very competitive in the (now scrubbed off the internet) phone call. Well, at least the audio of it is. I have my own copy of the transcript. I'll paste the tail end of it here:
J: So let’s get real, what did I say to Eden, other than the N word, and did she call me the N word.
N: She did not, no.
J: How do you know?
N: That’s what she said, this is all alleged and I’m trying to confirm it with you.
J: You think you know, and then Eden behind your back thinks that she is a person other than you and is quite competitive, much like Rob Cantor, who initiated your friendship?
N: Uh- I didn’t want to get too off topic, I didn’t want to take too much of your time-
J: Oh, I see, so this is about me, and not about you, how did you and Eden meet?
N: We met because of Tally Hall?
J: Okay, who initiated the friendship?
*Joe hangs up.*
I'd rather not talk on controversy. I'd never heard this phone call and I can hardly understand what's even being said. He's bloody confusing to understand and definitely got some issues. They at least had an interesting friendship, I hope Joe gets help because it's not right to throw Rob under the bus like that
WHY WOULD JOE PULL HIS PANTS DOWN IN A STORE
I have a few Tally Hall theory’s on why they haven’t come back if anyone wants to hear:
1. They decided they’d make another album when they got more money and forgot about the band. Now whenever someone brings it up they feel guilty and that’s why they don’t talk about it much.
2. They like they’re lives better as family men
3. They moved on
I feel like Tally Hall was just a little project that they didn’t know would blow up. Joe has multiple times acted like he took his band for granted and wants it back. Rob has moved on. Zubin is excited to make another album if it does happen. Ross and Andrew seem indifferent. These are just theories I don’t know anything about the personal feelings of the band members
Not to mention most of them have full time jobs they can’t just quit to start making music again :(
Is it just me or when I listen to good and evil I get medieval vibes
Same here, Who You Are sounds like a medieval love song, plus, well, most of the album ❤
Sacred Beast is so renaissance I can't get over it
6:29 i SWEAR that that ‘what?’ was sampled in TME
At what point?
@project_letters sorry, it was just my *mind* playing tricks on me, the "what?" in TME is at like 1:02
7:41 Banana Man flashbacks
Hi, welcome to shsmaudhfinc- *dies of death*
2:25 didn’t have to do me (and all of the fanbase) like that 😭🤣
(It is true though)
“EHH EHH EHH-!”
4:28 joe hawley ×18
yelwah eoj
@@iluvoj.x3 dude how did i just get one of your vids on my fyp and then get a notif of you replying to a comment i made😨
@@rd0-101 i have unlimited power
5:46 SHSHDJSKSKSS WHERES THE ORIGINAL CLIP ZUBIN/JOE IS A PANTSER😭
Their April fools video
What video is 2:31 and is there and uncensored version
It's from the bonus episode of T.H.I.S about South x Southwest 2007. There isn't an uncensored version but I'm going to try and get my religious studies teacher who's good at lip reading to try to decipher what's being said
@@project_letters thanks
It looks like
"you slammed my fucking hand!! ??????????? Yes! YES! you slammed my fucking hand.."
But i'm not too sure the bleeps distracted me tbh
why are people crying about "bobby couldn't be here today"? am i stupid
Basically, back in 2016 Joe tried to sorta reunite the band. His set contained multiple Tally Hall songs and just sings that required other members (like variations on a cloud). That clip is him about to sing variations on a cloud without Rob, variations on a cloud being a song you can't sing alone due to being a duet. People find it very difficult to watch one member try and sing songs he write for a band all by himself and how sad he looks on an empty stage surrounded by instruments (probably belongs to another band but it doesn't help the fact that he's singing songs like the bidding surrounded by instruments that his friends needed to be playing).
TL;DR Sonic lunch in an infamously sad video and in it Joe said "Bobby couldn't be here today" before singing a song, that's supposed to be a duet with Rob and himself, alone.
@@project_letters dang, that is really sad. I was unaware of that, thanks!
wheres the thumbnail from? also they're the best duo omg
5:46 pretty sure that’s Joe cause throughout the video, he’s wearing a striped shirt. If you pause at the right time (unfortunately) you will see the stripes. Correct me if i’m wrong‼️🔥
The thing is I'm pretty sure Zubin was too and that makes it all the more difficult to tell them apart
I thought it was Ross what 😭
I'm pretty sure it's Joe. You can tell because of the hair.
I’ve always known they were frenimenieseieeiesiees
why does rob sound and look like alex from marble hornets
Idk what that is
@@project_letters Look it uppp
@@project_letters Luckyyyyy
HE DOES
4:24 lethal company (i am so sorry)
2:57 is so funny omg
The pain in joe’s voice when he said bobby couldn’t be there LMAO
i cant believe rob would say y*s
Me & my sister be like
First clip is funny because on Instagram Rob follows Joe but Joe does not follow Rob even though Joe follows everyone else.
Joe doesn't own his Instagram anymore and around the time when he did have Instagram but wasn't following Rob there was a picture taken of the two together. I think it's just Joe forgot to follow him or something.
@@project_letters I don't think he actually doesn't like him. I think it's an inside joke.
Exactly. People take that interview answer so seriously and it's actually so weird. Tally hall constantly give stupid answers to interview Like saying that they're all dating or that Ross is a robot. Like For this bloody band to exist they had to have a mutual liking of each other. They also chose to perform together for years with banter and even had songs/performances after Tally hall where they did/tried to do a duet. They obviously were always friends and were just having banter in that interview. Whatever has happened recently is a separate thing entirely that we know hardly anything about so there's no point speculating.
Yo wait
I haven't seen some of these..
Mid telling where you found some (or all- sorry)?
Are there any specific time stamps you want. I can try do them all but it'll take a long time (I'll be making a part 2 to this with more videos)
4:32 lol i just made this cuz i paused it at funny time 🤓
fair,if you pause and then click the timestamp,it looks like Rob tripped
WHAT VIDEO WAS THE "IM A BITCH" ROB CLIP FROM MY ROB ERA AND MY BITCH ERA ARE OVERLAPPING AND I NEED IT PRETTY PRETTY PLEASE
It's from a boralogue
me and my friend
What video 4:54
Wall party '06. A performance done in a fan's basement. They have some lovely Rob and Joe clips where they seem to be having some fun banter. It's lovely to see Joe not being completely out of it and instead just a fun guy
where do you find the marvins marvelpus pranks promo stuff??
UA-cam