There were plenty of collab stages yesterday at smtown but this was was personally, by far, the most memorable and stood out the most for me. Their vocal color combined was too perfect. Kudos to onew and ning ✨
Me too. It was really magical. No Hype. No In your face attitude. No crazy beats. Just pure Magical Vocals. I just wish Ning would sing for OST for both KDrama and CDrama
We used to hear Ningning's highnotes and I'm so glad they let us hear Her calm and low notes through this collaboration. Their voice blended well and somehow matched with the atmosphere of the lyrics. They liven up the story of the song.
Totally drunk🥺🥺 the vibe just like an innocent but firm girl and a pure boy date quietly under a starry and gorgeous sky! What a peaceful and romantic atmosphere🌖 the voice of the two is so pure and bright that it sounds like little boy and girl telling love to each other with a gentle tone! Look forward to more collabs💫
This collab was lovely. "Way" is a masterpiece. Onew's heartfelt lyrics and rich, warm voice are both healing and uplifting. Ning Ning did a wonderful job filling in for Punch. Both women have lovely voices.
Technically the original is also very good, but only as good as commonly K-pop ballad. Ningning gives Disney vibe to the song that makes it special/unique.
@@vivenya1606 They have different style, but Punch's airy and matured voice doesn't really fit this song, in my opinion. I'd listened to the original first, but nothing got stuck in my head, untill I listened to the performance of Onew and Ningning a couple of days ago. Ningning brought the true vibe to the song, through her sweet and girly voice, which blends perfectly with Onew's warm voice and makes the song sound much better and more special.
I literally had goosebumps while listening to it at the concert live. This version is so much better tbh I just hope SM would officially post the performance vid like they did with zoo
내 맘엔 조그만 방이 하나 생겼어 잊을 수가 없는 너는 거기서 있어 그 문을 열어 너의 그리운 목소리가 나를 부르게 후회로 가득한 눈물이 멋대로 흘러 어디론가 나도 따라 흘러가면 좋겠어 따스한 저 햇살 속에 날 맡기고 싶어져 널 만나게 흩날리는 향기와 눈부신 네 눈동자 눈을 감아도 널 느껴 믿어 이건 조금 다른 시간 속에 보이지 않는 세상 속에 같은 방에 별 하나 너와 내 이름 하나 또 얼굴 하나 다시는 널 볼 수 없어도 같은 별을 따라 걸어가 더 미련 없이 날 믿게 한 그 이름 하나 목소리 하나 길을 잃고 또 헤매어도 서로를 향해 달려가 한동안은 찾지도 못해 서로 엇갈린대도 우두커니 이곳에 서서 방향을 다시 잡아 난 널 부르면서 흔들리는 세상 속에 발 디딜 곳 없을 때 어디선가 날 잡았던 보이지 않는 그 손길 다시 한번 따뜻한 네 품에 안기고 싶어 널 찾아가 따뜻한 숨결 눈부신 미소 눈을 감으면 널 느껴 믿어 조금 다른 시간 속에 보이지 않는 세상 속에 같은 방에 별 하나 너와 내 이름 하나 또 얼굴 하나 다시는 널 볼 수 없어도 같은 별을 따라 걸어가 더 미련 없이 날 믿게 한 그 이름 하나 목소리 하나 결국엔 변한 건 없어 우린 지금 손을 잡고 있잖아 같은 곳을 다르게 채우며 넌 거기에 있어 눈을 감으면 가장 가까운 여기에 우린 같은 길을 걷고 있어 같은 맘을 부르고 있어 함께 그린 선 따라 춤추는 별 하나와 나의 별 하나 볼 수 없는 수많은 것은 언제나 더 아름다웠어 너는 나의 곁에서 매일 뜨는 별 하나야 이름이야 Oh Nanana 가장 어두운 밤에 넌 Oh 별 하나야
Non mais lol.... Personnellement si je n'avais pas traduit les différents commentaires je n'aurais même pas capter que ce n'était pas Punch qui chantait ? Je n'ai pas réellement vu une grosse différence entre les deux voix..... Bon je reconnais que les voix féminines me touchent beaucoup moins que les masculines ^^ Et que j'ai tendance à plus me concentrer sur celle de Onew 😉❤ ............ No, but lol.... Personally, if I hadn't translated the various comments, I wouldn't even have understood that it wasn't Punch who was singing? I didn't really see a big difference between the two voices..... Well I recognize that the female voices affect me much less than the male ones ^^ And that I tend to focus more on Onew's 😉 ❤
![[SUB INDO/ENG CC] ONEW (온유) X NINGNING (닝닝)- "WAY (별 하나)"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xm9FKyP6i6Q/mqdefault.jpg)
![[SUB INDO/ENG CC] ONEW (온유) X NINGNING (닝닝)- "WAY (별 하나)"](/img/tr.png)
![[IU's Palette🎨] Eardrums might 'Melt Down' (With DAY6) Ep.28](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ho-LkB1VWv4/mqdefault.jpg)
There were plenty of collab stages yesterday at smtown but this was was personally, by far, the most memorable and stood out the most for me. Their vocal color combined was too perfect. Kudos to onew and ning ✨
right!? Ningnings voice on this performance was so perfect with Onews unique vocal
Me too. It was really magical. No Hype. No In your face attitude. No crazy beats. Just pure Magical Vocals. I just wish Ning would sing for OST for both KDrama and CDrama
Soooo in love with Ningning’s vocal in this performance
It's another proof that Ningning vocal can naturally blend into a song and other vocals. She has wide vocal range.
Ningning managed to make this song more comfortable to listen to, this is my taste and my opinion
NingNing best 4th Gen vocalist
We used to hear Ningning's highnotes and I'm so glad they let us hear Her calm and low notes through this collaboration. Their voice blended well and somehow matched with the atmosphere of the lyrics. They liven up the story of the song.
Totally drunk🥺🥺 the vibe just like an innocent but firm girl and a pure boy date quietly under a starry and gorgeous sky! What a peaceful and romantic atmosphere🌖 the voice of the two is so pure and bright that it sounds like little boy and girl telling love to each other with a gentle tone! Look forward to more collabs💫
Thank you, Onew. Because of you, I could hear this voice of Ningning.
This collab was lovely. "Way" is a masterpiece. Onew's heartfelt lyrics and rich, warm voice are both healing and uplifting. Ning Ning did a wonderful job filling in for Punch. Both women have lovely voices.
I wish SM could release this version's audio. It sounds much better than the original one. Ninging's angelic voice fits this song so well.
Well punch had her own style and ningning had her own style, you can't say ningning was better
Technically the original is also very good, but only as good as commonly K-pop ballad. Ningning gives Disney vibe to the song that makes it special/unique.
@@vivenya1606 They have different style, but Punch's airy and matured voice doesn't really fit this song, in my opinion. I'd listened to the original first, but nothing got stuck in my head, untill I listened to the performance of Onew and Ningning a couple of days ago. Ningning brought the true vibe to the song, through her sweet and girly voice, which blends perfectly with Onew's warm voice and makes the song sound much better and more special.
@@vivenya1606 Ningning voice more suitable for this song.. I like punch voice too, But Ningning voice really suit this song well
Thats not how you praise someone, aespa fans.
DAMN ONEW & NINGNING'S VOICE MADE ME CRY AND TREMBLE. 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
My top collabs along with Hate that and Ordinary Day
Ordinary Day and Way are my fav stages in SMCU Express concert
닝닝이 목소리 너무 이쁘다ㅜㅜㅜㅠㅜㅠㅜㅜ
I literally had goosebumps while listening to it at the concert live. This version is so much better tbh I just hope SM would officially post the performance vid like they did with zoo
Is this wonder you hear when you arrive in heaven
so effortless for Ning Ning
Thank you for the korean lyrics and english translation~ the lyrics are so beautiful and meaningful ! beautiful song ~
내 맘엔 조그만 방이 하나 생겼어
잊을 수가 없는 너는 거기서 있어
그 문을 열어 너의 그리운 목소리가
나를 부르게
후회로 가득한 눈물이 멋대로 흘러
어디론가 나도 따라
흘러가면 좋겠어
따스한 저 햇살 속에
날 맡기고 싶어져
널 만나게
흩날리는 향기와 눈부신 네 눈동자
눈을 감아도 널 느껴
믿어 이건
조금 다른 시간 속에
보이지 않는 세상 속에
같은 방에 별 하나
너와 내 이름 하나 또 얼굴 하나
다시는 널 볼 수 없어도
같은 별을 따라 걸어가
더 미련 없이 날 믿게 한
그 이름 하나 목소리 하나
길을 잃고 또 헤매어도
서로를 향해 달려가
한동안은 찾지도 못해
서로 엇갈린대도
우두커니 이곳에 서서
방향을 다시 잡아 난
널 부르면서
흔들리는 세상 속에
발 디딜 곳 없을 때
어디선가 날 잡았던
보이지 않는 그 손길
다시 한번 따뜻한
네 품에 안기고 싶어
널 찾아가
따뜻한 숨결 눈부신 미소
눈을 감으면 널 느껴 믿어
조금 다른 시간 속에
보이지 않는 세상 속에
같은 방에 별 하나
너와 내 이름 하나 또 얼굴 하나
다시는 널 볼 수 없어도
같은 별을 따라 걸어가
더 미련 없이 날 믿게 한
그 이름 하나 목소리 하나
결국엔 변한 건 없어
우린 지금 손을 잡고 있잖아
같은 곳을 다르게 채우며
넌 거기에 있어 눈을 감으면
가장 가까운 여기에 우린
같은 길을 걷고 있어
같은 맘을 부르고 있어
함께 그린 선 따라 춤추는
별 하나와
나의 별 하나
볼 수 없는 수많은 것은
언제나 더 아름다웠어
너는 나의 곁에서 매일 뜨는
별 하나야 이름이야
Oh Nanana
가장 어두운 밤에 넌
Oh
별 하나야
feeling emotional with the song and their voices blending well is not even helping ༎ຶ‿༎ຶ
This is so good 😭🥺
thank you very much for uploading this!! sm, give us the track please
Non mais lol.... Personnellement si je n'avais pas traduit les différents commentaires je n'aurais même pas capter que ce n'était pas Punch qui chantait ? Je n'ai pas réellement vu une grosse différence entre les deux voix..... Bon je reconnais que les voix féminines me touchent beaucoup moins que les masculines ^^ Et que j'ai tendance à plus me concentrer sur celle de Onew 😉❤ ............ No, but lol.... Personally, if I hadn't translated the various comments, I wouldn't even have understood that it wasn't Punch who was singing? I didn't really see a big difference between the two voices..... Well I recognize that the female voices affect me much less than the male ones ^^ And that I tend to focus more on Onew's 😉 ❤
Ces ningning et on voit la difference lol
Does anyone know the scene at 0:52 from which movie? That's so beautiful 😢
I think all of scenes in this video are from Love Alarm season 1
Anyone knows where can I watch the video of this performance??
No official ver on youtube yet😭 but I saw it on Twitter. Just search Ningning Onew.
ua-cam.com/video/loWrzbYRQVU/v-deo.html
Here, I found only this version...
ua-cam.com/video/d1PdtmAb1NM/v-deo.html here it is