How Indian Middle Class Is Getting Poorer Than Lower Class ?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 вер 2024
- #amitsangwan
#9911702005
#sangolifesutras
#economics
#middleclass
#middleclassfamily
Also watch:
Money Mindset Series : • Money Mindset Series
05 Belief Systems Of Middle Class Which Need To Be Crushed : • 05 Belief Systems Whic...
my several friends have already wasted 4-5 years in UPSC preparation. Now, they are neither good for a corporate job, nor good to run any shop. Only thing they have now is 30 years of age, zero bank balance, and tons of unnecessary bookish knowledge.
Fuck them
Who said bookish knowledge are useless
If private jobs provide security & good salary & comfortable working hour then nobody would opted for govt. Jobs
@@jms895 Becasue it does not give you any real life skills.
@@jms895 The attitude of no kaam only aaram!! Khali sarkari naukri isiliye toh chahiye. Bina kaam ke salary phir pension. Another reason why we will never become a superpower.
Pains of Middle Class well expressed. This video deserves to go viral . In the state of West Bengal , the educated Middle Class is already on its way to extinction and as you observed , the structure of society in West Bengal will drastically change for the worst.
Very well said!
it will soon become bangladesh thanks to bengali hindus who vote for TMC
No No WB Wants FREEBIES LIKE SRI LANKA >> THEY ARE JOBLESS BECAUSE YOU KNOW WHY NOT BECAUSE OF SKILL > ITS ABOUT SMARTNESS> YOU GUYS ONLY WANT OYO AND GAY RIGHTS
Pain of lower class bhi dikhao
Sirf middle class ko hi pain hota hai kya
main reason is TMC
The initial "Jhijhak" and "Log Kya Kahenge" mentality is what discourages my middle class family as well. Very well said Sirji and a complete eye opener for me. I will surely practice it with my kid. Practical knowledge or "Vyawahar Nyan" is the most important knowledge for kids and youngsters.
Because middle class people are ashamed to show themselves as middle class..That's why they buy all the things to make themselves look rich. expensive cars , iphone, house.. They get into debt in buying all this showingoff stuffs, they talk big, most are lies.. And worrying about debt they get diseases '' diabetes, bloodpressure, cancer , cholestrol common.. and they are 90% of the population in india.
Sahi kaha
You are very correct Sir. This ' Log kya kahenge ' mentality is keeping us down.
You are speaking the truth! We middle class are full of 'log kya kahenge'....log is leaving middle class behind 😃
Exactly
Finally someone is talking about real issue instead of caste language issue . As a bengali living in central india I like it.
Second you 👍
finally someone is talking se kuch nhi hone wala.. ya is ki video se kuch farak par gya?
Bengalis are rich.THEY DONT NEED TO WORK
Bengali are middle class like meee
Because middle class people are ashamed to show themselves as middle class..That's why they buy all the things to make themselves look rich. expensive cars , iphone, house.. They get into debt in buying all this showingoff stuffs, they talk big, most are lies.. And worrying about debt they get diseases '' diabetes, bloodpressure, cancer , cholestrol common.. and they are 90% of the population in india.
Sir you are absolutely right. I wasted my 3 years in government exam preparation and didn't get anything. I was working as an engineer before 3 years and earning 30k per month. Now again after listening you I got a job of 20k and said yes to raise myself. Thank you so much sir to draw away middle class from day dreaming.
Absolutely right sir. I have personally seen 18-19 yrs kids working confidently in other countries, only in india it is still a shame for some family.
Part time jobs are looked down in India. Even if kids work abroad. Indians tend to make fun. Deep seated casteism.
Sir, you are totally right. Today's engineers and other graduates are struggling to get job whereas even 12 failure earn good returns. Now it is common in our society.
It's due to skill gap...that no one is talking about
normal graduates are getting job of engineers now and engineers are getting jobless. The normal graduates don't demand high salary so company prefer them.
@@rohitnayak9952 this is BS excuse by the companies.
@@nishantkumar6960 I'm sure you're not working in any of the core engineering field
@@rohitnayak9952 cheap labour is in demand
Agree sir, Beacause of government schemes and no tax on poor most of the Poor's in our city are now living better life than a middle class people
Plus most imp ....tax payees are middle class and so called 🙃 lower class bhajiya thela ..Chai waala ..not paying taxes ..this is hitting hard ..
Very well said .....i debate on this in many forums..... sometimes earning enemies as those people hate my logic.....let me tell you this......99 percent unorganised roadside small time business are earning more than majority organised middle level jobs.....plus they don't pay any taxes.....and this idiot govt has no plans to bring them to the tax net due to vote bank politics..
Last time a boiled egg seller was raided by income tax department he has like 2-3 crore worth at that time ofcourse zero income taxes until the raid
In bhopal
Street food sellers don't pay rents, electricity bills,taxes,etc. and only pay daily haftha to the police. They're food is only Rs.5 or 10 cheaper than the restaurants. They occupy footpath space preventing pedestrians from walking and gradually become "owners" of that space. Some of them are downright rude to customers.That's why I prefer to eat in a restaurant instead of street vendors.
The day they start paying tax Indian economy will collapse.
Why do you think things are cheap . Because they charge it cheap.
Else everyone's cost and spending will increase.
Fir na tum kaam wali bai rakh payoge na 300 me cab kar payoge.
The privileged elite of this country makes me sick.
Lmao Indian middle class.
The most useless group in the entire World.
@@Terahydron to tu kaunsa ambani ka oulad hai bhai 😂
Middle class are the engine who run this country
Jaa jaake jnu main jhola latake k nare laga usike layak hai tu
I belong to a middle class family, I'm 21 working 16 hrs a day as a freelancer and Now I believe that I'm on the right track. I'm not wasting my time and my parents money on stupid obsolete courses.
वोट वापसी और ज्यूरी सिस्टम (ज्यूरी कोर्ट) कानून होने की वजह से अमेरिका और इंग्लैंड जैसे देशों में जज, पुलिस और नेताओं का गठजोड़ भ्रष्टाचार नही कर पाता और इस वजह से वहाँ पर कारोबारी(व्यपारी) उन्नति कर पाये।
कारोबारी उन्नति होने के कारण वहाँ रोजगार पनपा । सभी लोंगो को काम करने का समान अवसर मिला और वह विशालकाय बहुराष्ट्रिय कंपनिया खड़ी कर पाये।
तो अमेरिका और इंग्लैंड आज दुनिया में दूसरे देशों से आगे... बहुत आगे निकल गए उसकी सबसे बड़ी वजह है कि वहाँ पर वोट वापसी कानून और ज्यूरी सिस्टम प्रक्रियाए लागू है।
यदि गाजियाबाद जिला के सांसद और विधायक चाहे तो आपको वोट वापस लेने का अधिकार कल की तारीख में मिल सकता है।
अंत: मैं आपको यह सूचित करने आया हूँ कि यदि आप वोट वापिस लेने का अधिकार चाहते हैं तो अपने क्षेत्र के नेताओं, विधायक, सांसद से मांग करें कि वह आपको वोट वापसी पासबुक जारी करे।
यदि आपको यह अधिकार मिल जाता है, तो जैसे चुनाव में नेता और प्रत्याशी आपके पास आते हैं, वेसे वह पूरे 5 वर्ष तक आपके पास आयेंगे, और आपसे पूछेंगे की आपको कोई तकलीफ़ तो नहीं है।
आज जो system है आप वोट देने के बाद में कोई प्रत्याशी अपने मूड(मर्ज़ी) से काम करता है, ओर नहीं भी करता है, तो आप उसे हटा नहीं पाते, लेकिन यह कानून आने के बाद, आपने जिसे वोट दिया या जो आपका प्रतिनिधि है वो अगर ठीक से काम नहीं कर रहा है, तो आप उसे 5 वर्ष से पहले निकाल कर किसी अन्य व्यक्ति को चुन सकेंगे, तो यह कानून - वोट वापसी का कानून आपकी यानी मतदाताओं की - हमारी शक्ति में वृद्धि करेगा।
.
यह कानून आने के बाद में सभी प्रत्याशी अच्छा काम करना शुरू करेंगे, इसलिए मतदाताओं आपसे निवेदन है वोट वापसी पासबुक के कानून को आगे बढ़ाने के लिए
मुख्यमंत्री, प्रधानमंत्री को लिखित में आदेश भेजे। प्रत्येक महीने की 5 तारीख को अपने नजदीकी पोस्ट ऑफिस में जाकर खुला निर्देश भेजें।
@@ryangreen45 freelancing matlab bs website designing nahi hoti. Website to har koi aajkl khud se hi bna leta hai. Fraud courses bech kr aajkl har log website banana sikha rhe hain. aree bhai pahle ye to dekh lo tumhare paas kitne client aate hain website banwane ke liye 😂
ekbar bna kr dekho profile upwork pe. Duniya ki aadhi aabadi web developer milegi. log free me bhi kaam nahi dete.
@@nishantkumar6960 backend banake dikha khud se 2 min me hack kar dunga
@@anmolpatel793 utna jaroori nahi hey bhai . Use case hi nahi hey. Aggregator ya Google pe listing kafi hey Quantum of business ke liye.
Even capex heavy industries like steel,cemet, fabric don't need a robust website. Pdf banake Twitter pe dal sakte hein.
Websites have overstayed their welcome.
Abhi social media ya Google search pe hi 90% searches hote hein more so in handheld devices.
No one has time to visit website even.
Google skim karke dikha deta hey, uske upar ye news website walon ne case b thoka tha.
So secure and load heavy website are thing of the past. Kuch kuch services like payment,hotel booking wagerah ki lagti hey
Be specific gentleman ???
This uncle is giving sincere advice. His every word is priceless. Respect from UK.
This is True.
You are Absolutely Correct.
Poor Class is Rising and Middle Class is Becoming Poorer ... 😭
Crazy how you present contrarian ideas, which is actually the reality, to us middle class folks so bluntly, and with that sense of humor. Man you're fire. Thanks to youtube for recommending me this gem.
Mr so called thakur wearing a western shirt and using iphone does it make you poor???
Don't spread fake narratives...
This guy is definitely leftist......
How To Live In Harmony With Nature And Reduce Pollution
1. Many Production Which We Do Not Need Actually For Human Beings Has To Be Stopped
We manufacture so many products and it is creating pollution. So if we minimise our products, pollution would be less.
We produce so many things which we do not need, like cold drinks, leather products, potato wafers, chips, fruit juices, chocolates, biscuits, pickles, ice creams, etc.
Cold drinks, fruit juices, pickles, ice creams, etc. Should be cooked at home only.
If we stopped producing this things which are not required for humans, so much pollution could be reduced.
If we colour the clothes pollution occurs. So if we don't colour our clothes, the pollution resulting from colouring the clothes can be stopped. Let everything remain in natural colour.
2. We Should Cook Foods In Its Natural Form
We can cook rice and wheat in our homes and eat it. Rice and Wheat is produced in farms. Then it is packed and transported to big warehouses, then wholesalers buy from them and supply to retail shops.
But if a manufacturing company makes bread from rice and wheat, then to make bread a manufacturing company has to be set up, machines and working staffs are needed. When a company is built many other things are also needed. Then at last a plastic pack is required to pack the breads.
So if we start cooking eatable things in its natural form then we do not need many companies like bread manufacturing company, tomato ketchup, noodles, fruit jam, pizza, burger, etc., the things required for the company and the plastic pack, paper box pack and glass bottles. If done like this, so many companies will not be required and hence less pollution for the world.
Also we could save our money like this. If you buy a packet of bread, it would cost you more money than if you cook wheat and rice in home.
Previously before industrial revolution, we didn't have technology, but our foods were rich with nutrients. Now we have technology, but technology is polluting our foods and our foods are not rich with nutrients, and because of that also we have health problems.
If this is done, then many jobs would be lost. For that many peoples should do farming and they should be given loans if they do not have enough money to start farming on their own.
Food, Medicines, Surgeries and Education's should be made free to the world till the world settles down with farming. After that food, medicines, surgeries and education's should be stopped free to the world.
Many people should study botany subject so that they have knowledge of plants and they should do farming.
Is their any another solution, that humans won't lose jobs and also pollution would decrease. Humans have to take this step certainly instead of going on polluting the earth, making wildlife extinct and also mass extinctions of humans in future.
3. Electricity Pollution
We create electricity from many types of sources like coal, water, etc., but it creates pollution. If electricity created from windmill and solar energy then no pollution occurs in the creation process. But still to manufacture windmill and solar machines pollution would occur.
As I previously said that if we shut down many manufacturing companies which are producing things which are not needed for humans, then the world would not require so much electricity. If less electricity required, then less pollution generated.
4. Could We Stop Drinking Cow's and Buffalo's Milk
Whatever vitamins and nutrients we get from milk, if we can get it from other eatable things, then we can stop drinking cow's and buffalo's milk. As milk has to be packed in glass bottles and plastic packs and then transported to places. All of this can be stopped.
For infants whose mother's have died or mother's who cannot breast feed their infants, only for them cow's and buffalo's milk should be given. We use milk in tea and coffee. Instead of milk we must use lime with tea and coffee or just plain tea and coffee. A lime should be cut into a few pieces and cooked with tea and coffee or something else can be used instead of lime.
5. How Much Should Be The World's Population
Every place should have a single house. No buildings, everything ground floor. If we do this and the whole lands of our planet earth would be occupied one day with homes, farms, forests, schools, hospitals, etc., then we would come to know how much our planet earth can have maximum population.
Once the population is determined, then we have to maintain that population. For example if our earth can have a population of 10 billion peoples, then when the population reaches 10 billion, then everyone should have only one child till the population reaches 9 billion peoples. As if we have only one child then the population decreases. When population is 9 billion peoples, then everyone should have 2 children's till the population reaches 10 billion peoples. After that again we should have only one child. In this way population can be maintained.
Near Hastinapur my grandparents and 3 other make a villege, and invite relative to live, my father genration all have approx 1.5 hactare land, good life and we original were in TUSHION OR ATTITUDE. I grown up in environment that I wasted 4 year in engineering 4 year in exam no money no job, 4 lack loan , same goes to children of original neighbours children, but other relative children was like labour like thier parants.
In pas 5 years scene gonna changes, they got all jobs in private, labour etc 1 lac per year profit, 2 child parant, low expenditure hence 3 lac per year saving vary easily they got in past 10 years.
🤔 They all built house worth 5 lack purchases land worth 10 lack did marriage worth 6*3 18 lack, purchased bike worth 1 lack purchased tractor worth 5 lack।
And all have 5 lack in bank।
🤔 We all have 10 year old house, old tractor, 10% land sold, 5 lack loan , no job ,no buisiness, my parants body is very weak।
😭😭😭There is difference of 35 lacks they enjoying the life while I motherfucker searching how to get a job worth 10 k rupppes per month after wasting 8 year plus engineering and 25 age।
🤔 My body also got old, eye damage due to reading, depression, kidney problem, no future, सुसीडिया thoughts all times।
🤔 Reason-- i clearly see we 20 boys were enter in college but getting no job due to not getting enough support of parants।
Our parants don't have savings and they are in ATTITUDE of past ।
🙏🙏🙏 Please change your mind no work is abusive other wise after 10 year if you did mistake you will burning your degree by purchasing 1₹ machstick on loan।।
@@prashantkumar-gg9xw i understand your situation.
I am 38 and can totally relate to you sir. Earlier families never proposed these for their children. I will definitely do this once my kid reaches teen.
the your kid future is bright
Your words touch me i wasted my 10 years I am 32
Now earning 70k I think i have to replan things.
I witnessed change in society thanks for opening eyes 🙏
Bro how you are earning 70 k?
Mind well - it is not important how much you earn. But it is more important how much you save every month. Someone may earn 2-3 L p.m. But his saving is hardly 2500. While with 70K, if you save 7-10K or 20-25% of your salary, then you are ahead of him who earns 3L. If you invest your savings in a well planned manner, your money will start working with you and make you future ready.
If you like to learn more, you may get in touch with me.
hey i dont think earning 70k per month is a bad thing. You should be happy with your achievements so far, cheers for more growth
Only if you know to save and make your money work for you , I am sure you will be able to grow well and no money earned is small as long as you know to save well
You are earning 70k then i would say you had made a fabulous planning from the beginning, and you are still young so will grow more .I'm 34 and had to leave job .
Truth/reality has been spoken in a very productive way, those who are aware a bit can take so much out of it,
Thanks sir for this ground truth
This video should be shown to all the parents and children. Also this video should be shown in education institutes. This is gold
Your observation here is prophetic. I ( and my brothers) grew up in a comfortable double-income Govt Officers family. We didnot learn real life skills and how to struggle other than to pass exams!! 🙂. I already observe many people of my age who grew up in so called "poor" families already racing ahead of my family......I am not jealous, but this is the truth that I see....
Because middle class people are ashamed to show themselves as middle class..That's why they buy all the things to make themselves look rich. expensive cars , iphone, house.. They get into debt in buying all this showingoff stuffs, they talk big, most are lies.. And worrying about debt they get diseases '' diabetes, bloodpressure, cancer , cholestrol common.. and they are 90% of the population in india.
What are real life skills in your opinion my friend? Please take a little pain to clarify..
@@akIndia10 stop showoff... that's it.
I can totally relate with u ✌
practical exposure to real world is really missing for middle class kids.
You are absolutely right in bringing out harsh reality that is playing out all around us. This is visible especially in bigger cities but in smaller cities you need to be aware of the fact to notice this.
There is nothing wrong in this and as you said it is good for nation. It will uplift the entire nation and its status.
Your intentions are also understood and it’s natural that as we grow and compete with US, Uk and other nations the taboo with these jobs will diminish.
Kudos to you on bringing this to general public as it really takes courage and conviction to bring such observations on an open forum.
आपने मध्यम वर्ग के कल्पनालोक को बढिया तरीके से समझाया । मैं एक वरिष्ठ नागरिक हूँ । इन सब को बहुत ही बारीकि से देखा । धन्यवाद ।
I really appreciate and want to thank you for raising this issue and concerns, since I belong to a middle class family I can see and experience how govt schemes are hurting and undermining the middle class family lives, poor is getting every thing free, rich don't have to bother for anything but middleclass is struggling for everything😔
Always remember, no pain no gain
Become poor den... its easy
@@shaikthegangsta I have expected this reply from you, 😁 you live on the money of government via schemes and money from waqf boards and sharing knowledge here😂
@@ThinkZillion true, but for pain and gain ground should be of same level, for one money is flowing from govt and for one there is nothing
@@shreedattpatil6620 Nice comedy bro. But i was just trolling u ...take it easy. I am also against leftist policies.
The greatest tragedy is that there's never has been any schemes from middle class irrespective of political parties in power.
Because they don't vote in blocks.
Because middle class is the golden goose and most of us dont have any way to influence the govt.
Sir, middle class ka "Sabse Bada Rog, Kya Kahenge Log". Thanks for sharing practical life knowledge and logical advice.
You reminded me of a man in my locality having 8 children. One repairs puncture, one is barber, one is electrician, one sells vegetables, one fits tiles, one is private bus conductor. The other two are girls who are phool maala sellers. You would not believe there family income is more than 1 lakh per month. Now they are planning to buy maruti eeco to offer rental car service to daily teacher staffs.
Ye wo video hain jo slow speed me do baar sunne layak Hain.
😂
😂😂😂
I lived in India during the 1950s-60's. It was always the same. Workers were lucky to have permanent employment. Their wages scarcely rose to compensate for the prices of goods. It is the same in most countries. DEBT is the instrument used to control the population. People have known this for years.
Very true and deep observation of the changes happening in the society. I have also witnessed similar changes happening in the society. I quote one case study. Just 20-25 years before, the person who was dependent on one upper middle class family for livelihood, today
* his two sons are studying in good govt colleges (reservation).
*one son is running hardware business successfully.
*He has a pucca house.
*Now aspiring to contest panchayat elections.
The family who used to support him, now their kids are struggling to get good rank in JEE / NEET to secure some pvt job later at city away from his hometown.
Things are changing at faster pace...one needs good vision to observe them. Thanks sir for highlighting such relevant issues.
MC... Reservation se jal gai kya?? 😂😂
Dependent? Brahman tha kya jo agdam bagdam bolke dakshina le jata tha? Kaam karta.hoga na jo baman kar v nahi sakta .lmao
@@Terahydron bs aisehi rota rh
@@BankNiftyChamaeleon kaun ro raha wo to pata chal raha. Puri video bana di baman ne .
Ke koi bheek nahi de raha , ab kya hoga hamara buhu
@@Terahydron lol these so called bamans have more. iAs more ceos more company owners more inventors , is bubble se bahar aao , reservation helping no one seriously , reservation only pulling highly talented backwards that the ones country really needed and deserve , reservation only adding more donkeys in system
My kids joined BPO at age 18, And they are doing college and professional courses too. I'm very proud, happy and satisfied, also burden free. 😊🙏
You call your children burden? Shame on you
@@doyourbesteveryday6535 It's about making your adult children independent. They are free thinkers, fearless and have their own money to live life on their own terms. 😊
@@doyourbesteveryday6535 Talking of burden. Me and my wife becoming burden on our kids is the last thing I would want. We both are working and are 100% physically and medically fit in our fifties. 🙏
@@sanjaysable2006 Sir is your wife a working women?
@@sanathan4072 Yes.
Aapki video real me society me change la rhi h.....Mere mind set ko aapne bahut change Kiya h...u r doing so great work sir...🙏🙏
Good to see , u picked such a topic on which Indian politicians hesitate to talk, no one talk about of middle class ...
This was a eye opener video! I have forwarded it to my family group. I like your informal way of presentation... the way a family friend would share experiences. I also like few instances when you are brutally frank. Sometimes frank statements are required to jolt a person out of complacency. Thanks a lot Sir, for sharing your insights.
Because middle class people are ashamed to show themselves as middle class..That's why they buy all the things to make themselves look rich. expensive cars , iphone, house.. They get into debt in buying all this showingoff stuffs, they talk big, most are lies.. And worrying about debt they get diseases '' diabetes, bloodpressure, cancer , cholestrol common.. and they are 90% of the population in india.
Awesome video..
Its high time we realize this.
As an engineer i started my first job in semiconductor industry in 2017 with 15k per month and earn 150k per month now.
I got a break exactly with the sameway you mentioned, where i was spotted by a client manager and he contacted me to give me a better offer than my first company.
I learnt the same. Be there and start anywhere you get a chance.
Kudos to you sir for speaking on such an important topic.
Thank you for your valuable insight Sir. All the while watching this video, I was thinking as if you’re telling my story.😅 I’m from Bihar and I’m from a middle class family by mindset but lower middle class by financials. When I graduated from engineering college, I knew I wasn’t getting hired by any company so without wasting time I started working in a call center. My father, like every Bihari household wanted me to prepare for UPSC but I decided not to and that was one of the smartest decisions I took. 7 years of my working and I have learnt a lot by now. I made some stupid mistakes(as you mentioned) to satisfy my ego and got caught in debt trap but I learned about difference between asset and liabilities and now I’m in a better position. I would like to add that the biggest problem with us is poor knowledge of finance and lack of interest in learning. We think coz we have a degree so we know better. Also we have to justify we are better so we have to spend money on show offs which makes a hole in our pocket. If I talk about my state Bihar, people waste the most precious asset they have i.e. time on government job exams where chances of getting one is minimal. Had they spent this time in learning new skill, the result would have been much better.
Biharis ARE SUPER RICH.THEY DONT NEED JOBS.THEY HAV GOVT SUPPORT
Awesome... I just saw your video for the first time and subscribed ... Back in 2008-09 ... midst of recession.. I being an engineer couldn't get the job I desired... so joined a call center and learnt how people work professionally...Now I am an SME in IT who protects Data for various Blue chip companies.... Every profession has something to learn... No work is cheap .... it's the one's mentality..
Same here bro
Bhai pls tell me i m bankimg aspirant preparing for 2.5yrs i want to join some company now ..pls guide me
@@Akashyadav-rd1eo join some KPO..
@@ankushmukherjee3219 wht is kpo bhai ?
@@Akashyadav-rd1eo KPO are basically much better version of BPOs for example some company might have a process for a big US Healthcare company so you can hired as claims analyst, billing executive, simple MIS cum data analyst..
The thing is KPO has better career scope.. so yep.
Mind blown sir🤯 Few things to add:
1. Don't know why, it is very hard to resist addiction for those kind of lower middle class job holders
2. Probably to 80 to 90% of Indian population thinks, Stock market = gambling, even if some try, fail to figure it out and get out of it with loss, primarily I think lack of long term thinking
3. Eventually it does not matter if you are doing gig job or high end job, what matters is how you want to use your money to reach where you want to reach in life.
Those who focus on that without getting distracted from everyday noise will reach upper class, parents need to figure out how long they can afford to let their kids figure out what they want to do with their lives.
Stock market requires lot of involvement. For most people, mutual funds are best.
Excellent , sir.
Hard hitting truth... Those who understand, earn it... Those who don't, pay it...
Hahaha… That’s compounding
I have both side examples in my family itself . My most of the cousin brothers wasted early age in girlfriend and addiction , got no job or got it late in age of 25 . Other cousin took admission in Hotel management course in Pune at age of 17/18 and from that time he is earning by serving in hotels & bar as well . Now he can manage parties , and hotel services as well at age of 22 . He never asked for money at home . His understanding of society is very good .
25 is not old bro haha
@shivamagrawal521 same story for me.....apart from my parents all my relatives told just one thing to my parents ki "tera beta hotel mein kaam karega", now those relatives are secretly asking my parents to give them list of good HM colleges.
Wish I was the second example
Exactly hotel management is really looked down upon but it pays well, the cringe mentality of hotel me naukar stops a lot of young people to pursue this course
as a middle class i totally agree . parants used to say (caprasi ka naukri krna h? , village me farming krna h?) so we got setback. its mostly middle class thinking which parents have
city mein vo log bazaar se subji laakar khate hai jo gaon mein kheti karane ki yogyata nahi rakhate hai. gaon mein jo middle class hai vo chote jamin ka Malik hai, Amir sir ki sunega to Italian pizza hut ka noukar banega...ise Amit sir golden language mein "noukari" kah rahe hai. wrong advice.
Because middle class people are ashamed to show themselves as middle class..That's why they buy all the things to make themselves look rich. expensive cars , iphone, house.. They get into debt in buying all this showingoff stuffs, they talk big, most are lies.. And worrying about debt they get diseases '' diabetes, bloodpressure, cancer , cholestrol common.. and they are 90% of the population in india.
Very good video. I totally agree that the middle class is sinking with a mile stone of ego around its neck and the lower class is turbo charged. Look forward to talk to you personally if possible.
This is definitely a great lecture on the reality, really appreciate your efforts sir!
“We but mirror the world. All the tendencies present in the outer world are to be found in the world of our body. If we could change ourselves, the tendencies in the world would also change. As a man changes his own nature, so does the attitude of the world change towards him. This is the divine mystery supreme. A wonderful thing it is and the source of our happiness. We need not wait to see what others do.” - Mahatma Gandhi
Sir, you have explained so simply & nicely that anyone can understand the issue. Thanks for making such videos 🙏
You are absolutely right sir about the mentality of middle class. "What will other people say if we work this or that?" is the biggest issue we and our families are facing since long.
Sir, I am watching your channel for the first time. This video's theme is excellent and resonated very well. I watched it till the end. Liked it. As you rightly said, no one can take their position for granted be it individual, family or nation or organizations. This is natural evolution phenomenon. I have seen personally middle class families becoming lower middle class and vice versa. The only difference is that now the pace of this change is very fast. Earlier by that I mean in 70s or 80s , if this kind of transition was happening over several decades, now this kind of change is happening in 5 to 10 years. Keep it up. You are doing a great job by educating people. Thanks 🙏🏻
I have worked part-time in McDonald's when I was 20 yrs old while studying. Sir you are right, I have gathered many experiences which helped me later in life.
K
How much salary bro
@@harpalmettla4388
I hv worked for 1 yr in McD back in 2004 , that time I was a student and did only part time job. Earned less than €500,- . * it was part time !!!
@@rishiodeb what's your current job & what did you study there in european country?
@@gamingwithxan1430 Gas pipeline inspection work. I have studied in an Austrian German medium technical school.
Really appreciate your sincere efforts sir. Every middle class person must see this video. The future is going to be harsh for those who live in a fantasy world.
Very delicately analyzed the middle class situation which is very pertinently placed. Thanks for bringing up the topic.
In India, the middle class has set some toxic standards for themselves for which they themselves are going down. Example as same as you mentioned about working in Food Chains wearing a cap.
Toxic std 😂😂😂
@@radhikamulwani8542 Why u laughing, anything funny here?
Bhai konsi food chain wale 30k de rahe hain. 15k dete hain aur 9 ghanta kaam karvate hain. Phir insaan kya study karega.
@@enlightenedone2323 isn't it funny,since v ourselves have set up this toxic std n still crib about it
26-28 saal ke UPSC ki tyari kr rhe h... Sir aapne toh aate hi humari besti krdi 🤦♂️😅.
And yes sir, you are right about that Middle class thing. After graduation I started a job and was earning ok( not much but ok) . But my parents literally forced me too much for Govt. Job and I had to quit that job ( although I was not going to do that job for lifetime i was just trying to learn things) but my parents and relatives you know🙄 told to me to just focus on govt. Job and that's all you need to live a good life and then get married and happy life🤗.
But that's not the reality there is no guarantee you will get govt. Job in 1-2 or 3-4 for years or may be not but in that process you waste or lost your whole precious time to learn things and get your skill sharpened for future. you just waste your whole life and time in that exam preparation nothing else and if you didn't make it God knows what will happen to you or us, cause we are left behind much more to that time ,Just blank. and then we see others.
And yes, even my family took my job after graduation to their ego that how can you do that little paying job. I wasn't able to explain them cause they just don't want to listen 🤷♂️ that was so frustrating.
Middle class don't want to think beyond that cage of job and saving snd then marriage they don't want to try or don't let their kids try and in the end they blame their kids that's all.
Now I am 26 and going to be 27 this year already 2 attempts in UPSC just given everything to this exam and really hasn't done anything else( cause there is really no time in b/w to try something new) . Now I can only relay on this exam and if I didn't make it I know I have to start from years back where I left cause no one going to count my attempts into experience. Its a bitter truth .
If you have something to do, do it. came out this mentality " Maa baap ka sapna pura krna h " Do things learn things see people around you and take experience.
Parents need to tell/ guide their kids how to do what he wants to do but instead they just tell their kids to change his mind and do they wants. This is very heartbreaking they got selfish just for their own ego and blame thier kid in the end sometimes it leads to depression and failure.
This is first time I wrote a comment this long, hope you will get what I am trying to say👍.
And for parents just grow up with time don't force your dream on your kid just because you weren't able to complete them. Time has changed so we have to change our way of living too.
You don't know how much I want to write here about this thing but this is comment section not a essay😅 .
Bhai u write so well you will make it to UPSC. Keep going😀
All d best for Upsc-But ,if unlucky-,Its not d end. U must have definitely improved in many aspects(like english n essay 😂), just count on them and go ahead
I am 22 my parents too were forcing me to go for civil services but I told them I want to do business and now have joined with my father to do business I didn't wanted to waste time in things that doesnt fascinates me. And this is the high time for me to bring my life on a track and earn a living out of it. I wish you good luck ahead.
yo Bro try giving a sentence long gap in between two paragraphs . this makes it easy 4 us while reading your long comment . think of it as a short break for eyes .
Apart from that whatever you have mentioned is true & relatable to everyone .
Thanks for writing it 👍
Bhai kuch na ho paye to tutions chalu kar dena
Gov exam k liye prepare ho rahe ho to 12th tak sab perfect hoga..try karo all d best
This was the first Sango Life Sutras that popped in my feed this year in March, have been a fan of all the channels since then including the newest channel. Your videos are seriously helpful for the youth. Thank you sir!
This is GOLD! :) Thank you for this!
Sir you pointed out the most alarming situation for us who are the so called MIDDLE CLASS
This is the most eye opening video I have seen in months. Amazing knowledge sharing by the creator 💯👏🏽. Great job 👍🏽
Because middle class people are ashamed to show themselves as middle class..That's why they buy all the things to make themselves look rich. expensive cars , iphone, house.. They get into debt in buying all this showingoff stuffs, they talk big, most are lies.. And worrying about debt they get diseases '' diabetes, bloodpressure, cancer , cholestrol common.. and they are 90% of the population in india.
Thank you Sir, you opened my eyes.
You are saying absolutely true.
Sir, Really your topic is too practical. Thanks for giving some awakening shocks to middle class. Time has come to do something for middle class because all of us belongs to this only.
The only way, get rich and then help the middle class to get richer.
Nowadays no matter what people do. They will remain poor. That's a fact.....
Hi sir I encountered your one video yesterday which was about Midlife Crisis for men.
I am a 22 year old guy but ironically I saw a brother figure/ casual guide in you despite you being an old man which according to today's GenZ is useless to listen to people like you.
I am a lower middle class guy and each and every point of yours in this video hit me hard and has sticked in my mind.
I am glad tha I found your channel.
And yes I am sure that I'll get to know more things from you further and that's why I feel like you are one of those person towards which I feel like "This is that one person among five good people around you whose average is what you are going to be"
Love and Respect : )
Actually i am.not old man. Baal gyaan kr safed hain oomar ke nahin. I am.quite young so do not credit that way
Sir ka beta bhi Abhi 17 years ka hai , I think , he’s quite young don’t go by the hair colour
@@madhavkohli579 his boy is lucky.
Try to listen your Father... you'll be more greatfull sir coz he is the one who teach you everything with experience and expect nothing but your growth...
Absolutely correct …. Very soon the new generations of middle class will realise this need of working culture…to understand the value of money one should definitely start their own earning… study and practical knowledge should go side by side , now the time has come… life is becoming tough & tougher these days… gone are the days when there is only one working person & rest are just sitting and eating at home without any contribution. Good video 👏👍
Sir aapka ye video bhi copy kar liya CA Rahul ne… aur similar topic Sandeep Maheshwari ne bhi bana daala. You are the original creator. Hats off to your radical thinking. 👍🏻
You are absolutely right.. This has become the reality of middle class. We have become too picky about jobs. The middle class families stigmatises most other jobs which are not sarkari. " Lardka private mai kam krta hai kya future hai iska" these mentality needs to go. Yehi karan se bahut young boys and girls exam preparation mai apna life kharab krdete hai.
I am a middle class and this is very true....we have so much prestige to work for small jobs...even parents feel ashamed of it😅
are bhai ye adami tuzhe aur girane ko kah raha hai...tumhe tumhare parents ne jahan laya hai vaha se upper uthane ka kaam karo...swiggy..zomato...McDonald is not real life....without having a single square feet agri land you can do a agribusiness of min 2 cr pa...this a paradigm shift by current govt...do a start up ..fail...learn...don't repeat...again start up...don't work in McDonald's or ccd. you will get a wrong picture of animal civilization wearing a t-shirt of being human.
Dominos does not give 30-35k for standing at the counter. He is not that well aware of the ground reality.
@@shikhar2054 but not wrong on logic presented. still 1 rupee is better than nothing. also it develops communication power, confidence to deal with strangers, and interaction. ghar baithe 25-28 saal taak govt prepare karke history parne se kuch nahi sikhta wo. so a dominos and delivery boy os aged 20-24 age is much more useful now for the economy.
Even govts shame. Lol.
This is a dimension I did not explore till today, thank you for that.
I assume this ecosystem you are talking about is the situation in TIER1 & TIER2 cities of India.
I request you explore the current situation of rural India and see if your theory applies there as well.
Great effort Sir, Thanks again.
-Arjun, Theni, Tamilnadu.
I resonate fully with what sir here are saying. These are my exact thoughts too. Middle class has too much pride and shame to do literally anything what is needed to make and grow money and pursue their dreams. And they have too less money to buy anything or any experience they wish.
Having said that, the way our government is humiliating honest tax payers is also one biggest reason. A street chai vendor gives 0 income tax. We work some white collar job. Each and every Paisa earned by is visible to government and they squeeze us. In return we get potholed roads, water by tanker, irregular power connection. Lower class anyways here tremendous subsidies. Rich and business people have all the tricks to hide their income.
It is a punishment to be an honest, hardworking middle class person in this nation now.
Cut down d pride n see wonders
Don’t you think now-a-days people are obsessed with money!!!
Well said.
A good one. I am a school teacher. My retirement is on 2027. Although I shall get pension from government, still I have a plan to open a roadside stall to become active in a car of my own.
I am inspired by yours.
Wow
Excellent analysis for any country, not only for India. A common talk but life changing.
Thank you Sir. You have explained a major issue of the so called middle class in a simple way. I wish all our youths listen to this video.
'K'
I just visited your channel 1st time through this video.
Your analysis top notch sir.
Surely there is redistribution of wealth happening & it has started, bas dekhneka najariya chahiye. Middle class is stuck in poverty trap.🙏
My god, what an enlightening session. Your single video makes so much change in perspectives.
Omg, what a perspective Sir❤️. I'm a BBA graduate and I have done a delivery job, believe me, I learned a lot and I become confident.
get a BPL Card you will be happier
@@vinaysingh-my1lb seems experienced
Tum picchle month mera order deliver karne aaye the na
@@xdsamar Still better living on your dad's money.
Sir, To add - The middle class has always treated the lower class as inferior. We have seen the cases of food delivery boys beaten up by customers. This is why the middle class kid is reluctant to take up that role in the society which he thinks as inferior.
The technology and Communication skills that were once "inherited" by the middle class through their English Medium schools/colleges is becoming available for all And as you said the time is near when the push from the bottom will bring the Lower class equal to the middle class.
Lower class is that particular community who want free ration , free electricity , low fees school and big jobs these are so called lower class 😂😂😂
@@ShubhamKumar-vd9xy free reservation
@@ayushanand7933 cheap !!!!😛😛
actually, charbhi bohot chadhi hai middle class me, kabhi dekho kitna garur se chalte hai jab guard darwaza kholta hai
I am from upper middle class family also, however after knowing the background of my father and mother both I realized that I am to a child of a labour class who are rich now
bhai tu metro city main baith kr dialogue pel rha hy tier 2 and tier 3 city main difference hy bohut, Ha yeh theek hy ki wo log sab kam pe jate hy they are hard earner nd good people as compare to most of middle class family
नमस्कार sir पढ़े लिखे लोग तो बहुत है लेकिन वजन अनुभव से आता है आप अपने अनुभव से नई और पुरानी दोनो जेनरेशन को मार्गदर्शन करते रहे.... आभार 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Splendid macro & micro economics analysis 👌🏾
He express the transformation of today's life. Great analysis 👍
I have never came across something like this in my life . kya thought hai sir hatts up :) very very futeristic :)
Sir the middle class is not ready to accept such hard truths. I am working in logistics and seeing at close quarters the gig economy people earning 50k plus. And also seeing around me educated persons spending their 20s to clear competitive exams.
Rightly observed.
How many people understand what is the Gig Economy? Nice that at least you know it.
They will clear their exams and will rule over you don't be naive is someone chooses something else from your perspective, it's overall surrounding fault ki failure ko accept nahi karte, startup founders jo fail hue at least unhone kuch Naya try toh kiya and after failing no one hires them if hires that too at very low cost.
@@heatsingh2205 You want him to stop his perspective and still forcing your own perspective on him.
Hypocrite.
@@nochance3914 you don't have capacity to understand I can gauge that.
@@Evaisgalaxy Gig economy is basically that there are more short term contractual employment opportunities rather than permanent jobs. This is across public and private sectors
The only thing we have to remember as a middle class individual is to upskill ourselves continuously, try to learn business or job specific skills rather than completing highly difficult degrees. I a 12 pass right now had to leave my grad due to monetary issues , but now I have started from the scratch and just joined a MNC for a chat process, now I have pledged to myself to work for sometime and then upskill myself , by learning new languages and completing more technical courses. Which will eventually improve my job profile in the future. After that I will definitely look to start my own business, i have learned from my sister's experience that doing job will not increase your earnings on a large scale. India has to develop an entrepreneurial mindset to become a high income nation, we need to become producers and not service providers .
Your thought process is great. In today’s world degree is secondary. One can do anything, since the market opportunities are higher. All the best for your future endeavours. 👍
Hey iam also in college and i want to connect to you , can we become friends,
@@Kanaylist I am not in clg though I doing open grad . But yeah no problem😄
@@shodhitgoyal6539
Can we connect?
I have some doubts regarding SOL-
@@muktadixit Yeah we can , on which platform you want to ask your query?
Good line of thinking
Just another thought process:- is it only money which is everything in life and dignity doesn't matter
Rather than keeping up ambitions, why can't we live minimalist
Excellent and sincere analysis and well presented video. It is absolutely right. I have many poor families of 20 years ago living with us and were low educated have already crossed me (who was a highly educated and top class executive). You are very good.
Power Punch 👊Ego writing cheques which the body cannot cash 👌👌
What an amazing video. Absolutely true. This is what is happening in India since last decade and the Middle is in a big trap by now they are actually same as lower class but they are just not willing to accept the harsh reality. 1 man works in a middle class as a doctor or engineer and makes upto 1 lakh per month but lower class everybody works or runs small business like tea stall or eating outlet and they make more than middle class doctors or engineers
K. It feels so good that someone like Amit sir is able to enunciate what we have been feeling but not able to pinpoint or express due to the 'noise' around. If Almighty gives an opportunity, I would definitely like to connect and exchange thoughts on such topics.
Exactly sir ...i find personally, how kaam karne wali bai is earning and spending almost on equal footing or placed even better, wealthwise, than a single earning so called middleclass lady....they have no status issues in doing any job, they are clever enough to encash all govt schemes coming to them as below poverty line family from all directions....and is having more than 2 own houses but still stays free as watchman family in an apmt!!...your analysis hits the truth bang on sir!!🙏and....no taxes is their icing🙃
There are other reasons also for middle class like:
1. blind faith in education embeded by parents and schools and colleges/universities, in reality after 8th std its worth not a penny
2. Lack of initiativeness by parents. Punjabi families are very good example, they ask their kids to go out and earn early if they see that they are not able to gain anything from further study. But normally middle class lacks to provide and give this initiative to their kids
3. Forcing kids to not let them focus on those subjets they like, they never become the master in that subject they like and remained average in those subjects which he don't like means lack of self-confidence and feeling of unworthiness
4. Don't know what to do with their life, because of lack of exposure about fields like factory/indistry workings, computer graphics, photo-video editting, market level codings
5. Shame from working in worker/helper class because of judgement from other midlle classes and lack of respect by bosses in these fields
Wow
These are exactly my thoughts
But in college days
Bhadwe lok bullied me for having these thots
I am proud of my sociolist thoughts
My family undergone transition from lower middle to lower 😣
And I felt every point what u have shared sir!!!
Why so?
how?
@@Sri-Charan my dad had a sole proprietorship firm. COVID closed it after that he picked up job and im doing studies at age 21 not able to contribute for family
@@atharvjaju7511 Dont worry, things will change in u favour
@@Sri-Charan yes sir thanks
Making a correct assessment of self in every aspect is important. Person who can't crack group 2 state exams aspire to become IAS, wrong expectations. Parents think high of their children and misguide certain times. I have seen friends who destroyed their career with wrong assessment.
If you are earning Rs 30K per month your expenses should not exceed earnings, not point in planning for foreign trips etc
K… Hats off Sir, the way you present these hidden, valuable and never realised ideas is really commendable. Please keep spreading such eye opening treasures.
Mujhay Rona Aa Raha Hai 😢I was was from Upper Middle Class, But yes now we're Lower Middle Class Living in a 2 Crore House with only 1 person's Rs 70,000 Pension 😭
I m not understanding is this joke or serious 😂😂😂 2 cr ka ghar 70 k pension ka insaan lower middle class kaise hua..aap theek ho na
@@mi2066 😂😂 .are yrr shi bol rha hoga but hmlog ka etna bhi income nhi h .toh hmlog poor ho gye estrah toh 😂.
@@mi2066 I was very serious and got deppressed after watching this video. Now i am a little better
Dekh rha hai binod!
A man r u joking or wat, u r leaving upper upper class life
I don't know how UA-cam recommend me this video... But i agree with ur thought sir...I also belong from lower middle class.. Unfortunately I can't get formal education.. But i educate myself .. And currently I live in Dubai and work with real estate brokerage firm....
Very educational video sir, though we say that ki "koi bhi kaam chota nahi hota" but the fact is totally opposite. We have so much accustomed to our comfort zone that weekends are generally wasted which is equal to 100 days of the year.
YOU ARE RIGHT. Earlier the Appointment letters contained a clause that you could not take up any part-time job during working hours. If anyone wanted to be LIC Agent or do anything else he had to take permission from the office. Even for higher studies I had taken permission from my office.
Someone is going to file a p-i-l or whatever required regarding this obsolete rules
Lic agent is such a time waste😂😂
@@zipitar9018 no bro , some people make living out of it , it is good job
Your video resembles with my life, I started my life from lower class and now trying to enter in lower middle class, all of that possible due to my hunger of working, thanks for this wonderful video,, K
What I like about this channel is the fact that this gentleman gives unconventional wisdom.
Sir your videos are eye opener. Kindly make a video that architecture course of 5 years is a scam.
Even the brilliant Students of architecture has no scope of earning more then 20000/- Very pathetic situation for them.
My friend gets 30000/-pm as fresher though
Boht badhiya. Wisdom for the ages that modern consumerism is hell bent upon making us forget. Really appreciate your perspective and guidance.
Nice information
Eye opening
Wow this was a wake up call for me
I'm 22 and I've just been sitting at my home for a year. After my bachelor's I had lost motivation to study as well as absconded frm work but this vid has been a wake up call for me and I will try to work on myself thank you.
Very true story
Great, now get going ...or u miss d bus
Superb. Futuristic but you forgot to mention middle class will fall further and other classes will rise due to forcible distribution of income tax paid by the former class in freebies.
Yes, you are right. He hasn't been able to elucidate dangers of over population in India and unfettered capitalism.
Wow! Many people are educated, but you're Wise. I really appreciate your 'grabbing by the cuff' approach. Thank you for your frank and to the point videos. These 18 minutes were definitely enlightening moments. Kudos!🙏
Very true.middle class children don't want to work physically, and mentally they are occupied in phone. just wasting time and dreaming to be a hcs or IAS officer. They want to purchase brand clothes and accessories ,wasting their parents hard earned money.
Toh kya soche chai stol .mba chaiwala h .modi pokodawala 😂.kya chahte ho .Einstein bn ke noval prize laye india ke liye .phone chalne ka aadat toh sab me h chahe wo garib ho ya amir .
sikhaya kisne ye sab😂😂😂
@@shrishri8898 tere jaise ga##du thori tha .uske pass dimag tha . 😂Mtlb kaha se aate ho yrr. Jaisa bhi yahi h 😎.rhna toh tikh wrna America shift ho jao 👍.