Casey, you can literally take any eyeshadow color combo, and make it look stunning. I am always impressed with how well you make colors work together and how your eyes always turn out so nice. You are a natural, and i will never stop watching your videos. Much love for you!! Keep up the great videos!
Casey, I appreciate the way in which you review- no bashing, no omg, no drama- just ,you know, honesty! It's only makeup at the end of the day, BUT it does help to get an honest review. Thanks.
Laying in the hospital bed recovering from surgery.. I had to get 2 blood transfusions..😿 so thanks for posting a video.. it helps me get through the pain!! Love ya Casey!!
Casey this is one of the first videos I see from you and I can really appreciate your honestly and the fact that you didn't cut out the first try with the eye look.
Thank you for honest reviews and actually zooming in so we could see the makeup up close!! No one ever does that and it's awesome, super helpful! Love your videos.
So refreshing to see someone "mess up" and have to start over on these videos. I always watch beauty gurus do a perfect eye right away and feel like I am just awful at make up. I love your honesty and transparency, my favorite UA-camr by far. Keep it up girly! And post your dogs on Snapchat hourly because I love them.
I was digging that first eye look! When you put that yellow, it was like BAM! 💛 But I understand why you took it off. It was definitely a fall dramatic look.
Omg Casey I love your channel so much! Don't let any of those haters bring you down! You are beautiful your skin is beautiful and your personality is beautiful! Love from Canada
I love your makeup videos so much Casey they're my favourite to watch 😍😍😍 I honestly feel like you're so easy to watch and it's like I'm getting ready with a friend!!
Jesus said not today Casey you're not doing another Smokey look 😂. But nah for real I hate my palette too which is sad to say it's an Anastasia palette. Returning mines . Love you Casey ❤️🙌🏽
Oh Girl, when you went in with that palette for such a special occasion I wanted to scream, No, don't do it!!! If you can't really make it work, wtf am I supposed to do with it? No thanks ABH! Thanks Casey for showing us an honest review.
I appreciated you keeping the footage of you wiping away the eyeshadow. Just goes to show how not everything works out even with someone so big! Love you Casey 💗
That ABH palette looks like a huge disappointment. If you can't even blend the colors well, lol I can't imagine the struggle the rest of us will have! I really wanted that but looks like I'm going to have to pass.
Ginny Amick not sure how you feel bout him but if you like the colors Jeffree Stars palette is pretty close with the same colors. Everyone raves bout it.
@Ginny Amick I don't know if you saw ABH insta story their makeup artist describing to correct way of using this palette 2 days ago. Apparently, this palette is actually are hard if you're a beginner but not the pro, as by that say for using the palette all you need it's 1 tap into the pan and blending to your lids very light not hard. I think the other issued it's that few youtubers used concealer as eyeshadow primer which it's to dried or too patchy.
So thankful that Casey wasn't the least bit dramatic about the subculture palette in this video! Samantha Ravndahl and RawBeautyKristi have great videos dedicated to the palette.
I love the fact that you leave in footage of things that don't work out even if you have to start over. One of the realist people in this beauty community! ❤️
Wow! You can totally see that color change in your crease. That pallet makes me sooo sad. You always look so beautiful no matter what's going down on these crazy videos! Love watching!!!
I absolutely love your tutorials, I find them so helpful! Also really enjoy watching your vlogs and I just think your dogs are the cutest! I'm looking for some makeup advice - I am a ballroom dance and have been looking for a highlighter that will really stand out while I'm on the dance floor. Drugstore is preferred cause I don't want to spend a fortune on it. Any suggestions would be great! ❤️ you!
Alyssa Reese I agree with wet n wild for sure!! Especially if you get their cream stick one and layer a powder one on top....BAM! Blinding bitches in the back row!! 😉✨✨🔥
Kellyn Derrick I saw your comment and paused the video immediately LOL It's 2am for me right now and 2 of my dogs are sleeping next to me. I can't have them wake up right now HAHAHA I guess I'll be finishing this video later today 💜💜
Subculture palette disappointed me too. Ordered it the moment it went live. Kinda regret it. The colours skip really weird. Blend to nothing or blend blotchy. Especially the greeny colours. The two shimmers are not opaque. The metallic is dope. The yellows are too. But the palette is nowhere near modern renaissance level. Wondering if they sped up production/release cause of the leak?
Annabelle van der Scheer I feel like the two lighter shades are meant to put over other shadows since they're so light coverage. I did a look using the greens and blues and put the green sparkle color (I forget the name) over the greenish blue color and it showed up instantly and looked beautiful.
Unfortunately, I am returning my palette. The nonblendabilty and patchiness are too much. And you have to be too careful with touching the shadows with the lightest of touch to not waste all of the product. It is impractical. I *love* the colors and the MR palette, but this is a different animal altogether. 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 Betsy in the Seattle suburbs
They probably did. I'm not sure why the would change the formula if Modern Renaissance did so well. I'm not one to buy palettes once they are released because I want to see reviews before I spend my money.
Girl! You're the real MVP 'cause several of these products were a "no go" but you kept it moving. Happy birthday to your 'hubby-to-be' and God bless him for his service.
xoxoem25 Totally agree! Everyone is so crazy about it, but I don't feel it. I was like, am I the only person on the planet?! 🤔 I own the MR palette and definitely my favorite palette ALL TIME, but the Subculture Palette... nope. 😏
Girl I died when you said "some of y'all gonna kill me for doing another smoky eye" 😂😂😂 you are the smoky eye queen!🙌🏼 do you boo👸🏻 love you to pieces!💕
Even with all the fallout from this eyeshadow palette I am so in love with the final result of the eye makeup! It is absolutely beautiful! I love the colors and how you applied them! I just love this eye look so much! 💚
I had honestly been waiting for you to post a review of the ABH palette to see how it worked for your skin because we have similar eyelids and skin tone and now that I know how it worked for you, you saved me $42! Love you and your honesty with products that you review!
What's your go to liner for waterline? Everyone I use either smudges or just doesn't last long. Trying to find a long lasting one that's waterproof!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️
kuhayleex3 haven't tested for waterproof quality but the Marc Jacobs gel liner in blacquer is amazing and lasts until I wipe my makeup away and then still till the next day!!!
Casey's second eye look is the only decent one I've seen with the ABH palette! So glad there are beauty bloggers to try these things before I waste money on it myself! Thanks Casey!!
Honestly I didn't think the blendability of the shadows were bad at all but maybe it wasn't picked up on camera. Either way I'm excited to try mine and am hoping for it to not suck ass lol
I love how casey is so real like you get her real personality i feel like when i watch other people they are trying to sell u a product and act really fake she gives real reaviews love love love her
I love this pallet it's all about your technique I have never came across a pallet that has so much pigment that is what makes this pallet worth it just tap people so simple
You know a palette ain't no good when CASEY can't get it to blend ☹️ so glad I didn't fall into the hype. Even the people I've seen rave about the palette, their eyes look like dookie. So sad 😩 the colors are gorgeous!!
Currently going through and reducing the number of UA-camrs I'm subscribed to on UA-cam but your channel is always a must for me! Thank you for being consistently real and drama free. Honestly I come on UA-cam to destress from my daily life and your channel is the perfect way to do that ❤️
Love the video girly!!! Of course! But what is that song at the end??? I've been dying to know for like ever!! I mean I know you switch it up but that one was in one of them before and I loveee it... the like 5 seconds of it at least lol
Apparently ABH changed their formula so Subculture has a different formula than the Modern Renaissance. It seems like overall the MR was better quality-less patchy and less fallout. I love my MR palette but I will probably not be buying this product.
Peach Plum Girl if you compare the ingredients in the shadows from both palettes they're drastically different-idk how they can even follow up the MR palette with that
You looks amazing as always. I wasn't surprised by the AB palette. Jeffree Star had the same issue with the darker shades getting muddy and not blending. I'm glad so glad you always do your eyes first and could take it off! You made it work and I'm not surprised.
Casey, you can literally take any eyeshadow color combo, and make it look stunning. I am always impressed with how well you make colors work together and how your eyes always turn out so nice. You are a natural, and i will never stop watching your videos. Much love for you!! Keep up the great videos!
You know somethings up when Casey starts biting the brushes lol. Love you Casey!
Symone Pryor I don't remember her ever wiping off her eyeshadow like that!
Tracy Frederick I don't think she ever has.
Symone Pryor yep, shit just got real 😂
Lol ikr?
Symone Pryor I think it was because she was annoyed by the sound of the lawn mower in the background
happy birthday Davis! Thank for your service
Laura Gadzinski me and davis have the same bday yay!!!!!
Casey, I appreciate the way in which you review- no bashing, no omg, no drama- just ,you know, honesty! It's only makeup at the end of the day, BUT it does help to get an honest review. Thanks.
Literally the only person I trust to review the Subculture palette. Love ya!!
Laying in the hospital bed recovering from surgery.. I had to get 2 blood transfusions..😿 so thanks for posting a video.. it helps me get through the pain!! Love ya Casey!!
check out jackie ania!! she's so funny and honest! Feel better, sending positive vibes!!!!
rebecca wilson I love Jackie and her videos.. I'm going to watch her new one right after this one !!❤️❤️❤️
feel better!
Stacie Evans I hope you feel better soon.
Grecia Alvarez thank you luv!!
I always get so excited when I see a notification for Casey's videos 😍 MY #1 FAVORITE UA-camR!
Kaylee Kantorowski love her and rachhloves wish they would do one together!!😍😍
Megan Melissa YESSS 🙌🏼
Kaylee Kantorowski me too!!
You are so refreshing to watch. No drama, just honest reviews. I've learned a lot from you.... keep doing what you're doing! 💗
Casey this is one of the first videos I see from you and I can really appreciate your honestly and the fact that you didn't cut out the first try with the eye look.
Gabriela Maldonado I agree!!! Also nice name :)
Gabriela M name twinssss LOL
Gabriela Maldonado agreed so many UA-camrs are like stabbing the shadows with brushes and being like oh my god look there's fall out.
Thank you for honest reviews and actually zooming in so we could see the makeup up close!! No one ever does that and it's awesome, super helpful! Love your videos.
Girl I think your skin routine + NY is doing your skin some good!! (Even though us Georgia peaches miss you down here!)
Tiffany Orton She's from NY?
She just moved there recently from ga.
So refreshing to see someone "mess up" and have to start over on these videos. I always watch beauty gurus do a perfect eye right away and feel like I am just awful at make up. I love your honesty and transparency, my favorite UA-camr by far. Keep it up girly! And post your dogs on Snapchat hourly because I love them.
I was digging that first eye look! When you put that yellow, it was like BAM! 💛 But I understand why you took it off. It was definitely a fall dramatic look.
Christina Barnes it was a pile of mess
Rachel Monday I guess different people have different tastes because it looked like a patchy awful mess to me
I think the colors with the yellow just would have looked amazing if the eyeshadow had been working out
That zoom on the foundation was amazing, please do that on all foundation reviews.
I literally dropped the video I was currently watching when I saw the notification for caseys review 🙌🏼🙌🏼 my girl always tells the honest truth!
I was getting stressed out watching Casey try to save that eyeshadow look 😅
I was too! I was so happy when she wiped it off, lol.
Essence has the best mascara's and tinted brow mascara!
Amanda Cooper which of their mascara do you like best?
I have to agree!!! I own them all. Cruelty free and cheap ahh heck yes !!!!!
Taylor H the big pink one. I think it's called volume extreme.
I love how you will start a look with the palette and even if you don't like the way it's turning out, you'll still show us that part of the video!
I was so relieved when you wiped that first eyeshadow look off! Lol, love you 💗
I love that when you're thinking about it looking at your makeup, you put your brush in your mouth, I do that all the time!!
An eye shadow look with no tape from Casey? I'm quaking
Jools Humes she did use tape
angelica. At the end she didn't
Jools Humes haha you're right I commented too soon
angelica. Not the second time she didn't
Abh broke Casey!!! 😱. She abandoned the tape!!
your trying new makeup series is honestly my fav
Omg Casey I love your channel so much! Don't let any of those haters bring you down! You are beautiful your skin is beautiful and your personality is beautiful!
Love from Canada
I love how you'll do something & if it doesn't work, you just take it off on camera. You are so real & honest. Love you Casey!!!
I love your makeup videos so much Casey they're my favourite to watch 😍😍😍 I honestly feel like you're so easy to watch and it's like I'm getting ready with a friend!!
I smile every time you say "Let's just go ahead and get started" 😄
Hey girl! Love your reviews! Can you try the Glossier products? I would love to know your thoughts!
I LOVE the fact that you kept the first eye look in the video to show that everyone messes up and it's just makeup!!!!!
Jesus said not today Casey you're not doing another Smokey look 😂. But nah for real I hate my palette too which is sad to say it's an Anastasia palette. Returning mines . Love you Casey ❤️🙌🏽
love how you showed the trial and error with the subculture palette , thank you for always being honest
21:02 of pure relax!
YOU ARE MY FAVORITE UA-camR! ❤️
You're such a trooper for trying that eye shadow palette twice!
Oh Girl, when you went in with that palette for such a special occasion I wanted to scream, No, don't do it!!! If you can't really make it work, wtf am I supposed to do with it? No thanks ABH! Thanks Casey for showing us an honest review.
I love watching your first impressions videos, I feel like you're so real with them.
You should try xobeauty! From shaaanxo, her brushes and new makeup!
Anna Murrell I suggested that too on a different video!!
I'd like to see this too!!
I would love to see it too! 😁
Anna Murrell would loooove to see this! Shan needs other BGs to give her some love!!
Me too!
These are BY FAR my favorite videos. Do them more and more and more!!!!
The mascara was impressive
I am always here for the smokey eyes!!! Most youtubers always do "everyday" looks. I love that your everyday look is so glam.
❤️❤️❤️ got the notification and stopped what I was doing. Love you girl!
I appreciated you keeping the footage of you wiping away the eyeshadow. Just goes to show how not everything works out even with someone so big! Love you Casey 💗
When you said "it's starting to look like one color" I was thinking the same thing!!
Thank you for not being a drama queen. 🙌
I love how real you are in your videos! Sometimes we all have those days when we have to start over our eye look if it is starting to look crazy!
That ABH palette looks like a huge disappointment. If you can't even blend the colors well, lol I can't imagine the struggle the rest of us will have! I really wanted that but looks like I'm going to have to pass.
Ginny Amick I know that's right 😂😂
Ginny Amick JS, had issues with this palette. Especially, the color "all star".
Ginny Amick not sure how you feel bout him but if you like the colors Jeffree Stars palette is pretty close with the same colors. Everyone raves bout it.
@Ginny Amick I don't know if you saw ABH insta story their makeup artist describing to correct way of using this palette 2 days ago. Apparently, this palette is actually are hard if you're a beginner but not the pro, as by that say for using the palette all you need it's 1 tap into the pan and blending to your lids very light not hard. I think the other issued it's that few youtubers used concealer as eyeshadow primer which it's to dried or too patchy.
So thankful that Casey wasn't the least bit dramatic about the subculture palette in this video! Samantha Ravndahl and RawBeautyKristi have great videos dedicated to the palette.
I love the fact that you leave in footage of things that don't work out even if you have to start over. One of the realist people in this beauty community! ❤️
yessss my fav kind of videos
Wow! You can totally see that color change in your crease. That pallet makes me sooo sad. You always look so beautiful no matter what's going down on these crazy videos! Love watching!!!
More fashion videos please 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 outfit ideas loveyou so much 💕❤❤❤
hey girl before you unpack your travel makeup bag, you should film a whats in my travel makeup bag!! Love you Casey!!
I absolutely love your tutorials, I find them so helpful! Also really enjoy watching your vlogs and I just think your dogs are the cutest! I'm looking for some makeup advice - I am a ballroom dance and have been looking for a highlighter that will really stand out while I'm on the dance floor. Drugstore is preferred cause I don't want to spend a fortune on it. Any suggestions would be great! ❤️ you!
Alyssa Reese wet n wild have blinding ones for $6
elf has a good $4 one you have to kinda scrape off the top layer first lol
Look at her video about flower cosmetics! I bought the highlighter pallet she recommends from there and omg I'm obsessed
Alyssa Reese I agree with wet n wild for sure!! Especially if you get their cream stick one and layer a powder one on top....BAM! Blinding bitches in the back row!! 😉✨✨🔥
definitely wet n wild's highlight in precious petals!!! I got it for a dance competition and I'm pretty sure it was like, $4.99. SUCH a good highlight
The outcome of your look you created came out stunning, seriously
when daisy/rose barked my dog woke up from his nap and hasn't stopped barking for the past 5 minutes lol
Kellyn Derrick I saw your comment and paused the video immediately LOL It's 2am for me right now and 2 of my dogs are sleeping next to me. I can't have them wake up right now HAHAHA I guess I'll be finishing this video later today 💜💜
Casey is one of the realest youtubers
FINALLY THE ONLY PERSON I TRUST
i love how you keep it So real and show you trying out looks, not liking them, wiping them away..just so real and authentic!!! XO
Subculture palette disappointed me too. Ordered it the moment it went live. Kinda regret it. The colours skip really weird. Blend to nothing or blend blotchy. Especially the greeny colours. The two shimmers are not opaque. The metallic is dope. The yellows are too. But the palette is nowhere near modern renaissance level. Wondering if they sped up production/release cause of the leak?
Annabelle van der Scheer I feel like the two lighter shades are meant to put over other shadows since they're so light coverage. I did a look using the greens and blues and put the green sparkle color (I forget the name) over the greenish blue color and it showed up instantly and looked beautiful.
And you can always return the palette on the abh website if you don't like it!
I agree, I was overly disappointed. I will be returning it
Unfortunately, I am returning my palette. The nonblendabilty and patchiness are too much. And you have to be too careful with touching the shadows with the lightest of touch to not waste all of the product. It is impractical. I *love* the colors and the MR palette, but this is a different animal altogether. 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭
Betsy in the Seattle suburbs
They probably did. I'm not sure why the would change the formula if Modern Renaissance did so well. I'm not one to buy palettes once they are released because I want to see reviews before I spend my money.
I love the second eye look you did! Very light and summery in my opinion, as well as easy to recreate!
if you and Kathleen collab I would lose it!! ❤❤
Girl! You're the real MVP 'cause several of these products were a "no go" but you kept it moving. Happy birthday to your 'hubby-to-be' and God bless him for his service.
the subculture palette is so odd to me, i don't see cohesive looks. maybe just not my preference?
xoxoem25 one youtuber suggested looking at it in 3s and 4s, and the look she made was stunning. once i saw it that way i really wanted to buy it
xoxoem25 Totally agree! Everyone is so crazy about it, but I don't feel it. I was like, am I the only person on the planet?! 🤔 I own the MR palette and definitely my favorite palette ALL TIME, but the Subculture Palette... nope. 😏
Right! I wanted to be excited about it but I'm just not! with MR I can glance at it and be like this in the crease, this on lid, etc.
I live for your smoky eye looks😩🙌🏼🙌🏼 honestly the best❤️
Girl I died when you said "some of y'all gonna kill me for doing another smoky eye" 😂😂😂 you are the smoky eye queen!🙌🏼 do you boo👸🏻 love you to pieces!💕
Please never stop doing these kinds of videos girl!! They help me so much with picking out makeup :)
Jeffree, Laura and now Casey! My life is complete!!
same!!!
All my favs, waiting on manny 🙌🏻😍
Catarina Pereira Casey is too real for those fake ass bitches.
And Tati!! 👏
Agree
Even with all the fallout from this eyeshadow palette I am so in love with the final result of the eye makeup! It is absolutely beautiful! I love the colors and how you applied them! I just love this eye look so much! 💚
😩😩 everyone be muddying up their eyes with this palette on UA-cam today
You are honestly my favorite you tuber, always so genuine and i actually trust what you say. Thank you for being so real! Love you!!
omg! when the eye shadows were blending together into one color i no joke was like having a mini heart attack for you lol
That essence mascara was amazing!!! It made your lashes look bomb! Def need to try that out!
How does the feel of the elf liquid lip compare to the wet n wild cat suit formula?
girl, your skin is looking soooooo freaking good!!
when you wiped off the first eye look I was like "oh thank goodness, she's starting over"
Had to pause the vid to tell you that your skin looks SO good 💕 have you been using any new products?? Love you girl! 😘
I just realised that Casey spelt Estée Lauder like Edged Lauder hahahahha 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
I had honestly been waiting for you to post a review of the ABH palette to see how it worked for your skin because we have similar eyelids and skin tone and now that I know how it worked for you, you saved me $42! Love you and your honesty with products that you review!
What's your go to liner for waterline? Everyone I use either smudges or just doesn't last long. Trying to find a long lasting one that's waterproof!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️
kuhayleex3 she has been using the lottie london am to pm liner in her waterline and she says it lasts all day.
Kenetrice Nichole I knew she had mentioned something, I couldn't remember what it was! Thank you!
kuhayleex3 haven't tested for waterproof quality but the Marc Jacobs gel liner in blacquer is amazing and lasts until I wipe my makeup away and then still till the next day!!!
kuhayleex3 just got the Lottie London both of them they are amazing Casey was right :)
kuhayleex3 Try the new-ish Smashbox Always On liners. They go on super smooth and don't move on me. I have allergies and watery eyes as well.
This look is so pretty. I like the lightness of all the colors and products you used
wow, i've been watching you for years and i've never seen you wipe off an eye look.
Casey's second eye look is the only decent one I've seen with the ABH palette! So glad there are beauty bloggers to try these things before I waste money on it myself! Thanks Casey!!
Honestly I didn't think the blendability of the shadows were bad at all but maybe it wasn't picked up on camera. Either way I'm excited to try mine and am hoping for it to not suck ass lol
I love how casey is so real like you get her real personality i feel like when i watch other people they are trying to sell u a product and act really fake she gives real reaviews love love love her
Todays my bday im 16!!!!!!
Mary Brewer Happy birthday!!! 🎉🎁🎈🎂
Mary Brewer happy birthday girl!
Brandy Chapman thanks😁😁
Lauren Coffman thank u 😁😁
Mary Brewer It's my birthday, too. But you could be my daughter. 😂😂 All ages love Casey! Hope you had a great 16th!
Such a beautiful look!!! Everyone has had trouble blending the subculture palette. I believe I will pass on it until AHH can fix it!!! Love you Casey
Love you so much
Your skin is looking so good Casey! So happy for you!
*BUTTER?*
wtf paula
I laughed too hard at this
😂😂😂
Paula Deen is butter a carb?
YES sweetie it is.
Honestly, that first smoky eye looked so bomb!! Totally not your usual, but so nice!
Omg i wasn't expecting when she removed the eyeshadow lol
I love this pallet it's all about your technique I have never came across a pallet that has so much pigment that is what makes this pallet worth it just tap people so simple
You know a palette ain't no good when CASEY can't get it to blend ☹️ so glad I didn't fall into the hype. Even the people I've seen rave about the palette, their eyes look like dookie. So sad 😩 the colors are gorgeous!!
Girl when you wiped that first eyeshadow look off I was like YEEASSSS GIRL!!!
You know there is something wrong with a pallet when all these talented makeup artists are having to redo looks 2 to 3 times.
Currently going through and reducing the number of UA-camrs I'm subscribed to on UA-cam but your channel is always a must for me! Thank you for being consistently real and drama free. Honestly I come on UA-cam to destress from my daily life and your channel is the perfect way to do that ❤️
Love the video girly!!! Of course!
But what is that song at the end??? I've been dying to know for like ever!! I mean I know you switch it up but that one was in one of them before and I loveee it... the like 5 seconds of it at least lol
On soundcloud its play on ahlstrom remix!
Sarah Mazur Thank you!! I've been searching for this song forever!
+Sarah Mazur OMG THANK YOU!! I was looking on SoundCloud and could never find it!!!
I really liked that you left the first eye attempt in the video.
Seems like lower end brands are making better products than high end recently 🤔🤔
You're the first guru I've seen make a successful eye look with the Subculture palette. I really like the look.
Apparently ABH changed their formula so Subculture has a different formula than the Modern Renaissance. It seems like overall the MR was better quality-less patchy and less fallout. I love my MR palette but I will probably not be buying this product.
Peach Plum Girl if you compare the ingredients in the shadows from both palettes they're drastically different-idk how they can even follow up the MR palette with that
Olivia and Katie damn what a shame
You looks amazing as always. I wasn't surprised by the AB palette. Jeffree Star had the same issue with the darker shades getting muddy and not blending. I'm glad so glad you always do your eyes first and could take it off! You made it work and I'm not surprised.
Look at her ear too face. Casey, I love you so I suggest you to put some fountain on your ears.