The Seductive Nightmare of Bloodborne's Chalice Dungeons

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
  • I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed by madness, starving hysterical naked, dragging themselves through the Lower Pthumeru Chalice in the dead of night.
    Follow me at / yacobg42
    Patreon: / jacobgeller
    Big thanks to these fine folks for additional footage:
    JollyMoonMan: • Video
    Unachemaxwell: • Bloodborne death by sl...
    Moros Nyx: • *FIRST EVER* WANDERING...
    Visual Media used: Bloodborne, Demon’s Souls, Dark Souls 1, Dark Souls 2, Dark Souls 3, Bioshock, The Enigma of Amigara Fault
    Music used: Love (Under the Skin), The Alien (Annihilation), Secret Betrayal (Dark Souls 3)
    ----------------------------------------------
    Script available upon request for accessibility
    Check out Cane & Rinse for podcasts, written articles, and more caneandrinse.com/

КОМЕНТАРІ • 618

  • @LashknifeTalon
    @LashknifeTalon 4 роки тому +2442

    Just 8 days ago, all 2300 possible Root Chalice Dungeons were explored by the Tomb Prospectors subreddit. That should be the end of it; they found EVERY SINGLE POSSIBLE permutation of the Chalice dungeons based on the game's code.
    As of when I write this comment, there are still posts on that subreddit newer than that. They are still going.

    • @matthewrobinson6091
      @matthewrobinson6091 4 роки тому +204

      Even when we have discovered all there is to be discovered the abyss calls out endlessly and we will find more regardless of whether or not there is any more.
      I seriously can't wait for bloodborne 2.

    • @themostdiabolicalhater5986
      @themostdiabolicalhater5986 4 роки тому +131

      Matthew Robinson Not only can you wait, but you’re going to wait. Forever. Because there won’t be a Bloodborne 2

    • @HydrengeaEdelweiss
      @HydrengeaEdelweiss 4 роки тому +105

      @@matthewrobinson6091 There is no path... Beyond the scope of light, beyond the reach of Dark... what could possibly await us? And yet, we seek it, insatiably... Such is our fate.

    • @agiar2000
      @agiar2000 4 роки тому +36

      *D E E P E R*

    • @oceladeb
      @oceladeb 4 роки тому +23

      This is absolutely terrifying.

  • @shamp0ing339
    @shamp0ing339 5 років тому +935

    I found this channel through the Shadow of the Colossus video but after watching a few more I can safely say you are one of the best channels I've found in a while. The way you write these essays is absolutely captivating

    • @tgfnc
      @tgfnc 5 років тому +11

      How do you give a comment 5000 more likes? This is literally word for word my exact same experience

    • @BrunoB78
      @BrunoB78 4 роки тому

      exactly the same here

    • @epochii2756
      @epochii2756 4 роки тому +2

      I did too!! I watched the video near when it came out, and not recognizing the channel, and then became obsessed with the jokes, the poetic explanations, the cosmic horror. I love this channel, man-

    • @djestoussaint8968
      @djestoussaint8968 4 роки тому

      100% agree, exact same thing, ive been binchwatching all of his videos

    • @DodderingOldMan
      @DodderingOldMan 4 роки тому +3

      Ha, yeah, same. Glad that Shadow video was a break out success, there are so many great game commentators on UA-cam, but this guy is definitely amongst the very best.

  • @shaneshane8482
    @shaneshane8482 4 роки тому +717

    Another cruel thing: the rune Guidance (tier 3) has NEVER been found. A manual said it rests in depth 5 chalice dungeons. I am not even going to talk about the time I spent looking for an item that (debatably) doesn’t even exist. Odd enough, the name of the rune... guidance. We need guidance to find guidance. We can never have that rune.

    • @petruciosxd1374
      @petruciosxd1374 4 роки тому +56

      It could actually be a glitch with the DLC, since Guidance is the only rune you can get infinitely, tier 1 that is, next to a crow or from a crow in the Research Hall (it's been a while since I've played, ain't sure), you can get it after every new game cycle, real weird.

    • @shizotypical
      @shizotypical 4 роки тому +59

      It's confirmed that the tube doesn't exist, it's nowhere in the game files. It's so strange that we have a ton of hidden/cut content and yet there's this one thing that just doesn't exist even though it should

    • @petruciosxd1374
      @petruciosxd1374 4 роки тому +14

      @@shizotypical Tube? Caryll Tubes?

    • @shaneshane8482
      @shaneshane8482 4 роки тому +80

      Ксения Старцева - Actually, that’s incorrect. The rune is in the game files, but it doesn’t synchronize with loot chests in the dungeons. The rare drop table cannot make the correct calculations to ever make it appear. Through a certain mod, however, you can auto-place the rune in your inventory. And it’s legit; Guidance (fully colored in image) +30 discovery

    • @barbarianzg8826
      @barbarianzg8826 3 роки тому +11

      Chalices are procedurally generated so it's recomended to create every time a new one..somewhere in cursed chalices..search every cribit..lol
      There's a 3 outcomes...
      1. That specific chalice containing gui+3 rune has been created and not fully explored and deleted from server. (don't believe in this:)
      2. Someone did found it and never knew that is special.
      3. That chalice is still not procedurally generated.
      Happy search!

  • @Sha0wn1
    @Sha0wn1 4 роки тому +220

    This video feels like I'm listening to some obsessed dude's last audiolog before he finally went too deep. Very fitting and really well done.

    • @blarg2429
      @blarg2429 2 роки тому +6

      It's that exact vibe that keeps me periodically coming back to this one.

  • @syntholm2433
    @syntholm2433 4 роки тому +311

    I want to listen to that DEEPER sound effect until I delve into the spiraling madness in my mind dungeon that I created to escape my problems

    • @Somethingbloody
      @Somethingbloody 4 роки тому +33

      Definitely watch Annihilation if you haven't.

    • @Act5scene1
      @Act5scene1 4 роки тому +18

      you might enjoy The Mark - Interlude by Moderat. it's the track that sound is from.

    • @afrogod7556
      @afrogod7556 3 роки тому +4

      And a Majora's Mask pfp? Sick! Have you played Shadow of the Colossus? Another favorite of mine and Jacob Geller also has a video on it

    • @coal2710
      @coal2710 3 роки тому +5

      It's very relieving to explore the labyrinths with tomb prospectors and madmen while listening to nothing but ambient noise. Trying to locate the sobs, laughter and pitter-patter of spiders and rats turn the player into a cautious and skilful hunter.

    • @giddycadet
      @giddycadet 2 роки тому +1

      You'll like Hydroplane by KOAN Sound then. It uses a very similar synth to do the same sort of warbling bass sound.

  • @trashgremlin9055
    @trashgremlin9055 5 років тому +1342

    Theory: The world of Bloodborne is built so impractically vertical because after man discovered what was in the chalice dungeons they wanted to get as far away as possible. After building a sort of containment system they realized that there was no end, thus the only option was up. But what EXACTLY did they find?

    • @fizzie6902
      @fizzie6902 4 роки тому +157

      I always thought that the discovery of the old blood made the city grow way too fast for it's own good thus the vertically. Or maybe it had something to do with the dream realities during the night of the hunt or whatever.

    • @ghostface6387
      @ghostface6387 4 роки тому +86

      Another fucking poison swamp

    • @ThrottleKitty
      @ThrottleKitty 4 роки тому +91

      Or, what if everything is actually part of the chalice dungeons? The world of Bloodborne is all dreams stacked on top of one another, maybe the top layers of the dream just feel more vivid and alive, and the bottom layers are more dead and bare?

    • @scott4398
      @scott4398 4 роки тому +74

      Definitely not. Exploring the tombs was Byrgenwerth's domain, so the only people who know about them now are high-ranking Church members (Choir, Executioners, Mensis). And when those who would go on to form the Choir discovered an eldritch butterfly squid god in the tombs what did they do? Give it a place to live and start using its blood to seize power and experiment on the public.
      If anything their willingness to build on top of the tombs instead of moving far away from them is evidence of the hubris which ultimately ruined their society.

    • @MercurialRaven
      @MercurialRaven 4 роки тому +18

      @@ghostface6387 you probably aren't far off, considering the cut content about the "lake of mud" where you would have fought the moon presence in the chalice, or some iteration that became the moon presence.

  • @CelestialDraconis
    @CelestialDraconis 5 років тому +1951

    In the beginning, I used to HATE and loathe the chalice dungeons. After so many dreadful nights of mental torture, just to kill the Queen for the last trophy, I was burnt out. Months later, I had this urge to go back again. Like a cursed hunter who couldn't get enough of the bloodshed and killing. And I sort of became more and more fascinated and downright addicted to the chalice dungeons. As if discovering I was a masochist all this time.
    I've always used to say that the chalice dungeons were a great idea on paper with horrible execution, due to how repetitive they were. But I failed to realize their genius. They are the game's physical embodiment of insanity. Of humanity's lust for forbidden knowledge, that as a result, led to their insanity. Some things aren't meant to be known. You cast your eyes upon Cthulhu, and your brain will just shut down. And the dungeons themselves, they're the representation of the human mind, running helplessly in circles in search of answers, only to lose their minds in the process. It's Hell, forever trapped in this twisted limbo. Perhaps ignorance _is_ bliss.
    Humanity's fear of the unknown, and letting that fear control us, will be our greatest downfall. We toy with things we don't understand (like the church using the gods' blood for themselves, dooming all of Yharnam's populace), searching for things we're not supposed to see, and think we've become so enlightened, like Micolash did. But we're all still just animals.
    I apologize for being so dramatic, but it's nice to see someone who finally appreciates or at the very least have an interesting take on the chalice dungeons, and to mention Junji Ito as well! Been really into his stories lately, and what's great about his stories is how grounded to reality they are, even if he talks about fantasy and supernatural entities, there's always that subtle touch of reality behind his story's messages.

    • @LucasBarbosa-qh5ke
      @LucasBarbosa-qh5ke 5 років тому +63

      "the game's physical embodiment of insanity" holy fuck...
      And I actually enjoyed the chalice dungeons. I wonder what that says about me..

    • @joeysands8893
      @joeysands8893 5 років тому +9

      Plus Junji Ito has some pretty sharp satire and social commentary. He’s a master of horror, as well as subliminal messaging.

    • @hammer768
      @hammer768 5 років тому +7

      All right Socrates chill out

    • @dov8410
      @dov8410 5 років тому

      Alright m8 chill

    • @CelestialDraconis
      @CelestialDraconis 5 років тому +16

      @@hammer768 That's *Aristotle* to you, thank you *_very_* much.

  • @WWProductions94
    @WWProductions94 5 років тому +956

    Of course it’s the Annihilation soundtrack. Of course.

    • @cassius092
      @cassius092 5 років тому +41

      I heard this in another movie called Under The Skin, didn't know it was used elsewhere.

    • @sayst
      @sayst 5 років тому +59

      @@cassius092 There isn't any overlap in the tracks Annihilation OST and Under the Skin OST, except they are both used in this video. 8:23 is the "Annihilation" track, here used for title transitions.

    • @balakay493
      @balakay493 5 років тому +10

      I knew I would like the video as soon as I heard Moderat's The Mark (Interlude)

    • @Ciretako
      @Ciretako 5 років тому +26

      You know what they call Annihilation in Paris?
      Roadside Picnic with cheese.

    • @whym6438
      @whym6438 5 років тому +14

      Annihilation the book was very Lovecraftian, so it makes total sense.

  • @TouruZen
    @TouruZen 5 років тому +514

    I like the comparison to Amigara faults. But I feel Yharnam as a whole and the Chalice dungeons shares more in common with Uzumaki by the same creator. A yawning abyss spiraling ever downward. A compulsion to madness and an inability to escape. And all consuming insanity eminating from deep bellow that we will never understand fully. A force beyond mortal comprehension.
    Yharnam is just another step. Another floor on top of the chalice dungeons. To be forgotten to be built over. We already seen signs of this as well with Old Yharnam how it stretches down into the lower reaches of the city and yet it keeps going. Leading ever deeper. Another city will takes its place to be built over it. Another host to the blood sickness wrought by the force lurking deeper and deeper.

    • @blueWolfYuno
      @blueWolfYuno 4 роки тому +1

      forums.coronalabs.com/topic/76464-job-offer-game-tbs-br-mmorpg-tcg-c-s-get-rich-easy-job/

    • @Shnarfbird
      @Shnarfbird 3 роки тому +4

      Dragonfly pond dries up... For now.

    • @ScrawnyTreeDemon
      @ScrawnyTreeDemon 2 роки тому +3

      A chilling comparison. And an apt one.

    • @MadamFoogie
      @MadamFoogie 2 роки тому +9

      I agree. The way the population of Kurouzu-Cho devolved into monsters through obsession or ill intent is very reminiscent of _Bloodborne._ I'm especially reminded of the mosquito chapters, with pregnant murderous blood-swollen women slavering for blood, resulting in supernaturally intelligent children. Then, the whole thing with cannibalizing mushroom placenta, and returning to the womb. Junji Ito was a clear influence, and I think his entire body of work fits nicely into the mythos.
      Heheh, get it? Fits nicely, because _The Enigma of Amigara Fault._ XD

    • @blarg2429
      @blarg2429 2 роки тому +6

      @@MadamFoogie lmao
      Also: Junji Ito's _The Thing That Drifted Ashore,_ a short story about an incredibly gross and unnerving fish, seems to have parallels to the bit of Bloodborne lore pertaining to the death of Kos. You see, the thing that's so weird about the titular "thing that drifted ashore" is that its body is full of live humans, which it has scooped up and preserved in an unconscious state whenever anyone in the area was lost at sea. It's by no means an exact match for what Kos had going on, but worth a mention anyway.

  • @TM-vb5h
    @TM-vb5h 3 роки тому +62

    " people start to lose their minds, while beast started to gain one" that line gets me every time I hear it

  • @JoyAndAgony
    @JoyAndAgony 5 років тому +843

    rip to everyone who physically squirmed as soon as he mentioned the enigma of the amigara fault like me

    • @stoulmar2550
      @stoulmar2550 5 років тому +5

      Sounds hella interesting tbh

    • @PhantasmX
      @PhantasmX 5 років тому +56

      DDRRR DDRRRR DRRRRRR

    • @pedroscoponi4905
      @pedroscoponi4905 5 років тому +17

      What happens to the people who go inside their holes? It's very unlikely that I'll read it, please spoil away

    • @JoyAndAgony
      @JoyAndAgony 5 років тому +94

      ​@@pedroscoponi4905 READ MORE FOR SPOILERS
      .
      .
      .
      .
      .
      .
      .
      .
      .
      .
      .
      The people who have a hole for them are reincarnations of their past cavemen-selves executed for crimes. They were executed by going into a hole that makes them continuously slide forward as the hole (painfully) distorts their bodies into misshapen noodles that come out the other side of the fault.
      [it basically combines claustrophobia, dysmorphophobia, and general body horror. fears that all humans have to a degree]

    • @asmodeus235
      @asmodeus235 5 років тому +1

      Yes me too please

  • @discountphantomthief
    @discountphantomthief 5 років тому +235

    I suddenly have this urge not only to play Shadow of the Colossus again, but to go somewhere deeper. It seems you have a talent for memetic agents.

    • @callusklaus2413
      @callusklaus2413 5 років тому +10

      Hello, my name is John from the SCP foundation, please hold still while I administer this Amnestic.
      Okay, now that that is taken care of, let's start containing this Scip.

  • @cavfre148
    @cavfre148 5 років тому +208

    It still haunts me that I’ve never “completed” the chalice dungeons

    • @martinsegur7173
      @martinsegur7173 5 років тому +45

      And you never will, no matter how deep you go.

    • @HekateMGO
      @HekateMGO 5 років тому +24

      Martín Segur they’re not completely random, there’s only about 180-200 different variations on Chalice Dungeons. So you can definitely “complete” them. I’d hazard to say I have beaten every depth 5 variation, I farmed over 100 blood rocks from dungeons on my quest to upgrade every weapon & weapon variant to +10.

    • @martinsegur7173
      @martinsegur7173 5 років тому +15

      @@HekateMGO People said the same about Isz dungeons a year ago.

    • @thesatelliteslickers907
      @thesatelliteslickers907 4 роки тому +37

      @@HekateMGO there are about 2 thousand forms of chalice dungeon
      And it turns out that they aren't actually rng. It was discovered after the tomb prospecters mapped every possible permutation and found that they were all purposefully put together before hand. You can actually find the various chalice dungeons in the game data. Its not generated on the fly its pulled from the actual game files

  • @homunculi0408
    @homunculi0408 4 роки тому +50

    People: They build this city in such an inhabitable, insane way! It must be due to the influence of the eldritch beings, the dreams!
    Builders: Yo dawg, let's see who can build shit the highest!

  • @bleek1566
    @bleek1566 4 роки тому +43

    this video is one of my greatest inspiration sources for my eldritch DnD campaigns and stories of the unknown.
    the feeling to go ever deeper or simply obeying the primal feeling of curiosity until it becomes your demise.
    i love it

    • @JacobGeller
      @JacobGeller  4 роки тому +16

      Yo that's so cool! Good luck on your campaign!

  • @craigtrautmanjr9393
    @craigtrautmanjr9393 5 років тому +402

    I've heard nothing good about the Chalice Dungeons until this, and it convinces me to go try them out.

    • @sablemae8853
      @sablemae8853 5 років тому +22

      The deeper u go the better it gets.

    • @gv2212
      @gv2212 5 років тому +30

      @@sablemae8853 thats what she said

    • @sablemae8853
      @sablemae8853 5 років тому +8

      @@gv2212 got'em

    • @josephagnetti8921
      @josephagnetti8921 5 років тому +6

      They're pretty basic procedurally generated dungeons, which are fun the first time, but get pretty monotonous in a second play through.

    • @GirlPlus
      @GirlPlus 5 років тому +3

      Yeah, the shallow levels are nothing inspiring, but the later levels are fucking great.

  • @rafenelson7230
    @rafenelson7230 4 роки тому +74

    Talking about lovecraft and having music from Annihilation fits perfectly, that music never fails to give me shivers and portrays the strangeness and frankly terrifying nature of the dungeons so well. What a damn good video man

  • @Bluecho4
    @Bluecho4 5 років тому +124

    That bit about the architecture in Bloodborne trending toward the crowded and labyrinthine is fascinating. Something in the Eldritch Truth they've learned - even if only on a subconscious level - guides the hands of their architects, sculptors, and city planners towards creating these dense, vertical, recursive nightmare mazes.
    It's almost the reverse of the Psychitecture as described in Dean Motter's _Mister X_ comics. Instead of the architecture being designed to influence psychology, the psychology of the citizens of Yharnam - both ancient and modern - influences their architecture.

  • @quills4922
    @quills4922 5 років тому +172

    The more I learned about chalices the more I appreciated them. Their winding, endless, nonsensical nature brought about through rng is quite handily explained through the sheer insanity of their canonical builders. They lull you into that madness through those samey, endless properties that people hate them for. They addict players, and pull them in.
    Chalice Dungeons are terrible. You do have to be crazy to like them. You do have to be crazy to keep pushing into those nearly infinite mazes expecting... something.
    But that's all part of being a Hunter, isn't it?

  • @rohiogerv22
    @rohiogerv22 4 роки тому +110

    What I think is really interesting about the chalice dungeons is that I’m impulsively compelled to look for meaning in them.
    Across the standard trajectory, this makes sense. Maybe finding an Amygdala at the root of every defilement has meaning. Maybe the Old Lords’ affinity for fire means something. But I get the same compulsion in the root chalices. “I’m in Pthumeru. Why are there a bunch of celestial mobs staring at the same spot on the ground?” “Why are these particular glyphs on this particular wall?” “Whom is this statue representing?”
    I find myself searching for profane knowledge the same way the Byrgenwerth scholars had. And if I found it, would it even make sense to me?

  • @Pollokyn
    @Pollokyn 5 років тому +65

    Ive been playing Bloodborne for years... I just cant stop.

    • @coal2710
      @coal2710 2 місяці тому

      Could you?

  • @jamesprenatt2464
    @jamesprenatt2464 5 років тому +25

    Every night my wife asks me to play Bloodborne. Dungeons! she says when all I want to do is move the story forward. More gems! she says when I'm not powerful enough. She's conquered every single one and yet, they still produce obsession. If not her, someone else must do it. Glad someone else understands the allure of Pthumeru.

  • @AlexofZippo
    @AlexofZippo 2 роки тому +31

    I got to the queen. I traveled to the deepest depths. I cleared floor after floor, eventually reaching a proficiency where I could clear it without difficulty (with some few, notable exceptions...), but it reached this point were I wasn't playing Bloodborne anymore. Bloodborne was a game about memorization of paths, of enemy movements, of vicious combat. This was just... a path. Onward, downward, another room cleared, another boss defeated, pull the level, take the elevator. From castles to sand to blue fluorescent parodies of what I had long ago defeated, the rooms blurred together. I used a torch to test for hidden doors cause my weapon would lose too much sharpness if I used it. And those moments where i'd surface to spend Echos on potions or levels became like waking from a fever dream into something more approaching sanity.

  • @corwin32
    @corwin32 4 роки тому +15

    What's funny to me is that I never understood From's appeal until BB. For the first time I _wanted_ to know. I _had_ to know. No risk was too great, no death was one too many. I played it twice, and then dove back into the rest of the Souls universe with eyes open.

  • @owlgoddess8534
    @owlgoddess8534 4 роки тому +11

    ironically, this video itself is like an obsession for me. its less than half the length of your normal videos, and i wouldn't call it your best work (that award would go to fear of depths) and yet i've watched it more than any other. something about this video and the concepts you talk about in it are EXTREMELY compelling to me in a way that i can't fully understand. i really want to make something someday with a similar concept.

    • @catharticgemini
      @catharticgemini 2 роки тому +4

      Fear of Depths being your favorite is so perfectly fitting, because of this, it's funny

    • @owlgoddess8534
      @owlgoddess8534 2 роки тому +3

      @@catharticgemini the void calls

  • @Honkadelic64
    @Honkadelic64 4 роки тому +40

    this is like the exact opposite take that hbomberguy had, cool!

  • @cassius092
    @cassius092 5 років тому +58

    The song choice, Under The Skin is a great film!

    • @2007bmpgti
      @2007bmpgti 4 роки тому +5

      That movie is very underrated. It's is so stark, much more stark than I imagined "an alien movie starring ScarJo" would be. The beach scene is brutal but without menace and very effective. It really fucked me up for awhile.

    • @theblackswordsman9951
      @theblackswordsman9951 4 роки тому +3

      Also Annihilation

    • @maxximmc
      @maxximmc 2 роки тому

      I knew I recognized that music somewhere!

  • @ashenhunter1
    @ashenhunter1 Рік тому +5

    The bloodborne community is so damn cool and the chalice dungeons are so underrated

  • @adriansandoval3217
    @adriansandoval3217 5 років тому +50

    Amazing! I understand the criticism of the Chalice Dungeon design but finally someone shares his "madness" that deeper something may lurk, some item not discovered or some enemy not seen

  • @Spookybluelights
    @Spookybluelights 4 роки тому +10

    Man, your delivery in this one is so good, I feel your desperation and how much the compulsion kind of terrifies. Bloodborne is one of my favorite games ever and you completely capture one of the reasons why.

  • @mechatyrants6218
    @mechatyrants6218 4 роки тому +23

    Every possible chalice dungeon has officially been explored as of recently

    • @remmy3
      @remmy3 4 роки тому +1

      Did we find patches the spider?

    • @UriTrash
      @UriTrash 4 роки тому +4

      @@remmy3 yes, if you dont kill him in the main game he will appear in the loran chalices

  • @diogoneto7190
    @diogoneto7190 2 роки тому +4

    Still one of my favorite videos ever, came here to revisit this gem, still as beautiful as the first time
    Thanks for all of your work
    Time to rewatch the depths video 😊

  • @Ayahuasca98
    @Ayahuasca98 3 роки тому +5

    I love the chalice dungeons so much because it’s like, they add on another adventure to this fantastic game.
    I went through my first plyathrough without paying them much mind but now I have a blast with them.

  • @LivingMidnight
    @LivingMidnight 5 років тому +78

    What I got from this video: Some people have way more time to play video games than I do.

    • @rosesweetcharlotte
      @rosesweetcharlotte 4 роки тому +4

      It's just not a big priority anymore. I...I like sunlight. But winter is coming.

    • @michaelandrews117
      @michaelandrews117 4 роки тому +4

      @@rosesweetcharlotte eurgh, summer sucks here in the U.K.
      We don't have the infrastructure for it, especially since the underground trains (the things that I get on every day during June-August) frequently reach 40 degrees Celsius; my flat is sunrise facing so I'm woken up by the rising sun at 4am, Summer brings out my SADS massively, my suits are disgusting piles of sweat by the end of the day, existing in summer is just sweating in your own skin because 90% of English homes don't have built in air-conditioning... I could go on but you get the idea.
      Sun sucks. Stay in and play video games.

    • @a.d.d.j8673
      @a.d.d.j8673 4 роки тому +1

      Well we all have time now boys

    • @manscapedgrinch1427
      @manscapedgrinch1427 4 роки тому

      @@a.d.d.j8673 not those who work in essential services.

    • @a.d.d.j8673
      @a.d.d.j8673 4 роки тому +1

      @@manscapedgrinch1427 true much resepct to them, i wish i could go back to the job i love

  • @royalityxkx
    @royalityxkx 3 роки тому +1

    Excellent use of the sound track from "Under the Skin" !!! My commendations to you good sir.

  • @fivesilvercoins
    @fivesilvercoins 4 роки тому +2

    i appreciate how loopable this video is.

  • @dalethtichy
    @dalethtichy 5 років тому +19

    The ending music is not The Alien (Annihilation) - it's Moderat's "The Mark".

    • @JacobGeller
      @JacobGeller  5 років тому +7

      That's interesting! I took it right from the movie audio of that scene, but you're totally right. Didn't know it was an original piece before the movie existed.

    • @dalethtichy
      @dalethtichy 5 років тому +3

      @@JacobGeller I'm a fan of Moderat, so that scene from Annihilation impressed me even more. I like your video also and the use of Moderat's music.

    • @mist3rtank3r
      @mist3rtank3r 5 років тому +2

      @@dalethtichy Thanks, thought i was gonna be the first on that one. Both this video and Moderat rocks.

  • @FrogsOfTheNewWorld
    @FrogsOfTheNewWorld 5 років тому +11

    one of these days we're gonna find Riko's mother down there

  • @kos2919
    @kos2919 5 років тому +9

    What if the dungeon is interconnected to unlimited universes. Everytime you step into a new room you shifted into a new dimension filled with horrors.

  • @123NERDZ
    @123NERDZ Рік тому +1

    An absolutely fantastic video .
    Such incredible and intellectual content is worthy of more recognition

  • @fireworksfordinner
    @fireworksfordinner 5 років тому +11

    The use of the under the skin soundtrack is pretty great

  • @flame1154
    @flame1154 4 роки тому +3

    The first time you go back to he Cathedral Ward sanctuary after Rom was the most meaningful moment to me. The character there you've "saved" and who have offerend you advice, guidance and normalcy all lose their minds, and as a result, you no longer have a reliable measure of your own sanity. If you continue forward now, it's not because you're being willed forward by others, it's because you either want answers, or don't know what else to do

  • @toprak3479
    @toprak3479 5 років тому +40

    When I read the title I thought "a video praising chalice dungeons? pfffff" but then I saw the Enigma of Amigara Fault and I had to click

  • @Darisprites
    @Darisprites 4 роки тому +24

    The Chalice Dungeons remind me a lot more of a Made in Abyss, personally. And hey, both it and Lovecraft have authors who are pretty shit people but the concepts presented therein are interesting, and almost mind-consuming.

  • @AndrewEvenstar
    @AndrewEvenstar 8 місяців тому +2

    after beating this game 4 years ago, putting in 300 hours unto it, then beating elden ring, dark souls 1 and 3, I returned to bloodborne and started my first chalice dungeon tonight. this video and these dungeons are so damn haunting and cool! this video is one of the best I've seen about any game! wow. my story is very similar to yours with bloodborne ! I just started it first and also did submitted at the end!

  • @Evaquiel
    @Evaquiel 5 років тому +6

    that Under the Skin music totally goes well with Bloodborne.

  • @keith720
    @keith720 2 роки тому +1

    The sound used for "deeper" is so addictive for some reason

  • @spockninjitsu9396
    @spockninjitsu9396 5 років тому +1

    This textual analysis is better than most literature term papers. I'm fucking hooked!

  • @JohnDWJ
    @JohnDWJ 5 років тому +1

    What an excellent analysis/ blurring of the lines of game experience reaching towards Lovecraft level obsession.
    Well presented well executed. Striking sir, striking.

  • @gil4335
    @gil4335 Рік тому +1

    this aluring horror, the madness created by the fact that those dungeons exist, they're there, for you to go in. even if you know nothing's at the end, you cant help yourself. just like that junji ito manga. like the game Fear and Hunger, even when you complete your "objective", which is no easy task to do on your own with no guides, it keeps going, the dungeon of fear and hunger keeps descending. youve done your deed and yet you cant help but to keep going down, and it keeps going down for so long, for so many rooms and unimaginable creatures. also just like going cave exploring, like you mentioned in your "Fear of depth" video. this type of horror fascinates me

  • @primusavenged
    @primusavenged 2 роки тому +1

    Y'know, when I watched Under The Skin I wasn't really expecting my brain to go "oh this music was in a jacob geller video"

  • @VoltasP
    @VoltasP 11 днів тому +1

    Have you seen Charred Thermos' Agony of Effort theory? Suddenly Bloodborne makes sense. It's about the invention of Surgery in 18th and 19th century Edinburgh, with a bit of Lovecraft sprinkled on top to provide the otherworldly justification for bossfights. It takes a while to get through but holy shit by the end I was getting chills as even the silly cage hats had a clever explanation.

  • @mikoajk4317
    @mikoajk4317 4 роки тому +2

    Thanks UA-cam recommendations, you did great this time. This video is something else

  • @Pharthrax
    @Pharthrax Рік тому

    That musical cue that plays whenever you don’t say DEEPER gives me goosebumps.
    I love Bloodborne, and I love this video.

  • @chaosbean6320
    @chaosbean6320 3 роки тому +2

    Well, this is it. The most terrifying essay. I got chills listening to it, really good job on the sound design. Tying a specific sound to the word deeper worked really well

    • @yhavinmiles
      @yhavinmiles 2 роки тому

      no

    • @chaosbean6320
      @chaosbean6320 2 роки тому

      @@yhavinmiles lmao, this is the funniest think.
      Pal, you can't decide what's scary and what's not for me

  • @derekcampbell4209
    @derekcampbell4209 5 років тому +7

    At first I didn’t like the dungeons. But once I understood them, I really started to enjoy them. They’re super cool and fun. Almost feels like a different game sometimes than the main game.

  • @Hawlk12
    @Hawlk12 10 місяців тому +2

    The game Fear and Hunger has done this to me. It was so brutal that when I looked up tips I felt like I was ruining my experience and that I was supposed to fail and give up instead and there's harder challenges I can't even fathom in that game and even though I beaten it once I feel like I can't escape it unless I truly suffer the trial and error that game demands

    • @HollowPhntm
      @HollowPhntm 3 місяці тому

      Weirdly enough, the Bloodborne chalice dungeons and the F&H dungeon have this strange eldritch/omnipotent presence to them and that both fascinates me and horrifies me to my core.

  • @ethansalopek7610
    @ethansalopek7610 2 роки тому +1

    I've never been this incredibly unnerved by a video essay before. The "deeper" sound effect gives me bigger chills every time; it sounds like a being hidden deep underneath, the heart of a whale pulsating louder as you approach. Somehow the video essay about the extra content of Bloodborne is way scarier than the game itself. TLDR: Excellent use of sound.

  • @music79075
    @music79075 4 роки тому +2

    I love this video as well as the lore.
    That said i also cant help but think of Monty python
    "Our forefathers came to thisbland a built a great castle upon a swamp. Which then sank into the swamp. So we built another castle on it which then fell and sank into the swamp. But then we built a THIRD castle upon the second and THATS what you are gonna rule!"

  • @SinOfAugust
    @SinOfAugust 4 роки тому +1

    Near one of the highest (accessible) points in Yarnham there is a note that states simply: “Sky and cosmos are one”. Architects of the city were reaching out to the sky, to the Great Ones. The sanctum of the Choir is also located around the Astral Clocktower, despite the fact that the source of Church’s Old Blood came Ebrietas, who dwelt below.

  • @claytonseput5873
    @claytonseput5873 5 років тому +12

    This video gave me such a sense of dread. Excellent job. The selection of the Under The Skin and Annihilation soundtrack makes it even more dreadful.

  • @loroleibusser5993
    @loroleibusser5993 2 роки тому +3

    the jacob geller video catalogue keeps urging me to go deeper

  • @dustmemory9891
    @dustmemory9891 5 років тому +28

    You consume the reagents in the chalice after performing the ritual and the visit the dungeons in a form of astral and/or time travel.

    • @darktemplar5
      @darktemplar5 5 років тому +11

      Holy shit, I never made the connection that you might drink from the chalices. Blowing my mind here!

  • @leftovernoise
    @leftovernoise 3 роки тому +1

    The first time one of the labyrinth madmen with the sickles ran out of the mist towards me to a bloodcurdling scream, fuck, that still haunts me to this day

  • @jbvikingbat5595
    @jbvikingbat5595 4 роки тому +1

    I don't mean to sound over-exaggerative but this is genuinely one of the best horror pieces I've ever seen. I know it wasn't necessarily intended as that per se, but the music coupled with the narration that just continues to delve further and further into this quiet but insistent fervor that is so fittingly reminiscent of a Lovecraft character's obsessive, spiraling rambling, which somehow simultaneously manages to continually unveil truth while also falling deeper into some contagious sort of madness. It's so genuinely gripping that I seriously get chills every time I watch the video.

  • @jacksmith8299
    @jacksmith8299 Рік тому

    I just finished writing a 10 page term paper on Annihilation and this is an EXCELLENT use of that sound effect

  • @odone5765
    @odone5765 4 роки тому +1

    dude.. this hit me hard tho, great work and good wording!

  • @no1here27
    @no1here27 2 роки тому +1

    My god even after doing everything in elden ring i keep finding myself back at bloodborne and eventually this video as well.

  • @zmalone4237
    @zmalone4237 Рік тому +1

    Jacob, man you bat 1,000 with these videos.

  • @notyours5780
    @notyours5780 3 роки тому

    I watched this when it came out. Still one of my favorite videos of yours. Love you Jacob

  • @residentevilisreal
    @residentevilisreal 4 роки тому +1

    i love this video so dearly

  • @Bojonatanjarpehag
    @Bojonatanjarpehag 9 місяців тому

    Very nice production quality!

  • @user-dn2gm5dk1r
    @user-dn2gm5dk1r 2 роки тому +1

    i mistake this video for the fear of depth video because of "DEEPER"

  • @nineteenpassengers
    @nineteenpassengers 5 років тому +2

    Beating Orphan of Kos on my first try by the skin of my teeth was by far among the coolest gaming experiences I’ve ever had and maybe ever will.

    • @alastor8091
      @alastor8091 5 років тому +1

      I feel like you're missing out. Having died to him over 50 times, the release of finally beating him was like masturbation. Always coming so close to release only to be denied the pleasure and being forced to start all over so many times made the victory orgasmic.

  • @PitchIncorrection
    @PitchIncorrection 4 роки тому +4

    And this is why Bloodborne is my favorite game of all time.

  • @VII0777
    @VII0777 5 років тому +34

    LOVE that you opened with The Alien. A great movie and a great moment that captures everything Bloodborne is about.

  • @vagrantvienna
    @vagrantvienna Рік тому

    That annihilation soundtrack was such a thematically PERFECT choice, such profound unease

  • @stefanostsougkranis5851
    @stefanostsougkranis5851 4 роки тому +2

    What's even more interesting to me is that this game is actually quite... meta in a sense. By the end of your first playthrough you'll probably have many things left to check out in a second playthrough. Just think the possibility of not having guides or experts about this game... its hidden locations would take considerably more time to be discovered and a better understanding of the game in general would be more difficult and immersive by default. The game lures you in exactly for the reason to go deeper and deeper, blood drunken by your lust for more power so that you'll be able to gain more insight and eventually get mad from the insight you have gathered. I think that Chalice dungeons indeed have importance and contribute to this feeling of addiction besides the addicting gameplay loop. Brilliant game design.

  • @illtones_
    @illtones_ 3 роки тому

    Shout out for implementing the Under the Skin score into the video.

  • @TheRibb0n
    @TheRibb0n 5 років тому +12

    The final boss of the chalice dungeons made my boyfriend break his hand out of rage

    • @paulofkintyre8348
      @paulofkintyre8348 5 років тому +13

      He got passed cursed watchdog and amygdala and queen yharnam got to him?

    • @tetsuonitoramaru3065
      @tetsuonitoramaru3065 5 років тому +8

      Yharnam was a cakewalk compared to the cursed Amygdala.

    • @remmy3
      @remmy3 4 роки тому +1

      My guess is that it was headless bloodletting beast

  • @bw000m
    @bw000m 5 років тому +12

    videos that make me feel emotions

    • @westingtyler1
      @westingtyler1 5 років тому +3

      yeah, I'm loving this guy's vids. Check out the ones on shadow of the colossus, too. I haven't even played that game, but these vids make me want to. A lot of mysteriousness.

    • @bw000m
      @bw000m 5 років тому

      digimondudeify look into the ocean lol. then look into space. its all there friend

  • @maxwelldavidson4157
    @maxwelldavidson4157 5 років тому +4

    Now I bet you're wondering why we need to go to the chalice dungeons. To answer that, we need to talk about Parallel Universes

  • @River_StGrey
    @River_StGrey 5 років тому +5

    God these videos are so good. I love the stuff you make, it's so beautiful and always vaguely haunted and it's a great way to wake up and feel thoughtful and compelled about the day. So, thank you.

  • @dragoniraflameblade
    @dragoniraflameblade 5 років тому +3

    The DEEPER bit was stuck in my head all night and all morning after listening to this. Awesome video.

  • @nelsonandres1303
    @nelsonandres1303 11 місяців тому

    I'm absolutely obsessed with this video

  • @reigneir
    @reigneir 5 місяців тому +1

    Yharnam builds up because the Sky and the Cosmos are One

  • @brokenegg4714
    @brokenegg4714 3 роки тому +1

    I found my home here in the chalice dungeons.

  • @perfectlyhopeless
    @perfectlyhopeless 4 роки тому

    It is absolutely fascinating watching this vid after your Fear of Depths video

  • @matthewmartinez3907
    @matthewmartinez3907 4 роки тому +1

    I made up a fan theory once about the chalice dungeons and the theory of the souls games being in the same universe. That the dungeons keep going far deeper then the game suggests so far down it leads to place no one would’ve expected.

  • @noahmorris1015
    @noahmorris1015 5 років тому +2

    the way you storytell- its universal. i have never read eldritch horror. i have no desire to. i have never played bloodborne, and seeing as i prize my sanity, i doubt i ever will. but this video is something else. this is incredible.

  • @auramire6304
    @auramire6304 3 роки тому

    I keep coming back to this video. Every time I watch it I feel chills down my spine, all the hair stands up on my arms. Something about this concept terrifies me... but it also thrills me in a way I can't describe. So I come back and watch it again and again and again. It's beautiful in it's own way.

  • @nullanma5134
    @nullanma5134 3 роки тому

    That sound for the “deeper” transitions just chills and unsettles me to my core

  • @redsol3629
    @redsol3629 2 роки тому

    Well Jacob you have opened possibilities within myself, I wonder now how deep and long I can dive. Who waits for me?

  • @Liliputian07
    @Liliputian07 5 років тому +1

    Amigara Fault is *not* Ito's most lovecraftian work. That goes to either Hellstar Remina or Uzumaki

  • @micahmiller8441
    @micahmiller8441 5 років тому

    Great use of the Under The Skin score. I fucking love you.

  • @NIRDIAN1
    @NIRDIAN1 3 роки тому

    I keep thinking about this video... Almost expecting there to be more every time I see it. Kinda weird how it has the effect it describes? Good stuff.
    ALSO THE WAY YOU USED THE NOISE ON THE "DEEPER" BIT GIVES ME CHILLS EVERY TIME!!!

  • @clubbasher32
    @clubbasher32 5 років тому +3

    Its been 0 days since a horror game youtuber referenced Ito

  • @itcouldbelupus2842
    @itcouldbelupus2842 2 роки тому +1

    This is a tone poem about Bloodborne, and it f*cking slaps.
    If you read this Jacob, you should update the thumbnail to the style and quality of your more recent thumbnails, this isn't bad, but your thumbnails this past year have been great.
    More people should see this one.

    • @itcouldbelupus2842
      @itcouldbelupus2842 11 місяців тому

      Oi Jacob.
      Try my idea.
      Boost this wonderful video in the Algo!

  • @gjg5789
    @gjg5789 Рік тому +3

    I love the chalice dungeons I really feel they get a bad rep. Ironically a lot of the things people didn't like are present in Elden Ring but everyone seems to adore those while they have none of the charm or horror.
    I've done almost everything there is to do in bloodborne. Hopefully with the chalice dungeons it'll always be almost for me.

  • @chipychipz
    @chipychipz 4 роки тому

    how are all his videos so elegant & inspire such a deep understanding of his feelings the shadows of this video drive me to want to go deeper....