Zionism, Imperialism & Why the Arab Uprisings Failed - With Joseph Massad
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 лип 2024
- Joseph Massad, Professor of Modern Arab Politics and Intellectual History at Columbia University, joins Dispatches with Rania Khalek to help break down everything from Israel’s value as an outpost of US imperialism and why the Arab uprisings failed to the recent victory of Palestinian resistance forces and why it’s crucial to incorporate anti-imperialism in our understanding of the Zionist project.
» Become a patron: / breakthroughnews
--------------------------------
» Like us on Facebook: / btnewsroom
» Tweet us on Twitter: / btnewsroom
» Follow us on Instagram: / btnewsroom
At Breakthrough News we believe in the power of independent media. Five mega-corporations dominate the media landscape - controlling 90% of what we read, watch and listen to. They control the news cycle, to which social media and even most “alternative” media is forced to respond. We are breaking through that cycle.
We tell the untold stories of resistance from poor and working-class communities - because out of these stories we will construct a different narrative of the world, as it is and in real time.
People’s movements in every corner of the globe are changing history and shifting consciousness. But these movements barely receive any coverage from the corporate media. They need visibility. They need amplification. They need a media arm to break through.
We can be that media arm, but only with your help. Become a Patron and join us on the front lines in the battle of ideas.
Subscribe and follow us! / breakthroughnews @BTNewsroom
#palestine #freepalestine #gaza #gazaunderattack #palestineunderattack #palestinewillbefree #BreakThroughNews #BTnews #socialistnews #socialist #raniakhalek #eugenepuryear
Outstanding! I feel like I got three weeks worth of studies at university within the hour and a half time span of your content. Thanks Khalek!👍
Thank you for introducing brilliant professor Joseph Massad
Ra is so one of the best journalists around and this piece was an eye-opener. ❤
It’s more like an eye opener to lies, Jewish hatred and Islamic propaganda!
Extremely interesting! Prof Massad should be more on youtube
Yes, please!
Massad is clearly ignorant or a lier. He should be deported to Egypt where he can join the Islamic Brotherhood. He is a terror supporter and hates the US.
The notion of Israeli colonial aggression is a popular lie of arabs and Islamists around the world. Massad's views on all subjects is completely warped.
Excellent and thorough both historically and in the present. Thank you both.
What a brain this man has- I have watched this a few times now, but I think it is worth it.
Thank you for the intelligent informative reporting.
Thank you Breakthrough News and thank you Rania Khalek for this most informative podcast.
Thankyou Rania for an excellent interview with Prof Massad.
He is informative and concise in his analysis.
It is a privilege to hear him speak.
Excellent discussion. I really value these long form discussions on political theory.
Golly! Joseph Mossad is brilliant!
I don't think I've ever heard a better, more coherent overview of the IP conflict - just an incredibly vibrant picture.
Thank you!
What BS!
@@zohar1099 I'd be happy to entertain discussion on any particulars!
Amazing conversation. Thank you Rania for introducing us to this highly important guest.
Amazing guest. I've been reading a lot about Palestine but he still manages to bring knowledge I never knew.
Goofiest looking picture, this looks like a potato and he’s posing like he’s a model. Is this satire? Is this comedy?
He nothing but a Jew hater, Hitler lover. Pinche Colombians racista
Outstanding presentation. Much appreciated Rania
Thank you very much for the interesting discussion.
Excellent analysis! You need to go to the historical origins of this fiasco. Most people are confused because they are too lazy to listen to a dialog like this one.
This is ur best guest so far Rhania! Wow.
A must listen for anyone who is under any illusion both why, as humans of conscience they should give their full support to the Palestinians. This talk also shows exactly what the Palestinians are fighting. And why the Palestinian resistance is to be both admired and supported, by any means necessary.
Brilliant Joseph, what an excellent historiography
Wonderful interview Rania, and Prof... Massad. So interesting & intelligent- thank you for bringing us this information,
A most comprehensive and illuminating analysis of the criminal settler colonial project in Palestine, well worth listening to again and again. Thank you. Shared.
In Israel, formerly all Palestine?!
What an outstanding interview chock full of epiphanies for me and surely for most people!!! Thank you Professor Massad and thank you Rania!!!
Absolutely brilliant! I need way more of Prof Massad and will definitely be checking out his books.
what an incredible summary
This is unusually valuable because he lays out in straightforward way how Israel was a project of European elite anti-semitism well before the atrocities of WWII. This is usually a fact that is not even considered or understood. And this is something that is much less appreciated because the US is a relatively young nation and skyrocketed to being the biggest industrial power at break neck speed. So US culture is quite content being the moral superior of the world for taking care of one of the most persecuted peoples in history. That is what is on the front page and the more honest story is not even in the paper so to speak. There is a reason that states are basically taking propaganda pledges to obey the US. I was joking in another comment the other day that Blinkin was going around to other governments and telling them they have to support fascism or pay a price. This is actually the exact policy with Israel. If you don't go along with the anti-semitism farce you are in the crosshairs of US empire. Not a good feeling I'm sure.
Maybe historians, I mean historians who aren't already committed to the colonial state zionist position out of fear for their career. Maybe historians need to play a bigger role in this discussion. It sounds like understanding the decades before WWII would do a lot in empowering people with an accurate understanding of the political, cultural, European, and colonial origins of the dispossession of the people of Palestine. And now the reality of the situation is becoming a threat to the Israeli plutocrats and the US sick state. The deep sick state.
i admire joseph massad and used many of his articles as an undergrad in my papers. it would be such a pleasure to meet him and have conversations with him.
Great interview, thanks a lot.
How amazing to hear the subtitles of power dynamics without apology.
Thank you for your exceptional podcast, your guests are always engaging. 😊
This was amazing
Truly, Rania Khalek is drop dead gorgeous.
Underrated channel.
Thank you Rania khalek for this factual and enlightening interview with professor Joseph Massad. Keep up the great work!
We hope to see Dr Joseph Massad to be featured on one of your coming talk shows Ms Rania.....We read articles by Dr Massad being published in Arabic on an Arabic news web site called ( Arabi 21 ) but it is essential to host Dr Massad to address non-Arabs in English about the current running Israeli genocide against the Gazans.....
Thanks for your great efforts Rania.
WOW ! Breathtaking - literally.
Brilliant conversation!
Very informative and very infuriating. Western Imperialism is the root cause of so much misery around the world.
And progress, is is often overlooked for a cheap jab at a tiny number of ppl who made the world their bech
It’s sad isn’t it, The little people have absolutely nothing to do with it, we are all pawns in the game .I pray for the return of Jesus and to save us all .
Didn't expect neoliberalism-imperialism to be so prominent in the targeted nations of US imperialism.
I thought I knew everything there is to know about the history of Zionism but found I learned so much. Thank you both.
This was great!
What a surprise!
Thank you very much.
This is great, Mr Massad, you have really thrown so much light on Zionism Imperialism, Please keep up with this good work. And Rania, Thank you for puting him on..
Excellent , thank you
This is fantastic work! Thank you so very much for every word of this. We require the history and the acting countries' stories! Myths of "creations" too, of course. Before we are all de-monetized, de-platformed and censored. Even as Palestinians suffer these atrocities now as we hear this...Hugely helpful. Weeping all along this terrible evil slaughter is going on.
Professor Massad stated that European Jews are mostly not descendants of the ancient Israelite tribes. That is the only legitimate premise for Zionism, I think. I’d love to learn more.
"Israel is an American military satellite state staffed by Jewish soldiers." - MIND. BLOWN. Now that's a quote.
Reagan's secretary of state Haig, openly referred to israel as "America's largest aircraft carrier which never could be sunk"
That's BS. The US has military base at the 4 corners of the world. They don't even need Israel.
@@MustacheVerra of course they do - having Israel centralized in the heart of Arab nations is the key ingredient to making sure these countries never unite. Should the Arab world unite it will mean checkmate to all the super powers in the world. Of course they do.
Super informative.
oh, a history of the world since the 17th century, no problem
Seriously, Massad is a treasure!
Wow! That was amazing.
How would you like to be this babe who has to head nod forever? Slow death by words. Good to know how he feels about the country he's living and working in. So encouraging.
This has added 😢so much to my understanding of the struggle
Awesome interview
Absolutely brilliant.
She's a very beautiful woman in many ways. Great video.. thank you.
To find out about the Arab spring. I would suggest Brian Berletic's deep dive into that topic. For Brain covers. The involvement of NED and other such operations. In the Arab spring.
I've search through the internet for anything in relation to the Arab spring he wrote but wasn't able to find anything outside of a recent Myanmar article. Do you have suggestions or links? I'm very interested in what you said and reading what he said about it
@@JohnDoeX1966 I found this ua-cam.com/video/5RBeWw_UElg/v-deo.html
FFR
Thank you very much for the link. I'll check it out
@@JohnDoeX1966 sure - it doesn’t go in depth though, he does show a washing post article with information on the topic which can lead to further searches, so a good start.
Great interview! You might try and get Lawrence Wilkerson on to speak on wether Israel is still of interest to the U.S.. I've heard him speak on the subject and he knows what he is talking about.
Jospeh Massad, in a column published in Electronic Intifada called the Hamas attacks “innovative” and referred to the terrorists who para-glided into a music festival in Israel to rape and murder the young people there as “the air force of the Palestinian resistance.”
Too complicated for me to understand at once. I need to read his books.
“Arab Spring” in 2011 was manufactured by the National Endowment for Democracy.
What a wonderfully intelligent and eloquent speaker
What BS!
I don’t think so. Nothing at par as Bibi’s eloquence and class.
WOW !!! 🌺🌺🌺
This is terrible, the Israelis are treating the Arabs who have lived there since Old Testament times like the Nazis treated the Jews, how is that possible? I am beginning to feel that the Israelis should not pull the Nazi card until they treat the Palestinians as fellow human beings. Hamas and Nazis are the same thing, but not all Palestinians are Hamas, just as not all Germans were Nazis. And I applaud the minorities on both sides who are calling on their own people to wake up and stop the madness. Hamas wouldn't exist without IDF just like ISIS with USA , IRA UK , list goes on history repeating , one would think that wise Hebrews and yes they are very wise , wouldn't make such a mistake?
As a Jordanian, what are Prof. Massad's views on Jordan's King Hussein's, let's just say "forcible" ousting of the PLO from Jordan in 1970?
Rashid Bolsen who has suddenly appeared on his own utube channel is very interesting.
Great History of Israel and Arab relation and British and US
TOP.
'Age of independence' Is that a continuation Hobsbawm's 'age of empires'?
One interesting term he uses that I've never heard is 'islamist liberals'...(regarding mb)maybe I'd missed that term previously
It's depressing how I didnt even notice the date until like almost the end of the video... fk, what circle of hell are we stuck in...?!?!
That gulp of water looked like it hit different.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣😭😭😭
When?
GREAT SHOW, THANKS FOR ALL THE INFO...."THE BLACK VETERAN FOR REAL JUSTICE". B1....FBA... BLACK NATIVE.....PA/NY/SC....USA.
Damn, this Joseph Massad guy knows so damn much. Look forward to learning more from him.
Support Prof Massad! Free Free Palestine!
🎉🎉🎉🎉
Glad that the Palestinian flag is flown from by Celtic football club fans in games. Because of this and more specially in the north of Ireland the Palestinian flag is still seen on flags poles in areas of Republican areas.. the native Irish people who got cut on the wrong side off the border and still under British rule up on till the late 90s, it's not hard to understand the British hatred towards the catholic minority in the north of Ireland and who there friends were protestants and loyalists and were there affinity for Israel comes from, yes makes perfect sense.. my heart breaks as I know my countries history and it was evil and a genocide in its own right imagine what the Palestinian people are going through.. I not religious and don't care what religion but wrong is wrong, come up with any reason for the treatment that they go through, it's the biggest scab still going on in the world don't care what anyone says I really do but they have been stabbed in the back many times, it's true zionists are the most evil monsters after the ww2. With the help of America but most European countries. Is-ra-al don't like the thought of politicians in Ireland bringing up the Palestinian cause. Happens more than you would think. Richard boyd barrett telling the is-ra-ali foreign minister he should be expelled from the country. It's a dieing breed but all the major political party's are all compromised in the west and most Islamic countries. The Shia muslims are the resistance.. from Syria to Iran.. Yemen all the countries that are mostly Shia are hated by Zionism and its allies in other countries in the region... 🙏🙏🙏🤝
👍🏻 So the White armies weren't big on human rights.
I do hate it when it comes to colour. Doesn’t that take away from the important issue. People who are not worried about true, truth, always bring up colour, religion ect - facts are what educates you.
Some times you must walk in to the lions den. You must stand upright on two legs on the plane to see far ahead then load your mortor . The horse archers bible.
Blame it all on Arab leaders for being in yoke of Anglo / American masters. Divide and conquer has always been forte of British government.
pack your bags fella. You being booted outa Columbia, and that right quick.
8:02
20:00
00:00
Wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow wow
#الموت_لاسقاطیل ❤️🇵🇸✌️🇮🇷✌️🇱🇧❤️
United nations meeting live
The issue of zionists and Palestinians is far bigger than the current situation or what it is thought to be.
It goes as far back as time of messanger Moses.
Hey! Izrael ...leave Gaza alone!
Zionist Hasbara rage in this comment section is hilarious.
I’d like to hire that gentleman to entertain my guests as a court jester at my next party.
Regimes... hmm?...
When and where is the line that one has to cross to become the 'original inhabitant' of a land? A more concrete example: why among present day revolutionary leftists is it alright for a Palestinian to long for Haifa and Jaffa but a right wing fantasy for the Greeks to long for Constantinople?
But the Greeks have Constantinople already. What are they longing for? Except the Greeks in question are Muslims.
@@wahidazal Fine then the Palestinians also have Tel Aviv, Ashdod, Jerusalem, and Be'ersheba, except they are Jews.
@@erics7992 Not the same. Anatolians are Muslim Greeks. The residents of Tel Aviv, Ashdod, Jerusalem, and Be'ersheba are for the most part Ashkenazis whose Israelite pedigree is questionable but originated in Europe. You would have a point if the Turks of Turkey were descendants of Mongolians and Central Asians, the real Turks.
@@wahidazal I am very dubious that the modern day Turkish inhabitants of Anatolia are anything but Central Asian Turks. During the Ottoman times there were large populations of Greeks living there but they were all expelled in 1922 and it was done for nationalistic and not religious reasons.
@@erics7992 Therein is the problem because many of you white nationalists don't know your history or ethnography very well and make stupid generalizations that have no basis in historical facts. Modern Anatolian Turks are NOT ethnically Central Asian. This has been proven time and again. They are by and large Greek remnants together with Persians (which includes Kurds) and some Arabs. The Greeks expelled in the early 1920s were done so for reasons largely having to do with language and religion, and almost nothing to do with genuine ethnography which the waning Ottoman authorities of that time didn't have the slightest clue about. Besides, the father of modern Turkey, Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, himself was most probably of Greek stock, especially given where he was born and where his family came from. So keep trucking!
💩
What is this, a history lesson ? Make your point short, sweet and then move on to the next point. Too much blather and blah, blah...can't take it
Comment section reads like a ladies who lunch fan club. It was OKAY. It wasn’t bad, it wasn’t brilliant.
Rania, your ignorance, while not surprising, is disgraceful and distasteful. This is the most boring and dry dribble of lies I've ever had the displeasure of listening too. I was hoping to hear another opinion on the subject but I have suffered death by boredom
First and foremost, I respect professor Massad. However, this was waay too long and dense. Are you trying to communicate with Wall Street or Main Street? Obviously, this will be accepted by Wall Street's prep schooled demographic. Main Street will be left dangling in the wind. In my humble opinion, Main Street needs to be educated more then Wall Street. Just sayin'. :(
sometimes it helps to rewatch it once or twice! :)
@@waaaaaht Economy of writing style is much sought after. Likewise, economy of any type of communication is also desirable. At over and hour, this is a huge investment in time. Short attention spans, like mine, struggle with this hour long presentation. I just think (considering the bleak state of Main Street's attention span) maybe something more economical would be preferable.
@@pdurpan she has plenty of other videos on this matter. You can also read his articles and books if you prefer.
@@jacklyncheung4993 Perhaps I am mistaken, my sense of the thrust of this conversation was a CHANGE in perception of the Palestinian plight for the better. Professor Massad correctly talks about how erroneous that change really is. My suggestion is to redirect attention to Main Street perception management and away from Wall Street perception management. (which is what is happening n this video). Successful perception management on the Vietnam War happened when it was directed towards Main Street with daily repeated information. It worked. These long drawn out dense discourses have proven to be quite ineffectual.
@@pdurpan You’re right. Both short form and long form are required. Some people like to dig deeper and learn about the history. That’s what this sort of interview is for. But political change becomes more possible when Main Street -as you call it - becomes generally aware of the reality of a given situation. Short nuggets of information are therefore needed to help people understand that Israel is not a regular state, but actually a weird militarized society where everyone is a soldier involved in killing or stealing to some extent or another. And that the state has been doing some pretty sadistic stuff since its inception. I sometimes think that Palestinians have too much information and they try to share all of it (rightly so) but then it becomes overwhelming when newbies to the issue try to learn about it.
They just got used to stealing from me
With a name like Massad not sure i can trust him. 😂
How disappointing, for professor Massad to even share a platform with an Assad-apologist Rania Khalek, and not at least bring that up.
Here’s his opinion on the matter if you’re interested
www.middleeasteye.net/opinion/syria-war-who-are-real-anti-imperialists
khalek is a dimwit demagogue who thinks in notoriously simplistic terms; sad to see JM parrot her silly "anti-imperialist" cliché that the US is the only imperialist power in the world. his mentor was sharper.
What sooooo funny in all this tragedy... such an senseless presenter, OMG
Rania, are you enjoying that CCP paycheck?
rania is eye candy