Love your videos. If I’m ever questioning whether or not to get something I always look to you for guidance. You remind me of if I have something similar it’s not a need. I love the Beauty Bay eye formula. The brand is great. Their customer service is excellent.
Your description of the formula has me intrigued. I don’t always want a ton of pigment in my mattes or intensity in my shimmers-this sounds more quick and easy!
Botanical is such a beautiful color story that I’m so drawn to… obviously, because I also own Flora Story and Ghost Town! Thanks for talking me off the ledge.
Oh man, I have the Nomad Ghost Town USA and bought the Botanical by BB, lol. I didn't even realize the similarities 😂 I guess the color stories are definitely ones I am attracted to! Oh well, now I have a close back up to the Ghost Town or I can gift the Botanical palette to a friend who missed out. I love your videos❤ P.S. I was feeling FOMO on the Odens Eye palettes but now I am set!
Along with your own lovely palette, this reminds me so much of the Adept Flying Fiddles palette that came out in March. Guess this is still a popular color story!
This also reminds me of that Lethal palette from last year. And I agree with the commenter who said Flying Fiddles. I don't need them because I have Flora story and the Jord's collection (keeping reminding myself because I really like these palettes I dont have!)
I love the colour story of that palette, but you made me realize I have better. Between unearthly Fall magic and Sorcerous smoke, I think I have everything in there.
Ghost town is one I’ve had FOMO for but the price never dropped to the point I was willing to purchase. I do have another Beauty Bay palette, Dark Fantasy, and like the formula, and this color story appeals to me so I can see springing for it at the lower cost knowing I do like the formula.
I really love the look you created! It’s so elegant and suits your style very well. I would have bought it if I didn’t already own your Flora Story and the comparison was very helpful in making the decision ❤
you are so right, i have oily skin and ANY blush that is not in POWDER form its just a no no, everything i put on my skin like that it just brings out all the textures on my skin so everything i wear is in powder matte formula even my foundation is usually powder i love your look
Ok so I am obsessed with the shades Amazon & waterfall. I saw the comparisons and feel like I didn’t see a perfect dupe for those shades. I love the tone, depth, sparkle basically everything about them. Could you do a video of maybe some dupes from your collection that get even closer to a dupe? And in the video show us some other cool shades from palettes you have found good dupes for?
Thank you so much for comparing When It Rains from BB longing and Waterfall from this. I was drawn to it because it looked similar, but am disappointed in the shimmer quality of Waterfall. I’ll try with a brush since you mentioned it works better than finger. Fingers crossed!
I have never tried these products. I love the blushes on you. The eye shadow palette is very nice, i love the way you apply and blend colors. Great comparison swatches. I am more of a neutral girly myself so the blushes were my favorite. I loved the Colourpop lip balmscaand glosses, just haven't placed any orderrd yet. My stove died and had to buy a new one, I am on a dump on Gail kinda time now it will match the new microwave I replaced a couple of months ago. Tomorrow I see the surgeon Thursday July 25th at 11am am PST. Prayers welcomed.👍✔️🎨🖌️👍❗🌸💗
I appreciate you comparing BB Botanical to Nomad Ghost Town. They are similar, but I've been unhappy with the quality of some of the BB Botanical shadows. I love the color story, so I may still get the Nomad Ghost Town palette...!
Does it compare at all to the gourmande girls peach palette? I notice it also has some peaches and greens, but obviously more shades. Would you say the gourmande mattes and shimmers are more pigmented though?
I was drawn to this one, and I also have the longing palette. I do like the Nomad one, but for whatever reason, I didn't feel compelled at the time to get it.
It's a gorgeous colour story and the comparisons are some of my favourite palettes. I have most BeautyBay limited edition 20-pan palettes. Their mattes are fine, except for very light and very dark shades. They kind of remind me of some k-beauty formulas. Their shimmers are really really nice for the price, but I personally find them slightly wax and dimethicone feeling. They crease on me a *lot* but I have very hooded very oily eyelids. I like the finish on their liquid blushes and hope they release more shades. BB hardly ever expands their shade range for any product though. Ewww not The Ring! 😂 That is the single worst thing a lip product can do imo.
Thank you for your comparisons. Between your Flora Story and Ghost Town USA, I no longer want the Botanical palette. I can save my money for some thi gs I was wanting in the Sydney Grace sale.
This palette has 3 greys as the previous one…. I did not buy the reckless romance palette because of those greys, I don’t need so many. And this palette has the same issue. As for me it is disappointing 😢😢 really want a new beauty bay palette, but their last colour stories are just not for me 😢
Aww, poor Maggie 😔❤️🩹🐶 I don’t know if this would help given her background, but do you think it would be worth it to try one of those thunder shirts they make to help dogs with anxiety from storms? Thank you for this review! 💖 That palette is very pretty- I’m going to try to shop my stash and dupe the vibes since I’m not in the market to add any new palettes at the moment, though. 😅
We have a thunder jacket for her which helps a little bit but only about 50% of the time. The other half the time she just finds a way to take it off 😂 We have tried just about everything and the vet did give us some chill pills in case she is *really* distressed but usually she just needs some calm (and constant lol) reassurance and pets from her humans 😌
@@MakeupJustForFun Ahh, I see! I’ve heard those can be kind of hit-or-miss 😅 Thank you for replying- sending lots of chill + calm vibes to you and Maggie ❤️🩹🐶
Love your videos. If I’m ever questioning whether or not to get something I always look to you for guidance. You remind me of if I have something similar it’s not a need. I love the Beauty Bay eye formula. The brand is great. Their customer service is excellent.
This palette looks so beautiful! It’s the first palette I’ve been drawn to from Beauty Bay!
Same! I don't need it but it's so pretty!
Your description of the formula has me intrigued. I don’t always want a ton of pigment in my mattes or intensity in my shimmers-this sounds more quick and easy!
Botanical is such a beautiful color story that I’m so drawn to… obviously, because I also own Flora Story and Ghost Town! Thanks for talking me off the ledge.
Thanks so much for watching! 🤩
Me too! I have to keep coming back to the part of the video where Ghost Town is compared to the Botanical palette to remind me I don’t need it!! 😂😂
Same xoxox 😂❤❤❤🙏
Oh man, I have the Nomad Ghost Town USA and bought the Botanical by BB, lol. I didn't even realize the similarities 😂 I guess the color stories are definitely ones I am attracted to! Oh well, now I have a close back up to the Ghost Town or I can gift the Botanical palette to a friend who missed out. I love your videos❤
P.S. I was feeling FOMO on the Odens Eye palettes but now I am set!
Along with your own lovely palette, this reminds me so much of the Adept Flying Fiddles palette that came out in March. Guess this is still a popular color story!
I ❤ your comparisons. I have the Flora Story, Ghost Town and Jewels and Gems. Definitely do not need. But clearly I’m drawn to the same color story. 😁
I used to buy from Beauty Bay when their shipping was $10. It's much, much higher now. Love you, Amanda 💗
I am waiting on this palette now. Cannot wait!
I can't believe I didn't immediately think of Flora Story when I saw this palette! These were fantastic comparisons, Amanda.
This also reminds me of that Lethal palette from last year. And I agree with the commenter who said Flying Fiddles. I don't need them because I have Flora story and the Jord's collection (keeping reminding myself because I really like these palettes I dont have!)
I love the colour story of that palette, but you made me realize I have better. Between unearthly Fall magic and Sorcerous smoke, I think I have everything in there.
You just saved me money! I have Ghost Town, Flora Story and Stone and Rock.
Ditto, but only to Ghost town. It's close enough for me.
Ghost town is one I’ve had FOMO for but the price never dropped to the point I was willing to purchase. I do have another Beauty Bay palette, Dark Fantasy, and like the formula, and this color story appeals to me so I can see springing for it at the lower cost knowing I do like the formula.
Mine is on its way! It reminds me of Mel’s Tiny Marvels palette.
Your eyeshadow look is stunning!! I’ve been getting back into using my high shine eyeshadow recently.
Wow! Thank you so much for the Ghost Town comparisons. I was tempted by this Botanical palette, but now I know I definitely do not need it.
I really love the look you created! It’s so elegant and suits your style very well. I would have bought it if I didn’t already own your Flora Story and the comparison was very helpful in making the decision ❤
Thank you so much!!
Palettes with Green/Pink/Mauve/Purple/Burgundy & Green/Peach/Pink/Terracotta/Gold have been popular color stories for a while.
All quite wearable colors for most people so it makes sense they are very marketable! 😍
Thank you so much for the fantastic comparisons!
P.S. Flora story is one of my favourite palettes 🎨 😍❤
Leaving a comment because your twin told me too. She said to make sure I’m subscribed and that I tell you how much I love your video!
Yes! I have Ghost Town. Thanks! 🤗
Thank you so much for the comparisons! Definitely gave me ideas for how to shop my stash. ❤
You are so welcome! Happy to help
you are so right, i have oily skin and ANY blush that is not in POWDER form its just a no no, everything i put on my skin like that it just brings out all the textures on my skin so everything i wear is in powder matte formula even my foundation is usually powder
i love your look
I just received this yesterday, and I am loving this.
That eye look is beautiful 😍
Thank you so much 😀
Ok so I am obsessed with the shades Amazon & waterfall. I saw the comparisons and feel like I didn’t see a perfect dupe for those shades. I love the tone, depth, sparkle basically everything about them. Could you do a video of maybe some dupes from your collection that get even closer to a dupe? And in the video show us some other cool shades from palettes you have found good dupes for?
Thank you so much for comparing When It Rains from BB longing and Waterfall from this.
I was drawn to it because it looked similar, but am disappointed in the shimmer quality of Waterfall. I’ll try with a brush since you mentioned it works better than finger. Fingers crossed!
Wow, it’s very similar to Ghost Town! It also reminds me of ABH Nouveau as well. Thanks for the thorough video, as always!
Thanks for watching!
I have never tried these products. I love the blushes on you. The eye shadow palette is very nice, i love the way you apply and blend colors. Great comparison swatches. I am more of a neutral girly myself so the blushes were my favorite. I loved the Colourpop lip balmscaand glosses, just haven't placed any orderrd yet. My stove died and had to buy a new one, I am on a dump on Gail kinda time now it will match the new microwave I replaced a couple of months ago. Tomorrow I see the surgeon Thursday July 25th at 11am am PST. Prayers welcomed.👍✔️🎨🖌️👍❗🌸💗
I would love to see you review the beauty bay highlighters (liquid and powder). I need a reliable review!
I appreciate you comparing BB Botanical to Nomad Ghost Town. They are similar, but I've been unhappy with the quality of some of the BB Botanical shadows. I love the color story, so I may still get the Nomad Ghost Town palette...!
Lol, I just talked myself out of the Longing palette because I have the other three you used as comparison 😂
I love it!
Does it compare at all to the gourmande girls peach palette? I notice it also has some peaches and greens, but obviously more shades. Would you say the gourmande mattes and shimmers are more pigmented though?
I was drawn to this one, and I also have the longing palette. I do like the Nomad one, but for whatever reason, I didn't feel compelled at the time to get it.
Love it❤
MAN! I reeeally wanted this pallet until you showed the Ghost Town USA comparison. Now I can't justify it 😂. Foiled again!
Dang, I wish I had seen this before buying Botanical. I already have Ghost town. They are so close to each other.
Question, will you be doing a video on the blend bunny longing palette? Thanks
Not sure if I’ll do a dedicated video but at the very least it will be in a grwm or an indie makeup roundup!
oh no now I wish i got your flora story palette. it's what i wanted beauty bay botanicals to be :/ but oden's eye is quite expensive :(
Do you prefer the Odens Eye formula or Nomad’s?
Ooof both high on my list but I think I slightly prefer Oden’s Eye… it’s close though!
Love 💕❤ video
It's a gorgeous colour story and the comparisons are some of my favourite palettes.
I have most BeautyBay limited edition 20-pan palettes. Their mattes are fine, except for very light and very dark shades. They kind of remind me of some k-beauty formulas. Their shimmers are really really nice for the price, but I personally find them slightly wax and dimethicone feeling. They crease on me a *lot* but I have very hooded very oily eyelids.
I like the finish on their liquid blushes and hope they release more shades. BB hardly ever expands their shade range for any product though.
Ewww not The Ring! 😂 That is the single worst thing a lip product can do imo.
Some of my faves in the comparisons too… no wonder I like this one so much 😂
Thank you for your comparisons. Between your Flora Story and Ghost Town USA, I no longer want the Botanical palette. I can save my money for some thi gs I was wanting in the Sydney Grace sale.
❤
This palette has 3 greys as the previous one…. I did not buy the reckless romance palette because of those greys, I don’t need so many. And this palette has the same issue. As for me it is disappointing 😢😢 really want a new beauty bay palette, but their last colour stories are just not for me 😢
I love all your videos. If you start a membership I'll be there. Your videos are always the first ones I watch and I'd love more! 🥰🤗😘🤟🎉🥳😻🩵💜🤎💙🧡❤️
Aww, poor Maggie 😔❤️🩹🐶 I don’t know if this would help given her background, but do you think it would be worth it to try one of those thunder shirts they make to help dogs with anxiety from storms?
Thank you for this review! 💖 That palette is very pretty- I’m going to try to shop my stash and dupe the vibes since I’m not in the market to add any new palettes at the moment, though. 😅
We have a thunder jacket for her which helps a little bit but only about 50% of the time. The other half the time she just finds a way to take it off 😂 We have tried just about everything and the vet did give us some chill pills in case she is *really* distressed but usually she just needs some calm (and constant lol) reassurance and pets from her humans 😌
@@MakeupJustForFun Ahh, I see! I’ve heard those can be kind of hit-or-miss 😅 Thank you for replying- sending lots of chill + calm vibes to you and Maggie ❤️🩹🐶