Your criteria are excellent! I watched the 1960 Melbourne team win & thought they were just happenstance premiers ! I had forgotten how superior the year 2000 premiers were ! Just proves what clever coach Terry Wallace was !
I generally agreed with your list, I do think you were a bit tough on the 97, 98 Crows as they had the highest percentage in the Comp in both years plus won a heap of interstate finals. They were unlucky to finish 4th and 5th. Who do you think is the best team of all time to not win the flag I think it was the 2008 Cats.
Yes the 2008 Cats were definitely the best team to not win it. Honourable mentions to Melbourne 1958, Collingwood 1970, Collingwood 2011 and St.Kilda 2009
Your criteria are excellent! I watched the 1960 Melbourne team win & thought they were just happenstance premiers ! I had forgotten how superior the year 2000 premiers were ! Just proves what clever coach Terry Wallace was !
Glad you enjoyed it
I generally agreed with your list, I do think you were a bit tough on the 97, 98 Crows as they had the highest percentage in the Comp in both years plus won a heap of interstate finals. They were unlucky to finish 4th and 5th. Who do you think is the best team of all time to not win the flag I think it was the 2008 Cats.
Yes the 2008 Cats were definitely the best team to not win it. Honourable mentions to Melbourne 1958, Collingwood 1970, Collingwood 2011 and St.Kilda 2009