Had the privilege of spending a few days staying at Mick McNeil’s house in Glasgow Christmas 1986. Just the most generous, gentle and down to earth guy with an accordion. Made a big impression on me as a youth fresh out of Uni. I so wish I’d learned to play an instrument! I send my regards wherever you are
"No-one bought our first 5 albums" .. excuse me Jimmy, I was a schoolboy and I queued outside Bruce's records on Rose St in Edinburgh on the day 'Life In A Day' was released and it was the single greatest thing in my life. The next four albums were sheer brilliance and i bought them all on day of release. I wanted to like Sparkle as much, i really tried, but the magic had been replaced by the bombastic. Thank you for those first 5 - the magic dust, no one can take that away.
Absolutely knocked it on the head Andy. I think when Derek Forbes and then Mick left the band it was all over. Not forgetting the politics . Not playing Murrayfield and going to Meadowbank instead. Big mistake.
I started with Empires and Dance, then bought Reel to Real Cacophony, SAF/SFC, NGD and SITR. I lost interest with later releases, but like so many, love the earlier stuff! (I agree with Jim re; Sparkle in the Rain side 2. That may be why I started to lose them a bit. Its hard to recall now.)
Charlie always smiling & laughing...Jim always sayin..."let me see your hands"...but brilliant brilliant band... massively underrated, especially by the lazy music press.
Don't forget Brian McGee. That rhythm section is just killer. Much as I love Mel Gaynor's work, McGee and Forbes sit with me like Nile and 'Nard, Liebezeit and Czukay, Harris and Rustin' Man... unbeatable.
Great Band, greater personalties. You still can feel the enthusiasm inside them. Looking forward to their next tour. Live always an experience. Worth every single Euro.
One of the GREATEST BANDS in the history of Rock N Roll! I found them here in America with the import Sister Feelings Call. Like a few others that have defied time, they just keep on rockin'!!! NEW GOLD DREAM is a MASTERPIECE that belongs in every collection and to this day the songs and music is timeless!! "Someone, Somewhere, in Summertime". They also had some of the very best bass players of all time and great drummers. What an era, the 80's. How did we survive???? Who remembers Hatfield And The North? Camel? Gong? Henry Cow?
They summed it up perfectly: "Life Affirming"! I have always gotten that from their music and their interviews. "Waterfront" has fished me out of the Slough of Despond many times since the 80s. But let's not forget "New Gold Dream" and "Promised You A Miracle" as powerful songs! I hadn't been following closely for a few years and have only recently discovered "Big Music" and "Walk Between Worlds". Hard to keep with these brilliant artists! Thank them for me until the fates allow me to do that in person!
Loved this interview - thanks a lot. Would really like to hear them interviewed about the start of the re-birth era (Cry etc) and how the band picked itself back up.
I played the hell out of ONCE UPON A TIME....I also love the opening song and often wondered was it ever released as a Single...It was also the great Bands introduction song for their huge amount of fans to Robin Clarke who added an amazing chapter to Simple Minds. The video to ALL THE THINGS SHE SAID is the most iconic 80s clip of all time in my honest opinion~ I would love to know how they did it and whether it can be done these days, Also LOVE the songs Mandela Day, Promised you a Miracle, SHES A RIVER, ALIVE & KICKING (HUGE SONG!) and the beautiful GLITTERING PRIZE...From a HUGE First Nations Fan of Simple Minds way down in southern Australia! Much Love to you 2 AND ALL THAT HELPED ALONG THE WAY...and THANKYOU! WE LOVE YA xx
I absolutely loved this band between 1982 and 1995. ❤️ Have seen them 12 times over the years and live they were also amazing. Saw them a couple of years ago and it was like watching a Karaoke version of the band. Quite sad really because they were that good back in the day that watching them now was such a come down. Great interview though and great to hear the way the band made it and wrote the albums.
BTW, Elvis Costello is a great alt artist too who also started out in punk. When you guys came out with Sparkle in the Rain, U2, Big County, Tears For Fears also had big albums out and I could see you all in large venue together. But when I saw you in 1990, it was a medium-sized venue, U-shaped and not a bad seat in the house. I really appreciated that. Less is more and smaller venues are the best.
Great interview, I just listened to their three first records I never heard when I was young. They were incredible back then! Only, it feels weird to hear the old stuff for the first time Now when I'm almost 60.. I loved them, but had no way to hear the older songs then.
Stop interrupting this genius.. This guy caught my attenttion as a 4 year old... and now hes better thann before .vert underrated... i study classical baroque.. amd learned 6 instuments... And this guy was one of my favorite guitarist in the eighties... i love hunter and the hunted...
It’s unfortunate that most people say their “first 5 albums th oh s and that”… I love those but I wager their last 5 albums are just as really damn good!!
I bought all first 5 lps!Saw them as Johnny and the self abusers in Glasgow summer 77 at Mars bar 🍸 Superb night 🌙 And when Life in a day was released i was there to buy its naive but i loved that innocence and bought each lp and loved the fact with each lp they progressed until Sparkle in the rain half great lp but after that pomp and bombast that was it for me! But those early years were magick 🥳
By Sparkle/Rain and beyond, they would have been ready for Lallapalooza if it was around. Although, I saw them in 90 in a medium sized venue and I appreciated that.
It's telling that the focus of the interview musically, jumped from street fighting years to the acoustic album as if there was little of worth in between..... which is just about how I regard the Simple Minds catalogue.
Please anybody help! I want to watch it but here in Germany there is no way to find this documentary. Even at Paramount + Germany it seems not available. Any suggestions ? Many thanks in advance!
Blows me away how thick Jim’s accent is, but when he sings you don’t detect it. I recall learning in college, going back to the 50s and 60s, English/uk artists would sing to appeal to the US audiences.
Talking of producers, why no mention Steve Hackett and Pete Walsh, who I consider to be the producers of their best work. Lillywhite meets Gaynor was the beginning of the end.
jim hasnt said it (yet) but the influence of early U2 on their live shows and subsequent future tracks cant be understated . myself and many others bore witness to their transformation,which actually i think led to their ultimate artistic demise. that and also the loss of derek forbes,who was essential to the sound and compositions.
You are correct. SM influenced U2 originally. However when U2 started selling out stadiums in USA SM thought we’ll have some of that. Jim has openly said they wanted to earn some money. Who can blame them! Wasn’t my cup of tea but hey ho. I’ve got their first 5 / 6 albums to listen to. I’d probably forego a limb to see the original line up perform their early stuff again
Very good interview but it does confirm that after the 1st 5 awesome albums they did “sell out”. Backing singers, hits, stadiums, “You turn me on”, etc. All the stuff other people were telling them to do. Obviously it worked for them but the character and soul was gone. Still thank them for those first 5 👌
They completely still diss Forbes don't even mention he was crucial in the writing of those first 5 albums acting like these 2 wrote everything which is BS. I hate when bands hold grudges 40 years later and totally disrespect an original member that was a key to their whole success it just rubs me the wrong way.
@@DrPhil-pw2to Yeah. Couple of guys who were against apartheid, who've earned a fortune travelling the world as creative artists and have lived in Italy for years, hang on to grudges based around two shit football teams.
I love their 2nd album up to and including Sparkle in the Rain. Sheer brilliance. Although they seem a bunch of nice guys, what followed then was just so shameful....songs like Alive and kicking, Sanctify yourselves. Yak....a big mistake and I could not believe it was the same band who produced that crap. I never ever listen to anything new from them eversince. I only listen to the first 6 albums. the rest is irrelevant.
Jim is a very articulate guy, it's always interesting to see him being interviewed. Simple Minds have been one of my favourite bands for many years!
Had the privilege of spending a few days staying at Mick McNeil’s house in Glasgow Christmas 1986. Just the most generous, gentle and down to earth guy with an accordion. Made a big impression on me as a youth fresh out of Uni. I so wish I’d learned to play an instrument! I send my regards wherever you are
He has kind eyes and I say that has a heterosexual male.
"No-one bought our first 5 albums" .. excuse me Jimmy, I was a schoolboy and I queued outside Bruce's records on Rose St in Edinburgh on the day 'Life In A Day' was released and it was the single greatest thing in my life. The next four albums were sheer brilliance and i bought them all on day of release. I wanted to like Sparkle as much, i really tried, but the magic had been replaced by the bombastic. Thank you for those first 5 - the magic dust, no one can take that away.
Absolutely knocked it on the head Andy. I think when Derek Forbes and then Mick left the band it was all over. Not forgetting the politics . Not playing Murrayfield and going to Meadowbank instead. Big mistake.
I have the original vinyl too! Before “Don’t You”…they were majestic.
My whole chidhood was based on listening to their records on my mums old dansette record player.. I loved their early stuff
I started with Empires and Dance, then bought Reel to Real Cacophony, SAF/SFC, NGD and SITR. I lost interest with later releases, but like so many, love the earlier stuff! (I agree with Jim re; Sparkle in the Rain side 2. That may be why I started to lose them a bit. Its hard to recall now.)
I bought them, but after Once Upon a Time.
Charlie always smiling & laughing...Jim always sayin..."let me see your hands"...but brilliant brilliant band... massively underrated, especially by the lazy music press.
They are not underrated. Huge record sales, plaudits..etc..etc..
What an album Sons and Fascination is. The two people who made that album what it is are Mick McNiel ( Keyboards ) and Derek Forbes ( Bass Player).
Totally 💯 agree with you 👍🏻👍🏻
Don't forget Brian McGee. That rhythm section is just killer. Much as I love Mel Gaynor's work, McGee and Forbes sit with me like Nile and 'Nard, Liebezeit and Czukay, Harris and Rustin' Man... unbeatable.
Well they were 5
Great interview. Jim and Charlie complement each other so well.
A great, GREAT band who have accompanied me through life.
One the most beautiful voices of 80's and Charlie the most beautiful guitar player all the time 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻💕
Great Band, greater personalties. You still can feel the enthusiasm inside them. Looking forward to their next tour. Live always an experience. Worth every single Euro.
Truly the grand masters! Bravo
I've never seen them laugh so much, its great.
One of the GREATEST BANDS in the history of Rock N Roll! I found them here in America with the import Sister Feelings Call. Like a few others that have defied time, they just keep on rockin'!!! NEW GOLD DREAM is a MASTERPIECE that belongs in every collection and to this day the songs and music is timeless!! "Someone, Somewhere, in Summertime". They also had some of the very best bass players of all time and great drummers. What an era, the 80's. How did we survive???? Who remembers Hatfield And The North? Camel? Gong? Henry Cow?
I have never seen them so talkative and cheerful. Thank you for sharing.
They summed it up perfectly: "Life Affirming"! I have always gotten that from their music and their interviews. "Waterfront" has fished me out of the Slough of Despond many times since the 80s. But let's not forget "New Gold Dream" and "Promised You A Miracle" as powerful songs! I hadn't been following closely for a few years and have only recently discovered "Big Music" and "Walk Between Worlds". Hard to keep with these brilliant artists! Thank them for me until the fates allow me to do that in person!
Superb interview. I didn't realise Klopp was a Simple Minds fan :)
Please good gentlemen, come to Argentina! You are one of those great great bands that did not visit us yet.
One of my favorite bands.
I've bought everything they have brought out, for me they are the best
That's good stuff.....I'm one of the first 5 albums age group...Jim and Charlie are just excellent in this.
Great interesting interview....
Hopefully one day I'll meet the bhoys and thank them for the soundtrack to my life, thankyou guys ..keep kickin.....
I love SM! Love Charlie!
I love Charlie's guitar.
Loved this interview - thanks a lot. Would really like to hear them interviewed about the start of the re-birth era (Cry etc) and how the band picked itself back up.
Great interview.
Best rock band. Awesome music.
Gotta love a Scottish accent
Happy Birthday Charlie 💕
Love from Australia💛
Brilliant interview, the interviewer is genuinely interested in what they have to say.
Great interview, Great band.
Fantastic & entertaining interview, got my concert ticket today now have to wait patiently till Dec 2020 for the Sydney show
I'm also going to Sydney
Popping over from the UK
Great Interview.. And good questions from Jamie East.
What a brilliant interview. Got more out of Jim and Charlie than any other interview I've come across. Well done and thank you.
Just listened to " Sons & Fascination " 👌
I played the hell out of ONCE UPON A TIME....I also love the opening song and often wondered was it ever released as a Single...It was also the great Bands introduction song for their huge amount of fans to Robin Clarke who added an amazing chapter to Simple Minds. The video to ALL THE THINGS SHE SAID is the most iconic 80s clip of all time in my honest opinion~ I would love to know how they did it and whether it can be done these days, Also LOVE the songs Mandela Day, Promised you a Miracle, SHES A RIVER, ALIVE & KICKING (HUGE SONG!) and the beautiful GLITTERING PRIZE...From a HUGE First Nations Fan of Simple Minds way down in southern Australia! Much Love to you 2 AND ALL THAT HELPED ALONG THE WAY...and THANKYOU! WE LOVE YA xx
I absolutely loved this band between 1982 and 1995. ❤️ Have seen them 12 times over the years and live they were also amazing. Saw them a couple of years ago and it was like watching a Karaoke version of the band. Quite sad really because they were that good back in the day that watching them now was such a come down. Great interview though and great to hear the way the band made it and wrote the albums.
100% not a karaoke band. Don't listen to this guy. Simple Minds still rock and their sound is awesome live!
Love song is ma fav track ...just thought i'd throw that out there
Just seen the minds last night at the hydro took me back amazing night 💚
Seen them Easter Sunday in Dublin was brilliant
superb interview - cannot wait to catch them in Sydney with OMD this year !!!
A most captivating video as always .
BTW, Elvis Costello is a great alt artist too who also started out in punk.
When you guys came out with Sparkle in the Rain, U2, Big County, Tears For Fears also had big albums out and I could see you all in large venue together. But when I saw you in 1990, it was a medium-sized venue, U-shaped and not a bad seat in the house. I really appreciated that.
Less is more and smaller venues are the best.
I honestly only liked him then..
Simple Minds lived 10 miles away from me in Glasgow Awesome Band !
Decent fellas.
Love ❤️ Charlie 🎸🎸
Great interview I’m looking forward to the new album 💿
Great interview, I just listened to their three first records I never heard when I was young. They were incredible back then! Only, it feels weird to hear the old stuff for the first time Now when I'm almost 60.. I loved them, but had no way to hear the older songs then.
The best, what an incredible ride....
Stop interrupting this genius.. This guy caught my attenttion as a 4 year old... and now hes better thann before .vert underrated... i study classical baroque.. amd learned 6 instuments... And this guy was one of my favorite guitarist in the eighties... i love hunter and the hunted...
It’s unfortunate that most people say their “first 5 albums th oh s and that”… I love those but I wager their last 5 albums are just as really damn good!!
Great interview guys.😊
I bought all first 5 lps!Saw them as Johnny and the self abusers in Glasgow summer 77 at Mars bar 🍸
Superb night 🌙
And when Life in a day was released i was there to buy its naive but i loved that innocence and bought each lp and loved the fact with each lp they progressed until Sparkle in the rain half great lp but after that pomp and bombast that was it for me! But those early years were magick 🥳
When Forbes left they were basically a completely different band I hated it those first 5 albums are Simple Minds to me.
I bought the 5 first albums, including the single Saints and Sinners / Dead Vandals from Johnny and the Selfabusers..
Lol I bought the first 5 albums and still buying
By Sparkle/Rain and beyond, they would have been ready for Lallapalooza if it was around. Although, I saw them in 90 in a medium sized venue and I appreciated that.
Great alt band.
It's telling that the focus of the interview musically, jumped from street fighting years to the acoustic album as if there was little of worth in between..... which is just about how I regard the Simple Minds catalogue.
Jim: "Well, lo and behold..."
Charlie: "HAHAHAHAAHHH!!!"
❤ ❤ ❤ ❤ ❤
I met them and Charlie said he was 17 when they did Life in a Day.
Please anybody help! I want to watch it but here in Germany there is no way to find this documentary. Even at Paramount + Germany it seems not available. Any suggestions ? Many thanks in advance!
They were definitely not a one hit wonder. Put them up there with The Cure, INXS. Legends of the 80's.
Disappointing that Derek, Mick and Mel don't get as much reference as they should.
Yes, agreed.
Blows me away how thick Jim’s accent is, but when he sings you don’t detect it. I recall learning in college, going back to the 50s and 60s, English/uk artists would sing to appeal to the US audiences.
You're the one with the accent mate, not Jim.
@@FoobsTon fair enough, lol
Anyone interested in this, have a listen to Bob Lefsetz interview with Jim. Also Rockonteurs Podcast
Talking of producers, why no mention Steve Hackett and Pete Walsh, who I consider to be the producers of their best work. Lillywhite meets Gaynor was the beginning of the end.
Completely agree Peter Walsh revolutionised Simple Minds New Gold Dream was their absolute sonic peak
Chelsea girl ......classic song
jim hasnt said it (yet) but the influence of early U2 on their live shows and subsequent future tracks cant be understated . myself and many others bore witness to their transformation,which actually i think led to their ultimate artistic demise. that and also the loss of derek forbes,who was essential to the sound and compositions.
Really? Bono stated on Desert Island Discs that it was the other way round. If you look at them both around 84 SM were streets ahead in every aspect.
You are correct. SM influenced U2 originally. However when U2 started selling out stadiums in USA SM thought we’ll have some of that. Jim has openly said they wanted to earn some money.
Who can blame them! Wasn’t my cup of tea but hey ho. I’ve got their first 5 / 6 albums to listen to.
I’d probably forego a limb to see the original line up perform their early stuff again
Love Simple Minds, have done ever since I was a teenager in the 80s but Jim Kerr has not aged well at all.
Very good interview but it does confirm that after the 1st 5 awesome albums they did “sell out”. Backing singers, hits, stadiums, “You turn me on”, etc. All the stuff other people were telling them to do. Obviously it worked for them but the character and soul was gone. Still thank them for those first 5 👌
How is that a "sell out"? They grew up. You'd look like a muppet being a 30 year old in an art rock band
As always I cannot understand a word Charlie is saying.
Charlie pépère
Kraftwerk and Bowie were their main influences to move to post-punk new wave. Later Joy Division.
And Ultravox.
Charlie doesn't get a word in in these interviews.
I don't see Belfast Child as a "running song" gota say!
売れ線に走ったとか批判されたが何か憎めなくて僕は好きだけどなあ。
They completely still diss Forbes don't even mention he was crucial in the writing of those first 5 albums acting like these 2 wrote everything which is BS. I hate when bands hold grudges 40 years later and totally disrespect an original member that was a key to their whole success it just rubs me the wrong way.
A famous producer told a friend of mine it had a lot to do with him being a Rangers supporter.
@@DrPhil-pw2to
Yeah. Couple of guys who were against apartheid, who've earned a fortune travelling the world as creative artists and have lived in Italy for years, hang on to grudges based around two shit football teams.
@@FoobsTon Makes it all th more believable.
@@ВладимирКруглов-к9о
Does it, aye?
@@FoobsTon Oh yes, it very much does.
I love their 2nd album up to and including Sparkle in the Rain. Sheer brilliance. Although they seem a bunch of nice guys, what followed then was just so shameful....songs like Alive and kicking, Sanctify yourselves. Yak....a big mistake and I could not believe it was the same band who produced that crap. I never ever listen to anything new from them eversince. I only listen to the first 6 albums. the rest is irrelevant.