2 Reasons why YOU SHOULD NOT buy the WRC wheel! Fanatec WRC vs CSL

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 92

  • @JulianNDL
    @JulianNDL  Рік тому +1

    If you like the content I produce, please consider subscribing to the channel: ua-cam.com/channels/l5xcXq_UQepqBxMBuiM_Mg.html .
    *** If you’re interested in buying any Tesla products, i would strongly appreciate if you would use my referral code: ts.la/alexandram207520

  • @jamesarmenti8876
    @jamesarmenti8876 Рік тому +35

    the wrc wheel also unlocks xbox compatibility where as the csl just being pc/playstation.

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому +4

      HI James. Yes, that is true, and I forgot to mention this in the video.

    • @jorgito1559
      @jorgito1559 11 місяців тому

      Can I use the csl bundle on ps5 ????

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  11 місяців тому

      @jorgito1559 Unfortunately, it is not console compatible.

    • @belgradeboy1977
      @belgradeboy1977 11 місяців тому

      @@jorgito1559 you can look into GT DD Pro which is more less the same wheel base and it is compatible with PS5. It is also compatible with Xbox and PC when you attach compatible wheel

    • @HeadBassVTEC
      @HeadBassVTEC 11 місяців тому

      yes that is the real reason of the price difference....other than that it's just alcantara (bad for longevity) vs leather and different (imo uglier) colors

  • @Mototeam971
    @Mototeam971 Рік тому +6

    I just ordered the new Fanatec bundle to upgrade my g29 and had this same question! Thx for the video!

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому +1

      HI Mototeam, welcome to the channel and thank you. Congrats for your purchase, you'll love it!

  • @MobileMrManiac
    @MobileMrManiac 5 місяців тому +2

    I have the wrc wheel.. just a month old and it started disconnecting.. and the dpad button thing stopped working for the down direction. Took fanatec almost 4 months to send me a RMA shipping label. Horrible business practices. I'm not usually one to complain.

  • @stephen83546
    @stephen83546 9 місяців тому +1

    Hello my friend thank you for your presentation I have not picked I thought I did up until I watched your very very informative very on point video presentation that you put out to us. Thank you so much I'm not sure what to do. I'm still in the early stages of planning my setup:-) it's something I'm looking forward to it'll be a very nice hobby after a very challenging previous several years . Your information was helpful 👍

  • @victorsandoval6501
    @victorsandoval6501 10 місяців тому +1

    I had that same question, and ended up gettin the CSL P1 v2 despite is on backorder until feb 6, the wrc is already in stock... i would had chose the latter but needed to be budget wise

  • @callaghan22
    @callaghan22 7 місяців тому +1

    Another difference is that you can upgrade paddles on the wrc whell, despite than on p1 v2

  • @rudyg323
    @rudyg323 3 місяці тому +2

    Both are good. You can get away with buying these CSL wheels and still feel like you have good quality steering wheels. I like the Alcantara feel in the WRC and you can even use for from Gr.3 Gr.4 cars in Gran Turismo. I’m buying the P1 soon since I like the is leather and is a smaller wheel also 300mm.
    I already have bigger wheels too.

    • @enzoman444
      @enzoman444 3 місяці тому +1

      What leather?

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  3 місяці тому

      @enzoman444 Not leather, but Alcantara.

    • @enzoman444
      @enzoman444 3 місяці тому +1

      @@JulianNDL the p1 v2 that u show here and the chaps comment refers to is plastic with no leather or Alcanterra on at all.

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  3 місяці тому

      @enzoman444 Yes, the P1 V2 is not covered with Alcantara, like the WRC one, but with fake leather.

    • @enzoman444
      @enzoman444 3 місяці тому +1

      @@JulianNDL it’s not even fake leather , I had it. It’s rubberised plastic

  • @tpayne3047
    @tpayne3047 10 місяців тому +1

    I never got this wheel to work properly on PS5. Half the buttons don’t work when i play EA WRC or WRC generations. I’m not sure if it’s a defect with the wheel but my pedals also don’t work when i try to use the wheel.

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  10 місяців тому

      Unfortunately, i'm not a console player, so I have no experience what so ever with console compatibility, but I would suggest to try updating the wheelbase and also the wheel. I don't know if that is possible on the console or if you need acces to a PC to be able to update them.

    • @MrChocalatestarfish
      @MrChocalatestarfish 10 місяців тому +1

      What base are you using?

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  10 місяців тому +1

      @MrChocalatestarfish in general or for this video? My preferred one is the Asetek La Prima, but I constantly change them and feequently use every wheelbase I own. I own the Thrustmaster T248, T300, Moza R5, R9, Fanatec GT DD Pro and Asetek La Prima.

    • @tpayne3047
      @tpayne3047 10 місяців тому +1

      I did some digging and there were some configs I needed to change in WRC 😅

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  10 місяців тому +1

      @tpayne3047 I'm glad you figured it out, man. Could you explain what you had to do? Maybe someone else will have the same problem in the future and I could give them your way of solving it.

  • @tmkracing4447
    @tmkracing4447 10 місяців тому +2

    Needed this video so thanks 🙏🏽

  • @mdayton23
    @mdayton23 Рік тому +1

    csl wheel isnt xbox compatable right? Have to get one of the wrc or McLaren wheels right?

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      Yes, unfortunately the CSL is only PC compatible.

  • @CaptureFreakz
    @CaptureFreakz 2 місяці тому +1

    its the same price now?

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  2 місяці тому +1

      It depends on your region.

  • @simracingwales4997
    @simracingwales4997 9 місяців тому +1

    MUCH BETTER Video SIR! Thank you

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  9 місяців тому

      Hahaha. You can't learn without failing. My pleasure, dude.

  • @kenicsiro
    @kenicsiro Рік тому +1

    Are they compatible with fanatec magnetic paddle shifter?

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      As far as I know, yes. I can be wrong, though.

    • @urrugames4062
      @urrugames4062 9 місяців тому

      No, they are not.

  • @jimbonater
    @jimbonater Рік тому +2

    Off topic the R5 has a firmware update that talks about correcting current and voltage overload from the last update. So that last update must really be pushing the wheel to the limit. I'm afraid to update as I like the extra power and haven't had any issues 😁. This does explain why it gets hotter, but I have a fan on mine so no issues.
    I also took a digital scale to mine and measured the steering lock force at 12lbs with the Formula ES wheel at roughly a 5' radius this around 6.7nM so well above what is advertised. Not sure if it uses the steering lock force during the normal range of movement, but it should be able to?

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      Hi Jimbonater. Oh shoot! So we got happy for nothing. I hope at least they'll let it at 6 nm. I did not turn on mine since I bought the R9 but I was thinking to do next a Time battle betwen the r5 r9 and gt dd pro.

    • @jimbonater
      @jimbonater Рік тому +1

      @@JulianNDL Try it before and after the update and let me know. For now I'm not updating even if I can roll it back.

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      I will take some time this weekend and i'll do that. Most probably i'll do a video about it.

    • @jimbonater
      @jimbonater Рік тому

      @@JulianNDL I'm surprised I never see any videos on these firmware updates? Especially the one that increased power as it was a big change and evidently they over did it 😁

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      @@jimbonater I wanted to do one, and completely forgot about it, but if there is none out there, definitely i'll do one this weekend.

  • @blackhornetf
    @blackhornetf Рік тому +1

    Price wise the CSL wins but I own the WRC rim with a QR1 attached it's feel and grip is premium to the CSL . I use it when driving stick shift cars ( I don't play rally games ) I originally brought it because I was using a Xbox but now have a PC but im still glad i have this rim because it looks and feels awsome compared to the CSL.

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому +1

      Indeed, it looks and feels premium in comparison to the CSL one. The only small downside of alcantara rims is the fact that one must use gloves.

  • @maximum9065
    @maximum9065 Рік тому +2

    The only reason to get the WRC wheel is if you need it to work with Xbox. If you don't need it to work with Xbox, save the money and get the cheaper wheel. The extra cost is primarily to cover the Xbox compatibility.

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому +3

      That is true, but maybe there are people buying it just for its design, like I did. I just wanted a WRC dedicated wheel. :D

    • @grahamkelly8662
      @grahamkelly8662 Рік тому +1

      They must have changed price because both CSL elite and Wrc are both €199. Am I missing something?

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      @@grahamkelly8662 The WRC wheels was always around 200 euros. The cheapest one is the CSL, which is around 120 euros, and the CSL BMW around 140 euros.

    • @grahamkelly8662
      @grahamkelly8662 Рік тому +1

      @@JulianNDL so, is there a CSL and a CSL elite wheel? Because CSL elite is €200 and I thought there was only CSL elite and CSL Wrc

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      CSL is their tier. In the CSL tier, there are the P1 V2, the BMW, WRC, GT V2, R330 V2, and so on.

  • @Salustmaio
    @Salustmaio Рік тому +7

    I tegret buy the wrc wheel because alcantara uses rapidly

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому +5

      I played without gloves only once or twice, and even during those short instances, you could already see the wear marks on the Alcantara material. That's why I started playing with gloves from then on. The rapid deterioration of Alcantara is its unattractive aspect.

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  11 місяців тому

      Yes, Alcantara used for these wheels it's not the best out there. I think 5 years, though, is a decent lifetime for it, with gloves.

  • @wolfe1970
    @wolfe1970 Рік тому +2

    I got my WRC wheel in a offer, was nearly the same price as the CSL, and for that reason alone i will disagree with you, i love my WRC wheel, and will use it for rallying, if i want to drive other games i will use my GT or F1 wheel, thats the joy of this setup, you can tailor it to suit your needs

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      Well, I don't understand what you disagree with. Not everyone bought it at that price. Usually, it costs almost double than the CSL DD, just for its design. Now, I never said I don't like it. It's one of my favorite wheels, because even though it costs almost double than the CSL, it has a cool design and it's still cheaper than anything else on the market.

    • @wolfe1970
      @wolfe1970 Рік тому +1

      @@JulianNDL I disagree with the 2 points you made, i like the paddle shifters, i like that i can very easily remove them, also, the CSL doesnt come on the xbox, so thats another down side to the CSL,
      The WRC has the Alcantara too, which is more costly to produce,
      You are saying one is more expensive than the other, well its better quality material and a slightly different design, so that makes your comparison on cost completely redundant

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      Alcantara will look like sh*t if you don't use gloves, just after a few uses. So, looks is a downside, in my opinion. Not everybody wants to play with gloves. So, basically, you pay more for Alcantara, and you're forced to use gloves just because it looks a bit better..
      On the other hand, I played so many hours without gloves on the CSL, and it still looks like new.
      Yes, console compatibility is a big selling point for the WRC wheel.

    • @spayrex_
      @spayrex_ 11 місяців тому +1

      ​@@JulianNDLi wonder how long it will last... i heard some people playing for 3+ years with alcantara and having no issues without gloves... i bought it because i hate rubber and it also is only available in 2 months...

    • @spayrex_
      @spayrex_ 11 місяців тому

      ​@@wolfe1970when did you buy it and for how much did you pay? was it a bundle?

  • @grahamkelly8662
    @grahamkelly8662 Рік тому +1

    Can I buy Wrc wheel and buy QR2?

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому +1

      Yes. Qr2 is compatible with all the previous Fanatec steering wheels.

    • @grahamkelly8662
      @grahamkelly8662 Рік тому +1

      @@JulianNDL thanks

  • @swirkens
    @swirkens 10 місяців тому +1

    Rady to race bundle it's only 80 € diference. I will buy with WRC whell.

  • @MIMCKMedia
    @MIMCKMedia Рік тому +2

    Both work on Xbox?

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      No. Just the WRC is Xbox compatible.

    • @MIMCKMedia
      @MIMCKMedia Рік тому +1

      @@JulianNDL so why do you write "it's the same"? That is a major difference

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      Have you watched the video? Or are you just drawing conclusions from a thumbnail? Geez!

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      Or do you want the thumbail to explain the whole video? Lol!

    • @MIMCKMedia
      @MIMCKMedia Рік тому +2

      No, but not make false statements in Thumbnail to gain more clicks lol@@JulianNDL

  • @DerDichter85
    @DerDichter85 Рік тому +1

    I was to broke to get the WRC now im happy

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      Basically, the WRC wheel is a better dressed CSL P1 V2 wheel.

  • @lucasomeister2823
    @lucasomeister2823 9 місяців тому +1

    Csl wraped in tenis racket wrap. Cracking noice is gone and grip is awsome.

  • @stevebuscemi3622
    @stevebuscemi3622 Рік тому +2

    I got the WRC wheel, but vinyl wrapped the face because that design was ugly as hell

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      Yes, I guess its design is not for everyone. I personally like it.

  • @Eskoxo
    @Eskoxo Рік тому +2

    had wrc one for a few weeks the thumb encoder fell out and in general wheel cheaply creaked just by griping it so i sent it back... would not recommend any of these cheap wheels with that plastic qr1... you get what you pay for.

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      Yes, that's true. Both creak a lot, but to be fair, they're one of the cheapest wheels on the market. I personally think that for their price, the'yre both a good deal.

    • @Eskoxo
      @Eskoxo Рік тому +1

      @@JulianNDL Think spending $200 to get a full metal wheel with CSL Universal Hub V2 is much better choice long-term but whatever not my money i guess.

  • @themicrodriftpozzie9925
    @themicrodriftpozzie9925 Рік тому +1

    Talk about compatibility also

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  Рік тому

      Good suggestion! Thank you so much.

  • @christopherjones9487
    @christopherjones9487 8 місяців тому +1

    lol 😂 what is up with the music in this video? It is way over the top and absolutely ridiculous.

  • @usefulidiot21
    @usefulidiot21 Місяць тому

    Gotta love the AI narration and all of the mispronunciations that come with it.

  • @crossingblindstudios5663
    @crossingblindstudios5663 7 місяців тому +1

    F##k I hate sped up game play

    • @JulianNDL
      @JulianNDL  7 місяців тому

      I never speed up my gameplays.